The Unforgotten - Season 2: Unnatural Causes
Episode 10: The Lawmakers
Release Date: April 15, 2025

Introduction

In Episode 10 of The Unforgotten, titled "The Lawmakers," host Charlie Scudder delves into the ongoing legislative battle to enhance security measures in senior living communities in Texas. This episode provides a comprehensive look at the efforts of activists Shannon Dionne and Lauren Smith, both intimately affected by the tragic murders committed by serial killer Billy Shamirmere. As they testify before the Texas Senate Committee on Health and Human Services, the episode unpacks the challenges and progress in passing Senate Bill 1283 (SB 1283), aimed at preventing future tragedies.

Updates Since Season Two

Charlie Scudder begins by updating listeners on significant developments since the end of Season 2. Notably, the civil lawsuits against Tradition Prestonwood, a senior living community implicated in the Shamirmere case, have been settled out of court. Attorney Trey Crawford, featured in Episode 3, describes the settlement, which included undisclosed payouts and a non-disclosure agreement preventing families from discussing the case further.

[06:07] Lauren Smith: "We're paying a premium price to have our mothers protected there. And he was in there all the time and they did nothing."

Despite the settlement, Charlie emphasizes that the broader systemic issues remain unresolved, highlighting that the legal battles have ended without holding the community accountable.

Additionally, a startling development surfaced involving Fort Worth Congresswoman Kay Granger, who was found to be residing in a Tradition Clear Fork senior living community despite experiencing dementia. This revelation raises questions about the oversight and transparency of such facilities.

[08:41] Shannon Dionne: "She missed most of her votes in Washington throughout the summer and fall."

Legislative Hearing on SB 1283

The core of the episode focuses on the Senate Committee hearing for SB 1283, spearheaded by Republican Senator Tan Parker. This bill seeks to implement comprehensive security improvements in senior living communities, addressing the loopholes that previously allowed Shamirmere to commit his crimes with impunity.

Bill Overview

Senator Tan Parker outlines the bill’s intent:

[25:19] Tan Parker: "Senate Bill 1283 enhances the safety and security of residents living in senior retirement communities by establishing clear guidelines for preventing and responding to criminal activity."

However, discrepancies arise as Charlie points out inaccuracies in Parker’s account, such as the mischaracterization of Shamirmere’s employment status.

Testimonies and Stakeholder Perspectives

Shannon Dionne and Lauren Smith, both deeply affected by Shamirmere's actions, provide poignant testimonies supporting SB 1283. Lauren details the horrors her mother endured, emphasizing the necessity of the bill’s measures.

[31:11] Shannon Dionne: "If my mother and so many others knew that there had been a criminal trespasser, they would never have opened their door."

Cheryl Pangburn, representing AARP Texas, endorses the bill, highlighting its significance in safeguarding older adults.

[29:41] Cheryl Pangburn: "Older adults deserve to live in safe, welcoming environments free from crime and disruption."

Conversely, Carmen Tilton from the Texas Assisted Living Association (TALA) unexpectedly supports the committee substitute for SB 1283, citing a balanced approach between safety and independence.

[34:03] Carmen Tilton: "TALA appreciates that this bill directs senior living communities to have a proactive communications policy with their residents, but that it doesn't push into unnecessary scaremongering."

Challenges in Passing the Bill

The episode highlights the ideological battle between advocates like SOSS and conservative groups such as the Texas Conservative Coalition (TCC) that oppose increased regulations. TCC's influence often leads to the rejection of bills perceived as overly restrictive or non-conservative.

[17:29] Carmen Tilton: "The bill was viewed as not conservative enough for Texas, and thus, it never made it out of committee."

Despite these hurdles, SB 1283 made progress by being referred to the Senate committee, a significant step forward from previous legislative sessions where the bill was often sidelined without consideration.

Personal Struggles and Persistence

The emotional toll on activists Shannon and Lauren is palpable as they recount their experiences testifying. Their resilience underscores the personal commitment driving the legislative push.

[32:45] Shannon Dionne: "Envision your mom opening the door and instantly realizing that her life was in grave danger."

Current Status and Future Prospects

As the hearing concludes, SB 1283 remains pending in the Senate committee. Charlie reflects on the arduous path ahead, acknowledging that while progress has been made, significant obstacles persist. The episode underscores the importance of continued advocacy and public support to eventually see the bill enacted into law.

[36:19] Charlie Scudder: "Senate Bill 1283 will be left pending at this time. That's what happens to most bills when they're first considered in committee hearings. It could die there or be referred to the full Senate for a vote."

Conclusion

Episode 10, "The Lawmakers," provides a thorough exploration of the legislative efforts to enhance security in Texas senior living communities. Through detailed testimonies, expert insights, and a candid look at the political landscape, Charlie Scudder effectively conveys the complexities and emotional weight of this ongoing battle. For those seeking a deeper understanding of the systemic issues that allowed Billy Shamirmere's crimes to go unchecked, this episode serves as an essential resource.

Notable Quotes:

• Shannon Dionne [02:28]: "You could have knocked me over. There's an old term, gobsmacked. I don't have a word to describe when I think about what my mother's last moments. I have nightmares of that."

• Cheryl Pangburn [06:00]: "It'S one. Probably in the history of the US."

• Shannon Dionne [31:11]: "If my mother and so many others knew that there had been a criminal trespasser, they would never have opened their door."

• Carmen Tilton [34:03]: "We support resident independence. We maintain privacy. We try to keep people safe."

• Charlie Scudder [36:19]: "Senate Bill 1283 will be left pending at this time."

For more information on the legislative efforts and to support Secure Our Seniors Safety (SOSS), visit secureourseniorssafety.org.