The Unplanned Podcast with Matt & Abby
Episode: Married Couple plays Agree to Disagree unhinged
Date: December 17, 2025
Episode Overview
In this emotionally revealing and candid episode, Matt and Abby play their fan-favorite "Agree or Disagree" game—a relationship deep-dive that prompts them to individually react to a series of escalating, often unfiltered, statements about marriage, parenting, loss, and personal growth. Opening in their newly-upgraded (and kid-decorated) home studio, the duo talks through over 60 statements across three levels of intimacy, offering listeners an unguarded look into their evolving relationship, their perspectives on modern marriage, healing after miscarriage, boundaries, parenting choices, and more. The episode is peppered with both laughter and vulnerability, showcasing why fans appreciate their realness and willingness to address uncomfortable questions.
Key Discussion Points and Insights
1. Changes Through Parenthood and Loss
2. Marriage Timing and Compatibility
-
On Marrying Young
- Matt is adamant: "I just don't see it happening any other way... We chose each other over careers. We chose each other over money." [09:23]
- Abby shares it was about maturity in their relationship, not age.
-
Shared Life Goals
- Both agree it's important—though not vital—to have similar aspirations and to revisit them as individuals grow.
3. Parenting Philosophies
-
Screen Time as Survival
- Both strongly agree that screens are a tool for parents’ sanity:
- "If you need a little break because you're about to lose it—yeah. Put on, put on a little show." – Matt, [16:02]
-
Dog in the Bed?
- Both strongly disagree, but admit their position could change as their pet ages.
4. Marriage Foundations: Love, Finances, and Roles
5. Trust and Boundaries
6. Honesty and White Lies
- White Lies in Relationships
- Nuanced agreement—sometimes a gentle white lie is more compassionate, especially postpartum.
- "You know, I'm actually okay in that situation you lying to me. I prefer that you lie to me in that situation." – Abby [46:21]
7. Infidelity, Cheating, and Forgiveness
8. Social Media & Public Life
- Agree their online presence may amplify happiness, but strive for realness, especially through the podcast medium.
- "This is like the realest thing you can have. Like, we're just...sitting, chatting, you know?" – Matt [36:49]
9. Growth Over Time
10. Hope, Grief, Parenting after Loss
- Both discuss ongoing grief about miscarriage—how each has grieved differently, with Abby confronting feelings head-on for her children's sake, and Matt feeling dissociation followed by delayed emotional release.
- Contemplate "redemptive pregnancy" after loss and the hope and anxiety that brings.
11. Lighter, Playful Moments
- Abby pranks Matt about kissing another guy:
- "You did pull that prank. And I...I really believed that you'd kiss another dude." – Matt [82:29]
- Discussed the strangeness of twins in relationships and joked about their own friends' experiences.
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments (with Timestamps)
- On Marriage After Living Through Loss:
- "You're building a brand new marriage... that marriage is gone. And this, this is a new marriage we're building together again." – Abby [07:11]
- On Parenting Changing Identity:
- "I was looking in the mirror... I did not know my place anymore. I was so all consumed by motherhood." – Abby [13:06]
- On Cheating:
- "I would like to think that I would leave you if you cheated on me." – Abby [47:17]
- "I do believe in second chances and I really like you as a person. So I feel like...I would want to give you a second chance." – Matt [47:33]
- On Divorce As a Passing Thought:
- "I feel like couples that say they haven't are either in just the most magical whoopty doo marriage or they're liars." – Matt [53:07]
- On Being Different But Together:
- "Opposites attract 1000%. That's why we're married. We're different." – Matt [24:52]
- On Being Open About Phones:
- "Your phone is my phone." – Abby [38:28]
- On Kids Changing Everything:
- "Having a kid with someone is probably the biggest decision you can make in your life...I think you lose part of yourself." – Matt [12:20]
- On Grieving Differently In Marriage:
- "Grief is like a fingerprint. It's unique to everybody." – Abby [56:09]
- Joking About Opposite Sex Rooming Rules:
- "If you had a twin, that would be weird. That just would be. That just. Wouldn't that not be weird?" – Matt [80:24]
Segment Timestamps for Key Topics
- New Studio & Podcast Journey: [02:39–04:44]
- Agree to Disagree Game Setup: [04:44–05:11]
- Miscarriage and Marriage Change: [05:27–08:49]
- Marriage Timing/Young Marriage: [09:08–11:17]
- Parenting and Loss of Self: [11:31–14:58]
- Screen Time/Parent Breaks: [14:58–16:30]
- Marriage Compatibility & Goals: [19:32–20:24]
- Love vs. Money: [23:12–24:43]
- Household Roles and Cleaning: [25:10–27:26]
- Spouse vs. Extended Family: [27:26–28:31]
- Puppy & Trauma Buying: [28:32–29:58]
- Social Media Realness: [35:48–36:52]
- Passwords & Trust: [38:13–39:37]
- Opposite Sex Friendships/Boundaries: [39:51–44:50]
- White Lies/Compassionate Lying: [45:01–46:21]
- Cheating/Infidelity: [46:26–48:08]
- Considered Cheating or Divorce: [51:22–55:26]
- Grieving & Healing After Miscarriage: [56:26–59:42]
- Soulmates & Compatibility: [70:00–71:39]
- Flirting & Cheating: [76:30–77:58]
- Changed Over Time: [78:02–78:20]
- Life With One Person: [79:01–79:41]
- Kissing Others Before Marriage: [81:14–83:43]
Tone
Matt and Abby are casual, unguarded, and conversational, frequently oscillating between humor and gravity. They’re unafraid to challenge one another’s views but always return to mutual affection and respect, expressing their vulnerabilities without lapsing into melodrama.
Takeaways for New Listeners
This episode exemplifies the core of Matt and Abby’s draw: No topic is too sacred, too petty, or too “unhinged.” Their openness offers reassurance to anyone who’s ever questioned their own relationship’s ups and downs, and their mutual commitment, along with the willingness to evolve, underscores a deep foundation of trust and love.
Final Note:
If you’re navigating marriage, considering parenthood, or coping with loss, this episode offers a roadmap of hard conversations—brave, loving, imperfect, and above all, real.