E973 Ask Nick - My Therapist Is Bestie’s Toxic Ex

Summary

The Viall Files - Episode E973 Summary: Ask Nick - My Therapist Is Bestie’s Toxic Ex

Release Date: July 28, 2025

---

Introduction

In Episode E973 of The Viall Files, host Nick Viall, alongside co-hosts Natalie Joy and the Household, delves into complex relationship issues brought forth by listeners. This episode features two in-depth call-ins, addressing challenges related to toxic relationships and the intertwining of personal and professional boundaries.

---

Caller 1: Grace's Dilemma with Her Friend's Toxic Ex-Therapist

Timestamp: 02:05 - 35:24

Background:

Grace, a 35-year-old woman, reaches out seeking advice about her best friend's toxic ex-husband, who was also her therapist. The situation is complicated by ongoing legal and emotional struggles surrounding a child from their tumultuous relationship.

Key Points Discussed:

1. Toxic Relationship History:

   • Grace explains that her friend's ex entered a highly toxic relationship, which culminated in an unwanted pregnancy after an ill-planned reconciliation attempt.
   • The ex is now emotionally triggered, making civil interactions impossible, and has become uninvolved in the child's life.

2. Current Support Dynamics:

   • Grace and her husband are among the few pushing the ex to take responsibility and be involved as a father.
   • Other friends and the ex’s family are either indifferent or unaware of the significance of his involvement.

3. Legal and Emotional Barriers:

   • The ex faces significant legal hurdles in obtaining custody due to the mother’s instability and his strained relationship with her.
   • Grace highlights the immediate emotional toll on both her and her husband, who are new parents themselves.

Notable Quotes:

• Grace (02:18):

  "Our friend was in a very toxic relationship and he finally broke up with her. It dragged on for an unnecessary amount of time."

• Nick (06:04):

  "It's a tough situation that you just described... I don't think this is a situation where you cut off your friend."

Advice from Nick:

1. Empathy and Understanding:

   • Acknowledge the complexity of the situation and the emotional bond the ex might still have.
   • Encourage Grace to continue supporting her friend without enabling negative behavior.

2. Encouraging Professional Help:

   • Suggest that the ex seek a new therapist if current therapy isn’t effective.
   • Emphasize the importance of addressing underlying emotional issues to improve his involvement as a father.

3. Positive Reinforcement:

   • Advise Grace to focus on the long-term benefits of her friend being present in his child's life.
   • Recommend framing conversations around the positive impact of fatherhood rather than focusing solely on past shortcomings.

4. Balancing Support and Boundaries:

   • Counsel Grace to maintain her support while setting healthy boundaries to prevent emotional burnout.
   • Highlight the importance of collective support from other friends to alleviate the pressure solely on her and her husband.

Conclusion of Grace's Segment:

Grace expresses gratitude for Nick's advice and commits to involving her husband more actively in encouraging their friend. She plans to shift the conversation towards empowering her friend to take positive steps in his parenting journey.

---

Caller 2: Lindsay's Conundrum - Should She Tell Her Friend Her Ex Was Her Therapist?

Timestamp: 39:18 - 78:16

Background:

Lindsay, a 28-year-old master's student in counseling, seeks guidance on whether to disclose to her friend, Sarah, that her ex-husband was her therapist. This revelation stems from a developing friendship that began through shared interests in reality TV.

Key Points Discussed:

1. Nature of the Relationship:

   • Lindsay and Sarah became close over three weeks, bonding through watching Bachelor in Paradise.
   • Lindsay had been referred to Sarah's husband as a therapist but discontinued therapy after six months.

2. Complicated Dynamics:

   • Lindsay discovers that her ex-husband, Joe, has borderline personality disorder and was emotionally abusive.
   • She wrestles with the ethical implications of withholding this information from Sarah, fearing it could jeopardize their budding friendship.

3. Fear of Consequences:

   • Lindsay is concerned that not disclosing might lead to trust issues or awkwardness if Sarah learns about her through other means.
   • She feels conflicted between maintaining honesty and preserving the friendship.

Notable Quotes:

• Lindsay (39:18):

  "Should I tell my friend that her soon to be ex husband used to be my therapist?"

• Nick (40:33):

  "You should have told her. 100%."

Advice from Nick:

1. Prioritize Honesty:

   • Encourage Lindsay to disclose the information promptly to maintain integrity in the friendship.
   • Emphasize that transparency builds trust, even if the initial conversation is uncomfortable.

2. Approach with Vulnerability:

   • Suggest approaching Sarah in a private setting, such as over coffee, to discuss the matter openly.
   • Recommend expressing regret for the delay and explaining her reasons without making excuses.

3. Prepare for Various Reactions:

   • Advise Lindsay to be ready for a range of emotions from Sarah, including surprise, hurt, or understanding.
   • Highlight the importance of respecting Sarah’s feelings and giving her space if needed.

4. Focus on Building Trust:

   • Stress that this disclosure, while difficult, can strengthen the friendship by establishing a foundation of honesty.
   • Encourage Lindsay to continue fostering trust through consistent and open communication.

Conclusion of Lindsay's Segment:

Lindsay feels reassured by Nick's guidance and decides to approach Sarah with honesty and vulnerability. She acknowledges the importance of resolving the ethical dilemma to nurture a meaningful and trustworthy friendship.

---

Wrapping Up

In this episode, Nick Viall provides compassionate and practical advice to listeners facing intricate relationship challenges. By addressing Grace's concerns about her friend's toxic ex-therapist and Lindsay's ethical dilemma regarding disclosure to a new friend, the episode underscores the significance of empathy, honesty, and strategic support in maintaining and nurturing healthy relationships.

Listeners are encouraged to approach difficult conversations with transparency and to balance support with personal boundaries, ensuring that relationships remain authentic and resilient.

---

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• Grace (04:58):

  "We just really aren't sure how to proceed because we seem to be one of his only friends expressing how important it is."

• Nick (17:25):

  "He needs to take that ownership. He needs to accept that..."

• Lindsay (61:28):

  "I feel like I'm trying to analyze things to get to the bottom of it..."

• Nick (73:49):

  "You have to make him feel empowered. You have to make him feel like this is the right thing to do."

---

This comprehensive summary captures the essence of Episode E973, providing an insightful overview for those who haven't tuned in while highlighting the critical advice and emotional nuances discussed by Nick and the callers.

Transcript

[Nick]

Everyone's loving family Freedom from T Mobile. We'll pay off four phones up to $3200 and give you four free phones all on America's largest 5G network. Visit your local T Mobile location or learn more@t mobile.com FamilyFreedom up to $800 per line via virtual prepaid card typically takes 15 days. Free phones via 24 monthly bill credits with finance agreement eg Apple iPhone16128GB8999 Eligible trade in eg iPhone11 Pro for well qualified credits end and balance due if you pay off early or cancel contact T Mobile. Alright, quick break. Knock knock. Who's there? Amazon Music Amazon Music who? Amazon Music where prime members can listen to top comedy podcasts Ad free. No awkward interruptions, just non stop laughs from your favorite shows. It's free, it's funny and hey, it's better than my knock knock jokes. Download the Amazon Music app and let the good times roll. Or go to Amazon.com adfreecomedy that's Amazon.com adfreecomediDy to catch up on the latest episodes or without the ads. This episode is sponsored by Mint Mobile and we have an especially exciting announcement. We want to hear your scorching hot reality TV takes. That's why we have partnered with Mint Mobile to open a hot take hotline where you can leave us a voicemail message and give us your reality TV takes. Give us your hot takes, thoughts and theories and we'll read and react to the best ones on an upcoming reality recap episode. All you have to do is call 1-855-MINT Talk. That's 1855 M I N T TLK. Or if you prefer the numbers that's 855-646-8855 and leave us a voicemail again. Just call 1-855-MINT TLK or 855-646-8855, and leave us a message. This summer, don't get burned by your old wireless bill. Make the switch to mint mobile. Get three months of unlimited premium wireless service for 15 bucks a month at mintmobile.comv I l l that's mint mobile.comv I l l upfront payment of $45 required equivalent to $15 a month unlimited time. New customer offer for first three months only. Speeds may slow above 35 gigabytes on unlimited plans, taxes and fees extra. C Mint Mobile for details.

[Sadie]

You're crazy.

[Nick]

How's it going?

[Grace]

Hey Nick, My Name's Sadie, I'm 35 and my husband and I's best friend is a deadbeat dad and we're not sure where to go from here.

[Nick]

Is he, I mean, not that it really matters. Are you friends with him through like your husband? Is it like a mutual college friend that you're both friends with?

[Grace]

Yes, I met him through my husband. Him and I have since become very close. We, you know, over the years through all of his relationships experiences. I'm kind of his go to for advice. Like he just called me this morning, we talked for an hour about his current relationship. But he, if, if you like, I can go ahead and give you some background on the, the context of why he is a dad is really important. So I can definitely jump into that. So essentially our friend was in a very toxic relationship and he finally broke up with her. It dragged on for an unnecessary amount of time. Then she ended up showing back up at his house a couple days later. They ended up sleeping together and she got pregnant. Come to find out, she actually had planned it as much as you can plan that as like a last ditch effort to save their relationship. Obviously that didn't go over well with him and he became very, very highly triggered by her to the point where he can't have any civil interactions with her and is completely uninvolved in the child's life. As of now, my husband and I are parents. We have little kids ourselves. So we've been trying really hard to steer him towards being involved and to make progress in that regard because we know how important it is and she's not a particularly stable person and he historically has been. So we knew how important it was for the child to have that stability in their life. And not many of our other friends have kids and his family's not pushing him to be involved at all. So we just really aren't sure where to go from here. We seem to be one of his only friends expressing how important it is to be involved. And we, many of our friends have just kind of proceeded with him as of as if like nothing has changed, the child doesn't exist and we're the only ones like pushing him towards it. So it's kind of a balance of do we continue the relationship as is and just try to make small, small steps with him or do we, you know, cut off the relationship? We just aren't sure how to proceed because we seem to be the only ones that are pushing him in that direction and you know, the only ones that are giving him guidance to become involved with the child.

[Nick]

It's a tough situation that you Just described while you're, you know, while you were saying it. I'm trying to imagine, like, what would do if I were in your situation or how I would feel about a friend who is in your friend's situation. And like you as a relatively new parent and a new dad, I, I am more judgmental and critical of other parents. You know, I think, you know, online everyone is, but, like, not in the way that, like, listen, I think just being there matters the most, which, you know, obviously I'm sure you understand in terms of, like, every. I think every parent has the right to parent their child how they want, obviously within reason of their kids being safe and yada, yada, yada. But this is. It's definitely not the same as, you know, you were like our friends, a deadbeat dad, and he, you know, got divorced, he left his wife or his wife left him, and now he's just decided to, like, pretend he's not a dad anymore. Um, it's definitely different than that.

[Grace]

And he does express. He does express a lot of interest in wanting to be a dad. Like, he. He wants to have children. He loves our kids. He's highly involved in their lives. He's around a lot. He is consistently asking questions about, like, our baby, how to raise a baby, and he does want that.

[Nick]

How old is this kid?

[Grace]

Her? Less than a year old. He's like eight or nine months at this point. And he's never met him, never been. There's been no involvement up until this point, mostly. And up until she actually had the child, he expressed a lot of interest around wanting to be involved and even discussed having, like, sole custody himself because she is a very mentally unstable person. And that is, like, could be what's best for the child long term. But in where we live, it's very hard for him to get that unless he has a mountain of evidence. And even on the other side of that, up until this point, he doesn't really have many rights until the child reaches a certain age. And then on top of that, the mother is making it very difficult. So he does have a lot of barriers. But at the end of the day, my husband and I see it as. It doesn't matter how many barriers there are. Like, you could put a mountain in front of you. This is your child. Like, you have to prioritize that, and that's, you know, that's what's going to be important. And no matter how many, you know, things she puts in front of you, how difficult she makes it, like, you have to make that the focus. And he seems to be deterred by any small thing that she does or piece of bad news he gets from a lawyer.

[Nick]

What was the last con. You said you talked to him this morning for over an hour. What do you guys, what did you guys talk about?

[Grace]

So that's actually about his. So he has a new girlfriend and that was, that was a situation with his current girlfriend and he has since started a new relationship. We're very supportive of that relationship. I still think he has, you know, a lot of work to do personally. The relationship he's in now seems to be very healthy and she is, she is supportive of him being involved and the situation. So that is helpful. But they haven't made much progress. Not much. They have made zero progress other than having the conversation of like, I am supportive.

[Nick]

How old is he?

[Grace]

He's my age. Around 35.

[Nick]

Yeah. Okay, why did you guys talk about for an hour and a half if everything in this current relationship is solid?

[Grace]

She's a little bit younger than him and it's just around her wanting.

[Nick]

He.

[Grace]

At the end of the day, he's pretty insecure and she is like a decade younger than him. So she's just in a little bit of a different phase of life socially and is like wanting to go out a lot. And he is not in that phase of life. He wants to just stay in and it's just causing a bit of a rift for them and he's just like not understanding why that's such a big of a priority for her. Because they're in. It's just coming to. Their age gap is kind of coming to a head and they're at a crossroads really. Like, she says she wants to settle down and she says he's a priority. But is it. I think it's her actions are at the point where it's in. Are they in line with what she's saying? Like, is she actually ready to settle down or is she just thinks she wants to settle down and.

[Nick]

Well, I mean, a lot of, a lot of 25 year olds want to settle down someday. That last part, they don't often say the someday. Especially if they're dating someone older. Yeah. Or just don't communicate that. But for a 25 year old. Yeah. They'd be like, yeah, I want to settle down. 27, 28. You know, it's like, that sounds cool. That gives me a little bit of time. Even though time goes fast. And it's like, well, what is, you know, you know, someone who has a younger wife. Yeah. Where they are matters in their life. And if he feels like they want different things in different stages of their life, it doesn't matter if they both want to eventually settle down and have kids at the same time. You know, he doesn't want to go out all the time and she does. That's just a huge compatibility problem.

[Grace]

Yes, yes, we've had, we had that conversation.

[Nick]

Anyway, not why he called. What, what's his financial situation? Just out of curiosity.

[Grace]

He's extremely stable. He does very, very well. He owns his home, makes great money, is very capable. And the mom of the child is not in that current situation.

[Nick]

I mean, I'm not, I'm assuming he's spoken with lawyers to understand his situation and rights and things like that.

[Grace]

Yes, he has. He did. So he was of the mentality that he was going to be involved as much as he possibly could before the child was born. And then he had a conversation with a lawyer that was pretty disheartening to him. And essentially he can't have much custody or any custody until the child reaches a certain age. They favors the mother until they're, you know, one or two years old. So he essentially was of the mindset of, well, I can't do anything until the child reaches this age. And I'm at her mercy. Like at the most he could have scheduled visitation. And he is like so beyond triggered by her that he has kind of just let that go because he can't see past. He's not a parent, so he doesn't. He know I have the experience to know, like, well, you just have to get past that because the relationship with the child is so amazing that, you know, any roadblock that's put in your way, you know, you just need to get over. But he obviously hasn't had that experience. He doesn't see that like, end goal. And he's very blocked by his relationship with her and how unhealthy it is and how triggered they are by each other. So he just hasn't had, he hasn't had any involvement up until this point because he can't get past that. And she continues to put barriers in the way. And at the beginning I think she used it as a last ditch effort to save their relationship. But now that she is a mom, I mean, I'm speaking for her and what I interpret based on their limited interactions is that now she sees it as, she doesn't want him involved at all because now she just wants the child to herself because he's like a stranger to her at this Point. So she's making it very difficult for him to have involvement. But at the same time, he's. He's not really trying.

[Nick]

So you're saying that based off the state that you're in or wherever you're located, that, like, the parenting laws are such that because they're not married and they have a kid together, like, that he doesn't have. He has to go to court to get her to agree to scheduled visits because, like, I don't know what.

[Grace]

Yes, yes, they have to. At the most, I think he can have, you know, a handful of hours, like, maybe 10 hours a week of visitation with the child. I'm not sure if she needs to be there or not. But regardless, he, like, can't have the child come stay at his house. It's very limited in what he can do. But I would imagine. I mean, I'm not a lawyer, and I've never had any experience with this kind of situation, but I would imagine in order for them to be any kind of custody, when it comes to the point where he's able to have custody, there has to be some kind of experience with the child prior. But he. He has not had any.

[Nick]

Yeah.

[Grace]

So.

[Nick]

All right, well, it's a tough, tough situation. I already said that. I feel like the. I don't think this is a situation where you cut off your friend. You kind of floated that out there, you know.

[Grace]

No, I don't think cut off. I don't think cut off our friend. And, like, we love him so much. That's not what we want. It's more. We don't want to make it seem like we're okay with how things are going and be, like, complacent and him not being involved in the child's life, having kids. And, you know, we just had a baby ourselves when this happened. The kids are only a couple months apart, so it's very fresh and emotional for us as well.

[Nick]

Totally.

[Grace]

But we just aren't sure how to proceed because we seem to be the only ones really pushing him in that direction. He's not getting that from his family. Our other friends don't have children, so. So they can't really understand either. And 1. I am the person that he goes to for a lot of advice, and I. He has kind of pulled back because I think he knows where I stand, and it's in. Not in line with what he's currently doing, so he doesn't. He brings up his current relationship a lot, but not his. The. The child a lot. So we just don't aren't sure how to, how to go from here, how to encourage him to get involved, how patient we should be with it or how pushy we should be with it, considering we're the only ones that really feel this way. Our friends actually do, but they're not vocal about it.

[Nick]

What have you said to him?

[Grace]

So it's been kind of confusing because up until this, up until the child was born, up until he had that conversation with the initial lawyer, he was pretty, you know, sure that he was going to be involved. And then he had that conversation, he was really deterred. And it kind of, it was kind of like he, he lost steam. So then our conversations went more like. And then when the child actually got here, he. And it became more real. It's like he, he pulled back and you know, I would consistently ask him about, like, hey. Cause he was making like pretty small steps until earlier this year, and then it kind of came to a halt. And now he's at a point where he has to make a decision. He has to establish paternity, and he hasn't done that yet. And she won't do it volunt. So he has to sue her for paternity and he hasn't done that yet. And we've been lingering in that step for a long time. So more, you know, a few months ago, we had like a pretty good heart to heart with him where we're like, hey, like, you can't be a deadbeat dad. Like, it's not about, at the end of the day, it's not about your, you and her relationship. Like, you made a decision, she made a decision, and this child is paying the price for it. Like, you need to be focusing on that child. And he completely agrees, but he again, is so triggered by her. And we've had conversations around therapy and he is in therapy and has been for a really long time. But to me, his therapist is not super effective at this point anymore. And yeah, they, they aren't doing the hard work. Like, they're not having the conversations that they should be having. And I'm like, you should be coming out of therapy, like, feeling like you've accomplished something. Like, oh, that was really hard. We really dug deep there. And he never. It's more of just like someone validating his feelings. So I've encouraged him to get another therapist because he has so much to work through and they're not working through it.

[Nick]

Yeah, I mean, there's a lot of not, you know, great therapists out there. If he were my friend Right. I would do some version of what you're already doing, but it's more about trying to paint a picture about the long game. Right. You know, right. Now, you. You. You've said multiple times he's triggered by her. He's triggered by her. I have no doubt, and I can completely empathize with why. But there is a part which I'm sure you've kind of alluded to. You know, he's an adult man who made an adult choice, you know, and she came over, they had unprotected sex. You can't be like, oh, she's crazy. She's crazy, she's crazy, she's crazy, she's crazy. Oh, she's a psycho. She's a psycho. And then he invites her over or she shows up or whatever. They have unprotected sex.

[Grace]

She broke in. Yeah, she broke in, but he still made that decision. But I'm like, yeah, that's a whole other.

[Nick]

I mean, like, broke in either way. Yeah. Then he came and, you know, like, he. It's.

[Grace]

He's got a shocking.

[Nick]

So whatever. It just. He needs to take that ownership. He needs to accept that right now. He. Because he can easily be like, she broke in. She's crazy. She's all this. It's just so easy to paint her. And she is, you know, in some version of the. Is the bad guy to him. And she is going to make his life probably difficult, but he will be a happier person and go further in life in general by just, like, owning what he did wrong and how he can improve his situation. Yeah.

[Grace]

He's very much so in the victim mindset.

[Nick]

Yeah. So, you know, that's step one, and then step two is. Yeah. Just painting this picture of just like. Like, this could be as difficult as it is one of your best moments in your life. You know, very few opportunities in our lives. Do we get to be someone's heroes? Uh, do we get, you know, in parenting in general. I think, as you obviously, I'm sure, feel recently, you know, you just had another baby, you have young kids, You're. You guys are relatively new parents. Yeah. Like, most of us live these very charmed, privileged, whatever, like, you know, mundane lives and whatever. And the most meaningful thing we can do is be parents. Right. And then now he, you know, he doesn't have an ideal situation, but he has a chance to be this kid's hero, you know, and he has to think about the long game, and he has to think about the impact he can have on this child's life for years to come, you know, as a 35 year old man. And he's got to want to have to have that fight. And thank God he's in a, he's a successful man who has money and can make these fights and yeah, it might cost him in ways, but like again, like you. So you just got to paint that picture of it's, it's an opportunity for him. You know, you're not going to get very far by criticizing him and putting him down and calling him a deadbeat. It's more about like you have a chance here to do something that will make you really proud of yourself. And if you don't follow up with this decision, this is also something that you, you're. It's going to have years of regret. I mean just, there's just very few parents out there who, for whatever reason, you know, they all have the reasons in the present of why they just weren't as present of parents or why they weren't the type of parents they thought they would be when they thought about being parents. And this is something that could haunt you, you know, and it's like he's.

[Grace]

Looking for, I think it does.

[Nick]

He's looking for meaning. He's looking for purpose. And now he's like investing this time in this younger woman. And again, no criticism for me, but like, it's also someone who's like, he's talking to his friend for an hour and a half about a girl he just started dating. You don't do that unless there's some serious relationship problems. Unless you're, you know, and he's not even willing to see that this is emotional energy that he's wasting on someone who still wants to like pop bottles. And he's saying to himself, well, I don't get why she wants to do that. Well, who gives a shit why she wants to do that? She wants to do that. Like, I mean, I don't know, like maybe she had a different childhood than him, you know, I don't know, maybe she was in an isolated family where she didn't get to go out as much. I don't know. Part of the reason why Natalie and I work as well as we do is we had very different childhoods. You know, I got a. My parents were very strict. I didn't get to do much, you know, like in my team. I mean I had a great childhood, but you know what I'm saying, I wasn't just. Natalie was just living by herself at 17 in New York. You know, she grew up really, you know, that allowed us, when we met, for her to, like, actually want to do the same things that I was looking to do in the time in which we were together. It wasn't like, I want to settle down someday, you know, and things like that. So he doesn't want to see that right now. And honestly, there's a part like, this is drama that he can preoccupy himself with. So there's that. But I get as far as getting through to him. I really think you have to be patient. You really do. Don't be the only. You know, you said you're the only people who really feel this way. Well, you don't want to be the only people who are making him feel like a piece of. Because.

[Grace]

No. And we. We aren't. We definitely aren't. Like, we're super supportive. The conversations we've had with him are very positive over. Like, I never have said, like, you are a deadbeat. I'm like, you can't be uninvolved in this child's life. Like, you can't not be a dad when you have this opportunity to be a dad.

[Nick]

So I think you just change your messaging into what he can't do, because then it's just like, well, I mean, I can, you know.

[Grace]

Yeah. Yeah, he solidly has that option.

[Nick]

You don't want to be this, like. Like, I want you to think about 10 years from now, and, like, this is going to weigh on you. And, yes, this is a shitty situation, but, like, you. You just have to own the role you played. And now, like, this. This can't. This can be the best thing that ever happened to you. It really can. Because, like, you have a child, and it's going to be difficult, but if. If this woman is as crazy as he thinks, and, like, this kid needs someone, and he has to see it that way, but you're going to have to be patient with him, and it's a tough situation he's in, you know, and he's going to need people like you to believe in him that he can be a good father, because he's not getting that from anyone else, and he does.

[Grace]

So what's frustrating is that we have these conversations over and over, and I know. I can see that he wants it, but he just, like, can't get over the barriers of.

[Lindsay]

Of her.

[Grace]

And it's.

[Nick]

Yeah.

[Grace]

I mean, I've literally, like, we've had this. I can't even tell you how many hundreds of hours of conversations we've had about the situation. It's just kind of getting him over that hump. I think I know how to get him there.

[Nick]

Does your husband talk to him much about this stuff? Because I really think, like, man to man, he needs a little bit of, like, you know, he needs to get kind of called out and get a little pep talk about, like, hey, man to man, you need to step up and be someone I know you're capable of being because, like, you're better than this. And a little, like, you need to take care of your people. You need to take care of your family. This kid is your family. Do not abandon your family. And, like, adversity comes in all different forms. Right now you and your husband have this sounds like great nucleus. I don't, you know, listen, I'm not trying. Like, adversity comes to all of us, right? And you're, you know, and your husband has to paint this picture. Like, listen, this is how adversity is coming to your doorstep, but you still have to show up. And adversity is going to come to your guys's doorstep. I don't know in what way, but then you guys are going to have to step up and show up, you know, and that's. That's what being, you know, a parent, an adult, you know, a good, you know, and. And. And he just needs you two to believe in him. But I really think some of this will be more impactful coming from your husband, especially when it comes to, like, you need to step up for your family.

[Grace]

Yeah, I think that is a good idea, because I do think a lot of the advice he's getting from his family side is from his sister and mom. And I'm like the third person that he goes to, mostly his sister and I, which, up until the child was born, we were very much on the same page. And then I don't know what happened, but she kind of split and went the other direction, which is surprising.

[Nick]

It's not. Listen, it's one of those things where, like. Yeah, I mean, even. I'm sure people listening might be able to say, you know, it's a messy situation. There's so many nightmare stories when it comes to custody battles. And if this, you know, like, you know. Yeah, I. I think so. There's just. They're just operating out of fear, you know what I'm saying? You know, she's is an unpredictable person who has an immense amount of control and power in this situation. And that's scary when. When unpredictable people have power and control. So I get where the reservations are coming from, you know, I, Me too. Whether we understand it, whether we would do the same thing, it's just, it's, it's coming from a place of fear. So he just has to see this as an opportunity. He has to see this as the biggest challenge of his life to date. And a challenge that like, again, you know, whatever frustrations that this person brings in his life, he, he has a chance to like have a impact on someone's life in a meaningful way. And very often we don't get to do that, you know, and parenting is one is an opportunity for all of us.

[Grace]

Yeah, I do agree that. I think it would be helpful for my husband to have a really good one on one conversation. I don't think that that's actually happened up until this point. He has been involved in like a. More of a group conversation, but hasn't had like that one on one time with him. And I think as, you know, as a parent, my husband is less patient with the situation because he sees like how he'll like say one thing and then not follow through with it. Like he acts like he wants it but doesn't actually.

[Nick]

He needs to be patient and he needs to like also challenge his friend. But there, there needs to be a level of patience. Listen, like you guys, clearly he's disconnected from this kid. He's never been a dad. Like you said, he hasn't met this child. The bond isn't there. You know, he didn't like get to nest with his, you know, pregnant partner at the time in which she, you know, like, which even then, you know, like even dads. I remember when I was pregnant with river, it's like there's a different bond that moms have, you know, when you meet. So he doesn't have that right. You guys have this because you're bonding and connecting with your family. You've seen, you know, you're, you're just assuming how he's going to feel once he meets his kid. And so he needs to be patient, but consistent and patient and it's challenge him and it's like, it's more like you gotta, he's, he's gotta believe in his friend because you know, his mom and his sister are just feeding him with fear. Just like, I don't know, man, she can make the rest of your life, you know, next 20 years are just gonna be miserable and she's gonna try to take your money and yada, yada, yada. And like.

[Grace]

Yeah, that's good advice. Yeah. And I do have another question. So he's kind of at a crossroads now where the next step is to establish legal paternity. She won't willingly do it. And he has said and acknowledged that is what I need to do. It's been five months, and there hasn't. He hasn't done that yet. But what if. Then he gets to the point where he makes that decision, it is determined that he is the father, and then he ultimately decides, I don't want to be involved, which is a strong possibility.

[Nick]

What are you asking me, like, how.

[Grace]

Like, what I struggle with is, like, being okay with that, I guess, and.

[Nick]

Okay, what do you mean you? Like, like, what are you worried about? Are you worried about pushing this guy to do the thing that you want him to do and he. He decides to back out, and then now he's like, no, I'm worried about.

[Grace]

Him just ultimately deciding, like, no, I don't want to be involved. And, like, are we okay with that? As his friend of him just, like, not being involved in the child's life.

[Nick]

Yeah, listen. Yeah, I. I don't think you abandoned this guy. It is a unique situation. You can always. You can feel how you feel about it. He's gonna have to live with this. You know, he will. And the. And the point you're gonna make over the short term is that, like, listen, like, this is something either gonna, like, end up being really proud of yourself, and it's gonna be a life accomplishment 10, 15, 20 years from now when you realize you stepped up and. And again, like, maybe the most meaningful way of your life, or you're in 20, 15, 20 years from now, you're going to have a ton of regret, you know, and you don't know why. And in what manner and way that's going to manifest this. Does this kid reach out to his absent father and. And say, why weren't you there for me? Why'd you leave me alone with this woman? Or. Or is he going to wish, you know, or is he just gonna have nightmares about his son? You know, like, I don't know, maybe he keeps chasing the wrong women and he ends up, you know, not being a father and the way he planned. I don't know. And then I just. He. It's like, that's not your. You know, he will have to pay whatever consequences. It's not your job to, like, punish him by, like, alienating him. You don't have to love what he's doing, but, like, it's. He hasn't turned into a bad guy. It's not like he's magically unsafe around your kids or he's doing low character things like, yeah, we don't, we wouldn't do what he's doing. We don't agree with it. But you can still empathize with the situation he's in and you don't have to praise him for it. You don't have to pretend that you're okay with it. I don't think it has to define your friendship going forward. If ultimately he doesn't man up, he'll have to live with those consequences.

[Grace]

Yeah, that's really helpful. We've just. Because we don't have any. There isn't anybody else that's pushing him in that direction. We just didn't want it to seem like to him that it was coming across that we were okay with the situation. Now, mind you, I think he, it's pretty clear he knows where we stand on it, especially being parents.

[Nick]

But I think I, I just want.

[Grace]

To, I want you with complacency.

[Nick]

I want, I want the big message I want to get across to you is that if, if you're going to be successful in convincing him to do what you think he should do, it's not going to come from a place of you guys being his parent and being disappointed in him and letting him know that you don't agree with it. Like, at the end of the day, this is, you know what I'm saying? Like, he already knows that you don't agree with it.

[Grace]

Like, spin it into more positive.

[Nick]

Yeah, you know, it's like if, if you threaten to not talk to him anymore, he's just going to get and victimize himself again. You know what I'm saying? He's going to put himself as a victim. You got to make him feel empowered. You got to make him feel like this is the right thing to do, that, that this is a chance to fulfill his destiny as like a person who, like very few people nowadays, like, yeah, like most people are emotionally weak. You know, people who don't step up to challenges, who victimize themselves and are kind of losers. And he has a chance to be a winner here. He has a chance to be a winner and step up in ways that most people wouldn't step up. And, and it's going to be hard. It's going to be a battle and it's not going to be fun, especially early on. But the reward is so great at the end of like this fact that he was, you know, and he has to see that he is not going to make this decision because his friends are disappointed in him. You know what I'm saying? That's not why he's going to do this. Um, so it really doesn't matter. Like, you don't.

[Grace]

He has so much. Yeah.

[Nick]

You're thinking about, well, how do we make him feel shame if he doesn't do what we want to do? I would. That's just a waste of your energy.

[Sadie]

Yeah.

[Grace]

And no, it's not that. I think what it, it's not that we want him to feel shame at all. I think it's that we just see so much potential in him.

[Nick]

Sure.

[Grace]

Like, he's a really solid human. He's a great friend. He's got a great job. He, you know, he's just got so a great family. He's got so much going for him and he doesn't see what we see in him. Like, he lacks confidence and he's super good looking. Like, girls just like falling over.

[Nick]

Listen, if he had, if he had the right woman in his life who was saying, hey, we're, we're gonna do this together, he would. But he, you know, he's alone and he doesn't have the right, you know, and listen, I, I don't know what I would do 10 years ago if I was like, single as fuck and going on a bunch of dates and, and dating women my age or older and younger and just be like, I don't fucking know at this point, you know, Like, I, you know, we are in a, in a, in an emotionally healthy situation and we have a support system that he doesn't have. So you, you have to give him some empathy. You just have to like, really make him believe in himself and see the opportunity here.

[Grace]

So how do you, how do you. Because that is like one of our biggest issues or his one. Not ours. His is that he lacks confidence. So I'm consistently like, in our conversations, guiding him, like, hey, you have you so much going for you. Like, how do I. At the end of the day, I can only do so much. And like, he is in therapy. His therapist, in my opinion, I, I have shared with him, like, he does need a new therapist, but how do I continue. Just continue doing what I'm doing. Any other advice to.

[Nick]

Honestly?

[Grace]

Yeah, confidence is really.

[Nick]

He can only do so much. You know, Like, a lot of his confidence probably comes from his childhood. You know, I hope his mom made him believe in himself. You can only do so much, but keep doing what you're doing and you're. And again, slow burn. Yeah. Your husband as well. But yeah, you're. You can only do so much.

[Grace]

Yeah, that's. That's what I figured you would say.

[Nick]

He's only 35. You know, listen, the good news is, as a guy, you know, like the times, a little more gracious and forgiving with. With men who figure their shit out later in life, so maybe there's still hope, but, like, again, just. Yeah, just keep helping him believe in himself. That's all you can do.

[Grace]

Okay.

[Nick]

All right.

[Grace]

All right. Thanks, Nick. I appreciate it. That is really helpful. I'll have my husband talk to him. I think that, you know, could be a great next step. And just overall, I think not even. I don't think it's, like, vocally that we are negative about it, but I think we could, when we do have conversations, just, like, spend it as more of an opportunity. So he starts to change his mindset around it being less of a burden and, like, an issue.

[Nick]

He's got to think forward 10, 15, 20 years about how he thinks he's going to think about himself then, depending on what he does today. And does he really think he's going to regret stepping up, you know, no matter all the. What is sure to be a bunch of shitty moments and challenges and adversity dealing with this person, but at the end of it, he has someone who he helped raise and was a meaningful presence in this person's life and really helped save them? Or is he going to be the person who, you know, 15, 20 years ago, chickened out and played the victim and didn't own up to the fact that, like, he was a consenting adult in a pivotal moment of his life, and instead of stepping up, he took the easy way out and as a result, doesn't have a relationship with someone he's the father of.

[Grace]

And I can definitely tell it weighs on him. Like, it's a heavy thing. I absolutely know in 10 years he'll have regret. Like it's something he thinks about regularly.

[Nick]

It's just a matter of getting down. Don't tell him what he's, you know, just keep asking. Just paint the picture, you know, positive.

[Grace]

Yeah.

[Nick]

Okay.

[Grace]

Yep.

[Nick]

All right. I'll take care.

[Grace]

Thanks, Nick.

[Nick]

All right. Bye.

[Grace]

Bye.

[Nick]

Well, I'm a bread girly probably just like you we all love bread Bread, bread, bread, bread, bread. But sometimes when it comes to bread, you know, there's a lot of bad options out there and ones that just don't make you feel good after you indulge in your favorite carbohydrates. But not with herobread. Hero Bread fits my life and health goals. You would never know. It's low net carbs, zero sugar and also high in fiber. And I love that zero sugar part of it. Everything that Herobrand makes is delicious first and foremost from their croissants to their bread and everything else they have available. River is absolutely obsessed with their croissants. I love them too by the way. Their dinner rolls, amazing tortillas, great bagels, fantastic. And Herobred's sliced bread loaves are absolutely must have for any sandwich lover, which is me. So if you are looking to continue to enjoy eating bread in your life but get a healthy option instead, check out Herobred. You will absolutely be obsessed with their loave. Low carb, zero sugar and high in fiber bread. The best part is it will taste delicious. Herobred is offering 10 off your order. Go to Hero Co and use code V I A L L at checkout. That's V I A L L at H E R O CO. Well I don't know about you but when I want a tasty beverage that feels good, tastes great, I don't need the burps either and that's why I'm absolutely obsessed with Happy Thursday. Happy Thursday is a bubble free non carbonated spiked refresher that's 4.4 ABV with vibrant fruit flavors. Great fruit flavors. I would absolutely definitely call them vibrant. They're all delicious. They're a hit at every party. Mostly because of the non carbonation. Who wants to feel like a full burpee belly? No one likes that. You're just much happier when you're just have a tasty beverage that lifts your mood wherever you are. It's great on Thursdays. It's even better every day of the week. Why wait for Fridays when you can have a happy Thursday right now? Like I said they have a great selection of delicious flavors. Their strawberry, pineapple, star fruit, black cherry and mango passion fruit are all great. My personal favorite is black cherry but they really are all delicious. It's light hearted fun with crisp and refreshing flavors. It will be the hit at the party. So the next time you are going to an event bring yourself some Happy Thursdays and everyone will be happier because of it. So if you're feeling thirsty, have a Happy Thursday weekend vibes all summer long. To find out more and find a Happy Thursday near you, visit drinkhappy Thursday.com v I a l l that's drinkhappy Thursday.com v I A L l Celebrate responsibly non carbonated naturally flavored with other natural flavors. 21/ contains alcohol 2025 Molson Coors Beverage Co. Milwaukee, Wisconsin Beer Summer is here and we are all chasing something. A break, a goal, a vibe. Let's not let the bad socks and blisters ruin it. Bombas makes socks and now slides and seamless essentials that keep up with whatever your summer looks like. Whether you are running a marathon or just a few errands. Bomba Socks has a perfect socks for you. So it doesn't if you're dressing up, dressing down. Take care of your feet people. I mean I just don't think we appreciate just how much we stand on our feet and you should take care of them. Bombas has the most comfortable socks and a great selection. Again they have dress socks for every occasion. They have fun comfortable socks. Great designs. Nally loves their compression socks she wore throughout her pregnancy and then then some. She raved about them. She always I every every time she met another pregnant person she would always rave about Bombas compression socks. So if that's something you could benefit from, check it out. They don't stop at socks either. They have fresh white tees you barely have to break in, waterproof slides for the beach, backyard and everywhere in between, and buttery soft sweat wicking underwear that feels barely there. Everything that Bombas makes is high quality, so take care of your feet and check out some of their other great selections in the meantime. Plus, with wedding season being in full swing, you're going to want to see their ruffle and dress socks that make you the best dress guests there. Head over to bombas.com V I A L L and use code V I A L L for 20% off your first purchase. That's B O M B V I A L L Code V I A L L at checkout. How's it going?

[Sadie]

Good. My name is Lindsay, I'm 28 and I was wondering, should I tell my friend that her soon to be ex husband used to be my therapist?

[Nick]

How long you been friends with this person?

[Sadie]

So I've known her, let's call her Sarah. I've known Sarah about three years. We work, we're both fitness instructors at the same studio so we've known each other in passing if our classes are at the same time. But I haven't been friends friends with her until very recently. Just a few weeks ago we started watching Bachelor in Paradise together every week and that's really the first time that I've ever hung out with her outside of work. But I followed her on instagram the whole time I've known her. So I knew that she got married in 2023, and that's actually how I knew that her husband was a therapist. She posted about it, that he was beginning his pract. If you want a new therapist, here's the link. And I was like, you know what? I could use a new therapist.

[Nick]

So, wait, wait, you. So she refer. Indirectly referred you to her husband?

[Sadie]

Yes. And so that's what makes it extra weird is not only did her husband at the time, not only was he my therapist, but I knew going into it that he was her husband, which always felt a little bit weird.

[Nick]

And you didn't tell her because why? You just didn't want anyone to know you were in therapy or.

[Sadie]

It was partly that. Yeah. I didn't want to really talk about it. It was, I mean, a really, really tough time for me for so many reasons. And so I didn't really want to just be like, oh, yeah, therapy. But also because I didn't know her very well. We weren't very close, so I thought it would be a little bit odd.

[Nick]

Okay. And he's no longer your therapist. He, like, he sucked or what?

[Sadie]

Yeah, I just didn't like his therapy style. It wasn't what I needed at the time. So he was my therap about six months. And then in January, mid-30s. Mid. Late-30s. Yeah, in January.

[Nick]

And they were married for less than two years, huh?

[Sadie]

Yes. Yep.

[Nick]

You know. You know. Do you know the tea?

[Sadie]

Yeah. So I got the tea last week from her and. From her. Yeah. When we were watching Bachelor in Paradise before we started the episode. It's me, her, and a couple of her best friends. And so her friends already knew. But essentially the tea is he has borderline personality disorder and was just very extreme, very controlling, very troubled, had substance abuse issues, put on a pretty face when he was outside the house, but then he would come home to her and kind of just be nasty and she had had enough. Is essentially the tea.

[Nick]

And he's a therapist. Wow.

[Sadie]

Yeah. Yeah. That's the thing is I'm kind of shook because I never knew, like, you know, I only knew him in a very professional manner, and we never talked about his personal life, obviously, because he was my therapist.

[Nick]

I'm assuming this is a friendship that early on you value and that you want to maintain.

[Sadie]

Yeah, yeah. I've always really kind of wanted to be friends with her, but it's always kind of scary to reach out to someone and be like, hey, you seem really cool. We should hang Out. But yeah. How old is she also? Mid, late 30s.

[Nick]

Okay, you do absolutely need to tell her. 100%.

[Sadie]

Okay.

[Nick]

Yeah.

[Sadie]

Ah, okay.

[Nick]

Then how Convince me. Well, I mean, clearly this is like you were hoping I'd say something different just for fun. The part of your brain that's clearly too scared to tell her. Forgetting about your fear. Set your fears aside. Give me the unemotional argument of why you think it would be better not to tell her.

[Sadie]

Unemotional argument? I have no unemotional argument.

[Nick]

Okay, well, good. Okay.

[Sadie]

So I guess your point is being made. Nick. I think really I just was. Am wondering if there's a point. Just because if she. And that's part of she.

[Nick]

Definitely, to answer your question, if. If like she actually. She. Absolutely. This could. This could end your friendship. Like. Yeah, it just could, you know, totally get where you're like your best. You just have to be honest and hope that she receives it at a time in a place where she can get past the emotional trigger. And what is going to initially feel like a. Kind of a violation. Right. I'm completely disconnected from the story. And when, you know, it took a. Took you about three minutes for you to like paint the picture of the story. And then like the first minute I was like. Seems kind of fucked up. Like, why didn't I. How could she not tell her? And then it's kind of like, okay, I don't know, like therapy. There's a level of prop, you know. Okay, I get it. She just didn't want, you know, she had shit going on. She didn't really know this girl. And like there's some awkwardness. But like every day, every. Put it this way, like you should have told her before she confided in you about the tea, right? Because every instant that this woman opens up to you and trusts you with something that she's not necessarily trusting with other people, and you have something that you are not sharing with her that you know, she would like to. Something that personally involves her. Like her divorce has nothing to do with you. It feels like a violation. And that is just going to. When we meet people in adult life, ultimately, whether it's a romantic relationship or a friendship. And I'm. Especially as a woman, you can appreciate this as much as anyone. Like your. Your first thought is, is this person safe for me to be around?

[Sadie]

Yeah. And to really make that decision, you need to have all the information. And she doesn't have all the information.

[Nick]

Well, yeah, now you kind of. It's a little snake in the grassy. You know, it's just like you're feeding her, she's feeding you information, you're holding back.

[Sadie]

It's so what should I do then? Because that's. And I was think so. She, she gave me the tea. It was last week, so it wasn't that long ago. We were with her friends and they were talking about one of his friends was coming to get his stuff from her garage. And so it came up and just like enough like little things were dropped here and there that I was like, I, I'm just, I'm a nosy bitch. And I was trying not to let it get the best of me, but enough was being dropped that it got the best of me. And I was like, okay. So I asked her like when we were there with her friends if she like felt comfortable talking about it. I'm like, you don't have to. But like, what, what happened? Like, I'm really curious. And so she like opened up to me like with her friends there who already knew. And like, I guess. Are you saying maybe that would have been a good moment or before then. I've never really been with this woman one on one. It's always been either at the studio or around her friends.

[Nick]

Listen, I, you should have told her. I, I don't know the dynamic of your friendship, but like in my world I would have. As soon as you like, oh. Like, yeah, I'm actually like your husband's my therapist thanks to the reference as like a casual. But at the same time, I don't know what's like to be in your shoes. I don't know how sensitive therapy was for you in that moment. Understand that not everyone's comfortable sharing who their therapist is. You know, it's like my therapist's name is Darlene. You know, like whatever. I was my, my therapist, I was referred to by a friend who's now wife has the same therapist and we don't really talk about it. So I understand there's a level of sensitivity about like we go to the same person for like, I don't know. I, I get where you're coming from. I don't know if she will. Hopefully she will. Thank God you personally hate him as your therapist. Like you have that going for you. You're like, I did. I just. But you're gonna have to get it out fairly quickly.

[Sadie]

Uh huh. Okay.

[Nick]

Ah. You know, and you're gonna have to acknowledge that like I need to tell you something. I had my reasons. I handled it poorly. But like, I, I really value this. Your friendship And I, you know, especially in adulthood, and here's why. And, and I, But I wanted to tell you. This is not an excuse. I didn't know how to tell you. I should have told you beforehand. And my reasons for not tell you sooner is because, like, I was trying to figure it out, but I was. That this was wrong. And I, I, I. Val, I'm telling you because I value trust, and I, I want people to be trustworthy in my relationship. And I want you to feel like I'm a friend that you can trust. And, and I don't, I don't feel like I wouldn't be. And I think you just kind of get it out very vulnerably without trying to make excuses you really don't like. And she has every right to be as mad as she wants to be. That's the important thing is, like, if she gets super mad, you just have to let her be mad. That's not at the point where you're like, but, But I had the right to feel this way. You know, she. She might need some time to, like, take a break from you. I don't know. Maybe she, like, she might be like, girl, at least we both hate him. I don't know. Like, it really could go either way. I, I don't know. Like, you have to allow her to be. She has the right. She's going through a divorce. That's obviously very vulnerable. It sounds like her ex, you know, if he is a therapist and a little toxic, like, I'm sure on some ways he's made, you know, he's fucked with her emotions, take full responsibility, you know, and just, I don't know, you're gonna have to let it play out, but you have to tell her. You have to tell her.

[Sadie]

Yeah. Yeah. And the sooner I do it, the better.

[Nick]

Yeah.

[Sadie]

I think, Yeah. I think my only redeeming grace here that might make it okay is last week, her opening up about, like, why she's getting divorced is really the first time that we, like, kind of cross that line into, like, a vulnerable friendship. Before last week, like, we literally were just co workers who had started watching reality TV together. And so I'm hoping that because that door was, like, just barely opened that it's still an okay time to.

[Nick]

Yeah. And, And I think you just say, listen, it feels weird, and I feel like I should have just told you, but at the time, I just was, like, very nervous about therapy. I didn't really know where to get a therapist. That's a very common, you know, thing she provided a link because I'm sure she'll remember. And like, yeah, that, that, that happened at a time where I honestly just was like very nervous about therapy. And so no, I wasn't like, I wasn't trying to like advertise I was in therapy. Even though like it was your husband at the time and you know, doctor patient kind of thing. So I just kind of set that aside. But now that we've gotten closer and it, you know, and I don't work with him anymore, I just. But like, I felt like I should tell you because I didn't want to keep that from you and I don't like, I want friendships in my life where like, you know, there's. We can, there's a level of trust and I'm really sorry if I violated that trust. I, I don't think I handled it as best as I could. But this is me trying to do that and I think, you know, so you say something like that. Like, what you don't want to do is be like, well, this is why I said this and this is why I was justified for saying this is, this is why I'm not wrong. Like you were wrong and that's fine. And maybe well intentioned and maybe they're, you know, you just have to hope that she is in a position to empathize with the position you were in and then offer you grace knowing that like the person she got to know. Well, like the mistake you made is, I guarantee you she's made a version of this mistake at some point in her life. The question is, is she in a position to see that, that and to recognize that and offer you the grace that you're hoping to get from her?

[Sadie]

I'm scared, yeah. But that is, I've gotten myself in a predicament.

[Nick]

That's life. But like what you don't want to do is like let your fears justify your choices because that's when you get into territory of just like shitty behavior that you're able to justify because you don't want to be inconvenienced by some confrontation or the fear that you could lose someone. But you are establishing relationships based off of like deceit and lies and you wouldn't appreciate being in that position and you want to feel comfortable with the people you surround yourself with. And you know what? It's like, I am sure to have made friends and feel like they were kind of being shady and little misleading and having to be like, I don't know if I should with this person and I really used to with this person. But, like. Like, I don't know. They're just kind of. They always have excuses is why they can't just be up front.

[Sadie]

Yeah, no, that makes sense. Okay, then I need. I need your advice then on, like, how I should tell her. Like, should I be like, hey, let's get coffee? Like, so we're not watching Bachelor in Paradise this week because she had a conflict. So that buys me some time until I see her again.

[Nick]

Do you only hang out? I wouldn't do it that night. I wouldn't do it around her other friends.

[Sadie]

Yeah.

[Nick]

Have you had. Do you guys. Have you guys gotten lunch? Would that be a first if you asked her out for lunch?

[Sadie]

It would be a first. And again, I'm not making excuses for myself, but that's part of the reason I haven't told her. I've never been alone with this woman, really. It's always been either at work, around clients, or with her friends. And so this. This would be a first. But I don't think it would be weird if I asked her to get coffee. I don't think she'd be like, whoa, like, coming on too strong.

[Nick]

Ask her, you know, be like, hey, I. There's something I wanted to. I always hate the load. Like, something I wanted to talk to you about, but, like.

[Sadie]

Right, exactly. Like, we need to talk.

[Nick]

Suck. Don't get mad. Don't get scared.

[Sadie]

I don't want to freak her out, you know, Like.

[Nick]

Like, hey, do you, like, you want to get a coffee sometime? I wanted to run something by you.

[Sadie]

Yeah. Yeah. And I could just ask her, like, hey, since we're not watching Bachelor in Paradise this week, like, can we just, like, you know, hang out and do something else instead so I can still see you?

[Grace]

Ah.

[Nick]

I would maybe just say the. Run something by you. It's going to catch her off guard, but it won't. It won't freak her out because running something by you sounds like you're going to her for advice.

[Sadie]

Yeah. Okay, if you say so. I don't know.

[Nick]

I don't know if that's the best way.

[Sadie]

I'd be like, well, what are you running by me? Like, I want to know right now.

[Nick]

I don't know how. Yeah. I don't know how nosy she is about that stuff.

[Sadie]

Yeah, Yeah.

[Nick]

I just say, you know, you should try to get together with her or call her facetimer. I don't know. Would you. Have you ever. Have you called her ever? Have you faced.

[Sadie]

No, no, that's the thing, like, we really. This friendship is brand new, but I don't want to ruin it, like, right from the jump. And it sounds like maybe I am if I don't change something quickly.

[Nick]

Listen, you don't know this girl. It's. It's like a new relationship. You just have to come clean. Listen, she also does, like, this is also. Think of it in dating terms too, right? Understand that this is an exciting person you got to meet. You'd some good chemistry early on. There's some good compatibility. You have a mutual interest in Bachelor in Paradise. This friend has a lot of potential, just like a potential romantic partner does, right? And right now, you're seeing it through rose colored glasses. You're a little vulnerable about some baggage you're bringing into this relationship. You know, it's like, will they accept me because of this baggage I had that had really nothing to do with them, but, like, definitely could affect their opinion of me, et cetera, et cetera. But how people handle disappointment, how they handle adversity says a lot about, like, their ability to, like, be a part of your life and in a relationship with you of some kind in the future. And so, so you know that while, you know, you kind of fucked up and maybe didn't handle it the past, like, this is not a malicious thing. This is definitely. There's a little bit of like, what a coincidence. What a, like, crazy, like, oh, my God, like, it just kind of happened this way. I definitely wasn't expecting to be this woman's friend. Turns out, like, I mean, listen, ex wives and mistresses have become best friends. You know what I'm saying? So, like, you guys, there's a chance that this really is just a small bump in the road. I don't know this person, you know, but if this, if this girl is just completely unwilling to see your point of view at all, then, you know, maybe it's also not the friendship that you thought it would be. You know, because any friendship and relationship, it requires empathy and grace and understanding and vulnerability and things like that. And if she hears you out, it does make a lot of sense. You know, there's gonna be a little bit of, like, you know, I would just say, listen, when you were telling, I felt wrong hearing you open up about your ex. I only knew him in a professional capacity, but I also didn't want to bring it up because I didn't want to bombard you with the truth around your friends, and I just didn't know how you would feel about it. That's not an excuse. That just was my reasoning. And I just don't know you well enough to know how I should have delivered that information. And so you just say, like, I, you know, vulnerably, like, I, I, I, like I don't admit this. You can say this sounds corny, but like an adult, like, I've really enjoyed becoming friends with you and I value this friendship. And I, I want to be upfront and honest with you. And I, I, if I want to come to you and just tell you, and if you, I'd love to hear how you know, like, just tell me how you feel. You have a right to be upset. And if you, you know. And going forward, I hope that we're never in a position like this again. But.

[Sadie]

Imagine if we.

[Nick]

I do want to be upfront with my friends and I want, I want them to feel like I'm someone who just is as transparent as I possibly can be and I want to be transparent with you.

[Sadie]

Yeah, no, that, that all makes sense. And like, like I said, like, I, like, I, I don't know her super well either, but from what I know about her, I feel like she would take it okay. But you're right. If she doesn't, then she has that right as well. I do think it helps that it's been over six months since he was my therapist. I think that, like, distance helps and the fact that I, who knows?

[Nick]

That's not really for you to decide, you know?

[Sadie]

Yeah, no, that's true, that's true. She doesn't think it helps.

[Nick]

Yeah, you're just, you're wasting your energy trying to like, decide for her how she, like, what she's going to like. You don't, you have no idea.

[Sadie]

Yeah, you're right. I'm just trying to mentally prepare myself. Oh my gosh.

[Nick]

But you became friends with her. Rah. Recently.

[Sadie]

Really? In the past few weeks.

[Nick]

Okay. I think you're going to be okay. I mean, again, this all makes sense. It makes sense why you didn't tell an acquaintance that you're like, her therapist was her ex husband. Because, like, ultimately, like, you're not out there advertising that you're in therapy, but now that you've become friends with her, it just feels like something like friend to friend, like you wanted her to know because obviously she opened up to you and you just didn't know how to handle, handle it in the moment when you are around a group of people. But like, I, I don't want, I always want my friends to feel like I, I, I don't keep things from them that are their business, you know?

[Sadie]

Yeah.

[Nick]

And I feel like this is your business as much as mine now that we're friends and you're opening up to me about this guy, and I just. I. You know, and so I really think you. I think that's why you reaching out Go, like, will fit that narrative of why you didn't tell her along the friends, because this is you making sure you guys are alone. Because I just didn't. I didn't want to. I didn't know if you wanted me to tell you that way. So.

[Sadie]

No, that. That completely makes sense. And I mean, I guess, like, worst case scenario, she's like, screw you. And then when I went into her at the studio, it'll be awkward.

[Nick]

Like, I don't think she's gonna say screw you. I mean, that. That would.

[Sadie]

Based on what you're telling, like, that kind of person.

[Nick]

Also, just based on what you're telling me, it doesn't seem to justify a screw you. Like. Like, I get your point of view. Right. This is definitely, like, I don't know what you could have done differently, but I get why she might feel a little weird about this.

[Sadie]

Yeah. Yeah. And the longer I go without telling her, the worse.

[Nick]

It's just like, right now, right? She. This is a woman who probably has trust issues. Anyone going through a divorce has some kind of trust issues or some kind of emotional trauma. There's a very vulnerable like. So, yeah, when shit happens to you, it's hard not to get paranoid about it repeating itself. Right? Like, when you go through a break, breakup, or a divorce, there's always the, like, how did I not see this coming? You know, they presented one way. Now they're a different person. So, like, her radar for that type of behavior is probably more heightened now. So I'm just coming from that perspective, not the, like, you up and how could you have done this? And, like, I just. I can't. I can't reason with your logic. I'm not there. Like, everything you've said makes a ton of sense on why you got to this point. But what really matters going forward is, again, don't allow those excuses to get you into the territory of now. Six months go by. You've been friends with this chick for six months. You still haven't told her. You're still in kind of that gray area of like, you know what? I kind of get it. She didn't really know what to say. She told me pretty fast. And then when you sit down and you emphasize Honesty and communication and wanting to be upfront and having that difficult conversation with her. If she is a reasonable person, despite going through this very vulnerable state, I'm assuming she will see that rather than being the person who's this, like, very defensive, very argumentative, trying to justify everything, you know, that to me, that matters more because that will be more telling. You know, it's like when you date someone, again, use that same analogy. If you, or you just. People will give you certain cues about, like, how they are handling disappointment. And how people handle disappointment is a huge indicator on how they'll be in a relationship, whether it's romantic, whether it's a friendship. And while this is adversity that you guys are facing, you have an opportunity to give her some indications that, like, trust matters to you, healthy communication matters to you. You have a willingness and an ability to, like, have confrontation and just be an adult and, and, and be vulnerable and acknowledge that you, you made some mistakes and you want to correct them. Those are, those are a bunch of green flags. And you have to be willing to show those green flags knowing that, like, you don't know this person well enough to predict how they're going to handle this information and you are afraid that she won't handle it well. And you are, are afraid that you're going to lose this very short, brief, but like, very nice relationship you've been able to cultivate.

[Sadie]

Yeah, no, that, that all makes sense. That makes sense. Ah, I'm scared. Okay, so I'm dying to know how.

[Nick]

This, how this conversation goes.

[Sadie]

Yeah, me too. Okay, so next step then would be to reach out to her and just ask her either to FaceTime or get coffee or something, because I want to run something by her. And then hopefully, well, I would say.

[Nick]

I always say, hey, are you free for coffee whenever? And maybe not even the. Run something by. Maybe she's like, yeah, great. If she's just like, if she's like, oh, I'm kind of busy, blah, blah, blah, like, let's get together. Yeah, I'm not free until next, you know, Monday night or whenever it airs.

[Sadie]

I don't know, we always watch it on Tuesdays, a day late on Hulu.

[Nick]

So anyway, if she's not afraid, available till next Tuesday, then I would say, say, well, there's something I just wanted to run by you. Are, do you have time for like a quick call or a FaceTime?

[Sadie]

Okay, yeah. Kind of hold off on that sense of urgency or something.

[Nick]

Unless she says, and even then you're creating energy that you Run around something by her so you're not being like, hey, there's something I want to. Just something I want to run by you.

[Sadie]

Yeah, because something I want. I was wondering if I just asked her, like, hey, do you want to get coffee or something? And I. And just, like, left it at that. Would that be any level of, like, deceitful or anything, Asking her to get coffee when I know that the reason is I want to speak with her about this, but she.

[Nick]

No, because you do.

[Grace]

You.

[Nick]

This is a conversation that's better to have in person.

[Sadie]

Yeah. Okay.

[Nick]

I mean, again, there's no. Really. I mean, he was your therapist. You didn't have. You know what I'm saying? It's like, you didn't have a secret relationship. This is a professional relationship that, like, includes a level of privacy and vulnerability. Like, I don't know if. If her ex husband was an oncologist, and maybe he was your doctor because you had a cancer scare of some kind, and maybe you just didn't want the world to know that, like, you would have the right to, like, keep that a secret, you know? Like, I don't think you should lean on that or harp on that, but I just say, you know, like, listen, it hap. This has all happened when, like, I was. I needed therapy. I wasn't on. And maybe, I don't know if you're comfortable talking about why you needed therapy now with her that you can always open, like, you can offer that as like a. Almost like, you know, she shared something with you. Now you're. You're going to share something with her that's vulnerable and you hope that she accepts whatever. But it has happened at a time where you're just like, I just didn't, like, think of going up to this random girl who was more of an acquaintance, being, like, just, you know, your husband, you could have. But I just didn't know. I don't know. I was very private about my therapy at the time. It didn't work out. He's not my therapist anymore. Happy to, like, whatever you want to know about that, I'll tell you. But, like. And then we became friends, and I just kind of froze, and I didn't really know what to say. But I really like you as a friend, and I don't want anyone, let alone my friends, to feel like I keep things from them. And so I didn't tell you last week because we were around Betty sue and Diane, and I just wasn't sure how you would receive this or if they cared. And I just, I didn't want to assume. So I hope this is the, I hope this comes across as the most mature way of handling this because that's what I'm trying to do. But I, I, I, and if whatever questions you have and if I, I don't know if this, I don't even know how you're gonna feel about it. But like, I just, I want you to know that, like, I just wanted to tell you and however you want to feel about it, I'm. Is how you know you have the right to. I get it.

[Sadie]

Yeah. Yeah. Just being so open and vulnerable.

[Nick]

Yeah. That's your best approach. If she, she, I honestly think she. It'll be fine. I really do.

[Sadie]

Okay. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. She's a very like, level headed person and so I do. Yeah.

[Nick]

And like, she might like just love that you fired them. So like there's that, like, she probably bond over that. True. I mean, it just, you know, she just, that her first thought, her first question will be like, like if, if you don't get it out in time for her to ask, her first question would be like, is he still your therapist? Yeah, that's gonna, that's gonna be her first thought.

[Sadie]

Lead with, with that.

[Nick]

He used to be my therapist. I fired him a long time ago. That I would honestly lead with. That's how I would deliver it. Your husband used to be my therapist. I fired him a long time ago when we weren't friends and I just didn't like, I was very private about my therapy and just very like, honestly, like insecure about just, just getting therapy in general. I don't know if that. And so I didn't really want to tell anyone. And then we became friends and I, I feel like you should know that. And I, I hope that how I'm delivering this doesn't come across as misleading. And I didn't tell you when we were with the girls last time because I just didn't know if that would me be bombarding you. And I didn't know you well enough to know how you want this information. How do you want you to receive this information? So this is my best attempt at trying to do it the right way.

[Sadie]

Yeah. Best attempt. Yeah, for sure. Oh my goodness. Okay. I'm stressing, I'm stressing.

[Nick]

It's gonna be okay.

[Sadie]

Thank you.

[Nick]

It'll be okay.

[Sadie]

This is, this is really helpful. Yeah. Because I was like, I needed someone. That's why I wrote it. Because I was like, I need someone who doesn't know anyone involved to kind of just who have you run this by?

[Nick]

And have they given you anything different?

[Sadie]

Literally, I've only run it by two of my friends. One of them, she was like, I think you should tell her, but I just, just don't have any idea how you could possibly approach that conversation. And then the other one was like, if she's never gonna find out, then maybe it doesn't matter. So I kind of got conflicting opinions.

[Nick]

Yeah, I think there's way more to be gained for the long term by telling her.

[Sadie]

Yeah, I'm never gonna be able to stop thinking about it. It's always gonna be in the back of my mind. And I'm not a very good liar. And so I feel like when I have something to hide, I act a little bit, bit weird. And I think if I held it in for too long, she would kind of start to pick up.

[Nick]

Well, then it's just, it's not really the front. I mean, again, I don't know why you're choosing your friendships in adult life, but it's just like it's a tainted relationship that to begin with that's more based off of your mutual interest in a TV show rather than, I found someone in my adult life that I can build a meaningful relationship with that can maybe grow into like, I don't know, someone I go to for emotional support. Someone who's really in my very small, trusted inner circle of friends. I mean, she might not, this person might not get there to begin with. But if you're looking for those type of people in your life, that's how you have to start these relationships. And if you're looking for like, acquaintances that like, are fun to hang out with in seasons of your life, then that, then you take a different approach. But like, I think too many people treat what they call friendships as basically like, you know, temporary. They're like friendship situationships.

[Sadie]

You know, it's like, yeah, yeah, and I've had those. But this, Yeah, I mean, she's really a wonderful woman. And like I said, I've, you know, we've been, I guess, professional acquaintances for a few years. And I've always really looked up to her. And so now that I have a chance to actually be her friend, I don't want to screw that up. Yeah, she really does seem like an amazing person.

[Nick]

She'll probably respect how you handled it. It's not difficult to do. And knowing that, like, it sounds like.

[Sadie]

It'S not pass saving.

[Nick]

And my guess is if you asked your, you know, 10 people, my guess Is the advice you'd get would probably be fairly split down the middle.

[Sadie]

Your reasoning makes sense.

[Nick]

Yeah. I mean, and I'm just more like. I think anyone who would give you the advice not to tell her are the type of people who don't think about what it takes to make long lasting friendships or they're not that interested in having them and they're just used to. It's not a two way relationship. It's just more of a. Yeah. And I think if she's the type of friend that you hope and want her to be, she'll be the type of person who will appreciate your honesty.

[Sadie]

Yeah. No, I think you're right. And that all makes sense. And hearing it all laid out like that, it. It feels pretty clear. Yeah, I definitely need to tell her and I need to tell her sooner rather than later.

[Nick]

And I. These other women that were part of the group, are you friends with them too? Or are they more.

[Sadie]

No. So they're her friends. I've just met them through her.

[Nick]

Okay, well that's a little bit of an excuse you have too. Which is also really why you didn't tell them is like I wanted tell you. I didn't want to tell them about my therapy and.

[Sadie]

Yeah, yeah. Because I don't know these girls really at all. I met them two weeks ago.

[Nick]

But, you know, I don't know how she will feel about like. And I guess if you're only really, really been friends for a couple weeks, I guess it wouldn't have made sense for you to randomly tell someone. I, you know, you could just be like, I don't, I don't know what your, what your expectations about that were, you know, like, I don't know how you know know. I don't think spouses are supposed to like have. It's the hip, like.

[Sadie]

Exactly. Yeah. Like at the time it felt like a little bit of a confidentiality thing. But now you know, he's definitely not.

[Nick]

Supposed to tell her. Right. That would be a violation. I don't think you're allowed to tell your spouses who your patients are just because they're your spouses.

[Sadie]

But now that he's out of the picture as my therapist and out of the picture as her husband, I'm like, okay, now it makes. Yeah, no, no, no. Ah, I'm freaking out.

[Nick]

Just tell her. I just be vulnerable.

[Sadie]

I think it'll be fine. I think it'll be fine.

[Nick]

I really do. Otherwise you're just, or you're just saving yourself from someone who's just Maybe a little messy and a little toxic and a little just maybe not in a position to like, because, like, this is definitely. This is dramatic, right? I mean, hell, people listen to this and be like, oh, what a crazy story. It's like. It's dramatic. And so if she. If she's someone who is drawn to drama, she will use this as drama. And if she is someone who is, like, drama adverse. And ultimately, like, in her adult life, she's learned how to, like, separate drama from, like, like, ne things she can avoid to, like. Right. That's all maturity. And so if she is someone who really is, like, looking to, like, work through disappointment and, like, just get. Remove drama from her life, you are setting her up in a position to do that. That she might not take the bait. She might decide to use this as an outlet to release emotion. Who knows? Right? But, like, this will be telling for this friendship about how she handles this information because, like, ultimately, nothing you did sounds malicious and there's just maybe some miscommunication or just not really, like, a very unique situation where there weren't defined expectations and boundaries for a situation that usually doesn't present itself.

[Sadie]

Yeah, Yeah. I don't. I don't even know if when she put the link out, like, you know, she was just like, you know, proud wife moment. Like, oh, look, my husband's doing this thing. Like, I don't even know if she was actually expecting anyone to even consider seeing her husband as a therapist, you know?

[Nick]

Totally.

[Sadie]

Yeah. Okay. Okay. I feel. I'm scared. I'm scared, But I feel better about this because, yeah, I feel more certain that I know what I need to do and, like, why I need to do it.

[Nick]

I understand you're scared, but I think you need to, like, just remind yourself that this is the right thing to do. Yeah, it is. And you will. And things are going to play out how they're going to play out, but the res. The result of how she handles it does not change your decision tree.

[Sadie]

Yeah, Yeah. I need to stop kind of trying to think of different scenarios that could happen and just. Just go in.

[Nick]

Like, so many people in this position are basing their advice off of the outcome you want. Right? I want an outcome. So what do I do to get that outcome? Well, I want to save this friendship, so how do I save this friendship right now? But, like, the outcome you want isn't, like, how to save this friendship right now. It is, like, how to do the right thing, how to be a friend that is, you know, someone that can show that trust in communication matters to me and how do I build a friendship that actually, like, has like some real chance of being a meaningful relationship in my life? And based off of those parameters, what should I do regardless of the immediate reaction or how she might feel in the moment? And I. And if your only goal is to not feel like you're in trouble, then you know what I'm saying, that's what you make your decision on.

[Sadie]

No, yeah, that makes sense. Thank you, by the way, for not making me feel like I'm in trouble.

[Nick]

It's definitely a super huge coincidence and.

[Sadie]

It'S a weird situation. It's. It's. Yeah, I was like, I don't even know. I don't even know. But I feel. Yeah, I feel better after this about what I should do. And kind of just going into it knowing that it's the right thing to do regardless of the outcome really does make me feel better. And I think it makes it a lot less likely that I'm gonna chicken out because I feel awkward for sure.

[Nick]

Okay.

[Sadie]

Okay. Well, thank you. Oh my goodness. Thank you so much. I appreciate it.

[Nick]

Please let us know what, what happens.

[Sadie]

Yeah, I'll have to send in an update. And I just also wanted to say I've listened to your show for years and you're. You've helped me through like all sorts of things. I've never had to call in before because you've always helped me through everything. But this is just, this is a special one. So. But thank you for your show and thank you for your advice.

[Nick]

My pleasure. Thank you for saying that. And I'm glad that this seems helpful.

[Sadie]

Hopefully it is. Yeah, it really does. All right.

[Nick]

All right, well, good luck.

[Sadie]

Thanks.

[Nick]

I really want to know how she handles it. I really think you're going to be okay. And I honestly think this, this will bring you closer together.

[Sadie]

I hope so.

[Nick]

Like, he really sucked at his job.

[Sadie]

We can just bond over that. He really wasn't that good, I got to be honest. Sorry.

[Nick]

Well, if it was dealing with his own shit, it's apparently.

[Sadie]

Yeah, now I know. Apparently the week I fired him is the same week that she was like, had had their first talk about it. So I'm like, oof. Rough week for him.

[Nick]

Poor guy.

[Sadie]

Yeah.

[Nick]

All right.

[Sadie]

Not much sympath. All right, well, thank you so much. I appreciate it.

[Nick]

Thank you. All right, take care. C is for anyone who is doing all the right things but still doesn't feel their best because true wellness starts at the cellular level with science backed high absorption supplements. Designed to travel with you and work with your body. Symbiotica helps you feel more like you. Well, my favorite part is how they travel with you. They make these very individual like travel packs for you. I'm always on the go and that's been a good game changer for me to stay on my supplement regimen. With Symbiotica, it's absolutely game changing. I also just feel great about taking their supplements because they're so intentional. They only put the highest ingredients in their supplements. Well, if you're looking for glowing skin, anti aging and better gut health, their liposomal glutathione is a must have. Also the liposomal vitamin C N I absolutely love that. Can't get enough good vitamin C in your body. Helps with collagen production, glowing skin antioxidants and it's a great immunity booster. We all know what it's like to feel under the weather and that's never fun. It only takes 30 seconds a day to get all the nutrients you need. They have a formula to support your health goals. Everything from energy, digestion, immunity and mood. And like I said, their travel size packs are great for everyone because it just makes it easier to stay in your routine, especially if you're someone who's constantly on the go. Simon is one of the most trustworthy brands out there. They never compromise on quality and sourcing. Their products are free of seed oils, preservatives, toxins and artificial additives. Additives. It's something you can taste and feel in every packet. Go to symbiotica.com v I a l l and get 20 off plus free shipping that c y m b I O-T-I-K-A.com v I a l l for 20 off plus free shipping well, in an age of digital currency, when you have a bunch of credit cards, sometimes it's pretty hard to keep track of where your money is going. And that is really important when it comes to saving on things that matter the most. That's where Monarch Money can help you and your family. Monarch Money is for anyone who feels like their finances are all over the place. Whether you are budgeting solo or managing money with a partner. With one clean dashboard for spending, savings and investing, Monarch gives you full control and clarity to stop guessing and start building real wealth.

[Sadie]

Finances can be messy and confusing. Monarch Money acts like your personal cfo, giving you full visibility and control so you can stop earning and start growing. It's more than your average budgeting app. Monarch Money is a complete financial command center for your accounts, investments and goals. Don't just manage your money, start building wealth with 50% off your first year for our listeners.

[Nick]

With all your accounts, credit cards and investments in one place, you'll always know where your money stands without the hassle. Tracking your spending, savings and investments effortlessly so you can focus on what matters most, making your biggest life goals a reality. NAMED Wall Street Journal's best budgeting app of 2025, the top recommended personal finance app by users and Experts with over 30,000 5 star reviews.

[Sadie]

Get control of your overall finances with Monarch Money. Use code v I a l l monarchmoney.com in your browser for half off for your first year. That's 50% off your first year at Monarch Money Money with Code V I.

[Nick]

A L L Time to break down this week's Must Watch episodes. Honestly, Alex, I didn't binge anything, but I did switch to T Mobile with.

[Lindsay]

Their new Family Freedom offer.

[Nick]

That's not the plot we're following.

[Lindsay]

Well, I'm writing at&t out of the.

[Nick]

Series and giving T Mobile the starring role.

[Lindsay]

They paid off my family's four phones up to $3200 and gave them us four new phones on the house and scene.

[Nick]

Introducing Family Freedom Our lowest cost will switch our biggest family savings all on America's largest 5G network. Visit your local T Mobile location or learn more@t mobile.com FamilyFreedom up to $800 per line via virtual prepaid card typically takes 15 days. Free phones via 24 monthly bill credits with finance agreement eg Apple iPhone 16128 gigabyte $829.99 Eligible trade in eg iPhone 11 Pro for well qualified credits end and balance due if you pay off early or cancel contact Team Mobile. How's it going?

[Lindsay]

Pretty good. How are you?

[Nick]

Good. What's your name?

[Lindsay]

My name is Grace. I'm 31 years old and I'm wondering how I can move on from my ex girlfriend who held my keys hostage and hid a social media scandal from me.

[Nick]

You. You're wondering how you move on?

[Lindsay]

Well, it's less about moving on from her and from the relationship and more so about the things that were said and done to me and sort of trying to reclaim my story and find solace and validation in my own experience without requiring like answers or, or confirmation from other people about what I experienced.

[Nick]

Okay, I kind of get what you're saying, I think, but without maybe speaking in kind of more, I don't know, philosophical ways like how are you feeling right now? About this relationship? Like, what is it? Like what. In the simplest way, like, what are you feeling that you're struggling with? And that's kind of like, all right, because that's what you're trying to do. Like, this. This relationship, it ended. Things happened, and now it's left you with this icky feeling, and you don't know how to get rid of this icky feeling. Is that. Am I articulating that back to you? Do you feel it? Like.

[Lindsay]

Yeah, I think so. I think I was doing a pretty good job of. Of moving on, so to speak, until I got some information about my ex. And I think, yeah, I'm really just. I'm struggling to, like, find myself again after all of this.

[Nick]

What's the information?

[Lindsay]

The whole social media thing. So one of my family members essentially told me that my ex was involved in this big social media blowout a few years ago with my ex's ex partner at the time calling my. Let's call my ex Joe. So Joe's ex partner was calling Joe out for being an abusive partner on social media. And I had, like, just heard about all of this the other day.

[Nick]

Why are you struggling with that?

[Lindsay]

I think because I had a different idea about what the relationship was and that my ex trusted me, and we had this, like, beautiful, trusting bond. And it's one thing for that to end. And I mean, I'm the one that ended it, and I feel. Feel very confident about that decision. But to hear all of these other things after, I think I feel icky because I'm like, oh, so this person was. Was abusing other people and, And. And this has been going on for ages. And then I allowed them into my life, and they did it to me, and they lied about it.

[Nick]

And just. So I. I don't know. So when your ex was an alleged abuser or being accused of it or they were, like, harassing and bullying other people online, right?

[Lindsay]

No. So my ex was called out online allegedly for being abusive toward their partner.

[Nick]

Okay. A couple years ago.

[Lindsay]

Yeah, a few years ago.

[Nick]

And. Okay, no. Okay. And so your ex got called out by someone online for being. Is it physically or emotionally abusive?

[Lindsay]

Emotionally abusive.

[Nick]

Okay. And are you saying the things that your partner was accused of? Do you feel like she did that to you and with you in that relationship?

[Lindsay]

I do. I think I'm struggling.

[Nick]

You. You don't say that you're convinced of that. You're like. You're looking up to the left and you're like. I do.

[Lindsay]

Like, yeah, I think. And that's sort of what I'm, what I'm grappling with. Because I, so there's like this dichotomy between, like, logical and emotional mind. And logically, I, I, I can say that yes, I do feel that my ex was emotionally abusive and, and like.

[Nick]

And how so I guess like, because they were react, I mean, manipulative, reactive or temperamental or.

[Lindsay]

Yeah, a lot.

[Nick]

Like every day that they call you a worthless piece of shit, it was.

[Lindsay]

More so manipulation, I think, and sort of the classic, like, you don't really love me. You don't care about me, you treat me like shit. When I would, for instance, set a boundary and say, hey, I need you to go home. I need you to leave my apartment. I need to, like, go to sleep and get up early for work the next day. And then she wouldn't leave. She would stay, and then she would follow me downstairs when I would try to get space. And then, like, police got involved. Like, there were just so many things as a result of my boundaries not being respected and me communicating in a way that I thought was very calm and respectful and being met with. You're actually like a narcissist. And you're, you're horrible. And you treat me like shit. You don't love me, you don't care about me, like, those kinds of things.

[Nick]

She called you a narcissist?

[Sadie]

Yeah.

[Lindsay]

Or, or that I had strong narcissistic tendencies, I think was the exact phrasing.

[Nick]

But I just feel like your energy is being focused on the wrong thing. Well, one, you broke up with this person. So, like, gotta pat yourself on the back there. And now you're from. If I'm understanding you correctly, you heard this bit of information that, honestly, from how I'm understanding your story, all it really should have done is validate your decision of moving on from this person. Person. This person, as you're describing, when you reflected on your relationship was at best very reactive. And when they got triggered, was very cruel and mean and said things that are out of pocket that they probably didn't mean or they, you know, they were hurt, so they tried to hurt you. Hurt people, hurt people, things like that. Right. And eventually you came to a point where it's just like, I can't keep doing this anymore. You know, when it first happened, I'm sure you try to give your partner the benefit of the doubt. You tried to offer her grace, you tried to work through it with her, you tried to calm her down, yada, yada, like, and again, like, as Humans, we all just decide that, like we are now therapists and we can diagnose other people. And I think there's just a fun, like a lot about abuse is about consistency and there being a pattern. You know, it is not about like someone having a bad day and saying things out of pocket that they have to apologize for and then make some meaningful changes in their life or just never replicate that. And, and again, I don't know how much good it's doing by you trying to figure out whether your ex really did a abuse you or if you really knew who your ex was. I honestly feel like you do know who your ex was. Again, you know, like you're saying, well, actually from what I've heard about what she was accused of back in the day, you know, the thing that you're triggered by is that what you heard about your partner, you believe and you believe because that's the person you dated and got to know. So it's, it's almost like counterintuitive that you have now convinced yourself to have these internal thoughts about like, did I really know this person? Or I can't, you know, I, you know, whatever thoughts that you're having right now that are not, you know, do having the opposite effect. Instead of validating your decision to move on from this person, it's keeping you stuck emotionally and thinking about this person quite. You know, it's funny, I got in a spat with my parents. I don't know why I brought that up, because I'm random. But I, I, we were going in circles, couldn't get through to her. And then I finally asked my parents about like, well, what, you know, they were talking about their feelings and I was like, okay, fair enough. But what, how, how would you like me to respond so that I can based on off for everything talked about and they didn't know how to answer that question which made help them saw my point of view because it was more me. It was because my point was like, you know, your feelings about your, you know, but they are just your feelings and it doesn't mean that you're right. I feel a certain way, you feel a certain way. We know about that. But once we get past how we feel, what do you want to do with these feelings? I don't know if that's making any sense. And I want you to ask yourself that same question. What do you want to do with these new thoughts and feelings about your partner? You're already out. You already left the relationship. So what do you think you need? What is left to resolve. Like, what are. What are the answers that you need? Or are you just ruminating about someone that you up a little bit. Bit, and maybe you up more than you realized in the moment, and you're having a hard time processing, you know, the loss. And, yeah, you made it difficult to start breaking up with her, but you know what I'm saying? Like, at some point, if you're going to keep thinking about a topic and. And you. You have to try to, like, fix that. All right. It's just like, all right, well, what do I. What. What can I do about this?

[Lindsay]

Yeah, I think I definitely have a hard time letting thoughts go. I definitely, like, I want to analyze, I want answers, I want to think things through. And ironically enough, I love that you mentioned, like, I'm not a therapist. You're not a therapist. I'm actually in a master's of counseling program. So I. I really nerd out about, like, human behavior, and, like, I want to understand things, and that is just sort of my penchant for. For. For my nerdy thing.

[Nick]

I relate. But as someone who's going to school for this, I mean, you might. Yeah, you have to. It's really important to, I think, think. I mean, if you listen to the show, you hear all. I'm sure you've heard so many people call in who are like, yeah, I'm going to therapy. I go all the time about this very topic, and I've been going for three years. You're just. You're not actually trying to solve the problem. You're just trying to analyze it, you know, and in your analyzation of this problem, you're just kind of going in circles. Just, you know, it's. It's something to do. It's. You've heard me talk about. About, like, it's really tough breakups. There. There are these. You know, there's the, hey, I don't think we should be together. Let's stop hanging out. And then there's the physical, like, cutting that person off. The change in, like, your behaviors and your. The things that you did together, and just your routines change. But again, that emotional connection can live on in your mind and body long after a relationship ends. And I think ultimately what's happening is that you're still emotionally connected. This relationship. How long has it been since you broke up?

[Lindsay]

It's been about three. Three months.

[Nick]

Okay, so it's not that. How long did you date for?

[Sadie]

About a year.

[Nick]

Okay, so it hasn't been that long. We're definitely getting To a point where it's like, all right, it's time to, you know. But my guess is that this is just a subconscious way for you to convince yourself that it's okay to think about this person when you know you shouldn't be thinking about this person. But you're not thinking about them in an affectionate, loving way. You're thinking about them in this kind of like, like psychological analyzing thing. But it's not getting you anywhere. It's not accomplish anything. You don't even have a goal. Right. Like, there's no goal attached to this. Like, what are you trying to figure out? Like, you've, you think they were abusive? Really doesn't really matter at this point one way or the other, you're out of the relationship. Certainly it's disappointed that you thought you had a trusting relationship with this person and they chose not to tell you this information they got called out on. But you know, if you're trying to, even if you're trying to empathize with your ex, like, I bet she doesn't think that she was abusive. Like in her mind she's thinking, oh, my ex is the crazy one, right? She called you narcissistic. A lot of narcissistic people call other people narcissistic. Maybe your ex and her existence ex were both equally toxic and she's a victim in her mind when it comes to her ex calling her out online, you know? Right. So that might be her version. I don't know.

[Lindsay]

Of course.

[Nick]

So, but my point is, what is.

[Lindsay]

Your goal and what I think, I think I'm, I'm. I'm struggling with, like, I, I totally agree with what you're saying about the, the like cyclical nature of just analyzing things to death and it not actually resolving anything. Completely agree. But I think that like, like I am struggling to move on and just enjoy my life, move on with my friends, another partner one day, whatever. When all of these things were like, said and to me and done to me. And I don't even, I struggle to even label things as emotional abuse or narcissism and all of these buzzwords. Like, I have a real.

[Nick]

So when you say you're struggling to move on about because of what was said and done to you, like what.

[Lindsay]

What specifically calling me abusive, saying that her abuse was reactionary abuse to my abuse. And then, and I even talking about it now, I feel shame that I was even like involved in a relationship that is this damaging and that I didn't leave sooner. But I just, It's It's, I'm, I'm one. I feel like I'm trying to analyze things to get to the bottom of. Like is this, Did I do something? Is there something that I could be. Of course we all have things that we could change about ourselves. But like is there something that I done here? Is there any validity to what she has said about what I have done and things that I could actually improve on beyond just like general growth? Yeah, I mean trying to, yeah, trying to figure that out. Am I crazy? Because I feel absolutely crazy. And that is what is really difficult for me. I don't know if my story.

[Nick]

So why do you feel, why do you feel, why do you feel that way? I mean my, my initial reaction to what you just said is that's a very human response. To have the fact that you are even questioning and willing to look inside and reflect about the role you played suggests that like for one, she called you a narcissist. That's not a narcissistic, narcissistic thing to do. Right. We all can be narcissistic and self centered, but most of us have the ability to go I've been an asshole lately or that was selfish of me or I was wrong and I'm sorry. And I feel guilt for how know you feel guilt for something that you're not even sure you did and you're worried that you might be, you know, so that in itself suggests that you probably aren't that person. But being the person who wants to be a better person, who wants to take accountability, you really want to figure this out so that you're not the person that you're ex accused you of being. Right. It's a little gaslighty and things like that that maybe your ex did. But again like I always go back to like, like you've heard me go on my soapbox about gaslighting, right? Yeah. You go online and, and people will say if, if, if someone says any of these things to you, you're being gaslit. Right. And, and in, and embedded in, in, in those bullet points is some version of that person calls you crazy. Again, I've never been in a fight with a spouse or a partner or whatever or a friend where we don't at some point in the fight think the other person's kind of crazy. Right. That's why you're fighting, because you don't, you, you think their reality is kind of delusional and it's certainly different than your reality, which is why two people are in conflict. Right? It's, it's gotten to the point people fight. Relationships fight like they're emotionally like triggering. Like the whole point of being in a relationship, like if you can't get triggered by the person you love the most, then, you know, it's like, it's like, you know, that's the crazy thing about romantic relationships is like, they're the ones that trigger us the most and they're the most volatile because they're the most precious to us, you know, and they, you know, and when we get hurt by those people, it really hurts, which sometimes causes fights and which sometimes causes us to say things we don't mean and have to apologize still, like, again, if you're struggling with these thoughts, you know, work on this with your therapist and make sure it's going somewhere, you know, like, break it down. You know, break down a fight that you had and get a, a second ear on. Like, what could you have? You definitely could make improvements as a girlfriend. You know what I'm saying? You can be a better partner. We all can. Can certainly be a better partner. So work on that. I don't think you need to want, you know, like, was I, like, hopefully not. I don't think you were, you know, again, I wasn't there, so I can't say for sure. But the fact that you are even willing to reflect on something that your ex, who has a pattern of unpredictable and reactive and potentially abusive behavior, I wouldn't spend that much emotional energy giving it that much attention or validity to the point where it's really affecting your mental health and emotional well being and it's giving that person, you know, power they don't deserve.

[Lindsay]

No, yeah, I agree. That's a, that's a really good point. I think I'm, I think I'm worried that like, other people in my life might feel this way too and, and not have said anything and she's just the one that actually said it. But again, like, I guess you can.

[Nick]

Is there someone who comes to mind, Mind when you say I'm worried there's other people in my life who might have thought this way. If one person in your life outside of your ex felt this way, who would that be? Does anyone come to mind?

[Lindsay]

Not a specific person, I guess just like friends and family and I guess, I guess there are certain qualities about myself, like talking a lot or being kind of loud and verbose that I, that I wonder, like, do those come off as narcissistic? I just, I really care not about like not being myself because I think that I am comfortable in who I am but more that like other people that I care about are going to be upset or offended based on my behavior.

[Nick]

I mean, listen, you caring so much about what other people think of you is I guess in some ways has a narcissistic point to it.

[Grace]

Right.

[Nick]

A lot of what you're saying seems to be ego driven which is in itself kind of has a narcissistic element to it. It whatever. And yeah, you could work on that for sure. But if no one comes to mind if you're not like, you know what, my best friend Jenny actually I'm, I actually wonder if I, if I have I mistreated her. Have I really taken her for granted? And if you're not having an epiphany about like some crazy shit you've said to her. I mean, yeah, again you've probably been self centered or probably been, you know, if this isn't about. And this is not an exercise to be like, you know, how do I know you? What are my bad habits? Yeah, I'm sure all your closest friends could be like, well, you know, know kind of insufferable. Sometimes when you get like this, you're hard to be around. You're. I don't know, you're really in. I sure we all are but most of us are people who have seasons of this. You're old enough to have probably been a really selfish prick for a half a year at some point in your life. I don't know where you just like totally, you know, especially when we're, when we're the most lost, we're the most self centered, you know, when we're the most like single because we feel justified, you know, like we're all, I'm alone, all my friends have relationships. I don't have what I want yet. Those are really selfish moments of our lives when we are like still chasing our dreams, you know, I don't think that makes you narcissistic. You know when you are in fight or flight mode in a, in a fight, in a relationship, sometimes we say things that are hurtful to that other person. Hopefully you apologized at times when you've, you said things to your partner, you know, took accountability. But yeah, this is not about you, your ex saying some things and then you turning into your ego, wondering if people like you. That's kind of what I'm getting a little bit.

[Lindsay]

Do you have any advice then or perspective I guess on how to balance. Reflecting inward and trying to.

[Sadie]

Yeah.

[Lindsay]

Reflect upon what somebody said about you. And, and do better and sort of like unpack that a bit and think like, what did I do to here versus just unproductive overthinking. Because I feel like I'm defining where that line is.

[Nick]

Put a definition on it. Ask yourself the goal, right? Like the questions I'm asking you, you know, one, like, what am I trying to actually figure out here, right? You can ask yourself that question. You can get to that answer by asking yourself that question. You, you get certain answers or what. How. What is this accomplishing? What am I feeling? What's the, what's the main feeling I have as a result of this rumination? How is it making me feel? If a lot of your answers are, I don't know, then maybe it's a sign that you're ruminating for, for no reasons that you. Or reasons that you can't be honest with yourself about, you know, and again, usually that's just like ego, right? Like, our egos are very tricky because again, like, it comes, usually come. You know, it's like disrespect. Not all ego feelings and thoughts, I think are wrong, right? Like, our egos help us have self respect and to enforce our boundaries and stand up for ourselves. And those are important, important characteristics to have. But the stronger we, the better. The better we are at that, the more at risk we are of our, our vic. Our egos taking over and allowing us to see ourselves more as victims in any given situation. And, and then when that happens, we just kind of go down these rabbit holes. But like, if you can't accomplish anything from your rumination, my guess is it's probably, probably time to challenge yourself to like move on from it and that you're maybe just analyzing it to stay emotionally invested in it. And if you're, I'm an analytical person. We just like breaking down. It's like puzzles in our head. You're emotionally attached to this puzzle. It. It's exciting in some ways. Is, is. It's a challenge.

[Lindsay]

Yeah. It's tricky though, because I feel like I had really detached myself from the puzzle and was, and was doing really, really well emotionally.

[Nick]

Maybe you were.

[Lindsay]

But like this, this info, which is still my responsibility, but that was a.

[Nick]

New piece of the puzzle, right? Like, yeah, you're describing like, you know, I don't know if you've seen like American Treasure, you know, with Nicholas Cage, whatever, and like his family were like these lifetime treasure hunters, kind of addicted to treasure hunting and things like that. And at times they'd be more like obsessed with it. Or not, but like you got a new clue and it was like Nicholas Cage's dad being like, this is just another stupid clue clue. Like we've, we've been following stupid clues our whole life. Right. And he's like, no, but this is a really good clue and you got a clue and now you're just like, oh, now we're back on the treasure hunt, you know.

[Grace]

Totally.

[Nick]

So, yeah, you were fine. You got triggered. You haven't dealt with this trigger in a productive way. Yeah. And you've used this trigger as a way to justify a bad habit you have, which is to overanalyze and ruminate about things and then ones that you're emotionally connected to. It's just that much easier to go down these rabbit holes, but it's not getting you anywhere. It's not accomplishing anything. There's nothing for you to actually solve. And now you're asking yourself questions about yourself that I think deep down you know the answers to.

[Grace]

Yeah.

[Nick]

You know, ironically, it is self indulgent and it is you thinking about yourself. So if you really want to work on this so called narcissism that you're being accused of, prove your ex wrong by letting it go.

[Sadie]

Yeah.

[Lindsay]

And see, like I've, I've, I feel like it's coming from a place of, well, I want to figure out what I did wrong so that I can be a better person to help other people, so that I can be a better therapist one day a better mom, one day a better partner, a better friend. But it is, it ultimately leads back to ego and to myself and then it, and then, and then that fuels the, the, you know, shame of feeling narcissistic or whatever it is.

[Nick]

So again, yeah, once you figure your shit out, in the short run, you'll be a better version of yourself in the long run. But you know, baby steps. Yeah, you're kind of mind fucking yourself by saying, well, I'm doing all this to like again, be a better person, be a better mom. And you've convinced yourself that's the goal, but it's actually like again, that you're not. That's why the ruminating goes nowhere. Because the goal is so broad and so big and kind of just like unspecific that you never ask yourself, what am I actually ruminating about in this moment? And what is the specific thing I'm trying to solve and understand? And that's. And the reason you can't get there is because there's nothing really to solve or understand. You're broken up, you know, that she wasn't right for you. You know that while you weren't a perfect partner, that like you were generally okay, but there is some things you have to work on and that's, and that's that and you, and you're not surprised. And honestly, this information, this clue that you received is not all that surprising. It just confirms what you already thought. And a person who has shown a pattern of this in past relationships said some very hurtful things that really like got under your skin and, and messed you up and, and you should deal with that. But like, that shouldn't require you to stay in your head 24 7. For sure. Yeah.

[Lindsay]

I think there's also an element of this being my first like queer relationship that I'm kind of holding on to that in a certain way. And it's, it's been more difficult because I feel like I'm like holding on to this element of myself that I've like recently let surface. I don't know if that makes sense, but I think that's part of it too.

[Nick]

And I'm just maybe, yeah, I probably have a hard time harder relating to that aspect than you, but I, at the same time, I just think maybe you should give your. Rather than be harder on yourself about it, you should give yourself more grace. This is new for me. A lot of what I'm feeling is new and I'm trying to understand it. So focus on that rather than this. Again, just trying to understand your ex on any level is just a giant waste of your time and energy. Who was I actually dating? You know, a flawed person of which you kind of knew about and that's why you broke up.

[Lindsay]

But is trying to understand myself in relation to what I went through a waste of time?

[Nick]

I mean, you know, maybe a better question for someone a little more experience than me, but like, I think that's, I think you could argue semantics and I think you can debate that. I think deep down you know the answer and it's just striking that balance. It's just having balance in your life and it's just reminding yourself a couple times a day that your ego exists, that it needs to be constantly kept in check, that it's going to cause you to focus your energy on unproductive things that are more ego driven rather than things that are actually worth your time and make you happy. And you kind of know the answer. And ruminating over it is really just something to do and entertaining.

[Lindsay]

It's wild how you can know one thing that isn't you can know that this isn't productive and that you don't want to be stuck in this, but there's some part of you that's clinging to it for God knows what reason. So.

[Nick]

I have found that in those moments, the answer is almost always your ego.

[Sadie]

Yeah.

[Nick]

And the more you get enlightened about your ego, the harder it is to just, you know, check yourself. But, like, it's also. It can be easy to do and just be like, yeah, I mean, all right. Like, it never goes away. Your ego isn't something you conquer and eliminate. It's something you learn to control. It's a superpower that, left unchecked, can kind of turn into this nasty virus that can take control of your life and cause you to do hopefully out of character things. When kept in check, it can be something that's really helpful for you to stand up for yourself, know your self worth, set and communicate and enforce your boundaries, and know how to say no to unhealthy people and choices and situations. Then it's really productive. And every day, like, the more enlightened you become, the better you are at every day kind of workshopping those kind of competing emotions on every day. There's some version of that conversation you probably need to have with yourself. But ruminating is a sign of the ego, I think, having more control than you want to acknowledge. I think ruminating is a sign of a lack of acceptance, especially when there's no specific goal of what you're ruminating over. When there's not a, Like a. Oh, all right. I need to. This is my problem. I want to solve this problem. And as a result of the problem, I'm going to ruminate. You're just like, I feel this icky feeling. I want to understand this feeling that I'm having. I want to just keep. I want to figure it out. And you don't even know the problem.

[Lindsay]

Right.

[Nick]

Or the problem is. Or the problem is. This is some vague, general thing.

[Sadie]

Right?

[Lindsay]

No, I think there's an element of being just having had a lot of anxiety for my entire life and almost feeling some weird sense of comfort in that. Even though on the surface I don't like my anxiety. It's not productive, it's not pleasurable, but there's an element of comfort. If I let it go, what will happen? You know what I'm saying?

[Nick]

Yeah. Well, thanks for the call. Keep us updated on how you work through this, and we'd love an update, and hopefully this is helpful.

[Lindsay]

Thanks so much, Nick.

[Nick]

All right, take care. Take care. All right.

[Grace]

Bye.

[Nick]

Sam.