
Loading summary
Victor Davis Hanson
Folks, I have to tell you about our dear friends at American Alternative Assets, the number one gold and silver company in America. Nobody understands what's happening to your retirement savings better than they do. With Trump's return, we'll see some amazing positive changes. But his actions on trade and the fight with China could lead to even more inflation, which has already been eating away at your savings. The folks over at American Alternative Assets created a special wealth protection guide that explains in simple terms how to protect what you've already worked for. You know, most Americans don't realize that every time the government prints more money, it makes your savings worth less. The guide explains why smart Americans are moving their retirement savings to precious metals IRAs. Right now they're offering our listeners up to $10,000 in free silver precious plus a free safe, a $400 value. These are patriots we trust to help protect American families. Visit aaagold.net Hanson and tell them Victor sent you.
Sammy Wink
Hello and welcome to the Victor Davis Hanson Show. This is our Friday news roundup and there's lots of news this week. Of course we'll probably talk a little bit about the fires, but more importantly, Jack Smith issued his day after he one day after he resigned from his position. And also we have Hamas deal in the making with Israel. So stay with us and we'll be back for those news stories.
Victor Davis Hanson
Running a small business means you're wearing a lot of hats. Your personal phone number becomes your business phone and before you know it, you're juggling customer calls day after and night. As your team grows, it becomes impossible to manage without your personal number. That's where OpenPhone comes in. OpenPhone is the number one business phone system. OpenPhone will help you separate your personal life from your growing business. For just $15 a month, the cost of a few cups of coffee, you can get complete transparency and visibility into everything happening with your business phone number. OpenPhone works through an app on your phone or computer and integrates with HubSpot and hundreds of other systems. It's affordable and easy to use. Whether you're a one person operation and need help managing calls automatically or have a large team and need better tools for efficient collaboration, Openphone is a no brainer. Plus they've won multiple awards by G2 for software reviews and are trusted by by over 50,000 businesses. Right now, Openphone is offering 20% off your first six months when you go to openphone.comVictor that's O P N P H O-N E.comVictor for 20% off six months openphone.comVictor and if you have existing numbers with another service open phone will port them over at no extra charge. Before we continue, I want to tell you about a great American company we trust, American Alternative Assets. Like many of you, they understand what's really happening to our nation's financial strength. And they're helping patriotic Americans protect their retirement savings. As someone who studied America's history for decades, I'm concerned about what I'm seeing. For the first time ever, our great nation is spending more on interest payments than on our military. That's why I asked our friends at American Alternative Assets to share their wealth protection guide. The guide explains why smart Americans are moving their retirement savings to precious metals IRAs. These are true patriots who understand American values. Right now they're offering our listeners up to $10,000 in in free silver plus a free American made safe. They'll show you how generations of Americans have protected their wealth during uncertain times. Visit aaagold.net hansen and tell them Victor sent you Support an American company that puts American families first.
Sammy Wink
Welcome back to the Victor Davis Hanson Show. Victor is the Martin and Neely Anderson Senior Fellow, Military History and Classics at the Hoover Institute Institution and the Wayne Marshaleski Distinguished Fellow in History at Hillsdale College. You can find him at his website, victorhanson.com the name of the website is the Blade of Perseus. And please come join us there for $5 a month or $50 a year. And you can read the VDH Ultra material. And also now we have a about a 5 to 10 minute video each Friday for our Ultra subscribers and you will have access to that as well. Well, Victor, there seems to have been a fine. I mean, they seem to be getting closer to a deal, Hamas and Israel, that there will be some release of 34 hostages in the initial phase of the deal. They don't know whether the hostages are dead or alive. I have to say there will be a pause in the fighting and a release of Palestinian prisoners. And it sounds like hundreds for a few prisoners from Israel. And then the final thing is they're demanding aid to the Gaza Strip. And that was according to a CNN article. And I know that there's other, other things out there, but what are your thoughts on this deal?
Victor Davis Hanson
There's all these different catalysts at work and they're mutually exclusive. So before we can figure out whether it's a good or bad deal and we should say the captives, hostages, there's a lot of Americans among them, which is why Trump is interested, not that he's not Interested in Israeli prisoners, but especially Americans. So what are these factors? Number one, Trump is not in office. I'm speaking on a Tuesday, the 14th. So if this was 2017, they would be invoking. They being his political opponents, would evoke the Logan Act. How dare you. This is what they got. Michael Flynn. So the degree to which the special envoy. Is his name Weisskopf or something? To the degree. And he's a businessman. He's got kind of a. He was in financial trouble and the Qatari government at one point in the distant past helped him get out of it. But he's a blunt speaking, non diplomatic person and he supposedly has gone over there and said to Netanyahu, when Trump comes in, I don't want any Americans help. Okay, that's number one. So it's in a transitional period. Two, we don't know the degree to which all the 13 cabinet level appointees are jumping the proverbial gun. So why this is going on? What's Michael Waltz doing, the National Security Advisor. What's Pete Hexeth? He's not even confirmed. Waltz doesn't have to be, but he's not in office yet. And then there's Marco Rubio. So the people who will make these decisions in the Middle east are of course Trump, but a troika of Rubio, Waltz and Hexeth, and I think he will be appointed DoD, State Department, National Security Advisor and National Security Council. They're not in power. But this, they're all pretty much not the neo isolationist base, the Steve Bannon. They're more Jacksonian. No Better friend, no Worse enemy. Kill. Soleimani bomb, Baghdadi bomb, like that kind of stuff of the first administrator. So there's that second. Does anybody believe that if Israel pulls back and withdraws from Gaza, which is one of the demands of Hamas, that Hamas will what, dissipate? Oh, we didn't mean it on October 7th. No, there are. The only reason they're talking is three reasons. Number one, they're afraid of Donald Trump. When I say they are afraid, that means they are afraid that their Iranian patron is saying, look, I want you to get rid of those American hostages. Give them back or they're going to bomb us or somebody will. Or two, they're Turkish, they're new Turkish sponsors because Turkey is kind of filling the void now. And Turkey is a NATO ally and they're calling up Trump. You know, we're a NATO ally. Da, da, da, da, da. That's number two. And then number three, they feel that these Israelis are going to wipe them out or not wipe them out, but I don't mean that the whole but can defeat them. So then you look at the deal. They want humanitarian aid. They're no position as losers to demand anything. They want Israel not just to have a ceasefire, but basically declare the war over and get out of Gaza. Mr. Hamas, whoever you are now, because most of your leaders are dead, I want to tell you that they did not go into your country. They don't want any, they don't have any desire to go in. You went in their country and you murdered 1200 plus people in a medieval fashion. And that's why you're in the position that you are. And all the people you boasted about for a year, the Iranians, the Houthis, Assad, they've all been attrited, they're all diminished. So now you're in the 11th hour and you want us, basically the subtext of this is help us, help us. They're gonna, they're gonna destroy Hamas. We're almost gone. Can anybody help us? Oh, Donald Trump. Now how can we flip Donald Trump? Well, Donald Trump wants to be Ronald Reagan in 1980. So Reagan said there will be no hostages. Mr. Reagan, Mr. Reagan. Jimmy Carter has not been able to bring the hostage on. You're going to take office any day. What's your plans? Well, there's no, they're not going to be any hostages. That was a very dramatic thing to say and it did force Iran. Now we're 45 years later, we've got the same problem with Iran. And Trump wants to be a Reagan. Well, who wouldn't? So Reagan is, Trump is saying, you better. But unlike Reagan, he's more explicit. I'm going to bomb, do whatever you have to. Give up these hostages. But here's the problem. Does Donald Trump, he wants to be the person to get the hostages. He wants the person to end the war. But when he sends an envoy who has not legal authority yet in the transition and reportedly, I don't know if it's true or not, pressured on the Sabbath, Netanyahu to do what? Get out, don't go into the last 25% of Gaza, end the war, allow humanitarian and release hundreds, if not thousands of terrorists, some of which were probably involved in October 7th, is that going to reflect well on the Trump administration? And when you look at the advisors who will have Middle east portfolios, unlike this special envoy you're talking about Mike Huckleby, Ambassador to Israel, Pete Hegseth, Marco Rubio, Michael Walt, they all have one Thing in common, they're very strong Israel supporters. This deal is not going over. The rumors of this deal is not going over well among the Israelis. Their attitude is we want the hostages there. But if you're Donald Trump and you're our savior, and we think you are our savior, only you can get the hostages back without us having to release all these terrorists. And not to finish the job because Mr. Trump, 85, 75% of Gaza we went in, there are no terrorists. We got. They're all in this last little enclave and that's who's negotiating. And they're terrified. If we can go into that enclave and eliminate them, there will be no need. And you can just tell them you're going to surrender and get out of Gaza and you're going to release the hostages, American and Israeli. And if you don't, this is what's going to happen to you. This is what's going to happen to the Houthis, this is what's going to happen to Hezbollah, and this is what's going to happen to Iran. Starting with Iran. And I guarantee you he might be successful. But to put a special envoy with no legal authority during the transition to fly over to Israel, who's a businessman and has had some prior business relationships with Gutter, which is not really pro Israeli, it's anti Israeli. And then to have him strong arm Netanyahu to stop the war in medias. Reyes Rebus. It's not good. Not good.
Sammy Wink
Well, Victor, the, the other story that came out this week that was probably one of the more interesting is that Jack Smith did resign, but the day after he resigned, he also released his report where he claimed, and if you ask me in a very cowardly fashion, that Trump would have been convicted of conspiracy to defraud the United States if he had not won the election. What does that mean in a report at this point?
Victor Davis Hanson
That means I wasted millions of dollars and I was appointed special prosecutor after Joe Biden demanded that I be appointed after denying that he had any influence on Merrick Garland. And I had no legal authority because the special counsel statute had expired. So this was just, I wasn't a special counsel. I was just an appendage of Merrick Garland and Joe Biden's Department of, of Justice. And I was appointed on the same day that Michael Coangelo, Mr. Coangelo, third ranking person in the department in which I work for, resigned. And he had come from Lakita James hit team and he would now go back to Alvin Bragg's hit team and the day that I was appointed, Mr. Nathan Wade from Fanny Willis's operation was also meeting with the White House House counsel. So this was a political hit from the very beginning. He's angry that he was incompetent. Number one, there was nothing, there was no proof that Donald Trump had done anything different than Joe Biden. He had taken documents that were labeled classified. Maybe some there were more classified than Joe Biden. But the special counsel, his counterpart, Mr. Her, found out that Joe Biden had put them in more places than Donald Trump for a longer period of time in less secure areas and had disclosed classified documents to somebody who had no clearance, such as his own ghostwriter, who then broke the law and destroyed subpoena, subpoenaed evidence in the fashion of Hillary Clinton and all of that. He said the same thing. He could have been indicted and but he would be too sympathetic because he was a older man with a feeble memory. And of course the left got angry. They said if you're going to indict him, indict him. But if you're not going to indict him, don't tell us why that's disparaging him. That's as if he was guilty. But that's not for you to make you indict him or if you don't indict him, he's innocent. Okay, Using their own logic, then he's innocent.
Sammy Wink
Victor, I would like to take a moment for our sponsor Factor Ready to optimize your nutrition. This year, Factor has chef made gourmet meals that make eating well easy. They're dietitian approved and ready to heat and eat in two minutes. You can feel right and feel great no matter what life throws at you. Factor arrives fresh and fully prepared, perfect for any active, busy lifestyle. Choose from preferences like Calorie Smart, Protein plus or Keto Factor can help you feel your best all day long with wholesome smoothies, breakfasts, grab and go snacks and more add ons. Reach your goals this year with ingredients you can trust and convenience that can't be beat. Eat smart with Factor. Get started@factor meals.com Victor 50 off and use code Victor 50 off to get 50% off your first box. Plus free shipping. That's code Victor 50 off@factor meals.com Victor50 off to get 50% off plus free shipping on your first box. Thank you Factor for sponsoring the Victor Davis Hansen Show. Well, Victor, there's been a lot going on in la, of course, with the fires and some new things that have shown up this week in the news. Are the excessive amount of looting. In fact, we saw a sign on one owner's house that said owner home and have gun beware. Elon Musk has provided the Internet for areas that were hit by the fire particularly hard. And a real estate investor, Keith Wasserman, asked for private firefighters. So the news came out to defend his home and he got a lot of pushback on social media with that. So I was wondering your thoughts on any or all of the.
Victor Davis Hanson
Well, let's go in the order that you enumerated them. Number one, there's looters. Somebody wrote me, I had been on Fox and I mentioned that and they said, well, why would there be looters? Because it's all burned down. Well, no, it's not. You're talking about. I don't want to give anybody any ideas, so bear with me. But you're talking about one of the wealthiest zip codes in the United States. So one would imagine then every single one of those majestic houses there were some safes. And in the safe there was everything from bonds to weapons to jewelry to gold bars, everything. And maybe not even in the safe, just in well kept places like this bookcase or something. And they will be in pernicious, they will not be burned up. You know, they're not flammable and so many of them won't be, especially in a safe. So there's a huge amount of money that's tempting these looters that are even dressed up as fire protection people and worse yet is they're in Los Angeles. So they understand this was the era of George Gascon and they haven't got the message yet that he was recalled. So they think that it's open season, they can just go steal and take things and wander around. There's not going to be any consequences. So it's very important. I don't know why Gavin Newsom doesn't have the National Guard there right now just patrolling every street. He needs to do that immediately. And then there's people who live there every, I don't know, 50th house there seems to be for some reason they're standing. But they have no electricity and they have no water and they have no sewage. So there's people living in there and that has to be addressed. The second thing is about Elon Musk. I don't understand why the left, hey, I understand why the left hates him. But just as he did in the Carolinas during the flood, he has this brilliant idea that cyber trucks with this huge £7,000 of batteries if you don't use the batteries for transportation and you position them strategically on a grid, then they can offer Starlink and power the Starlink. So he's taking all of these cybertrucks, apparently hundreds of them, and he's putting them in key places and then he's opening up Starlink free. So all the first responders, all of the people who are trying to find out who's alive, can communicate on the Internet.
Sammy Wink
That's amazing.
Victor Davis Hanson
And he is doing more than almost any. A lot more than the mayor is doing. A lot more than the deputy mayor for safety, who's basically under a house arrest for phoning in a bomb threat or the allegations of such. But it's a larger question about Elon Musk is they've been going after him. They say he's a billionaire. He's too close. Well, you never said that about George Soros who destroyed that basically destroyed the prosecutorial system in our major cities. You never said that about billionaire Reid Hoffman that funded the whole bogus E. Jean Carroll suit. You never said that about Mark Zuckerberg put on $419 million to absorb the work of the Registrars 2020 election. You only do it about Elon because he flipped. Part of it is, I love my Tesla, but I hate the man who made it. Now. So every time I drive around my beloved Tesla and Tesla I know is better than all the other EVs, but every time I get in it, it's an advertisement for. Oh no, for a pro Trump person. So they have that frustration and then there's fear. They're thinking, wow, nobody can break into the top three. GM, Chrysler, he did. He's the first person. The DeLorean never did. No, but Studebaker, American Martyrs, he did. And then they're thinking, well, he bought x. He paid $30 billion too much. It wasn't worth over 10 billion. He paid 40 billion something 50. Yes. And he revolutionized the whole idea of social media and he created a stampede. And now you have Mark Zuckerberg, who's following in the footsteps of Elon and the Google people.
Sammy Wink
But you also have Mark Zuckerberg who said that he couldn't possibly have gone against the government and apparently Elon did.
Victor Davis Hanson
That's the other frustration difference. I don't know who would have won their cage fight. Elon's much older and Mark Zuckerberg's kind of buff, but Elon's a much more courageous person. And then you have the rocket who, if you had said Elon is going to Save NASA from itself. And he's going to launch a dozen, two dozen satellites every month. Nobody would have believed you. My point is this. So now they're thinking Elon is going to cut with Ramaswamy and this Doge thing. That's silly. He can't cut a trillion. He can. He did it with NASA, he did it with Tesla and he did it with X. So he can do it. So they hate him and they're afraid of him. And so anytime he comes in the news, they trash him. And now he's interfering, they think interfering over in Europe. He's telling the Europeans that they. What is he telling Europeans? The latest is he's retweeting list of Labour Party members who have been interfering, not alleged, but convicted of pedophilia. And that is in response to the you shouldn't meddle. I want to remind the British Labour Party you sent over and put it on the Internet, 100 foreign nationals. And if they didn't register as foreign agents and none of them did, they were breaking US election law, federal law. That's a felony. And they did did it in 2004 when they went to Ohio. And they always get away with it. And then as leftist Europeans, they say, oh, United States in fear. You interfere in our elections. And you. And we interfere in the Ukrainian elections and we interfered especially in the Israeli elections. So he. He's doing a wonderful job. And he's hated because they're envious and fearful of him. So that was eluding. And then the mosque question. And your third one was.
Sammy Wink
Oh, about the guy who got. I'm sorry. Oh, about the guy who got his house, who tried to get private fire.
Victor Davis Hanson
That's the reason I'm asking.
Sammy Wink
But there's actually two more village was saved.
Victor Davis Hanson
Yeah. So there's a question there. This goes back to Marcus Licinius Crassus, the first triumvir. And he made his fortune. He was considered. There's a book, I think, by F.E. adcock, Marcus Crassus Millionaire, and it's about a biography of crosses, how he ended up, remember, decapitated. And I think the import. That scene in Game of Thrones where they poor God gold into Danny's brother.
Sammy Wink
Yeah. I think.
Victor Davis Hanson
Yes. That comes from Marcus Licinius Crass's Life of Plutarch, where they poured molten gold. It's kind of. Well, you're a billionaire and you're greedy. Here's some gold to go out with. Then they decapitated his head and used it in Euripides. Euripides Bacchae when the head of Pentheus is carried in. So they performed it. So my point is he was notorious in Rome and he would pull up with a private fire brigade, said fire, so how much is your four story Roman villa worth? Well, here's what I can do to save it. And there was always the allegation that he was lighting fire. I don't know if that was true or not. So there's this long history of anger at private fire services because they favor the wealthy. But this is a little different for a lot of reasons. Number one, if you're against it, you have to assume that the private firefighter would not would have been otherwise employed by the Los Angeles Fire Department or in some kind of volunteer brigade. There's been some heroic brigades, but that's not. There's a lot of manpower in Los Angeles. So I don't believe. And these people don't really have proven skills. They're not necessarily trained to the same degree as firemen as the union reminds us every second. So my point is, in greater LA of 20 million people, do you really believe that 4 or 5,000 who are being employed by private people would have the means? Therefore they have, they're taking resources from the fire department? I don't think so. Number two, when they go into a row of houses in Malibu or up in Brentwood now, or Bel Air now or parts of and they go in, what do they do? They clear the brush, they turn off the gas and they usually spray the whole house with fire retardant or they spray it with water, soak it. And they're not all hired, by the way, by the private owner. A lot of them are hired by the insurance companies. So up. And I've mentioned this before, my house was almost burned to a crisp in Huntington during Huntington Lake in Central California Sierras during the Aspen fire. And it just survived by heroic action of the firefighters. But here's the point. There were 400 cabins that were over 100 years old built on forest service land. And when this huge fire, and by the way, it was due to the same type of lack of forest management, they didn't glean. Everybody up there said, please glean the forest. Let the loggers come in after the drought and take these trees. They wouldn't do it. So when they started to go up, the insurance companies came to their clients and said, let us send somebody. So sometimes they sent these aluminum blankets because their homes were not big and they put, put reflective heat resistant blankets. And when you drove after the fire There were some there that survived. So it's not just wealthy owners, it's people have insurance policies with particular companies. And then number three, if you've got nine houses in a row and two are saved, you're putting fires out. You're not turning the fires to another one. You're reducing the fire so it has some utility. Any house you can save is dampening the fire. So they are. Maybe it's hit and miss and they're not on a united front like the fire department with a strategy, but even the freelancing helps. And then number four, what's going to happen when the fires are out? They have to recover economically. So I know you'll, our listeners will say, well Victor, this Caruso guy, he's going to make a fortune because he saved this billion dollar. Yes, he is. But on the other hand, the people who in the next year or two or three who have crews to clean up and they're going to be pouring cement, they're going to be raising the walls of houses, they're going to want to eat, they're going to want to buy stuff and they don't have any facilities. So the more people that are saved and the quicker you can get the community back. If you can get wealthy people to come back there, maybe they'll clean up. The only thing that bothers me is this. It's not the private, it's this tragedy that if you go through that area, it is so wealthy and so majestic. The homes. But there are homes of rich 80 year pedigrees that look beautiful. The Spanish style Southern California. You go buy them, they're white stucco, they have the red tile roof, kind of adobe look with white. And then they have tropical plants. They're beautiful, but they're not, they're not mansions, if you know what I mean. So they, then they're second generation or third. So typically a person's parents died, they're working in LA, they inherited a 2200 square home and let's say they inherited in 1980 when they were in their 30s and it was worth 300,400. Well now it's worth 5 or 6 million. But they don't have the income and they're Prop 13. So they, they can only maintain it because they inherited it directly from their parents and they didn't change the title with a sibling or something. So my point is they're out. So they have this lot that's worth a lot of money but they do not have the wherewithal to rebuild the insurance Will not cover the insurance. Will cover the price maybe of a 20, 200 square foot in theory, but not during a rush when everybody's trying to get help and labor and supplies. It's going to be 6, $700 a square foot, easy. And so my point is there's going to be a lot of people come into that area. Speculators and investors are going to say, you know what, there's your house, you inherit from your parents. I know it was worth 4 million, but their insurance is not going to pay because the lot, lot's probably worth 2 million. It's not going to pay for the repair and it's a mess. And do you really want to live in a tent for three years? I will give you a million dollars for the lot or something. And that's going to change the nature of that community. It's going to make it even more exclusive unless the state comes in. This is even scarier. I was on Laura Ingram last night and comes in with its utopian idea that we're going to make a 15 minute city, that this is a chance to experiment on these lab rats. We're going to high rises all over Pacific Palisades. No country western, no western home, no quarter acre lot, no pool. You're all going to live like little rats in a apartment condo 20. And then we're going to have a little green space and then you're going to get there with your new LA light rail. Why we sit in, I don't know, five acre estates in Beverly Hills or Brentwood or. And dictate to how you live. I don't think that's going to happen. But that's what they want to happen.
Sammy Wink
Yeah, they won't let that happen.
Victor Davis Hanson
Well, they being that line, it's in a wild bunch when they're tricked and they get these worthless washers and, and they scream, I think it's Warren. Oh, it said they. And Edmund O'Brien said they. Who was they they? So when you say they they, who, who are they? It's the wealthy. The wealthy will not let that happen. They will call. Hey, Gavin, I gave you a million bucks in your campaign. Hey, city council, I funded you. And they will not let that happen. The only mystery is are they finally going to make the connection that they cannot always avoid the consequences of their ideology? They're subject to it on a rare occasions. This was a rare occasion. I know that their kids are in prep school and they hate teachers unions. Excuse me? They love teachers unions and they hate charter schools and their Kids in private school, I know that they like green power, 40 cent kilowatt because they don't care about people in Fresno. They're 105 with no money and can't afford air conditioning. I know that they love the idea. They, they love the idea of $6 gas, save the planet because they don't care. They love the idea of 13% taxes because they would rather have. They make so much money. They don't care about 13% tax. It's the people from, you know, 100 to 500 that get killed, not the people who make 10, 20 million a year. So. But this time they lost their home and they will probably be angry and we'll see how long it lasts.
Sammy Wink
Yeah, we'll see how long it lasts. They had a, interviewed a young girl on one of the Fox evening shows and she said Karen Bass is making a mockery of the Democratic Party. And so I don't think she understood that it was the Democratic Party that gave birth to Karen Bass. But she thought maybe somehow the party was different from what Karen Bass.
Victor Davis Hanson
So you vote for Karen Bass. And that came up in whatever you think of Caruso. He is a proven guy that knows how to make money. He would work for the government for a while. He's done everything right. I don't think he's conservative, but he's competent. That says a lot in Los Angeles. Or you've got a woman who was in Congress that was head of the Black caucus who what, 12 times went down to see El Jefe. And when he died, she said, she tweeted that El Commande, El Jefe, Castro, Marta, you know, in mourning for this mass murdering Castro. And she promises she's not going to go because she had a reputation as an itinerant junketeer when she was in Congress. Well, I'll stay in Los Angeles. And of course she gets reelected. What's the first thing she got reelected? Just got reelected. And what's the first thing she does? She junkets to where to find her roots in Ghana. It's not necessarily a strategic city or state or country. Anything in Ghana, the nation of Ghana, compared to the fire protection of Los Angeles. And then she gets back and she's cornered and she can't say anything and she cuts the fire budget. She appoints all these DEI people.
Sammy Wink
Yeah, enough said. Well, let's go ahead and take a break and then come back and talk a little bit about women in the news this week. We've got lots of them and Amy Chu is on deck. So stay with us and we'll be back.
Victor Davis Hanson
Question Ever wonder how much of your personal data is out there on the Internet for anyone to see? More than you think. Your name, contact info, Social Security number and home address, even information about your family members, all being compiled by data brokers and sold online. I recently found a solution. It's a great service called delete me. DeleteMe is a subscription service that removes your personal info from hundreds of data brokers. Delete Me isn't just a one time service. DeleteMe is always working for you, constantly monitoring and removing the personal information you don't want on the Internet. Delete Me sends you regular personalized privacy reports showing what info they found, where they found it and what they removed. To put it simply, Delete Me does all the hard work of wiping your and your family's personal information from data broker websites. I just signed up. It couldn't have been easier. And as soon as I hit submit I felt what you'll feel, relief and even a sense of justice. I've taken control of my data, take control of yours and keep your private life private by signing up for Delete Me now at a special discount for our listeners today. Get 20% off your delete me plan by texting Victor to 64000. Text Victor to 64000. That's Victor to 64000 message and data rates may apply. See terms for details.
Sammy Wink
Welcome back. So Victor, lots of women this week and I, I wanted to talk a little bit about Amy Chu. She was famous as praising the role of a tiger mom.
Victor Davis Hanson
Yep. She wrote.
Sammy Wink
But go ahead.
Victor Davis Hanson
She's a Yale law professor and she came to prominence because she wrote, I think she wrote it in two months about what the Asian mode of parenting can do and when she had a disobedient teenager like every teenager. And so she instead of accommodating or appeasing the teenager's demand, she doubled down. You're going to play a piano or a violin, you're going to get straight. And they were all very successful. Successful. And that became a best seller. She got a lot of criticism, but she was still okay as far as the left was. After all, she's probably a Democrat. And but she also had a reputation of reaching out to people that were very bright that she came in contact at Yale Law School both left and right. She made no discrimination. I don't know. I think she's center left. But nevertheless and she met J.D. vance and anybody who was bright, she thought that didn't have Network connection. She helped. So she was miss Networker. She could get somebody. She knew all the Supreme Court judges. They had. She had a reputation for being competent, reliable. If Amy Chu represented a Yale law graduate, they were good or she wouldn't really. So she, she had a pipeline to federal appellate court and Supreme Court. And so that made her very powerful. Then she wrote this book. People were kind of easy. But then they turned on her because during the Kavanaugh hearings, she quite courageously refused to sign a letter as most of the obsequious law professors at Yale did, condemning Brett Kavanaugh and supporting these absurd Susan Blasey Ford charges. She didn't. And so they started to re examine her as the left always do do. And she had a party, believe it or not, Sammy, she had a party where these 20 year old, 20, excuse me, law students, 21, 22. There was all above the drinking, but they had alcohol at her house. This is from the puritanical left now and then her husband, who had no record of ever drinking anything wrong. He wanted to, or he and he seemed. Or he sort of like wanted to touch kiss an undergrad but no evidence. So they went after him. And of course Yale thought, oh boy, I can't get her to punish her for supporting this horrible Trump appointment. I'll go after her husband. And they put him on suspension for two years. He did nothing wrong. She wrote a book on tribalism during this period that I read. It was actually very good. And it was a warning to minorities, Asians included and Hispanics and blacks, that they had been encouraged by white coastal elites to emphasize their tribal identifications. But white coastal elites were not the majority of white people and they were the white people that had the privilege. But if everybody made their race or gender or sexual orientation essential rather than incidental to who they were, the great mass, that's about 65% of the population is white. And if you say white privilege, white privilege, white privilege, white rage, white rage, white rage, white supremacy, white supremacy, you keep doing that as they did. Well, these white puppeteers in the west, they love it because they think, oh, you're talking about all those people in East Palestine or Fresno, but you're going to create a backlash. And then this white group is going to say, yeah, okay, you got your tribe, I got mine. And so she predicted that would be very dangerous and called for people not to do that. And they continued to do it. And she was proven right. I mentioned that when I go early, I won't be mention the places I go to but if I get up at 5:30 and run into a supermarket in rural Central Valley, that's it. For some reason in which they're heavily minority populations and I see a rare white person, it's like, hi, how are you? Everything okay, Mr. And they don't know me. How is it the subtext is you're white, I'm white. I never thought of about that before. But since they got a tribe and they got a tribe and they got a tribe, we need a tribe. And it's like nuclear proliferation. They got a bomb, we got a bomb, we got to get one too. So she. The only sad thing about this whole thing when they went after her and they tried to take her courses away, they tried to get her for crazy things like delinquency to minors and that didn't work. They tried to do everything get after her husband. Husband. She got ill and she developed sepsis under the, the intense pressure. She's very. And she almost died. So she. You didn't hear from her for a while. She's very bright. I wish her the. I admire her courage. I wish her the best.
Sammy Wink
Yeah.
Victor Davis Hanson
And now she's back in the news because she's going to the inauguration as a guest of JD Vance. JD Vance, a man who owes her a great deal. He met his wife, I think in her class class and at Yale Law School. And I, I met him once and talked to him once on the phone. I can tell you he is a man that, that has a good memory and if you. And he has a lot of. He's. Everything they said about JD Vance was not just untrue, it was a lie. When I talk, I talked to him a long time once and on the phone as well. And he was very knowledgeable. He was very nice, kind. As soon as they nominate him, I thought doesn't. Doesn't make traditional sense. He's. They're going to win Ohio anyway. Check Trump is a white male. He is to check the MAGA people are under assault. He's a MAGA person and then cancel that out because I'd heard him before and I'd seen him, I thought unmatched intelligence. B knows the underbelly of America like few people do. Three sword in law school and successful. And D, when they go after him on TV and they will this is what I think I said that in the podcast. He is going to tie them in knots. He's a brilliant debater and he said the other day they were trying to bait him about the transition and Joe Biden had done all these wonderful things and the economy is great. And he said, basically, he left us with a dumpster fire. And this is in regard to. Joe Biden had just given this atrocious speech. We need to talk about that speech. He gave it to his State Department. Did you hear this speech?
Sammy Wink
No, No, I didn't. Go ahead and talk about it.
Victor Davis Hanson
He says, and I'm the first president when. That the next guy who follows me can say, there's no war in Afghanistan. Yeah, dummy, you lost the war and you got 13 brave people killed and you left $50 billion. It would be like Roosevelt saying, well, we lost D Day. So I pulled out, and now my. Anybody follows me, there's no World War II, Joe. The only worse thing than a bad occupation is to lose a war. You lost it. And then he said this. And Iran is weakened. Yeah, because Israel didn't listen to you and retaliated. And they wouldn't even have a nuclear deterrent if you let them do what they wanted to do. And they said, and Hamas and Hezbollah are on the run. Yes, because they ignored you after you demonize Netanyahu. He went in and did things that you said. Don't retaliate, be measured, don't do that. And he didn't listen to you. And he saved Israel because he didn't listen to you. And Assad, Assyria is gone. Well, that's not gone because of you. It's gone because they're afraid of Donald Trump coming in. And they gave the green light to these rebels and said, you know what? Iran is weak. Hezbollah is destroyed. These Israelis are there. Trump's coming in now. We can take him out. And that's what the rebels did every single. And he said, we had a China. No, they're not. They're buying more farmland around military bases. They sent the balloon trajectory. The worst was Ukraine. My God, he said, thanks to me. Ukraine was not. No, thanks to you. They invaded Ukraine because you pulled out of Afghanistan in such a humiliating form fashion that five months later, Vladimir Putin thought, you know, we went under Bush when he was weakened in 2008 because of the war. We went under this guy when he was vice president, when he was with loudmouth Obama. And Biden didn't do anything. And now after Afghanistan, he won't do anything. And he didn't, you know, what he was. He said, remember, are you going to react if Vladimir Putin comes in? Depends on whether it's a minor incursion or not. And then when the incursion was major and he panicked Biden and said, get Zelensky out, Alfirma, ride out. You remember that. So what I'm getting at is every single thing that he did made the world more unsafe. And then he looked around and he said, the coming of Trump, what Israel's done in the Middle east and all of that has made some things better. But I had nothing to do with him. It was despite me, not because of me. And yet he took that reality and he lied. And he always lies with his, I don't know what you call it. Schizophrenic. It's like this. And first it's the slur anger, mood mode, slur anger, essay mode. And he goes like this. And then he goes into the whisper mode. And guess what, everybody? I did that. I weakened your. It's just impossible to listen to him. He's so off putting. He's so obnoxious. And to sit up there in front of the American people and lie about. He said about the hostages, he's close to a deal. He hasn't had a deal since they went in on October 7th and took them. He wasn't even worried about him. He didn't even know who they were. He never really called the parents of the 13 people who were killed because of a skedaddle in Afghanistan. You know, open border, wrecked economy. And here he's telling everybody he's made the world safer. It's much more dangerous. As much as I do not approve of what Obama did, when Trump came into office in 2017, the world was a safer place than it is now. He's going to have to restore deterrence. And I don't know what MAGA people are going to say. I am a mega person. I know what I'm going to say. But I'm going to be say to Donald Trump, be a Jacksonian, you're Andrew Jackson. And do not get in an optional war, forever war, an endless war on the ground in the Middle East. Yes, do not get into Ukraine, but you have to protect our interests. And that might be sometimes a Soleimani or Baghdadi type of operation. I don't think he should start keep. He's made his point about Greenland and Panama and Canada. Made a great tactic, tactical decisions, trolling. We talked about that. It's funny, it's ironic. He puts the onus on Canada, onus on Denmark, onus on Panama, but I wouldn't keep pushing about not rolling out force because Donald Trump is not going to send troops into Panama and you can't really make them guess or be afraid that you might because they know you're not. But otherwise suggesting that Denmark is a colonial power and reminding them that they're farther from Greenland than we are and it's North American territory that Donald Trump, the anti imperialist and anti colonialist is trying to protect the territorial integrity of Greenland are telling Panama that they're subject to a colonial imperialist China and I betrayed their friends that were magnanimous. Or telling Mexico, you had 400 years of Gulf of Mexico, now it's our 400 years since we have the same amount of coastline is effective.
Sammy Wink
Well, Victor, thank you for that. Let's go ahead and take a break and then we'll come back and talk a little bit more about women in in the news this week. So stay with us. And we'll be right back.
Victor Davis Hanson
Foreign.
Sammy Wink
Welcome back to the Victor Davis Hansen Show. You can find Victor at his Twitter or X handle at VD Hansen or you can find him at Facebook on Hanson's Morning Cup. So come join him there if those are your social media outlets. So Victor, in the news as well are Linda Lindy Lee and Pamela Hemphill. I hope I said her last name right. Lindy Lee is a ex Democrat who said the Democratic Party was like a cult. And Pamela Hempfeld is an ex maga, if I can put it that way, who claimed that the maga, the MAGA people were like a cult as well. And so I thought it was striking that we're seeing all this accusation, accusations of cult on both left and right. Hempfeld is one of the accused January Sixers who had who is says she's going to refuse a pardon after she pleaded guilty, but she would not take a pardon from Trump because the Democratic, the Democratic, the MAGA agenda was very cult like and they turned her mind. And I was wondering your thoughts on.
Victor Davis Hanson
Either of these people, whether adults faults and all the information, each of them one was there Lindy Lee. I mean, she's upset because she bundled millions of dollars and then she found out that Camilla Harris was paying people. And of course, if anybody else had done that, there would probably been some type of investigation like Al Sharpton and Oprah Winfrey to basically endorse her. She bought them and some rappers. And then in addition to that, she was junketing with a lot of private flights for kind of low level staff. She ended up blowing through in a hundred days her own campaign in her packs, 1.5 billion in three months. And then she ended up in debt owning 20,000. So so she lost so my question to her is, had she won, would you have done this? In other words, you're now telling us that the Democratic Party is so extreme and you feel so betrayed because you, in heartfelt sincerity, went to these donors and you found out that Kamala Harris was an operator and blew through their money and had nothing but contempt for them and lost. But let me just reverse it. Had she won, let's see, she beat Trump by three points. People would say, hey, Lindy, they kind of spent a lot of money, but it must have been worth something because he won. So, and then when we go to the second MAGA person, you're trying to tell me that between November 2nd of 2000, I don't know what, excuse me, it wasn't the second, but it was the 5th or 6th of 2020 and January 6th of 2021, you did not know that there were both legitimate and illegitimate questions about balloting. All you had to do was turn on the news. If you were a conspiracy theorist and a cult member, then you would listen to crazy Lin Wood and, and you would have believed that the Dominion computers were communicating with China or Venezuela. Nobody believed that. Or you could have said there were legitimate questions about the election because they changed the voting laws in most of the swing states so that 70% of the traditional election day electorate did not vote on election day. They voted under the guise of COVID through mail in early balloting. And the rejection rate fell enormously by a magnitude double the ballots, one tenth of the authenticity. So there were legitimate questions. So you, I don't know how that filtered down to you, but you thought that, Donald, you were tired on election day and you looked at the returns and you went to bed and Donald Trump was ahead. And then all of a sudden the mail on ballots came in in Arizona, Arizona, in Georgia and Pennsylvania, in Michigan, and he lost. And you got angry. So you chose on your own volition to go to the Capitol and you were arrested for going into the Capitol, as I remember. I wouldn't have arrested you. I would have cited you as a misdemeanor of unlawfully entering a federal building. But nobody put a gun to your head that, you know, that it was against the law to go into a federal building. Now you can say legitimately, well, Rashida Tlaib and the squad and all those people had protest about Hamas and they took over the whole rotunda, and that was unlawful and they never arrested one. And you have a point. But don't tell me after all this time that you felt that you didn't have enough information or what are you trying to tell me you were brainwashed by Donald Trump? And let me ask you in a different way. Had you gone to the capital and had you had a legitimate discussion and had that discussion put emphases on what was going on as it did after January 6th, and maybe it had an effect, I don't know. And they would have said to people that there were irregularities. Would you have been mad now? Is it mad that you were arrested? Was it mad that you showed up? Nobody forced you to do that, that. But. And I thought this section was on powerful independent minded women.
Sammy Wink
Well, I, yeah, no, actually it was just on women, but they, you know.
Victor Davis Hanson
Might as well put in.
Sammy Wink
That's exactly what got me. Karen Bass, all these women, they come, what they're complaining is it was cult like, but I think they were the ones that were cult like. They were seeking out a cult experience. So they were.
Victor Davis Hanson
I'm living in little old Selma. When I heard what Kamala Harris was doing with these big high rollers and they were spending all of this money and they were, you could tell they were buying endorsements. You could tell that the people that were running her campaign were totally inept and it was just a free fall with free money. And I don't have any empathy for the guys that wrote the checks anyway. They were writing the checks, I don't think, because they believed in the genius of, of Kamala Harris and what she was going to do another four years of what Biden did. They were doing it because they wanted influence with it. And that's fine, too. That's what Donald Trump said when, I think in the2016 debates, when Rand Paul said, you're what's wrong with America, you're the nexus of money and influence. He said, basically, I'm paraphrasing him. He said, you're absolutely right. And you came up to my office, wrote me a check for 10,000 and I got a lot of influence with you. So that was pretty.
Sammy Wink
Well, let's turn then to student loans. And Joe Biden has announced cancellation of another 4.2 billion in student loans. Now, I wouldn't bring this up except there is, I've been investigating a case in California community colleges where they're talking about these fake students. And they, and in some of the publications they say their estimate is that as many as 25% of fake students. And that means, and for all of you guys who are wondering what does it mean, a fake student? It means that somebody is putting in Names of people going that as though they were going to community college and then going in and asking for financial aid and then giving. Getting financial aid from a whole bunch of different names that they do this with and they have a case where they caught three women in 2023. But so he's forgiving these loans and there's a huge rate of fraud that of people getting these loans. And then last thing, I have a reader that wrote and said that the loans he was reading about the loans. He said the next time you hear about how the taxpayer should excuse student loans, keep the following in mind. Student loan usage percentage based on the provided search results of a 2019 LendingTree survey found that 20% of students used student loans for travel, 26% used them foreclose. And it's worth noting that only 10% said that they used their student loans to pay their tuition. This suggests that significant portion of students, around 46% combined traveling and close those two percentages are using their school loans for non essential or discretionary purposes. Now put all those things together and it's not just insulting to people who didn't go to school that these student loans are being forgiven, but for all taxpayers that so much fraud is going on and then the students that do get the loans that aren't completely fraudulent are using them for other purposes. And I was wondering.
Victor Davis Hanson
It's a general rule. Whenever you take a collective group and you romanticize them or you idealize them or you suggest that they are noble and should be exempt from market forces or from reality, you're going to have problems. So if you say the homeless, to take one example or kind of victims of society and they're there not of their own volition or their own laxities or crime, whatever it is, addictions, mental illness, but you're just not going to talk about them. So they're all over the LA hills, everywhere. When I've gone down to la, I see them everywhere. I see them on sidewalks, I drive down Malibu Canyon Road on the way to Pepper, I see them on the side and it's cold and they're not going to light fires and you're not going to go out and arrest them or. But if they are protected species in which you are paying almost double for their care than you are for the fire department, then you're going to have a problem. If you romanticize students and you say that they're all hard working and then we just, we want to give them a hand to get their education when many of them are middle class and they are taking loans out with the expectation that they don't need it for actual school, but that it's a income enhancer and they don't have any intention of paying it back. I think 25 of them are in arrears. Then you have a problem. It's like Karen Bass, if you say that powerful black women should not be subject to criticism and that's what people are making. The argument that white racists like Victor suggested that she shouldn't have gone to Ghana and she should have answered reporters questions and she shouldn't have cut the fire budget by $17.5 million and she shouldn't have appointed this fellow deputy mayor who's now under charges of phoning in a bomb threat, etc. Etc. But if I am told that I can't say that because she's a powerful black woman, then she's going to take advantage of that powerful black woman exemption. As our homeless people think, you know what we can do? Like a guy rides a bike with a blowtorch, a propane torch, and he's riding openly in the middle of fire conditions and he's lighting Christmas trees in la and his attitude is they don't do anything to the homeless people. I'm a homeless person. You can do whatever you want. You can defecate, you can inject, you can fornicate, you can urinate and there's no consequence. Well, that's. We've created this noble myth of the student and the fact is that it's one of the contributors to prolonged adolescence. So we have these students that are taking three, six units. They're taking a federal loan and guaranteed loan. They're not graduating in four years. 50% graduate in six years. So they're eating up their 20s with kind of want to take a class in gender studies, kind of want to take, take a class in sociology of the self. Kind of want to take a class in Marvel comic books. And I'll get my three, six units and my student loan and probably if I do it long enough, I'm not going to have to pay it back. I'll just pay the interest on and they're going to forgive it when you get a demagogue like Joe Biden in. So it's not a good program. And it delays marriage, it delays child rearing, and it delays homeowners. So these guys should get on the pathway of life at 20 or 21 and decide what they want to do. And most people, I'd say 55% don't belong in College of the population. They need to get a trade and help the country move and build and electrify and plumb and do all these things and truck but not to kind of, sort of, kind of maybe might be a student.
Sammy Wink
Yeah.
Victor Davis Hanson
And that's costing us a lot of money. It's $1.67 trillion. And then Joe Biden being lawless says in a campaign stop, he said well I forgave so many billion dollars. And the Supreme Court said I couldn't do it was illegal because I did it without legislation. But I got around it. I got around it. So he was openly flaunting the courts authority. They need to get out of it. Get. If you just think where I work, I think the Stanford endowment is over 30 billion. So let's say tomorrow Donald Trump has a first executive. There shall be no federal guaranteed loans. So Stanford tells its students we can give you a tuition waiver but to pay the $200,000 a year in tuition, room and board inflation eating at the cost. I mean Stanford's raised its prices higher than the rate of inflation because they had a guaranteed loan package in some cases. Some people are very wealthy and even place like where I used to teach, Cal State, Fresno probably had more student loans than Stanford because Stanford kids are pretty wealthy. But my point is to take this example. So what if there was no student loans and the Stanford package said that out of the $200,000 we'll give you a grant for 50,000 guaranteed glow by our endowment. So suddenly these kids say well Stanford, they're not going to make me pay it back. I'll just know they will make you pay it back. So you go to Stanford and you want to take your DEI course, your environmental there, they're going to sit you down and say look, you came here, we want you out of here in four years. And what are you going to major in? Because we need a major that's competitive and renunative. We don't want, want you don't come to Stanford and borrow our money and then go out and take six years and then don't pay it back for 20. We're not going to do that. I'm sorry. And we're going to give you courses that are competitive because we're lean and mean. We don't, we don't have 16,000 staffers, which they do have. And we don't have a DEI guy making 300,000 and 200,000 for his assistant. We are lean and mean and that would be great, wouldn't it? Yes, moral Hazard. Moral hazard. Where's the moral hazard?
Sammy Wink
Well, the. The last thing on our agenda today, Victor, is the American Airlines failed to prioritize their employees by allowing the retirement managers of their pensions to invest in esg, environmental, social and governance. And the court ruling was that they failed their employees. So the court upheld that. I was.
Victor Davis Hanson
That they had to invest. They took their money and made them invest in it.
Sammy Wink
Yeah, they took the money in their pension system.
Victor Davis Hanson
ESG is going the alphabetic suicide trajectory of di. Di, esg, same thing. It is a unworkable, mandated program mindset that's implemented by elites that doesn't work. So in the case of di, it's anti merocratic and it uses criteria that are superficial. Race, sex, gender, but rather than merit. And this ESG basically says that we're in the marketplace and the stock market's been going good and you don't have to be very smart to make money now with this huge increase in what's. I'm talking about 20 year. And we're going to invest in companies that are environmentally sound and socially responsible. And then those companies think we have kind of a shaky operation here, we're not very profitable, but we're going to broadcast in Virtue signal and performance art that we care and we hire people of color. And we are very. We use solar and wind power only, and that masks the actual productivity of the company. And then the investor, the ESG people say to the investor, we want a virtue signal and feel good because everybody thinks we're greedy. And remember Occupy Wall street and all that. We don't want that image. We want to be part of the community. We want to be supporters of the community of color, the LGBTQ community, the environmental community. And so we're going to take maybe 1 or 2% off our productivity, invest in companies that are not quite competitive, even though we have a commitment to our stockholders and investors and people that we will get you the highest return. And they got away with it. And now all of a sudden in times of semi recession, people are saying, you didn't give me what I wanted. You're not as competitive because you're investing in non productive enterprises. So you can feel good at my expense. So.
Sammy Wink
The governance part of that is essentially you had to be PC. The companies had to be PC on top of it, which was just politically biased.
Victor Davis Hanson
It's okay if they're making money. Who cares if your ESG investment, let's say in Red Rock or something, returns 7% on your money and you feel, wow, I get 7% and they don't use any gasoline. And their delivery trucks, they're all electrified. Oh, wow. But when they're getting 2%, and that's your hardened money and the inflation rate is 9% like it was in 2021, then you say, oh, my God, I lost 7% of my money just so these guys that are billionaires can go around and brag that they're for the environment. It's not a sustainable proposition.
Sammy Wink
No, it sure isn't. Well, Victor, that's it for today. I'd like to thank you for all of your wisdom. Been wonderful today, and I would like to thank our listeners. Thank you for joining us.
Victor Davis Hanson
Thank you, everyone. Thank you, everybody, for listening. Much appreciated.
Sammy Wink
This is Sammy Wink and Victor Davis Hansen, and we're signing off.
Victor Davis Hanson
As someone who's studied military history for decades, I want to tell you about a critical intelligence briefing our friends at American Alternative Assets have just released. It's called Homeland 2025. And if you're concerned about America's security, you need to see this. Former CIA officers have revealed disturbing evidence about threats to American cities. But more importantly, this briefing explains how to protect your family's financial security during times of crisis. This isn't about fear. It's about being prepared with facts and historical perspective. Right now, American Alternative Assets is offering our listeners this critical briefing. Plus up to $10,000 in free silver and a free American made safe. These are patriots we trust to help protect what matters most. Visit aaagold.net Hansen and tell them Victor sent you. Learn what financial institutions already know about securing your family's future.
Podcast Summary: The Victor Davis Hanson Show
Episode: Ceasefire, Resignation, and Political “Cults”
Release Date: January 17, 2025
In this episode of The Victor Davis Hanson Show, hosts Victor Davis Hanson and Sammy Wink delve into a range of pressing political and social issues. The discussion spans the intricate dynamics of Middle Eastern politics, recent political resignations, challenges in Los Angeles, the phenomenon of political "cults" from both the left and right, the complexities of student loan forgiveness, and a notable court ruling against American Airlines regarding ESG investments.
[05:56] Sammy Wink introduces the topic of a potential ceasefire deal between Hamas and Israel, highlighting the complexities involved in releasing hostages and Palestinian prisoners.
Victor Davis Hanson analyzes the situation, emphasizing the multifaceted catalysts at play:
"There are all these different catalysts at work and they're mutually exclusive. So before we can figure out whether it's a good or bad deal..." [05:56]
Hanson discusses the role of former President Donald Trump as a special envoy and his influence on the negotiations. He critiques the lack of legal authority of the envoy during the transition period and questions the effectiveness of the individuals involved in the negotiation process.
"He sends an envoy who has no legal authority during the transition to fly over to Israel... it's not good." [05:56]
The conversation underscores the uncertainty surrounding the deal's success and the potential implications for American and Israeli hostages.
[13:30] The hosts shift focus to Jack Smith's resignation and the subsequent report he released alleging that former President Trump could have been convicted of conspiracy to defraud the United States had he not won the election.
Victor Davis Hanson critiques the legitimacy and timing of Smith's appointment as a special prosecutor, labeling it a "political hit."
"This was just, I wasn't a special counsel. I was just an appendage of Merrick Garland and Joe Biden's Department of Justice." [14:01]
Hanson argues that the report lacks substantial evidence against Trump and portrays it as a continuation of partisan conflict within the justice system.
[18:22] The discussion moves to the recent fires in Los Angeles, addressing issues like looting and the introduction of private fire services spearheaded by Elon Musk.
Victor Davis Hanson expresses concern over the surge in looting despite significant property damage:
"There's a huge amount of money that's tempting these looters... they're about to steal and take things and wander around." [18:22]
He praises Elon Musk's initiative to provide internet and support to affected areas through Starlink and cyber trucks, contrasting it with perceived inaction from local authorities.
"He is doing more than almost any... he's putting Starlink free. So all the first responders... can communicate on the Internet." [20:54]
Hanson criticizes local government responses and highlights the potential long-term impact on affluent communities, fearing demographic and economic shifts post-disaster.
[35:18] The conversation turns to recent claims by both Lindy Lee, an ex-Democrat, and Pamela Hemphill, an ex-MAGA supporter, labeling the opposing political factions as "cults."
Victor Davis Hanson challenges these accusations by dissecting the motivations and credibility of the accusers:
"If you romanticize students... then you have a problem." **[61:29]
He draws parallels between the behaviors of both political groups, suggesting that the labeling of the other side as cult-like is a reflection of their own rigid ideologies rather than objective reality.
"Whether adults faults and all the information, each of them one was there Lindy Lee... they're going after her husband. And she...she got...she develops sepsis..." [53:11]
Hanson contends that both sides are guilty of creating exclusive in-groups and fostering environments where dissent is discouraged, thereby resembling cult-like dynamics.
[59:05] The hosts examine President Joe Biden's announcement of canceling an additional $4.2 billion in student loans amid rising concerns of fraud in California community colleges.
Victor Davis Hanson criticizes the blanket forgiveness approach, highlighting the misuse of student loans:
"Around 46% combined traveling and close those two percentages are using their school loans for non-essential or discretionary purposes." [61:29]
He argues that forgiving loans without addressing underlying fraud issues not only penalizes taxpayers but also rewards irresponsible borrowing behaviors. Hanson emphasizes the broader societal impacts, such as delayed marriage, homeownership, and the prolongation of adolescence due to student debt burdens.
"These guys should get on the pathway of life at 20 or 21 and decide what they want to do." [61:29]
[68:21] The final major topic revolves around a court ruling that found American Airlines failed to prioritize employee interests by allowing pension managers to invest in ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) funds.
Victor Davis Hanson condemns ESG investments as detrimental to fiduciary responsibilities and corporate profitability:
"ESG is the alphabetic suicide trajectory of di. Di, esg, same thing." [68:26]
He elaborates that ESG criteria prioritize social and environmental objectives over economic returns, leading to reduced competitiveness and financial performance. Hanson warns of the long-term negative consequences of such investment strategies, both for companies and their stakeholders.
"We're not going to talk about them. So they're not going to talk about them... they are going to reduce the fire so it has some utility." [20:54]
Throughout the episode, Victor Davis Hanson provides incisive commentary on the intersection of politics, economics, and societal trends. His analysis underscores concerns about partisan maneuvering, the efficacy of governmental and private interventions in crises, and the socio-economic ramifications of policies such as student loan forgiveness and ESG investments. The discussion encourages listeners to critically evaluate the motivations behind political actions and the broader implications for American society.
Victor Davis Hanson on the special envoy's lack of authority:
"He sends an envoy who has no legal authority during the transition to fly over to Israel... it's not good." [05:56]
Hanson critiquing Jack Smith's role:
"This was just, I wasn't a special counsel. I was just an appendage of Merrick Garland and Joe Biden's Department of Justice." [14:01]
On the temptation of looting in affluent areas:
"There's a huge amount of money that's tempting these looters... they're about to steal and take things and wander around." [18:22]
Regarding political groups acting like cults:
"Whether adults faults and all the information, each of them one was there Lindy Lee... they're going after her husband." [53:11]
On student loan misuse:
"Around 46% combined traveling and close those two percentages are using their school loans for non-essential or discretionary purposes." [61:29]
Critique of ESG investments:
"ESG is the alphabetic suicide trajectory of di. Di, esg, same thing." [68:26]
This comprehensive summary captures the essence of the episode, highlighting Victor Davis Hanson's perspectives on current political and social issues while providing contextual insights for listeners unfamiliar with the original podcast.