E990 – Going Deeper with The Nader Sisters - The Viall Files

Transcript

A (0:00)

The five Houses is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Hey, you chose to hit play on this podcast today. Smart Choice make another smart choice with Auto Quote Explorer to compare rates from multiple car insurance companies all at once. Try it@progressive.com Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates not available in all states or situations. Prices vary based on how you buy.

B (0:20)

Ever notice how ads always pop up.

C (0:22)

At the worst moments when the killer's.

B (0:25)

Identity is about to be revealed during.

D (0:29)

That perfect meditation flow On Amazon Music.

B (0:33)

We believe in keeping you in the moment.

D (0:36)

That's why we've got millions of ad free podcast episodes so you can stay completely immersed in every story, every reveal, every breath.

B (0:46)

Download the Amazon Music app and start.

D (0:48)

Listening to your favorite podcasts.

B (0:50)

Ad free.

D (0:51)

Included with Prime Symbiotic is for anyone who's doing all the right things but still doesn't feel their best. Because true wellness starts at the cellular level with science backed high absorption supplements designed to travel with you and work with your body. Symbiotica helps you feel more like you.

A (1:07)

Seriously, if you are like us, you want to take care of your body and your wellness matters to you. And if you've tried vitamins before, I don't know about you, but I've I'll try them for a week or two. I'll get off the cycle because I'm traveling. I'm always on the go. It's easy to forget, but not with Symbiotica. Their travel custom made packets make it easy to stay consistent and keep using those vitamins that are great for you and your wellness.

D (1:32)

It only takes 30 seconds a day to get all the nutrients that you need. They have formula to support your health goals from everything from energy, digestion, immunity and mood. You just throw them into your purse, throw them into your carry on, leave them in your car. I don't know what you're doing, but they're so easy to take. So Symbiotica is one of the most trustworthy brands out there. They never compromise on quality and sourcing. Their products are free from seed oils, preservatives, toxins or artificial additives. It's something you can taste and feel in every packet. Well, something I love about Symbiotica is that they actually taste delicious and you know they're working. Go to symbiotica.com v I a l l to get 20% off plus free shipping. That's C-Y-M-B-I-O-T-I-K-A.com v I a l l for 20% off plus free shipping.

Summary

The Viall Files — E990: Going Deeper with The Nader Sisters
Release Date: August 27, 2025
Host: Nick Viall with Natalie Joy and The Household
Guests: The Nader Sisters — Brooks, Grace Ann, Sarah Jane (“SJ”/Gan), Mary Holland

Main Theme & Purpose

This special "Going Deeper" episode welcomes the Nader Sisters—stars of the buzzy new reality series, Love Thy Nader—for a candid, lively, and hilarious roundtable about Southern family life, religion, relationships, reality TV, heartbreak, sexuality, and the meaning of authenticity in the reality TV era. The sisters and Nick Viall explore how their upbringing shaped them, how family boundaries adapt (or don’t) for TV, the emotional fallout from high-profile breakups, and the unique sisterhood that defines their show.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Identity, Upbringing, and Family Dynamics

(02:25–05:38)

The Nader sisters introduce themselves, share fun name stories, and reflect on their close Southern upbringing.
Nick: “Did you ladies grow up feeling like you were stars?”
Brooks: “I think we thought it was normal to just be so close and crazy and naked, but moving to New York made us realize how rare that bond is.” (04:49)
They explain the genesis of Love Thy Nader: “It kind of fell in our laps... almost divine timing.” (05:18, Brooks)

2. Approach to Reality TV & Setting Boundaries

(06:33–09:52)

The sisters agree on authenticity: “You get one shot. We’re just gonna throw it all on the table. Fully be yourself. There's really no other option.” (06:49, SJ)
Some off-limits topics—mainly relationships for those in them when filming started.
Family, particularly their parents, decided, “screw it, let’s just do it,” even filming real-life events like job resignations.

3. Career Sacrifices and Evolution

(09:52–11:26)

Mary Holland shares about quitting her five-year corporate job at Deutsche Bank to join the show: “Now they’re my biggest fans; they’re throwing a watch party.” (10:17)
Nick connects, “Someone who used to work in corporate America, I don’t miss it.” (10:33)

4. Navigating Criticism and Public Scrutiny

(11:26–12:19)

Brooks talks about protecting her sisters from online hate: “People start to rip on them already... appearances, weight, you know, all the things.” (11:17)
“When you go on TV, they’ll tell you you’re ugly,” Nick adds, to laughter.

5. Relationship Talk—Boyfriends, Boundaries, Breakups, Divorce

(13:12–28:16)

They discuss dating, old-man “dilf” jokes, and rules: “The guys we fuck cannot be uglier than Dad.” (12:44, SJ)
Childhood: Pastors' kids, started poor, religious, then Dad transitioned to finance. “Football and God was like our entire life.” (16:23, Brooks)
Brooks details her Sports Illustrated “big break”: attended an open casting after being told, “They would never look at you twice…then I ended up sending a signed copy of my cover to that agency.” (21:59, Brooks)
Divorce: Brooks opens up about her divorce from her first boyfriend/husband, meeting at 19, the difficulty of leaving, “Just because you don’t love somebody, that’s why I did it.” (23:25, Brooks)
How the family dealt: “We watched her fall apart…divorce was not okay growing up. My parents didn’t take it very well at first.” (25:19, Mary Holland)

6. The Gleb Saga: Dancing with the Stars, Romance, Heartbreak, and Scandal

(31:06–51:20)

Brooks' post-divorce relationship with pro dancer Gleb Savchenko is dissected in detail:
- “I said, give me the hottest, douchiest fuck boy…and there he was.” (31:38, Brooks)
- The relationship turned toxic—love bombed, boundary-crossed, intense PDA.
- Discovery of cheating: Gleb left his phone in an Uber, which led to the sisters investigating and uncovering a pattern of infidelity.
  - “He left his phone in the car…Uber driver just showed up…as any girl would, we got in.” (39:01–39:07, Brooks/SJ)
- Nick: “He checks a lot of (love bomber/gaslighter) boxes…It’s like he was raised that as long as you say ‘I love you’ you can do whatever you want.” (47:06/47:21)
- The sisters affirm the show is about their family, not Gleb, and how the ordeal strengthened their sibling bond.

7. Sex, Upbringing, and Breaking with Tradition

(54:48–76:41, interspersed)

Candid conversation about sex—past religious guilt, “True Love Waits” pledge rings, sneaking around, and the normalization of sexual openness as adults.
Brooks: “I had a whole hand of promise rings because I hoodwinked…I fucked up, had sex, but needed a new ring, and then I’d have sex again.” (75:17–75:27)
SJ details coming out to her family—how she told her sisters and parents, their journey from confusion to support.

8. Family, Religion, and Modern Values

(64:16–69:11)

Kids? Most want big families, but “no pressure” from parents except at holidays.
- “I think we'll all have a lot of kids. I feel no pressure. The only time I feel pressure is when I go home.” (64:50, Brooks)
Faith: Most sisters still identify as Christian in some form, but Mary Holland openly identifies as more spiritual/agnostic.
- “I’m not atheist…I’m spiritual more so.” (66:10, Mary Holland)
Parental evolution: Their parents’ religious beliefs have become more progressive as the sisters grew.

9. Sisterhood, Petty Fights, Independence, and Style Battles

(56:15–83:55)

The sisters’ banter and squabbles on everything from skincare luggage to photo shoot outfit choices highlight their raw, genuine connection and the “mother figure” role of Brooks.
Discussion about who is most independent, who gets picked on most (Grace Ann), and family styles (“I do just wear whatever I want—very Carrie Bradshaw…it’s refreshing.” (83:05, Brooks)).

10. Accents, Family Participation, and Comparisons

(83:25–86:29)

Southern accents—how they worked to minimize them for modeling/acting, but “it comes out when we go home.”
Family—including parents and grandma—are all-in for the show: “They will do anything for us.”
Parental pride: Dad’s got four TVs ready to boost ratings; grandma’s emotional support for every episode.

11. Pop Culture, Show Reception, and Legacy

(86:29–88:09)

Comparisons—the sisters embrace “OG Keeping Up With the Kardashians” and early-2000s reality, but with their own uniquely Southern, outsider twist.
Natalie Joy: “It’s very much OG Keeping Up With the Kardashians in the best way…” (86:43)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments (with Timestamps)

On Authenticity in Reality TV:
“If you try to fake things or hide things, it does come out. So it’s like, yeah, our whole approach, we were like, let’s just do it and free ball it.” (06:49, Sarah Jane)
On Family Support:
“Our biggest thing was we didn’t want to walk away and be like, we could have put more on the table… Our goal was just to be as raw and open as we could.” (09:52, Brooks)
On Southern, Religious Upbringing:
"Our whole upbringing was centered around Christian camps and, you know, sports and Christianity… football and God was like our entire life." (16:23, Brooks)
On Handling Criticism:
“People start to rip on them already…appearances, weight, all the things.” (11:17, Brooks)
On Sexuality and Coming Out:
"When you come out, whether your parents are supportive or not, it's like a death of an expectation… It's not necessarily good or bad, it's just changing what you are imagining for your daughter." (69:11, Sarah Jane/SJ)
On Sisterhood:
“Watching back, the beautiful part is seeing how my family rallied around me... usually I’m the one taking care of others, but they came to my defense and were there at my bedside with breakfast and tissues.” (50:16, Brooks)
On Gleb — The “Hot Mess” Appearance:
“I was like, give me the hottest, douchiest f*** boy in the whole roster… and so there he was.” (31:38, Brooks)
On Being Southern in NYC:
“When you move to New York, you’re kind of insecure about it in modeling… None of the girls had the accent.” (83:39, Brooks)

Important Segments by Timestamp

02:25–05:38: Sister introductions, childhood bonds, path to reality TV
06:33–09:52: Philosophy of authenticity, boundary-setting on reality show
13:12–28:16: Relationships, dating older men, career journeys, family money discussions, childhood finances, divorce and heartbreak
31:06–51:20: The Gleb relationship arc, cheating discovery, emotional aftermath, family unity
54:48–76:41: Sex, religion, coming out, and changing traditions
83:25–86:29: Accents, parents joining reality TV, family-wide support
86:41–88:09: Cultural comparisons, early-2000s reality nostalgia, what sets their show apart

Tone & Language

The Nader Sisters exude fast-talking, hilarious, loving, and self-deprecating Southern energy. Their candor about sex, money, trauma, and family mess is balanced by warmth and supportive “ride-or-die” sisterhood. Nick matches their informality and openness, sharing his own big-family and religious background to elicit honest, revealing answers.

Summary Takeaways

Love Thy Nader is not just a reality show—it’s about the complex love and chaos of four Southern sisters navigating modern life, love, sex, and religion in New York.
The sisters promise authenticity, rawness, and no-holds-barred openness—hallmark traits of reality TV’s golden age, with a contemporary, post-religious, Southern twist.
Family, both as source of challenges and the ultimate support network, is at the heart of the sisterhood and the show.
The Gleb relationship saga is dramatic, but it’s ultimately a vehicle to showcase the sisters’ resilience and loyalty.
The sisters juggle modern dating, evolving beliefs, and being role models for the next generation of “reality families”—with warmth, wit, and a healthy appetite for drama.

Recommended for: Anyone who enjoys honest, hilarious, and insightful depictions of modern sisterhood, reality TV authenticity, and Southern family culture—with plenty of tea spilled and wisdom shared.