
Loading summary
Bill Simmons
This is Bill Simmons and I want to tell you about my movie podcast, the Rewatchables, where each week I'm joined by ringer movie lovers Chris Ryan, Sean Vanity, Van Lathan, Kyle Brandt, Mallory Rubin. We have a whole bunch of people on. We talk about movies we can't stop rewatching. And now you can watch us cover these movies on video in the Spotify app. We have covered over 350 movies, including Heat, Goodfellas, Boogie Nights, Pulp Fiction. We have some real heavy hitters coming up here in 2025. Make sure to follow us on Spotify where you can watch every new episode. Right now, just head to the rewatchables on Spotify now on video.
Emmy Awards Announcer
Adolescence has been nominated for 13 Emmy Awards, including outstanding limited series, Outstanding lead Actor, Stephen Graham.
Scott Mendelsohn
What are you doing?
Emmy Awards Announcer
Outstanding supporting actor, Owen Cooper.
Matt Bellany
I haven't done anything.
Emmy Awards Announcer
And outstanding supporting actress, Erin Doherty.
Bill Simmons
You need to sit down, Jay.
Scott Mendelsohn
Tell me where to sit down.
Emmy Awards Announcer
Forbes raves adolescence is an all time technical masterpiece. Deadline declares it a world changing phenomenon. For your Emmy consideration, Outstanding Limited Series Adolescence only on Netflix.
Matt Bellany
This episode is brought to you by Acorn tv, the world's best streaming service for thrilling crime dramas and brilliant mysteries. Don't miss Stephen Moyer in the hit new series Art Detectives. And coming this month, Alicia Silverstone executive produces and stars in the newest Acorn TV original series Irish Blood, where she'll unravel the mystery of her father's disappearance and all clues lead to Ireland. Catch these killer new mysteries. Streaming now Only on Acorn TV. It is Thursday, August 28th. Happy Labor Day weekend. Which of course marks the end of the summer movie season. Not a great one for Hollywood hits, of course. Some pretty meaningful ones. Superman cracked the 600 million line worldwide, which means Warner Bros. Can keep making DC movies with this universe of actors. F1 did better than 600, which means that Apple may keep releasing some movies in theaters. Not sure about that yet, but overall box office is gonna stay below 4 billion and that's down from 2023. Maybe it gets to more than last year. We're still not sure about that. Internationally, only one movie got to a billion. Lilo and Stitch. Congrats to Lucas. He's got that one in our box office draft. And a bunch of the hits like Final Destination and Weapons, they're probably considered doubles rather than home runs. There was certainly no Barbenheimer type phenomenon. If you remember, back in May, we had Scott Mendelsohn on the show. He's the box office guru at Puck and he has his own substack. We went through our summer movie confidence scale. We assigned a number, 1 through 16, to each movie based on how confident we were that it would hit the target the studio expected out of it. We're all about accountability on this show. So now we're back and we're going to see how we did. Was our confidence or lack of confidence justified and whose gut was most accurate for this summer? Today it's the summer box office reckoning for both Hollywood and Scott and me. From the ringer and Puck, I'm Matt Bellany and this is the town. All right. We are here with Scott Mendelsohn, box office guru and returning champion on the town. Welcome back, Scott.
Scott Mendelsohn
Always a pleasure. Thank you for having me.
Matt Bellany
I gotta admit, I'm sort of dreading this episode because I've watched one by one these movies come out this summer and sometimes our confidence was a little misplaced here and sometimes my lack of confidence was proven wrong here. So we're gonna go through one by one these movies that at the beginning of the summer we ranked. Remember we were forced to rank 1 through 16 and we could not repeat a number. So everything got a number that reflected our belief that it would perform or not perform to expectations. And we are now going to see how we did and hopefully I turned out okay. Although you are the expert.
Craig
So you, Matt, you sound devastated to go through this.
Matt Bellany
I am a little because I've seen the numbers and it's not great. Okay, first though, Scott, overall impression of the summer. Yay. Nay may meh. Shrug, shrug. Me too. Kind of boring stuff. Did okay stuff didn't perform like nothing really interesting to talk about.
Scott Mendelsohn
The issue, simplistically speaking with the summer is as usual. There weren't enough major movies in wide release and unlike previous summers past, there was not one or two super mega smash hits to sort of COVID the spread of underperforming films and. Or movies that just did okay and or a lack of overall content.
Matt Bellany
Right.
Scott Mendelsohn
You had hits but you didn't have any super mega Barbenheimer style over performers.
Matt Bellany
Yeah. Not even one of those like faith based movies that all of a sudden is gross $200 million like nothing like that.
Scott Mendelsohn
Yeah. Which again, you can't depend on those obviously. Just like you can't depend on, you know, a sporadic miracle like, you know, in 2004 you had the Passion, the Christ and Fire, 9911 making gajillions of dollars for people that otherwise would have stayed home.
Matt Bellany
Well, and not even like a big indie thing. Where, you know, we had long legs or something. I mean, yeah, materialists did fine. It's at like 85 million. And.
Scott Mendelsohn
And weapons.
Matt Bellany
Weapons, Right, but Weapons is a studio horror movie, so we'll get to weapons, but. But yes, and a lot of doubles, not a lot of home runs. So let's start here. Final Destination, Bloodlines. You had it at a 15 on the confidence scale. I was a little less confident at 13. $50 million budget, ended up doing 287 worldwide. Pretty good.
Scott Mendelsohn
It just opened in China last weekend, according to wbe and I can't find anything to refute this. It's the first R rated supernatural Hollywood horror film to open in China, if not ever, then certainly in a very, very, very, very long time. It did 6 million its opening weekend, so it should be over under 300 worldwide right now.
Matt Bellany
Oh, okay, then I stand corrected. Who knew the Chinese love hot people.
Scott Mendelsohn
Getting murdered when they're offered it. Yes.
Matt Bellany
Okay, so you win that one. Craig, will you take. Will you keep track of which of us won each movie and then at the end we will tally up.
Scott Mendelsohn
Sure.
Matt Bellany
Okay. So, Scott, at a 15, I think this movie exceeded expectations. 287 or 300 worldwide on a $50 million budget. Definitely relaunched the franchise. You were more confident, so you win that one. Lilo and Stitch, I had it at a 15 on the confidence scale. You went all in. A 16 and you were rewarded. Billion worldwide. 6, 10 international. That's a pretty good number. This is the only movie this summer to get to a billion. And I will admit I said this on the first show. I underestimated this movie. I am not a millennial. I did not have the nostalgia for it and I was proven wrong. Well, not that wrong, though I did say 15.
Scott Mendelsohn
Yeah, well, you did 13 for final destination. It's not the end of the world that it did better, but whenever. That's true. Stitch. Yeah, that's the one cartoon of the post Katzenberg and let's say pre Princess and the Frog Tangled era that's even as remotely as popular in present tense moviegoers as the Renaissance stuff.
Matt Bellany
Yeah, Stitch, very popular. So, all right, we were both very confident, but you were more confident and it exceeded expectations, so you get that one. Moving on to Mission Impossible, the final Reckoning. You had it at a three on the confidence scale. I had it as a four. The budget, $400 million for this movie. The overall worldwide, 598 worldwide. So it exceeded the previous one by about, I think 10 or 20 million, but basically did exactly the same as the first Reckoning Mission impossible and cost $400 million. This movie will not be profitable for Paramount and Skydance. This movie did okay, right?
Scott Mendelsohn
Yes. But first of all, again, I'm willing to give some leeway to the budget because shot during a pandemic, from what I'm told, they kept everybody on payroll, which is something that is good.
Matt Bellany
Good for them, not so good for the studio.
Scott Mendelsohn
Most of the global downturn from these last two pictures compared to the 2010s installments was because of an overall downturn in China and Russia. So it basically performed like a Mission Impossible sequel. It was leggy as hell in North America, which was. People liked it. And with all the hubbub about Dead Reckoning tanked because it lost IMAX screens. This film was leggy as hell even after it lost IMAX screens.
Matt Bellany
Yeah. And it did have those IMAX screens, though, that the previous one did not.
Scott Mendelsohn
Because Barbenheimer and Nothing dropped dead after losing its PLF screens. And that is a very encouraging thing.
Matt Bellany
All right, so who wins this one? You were less confident than I was. Do I win this one? Because you say it did okay, and I had it. I was a little more confident.
Scott Mendelsohn
I'll give this one to you. If I lose by one, then we'll talk.
Matt Bellany
Well, neither of us was that confident, so I'll take the. The W on that one just because I was a little bit more. And do you think they make another soon?
Scott Mendelsohn
No, and I think in the broad scheme of things, this is still a win because you still get a complete eight film saga that doesn't end on a giant cliffhanger. So they kind of had to suck it up and finish the movie.
Matt Bellany
Yeah, I disagree. I think they will make another one pretty soon. I just think Skydance, now running Paramount, they're looking for franchises anywhere they can find it. They'll take a couple of years off. Cruise will do some other things, but I think within five years, there will be another Mr. Impossible. I think what they should do is strip it down and have it be like a very tight, you know, hour 45. Yeah. Escape movie or something like that, where it's. It's different and it feels kind of like maybe even he's got a partner or something. I don't know if Renner's available, but they got. They got to do something different. But I do think they'll make another one. It's sort of fiscally irresponsible to not. All right. Karate Kid Legends. I had this movie as a one on the confidence scale. I was not confident at all. I did not think this would perform. You had it as an 8. It had a $45 million budget. The worldwide on this movie was 112. Not great. I'm going to take the W on this one, too.
Scott Mendelsohn
Well, I mean, yes and no.
Matt Bellany
Oh, you're going to claim that The Sony wanted 112 million out of this movie?
Scott Mendelsohn
No. But will it make money over the long haul?
Matt Bellany
Oh, forget the long haul. We're talking about this summer. This summer they wanted 300 million out of this movie.
Scott Mendelsohn
Yes, that's fair. And I liked the movie, but it was also like, what the hell are you doing here?
Matt Bellany
Oh, my. You liked it? They didn't like. Daniel LaRusso wasn't even in it until like an hour and something into it.
Scott Mendelsohn
That's why I liked it, because it was its own thing. I love the first hour when it's just the kid training his girlfriend's father how to be, you know, a kickboxer or whatever.
Matt Bellany
Oh, see, I was the total opposite. I was like, I come to Karate Kid. I want to see the goddamn Karate Kid. Where is Daniel LaRusso?
Scott Mendelsohn
He's elsewhere. But I like this new Karate Kid who is fun and charismatic.
Matt Bellany
Sure. All right, 112. I'm going to take the W. I was not confident. And there will not be another Karate Kid movie for a long time. Nor should there be Ballerina, Our Girl, Ana de Armas. Craig was very excited about this one. I had it as an 8. You had it as a 5. On the confidence scale, the budget, they say it was 90 million. I don't know if that includes all the reshoots and putting more Keanu in it. It does. Okay, well, I'm a little skeptical of that. Overall, worldwide, 135 million. Not great.
Scott Mendelsohn
No. I mean, again, to be fair, good reviews, good word of mouth, people seem to like it.
Matt Bellany
Yeah. What happened here?
Scott Mendelsohn
I will argue that they overcompensated and selling the wickedness of it all to the extent that they sort of implicitly argue that there wasn't that much special about the movie itself. And as someone that thinks it's a solid three star programmer, I think that was a mistake.
Matt Bellany
Well, they did fire their marketing people after this movie. Lionsgate got rid of the marketing people. They say it was unrelated. I have my doubts. But, yeah, they wanted a lot more out of this. So you get the win on this one. You were less confident than I was. I had an 8, you added a 5. So you are going to take the win On Ballerina. Will they do additional John Wick spinoffs is the question.
Scott Mendelsohn
I don't know how long in development the Donnie Yen picture is, although, I mean, if they can spend $60 million on a Donnie Yen directed Donnie Yen action movie that has value beyond just the John Wick brand, I would argue. Do they do it? I don't know. But it's not the worst. If you want to make John Wick spin offs and we can debate whether they should, there are worse wins.
Matt Bellany
Well, they sort of have to. This is Lionsgate. This is like their biggest franchise, and they killed off the main character in the previous John Wick. So other than bringing him back or having, you know, the ghost of Keanu advising other people, like, what are they going to do?
Craig
I think this movie struggled because it came out in the summer right around Mission Impossible, and it got swallowed up by that.
Scott Mendelsohn
And if this movie was.
Craig
I think if this was an April movie, it would have done a lot better. And it feels like a much more successful April movie than it does a competing with Jurassic park and Mission Impossible movie.
Matt Bellany
So Lionsgate got a little over their skis.
Scott Mendelsohn
And what they had, Covid and Strikes notwithstanding, this film obviously would have had a little bit more buzz had it come out a maybe between John Wick 3 and 4, so the continuity wouldn't be all convoluted and much sooner after Knives out and no time to die when Ana de Armas was. To a certain extent.
Craig
That's totally fair.
Matt Bellany
That's fair. How dare you, Scott? How dare you say anything negative about Ana de Armas? She is the patron saint of the town. Craig. Craig, how do you agree with that? You got to defend her.
Craig
Look, I thought the movie was. Was solid.
Scott Mendelsohn
I.
Matt Bellany
She got you in the theater. She got you. You. You attended this movie in the theaters. Paid. Paid real American money.
Craig
I went to the premiere alone, actually.
Matt Bellany
Oh, that's right, you did go to the premiere alone. Yes, but yet you were too scared to say hello to her, which I stand by. Okay.
Scott Mendelsohn
It comes to modern American movie stardom more often than not. Deserves. Got nothing to do with it.
Matt Bellany
Okay, well, let's move on. How to train your dragon. Scott was a 13 on this movie. I was a 12. Budget 150. I think it was higher. And worldwide, 628. Pretty good.
Scott Mendelsohn
Yes. I would say this was an unmitigated win. The reviews were good, the legs were long, People showed up and they liked what they saw.
Matt Bellany
Well, and Universal has two more of these coming. They say. Or at least one is dated. So this was very important because they want to be in the Disney business of remaking the hits. And now they can be. They got. They got a real franchise here.
Scott Mendelsohn
Unlike Pixar and Disney, DreamWorks franchises, for better or worse, are franchises. Most of the hit films have two or three sequels. And weirdly enough, most DreamWorks animated franchises have a part two that's better than the part one. So if they can get part one and get away with it, then they've got two or three almost automatic hits.
Matt Bellany
Does this mean that we're going to get a Kung Fu Panda live action?
Scott Mendelsohn
That is the great question. You know, making a Kung Fu Panda live action is very different than making how to Train you'd Dragon live action because one is basically a Cuban set Dungeons and Dragons adventure story and one is like the Lion King. But can we get away with it?
Matt Bellany
Okay, but, but my point is the dragon is a CG dragon at the center of it and you could make the panda a CG panda at the center of that movie, but then everyone.
Scott Mendelsohn
Else is also cg and that's what's sort of different about it.
Matt Bellany
Well, yeah, I guess you'd have to change that.
Scott Mendelsohn
Like Lilo and Stitch, you have one CG crowd pleasing element amidst an otherwise human story.
Matt Bellany
That's true. How to Train youn Dragon. Huge win for Universal. You were more confident. So you get the W on that one. Elio. Oof. You had it as a six. I had it as a two. Budget. 150 to 200. That's a big range. They say 150, I think, but I think they did a lot of tinkering with this one. So probably closer to 2. Domestic was only 72 million on this movie. Yikes. Worldwide, 152. The lowest grossing Pixar movie ever. Is that right?
Scott Mendelsohn
I think Onward was less than that.
Matt Bellany
Well, Covid impacted. Yeah, non Covid impacted before 2020.
Scott Mendelsohn
How about that?
Matt Bellany
Okay, so huge loss here for Disney. I was way less confident in this movie than you were. So I'm going to take the W. I mean, what. What's left to say about Elio?
Scott Mendelsohn
They should have kept it in summer.
Matt Bellany
2024 as no, they Iger didn't want this coming out. Right when he had an activist shareholder up his butt. He wanted this to be pushed so he could get rid of the activists and then it would be dumped and he didn't have to worry about it.
Scott Mendelsohn
I mean, it would have been more successful.
Matt Bellany
You think so?
Scott Mendelsohn
I do. I think the original cut, assuming all the, you know, the Mudsling.
Matt Bellany
Oh, you're talking about content wise, you're thinking. You think they washed it of anything controversial?
Scott Mendelsohn
Yes. And whether or not the unedited version would have been more successful, it couldn't have been any worse. And it would have been coming six months after a year after Elemental, which showed that audiences were willing to come back to see a Pixar original. The alternate to that is that it would have been a few months after Wish, which was one of the worst movies Disney's ever made. So I might be wrong, but I do think coming off of Elemental, there was reason to be optimistic that maybe that was the one that was going to re acclimate them to showing up for non sequel animated films again. And the fact that they didn't is terrifying.
Matt Bellany
Yeah. So the larger lesson here, do you think Elio was an Elio problem or is it a Pixar problem?
Scott Mendelsohn
It's both. I think in a vacuum, maybe you do good dinosaur numbers, which is still terrible, but you make it back over the long haul and post theatrical, but you don't make back 150 worldwide on a 2 to 2 whatever the actual budget was from DVD sales and Disney streaming DVD.
Matt Bellany
Who's buying DVDs?
Scott Mendelsohn
Exactly.
Matt Bellany
I think it'll do fine on Disney at the beginning. But these Pixar movies aren't musicals. And the musicals are the ones that keep popping up on the charts.
Scott Mendelsohn
That is correct. That's what Encanto has in common with Demon Slayer. Everyone's listening to songs.
Matt Bellany
You mean Demon Hunters? Please get your demons straight.
Scott Mendelsohn
Which one's got the Infinity Castle? I don't remember.
Matt Bellany
No. Demon Hunters is the K pop movie. Demon Slayer is the Japanese movie that's coming out later, which is going to.
Scott Mendelsohn
Kick ass in September domestically as it races toward 300 worldwide.
Matt Bellany
All right, well, that is outside our purview here, so I'm going to take the W on Elio. I was way less confident than you were. Let's move on. 28 years later, the sequel, 20 years after the previous zombie movie with Danny Boyle back directing. I was confident in this. I had it as a 9. You were less confident, you had it as a 7. The budget was 60 million on this. The worldwide was 150 million worldwide. So not what they wanted out of this. Sony, I think when they bought this, it was a competitive situation. They bought this thinking this could be a summer franchise and could do 2,300 million. 150, I think is a disappointment.
Scott Mendelsohn
And I think the problem is Hollywood sort of tricks themselves into thinking these vaguely recognizable IPs are worth worthy of a competitive bidding war. And quality notwithstanding, they're not.
Matt Bellany
Well, Sony didn't have anything else for this summer, so they kind of needed this. And once Spider Verse got delayed, they needed something that they could plug into the summer. So, you know, I think they'd probably do this deal again. It's not going to be a big money loser for them, but certainly not the Juggernaut. And they got another one of these coming in what, six months?
Scott Mendelsohn
Once again, Nia dacosta is being set up to take the hit for another film slash franchise's underperformance.
Matt Bellany
She did Candyman and she did a Marvel movie. Right. Although Candyman was good, Candyman was profitable.
Scott Mendelsohn
That made money.
Matt Bellany
Okay, but she. Which one of the Marvels did she do? The Marvels.
Scott Mendelsohn
The Marvels.
Matt Bellany
The Marvels. Okay. Well, hopefully she'll have better luck here. But you actually predicted, you said 28 years later will open bigger than Elio, which turned out to be true. It was a 30 million opening, and Elio only got to 20, so I'll take it. Let's move on to Megan 2.0. Oof. We both took a hit here. I was confident. I said this was an 11. I thought this would work. You were a little less confident at 10. The budget was anywhere from 15 to 25. I think Blum said on the show that it was 20, if I remember correctly, worldwide, 39 million. Yikes.
Scott Mendelsohn
I mean, to be fair, other than the Purge franchise, Blumhouse sequels generally don't over index compared to the first ones.
Matt Bellany
But the first one did 180 worldwide. I mean, it was underperforming. And then there's like falling off a cliff. She did the Toonces, the driving cat off the cliff here. And this is a quarter of what the first one did.
Scott Mendelsohn
This is an overestimation of the marquee character. You could argue that switching up genres did more harm than good.
Matt Bellany
That seems to be what Blum thinks. He thinks that they were too confident. They thought M3 Gan could do anything. She was a superhero, she was funny. And they got away from what made the original work, which was that ultimately it was a horror movie.
Scott Mendelsohn
I think if they had made a film that was basically demolition Terminator 2, but with Megan, but made that movie, I think it would have been fine. But they really didn't give you that level of Megan in her Megan outfit versus the evil robot beating the crap out of each other. I mean, they don't give you the Demolition man payoff.
Matt Bellany
All right, So I was more confident than you. We both kind of take a loss on this one. But you were less confident, so you.
Scott Mendelsohn
Take the W. I was pretty confident.
Matt Bellany
We were both confident. I know neither of us should get a win on this one, but somebody has to. And you were less confident, so you get it.
Scott Mendelsohn
And I think it's. It's scary for Blumhouse because they are not the brand name that they were in the mid to late 2010s.
Matt Bellany
Yeah. But they're still doing a lot of movies, so I think they can get it back. They got Five Nights at Freddy's too. Hopefully that will be a little bit better.
Scott Mendelsohn
That would be probably so profitable it might make up the difference for everything else.
Matt Bellany
Maybe. We'll see. I'm sure they are furiously tinkering that one to make sure it does as.
Scott Mendelsohn
Well as possible, because that always works.
Matt Bellany
All right, F1, I had this as a seven. You had it as a four. You were pessimistic on this one. Worldwide, it is at 605 million. The international, as we both predicted, the international is much larger. 419 domestic, just 185. So it doubled, more than doubled its take internationally. I'm going to take the W on this one. This is a good result for F1.
Scott Mendelsohn
This is a spectacular result for F1. It was leggy. It was well liked, it was well reviewed. We spent all summer talking about underwhelming overseas grosses, even for big domestic pictures. This was an example of a film that kicked ass overseas.
Matt Bellany
Yeah. No, and which, which we kind of knew it would do. The budget, you know, anywhere from 250 to 300. So not cheap. And it's a standalone. I don't know, maybe they'll do a sequel. Yeah, maybe they will. But. Yeah. I just feel like this is a invitation to Apple to do more big budget summer movies and put them in theaters. And that is what Hollywood wanted out of this movie. And we got it.
Scott Mendelsohn
They could still chicken out. And frankly, of course, there's no reason why Highest to Lowest didn't get at least a token theatrical release.
Matt Bellany
Well, that's a whole separate the Spike Lee movie. You got Denzel in a drama and you dump it in late August. Like, I don't know what happened there. Dive into an Italian summer with Dolce and Gabbana light blue. Visit Dolce Gabbana.com to discover more.
Bill Simmons
This message is a paid partnership with Apple Card. If there's one thing I'm going to make sure I pack for my summer vacation, it's my Apple Card. I can earn up to 3% daily cash back on every purchase, including fuel for my car and booking places to stay. Plus, I don't have to worry about fees, including foreign transaction fees, which is perfect when I'm planning to travel abroad. To get an Apple Card for your summer travels, apply in the Wallet app on your iPhone today, subject to credit approval. Apple Card issued by Goldman Sachs Bank USA, Salt Lake City Branch. Variable APRs for Apple Card range from 18.24% to 28.49% based on creditworthiness rates as of July 1, 2025 Terms and.
Matt Bellany
More at applecard.com Jurassic World Rebirth. This was my number one most confident movie. I put this as a 16. You had it as a 14 budget. Around 200 worldwide. 850. Pretty good result.
Scott Mendelsohn
The only reason it's not 15 is because final Destination was so cheap that I couldn't imagine it not at least crawling to 150.
Matt Bellany
Okay, but this is down from a billion. These Jurassic movies keep grossing less and less each time.
Scott Mendelsohn
Not really. If you take out China, which is a macro issue, this film is going to end up within 10% of Dominion domestically and overseas.
Matt Bellany
All right. I'm just saying we got to take out China because China's not a factor. Although it did get a release in China.
Scott Mendelsohn
It did. It did. $70 million, which is why 2020 standards is good, but it's still less than the 160 that Dominion did.
Matt Bellany
You're making my argument. I was most confident about this. And you think that this movie hit the expectations that Universal had for it?
Scott Mendelsohn
Assuming their expectations are realistic. And I'm assuming they were, you know, they were spending 180 and hoping for 750. They got 850 plus. I imagine they're thrilled.
Matt Bellany
Yeah. And this was rushed into production because they needed a big summer movie. So I think it's a win. I'm going to take the W on this. They can do more Jurassics with this cast, so I'm going to say this is a win. I'm going to give myself the W on this. All right. Superman, you were much more bullish on this. You had it at an 11 on the confidence scale. I had it as a 6 budget. 225 worldwide. 606 million. So not embarrassing. They can do more Supermans. I think this is a win for Warners.
Scott Mendelsohn
Yeah. The domestic number is very strong. It's Leggier.
Matt Bellany
350.
Scott Mendelsohn
A hell of a lot leggier than the last one. People like it. And Obviously this is 2025. But in terms of sentiment, this feels a hell of a lot closer to Iron man and Batman Begins versus Man.
Matt Bellany
Of Steel and Amazing Spider Man. It's fine. This is not. People were not through the moon on this one. The. The Rotten Tomatoes score is good, but I don't think this is. If this had arrived out of nowhere, Like, I don't think this is a franchise starter. I think it's good enough. People liked it. They found it to be different enough and charming enough. The cast is good. Like, just take the W. I don't think we need to declare this to be the new Iron Man.
Scott Mendelsohn
This film was received in a way that will make people excited or interested in what comes next. And frankly, I am more bullish for Supergirl because of Superman than I would have been before Superman.
Matt Bellany
Okay, well, that's a good point. People talk about Superman as this big hit, but it did less than man of Steel, not adjusted for inflation. In 2013, man of Steel did 670 worldwide, which would be way more than Superman.
Scott Mendelsohn
It would be. And my only defense, for lack of a better term for that, is reviews were better, word of mouth was better, buzz was better. And in 2013, man of Steel was basically being sold as the metaphorical Dark Knight, Part four. You had that going for it in a way that you didn't for Superman.
Craig
Also, it was a different time. Superman doing what it did in 2025 is more impressive than what man of steel did in 2013.
Scott Mendelsohn
Agreed.
Matt Bellany
Man of Steel actually grows more internationally than domestically, which is not the case for this one. And you were more confident on this movie than I was. So you are going to get the.
Scott Mendelsohn
W in terms of launching a franchise. It had everything you wanted. Even noting the underwhelming overseas grosses, because nine times out of 10, when you launch a franchise, the ones that become franchises are the ones that over index in North America, not the ones that over index overseas.
Matt Bellany
Why is that? Because it's more reliable. You know you can repeat it.
Scott Mendelsohn
Yeah, probably.
Matt Bellany
And perception wise, you've got to have that domestic in order for the US Audience to be like, oh, we get why they're doing a sequel.
Scott Mendelsohn
Yeah.
Matt Bellany
All right, Smurfs. This one's bad. I had this as a 10 on the confidence scale. You had it as a 1. Your least confident budget? Almost 60 million worldwide. 110. Not great. Big loss for Paramount.
Scott Mendelsohn
Paramount. I love you. I know you've been struggling the last decade because the bottom fell out on studio programmers. That isn't your fault.
Matt Bellany
Well, it is Their fault not having franchises and not bulking up in the 2010s when all the other studios bulked up on franchises.
Scott Mendelsohn
The only thing worse than trying to refurbish your discarded leftover IP is dumpster diving through another studio's discarded ip. And that is what happens. And this is not a surprise. And the only other thing I'll say is that budget notwithstanding, the original Elio still made more money in theaters than Smurfs.
Matt Bellany
Yeah, with a budget like three times as much.
Scott Mendelsohn
Budget notwithstanding, in raw theatrical, a IP for the sake of IP can be no riskier than a long than an original picture.
Matt Bellany
Yeah, Disney didn't have to pay Rihanna. Also, what a grift. Man, that song was so half assed. And she made some appearances at Cinemacon, went to the premiere like I don't know what her paycheck was, but I imagine it was not cheap to get her and did not seem to help.
Scott Mendelsohn
No, and it shouldn't have expected to help. I mean Katy Perry only helped so, so much with the first Smurf movie back in 2011.
Matt Bellany
But Paramount seemed to think that Katy Perry helped because they went the exact same playbook.
Scott Mendelsohn
They were wrong.
Matt Bellany
Okay, well, Brian Robbins, Paramount studio had the final kiss off to the new owners was Smurfs. So good for him. All right, Fantastic Four first steps. I had this as a three on the confidence scale. I was not confident, but you jumped me and went to a two on the comp. You were not confident at all. Budget was more than 200 million worldwide. 491. That is not a good result for Fantastic Four in my opinion.
Scott Mendelsohn
Yes, the film did make five. It will make 500 worldwide. It'll do 260 give or take. But domestic, this was supposed to show that the Marvel brand was still strong enough to push new to Marvel franchises and previously done franchises to at least phase two level box office, which is around 7,800 million worldwide. On the strength of the Marvel name, that didn't happen. This film will sell fewer tickets than the 2005 Fantastic Four. And it was no leggier than the 2015 Fantastic Four. What this means is that unless you're dealing with outside nostalgia, no Way Home, Deadpool and Wolverine, the Marvel brand is now a 4 fans only franchise. Which means you're not getting people that are outside general moviegoers that aren't already interested in Marvel in the abstract. And that is a terrible place for Marvel to be.
Matt Bellany
Yeah, especially when you got Avengers movies coming that are extremely expensive and are just throwing tons of characters at the wall. Maybe people don't care enough to want to see those characters again.
Scott Mendelsohn
Well, yeah, not all of this is Kevin Feige's fault. I'm going to assume he did not say, I want to make tons of Disney shows, and I want to sell the lie that you need to watch them to understand the movies. I will assume that was not his doing. However, that's a huge reason why Marvel is in the place that it is. Because they oversaturated the brand. They turned it into homework. They wasted a ton of promising new characters and new storylines on the Disney shows that very few people watched. And now here they are where they are banking on nostalgia for 2010's Marvel movies and nostalgia for not Disney Marvel movies like Amazing, Spider Man, Deadpool, et cetera.
Matt Bellany
X Men. It's all on X Men now. They got to do something cool with that.
Scott Mendelsohn
Who's going to give a crap about X Men?
Matt Bellany
I know there have been like seven movies.
Scott Mendelsohn
Exactly. And now that the Marvel brand is no longer an automatic A plus cinematic vacation destination, it's just going to be another X Men movie.
Matt Bellany
Yeah. Hopefully better, though. All right, moving on. Naked Gun. I had it as a five. I was not confident you had it as a 12 budget. 40 million worldwide, 88 million. So not a disaster, but not great. This did exactly what we thought it would do, in my opinion. I was not confident you thought it.
Scott Mendelsohn
Would do more because I would argue that the marketing did the job in terms of this film will be funny and entertaining, even if you don't give a damn about Naked Gun. And I would argue the film delivered on that. Good reviews, good buzz. I think theoretically, if they do make a sequel to this, I'm not saying they should. If they do make a sequel, this has the potential to be a breakout sequel, which is the people that discover it down the line like what they see, and they show up on opening weekend for the next one.
Matt Bellany
You can't do a sequel at 88 million worldwide.
Scott Mendelsohn
No, I agree with you.
Matt Bellany
I don't know. And I don't know what everybody going into this movie was saying, okay, this needs to do well for comedies to be released theatrically. I don't think we got a clear message that more comedies should be released theatrically here.
Scott Mendelsohn
I think that was a very funny advertising campaign, and I'm glad they leaned into that. I think it did well enough to say we should keep trying, as did the next film we're going to talk about.
Matt Bellany
Yeah, I was going to say, so I get that one. And then freakier Friday. I was very confident in this one. 14. I thought this might be a breakout. You were less so at 9. Budget around 45 million worldwide. 115. So this comedy did better than. Than Naked Gun. It was, you know, totally different audience. Millennials versus Gen X. And is this a hit?
Scott Mendelsohn
Yeah, it's got triple its budget, more or less because it's not done.
Matt Bellany
Yeah. So I win this one. So I get. I get the W on this one.
Scott Mendelsohn
I'll give you that.
Matt Bellany
Okay. So yeah, I mean, not much to say about this. I think this did about what I thought it would. I thought maybe it would get to 150, maybe a little higher than that, but solid little movie for Disney.
Scott Mendelsohn
If this is how Disney gets audiences re acclimated to showing up to stuff like Cheaper by the Dozen or Alexander and the Horrible, Terrible, no Good, Very Bad Day, then great.
Matt Bellany
Yeah. And 100%. Three years ago this would have gone to Disney.
Scott Mendelsohn
Absolutely.
Matt Bellany
All right, final movie we did not assign our confidence scores to. But Scott, you volunteered that we should be keeping our eye on weapons, which I think is a big flex for you because obviously it's been doing well. Budget, 38 million worldwide is at 207 right now and counting. It'd probably get up to like 230. 240. Big W for you.
Scott Mendelsohn
I am two for two in terms of keep an eye out for this one because last year it was with us.
Matt Bellany
Well, it's not out of the blue. People were saying this one was good. And in all the coverage of the Warner brothers Mike and Pam drama, everyone was saying that people had high hopes for weapons. So it was not out of nowhere here. All right, so before we tally up and drum roll, the winner of the summer box office confidence scale, give me your studio winner and your studio loser for the summer. I have my picks.
Scott Mendelsohn
Studio winner is Warner Brothers.
Matt Bellany
Yeah, that's pretty clear. They had weapons. They had Superman. They released F1 even though they didn't make it. They released it for Apple.
Scott Mendelsohn
They marketed it.
Matt Bellany
They had final destination. Those are all hits.
Scott Mendelsohn
And frankly, if summer 2025 ends up above summer 2024 and it will be a nail biter, it will be because Sinners and Minecraft brought in about 180 million after April.
Matt Bellany
Right. So in May, the holdover of Sinners and Minecraft really helped the summer. And those are both Warner's movies.
Scott Mendelsohn
Sinners alone made like I think 132 million, which is more than a lot of the would be tent poles did in North America.
Matt Bellany
So we agree on studio winner this summer, I think Universal actually did fine because they're two kind of not risky, but Jurassic and How to Train youn Dragon both kind of hit their mark, but I think Warner's is the winner. Studio loser. This one's easy for me. Sony breaks my heart.
Scott Mendelsohn
Lionsgate.
Matt Bellany
Oh, you're going to pick Lionsgate just because of Ballerina?
Scott Mendelsohn
Yeah, it's Ballerina. Because they didn't basically had nothing else.
Matt Bellany
Yeah, well, they had some garbage late August dump movies that are basically for vod.
Scott Mendelsohn
The issue with Ballerina isn't that it underperformed is that with Michael says of 2026 and saw 11 in purgatory, this is it for them, you know, up until September.
Matt Bellany
Well, they got the long walk, the.
Scott Mendelsohn
Stephen King, to be fair, starting in September, they are getting their asses in gear and I am perhaps overly confident. Long walk, good fortune. How did you see me? Three Strangers Part two and the Housemaid, which is my second most anticipated film of the rest of the year after Avatar 3.
Matt Bellany
So you have Lionsgate is the loser for me. It's a race between Sony and Paramount. I'm going to pick Sony just because they had a couple of would be franchises that didn't really work. Karate kid. And 28 years later, they also had another one that we didn't even discuss. I know you did last summer that fizzled and we thought so little of it, we didn't even discuss it. And for a studio that considers itself still in the tent pole business to not have any in the summer is bad. Paramount, I think, is a close second because the only tent pole they did have, Mission Impossible, ended up losing a bunch of money. But they did, at least for market share, get up to, you know, almost 600 million on that movie. So they did have a high grosser. Even though Smurfs and Naked Gun did not perform.
Scott Mendelsohn
They were certainly a better studio for theaters than Sony and Lionsgate. And I have no nice things to say about Sony this summer because again, all three of their pictures were IP for the sake of IP that everyone should have seen coming. Yeah, how they did not have a Where the crawdads sing and or it ends with us type picture set for July or August is madness to me.
Matt Bellany
Right, yeah, they've had a history with those and yet nothing. Okay, so Craig, have you done the tally?
Craig
Yes, I have.
Matt Bellany
Who is the winner of the summer movie confidence scale game?
Craig
You guys were close on a lot of these, but based on how you kind of assigned wins and losses, Scott.
Matt Bellany
Won nine to seven, closer than I thought.
Craig
And the four movies that you guys had the largest gaps on in terms of your confidence was Smurf, Superman, Karate Kid and Naked Gun and you guys split those. Matt was much more confident about Smurf, so Scott won that. Scott was much more confident about Superman, so he wins that. Scott was was more confident about Karate Kids, so Matt won that. And then Scott was more confident about Naked Gun, so Matt won that. So the largest gaps you guys had, you also sp. It almost proves that this is very hard to predict and everything is a coin flip.
Matt Bellany
Yes. And we were both super confident on Megan, Megan 2.0, which turned into a series we both blew.
Scott Mendelsohn
Megan and I will argue I blew it on F1. You know, the numbers aren't that different, but I thought, gee, I hope this was great buy and it's the biggest grossing live action Hollywood original since Interstellar.
Matt Bellany
Yeah, well, I blew it on Smurfs. My confidence in Rihanna was just way.
Scott Mendelsohn
Misplaced, Alan notwithstanding, because dessert's got nothing to do with it.
Matt Bellany
True. All right, well, I appreciate the time, Scott. There is unfortunately no prize. There is no prize for the winner. Craig, can we get some kind of trophy or something?
Craig
You get the pride of winning the summer box office competition. Now walking around la.
Matt Bellany
Yes.
Craig
People will shout you out and congratulate.
Matt Bellany
Exactly. All right. Thank you, Scott.
Scott Mendelsohn
You're very welcome. Always a pleasure.
Matt Bellany
All right, before we go, I want to thank everyone that came to the live show at the El Rey theater in Los Angeles last night. Great crowd, really fun. Our secret, top secret guest was Adam Aaron, the CEO of AMC theaters, my part time nemesis, my very good friend, Adam Aaron. Good talk. And Lucas was there. Cool crowd. So that episode will post on Monday for the holiday. And until then, I want to thank today's guest, Scott Mendelsohn, producer Kirk Horleback, artist Jesse Lopez and I want to thank you. We'll see you next week.
Bill Simmons
This episode is brought to you by Whole Foods Market. You know the deal. Summer means grilling, maybe even impressing your pals with the best cookout of summer. Well, if you want to go big on quality without breaking the bank, say hello to 365 by Whole Foods Market. They've got everything you need for the grill, from antibiotic free chicken thighs to uncured hot dogs, even wild caught salmon burgers. If you're feeling fancy, you can pick up organic condiments, sides, chips, drinks, even dessert from ice cream cake cones. Plus you'll see these yellow low priced signs all over the store. Yeah, they actually mean something here. Same for the yellow sale signs with new deals every Wednesday. And if you want to stay at home, no worries. There's delivery options, too. So whether you're a grill master or just there for the snacks, there are so many ways to save on summer grilling favorites at Whole Foods Market.
Episode Title: The Summer Box Office Report Card: Surprise Hits, Big Flops, and Key Takeaways
Date: August 29, 2025
Host: Matt Belloni
Guest: Scott Mendelsohn (Box Office Analyst, Puck)
Episode Theme:
Matt Belloni and returning guest Scott Mendelsohn break down the 2025 summer box office, revisiting their pre-season “confidence scale” rankings for this summer’s wide releases. They analyze hits, misses, and the broader industry implications, including Hollywood’s ongoing franchise obsession, original IP drought, the international market’s shifting role, and what this summer means for the future of theatrical releases.
(discussed largely between [05:21] and [36:53])
Matt (on summer 2025 as “boring”): "Kind of boring stuff. Did okay. Stuff didn't perform. Like nothing really interesting to talk about." ([04:04])
Scott (on IP bidding wars): "Hollywood sort of tricks themselves into thinking these vaguely recognizable IPs are worth, worthy of a competitive bidding war. And quality notwithstanding, they're not." ([20:02])
Matt (on Smurfs & Rihanna): "What a grift. That song was so half-assed. And she made some appearances at CinemaCon...did not seem to help." ([31:02])
Scott (Marvel’s current status): "Unless you're dealing with outside nostalgia...the Marvel brand is now a 4 fans only franchise. That is a terrible place for Marvel to be." ([33:02])
On animation & musicals:
On Megan 2.0: "She did the Toonces the driving cat off the cliff here." — Matt ([21:36])
The episode provides an in-depth, candid “report card” for summer 2025’s major releases, highlighting how even industry insiders can miss the mark in their predictions. It reinforces both the unpredictability and the franchise obsession of the current studio system, noting the increasing challenges faced by originals and second-tier IPs in breaking out. Ultimately, the episode is marked by its tone—wry, self-aware, and energetic—matching the creative and commercial volatility of the movie business.
To hear all the candid industry insights and banter, listen to The Town with Matthew Belloni, August 29, 2025.