E1114 - Temptation Island S2 Reunion: Part One | Exclusively on The Viall Files

Summary

The Viall Files – E1114

Temptation Island S2 Reunion: Part One

Release Date: April 22, 2026
Host: Nick Viall, with Natalie Joy and the Household
Summary Focus: The cast of Temptation Island Season 2 reunites to unpack what happened on the island, discuss their motivations, personal growth, and relationship outcomes since leaving the show.

---

Episode Overview

This episode marks the first part of the Temptation Island Season 2 reunion, where Nick Viall, Natalie Joy, and the Household welcome all the main couples and key singles from the season. The group candidly discusses their reasons for joining the show, how the experience challenged them, and how their relationships have evolved (or ended) since filming wrapped. Throughout, the conversation moves between heart, humor, painful confession, and honest introspection, with Nick prompting for deeper insight and concrete lessons learned.

---

Main Discussion Points & Insights

1. Why Did They Go on Temptation Island?

[04:02–19:25]

Each couple details their unique path to the show:

• Jack & Cheyenne
  • Jack was the driving force, convinced if their relationship could survive the show, they could survive anything.
  • Cheyenne was initially against it: "Not fucking happening. That is not happening." (04:50, Cheyenne).
  • They nearly didn’t participate, joining as alternates only after much persuasion and reluctance.
• Sydney & Mikey
  • Sydney initiated joining, hoping to see if Mikey had truly grown up after college.
  • Mikey initially refused: "Fuck no." (10:30, Mikey), but relented out of loyalty: "If she told me to jump off a bridge, I'd ask how high." (11:08, Mikey).
• Summit & Kaylee
  • Kaylee was approached to join as a single while broken up, then brought Summit in when reunited.
  • Summit wanted to conquer commitment issues; felt going on the show was a make-or-break moment.
  • Kaylee didn't really want to go: "I honestly didn’t want to go on the show at all. And he told me, if we don’t go on the show, I’ll think about it for the rest of my life." (16:39, Kaylee).
• Cole & Scarlett
  • Scarlett was contacted via Instagram and initially said no, fearing for their already-rocky relationship.
  • Cole encouraged trying the casting process—eventually they both agreed, hoping that "not cheating" would resolve their trust issues.

Nick’s Reflection: Many couples thought making it through Temptation Island would mean their relationship was "unbreakable"—a theme that will unravel as the reunion continues.

---

2. Relationship Status Update

[20:08–20:52]

• Kaylee & Summit: Still together, planning to move in and get the promised wiener dog.
• Scarlett & Cole: Back together after splitting on the island.
• Jack & Cheyenne: Still broken up (mutually).
• Sydney & Mikey: Not together; Sydney “focusing on myself.”
• Sydney & Xavier: Not a couple, but Sydney hints at reopening communication.

---

3. Kaylee & Summit’s Growth and Challenges

[27:00–45:05]

• Body comments & communication:
  • On the show, Summit made remarks about Kaylee’s body that were highlighted. Kaylee clarifies: "He has said things in the past that hurt me... As a woman, it hurts to feel like you're not enough." (29:31, Kaylee).
  • Summit expresses deep regret and describes how the experience—and advice from the single women—made him more sensitive and careful.
  • Key lesson: “You can’t speak to women like you would a guy.” (30:39, Summit).
• Support from singles: The singles on both sides offered essential, non-romantic support that helped both Kaylee and Summit grow.
• Relationship security: Both say they are more secure and independent now: “Everything I ever wanted to be is where we’re at, and it’s amazing.” (43:01, Kaylee).
• On emotional connection and public perception:
  • Kaylee regretted talking about Summit as a “sociopath” and now recognizes how much negative comments can hurt.
  • Summit: “I talked more about my feelings in that month in Temptation Island than I probably have my entire life.” (42:45, Summit).
• Key takeaway: The experience was “game changing”—they don’t think they’d be together otherwise.

---

4. Sydney & Mikey: Love, Loss, and Emotional Maturity

[50:27–82:22]

• Relationship aftermath:
  • Got back together four days after filming but broke up after three months.
  • Sydney left because Mikey couldn’t move past the show and would throw it in her face during arguments.
  • Sydney: "There was so much more that I wanted from our relationship... I want you to show me that you love me... I gave him the blueprint." (55:30, Sydney).
  • Mikey takes accountability: "I took her for granted 1000%. That's her truth. I respect everything that she says." (56:27, Mikey).
• On appreciating love:
  • Mikey admits losing Sydney forced him into therapy and self-reflection: "I wish I had that opportunity again to go on the island as the version of myself that I am right now." (57:52, Mikey).
  • Sydney confirms: "We're better as friends, and I think we support each other better as friends." (60:17, Sydney).
• Best friends, not lovers:
  • Mikey and Sydney express deep love for each other but agree not to reignite the romance.
  • Mikey’s emotional journey: "She's my best friend... the first woman I've ever experienced love with in my entire life. The only other person that I've ever truly loved is my mother." (59:11, Mikey).
• Sydney and Xavier:
  • Sydney reconnected with Xavier after filming, appreciated his understanding—he never threw her choices in her face. “That’s something that I really appreciate about him.” (81:47, Sydney).
  • A heartfelt video message from Xavier is played for Sydney at the end (82:22).

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Cheyenne on agreeing to do the show:
  • "That is not happening. I was like, I'm not going on the meeting. Like, I think this is a terrible idea.” (04:50, Cheyenne)
• Mikey’s support for Sydney, at his own expense:
  • “If she told me to jump off of a bridge, I'd ask how high.” (11:08, Mikey)
• Summit’s reflection on commitment:
  • “I think I had this thing in my head where I was like, if you commit to a relationship, it means you have to, like, get married and get the dog the next day.” (15:51, Summit)
• Kaylee’s realization post-show:
  • “We like, do everything together, but we're not, like, so codependent. Like, we also have our own things, and we're independent in our own ways.” (43:01, Kaylee)
• Mikey on taking accountability:
  • “I did not treat you the way that you deserve to be treated. And for that, I apologize, guys, 1,000%.” (64:02, Mikey)
• On losing someone due to lack of appreciation:
  • “I truly do wish that I appreciated Sydney more. But it's always me learning too late, so it's always me learning too late.” (71:41, Mikey)

---

Key Timestamps by Topic

• Introductions and appearance updates: 01:20–03:33
• Couples’ origin stories / why they went on the show: 04:02–19:25
• Relationship status check: 20:08–20:52
• Kaylee and Summit deep dive: 27:00–45:05
• Sydney and Mikey relationship fallout & lessons: 50:27–82:22

---

Episode Tone

The conversation is candid, emotional, and at times playful, but always deeply reflective. The group is honest about heartbreak, healing, and regret, with Nick and Natalie encouraging vulnerability and accountability.

---

For Listeners Who Haven’t Tuned In

This episode is a must for anyone invested in Temptation Island S2’s couples. It delivers rare post-show honesty about trust, personal growth, the pain of public breakups, and the subtle ways emotional connections shape relationships, all in the unfiltered, intimate environment that The Viall Files is known for.

---

What’s Next

The episode ends on a cliffhanger for Part Two, previewing coming confrontations and deeper dives into the remaining couples—including Jack and Cheyenne’s final fallout and Scarlett and Cole’s reconciliation.

---

“She deserves everything... I'm not saying that I'm a piece of shit. Trust. I'm that guy. But... I understand that I messed up, and you don't deserve that.”
— Mikey (79:42)

“Everything I ever wanted to be is where we’re at, and it’s amazing.”
— Kaylee (43:01)

Transcript

[Host 1]

The BHAUS is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever find yourself playing a budgeting game? Well, with the name your price tool from Progressive you can find options that fit your budget and potentially lower your bills. Try that progressive.com, progressive casualty insurance company and affiliates. Prices and coverage match limited by state law. Not available in all states.

[T-Mobile Representative]

Everyone deserves to be connected. T Mobile and US Cellular are joining forces. Our networks are coming together bringing more T Mobile coverage all over the country. Switch to T Mobile and save up to 20% versus Verizon by getting built in benefits they leave out. Check the [e-mail] switch and now T Mobile is available in a US cellular store near you Bigger network. The combination of T mobiles and US Cellular's network footprints will enhance the T mobile network's coverage savings versus comparable Verizon plans plus the costs of options, benefits plan features and taxes and fees vary. Savings with three plus lines include third free line free via monthly bill credits credit stop if you cancel any lines. Qualifying credit required.

[Sydney]

You're crazy.

[Host 1]

If you are list to this reunion on audio. Be sure to check out the extended video version exclusively on the vile files on YouTube where you can look at all the crazy reactions and intimate moments from the cast of Temptation Island. You'll be glad that you did, so

[Nick (Host)]

be sure to check it out.

[Host 1]

Hello, everyone.

[Nick (Host)]

Welcome to the temptation Island Season 2 reunion.

[Host 1]

We are your hosts.

[Nick (Host)]

I'm Nick.

[Natalie (Host)]

And I am Natalie. We are so excited to welcome the cast of Temptation island season two.

[Nick (Host)]

This season there are a lot of tears, a lot of messy behavior and

[Host 1]

a lot of heartbreak. With temptation at an all time high,

[Nick (Host)]

only one couple survived the island leaving

[Natalie (Host)]

together, others left alone while a new couple emerged. Today is all about what's happened since everyone left the island during this reunion.

[Nick (Host)]

We want to unpack it all. Where everyone is at, where they've been and above all else, what they've learned from their experience.

[Natalie (Host)]

Cheyenne, you look gorgeous.

[Cheyenne]

Thank you.

[Natalie (Host)]

You're welcome.

[Kaylee]

So do you.

[Natalie (Host)]

You look great.

[Sydney]

Thank you.

[Natalie (Host)]

Thank you.

[Nick (Host)]

Jack, you're blonde now.

[Jack]

Blonde.

[Nick (Host)]

What was the motivation behind that?

[Jack]

I did it like three years ago.

[Nick (Host)]

Okay.

[Jack]

And I was like, you know what, I want to change that show. Just put me through a lot. Blonde Jack is like more chill.

[Nick (Host)]

Okay.

[Natalie (Host)]

Who do you trust more? Blonde Jack?

[Host 1]

Me.

[Natalie (Host)]

The Internet.

[Sydney]

Me.

[Kaylee]

The. Okay, wait, I thought his hair was blonde.

[Natalie (Host)]

Summit. How is your mom?

[Summit]

She's good. Yeah, everything's good. You know, it's been exciting watching the show with my friends and family and a lot of like Support overall.

[Nick (Host)]

Did you two coordinate the mustache or what's going on?

[Summit]

No.

[Cole]

Well, he's wearing my pants. Those are my pants.

[Summit]

He copied my mustache.

[Nick (Host)]

Kaylee, do you approve of the mustache?

[Kaylee]

I do. I love the mustache and the mini mullet.

[Summit]

She kind of doing it for me. Yeah. Was the one who, like, pushed the mustache.

[Mikey]

And now.

[Summit]

Now I'm liking it, so.

[Nick (Host)]

Okay.

[Natalie (Host)]

Sydney, have you been serenaded by any guitars recently?

[Sydney]

Not lately, but definitely, you know, on the island for sure.

[Natalie (Host)]

Okay, we'll circle back.

[Sydney]

We will circle back to that.

[Mikey]

We will.

[Nick (Host)]

Mikey, you look great these days. I appreciate that. What's new about you?

[Mikey]

It's been a good life, truthfully. Just been focused on the betterment of myself. Okay. Putting Mikey first.

[Nick (Host)]

Cole, are you reading anything? Currently reading?

[Cole]

Yeah, like a book or a journal

[Natalie (Host)]

or a journal or diary or Dive right in.

[Mikey]

That was good.

[Host 1]

Yeah.

[Cole]

I've actually, since the show, probably upped my journaling and reading a lot. He's reading his own, not reading her journal.

[Nick (Host)]

There you go.

[Cole]

My own journal. Maybe the newspaper sometimes.

[Nick (Host)]

I don't know, or something.

[Natalie (Host)]

Scarlet, how did it feel to have two men crying for you?

[Scarlett]

Bradley was. I think the crying kind of, like, threw me off at the end just because it was. I don't know. I mean, I could tell that there was, like, so much love there, but for me, it was such an amazing friendship that really got me through such a hard time. There's his side and then there's my side. And I don't know, it was. It was a hard situation.

[Nick (Host)]

Well, we are going to unpack all of each relationship as we go through this reunion.

[Host 1]

But where I want to start is

[Nick (Host)]

why the heck did you guys agree to go on Temptation Island? Obviously, this is a show that has an unconventional premise coming on with your partner and allowing your partner to engage with singles. But what I love about this show, in the words of your wonderful host, Mark Wahlberg, this is a show that really unpacks a lot of the interesting layers about relationships, why they work and why they don't work. So I'd love to just go around the room and just from each couple or former couple, how did you guys come to the decision to go on Temptation Island? And just from an individual standpoint, I'd love to hear, like, what each person was hoping to get out of going on Temptation Island. So maybe I'll start with Jack and Cheyenne. How did you guys come to going on Temptation Island?

[Cheyenne]

It was fully Jack's idea to go to Temptation Island. I was not for it when he first brought it up, I was like, not fucking happening. That is not happening. And then, I don't know, he just kind of convinced me. He was like, I think if we can get past this, like, we can get past anything. And, yeah, so I agreed to go, and we did the experience. We learned what we learned. But I think ultimately I was just looking to, like, fully trust him after the show, and I don't think that quite went in my favorite.

[Natalie (Host)]

Yeah, it seems like it went maybe the opposite.

[Cheyenne]

But I won't take anything back from what happened on the island. It is what it is, and life moves on.

[Natalie (Host)]

How long did the convincing process take for him to get you on board?

[Cheyenne]

I would say it took a couple months, because even. Honestly, all the way up to when we left, I didn't even show up to the last meeting, like, the. Like, with the executives, because I knew what was going to happen. And so it was just kind of like, I don't want to do it, but I don't know. I forced myself to do it.

[Kaylee]

And.

[Jack]

No, no, no, no, no.

[Cheyenne]

I'm the one who. I was like, I'm not going on the meeting.

[Nick (Host)]

I was like, jack's so determined. He shut up. He's like, no, she's good for it.

[Cheyenne]

No, I was like, I'm not going on the meeting. Like, I think this is a terrible idea. And then Jack did his little talking, and he was like, oh, she just doesn't feel well, or whatever his excuse was. And then we ended up going. But we went in as the alternate couple, so technically, we weren't supposed to be on the show.

[Natalie (Host)]

When you found out you were gonna be on the show, what was that conversation like?

[Jack]

We went out there, like, honestly, expecting to fly out there, go through all the stuff, and then fly right back home. That was our hope a little bit, and.

[Summit]

Her hope.

[Jack]

Well, her hope.

[Nick (Host)]

Okay.

[Jack]

And then I got. And then we got there, and then we went through everything, and then they obviously came to our room and told us, and then we were just, like, kind of looked at each other. We're kind of just like.

[Cheyenne]

I was not happy.

[Nick (Host)]

We heard a rumor there might have been a flight.

[Cheyenne]

Yeah, there was a couple of fights in the hotel.

[Jack]

Arguments. Yeah. I wouldn't say fight. Argument. Argument's the right word. Yeah.

[Sydney]

Yeah.

[Nick (Host)]

Why were you so unhappy about the idea of you guys going on this show?

[Cheyenne]

Because I. I knew deep down, like, what was going to happen. I just knew. And so I was just. I just had to accept it. I was just like, he wants to do this, let's just do it.

[Nick (Host)]

Was there any part of you that thought, like, if you want to do this show that bad, maybe we should just end it here right now?

[Cheyenne]

Yes. I feel like that thought did go through my head. But as much as I knew what was gonna happen, I still had that, like, little bit of hope that was like, we're gonna make it out. We've been together for so long. That this could end in like, a way that I would feel is like a dream come true. Right? And that shit failed.

[Natalie (Host)]

Sydney, you brought Mikey to the island, right?

[Cheyenne]

I did.

[Natalie (Host)]

Okay, so why did you wanna come?

[Sydney]

So with Mikey, when it. When the opportunity presented itself and I brought it to him, he was like, absolutely not. He had watched the show multiple times, multiple seasons. And okay, am I. Correct me if I'm wrong?

[Kaylee]

Okay, but.

[Sydney]

So he had watched multiple seasons. I had never watched it. I had watched it with him like three episodes. And I was like, oh, like we had talked about it before and we were like, what if this was us? And then like, when they. When they reached out, I was like, oh, let me talk to him. He was like, absolutely not. We're not doing it. And I was just like, well, in the past, like, we've talked about different shows like this and dating shows. I was like, so why not give it a try? And then that's when I reached back out to the casting producer and I was like, yeah, he's not going for, like, he doesn't want to do it. And then they were like, well, let's just hop on a call and we can talk to him, talk him through it and see if he changes his mind. And at the end of that, he said, you know what, let's go through the application process. And that's what it was.

[Nick (Host)]

What were you hoping to get out of it? Because obviously your guys storyline was one of you feeling like Mikey wasn't showing up in your relationship the way you had hoped, or you felt like he was taking you for granted and things like that. So I think with this show, we always expect to hear that the men wanted to go like Jack and Cheyenne, you know, in a way that, like, Cheyenne kind of suspected that maybe Jack was hoping this was an opportunity to meet other ladies. But like, I think it's more of a surprise when you hear it from your end. What were you thinking this would do for your relationship going in?

[Sydney]

So when we originally got into our relationship, once he graduated college, it was like he was a completely different person that I didn't recognize. So what he was telling me sounded good, but it's like I hadn't seen the actions. So it's like, when the show reached out, I was like, this would be a good way for me to see if he has changed and if he is the person that he's telling me that he is. So that's why I wanted to go

[Nick (Host)]

and what was called. And I know you called yourself a dog a lot and kind of, you know, you called yourself a hoe.

[Host 1]

What did that actually look like?

[Sydney]

So what it looked like was when me and Mikey first met, I didn't know who he was on campus. I was a transfer to A and T. I transferred from a different college. So I wasn't, like, aware that he was, like, the big host on campus. Like, he was well known and everything like that. So I'm just talking to him, like, trying to see what it could be. And when we start sleeping together and getting romantic, then that's when other people come to me and they're like, oh, he actually is talking to, like. Like, he has a girlfriend. And I was like, what do you mean he has a girlfriend? So that from the jump, like, made me take a step back and be like, oh, like, I'm done, Mikey. Like, I did not talk to him for two years in college after that. Then that's why when he came back around, when he graduated and was like, oh, I'm this new person. I'm like, why should I believe that?

[Nick (Host)]

Mikey, I'm curious. How about you? When Cindy wanted to come on the show, how did you first initially receive it?

[Mikey]

She picked me up from the airport. Cause I had a show and she brought it up to me. And I wish I still had the video to show you. Cause it's so funny. She said, yeah, we can go to Temptation Island. And I looked at her and I said, fuck no. And she said, oop. And she cut off the camera. I love that video. But my biggest. But my biggest thing was I saw the look in her eye, and I was very timid to the opportunity. But talking to whoever. Who was it again?

[Sydney]

Chris.

[Mikey]

Yeah. Yeah. When we were talking to Chris and everything and just hearing, like, the passion she had behind it. Truthfully, like, that's my best friend. If she told me to jump off of a bridge, I'd ask how high you get. What I'm saying?

[Nick (Host)]

Yeah.

[Mikey]

So it's just on the side of just like, I always want to support whatever she put in front of me. And same way how I know she'll always support whatever I put in Front of her. So it would be wrong for me to tell her no.

[Natalie (Host)]

Well, you were a fan of the show, so you kind of knew the risk going into it.

[Mikey]

Yeah, I doubt it was fake, guys. I thought this was fake. I'm like, oh, yeah, Island, Hawaii. It's fake. It has to be fake. Truthfully, I thought all of this was fake. I was like, there's no way this is real. What if you go there with your girlfriend? You guys obviously are like, you guys are going home together.

[Summit]

But you watched the show.

[Mikey]

I didn't. No, I thought it was fake. I thought all of them were actors. Thought everybody was an actor. They give you a script, they're just like, yo, this is how it goes down. No, that shit's real. That shit is fucked. That's a fucked experience. Oh, my gosh.

[Nick (Host)]

Despite you thinking it was fake and everyone else was an actor, I am curious. Like, what did you think you needed to do to get through to the other side with Sidney? Like, was it just not hooking up with someone?

[Mikey]

Thousand percent. I truly just thought. I truly believe that if I just flirt, show my personality, get through it, we good?

[Nick (Host)]

Okay.

[Mikey]

But if I touch somebody, if I did anything, if I touched somebody in there, I would be screwed. I would be on a cross. I would.

[Natalie (Host)]

You thought she wanted to watch you flirt?

[Mikey]

My biggest thing is when we went into the experience, it was very. I knew. I knew the risk. I was like, you. You have to go on dates. You have to be in these romantic ass settings, and they're beautiful.

[Sydney]

But just because you're in romantic settings doesn't mean that you have to, you know.

[Mikey]

No, and that's totally true. But it's still on the side of just, like, conversation.

[Sydney]

But certain conversations didn't.

[Mikey]

No, and I understand that because, I mean, the biggest thing from what I watched is my mouth got me in trouble. And I was the most immature person that was on that television show. Out of everybody here, I was the most immature. And it was embarrassing to watch back. So, no, I was way more immature than Jack.

[Nick (Host)]

We'll definitely unpack you guys later. I do want to go back to Jack. Hearing Cheyenne say, she knew it was going to happen. She knew it was going to happen.

[Host 1]

Do you agree with her?

[Nick (Host)]

Do you feel like you were kind of destined to end up doing what

[Jack]

you did going on to the show? The one thing for me, and we talked about was they all heard it, too. When we first got there was, don't drink alcohol. Just because I knew that. And mind you, I changed myself from that what's really cool about the show, I didn't change myself. Actually been working on myself.

[Mikey]

There we go.

[Jack]

But what's really cool about the show is I get to reflect on who I am as a person and who I was nine months ago. And alcohol is honestly what fucking killed me. I mean, I saw.

[Cheyenne]

Did you think you were going to cheat on me going into the show?

[Jack]

No. Sorry. Off track. No, I didn't think. Honestly, no, I didn't.

[Nick (Host)]

Why did you want to go on the show? Like, why were you so determined to convince her to do it?

[Jack]

Just because prior to the show before, our relationship was super rocky. We'd argue all the time. I feel like we just weren't happy. We'd spend every day together and I mean every single day, all day.

[Nick (Host)]

I spent every day with my wife. I don't say it like that.

[Jack]

No, but I mean, he was stunning.

[Natalie (Host)]

He was stuck.

[Nick (Host)]

Dang.

[Jack]

No, I'm talking like, she's sitting on the lap while I'm taking a shit in the bathroom.

[Mikey]

Oh, my gosh.

[Natalie (Host)]

What the fuck up?

[Kaylee]

Oh, my God.

[Jack]

I'm just kidding.

[Natalie (Host)]

But honestly, though, don't be saying that.

[Jack]

But honestly, though, what? No, it just. We just had troubles before going onto the island.

[Nick (Host)]

Okay.

[Natalie (Host)]

Summit and Kayleigh, who. Which one of you's idea was it to go on the show?

[Summit]

I mean, she had initially brought it to my attention and. But she was, like, very tentative when she did bring it to me. And I was kind of like, excited about the opportunity.

[Kaylee]

Very excited.

[Sydney]

Excited.

[Summit]

Very excited. It was pretty.

[Mikey]

It was like a crazy concept.

[Nick (Host)]

Almost like in a. You almost regretted suggesting it.

[Kaylee]

Well, they reached out to me as a single and we had broken up at this point. And I responded because I was like, you know what? Like, let's just see what happens. I would never go on that show as a single now, looking back. But I responded and then we got back together and then casting reached out to me, like, the week we got back together, which was like, weird timing. And then I brought it up to him as a joke and was just like, oh, my God, Temptation island, like, reached out and he was like, oh, my God. Like, this is so sick. Like, ask them if they're casting couples. And. Yeah.

[Nick (Host)]

Why did you guys break up before?

[Kaylee]

You want to talk? You wanna go?

[Summit]

Yeah. I mean, we talk about it on the show. And this is really the reason we went on the show is just my inability to, like, commit to a relationship and just kind of like, give more of myself to a relationship. For me, before the show, that was just really scary. And I think I had this thing in my head where I was like, if you commit to a relationship, like, 100%, it means you have to, like, get married and get the dog the next day. And I think that's something the island taught me, is that's not the case. Like, you can still be 100% committed to someone and, like, give them a lot of time and energy without it meaning, like, you're getting married tomorrow. But anyways, we went on the show basically just so I could, like, get over my commitment issues. And that's why we broke up initially, is I just wasn't giving enough to the relationship.

[Kaylee]

Yeah. And I honestly didn't want to go on the show at all. And he told me, if we don't go on the show, I'll think about it for the rest of my life.

[Nick (Host)]

That's heavy.

[Kaylee]

I was sort of left with a, like, do I do this for him? Situation.

[Nick (Host)]

It feels like almost like an ultimatum.

[Kaylee]

Yeah.

[Mikey]

Yeah.

[Natalie (Host)]

Oh, well, we will honor that.

[Summit]

I mean, that's deep. I don't think that that's.

[Nick (Host)]

You look like you look deer in the headlights right now.

[Summit]

Yeah. I just don't think that I put that much intensity into it, but.

[Nick (Host)]

Okay, well, we'll unpack that later this episode. Cole and Scarlet love to hear from you guys about how you guys ended up Temptation Island.

[Scarlett]

So I got reached out to. On Instagram, and I saw the message, and I was like, absolutely not. Didn't reply. And then some time went by, and I was like, would we be okay? So I brought it up to Cole, and I was like, hey. Like, there's this. And we said, let's do the first interview. After that, I was like, I don't think it's a good idea. Like, I don't think we should do this. We were working on our relationship. There was a lot that we were going through, and I was like, this is not smart. And then he said, scar, let's just try. Let's just do it. And I was like, are you sure? So we continue to go through. And then we. You know, we both agreed. We're like, all right, let's do it. Like, we clearly have a lot of trust issues right now. And at this time, we were thinking,

[Kaylee]

oh, if we can make it through

[Scarlett]

Temptation island and not cheat, which, like, that's the bare minimum, then we'll. The trust issues will be gone, and we'll be good at the end of this. And so that was kind of like the agreement going on. And so, yeah, we agreed to go, and that's pretty much how it happened.

[Nick (Host)]

You agree with.

[Cole]

Yeah, from what I remember. Yeah, something like that. I think it was kind of like me going, like, let's try it out. Go through, like, the process, which is so long, you know, to even get on a show like that. And it just kept kind of snowballing to the next round of interviews. And before you know it, we're on, like, a family trip in Lake Tahoe and we're sneaking up to the bedroom upstairs to do an interview. And then, yeah, next week we're flying to Hawaii.

[Nick (Host)]

So, honestly, a little surprised to hear that you had the reluctance and you were the one who almost kind of encouraged you guys to go.

[Cole]

I don't think I encouraged it or it was reluctance. I think it was like, she, you know, she got reached out to she. Obviously, he has gone on reality TV before, and we talked about it, and then it was like, I think it's just like, let's just try the interview. But we were so at, like, a lower stage where I didn't think, like, we were going to, like, get to, like, the point of, like, we want you on the show. And so we just kind of, like, went through with it. But, like, I mean, I'll say it was like a mutual agreement. We both signed the contract and went on. So it wasn't like, no. Maybe similar to the other couples. Like, we didn't force each other. Wasn't like, if you don't do this, like, I'm breaking up with you. Or like, we were like, I think summit. Yeah.

[Summit]

Yeah.

[Cole]

I think if we both were like, hey, we don't want to do it, or one is want to do it, like, we wouldn't have done it and, like, we just wouldn't have done it. So it wasn't like a end all be all. Just we both agreed.

[Natalie (Host)]

Now, Scarlett, this wasn't your first time on reality tv, right?

[Scarlett]

No, I did below deck, which was way fucking easier.

[Sydney]

Like.

[Nick (Host)]

Yeah, I imagine we were living on

[Scarlett]

a yacht and it was. It was still really hard. Well, one of the things, actually, one of the reasons I thought this would be good for us was because even that you're put in these situations where it really does force you to grow and look inward. And so I told him going into it, I was like, it's gonna be like, so hard, you know, and you don't even realize. But then once you get there, it's like things come up and, like, you're just put on the spotlight and, you know, under all of this pressure. And so I said, you know, if anything comes of this, like, let's just really use this opportunity for growth. And I think that was another reason that I thought it would be good for us.

[Nick (Host)]

Okay.

[Natalie (Host)]

We'll definitely get to each couple to unpack each relationship. But leaving the show, we only had one couple leave together. Kaylee and Summit. Are you guys still together?

[Kaylee]

Yeah.

[Summit]

Yeah.

[Kaylee]

Okay.

[Mikey]

We are.

[Sydney]

Okay.

[Natalie (Host)]

And are the rest of you still broken up?

[Kaylee]

Yes, we're together.

[Cole]

We're together.

[Nick (Host)]

You guys are together?

[Natalie (Host)]

Scarlett and Cole, y' all are back together.

[Nick (Host)]

All right.

[Natalie (Host)]

Love it.

[Nick (Host)]

I'm excited to find out how that happened again.

[Natalie (Host)]

Jack and Cheyenne, y' all are still broken up?

[Sydney]

Yeah.

[Nick (Host)]

Yep. Okay.

[Jack]

Mutual.

[Sydney]

Oh, got it.

[Kaylee]

Okay. Of course.

[Sydney]

Okay.

[Natalie (Host)]

Sydney and Mikey, y' all are also not together.

[Mikey]

Not together.

[Natalie (Host)]

And are you still with Xavier?

[Sydney]

I am just focusing on myself.

[Nick (Host)]

Okay.

[Host 1]

All right, let's take a quick break

[Nick (Host)]

to hear from our sponsors.

[Host 1]

Don't forget Vile Files plus now offers ad free episodes for all Vile Files episodes, including Ask Nick Reality Recap and Going Deeper. Plus, if you love Ask Nick, you will absolutely love our Ask Nick updates where you get updates of your favorite calls, our deep dive on all your favorite reality recap TV shows, and our pop culture roundup where we talk about all your favorite pop culture topics that we didn't get to in this week's episode. Plus deep dives on our Going Deeper guest, and so much more. All you have to do is go

[Nick (Host)]

to Vile Files plus and you will

[Host 1]

be lucky you did.

[Natalie (Host)]

I am getting ready to pack my hospital bag. I'm going to the hospital giving birth to these twins and like, top on my list. The thing that I don't even have to think about packing is a Minky Couture blanket. Because I 1 million percent need comfort. I need luxury, I need soft, I need cozy. And that's everything that you get with Minky Couture. They have the plushiest blankets on the planet. It feels like you're like hugging a cloud. It's double sided. It was founded by a mom who just wanted to provide luxurious comfort to her daughter's life. I mean, like, you're in good hands. You're in great hands. They have the biggest selection of colors and patterns and sizes than any other market. It is the best blanket ever and you need it. So if you want to romanticize the little things in life, like getting cozy, visit minky couture.com and use code V I L L at checkout for 50 off all full priced blankets that's minky couture.com use code V I A L L for 50 off all full priced blankets.

[Host 1]

Helix Sleep I'm so excited to talk about Helix Sleep, the greatest mattress ever made for mankind. I've been sleeping on a Helix mattress

[Nick (Host)]

for six years now. My wife has also been sleeping on a Helix mattress because we sleep in the same bed.

[Host 1]

It's the greatest mattress you could ever imagine. Helix Sleep has 20 unique mattresses for all kind of sleepers. It doesn't matter how you sleep. You sleep hot, sleep cold on your back, on your side, curled up into a little ball. It doesn't matter. Helix Sleep has you covered even the big and tall sleepers and those kids. Helix Mattress has a mattress for you.

[Natalie (Host)]

I honestly have beef with Helix Mattress because as soon as we get into bed I am wanting to talk and converse and like tell all my secrets to Nick and he is snoring immediately as soon as he hits that mattress because it is so comfortable. We also are switching river into a toddler bed and we just got her a twin mattress from Helix so she can sleep as good as she sleeps with us by herself.

[Host 1]

Every room in our house and our lake house has a Helix mattress and so many of our guests have woken up and then went straight to helixsleep.com to get a mattress for their home. And it's that good people stop wasting time going to mattress stores. If you have been not getting the best sleep you've ever had or thinking that maybe you need to upgrade your mattress today, do yourself a favor, go to helixsleep.com you won't regret it. Answer a few questions about your sleep preferences and you could be sleeping on the most comfortable mattress you've ever experienced

[Nick (Host)]

in a matter of days.

[Host 1]

If you don't want to take our word for it, don't worry. Helix sleep gives you 120 day sleep trial. You can sleep on it, do whatever you want, bounce around on it, make sweet sweet love on it for 120 days. And if you're not absolutely obsessed with your Helix mattress, you can send it

[Nick (Host)]

back no questions asked.

[Host 1]

In addition to that, all their mattresses come with a 10 to 15 year warranty depending on the mattress and their mattresses are recommended by doctors of sleep medicine and leading chiropractors. So you know it is great. So if you want to upgrade your sleep, go to helixleep.com V I A L L for their spring savings event. 20% off site wide. Again, that's helixsleep.com time helixleep.com V I A L L for their spring savings event 20% off site wide. You know how I feel about going in the gym. It's generally a waste of time. And I know all you busy people out there. You want to stay healthy. You want to find the time to get a quick workout in. But if you're like me, then you have a bad tendency of doing the same workouts over and over and it gets a little mundane and a little monotonous. Ladder is here to help you get the training that you need wherever you are. It's so great because all you need is a device to get your Ladder workouts. They have so many amazing classes and and types of exercises with leading trainers to help you get new and dynamic workouts. So if you are someone who's busy on the go, maybe you travel a lot for work, you can do it in the comfort of your hotel room, your home. Stop wasting time going to the gym unpacking your bag. You can get amazing workouts in just a few minutes with Ladder. Ladder is an expert strength training plan, not a content library. It works with any type of strength training that you prefer, whether you're looking for Pilates, bodybuilding at home, dumbbell only workouts, hybrid strength, gluten focused programs, Kettlebel Pre Postnatal Ladder has workouts for every type of person at any type of level. So if you want to get great workouts with minimal equipment and waste minimal time, Ladder is the app for you. It costs less than a dollar a day. That's elite level personal training for a fraction of what you'd pay in person. Ladder now includes nutrition tracking at no extra cost, AI powered food logging and macro insights integrated with your training plan. Your progress is tracked automatically. The app remembers your weights, reps and sets so you can see yourself getting stronger over time. So if you are looking for new and more dynamic workouts, no matter what your level is, look at Ladder. You'll be glad that you did. You'll get so many different types of exercises. It helps make working out, stay fun, stay refreshed and keeps you coming back for more. That's one thing I found with using Ladder. It's helped me stay more on track and more consistent with my workouts. Remove the guesswork with Ladder and get a real coach in your ear telling you exactly what to do for every workout. No thinking everything is planned for you. And if you have an iPhone, head to Ladder Fit V I A L L and take a quick quiz to find out your perfect Ladder plan. Use our link and get a free 7 day trial with no credit card and $10 off your first month if you join again. Head to Ladder Fit V I L

[Mikey]

L.

[Natalie (Host)]

And we're back to part one of the Temptation island season two reunion.

[Nick (Host)]

Maybe it makes sense to kick things off with the one couple that left the island together. Kaylee and Summit.

[Host 1]

With Summit's slight slip and slide and Kaylee's realization that she deserved basic respect

[Nick (Host)]

from her partner, these two lovers may

[Host 1]

not have looked like they were going

[Nick (Host)]

to make it out together. But after the beach did its magic, Summit and Kaylee decided to give it another go. Move in and get a dog. Sometimes love really does win.

[Natalie (Host)]

So did you two move in together and get a dog?

[Kaylee]

Not yet, but it's coming.

[Natalie (Host)]

We haven't moved in together. We haven't got a dog. Or both.

[Kaylee]

Neither.

[Summit]

Neither.

[Scarlett]

How long.

[Nick (Host)]

How many months has it been since you guys filmed?

[Kaylee]

Like eight or nine months.

[Summit]

Eight or nine months? Yeah. We want to move in and get the dog, like asap. It's just kind of the realities of life that can make things prolong that process. But, like, if I can move in with Keely tomorrow, I would. I'm sick of my.

[Nick (Host)]

So it doesn't feel.

[Host 1]

There's no doubt in our mind that

[Kaylee]

we are both aligned on still one.

[Summit]

Getting that. Yeah. And we need the. The house to get the dog. We've even considered getting the dog. Not living together, but that seems problematic.

[Kaylee]

We really wanted to have the wiener dog to pull out at this podcast.

[Natalie (Host)]

I mean, like, where it.

[Kaylee]

Where's that collar?

[Summit]

I didn't bring it physically here, but I brought it to la.

[Sydney]

Okay.

[Natalie (Host)]

Just in case.

[Kaylee]

It just comes everywhere with us.

[Nick (Host)]

In case you find a dog.

[Summit]

Yeah. No, literally.

[Nick (Host)]

And your dad said a wiener dog. Yeah.

[Summit]

Yeah. What's funny is I never thought in a million years I would get a wiener dog. And she just keeps pointing out cute wiener dogs over, like the last year we've been together and now all of a sudden I want a wiener dog. She like, brainwashed me into wanting one.

[Kaylee]

Yeah.

[Nick (Host)]

Well, we're definitely excited to hear more about your relationship and how it's grown since Temptation Island. But I do want to go back to kind of where your relationship was when you went on Temptation Island. And there was obviously, I think the big theme with you guys was one of the themes was centered around some comments Summit that you made about Kaylee. And as difficult as I'm sure that was for both of you to talk about on the show, I do think it's honestly, like relatable for relationships, for maybe a well intentioned guy to say something that we put our foot in our mouths a lot sometimes, but at the same time, it doesn't stop maybe us hurting our partners with our words.

[Host 1]

And so I guess just for context,

[Nick (Host)]

could you guys just kind of like, I feel like we had an idea of what happened, but you guys never really spoke about the specificity of, like, what that conversation looked like where you found his words so hurtful when talking about your body.

[Kaylee]

Well, there's a reason I didn't bring it up at the final bonfire. It's because that was something I never wanted to speak on publicly.

[Nick (Host)]

Okay.

[Kaylee]

And it wasn't this, like, main driving issue in our relationship, but the show sort of dialed in on that and made that a big part of it. And that's just. That was never my intention. He has said things in the past that hurt me, and those are things you can't erase. Like, you hear those little comments and you never have mal intent when you say them and then you hear them and you think them in the back of your head. And it hurts, right? As a woman, it hurts to feel like you're not enough. But since being, like, on the show and since him realizing that saying those little things is so hurtful, he has, like, never said a word. Again, like, we have never had an issue with this since.

[Nick (Host)]

And I'm just curious, like, how. How did you learn that lesson? Because again, it sounds like even hearing from Kaylie that she never thought you were coming from a place of trying to hurt her.

[Summit]

Yeah.

[Nick (Host)]

So what was the lesson that you learned to realize, like, walk me through, like, Old Summit and what you might have thought was okay to say. And now how have you learned to, like, you know what? Maybe I'm just gonna shut my mo.

[Summit]

Yeah. No, I mean, it was obviously with never, like, any sort of maliciousness. And I think it really stems from just this idea that, like, Kaylee is only my second serious relationship ever. And I think I'm just learning. And I've learned, you know, Temptation island is like the gauntlet. Like, it's like a pressure cooker where it basically expedites that, like, tenfold. And I feel like I learned so much on the island and I just learned that you can't speak to women like you would. A guy is kind of like, you know, I grew up with two younger brothers and a single mom who's, like, hardcore. And there was just not a lot of, like, I don't know, like, delicate women walking around, you know, and I guess I'm just getting used to that. And, you know, it was just silly, dumb things that I never meant with any sort of maliciousness. But now I know, you know, because of Mark and seeing how much it hurt Kaylee, I don't know, now it seems, I guess, just more obvious that, like, okay, I can understand how that would upset someone. And, you know, Kaylee knows that I think she's literally like the most beautiful girl on the planet. And I tell her that every day. But it doesn't matter if you tell a girl a billion times a day she's the most beautiful girl on the planet, because she's only going to remember that time where you're like, you know,

[Kaylee]

and don't say whatever your example is. Just keep the example to yourself.

[Mikey]

Yeah, yeah.

[Nick (Host)]

So do you remember what you said?

[Summit]

I. Well, I mean, once again, not defending myself, but it is these scenarios where it's exactly what was talked about in the show, where Mark, you know, Kayla would come to me and be like, I wanna grow my butt. And then I'd be like, okay, do squats. And then she'd be like, oh, okay, so now you're, like, thinking it wasn't

[Kaylee]

just that there was other comments made.

[Summit]

So I. I don't. Yeah, I don't know. The other comments. That was the comment of the one on the show.

[Nick (Host)]

So you had a very meaningful conversation with your mom prior to the final bonfire. Why was it so important for you to talk to your mom before that?

[Summit]

My mom is just. Yeah. Has, like, always been everything for me. She was mom and dad and superhero, and she's just always been my rock and, like, there for me. And she's the first person I go to for advice is my family, my mom, my brothers. And it just seemed like an obvious for me to contact my mom. And it was crazy how she knew exactly what I was going through.

[Cheyenne]

I just don't think it's fair that we didn't get to call our moms.

[Kaylee]

Yeah, I would have liked to have called my mom and cried every day.

[Summit]

Well, I actually. I wanted to call her and then they were like, you can call her, but you called her every day. No, no, they said it needed to be on camera.

[Mikey]

Okay.

[Summit]

So that was like the.

[Natalie (Host)]

And has she watched the show? How does she feel about it?

[Summit]

Yeah, I mean, she. She enjoyed it. She's very proud. And she's very proud of Kayleigh and I and us making it out and just the fact that we were the only couple that did make it out. And she was Very proud with how I handled myself and how Kaylee handled herself and. Yeah, you know, she had obvious. She all sorts of, like, funny comments and. Yeah. But, yeah, she's proud.

[Nick (Host)]

Kaylee, what's your relationship with Summit's mom?

[Kaylee]

We're friends. Okay. Yeah. I've only, like, met her, like, three times because she lives in, like, Montana, so I don't. I'm not like, super close with her, but, well, a great lady.

[Natalie (Host)]

Nick got a DM from Chris, and he called your relationship one of the most intense emotional experiences.

[Kaylee]

My relationship with Chris.

[Natalie (Host)]

Your connection with Chris was the most intense emotional experiences of his life. What we did not get to see a lot of yalls relationship. So can you kind of give us some insight? Insight into what that looked like?

[Kaylee]

I mean, Chris was like my rock. He really, like, helped me through that whole process. And he was an amazing friend. And he made me, like, dig deeper within myself and discover things about myself that I hadn't even, like, realized. And it was like a great, great friendship. It wasn't some. What did he call it?

[Natalie (Host)]

Deep, intense emotional experiences of his life.

[Kaylee]

Yeah, that's a little much for me.

[Nick (Host)]

Maybe it was for him.

[Kaylee]

Yeah.

[Nick (Host)]

You know?

[Kaylee]

Yeah. I think he was a lasting impression. Yeah. And he left an impression on me. I mean, a lot of the things he said to me, like, he empowered me to see the beauty within myself and to be more confident and walk different in life.

[Nick (Host)]

Well, that is interesting. And being one of the few couples still together, I am curious how you both leaving the island, discussed your time on the island because you didn't cross any physical boundaries. And that's easy to be like, yeah, I didn't do anything. But, like, knowing that your partner was talking to and getting to know these other people, it sometimes can be difficult to say, hey, this guy really helped me. He made me realize this about myself. He made me feel this. And how did you guys communicate that to each other? You had a very similar experience with some of the women.

[Summit]

Yeah.

[Nick (Host)]

So that must be challenging to hear. But how did you guys work through that to help you guys be a better couple?

[Summit]

Yeah. I mean, we binged the show start to end right as it came out, and we weren't shocked by anything we saw in the show because we lived it and the bonfires. But, you know, there were still moments where we're like, damn, like, you said that. Or like, he affected you that much. Like when, you know, she's bawling her eyes out and Chris is crying, and she's like, I've never Met a human like you in my life. Like, of course, as a man, my ego is like, a little shot. I'm like, well, like, I'm special too, you know? Like, that's just. I think it's hard to not feel that way, like you said.

[Nick (Host)]

Sure.

[Summit]

But at the end of the day, I think you just gotta drop the ego. We were in a crazy situation. You know, those. The single girls helped me out a ton. Those single guys helped her out a ton. And without them, we wouldn't have grown and we wouldn't have gotten off the island together. So, like, whatever happened, I don't want to change anything. And at the end of the day, like, I'm grateful for Chris for helping her through that process.

[Kaylee]

Yeah, I'm very thankful for those girls. Like, the man I saw at that final bonfire was a changed man. And I know Mark did some wonders, and I know he did a lot of work himself, but I also know living with those girls helped change him because they taught him sides of girls that he didn't, like, understand before. So I'm thankful for them.

[Summit]

Honestly, even, like, what we were talking about earlier, where just, like, how you can be more delicate speaking to a girl. I mean, I would come back from bonfires and ask those single girls, I would be like, what do you think about this? They're like, summit, you're an idiot. Like, they would tell me straight to my face.

[Kaylee]

And sometimes it takes other girls telling you, like, that's not right, instead of it just being me.

[Natalie (Host)]

Totally.

[Nick (Host)]

Yeah. I think Julianne mentioned that you felt like she saw you for who you really were. I think you even expressed that you kind of wanted Kaylee to see you the same way Julianne saw you.

[Summit]

Yeah, Just this idea, you know, probably the same way she said, like, Chris just saw the beauty in her, which I obviously saw the beauty in Kaylee. But I don't know, you're just, like, in those moments. What I appreciate about Julianne is she just really wanted. She just, like, loved me no matter what. And I think loved no, like, just, like, really appreciated me no matter what. And I think you have to be a little realistic in that setting because, like, at the end of the day, these people are singles on the show as, like, a job, and their job is to please you. Like, when the girls come home from a bonfire and the guys are waiting there with flowers, it's not like they went and picked the flowers. Like, production gave them the flowers. And, like, obviously Julianne is gonna be super nice and helpful throughout that entire process. It'd be weird if she wasn't.

[Sydney]

Totally.

[Kaylee]

Yeah.

[Natalie (Host)]

Speaking of that, we had a chance to talk to Jesenia, and she said that she doesn't think you continued your connection with her because you knew you would be tempted. Do you believe that to be true?

[Summit]

No. Like, there was really never. There was doubts in my mind throughout the process as to whether Kaylie and I would have made it out of the show. And that was more of, like, a personal journey, whether I could just, like, commit. But, like, there was never one time throughout the show where I felt, like, actually physically tempted to the point where, like, I would have done anything with any of the girls. Do I think they're pretty. Totally. Do I. Would I have done anything? No.

[Natalie (Host)]

Kaylee, you mentioned that you did not remember calling Summitt a sociopath at the final bonfire. How was it watching that scene back together?

[Kaylee]

I think. I mean, I didn't call him a sociopath. I said the way he was acting was sociopathic. And I think he just heard that word and kind of freaked out and ran around and was like, oh, my God, I'm a sociopath. Like, what's going on? Watching it back, I'm like, with the context of the story, I mean, I obviously should have never said that. And I feel bad that now people are gonna call you a sociopath. Cause that's not true at all. But, I mean, in the context of the story, it was more of, like, me just describing the way he was acting was sociopathic. And watching it back, it sucked. I feel like I regret a lot of the ways that I spoke about him on the show. Like, I am sitting here saying, Summit used to talk down on me. I sat there for eight episodes straight talking down on Summit and watching that back hurts. It's hard to see. Wow. I spoke very negatively of a man that I love so much. And what you don't see on the show is me saying I love him so much every single goddamn day. And all the guys being like, please stop talking about Summit.

[Nick (Host)]

Did you have to prepare Summit for that? Did you realize how much shit you talked while filming it?

[Kaylee]

The producers make all four of us women sit there and talk about our problems. Sure. So by talking about my problems, since I wasn't always the main issue in the relationship, I had to talk about things that he's done wrong. And as a result, that looks like I'm talking shit, but it's like, for the most part, I'm speaking my truth. Like, I'm speaking my experience. So, yeah.

[Nick (Host)]

Yeah. How did you process that, you know, because, again, I think sometimes us guys don't realize how hurtful it can be to hear our partners, like, talk about our character. Sometimes I think that hurts us more than physical boundaries being crossed.

[Summit]

Yeah, I actually saw that on your other podcast. I thought that that, like, resonated with me because I went into the show. You, as a guy, you go into those shows, and you think, like, as long as my girl doesn't, like, touch a guy, we're good. Like, whatever. And then you learn that, like, the emotional connections that they build with the dudes does still fuck with you. And I was surprised how much that fucked with me. But it's just, like, a buildup of so many different factors, and you're in this, like, crazy, unrealistic scenario where there's no friends, no family, no contact with the outside world, and you just. It's very easy to, like, lose touch with reality. And I think small things can, like, feel very, very big. And so when I heard sociopathic, I just started spiraling. And it's also, you know, from the guy that she's, like, has built this emotional connection with. Like, it's just a. This accumulation of so many things. It's very easy to get very worked up.

[Mikey]

Yeah.

[Nick (Host)]

Well, the good news is, if you were sociopathic, it wouldn't have phased you.

[Mikey]

True.

[Summit]

Yeah. So boom. I just proved it right there.

[Kaylee]

Clear the air. He's not a sociopath, everyone.

[Cole]

It's clear.

[Nick (Host)]

It was. It was pretty clear, like, seeing how much it bothers you watching. It was pretty clear that you're not.

[Summit]

Yeah. Okay.

[Nick (Host)]

I appreciate that.

[Summit]

I think, if anything, I'm, like, kind of, like, sensitive dude.

[Mikey]

Yeah, yeah.

[Kaylee]

Like, but you weren't always sensitive. In the past. You hadn't been that sensitive side that you are now.

[Summit]

Yeah, no, I mean, the show. The show helped a lot. I talked more about my feelings in that month in Temptation island than I probably have my entire life.

[Nick (Host)]

So how do you two now. How do you guys go about showing up for each other that allows you guys to. It seems like you guys are in a really good place right now.

[Kaylee]

Yeah, I think we're everything. We like. Everything I ever wanted to be is where we're at, and it's amazing. We, like, do everything together, but we're not, like, so codependent. Like, we also have our own things, and we're independent in our own ways.

[Summit]

Yeah. I think ultimately, you know, one of the main reasons we went on the show and something we had to work out was this idea that we are kind of innately different people. And we. I do, like, I think my independence more than she does sometimes. And it seems like since the show, that just hasn't been a problem at all. Like, I'm able to do all the things that I want to do. And I think she just, like, got more confident. I don't wanna speak on her journey, but, like, more confidence in herself. So she doesn't mind as much when I go surfing for five hours or whatever. And then it's also this idea where now I just realize, like, all those things I used to think I wanted to do on my own, I actually do wanna do them with Kayleigh now, like, everything I do, I invite Kayleigh. And before the show, I wasn't doing that.

[Natalie (Host)]

Do you invite her to sit on your lap when you ship?

[Summit]

That is the one thing I don't.

[Kaylee]

That almost happened in the hotel room yesterday.

[Summit]

We are in a very tiny hotel room here, though. And, like, we were. Like, we're too close now. Like, she was brushing her teeth while I'm. Shit, you know, like, it's a lot.

[Kaylee]

I think the. The main takeaway for us is I feel way more secure now in the relationship. And that's what's made everything just so much better for us.

[Nick (Host)]

And how did you get to that point? Because I imagine he's been helpful, but usually when we kind of tackle our insecurities, I think sometimes we're surprised how much it has to do with ourselves.

[Kaylee]

I think knowing, like, I can literally look him in the eyes and I know he loves me wholeheartedly, without a doubt. And I didn't feel like that before we went on the show.

[Nick (Host)]

Do you think going on Temptation island experience was game changing for you guys?

[Kaylee]

It was like, it actually was.

[Summit]

I don't know where it'd be. It's interesting to think, like, where we would be had we not gone on the show. Realistically, we either would have been broken up or, like, have broken up and gotten back together, like, several more times. Like, there's no way.

[Kaylee]

We have the same issues. Like a toxic cycle.

[Mikey]

Yeah.

[Natalie (Host)]

Let's take a quick break to hear from our sponsors. Well, if you can't tell, I am a mother, I'm going to be a mother of three. And I can't tell you what I love more than flowers, especially flowers on Mother's Day. It's giving your thinking of me. It's giving you care about me. And flowers are the number one gift to give for Mother's Day. But it can be hard to know which ones we'll show mom how much she means to you. For 50 years, 1-800-Flowers has been helping people send beautiful bouquets. Mom will love and express all the gratitude you have for everything she does.

[Host 1]

Natalie's not wrong. Every lady loves flowers. It's my go to hack for procrastinating and forgetting about those special days. And 1-800-FLowers has been my sidekick to procrastination and love.

[Natalie (Host)]

And right now, when you order one dozen roses from 1-800-flowers, they'll double your bouquet to two dozen for free. Twice the flowers for the mom who gives everything.

[Host 1]

Wherever you are in this country, 1-800-FLowers has you covered. Mother's Day certainly is coming up. And if you don't know what to get the special ladies and moms in your life, think of 1-800-FLowers. And it doesn't even have to be a special day.

[Nick (Host)]

It can just be a Tuesday.

[Natalie (Host)]

They also don't have to be moms of children. They can be moms of dogs and cats and reptiles and birds. So Mother's Day is Sunday, May 10, and bouquets are selling out fast. Trust us. Don't wait to claim your double roses offer before they're gone. Visit 1-800flowers.com v I a l l that's 1-800flowers.comv I a l l 1-800flowers.com V I a l l this one's

[Host 1]

for all my TV lovers. My entertainment from Direct TV gets you 60 plus channels and Disney Plus, Hulu and HBO Max all in one pack. But here's the thing. With so much great TV in my entertainment, you're going to want to talk about everything you've been watching. Just remember that your friends might not be as well watched as you. Don't be a spoiler and encourage them to get my entertainment for just 34. 99amonth. Go to directv.com genrepacks and sign up today. New customers only. Service renews monthly unless canceled. Credit card required. Conditions applied to all apps, HBO Max Basics and ads begin after DIRECTV 5 day trial. Learn [e-mail] restrictions apply. If your morning coffee isn't cutting it lately, start your day with something amazing. Our next sponsor makes bone broth that hydrates, nourishes and wakes you up without spiking your nerves or blood sugar. I love coffee. I definitely love having in the morning, but I realized that starting my day with a cup of coffee isn't the best way to feel myself. And bone broth has been a great substitute. Just have a little bone broth in the morning before you start your coffee, your body will thank you. It's great for your digestion. It has so many great nutrients, it tastes great and it doesn't have anything crappy in it like a bunch of sugar or things like that. It's also great for a mid afternoon snack. If you hit that mid afternoon energy crash, you know the routine. Another coffee, a bar or chips you probably didn't need. Well, bone broth is a way better option. Again you get those great nutrients, it tastes great and you get the energy that your body craves so that you can keep staying at your best level throughout the day. Brodo comes in eight delicious flavors from classic chicken to spicy nona. The more creative blends like ginger, turmeric, herb infused and veggie based broth. I recommend trying their sample pack so you get to figure out for yourself what flavors you love the best. Personally, I'm your classic chicken kind of guy, but maybe you like to spice it up with some of their other great flavors. Shop the best broth on the planet with brodo head to brodo.com viall for 20% off your first subscription order and use code VI A L L for an additional $10 off. Once again, that's Brodo B R O D O.com backslash V I A L L for 20 off your first subscription order and an additional $10 off if you use our promo code V I

[Natalie (Host)]

A L L Right now I'm all about what is making my life easier. How can I be as relaxed as possible? And the answer to that question is Instacart right now. I have been using Instacart for so long because it makes your life so much easier. It's more than a grocery technology platform, it's a care company designed to make life easier. It connects you to thousands of stores across the United States, giving you time back to focus on what matters most. With just a few taps, you can shop from your favorite stores and have fresh groceries and household essentials ready for pickup or delivered to your door in as fast as 30 minutes. Instacart helps take care of delivering some of the things you love so that you're free to take care of life. I understand that the weekly restock can feel like a lot, whether you're shopping for just yourself or managing meals for the whole family. With Instacart you can take care of everything on your list without making a trip to the store. From meal prepping for the week to restocking the essentials, Instacart makes It easier to get it all done without adding an errand to your day.

[Host 1]

We are absolutely obsessed with Instacart. There's nothing worse than, like, having a busy day, realizing it's already five o' clock and you just don't have time or want to go to the grocery store. Instacart is absolutely game changing in those days, and those days happen more often than not.

[Natalie (Host)]

Instacart brings convenience, quality and ease right to your door so you can focus on what matters most. Download the Instacart app now and get groceries just how you like.

[Nick (Host)]

And we're back to part one of the Temptation island season two reunion. I think it's time to move on to Sydney and Mikey to some.

[Natalie (Host)]

Attending weddings and meeting the family are the ultimate testaments of love. But when Sydney brought Mikey to the island to see if he could finally put his playboy tendencies to rest, there were three who gave Sydney the clarity she needed. Clarity being one man and one seafoam green guitar. And who would have thought Mikey would be the one committing in the end?

[Nick (Host)]

Sydney, how difficult was it for you to watch Mikey be emotional throughout the entire season?

[Sydney]

It was extremely hard watching him go through those emotions because it's not something that I've seen before. And you know, like, it broke my heart because I hated seeing him like that.

[Kaylee]

Aww.

[Natalie (Host)]

Mikey, how does it feel to see her get emotional?

[Mikey]

I mean, truthfully, I know Sydney loves me. Like, no matter what we go through, I know. No matter what she knows, like, you're my best friend. It don't matter what we go through. It don't matter who comes into a picture. If I don't see her for months. Like, we haven't seen each other. How many months is we haven't seen each other for.

[Sydney]

It's been like four months.

[Mikey]

Yeah, it's been like four months since we've seen each other.

[Nick (Host)]

What happened four months ago?

[Mikey]

Can I. Yeah. So me and Cindy got back together four days after the show.

[Natalie (Host)]

Four days after the show?

[Mikey]

Yeah. Like four days after we got back

[Nick (Host)]

from the island, you guys agreed to date again.

[Mikey]

Yeah, and we dated. We dated four days after we got back. And it was. Everything was going so good and it was going phenomenal. Blah. Say blah. But the thing about it was I was holding on to what I experienced on that island and that was not fair to her whatsoever. Like, I was like, any inkling of us having an argument, I'm throwing that jab at her. And as a woman, I can. I saw like, I saw, like, her as a Woman really be like, it was tearing her down because I could see, like, her heart was hurt because I'm throwing that at her. And that was not fair.

[Nick (Host)]

Yeah, I'm actually a little surprised to hear that because. Well, for one, I'm surprised that four days later, to hear you guys got back together, well, it seemed like you had, like, a. Like a second life. You know, that. Quite honestly, I think as viewers, we didn't expect. And instead of seizing that opportunity to, like, really maybe try to show Sydney that you might appreciate in ways that she didn't feel appreciated. And I'm surprised to hear that. It almost sounds like, no offense, like, old Mikey came back out. Because, like, what I took from that relationship is that you really felt like you were in control of yourself in that relationship when you guys dated in ways that maybe Sidney didn't feel. And to hear you kind of, like, not seize that opportunity and kind of throw what she did in her face was kind of almost like, what sounds like old Mikey would do, I would say.

[Mikey]

I wouldn't even say it was old Mikey. I would say it was the immaturities. Because truthfully, like, watching it back and totally, like, I've been on my therapy journey. I've been focused on my relationship with God based upon, like, truthfully losing Sidney. Like, I never thought I would really dive into therapy. I always thought therapy was a joke. I'm looking at it. Like, I'm really thinking about it. Like, I'm not that messed up as a person. But to understand that I had so many insecurities in myself, and I was projecting those onto this beautiful young lady right here. It wasn't fair. It wasn't fair to her. And when I say that she's my best friend. I said it in the first. I said it in the first scene. I said, I love her from the soles of her feet to the top of her head. That's something that I've said to her forever. You know what I'm saying? So the fact that I didn't seize that opportunity, that's just something that I have to live with. But the fact that I'm, like, I'm perfectly okay with having to live in that truth. That just shows the growth that it's just, like, it has to be okay.

[Nick (Host)]

How long did you guys stay together after you got back together?

[Sydney]

We stayed together for three months.

[Natalie (Host)]

Okay, what happened to. Cause that breakup?

[Sydney]

Basically, what he said with, like, the whole show and everything. And originally when we got back, you know, he was like, forget about the show. Like, what you did and everything like that, we can move past it. We can move past it. And. And he brought to my attention, like, he was like, the things that they showed you at the bonfire. That's not what I said. Like, they clipped it up. They edited it. So I was like, so you're telling me, like, what I saw and how I moved after that was off of something fake. So, like, I felt guilt in myself, and I was like, I don't want to do that to him. And it's like, he was. He's my best friend, and I. I didn't know how to move forward with the new connection that I had made on the island because I did care about Xavier, you know, that was real. That whole experience that I had with him was real. And I think trying to say that to Mikey was really hard. And it made me feel guilty when he said, I didn't do anything. You know, talking to the single girls. That's not what I said. I said, my biggest fear is Sydney thinking, I'm falling for you. Not my biggest fear is falling for you. And then him just telling me all these different things, and I'm like, whoa, wait, this is not what my experience was. So when we got back together, and he was like, I've changed. I learned so much from those girls on the island. I was like, okay, let's see. So I would say for, like, a few weeks, I saw a difference. You wrote me two letters in a span of three months. So I was like, there was so much more that I wanted from our relationship. And he knows, like, how I am. I'm a lover girl. Like, I want to be. I want you to show me that you love me. I want you to write me letters. I want you to bring me flowers. I want you to do all the things that, like, tell me that you love me. And it's like, I gave him the blueprint of everything, everything he had to do. And it's like, first off, I shouldn't have to do that. And then when he wasn't doing it, I was like, you know what? I'm done. And since then, we have not talked.

[Mikey]

We have not spoken.

[Sydney]

We have not spoken.

[Nick (Host)]

Do you feel like Mikey took you for granted?

[Sydney]

I do. Yeah.

[Nick (Host)]

Do you agree with her?

[Mikey]

I took her for granted 1000%. That's her truth. I respect everything that she says.

[Natalie (Host)]

Is that her truth, or is that the truth?

[Mikey]

There is no good guy, bad guy. It's just two people that don't align. That's all it is. Sure.

[Nick (Host)]

But just to Push back a little bit. And I think it's. I think there was a theme here with the guys, which is interesting because, like, sometimes the, you know, you talked about bare minimum. Like, being a good guy is the bare minimum. The bare minimum, right. You know, like, not cheating on your girlfriends, like, the bare minimum. But, like, I think sometimes in relationships, we just sometimes can get complacent. You take people for granted, you know, like, it was interesting when we started this conversation that you thought, like, I could flirt as long as I didn't, like, touch anybody, touch anyone. Which I'm thinking, like, how is. Huh? Like, you know, this is a girl who has expressed to you that she felt like you took her for granted. So much so, it was like, almost shocking to me as a viewer to see you kind of almost like, walk that tightrope, where it's just like, you know, how much can I get away with and get her to stick around? And I think sometimes as young men, we do that. Sometimes where we, like, we see what we can get away with is almost a way to, like, test our partners.

[Mikey]

I think my biggest thing is, like, I have to be kind to myself because I am only 24 years old, and I'm still learning how to become a better individual.

[Nick (Host)]

Okay.

[Mikey]

I'm not gonna say that I am the most mature, but I do really wish I had that opportunity again to go on the island as the version of myself that I am right now, based upon, for one, my mindset how I think about things and how I could actually be serious. Cause truthfully, if this was me, from the people that saw it on the show, I'll be in here joking with you, trying to make a whole bunch of jokes and comical and all that ain't shit funny no more. I really, like. I don't know how I lost my sense of humor from that show to here to now, but it's just like, I know when it's time to lock in. I know when it's time to have fun. And that's something that Sydney truthfully hated about me. It was just like, you never can go in depth. You never can be serious. You think everything is a joke. And I was just always thinking to myself, like, I mean, like, life is all about smiles and all that, but it's not like life is about getting into it for real, actually having those deep in depth conversations and watching the show and seeing that with her and Xavier. I mean, I was just on the side of just, like, I was happy watching it. Like, I'm not gonna lie like, watching it back from, like, this version, I was like, she's happy. And as long as my best friend is happy, that's all I need to care about. That's all I need to care about.

[Nick (Host)]

You still consider her your best friend?

[Mikey]

Oh, 1,000%. I mean, that's always gonna be my best friend, no matter what. Even if we don't talk forever, Even

[Nick (Host)]

if you, like, meet someone else.

[Mikey]

Yeah. I mean, that's always. I mean, I'm gonna be truthful. I'm gonna be truthful. And the emotions that I displayed on the show is because that is the first woman I've ever experienced love with in my entire life. The only other person that I've ever truly loved is my mother. And she can attest to this, too. I've looked my mom in my eyes and I've said, I love Sydney. Am I wrong?

[Sydney]

No, you're not wrong.

[Mikey]

So that's why those emotions of going through all that shit, all that shit, it caught me off guard. I'm like, whoa. Like, shit. Like, it really went in my life. It went.

[Host 1]

It went.

[Mikey]

Sydney, my mom. And I was just like. Like, Sydney was. She could do no wrong in my eyes, ever. She could never do any wrong. So. But that's where I messed up.

[Natalie (Host)]

So, Sydney, is there ever a chance that the two of you would get back together, or is it over?

[Sydney]

I just. Since we broke up and, you know, I'm, like, seeing him here now, he's grown so much. Like, I'm loving this new version of Mikey, but, no, I don't think so. I think we're better as friends, and I think we support each other better as friends.

[Natalie (Host)]

What was that conversation, like, four days after leaving with Xavier that you had with him? That you were gonna.

[Sydney]

With Xavier?

[Natalie (Host)]

Yeah, the conversation that you had with Xavier.

[Sydney]

Yeah, yeah, yeah. So basically, as y' all know, Xavier is a very understanding person, and he's somebody that you can talk to about anything. So leaving with Xavier and coming back and being with Mikey, when I talked to him about it, I was like, you know, like, there's a lot of feelings and emotions that I've had coming back, and it was a lot to go through that in that time frame, and I didn't know how I would feel coming home. So it's like I had to process that. I had to focus on me, and I wasn't gonna jump into another relationship. Although, like, you know, I was dating him on the island. It was. It was real. Like, I made a real connection, but I still had to deal with those feelings that I had with Mikey. And it's like, I couldn't just jump ship and be like, oh, forget about this guy, because he was my best friend.

[Nick (Host)]

When you look back on your relationship with Cindy, like, what's your biggest regret?

[Mikey]

I would say my biggest regret was not being emotionally mature within the relationship. That's my biggest regret. Because having that emotional maturity, I definitely think we would be sitting here and this would be a totally different conversation that we're having. So I say my biggest regret is being. And I was not. I was intentional at times, but I wasn't intentional all the way. And that's something that I regretted. That's something that I have to live with. And whoever I find love with. Cause trust. I'm still looking for love. Y' all see on the show, I'm a lover boy, so I'm still looking for love. And I got all this love that I want to give to somebody, so hopefully one day I can give it to him.

[Nick (Host)]

Do you think seeing Sidney with Xavier, and I think, you know, we can all give him props. He seems like a pretty great guy.

[Mikey]

Yeah, for sure.

[Nick (Host)]

Do you think that made you appreciate Sidney in ways that you hadn't appreciated about her in the past?

[Mikey]

Well, I would never give that much

[Nick (Host)]

credit, first and foremost, but let's just be honest. Let's just keep it real.

[Mikey]

Yeah, I'm being real. When it comes to the fact of, for one, had no idea fucking Xavier is. He grew up with my best friend. Had no fucking idea. That's fucking crazy.

[Kaylee]

Right?

[Mikey]

So finding that out and finding out how good of a guy he is, like, Xavier is a great guy. And finding that out and seeing. And seeing how he treated Sydney, thousand percent. Like, I appreciate him for taking care of her and showing her what she deserved, truthfully.

[Cole]

Yeah.

[Nick (Host)]

But doesn't that in any way bother you that you couldn't do that on your own?

[Mikey]

Tight. It had me tight in the villa. Oh, my gosh. I was so blown. You asked the guys, they didn't put the scene. I pushed a hole in the wall. Oh, it was bad. I punched a whole hole in the wall. Like, I was blown.

[Natalie (Host)]

Punched a hole in the wall?

[Mikey]

Yeah, over there.

[Natalie (Host)]

Who paid for that?

[Mikey]

I don't know. Shout out Netflix. What camera is it? Ah, shout out Netflix. But it was just. But those are just those emotions that showed how much of a child I was on the show. Like, it showed like I was a kid, because it didn't have to get to that point. Because if I would have stepped up in the ways that a man is supposed to step up, we wouldn't be in that position. So I'm perfectly okay with taking accountability for my actions. I did not treat you the way that you deserve to be treated. And for that, I apologize, guys, 1,000%.

[Sydney]

I appreciate it.

[Mikey]

And the fact that she found that on. On. On the island, I mean, yeah, it sucks, but people get that girl took you. Everyone in here has lost somebody before. Everyone in here has lost a partner, right or wrong. And from either they left or somebody took them. It just so happens that mine's on tv.

[Nick (Host)]

Yeah. But I think even more relatable to your point is, like, I think what's so fascinating about your relationship is that especially I think with guys, we've seen the unappreciated person finally realize or have someone show them their worth. And it's only until then that their original partner, like, oh, my gosh, wanna try to step it up, wants to step it up and, like, you know, write all the letters or the poems and. Heck, I remember being a young man and having a conversation like that, and, you know, but you're only doing this now and stuff like that. So it's a tough lesson to learn when you realize that's why you lost someone, that you still to this day, call her your best friend.

[Mikey]

Oh, for sure. Always. And that's just. But the thing about life, it's not about the destination. It's really about the journey. And Sydney taught me so much, like. And that's why I'm not bitter to her. I'm not bitter to Xavier. I'm not bitter to any of the 12 guys. But that it took me a while to get there?

[Nick (Host)]

Do you think if you wouldn't have thrown some of Sidney's choices on Temptation island in her face, that you guys still might be together today?

[Mikey]

Truthfully, I saw myself going into the right direction. I knew I was gonna get there. It's just. How much more does this beautiful girl have to drag her feet for my own insecurities and my own personal problems. Cause my personal problems should not be projected onto her. Simple. That's just not how it's gonna go. So I just. I messed that up. I did.

[Natalie (Host)]

Did you ever give her back the photo of her and Xavier that she liked? That was her favorite.

[Mikey]

Nah. So me and Jax still got the so many.

[Natalie (Host)]

What are y' all doing with them?

[Jack]

Oh, I gave them to Cheyenne.

[Mikey]

Oh, you gave it back?

[Jack]

I did.

[Mikey]

No, actually, when we got back together.

[Nick (Host)]

Oh.

[Mikey]

I had her throw all that shit away. Which is insecure as fuck. But I definitely said I found them. I was like, what the fuck? And I said, throw them away. She said, bet she threw them away.

[Natalie (Host)]

You said at the final bonfire that you felt like you made yourself smaller so that. That Mikey could be bigger. Do you agree that you felt like she did that?

[Mikey]

That's something that's been a trend in, like. Like, I've always heard that my whole entire life, it's always been, like, you always. Based upon my personality, I shine. I'm just so loud. I'm so outgoing. So it makes the people around me feel like they have to diminish themselves. And I hate that. That it's tiring, because I'm just truly just trying to be myself. And even from watching the show, it made me feel like even the world just seeing my true personality, the world is basically clowning on me for being myself. Like, everything y' all see on Temptation island, like, I'm just truly just being my authentic self. I have a huge personality for a man. I get that. That's cool. But also, I'm not about to. I'm not about to sell myself short and put down my own personality for the betterment of literally nothing. Because if you're not gonna be yourself, then why the fuck are you here?

[Natalie (Host)]

Sydney, did you feel like it was just his personality that was so big?

[Sydney]

Yeah, I would say, you know, Mikey has a big personality, and it's like, I knew that, but at the same time, if we're in a relationship, if we're partners, then, like, bring me up with you. Like, don't, like, leave me where I feel like I was. And I feel like he's very much main character, and I was just, like, sidekick. And I didn't feel like that was. That's not what I wanted in a relationship. I feel like we should be equal. And I don't feel like.

[Mikey]

But that's never what I want, you know? That's never what I wanted, though. Like, I never wanted you to feel like sidekick. I've always.

[Sydney]

No, I'm not saying you wanted me to. I'm saying that's what it was.

[Mikey]

But, you know, I've always been your biggest fan.

[Natalie (Host)]

That.

[Sydney]

Yeah, you're right.

[Mikey]

Like, I'm just, like. I'm just being honest. Like, when.

[Nick (Host)]

That.

[Mikey]

Whenever I've. Whenever you bring something up, I've always been your biggest fan. I support it. And that's why, like, hearing the things.

[Nick (Host)]

What do you mean? Can you give me, like, an example?

[Mikey]

Like, boom. She had her opening for her Business. I'm first one there. I'm in there selling candles, making sure everything's good. I'm hyping it up. I'm over here. Like, you get what I'm saying? Like, anything she needed for her new crib, I'm like, yo, I'm here. I got you. What do you need me to help you with? Are we serious?

[Sydney]

Do you all not remember the bar cart situation?

[Mikey]

That sat there for that was one thing.

[Sydney]

No, the bar cart.

[Mikey]

It took me a while to build work.

[Sydney]

I put my dresser together by myself while you sat there on the couch and watched Netflix.

[Mikey]

Are we serious?

[Sydney]

I am dead serious. You don't remember that?

[Mikey]

I don't.

[Summit]

You gotta build the stuff, Mikey.

[Sydney]

You were scrolling on TikTok watching Netflix while I'm on the floor putting together my dresser.

[Cole]

Oh, that's fucked up.

[Sydney]

And then, no, my bar cart sat at the door for months.

[Summit]

You gotta build this stuff.

[Cole]

I love building Scarlett's dresser.

[Natalie (Host)]

So it's like you watched her build the dresser?

[Sydney]

Yes, you did.

[Mikey]

I'm serious. What?

[Sydney]

Are you being really serious?

[Nick (Host)]

Are you saying she's lying?

[Mikey]

I'm never gonna call you a liar, but I'm just saying, on the side

[Sydney]

of, oh, my gosh, I've helped you with what?

[Mikey]

I've helped you.

[Sydney]

I helped Maggie. How to help, bro?

[Host 1]

You've helped her or you helped?

[Nick (Host)]

I didn't help put a screwing.

[Sydney]

I'm not gonna.

[Scarlett]

Like, that's crazy.

[Mikey]

I didn't help.

[Nick (Host)]

Well, is it multiple things?

[Sydney]

I'm sorry.

[Mikey]

No, no, please.

[Natalie (Host)]

When did the bar cart get built?

[Sydney]

Two months after the show when I had already brought it up, y'.

[Kaylee]

All.

[Sydney]

The bar cart had sat there for four months before the show. We get back from the show, he's like, I'm gonna put it together.

[Mikey]

I'm putting together.

[Sydney]

It sits there for two more months. I have a picture of it on my phone, actually, of when it happened.

[Host 1]

You know what?

[Mikey]

If I didn't build it, I apologize. But still, on the side of anything, let's just be real. Anything I've ever needed, you help me with. Anything you ever needed, I've helped you with. So I don't want to be over here. That's not what we here to do. You get what I'm saying? I've always. I've always. Come on now. You gotta give me a little credit somewhere. And they're like, I'm saying, like, I was not just a piece of shit. You get what I'm saying?

[Sydney]

I'm not calling you a piece of

[Mikey]

Shit, I understand that, but I'm just Shannon shy. Like, come on, bro. I always got you. You always had me. We good.

[Nick (Host)]

But that is interesting. Cause I've never ever, from watching the show or our time here, ever felt like Sydney ever spoke. Spoke to you about, like, you know, about. But it's been clear that Cindy seems to have a lot of respect for you and a lot of care and consideration that's even today, you know? But I think what she. It seems like, and I don't want to speak for you, but, like, she's always been trying to convey to you that you just always seem to stop short of, like, doing what you are capable of doing. And she seems to, like, know what you're capable of.

[Mikey]

That's real.

[Sydney]

It's because I've seen it. Like, even after we broke up and you were writing me letters every day, you were bringing me flowers every day, 8am sharp, every single day. It's like you're showing me you're capable of it. But why not? Why not do it in the relationship?

[Mikey]

Exactly. I truly just feel like we, as humans, we don't appreciate something until it's too late. And that's how I felt on the island too. Like, when I was. When I was watching her fall in love. Because I'm not going to lie, like, hearing her say, like, I love you, it fucked me up. I will say that. It fucked me up. And then I'm just like, damn, that. That was fucked. Like, I was. I was fucked. I was fucked. I knew it. I knew I was fucked. I said it to everyone. Then I looked at everybody in the face.

[Summit]

Well, we told you you were fucked.

[Mikey]

Yeah, everyone told me I was fucked. And all 12 girls said, yeah, you're fucked. And it was just the thing that I still stood on my tent of saying, like, if she's happy, I'm good. If she's happy, I'm good. So, I mean, it sucked, but it's life. I. I truly do wish that I appreciated Sydney more. But it's always me learning too late. So it's always me learning too late.

[Nick (Host)]

Well, you know, you're still a young man, like you said. And, you know, I will say, you know, I think we have different personalities. But what. What is. I don't mean that like, you know, it's just like, I'm not as. Honestly, I'm. I'm sometimes envious of, like, you're a kind of extroverted personality. But what I've always being good at is kind of being comfortable in my skin, and you seem comfortable in yours. But it's interesting, as you get older, you realize that that's not always an excuse. It's not to disappoint people. Or, like, sometimes it's like, you know, I don't care what other people think. Like, it's good to know that. But, like, sometimes you just have to realize if you're not going to change, you will turn some people off, and some people will choose not to fuck with you if you don't choose to adjust your behavior. And my personal. This is who I am just kind of gets. You know, it gets old.

[Mikey]

Gets old because we as relationships are supposed to be about growth. And if you're not growing within the relationship, then it's not benefiting each other. And I wasn't growing. And that's something I literally. I'm gonna be real. I would never say something like this. Like, if the person I was. I would never say something like this. But, like, truthfully, I wasn't helping you grow. I felt as if I was based upon. You gotta understand, you. You are my first real relationship. Like, my first actual one. And I'm still. I was still learning. I'm still learning. I was still learning how to love, and I was only loving you to the level that I knew possible. You get what I'm saying? So that's where I got messed up. Because. Just because I thought I was loving you to this high degree based upon what I thought real love was, that doesn't mean that's what you thought love was, and that's disrespectful to you.

[Natalie (Host)]

So, yeah, Sydney, watching it back, were you. Or I guess while you were there, were you shocked that he resisted temptation, or was what you saw kind of what you expected out of him?

[Sydney]

No, I genuinely was shocked that he resisted temptation. And, you know, just watching it back, it was like seeing that, like, at the beginning, he was making, like, slick comments, flirting with the girls, and that's what ultimately turned me off. And I was like, oh, I'm done. I'm leaving. Like, I'm done with this relationship. But watching him see me fall for Xavier and what that did to him, I think that just really showed, you know, how much he felt on himself to take a step back, look at what was going on around him, and be like, okay, this is how I should handle this moving forward.

[Natalie (Host)]

Mikey, you saying you were gonna shoot your shot with India, was that kind of a reactive.

[Mikey]

No. Can I just be truthfully honest with you?

[Natalie (Host)]

Please?

[Mikey]

There's just no way I Walk into a confessional, just sit my ass down, look in the camera and say, shit, I need to be selfish. I need to shoot my shot with India. Obviously, somebody asked me a damn question. If this happens, what will you do? Well, shit, I guess I gotta be selfish, and you gotta shoot your shot with India. But that's just some shit where it's just like, you get fucking clipped. I'm the clip master. I'm. Be real. I get clipped because I just be talking, and I always get clipped too damn much. I always get clipped. All the guys would be like, mikey, stop talking, because you're going to get clicked. And I'm like. I'm like, no, I'm not going to get clipped. I'm fucking good. Then I say something. I'm like, oh, I'm fucking clipped. I got clipped. That's all it was. I got clipped.

[Nick (Host)]

But nevertheless, you still admitted to, like, thinking it was okay to flirt.

[Mikey]

Yeah, because we came into it with the boundaries of flirting. You guys agreed that you could.

[Sydney]

We agreed we would go on dates. I don't know why you keep saying that. We agreed that we could flirt. We never said that. We said we were going to. We knew we had to go on dates. You can go back and watch the show.

[Mikey]

I understand.

[Sydney]

I'm serious.

[Mikey]

I understand.

[Natalie (Host)]

Fans noticed that when y' all separated at the beginning of the show, y' all did not kiss. Was there a reason for that, or was it.

[Sydney]

We did kiss. It wasn't included, and I didn't.

[Mikey]

We did a whole handshake and everything.

[Host 1]

We got a whole hand.

[Mikey]

We did a whole handshake, little kiss. We did everything.

[Sydney]

We just did. Yeah. I don't know why they didn't. Because I did see that clip where they were like, they look.

[Mikey]

Yeah, yeah. And my biggest thing is, like, everyone thought me and Sydney weren't, like, a real relationship. That's some fucking bullshit. Because, motherfucker, I, I. This is my first. This is my first real, actual girlfriend ever.

[Natalie (Host)]

Is anyone on TikTok gonna come out and be like, I was actually his first girl?

[Mikey]

Some. I mean, if she.

[Sydney]

She would.

[Mikey]

If she probably would from. From college, but I don't count that. Cause I. Cause I cheated on her. I cheated on the girl from college, like, all the time. And so I don't count that as. I don't count that as real.

[Kaylee]

That's still a relationship.

[Nick (Host)]

I don't even think Jack would say that I cheated.

[Mikey]

I really feel like. I truly feel like if you don't. If you can't be A committed individual within the relationship. Then you didn't. Then you did not deserve that relationship. So you can't even claim that relationship.

[Natalie (Host)]

But she would claim that relationship.

[Mikey]

I doubt she would claim me.

[Summit]

It's just a bad relationship.

[Mikey]

It was a bad relationship. Yeah, that's better. A bad relationship. I know. She wouldn't claim me, though. Lord have mercy.

[Natalie (Host)]

Was watching him say that he could fall in love. Was that the moment of, like, no return for you?

[Sydney]

Yeah, that was like. When I was like, no way. It's been three days. And he just said I could around and fall for one of you.

[Mikey]

I got clipped.

[Sydney]

What? I'm like, how does that. Like, I'm like, we just got here.

[Nick (Host)]

How do you remember saying it, bro?

[Mikey]

Jack. Jack was there. He was behind the bushes.

[Natalie (Host)]

Behind the bushes, behind the bushes. It was the three girls.

[Mikey]

No, I'm saying I was by the. But I'm talking about a roundabout. Do you know how we walk up to the thing? I walk down. Jack was over there. I literally said, they're gonna fuck around and tell and say. And get me clipped up saying, da, da, da, da, da, boom. As soon as I said it, I said, clipped. Jack screamed out clipped, and I was fucking clipped.

[Natalie (Host)]

Seems like y' all were very hyper aware of the cameras and, like, what would be played back at bonfires. Does that change some of Yalls behavior a little bit?

[Jack]

No, once. No, I mean, once you're in there,

[Mikey]

you forget about it.

[Jack]

You forget about it. It just becomes real life. It was like two days of, like,

[Cole]

weird saying that maybe being somewhat. But then it was like, yeah, kind of goes in one ear, out the other.

[Summit]

Yeah.

[Nick (Host)]

Mikey, would it be fair to say that you are like a. You like being liked and you. You have a hard time hearing when people don't like you?

[Mikey]

I would say 1000%. The version that I was, when I was in there, very much people pleaser, all of that. But I had learned that that's an insecurity through, like, therapy. I was just like, it doesn't matter what people think. As long as I'm happy with myself, that's all that matters.

[Nick (Host)]

Do you think old Mikey, the people pleaser, had a bad habit of maybe crossing some boundaries with women? While maybe your intention wasn't to cheat or hurt your partner, that it maybe would come across as inappropriate to your girlfriend and she. Let's say, if she was watching you interact with other women.

[Mikey]

Thousand percent.

[Nick (Host)]

Is that something that you've, like, changed about yourself?

[Mikey]

Yeah, that's something that I like. I learned that My biggest thing was I made an excuse for my personality of. To be a flirt. Like, I. I was always saying, like, well, that's just who I am. That's just who I am. Da, da, da. No, you're dead wrong, my guy. Like the fact that you feel like you can flirt and you can be this extroverted person, and you think that flirting within that makes it okay. No, it's not. It's not, right? So that's something I really worked on. On mean what I say. Always, always mean what you say. And walk with intention in everything that I do.

[Nick (Host)]

I'm gonna ask you a question. I want you to be real with me and not just, like, you know, protect your ego. But if. If I know. We already asked Cindy the question and we heard her answer. Nevertheless, if Sydney were to give you another chance, would you take her up on that? Or maybe a better question is, is there any part of you that has just a little bit of hope that you two can have another shot?

[Mikey]

Truthfully, I. It wouldn't be the smart thing to do, and it would be the. It would be. It wouldn't be the right thing to do because she gave me so many chances, and it would be selfish of me to try to take another chance on someone.

[Nick (Host)]

What if she begged you?

[Mikey]

Cindy would never do that. First and foremost. She would never. She would never do that. Cause I'm not gonna lie. I'm not gonna lie. Y' all think my pride is bad. Her pride is. Her pride is out of this world. But it's just on the side of. Just like I was irresponsible with the relationship, and I don't. I. I truly feel like I don't deserve another chance. I truly just don't deserve. I just don't deserve that from her. She deserves everything, mind you. I'm not saying that I'm a piece of shit. Trust. I'm. That I'm that guy. But it's just. It's. Yeah, it's just. It's just the side of. I understand that I messed up, and you don't deserve that. And no matter what, I truly feel like she would still be holding onto that version of Mikey that she knew since September 3, 2021. You know what I'm saying?

[Nick (Host)]

Do you still have romantic love for Sydney?

[Sydney]

Oh, yeah.

[Mikey]

I love her. Look, she fine as hell. Look at her fine ass. How you doing? I ain't seen her in months. I ain't seen her in months. Girl, you look good. You look good. You look healthy.

[Natalie (Host)]

So these past four Months. Have you been back in contact with Xavier? Are you, like, fully cut off, the two of them? Where are things?

[Sydney]

So I have been back in communication with Xavier. I did reach out to him, and I was like, hey, I know I'm probably the last person you. You want to talk to, but would you be open to a conversation? And grabbing coffee? So he was like, yes, of course. And we went. We grabbed coffee. We talked about everything. I told him, you know, what happened when I got back, everything that me and Mikey went through and where I was. And I told him, like, you know, like, I'm really working on myself and trying to process everything that happened in that relationship, process my feelings. And he was very, like, understanding and still very caring, which is, like, hard for me to believe that somebody could, you know, go through that experience with me, come out the villa, and I'm like, well, I'm gonna go back to my ex, who you helped me get through that relationship on the show. So it was just crazy for him to be open to the opportunity of, like, seeing where it could go again.

[Nick (Host)]

Did he ever throw it in your face that you went back to Mikey?

[Sydney]

No, he didn't.

[Nick (Host)]

What did that mean to you?

[Sydney]

It meant a lot, because that's what you expect. You expect him to be like, well, you know, throw it in my face. Be like, I'm gonna make you work for it? No, like, that's not who he is at all. And that's something that I really appreciate about him.

[Nick (Host)]

Okay, well, we do have a video. We wanted to maybe consider bringing some of the tempters and temptresses here, but out of respect for everyone here, we obviously did not do that. But since I think so many people fell in love with you and Xavier and watching you, he wanted to send you a message, knowing that maybe today would be a tough day. And so we wanted to play that for you.

[Sydney]

Okay.

[Nick (Host)]

It's a nice, very sweet message. Mikey. You.

[Mikey]

You.

[Nick (Host)]

I don't. I just want to be respectful. You like, you cool, you know? Okay. Okay.

[Natalie (Host)]

On part two of the Temptation island season two reunion, he knew he did

[Cheyenne]

not want to look like a hypocrite. Deep down, you know, that hurt.

[Jack]

You're good.

[Cheyenne]

No, I'm speaking the truth. I'm speaking the truth.

[Mikey]

You're good, bro. You're good. You're good.

[Summit]

You're good.

[Mikey]

Let it out.

[Natalie (Host)]

What are you feeling right now, Jack?

[Scarlett]

I had been hurt over, over and over with lies.

[Cole]

And I did get mad at the end. They didn't really show it, but I feel like I was frustrated because I cared though, because I love this woman, you know, and.

[Nick (Host)]

But what are these little lies?

[Natalie (Host)]

We're lost. It feels like we're going round in circles. I'm gonna ask that man for directions. Hi there. We're trying to get the to the state fairgrounds.

[T-Mobile Representative]

Well, you're going to take a left at the old oak tree at this here road.

[Mikey]

Nah, I'm just kidding.

[T-Mobile Representative]

Let me get my phone out.

[Natalie (Host)]

How is their signal out here?

[T-Mobile Representative]

T Mobile and US Cellular are coming together so the network out here is huge. We get the same great signal as the city. Saving a boatload with benefits. And there's a five year price guarantee too. Okay, here's the turn.

[Natalie (Host)]

Actually, can you pull up the way to a T Mobile store?

[T-Mobile Representative]

America's best network just got bigger. Switch to T Mobile today and get built in benefits the other guys leave out. Plus our five year price guarantee. And now T Mobile is available at US Cellular stores in hermiston Best mobile network based on analysis by Ooklo Speed test intelligence data second half of 2025 bigger network. The combination of T Mobile's and US Cellular's network footprints will enhance the T Mobile network's coverage price guarantee on talk text and data exclusions like taxes and fees applied. See t mobile.com for details.

[Cantu Representative]

Cantu heard you loud and clear with their new Ultra Moisture collection. Powered by Botano oil and Jamaican Black castor oil, this new lineup collection is clinically proven to deliver non stop moisture for up to five days. Five whole days. The shampoo gently cleanses without stripping and the leave in and stylers keep curls soft, defined and nourished long after wash day. Plus it's free of sulfates, parabens, silicones and mineral oils. If your curls are have been craving real moisture, this is it. So if your hair's curls have been thirsty, go ahead and try the new Cantu Ultra Moisture collection. Your curls will thank you. Available now at Walmart.