Loading summary
Transcript98 lines
- [00:02]
David Pierce
Hello and welcome to the vergecast, the flagship podcast of ultra wideband door locks. I'm your friend David Pearce and today on the show we are answering your questions about the smart home. We get a lot of questions about the smart home. I would say that it is the single most popular thing on the Vergecast hotline 866 verge11 or send us an email@vergecasthevirge.com so every once in a while Jen Tuohy comes on the show and just answers as many of your questions as as we can. We also have the new Google home speaker in house. We've been testing this new smart home device from Google and we both have some thoughts about what this thing actually is. We're going to get to all of that in just a second, but first, here's everything else happening on the Verge today. This is 90 seconds on the Verge for Wednesday, June 24, 2026. OpenAI just revealed its first AI chip, which is for some reason called Jalapeno.
- [00:49]
I don't know.
- [00:50]
It's specifically an inference chip, which means it's not for training huge models, but for interacting with them. OpenAI has been working with Broadcom on chips, and if they're good, they're actually a huge deal. Nvidia became the world's most valuable company in large part by having the best AI chips around, and everyone else would love to control their own destiny a little more and stop needing Nvidia so badly. Plus, OpenAI desperately needs to figure out a way to make AI usage cheaper and more energy efficient. All of which it says Jalapeno will do. We'll see about all that when it launches later this year. Meanwhile, big day for price reveals. We finally know what Grand Theft Auto 6 will cost when it finally actually apparently for real, seriously launches this November. It's going to be 80 bucks for the standard version, which is unfortunately increasingly the price of high end games or 100 bucks for the ultimate version. Pre orders start tonight and you get some cool added gear and you might even get the game early if you pre order. But you know what you apparently can't get at all is a disc with the game on it. Imagine even the quote unquote physical version of GTA VI is just a box with a download code in it. Does that even count as a physical version? That's up to you. I say no, it absolutely does not. Meanwhile, the slate truck, the extremely minimalist pickup truck with no paint or speakers or power windows, finally has a price tag. It's going to start at 20 doll, $24,950. That makes it the cheapest pickup and the cheapest EV you'll find pretty much anywhere on the market right now. People have been really interested in this thing and I suspect the price tag is only going to be good news. And finally, it's Amazon Prime Day and we're tracking all the best deals everywhere. But here's my main recommendation. A lot of Apple gear is on sale right now and you should jump on those deals. Apple CEO Tim Cook said recently that prices are about to go up, so I would buy while the buying's good. You can read more about all of this@theverge.com that is 90 seconds on the verge for Wednesday, June 24th.
- [02:32]
Geico Ad Voice 1
When I scraped my car in that parking garage, I was worried that it could be a long process to take care of it. Like a landscaper's first day trimming a hedge maze.
- [02:40]
Geico Ad Voice 2
I have definitely already been here. Now, was it left right or right left? Well, maybe I'll cut a path out and find my way back later.
- [02:52]
Geico Ad Voice 1
But it wasn't like that. I filed a claim in under two minutes on the Geico app and they handled it from there. It was taken care of almost as quickly as it happened.
- [02:59]
Geico Ad Voice 3
It feels good to get help quick. It feels good to Geico.
- [03:03]
Fetch Pet Insurance Ad Voice
Support for this show comes from Fetch Pet Insurance. Do you have a pet? Every six seconds a pet owner in the US gets hit with a vet bill of over $1,000 and it's almost always an unwelcome surprise. That's where Fetch Pet Insurance comes in. Fetch is the most complete pet insurance get paid back up to 90% of vet bills. You can use any vet in the US and Canada. All vets are in network. Go to fetchpet.comsave right now for your free quote. That's fetchpet.comsave.
- [03:43]
David Pierce
Let's get to some of your smart home questions. Joining me now, Divergence gentouhey Hi Jen.
- [03:47]
T-Mobile Ad Voice 1
Hi David.
- [03:47]
David Pierce
You are. You are somewhere on a college campus being, being collegiate and having lots of school spirit is what I'm to understand.
- [03:54]
Jen Tuohy
Oh, the school spirit.
- [03:55]
Geico Ad Voice 4
Yes.
- [03:55]
Jen Tuohy
This is the south. Go to Tigers.
- [03:59]
David Pierce
It's not. It's June, so it's not football season. But it is always football season.
- [04:04]
Jen Tuohy
Always football season in the zap that is very much the case.
- [04:08]
David Pierce
Well, I appreciate you jumping on and doing this with us. We have a couple of smart homey questions to get to. But first I want to talk about something that we have been asked about a lot over the last nine Months. Because it has taken this thing nine months to ship to the world. Which is the Google home speaker. You have one waiting for you at home. I have one sitting right here next to me.
- [04:27]
Jen Tuohy
It's so red.
- [04:28]
David Pierce
It's very red. I will say my. My immediate response was like, when you fill out a form to get products like this from Google and they make you sort of list in order, what colors you want. And I was like, how do I say I only want the red, red, red. And under no circumstances should you send me anything else. I find this always completely fascinating in part because, like my. My sort of early returns on 24 hours of using it are that it's a pretty good speaker. It plays music. It sounds like a thousand times better than the Echo Mini. I have a Logitech Wonderboom, the little Bluetooth speaker that I use for everything all the time. And I think I like this better than that. Like, as a little thing for playing music. It's pretty. But I find myself wondering the same thing you and I have been asked many times, which is why on earth should I trust Google to be my smart home platform of the future? This is the first Google home speaker in six years. Google has seemed at various times to care deeply about doing the smart home and smart speakers, and then at times to completely forget that it does any of these things. So give me a sense. This thing is $99, it's red, it's cool, I like it. It seems almost sort of irresponsible to tell people to buy it because of Google's commitment to this thing. How should I feel about this?
- [05:40]
Jen Tuohy
So. So this is kind of the story for all the major platforms, honestly. And you know, we've had Aneesh Ketakaran on. On the Vergecast. We talked with him and he's the head of Google Home and he gave an impassioned defense of Google and the smart home because. And I. And I just spent a few days at a conference about around matter, where all of the engineers and people that make the smart home for these big platforms and they are all fully in on the smart home and matter. But the question is, are there bosses? Like, how much further is this going to go? And I do think this time around, and I'm going to get a lot of hate for this. I feel like Google really is putting in the effort here. I think the fact they spent nine months to ship this speaker after announcing it. And I asked this question, why nine months? Because we were making sure it really worked well with Google Home. Gemini for Home. They've spent an awful lot of time re architecting the foundation of Google Home. And this is one of the reasons why I think so many people have had struggled with Google Home in the past is it was basically the original smart speakers were like Chromecast software. It wasn't designed to be a smart home device. Apple's HomePod, Amazon's Echoes, those were designed in many ways for the smart home. Google's really weren't. And I think this speaker is the beginning of the hardware specifically designed for the smart home. So I'm excited to see where Google goes next. And I also, I don't dislike the restraint. I'm not a huge fan of how many echoes there are out there and the sort of the need feel like do I need to upgrade to get a better experience, you know. But Google Home's current devices are very long in the tooth and in fact have now officially been discontinued. So at least the Nest mini has no longer available. They're definitely shifting away from the Nest name. So you know, I think it's, I think this is their last chance. Get it right now, Google. But from what I've seen and talking to people in the industry and Google, people at Google, there is a lot of momentum for them behind this because it's a place for Gemini and the whole company is Gemini. Now
- [08:11]
David Pierce
you can argue this is an AI device as much as it is a smart home device. And in that sense I have a lot of faith in Google's ability to care deeply about this thing for a very long time. Yeah, that end actually. Well, one thing on the hardware before, I want to talk about Gemini for home for just a minute because I don't fully understand what it is, but. And I'm hoping you can explain it to me. But on the hardware front, I have realized in testing this thing that everybody has experimented with lots of different kinds of hardware. Right. There was a time where people were doing sort of big, high end, like professional level smart speakers. We've seen the big tall ones, we've seen lots of different shapes and sizes of all of these things. It does feel like this. And I'm holding up the Echo Mini and the Google Home speaker is the correct answer. Like as, as a. I think what we've discovered is most people don't want these to be like gigantic home theater systems. They just want them to be relatively small, sound relatively good, and like sit on a table in your living room somewhere. Like if you're gonna pick an answer, this feels like the right answer. Do you agree with that.
- [09:12]
Jen Tuohy
That's the Echo Dot just to cover it. You're right, sorry.
- [09:14]
David Pierce
It's the Echo dot.
- [09:15]
Jen Tuohy
The Nest Mini was the little Nest. Yeah, yeah, the Echo. I do, I think, I think if you're a high end, if you want high end audio, you're not buying smart home speakers. You know, you're going with the Sonos or the Denon or something even more expensive. But the way that these smart speakers work, and this is one of the things that the new Google home speaker does is you know, you can pair them with your Google Home Streamer or your Fire tv. So there is an element of added sound benefit that you're getting from these speakers. But generally, yeah, you're just using them primarily for that voice interface like setting the timers, asking for the weather or whatever Gemini or Alexa can do for you. So. And I think one of the arguments that Google said why they created this shape was because people didn't like how big the Nest audio was. It was hard to fit in spaces. And I actually had that issue too with the Nest audio. So I can see that argument. And I also think the smaller ones, the really small ones like the Echo Dot before this and the NES Minis were too small, too tinny, didn't have a have people have gotten used to decent sound now we've found that spot and I don't think we're going to move from it for a while.
- [10:29]
David Pierce
Yeah, I tend to agree and I think in terms of like can we get the sound to good enough? The home speaker I think easily clears that bar, which I find actually pretty exciting. Like as a sort of simple. Like right now I have a Sonos speaker in our playroom that we just like use to play toddler music all day. I would absolutely swap this thing into that spot and be very happy with the sound quality, which I think is kind of all it needs to be.
- [10:51]
Jen Tuohy
Yeah. And I've heard it's not as good technically a speaker as the audio, the Nest audio. But I think you're right, the difference is probably negligible for the type of device this is and what you're likely to use it for.
- [11:05]
David Pierce
Yeah, totally. Real quick on Gemini for home. I think Google has made a lot of noise about this big AI upgrade for smart home stuff. The replacing Google Assistant with Gemini. Everything is LLM powered. We've also watched Amazon do this same thing. I would say to not always great effect. Like, yes, it's great that you can talk more naturally to these things. Yes, it's good that you can have sort of longer, more complicated conversations. On the other hand, it actually seems in many cases running these things through this more complicated AI technology makes it harder to just say, turn on the lights and assume that the lights will turn on. You and I both have a lot of Gemini for home testing to do.
- [11:45]
Jen Tuohy
Yeah.
- [11:46]
David Pierce
But I'm curious what you've seen sort of in this space in general with Alexa and Gemini for home and all of this stuff. Like, are we. Is the AI smart home control actually getting to the point where it can work?
- [11:59]
Jen Tuohy
I'm. No, not yet.
- [12:01]
David Pierce
That's what I was afraid.
- [12:03]
Jen Tuohy
So this has been my biggest sort of frustration with the new LLM powered smart home assistants or smart assistants, because I feel like to our point earlier, that this is Alexa and Gemini is what the broader companies want and they're focused on the larger use cases, the more personalized assistant use cases. You know, being the new Siri, being part of your whole life, not just your home. And in my experience, that feels that the home side has been slightly. It's less priority for the home side, more priority for ordering an Uber or buying, getting me a handyman or telling me, you know, giving me a whole exposition on the state of the World cup, you know, like giving that experience, which is there's valuable experiences in there, but the core basic I'm just going to be able to use my smart home better is still wonky. I can see that it's getting a little better. I mean, some of the best experiences I've had have been able to set up routines with voice, which you can do with Alexa, and being able to do multiple commands to control your devices, which you can do with both home assistants. But yeah, right now I feel like the focus for most of these companies is making the Gemini or the Alexa better. The larger picture, they're not smart home specialists anymore, which is what Google Assistant and the original Alexa really were. I don't think that means they never will be. I just feel like that part has been a slower boil. Some things I'm excited about with Google Home is that they have added a lot more local control to the devices. It's still just specific model, specific device types. So lights and plugs that shift towards local, which is also powered by the matter support both platforms offer, that's going to present a much better smart home experience for your basic use cases. The big picture for both of these platforms is also the AI with the camera and the home security. And this is also something I think we'll see coming more to Apple when they Launch, if they launch their new Siri in the home is being able to query your speaker and sort of say, when did you see the UPS guy? Those types of experiences I think are going to be the primary focus for the smart home. More so than just making sure your lights turn on fast.
- [14:26]
David Pierce
Yeah. It's an interesting, it's an interesting piece of it because I think you're right that we are getting more complicated, more interesting possibilities out of the LLM powered stuff.
- [14:36]
Jen Tuohy
Yeah.
- [14:37]
David Pierce
While running the risk of losing all of the stuff that you actually need to do all day every day. Yeah, it's going to be interesting. And I think the idea of these things being primarily AI speakers with a sort of side of smart home is probably right. And it's. I don't know if that's what I would like these things to be, but it does feel like if you, if you sort of look at it as every company ships its org chart, like there's more AI in here than there is smart home. Very much for better and for worse.
- [15:04]
Jen Tuohy
Yeah, yeah. And it's nice that Google are bringing along their smart home. I mean I could have, I felt like, you know, given their history, we could have totally expected to see them just be like, okay, we're going to just cut the, cut that off at the legs and start fresh. But they've put a lot of effort into bringing old devices or bringing the whole ecosystem of how you used Google Assistant before into Gemini for home. It's been a bumpy ride though. I think it means that people that are using for Gemini for Home today who have previously used Google Assistant are still finding things that they can't do. But talking to the Google home folks, they are constantly trying to add these new, these old features back into the new system and hopefully they will work better once they're here.
- [15:52]
David Pierce
So here's hoping and I just want you to know, and I want everyone to know who's at home listening and watching that I haven't rolled my eyes any of the times Jen has said matter so far. I just want everyone to know that
- [16:03]
Decagon AI Ad Voice
support for the show comes from decagon. If your team is dealing with more support, tickets, more channels and higher expectations from customers, you've probably thought about using AI for customer support and you've probably seen how limited or time consuming most options are. That's where Decagon comes in. Decagon helps companies create personalized concierge style customer experiences with AI agents across chat, email, voice and SMS. They're available 24, 7 feel natural to talk to and can resolve customer requests on their own so businesses can keep up with requests without losing their personal touch. Decagon plugs directly into your existing systems so agents get live quickly ready to transform your customer support. Go to Decagon AI Verge to get a personalized demo and see what Decagon can do for your team. Check decagon out at Decagon AI Verge. That's Decagon AI Verge.
- [17:10]
Geico Ad Voice 1
When I scraped my car in that parking garage, I was worried that it could be a long process to take care of it. Like a landscaper's first day trimming a hedge maze.
- [17:18]
Geico Ad Voice 2
I have definitely already been here. Now, was it left right or right left? Well, maybe I'll cut a path out and find my way back later, but
- [17:30]
Geico Ad Voice 1
it wasn't like that. I filed a claim in under two minutes on the Geico app and they handled it for me there. It was taken care of almost as quickly as it happened.
- [17:37]
Geico Ad Voice 3
It feels good to get help quick. It feels good to Geico.
- [17:40]
T-Mobile Ad Voice 1
Whoa.
- [17:41]
T-Mobile Ad Voice 2
Okay, this one says you get a free phone if you switch. Hey, this one also says you get a free phone if you switch.
- [17:47]
Jen Tuohy
Yeah, they all do one.
- [17:50]
T-Mobile Ad Voice 2
Huh? The T Mobile one says their customers had the lowest wireless bills versus the other big guys over the past five years and their latest experience plans have Netflix included. Plus year of dash pass by door dash.
- [18:02]
Jen Tuohy
Hang on, let me see that. Oh yeah, we're switching.
- [18:05]
T-Mobile Ad Voice 2
That's what I'm talking about. Do we clap now or AT T
- [18:09]
Geico Ad Voice 3
Mobile get savings that keep stacking up. That's value you can feel every day. And right now bring your phone to T Mobile and we'll give you $400 when you switch.
- [18:20]
T-Mobile Ad Voice 3
Savings based on Harris X billing snapshots from Q3 2021 to Q4 2025 compared to average AT and T and Verizon. Comparison includes discounts, credits and optional charges. $400 with new account on qualifying line unlock device credit ported 90 plus days with device and carrier and timely redemption required. Virtual MasterCard typically takes 14 weeks, no cash access, and expires in 6 months. Card issued by Sunrise Banks and a member FDIC.
- [18:38]
T-Mobile Ad Voice 1
Visit t mobile.com Feel like you're being told to wave a magic AI wand and everything will just get better? Sure, AI can chat and summarize, but what about big business problems like rerouting stock through a canal that won't unblock? Enterprise AI needs context for that, so Celonis provides it. The Celonis context model gives AI operational clarity so agents know how your unique business Runs and how to improve it. Meet the model at C-E-L-O-N-I S.com context.
- [19:17]
David Pierce
Well, we have lots more Google home speaker stuff to do. Uh, you have some testing to do. I have some testing to do. We, we may come back to this thing at some point in the near future because it's, it's red and it's cool looking and I like it. But for now, let's get to some of our other questions. All right, Jen, I have two questions for you. Uh, the first one is from Patrick. Uh, and it is a question that has made me feel a surprising amount of feelings. Uh, so Patrick says, I own an ecobee smart thermostat and I've owned it for a while now. At the time, I think it was one of the few HomeKit enabled brands, or at least it was highly recommended for someone in the Apple ecosystem. I think it's one of those gadgets that are reliable, so we don't get new ones every year. But also, this thing hasn't changed at all since I bought it years ago. No new features or innovation, not even AI. Nobody has tried selling me an AI enabled smart thermostat yet. Not complaining, just surprise. Even my dishwasher's default cycle is AI Wash. Do you see why this made me feel feelings?
- [20:11]
Tech Security Ad Voice
Jen, this is.
- [20:12]
David Pierce
But I am so with Patrick on this emotional rollercoaster. Yeah, but I guess there are sort of two parts of this that I'm curious for your thoughts. One is, are we due for the aiification of every single product that A, these companies want to sell you and B, they want to update that are already in your house?
- [20:31]
Jen Tuohy
Well, yes. Again, this conference, I was just at Unify, which was the conference from Connectivity Standards alliance, the founder, the people behind Matter, the originator of the term Internet of Things, was talking and he was railing against smart appliances. He's like, we do not need smart appliances. We do not need a smart fridge. We do not need a smart dishwasher. He was saying we need to put AI into creating much more valuable experiences because he doesn't see any value in the current experiences. But when it comes to thermostats, I think the specific argument here is actually these were already using a form of AI.
- [21:16]
David Pierce
True. All the way back to the Nest. It is like fundamentally AI technology.
- [21:20]
Jen Tuohy
Exactly. It was one of the earliest machine learning devices we put in our homes. And the ecobee also not quite as learning as the Nest, but it used machine learning to kind of optimize your comfort and energy savings. Was kind of their line because it was observing your behavior, detecting patterns. It was using something that your bog standard thermostat did not. And I think that's probably why you feel like you haven't seen people touting AI as a feature here. Because the core use case of the type of intelligence we're talking about for bringing into the home is to sort of manage it automatically for you without you having to input. And that's really what the sort of selling point of these thermostats has been. For the decade that they've been around, they were ahead of the game, to be fair. They have had a lot of under the hood kind of upgrades and improvements, but the newer models have added a lot more whiz bang features. And that's what I think we're starting to see in the smart home is bringing in more use cases for your devices and also connecting into the rest of your home. The AI powered element I think we'll start to see more of. Like we mentioned with the speakers, there's this sort of push from the platforms to, you know, integrate their Gemini and their Alexa into these devices more so that you can do more with them in your home or ultimately have your home do more for you without you having to do any input. Because that was one of the arguments against these devices, the Nest and the ecobee early on is they would just go off and do their own thing and you're like, no, I don't want to be that cold.
- [23:00]
David Pierce
For better and for worse.
- [23:02]
Jen Tuohy
Yeah, yeah. So I think it's an interesting space to watch. I mean, there's a lot of new smart thermostats that have come out recently that have. One interesting area is Apple's new adaptive temperature feature, which basically takes what both the Nest and the ecobee made their name on that automatically adapting to your habits and use and makes it available to any thermostat that works with Apple home. So we're sort of seeing, so you have to adopt their API, their adaptive temperature system, but they can do everything like switch modes, detect occupancy, determine when you're coming and going, which is what these other thermostats all did. So we're sort of seeing a democratization, I suppose, of these smart features. Because both the Nest and the ecobee are expensive. You can now buy a smart thermostat for, you know, $150 and I think we'll start to see only a couple work with Apple right now, the adaptive features. But I think we'll start to see More of those, especially with. Because it's all through matter. So we're starting to see again it to get less expensive to get these smarter feature. And I like his point that we don't upgrade our thermostats very often. But.
- [24:18]
David Pierce
So this is the other thing I was going to ask you about which is I think what is, what is a reasonable set of expectations to have for something like a smart thermostat that I, I plug into my wall and ideally I would like to have it there until I die. Right. Like, I don't know. No one has ever been excited about upgrading their thermostat. It's a thing you do when you have to do it.
- [24:39]
Jen Tuohy
Yeah.
- [24:39]
David Pierce
And so I think I get it. You do. This is why, this is why you're here, Jen. This is why we love you. But I think on the one hand, one of the cool things about having these things be more technologically advanced is that they can get new features. On the other hand, what if I hate those features?
- [24:55]
Jen Tuohy
Yeah.
- [24:56]
David Pierce
And I think especially now people are reckoning with this with AI in a very real way of like actually, I don't want you to stick your weird AI nonsense into my thermostat.
- [25:04]
Jen Tuohy
Yeah.
- [25:05]
David Pierce
But I'm sort of captive because literally the thing is in my wall.
- [25:08]
Jen Tuohy
Yeah.
- [25:09]
David Pierce
How do you think through that trade off right now?
- [25:13]
Jen Tuohy
So this is a sort of concern people have had about appliances in general, not just around smart. Just as they get more technologically advanced, they last less time. Like people talk about their grandmother's washing machine, that goes for 20 years. Whereas now most of them, you're lucky if you get your washing machine to last like a decade. And that's the trade off though is that these washing machines can do so much more than your grandma's in theory, depending on what you're looking for from your washing machine.
- [25:42]
David Pierce
But you know, mostly just clothes washing.
- [25:44]
Jen Tuohy
Ideally use less water, use less energy. Being able to schedule them, being able to program. I can program a dog bed mode into my washing machine. You know, there are, there are benefits. So that's the trade off, I think for a device like a thermostat. The only real reason to, I mean Nest has told us with theirs 10 years is basically what you can expect. Right. Because they end of life. Their original NEST thermostat, I think it was almost 13 years, although you can still use it. And this is a key part for any. We've talked about this before, but it's worth repeating. Any smart appliance you buy in your home, you Want to make sure that the basic functions will continue even once you have disconnected it from the Internet, because you need to disconnect it from the Internet once it gets to the point where it's not getting software updates so it doesn't become part of a giant DDoS attack. So you definitely. But as long as those devices can still work the way they were intended to as a basic function, which the nests can. Even though Nest is now discontinued. Sport, there is, you know, that's the trade off. Look for that and then local control. To your main point about the AI, if you don't want some of these features that either your thermostat company or your smart home platform is pushing on you, or eventually maybe your energy platform, if you don't want those features, you need to look for a device that's going to. You're going to still be able to control locally. And this is where matter comes in, because it will allow. Once a platform takes away support, the device should still be able to work on your local network. So it's hard to know for sure though, until we actually see this happen. This is all somewhat theoretical, but yeah, that's what I would definitely advise. A device that can work locally can also run locally if you still want some of the smart features. And then you can kind of take or leave, hopefully, if people are pushing AI features at you.
- [27:37]
David Pierce
Yeah, that makes sense. All right, last question, which I'm including partly because it's a good question and partly because this is just a thing you and I can't stop talking about. Here, let me just play this question for you.
- [27:48]
Hello, this is Rhys again. I'm at the 1 hour 20 minute mark of the Vergecast on Friday, June 19th and I found myself yelling at the screen because the sleeping giant in smart home is ikea. They have the most to gain from matter and they need to be the one Dragons want because they sell the cheap stuff that everyone's buying. But their smart home ecosystem in terms of their hub is awful and so they need all of their stuff to work properly with Google X etc and aren't gonna put the engineering resources into making that happen the way Hugh has. He was early enough where everything had to support it to be considered a smart home. But IKEA is coming in and is easily the giant in the smart home space as looming over it. And I think that they have the most to gain from matter.
- [28:46]
All right, Rhys gets it. Jen.
- [28:49]
Jen Tuohy
I was there with you, Rhys. I was shouting at them at the same time. Maybe not about IKEA specifically But yes. So again, just spent a whole week talking to companies about the value of matter in the smart home. And I agree with you, companies like Ikea are the ones that are going to benefit from matter because its core promise is basic interoperability for both the manufacturer and the user. So a company like Ikea that makes furniture doesn't have to worry about developing separate routes to work with Apple and work with Alexa and spending the resource engineering resources on that. They can just use one platform or one standard matter and it should work, should work with everyone. And I think that's really the value proposition of matter for manufacturers in general. One thing I've been surprised about though is we haven't seen more companies taking up this opportunity because right now most matter products come from the companies that were already in the space. And the point about Philips Hue that you made, David, is that they already worked with all these platforms. So what's the benefit now of switching to matter for them? And I actually spoke with the CTO of Hue at this event and for them the real benefit here is that they can now build more experiences on top of that connectivity layer and not have to spend all their time troubleshooting whack a mole with five different platforms. So it kind of helps them stay relevant in the ecosystem in the smart home space as these mid tier value brands like Ikea and I cara start coming in and potentially eating their lunch. Which is what we're starting to see, and this is where matter is great for the user, is that we're seeing less expensive products come into the market because these companies haven't had to invest a ridiculous amount of time and money working with everyone. What I'd like to see is more non smart home companies, more IKEAs coming in and making interesting products that work in our smart homes that they don't have to sort of deal with just the connectivity. They can come up with really good and useful features for us in our homes. We're starting to see it from some of the lock manufacturers like Schlage and quickset. You know, they're adopting this, the UWB unlocking, which is really interesting and that would have not been possible before open standards. And this is the hands free, walking in, having your door open with just using your phone in your pocket. Smart appliance makers, we talked about washing machines, fridges, again they need to come up with the value add like okay, we're going to connect this device, but it's not just about the fact that it's connected, it's about what it can do for you. And that's what I'm hoping to see more of. And I've been disappointed we haven't seen more of that to date. And I think that's largely to do with the rollout of matter. You know, it's taken a while. There've been some bumps in the road, and I think I'm really keeping a close eye on whether we're going to really see outside of the smart home adoption, because that's when it reaches that kind of critical mass and hopefully becomes a more of a mainstream solution for people, because today it's still niche. And the people that are really benefiting from matter today are actually the semiconductors makers, like nxp, Nordic, SI Labs.
- [32:30]
David Pierce
Well, there's the matter story we were looking for, Jen. We helped the semiconductor companies.
- [32:36]
Jen Tuohy
They're the ones that are really benefiting at this stage because everyone's, you know, there's Tri Radio chips, everyone's got their Thread and their WI Fi and their Bluetooth. But in many ways that's good for the consumer. But just not for a while, because once these device, once these new chips are in these devices, you'll be able to use any platform you like. That's, like, ultimately going to be. I know. It's the long game, though.
- [33:00]
David Pierce
It's great for the consumer, but not for a while is the whole story of matter. It's like, someday it's gonna be so dope matter. Like, it's great. I agree with all of that. And I also think that if IKEA can be the one to prove the theory in a real way, it's why you and I spent a whole episode talking about the buttons, right? Like, just the idea of IKEA being like, hey, this thing costs $4 and it works is so powerful that it was so frustrating to see it kind of fall on its face in the way that it has. But to Ikea's credit, I think that stuff has gotten meaningful even since then and will continue to do so. So I'm. I'm actually very optimistic about Ikea's ability to, like, do the thing Rhys is describing and kind of drag everybody along.
- [33:47]
Jen Tuohy
And they are. And in fact, I did talk to someone from one of the major ecosystems at this panel conference who was in charge of bringing everyone together to fix the IKEA problems. So they had like a emergency summit for like a week with all the major platforms.
- [34:04]
David Pierce
Oh, wow.
- [34:05]
Jen Tuohy
And we're like, we're going to fix this now. That's, like, unprecedented, you know, and that
- [34:11]
David Pierce
for a $4 button for a $4 button.
- [34:13]
Jen Tuohy
That gives me a lot of hope for the standard because my biggest concern when it first launched was, you know, okay, we've got Samsung, Apple, Google, Amazon. Yeah, we're all working together. Kumbaya. This is going to be great. But you know, two, three years down the line, are they all going to be like fighting at dawn with each other to like, no, get off my turf. This is my walled garden. And honestly I don't think that's happened. I think the platform been somewhat slow to adopt support, that's been a frustration. But it does seem like they are still all working together because success for matter should equal success for them. It's still a little up in the air. Their partners are people like Ikea and they want those partners to be successful so that they will continue to support their smart home ambitions. So it's, it's a bit of a sort of flywheel. But I feel like that concern I had early on that the sort of the alliance would crumble after a few years, so far I haven't seen the sign of that. In fact, I've seen the opposite. They really all do seem to be working together. So that is good for the consumer.
- [35:28]
David Pierce
That is good. Just not for a while.
- [35:30]
Jen Tuohy
I'll take it.
- [35:32]
Tech Security Ad Voice
All right, Jen.
- [35:33]
Jen Tuohy
It's hard. That's what I've been told. This is all very hard, for sure.
- [35:36]
David Pierce
And they continue, they continue to want the right things. So I am continually encouraged by the direction of this, if not the speed of it.
- [35:44]
Jen Tuohy
And AI I think is actually helping in that respect, even though it's not helping necessarily on a daily basis for us. But it's keeping these platforms interested in the smart home space where prior, as we had seen it seemed like they were losing interest. But now they've got a real use case value prop for and I wrote about this on the Verge. So there's a real value proposition for these companies to get AI into your home through the smart home. So whether you welcome it in or not though, that's up to you.
- [36:15]
David Pierce
Very, very true. All right, Jen, thanks for being here. Good to see you.
- [36:18]
Jen Tuohy
Good to see you.
- [36:19]
David Pierce
All right, that's it for the show. Thanks to Jen for being here and thank you as always for watching and listening and sending us questions and keep sending us more questions. Jen has just all kinds of smart home thoughts and, and likes coming on the show to yell at me about how great matter is. So please keep giving her reasons to do so. Call the hotline 866-Verge 11 Send us an email at vergecast of the verge.com we absolutely love hearing from you and as always, the best thing you can do to support everything that we're up to here is go to theverge.com subscribe and subscribe to the Verge. That's how you get all of our podcasts ad free, including this one. That's how you get all of our exclusive newsletters, all of our coverage of the weird things that matter is and isn't doing, and everything else@theverge.com subscribe. Thank you in advance. The Vergecast is a Verge production and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. The show is produced by Josh Kahas, Eric Gomez, Brandon Kiefer, Travis Larchuk, and Aaron Locasio. We'll see you tomorrow. Rock and roll.
- [37:12]
Geico Ad Voice 4
When I got a new car, I
- [37:13]
T-Mobile Ad Voice 1
thought my insurance premium would increase and empty my bank account like if Fatween won the lottery.
- [37:19]
Geico Ad Voice 4
I've invested most of my winnings in chicken tenders because they're bomb but bro, I bought a house and it's sick bro. I'm thinking the floor is going to be all trampoline, bro with a helipad on the roof. The contractor said it's structurally unsound. They're just being babies.
- [37:33]
T-Mobile Ad Voice 1
But switching to GEICO saved me hundreds. So my bank account is safe.
- [37:37]
Geico Ad Voice 3
It feels good to save some hard earned cash. It feels good to geico.
- [37:43]
Tech Security Ad Voice
Here's a finding that should stop every tech leader cold. Organizations most confident in their AI deployments have more than 20 twice the security incident rate of those that aren't 72% versus 33%. That's from Teleport's 2026 Infrastructure Identity Survey of more than 200 infrastructure security leaders. Teleport establishes a unified identity layer for humans, machines and agents that is cryptographically backed. That enables agents to be controlled and contained with the same rigor that you apply to other actors in your infrastructure. Because in the new era of AI, the problem isn't agents, it's the privileges we're giving them. Download the free report@goteleport.com Vox.