Victor Davis Hanson (5:09)
Yeah, I think it happened a little while ago. And the reason we didn't learn that as a nation was the the mayor had suppressed the video and she made this. The mayor of Charlotte had said this is a tragedy. It was not a tragedy. It was an act of deliberate evil. Didn't just happen. Number two, she said that we should not use this to judge homelessness. Why not? Because this happens a lot from homeless people. Number three, she said she didn't want to use this incident for political purpose, but by the very suppression of it, it was a political act on her part. The subtext was we are getting battered because liberal judges, liberal prosecutors, the defund, the police, the Black Lives matter have created a crime epidemic in 2020 21. Now the left says it's going down. I have two responses for that. We all know that left wing jurisdictions, especially big city have not been cooperating with the FBI to send in the full tallies of murders and breakdowns on the nature of the assailant and the assailed. So I don't think that they're that accurate. But more or less, if you look at today's figures, 2024 being the latest, it's still higher than 2019. So it's very high. And she doesn't want that. Nor did the governor, Governor Stein want that to be released. That was the first thing. The second is the media did not cover it for a week and would not cover it. And to the degree that it did cover it, finally out of shame, things like ABC or CBS or NBC said things like the alleged murderer or the purported murder. And when you watch the video, there is no alleged murder. You see who did it. So that was another striking thing. And then when they did report alleged murder and purported and all of this stuff, they did it in the context of Republicans. Pounce this is being used by Republicans. It's not being used. It's just there to see that she left a war torn country and found it more war torn in the United States, more unsafe. And then there was a blanket of silence that this had a racial component. So the usual suspects, Al Sharpton, you know who they are, they all came out and said the the right is using this. Then we found out that he muttered and it was apparently visible on the audio version or people reported I killed that white girl or I killed the white girl. So it was a racially motivated. And that was not. That was not reported the Wall Street Journal that I'd been picking on its news division. It was really late and even when it did we finally reported, I think yesterday it did it in the context of the right that is using this. If you look at the story. So the media was completely. Who are the losers in this? The people culpable. The media did not report it. And why didn't they? Because they have a pre existing narrative that black people as all non white people are victims and they're Marxist minories and you cannot produce stories that suggest that they are victimizers and if you do have stories that they are victimizers, then. Excuse me, turn this off. Can we cut for a second? Yeah. So if we do have stories that contradict the narrative, they either editorialize them or they don't air them. And why do they do that? Because they think for their higher moral purposes, you cannot have black assailants attacking white people because that's not their narrative. The narrative is white people. White police hurt black people. And yet again and again, as we've said, that that demographic, from 15 to 40 of black males, which is only about 3% of the population, they're committing 50 to 55% of violent assaults, rapes, murders. No one wants to talk about that. And to the degree they do talk about it, they have to incur charges of being racist. The black left wing community is completely culpable in the sense that they will not discuss this. They will not discuss why black males inordinately are committing violent crimes, mostly in the big cities, mostly against other blacks. You think they would want to address that of only about 7 or 8% of their victims are white. But that's a lot of white people, given the amount of crimes that they commit. The other thing is in this story, a couple of other things very quickly. This was a total systems breakdown. It's very analogous to the Pacific Palisades where we saw Karen Bass, or over in Ghana, we saw the deputy mayor under house arrest for phoning in a bomb threat. In la, we saw that public works director unable to fill a reservoir. We saw the fire chief not too concerned that fire hydrants weren't fully operative. Karen Bass cut her budget. It was all DEI too. All of the people I met, I just mentioned were dei. In other words, they had run for office on the idea that I'm a proud black gay woman, I am the deputy member because I'm a proud black man who phoned in a bomb, a bomb threat. As a deputy member. I am a proud gay woman Fire chief. I am a proud Latina. The public word that may be true, but that's incidental, not essential. They never said what their standards or what their expertise or education was. And it wasn't much in these cases. So it was a systems breakdown because the judges in that area, the magistrate judges don't have to have law degrees. And the one that let him out into alternative sentencing and treatment had an interest in that herself. She should be summarily dismissed right now for doing that. He had 14 felonies. His father was a murderer. As I, our brother was his brother was. I think the whole family was violent on that male side. And in addition to that, in the larger judicial process in North Carolina, they have a history of just doing exactly what Chicago and New York, Alvin Bragg, and what we saw in Los Angeles and San Francisco under Mr. Boudin, etc. They let people out under critical legal theory and clinical race theory, which says, as we just heard Jasmine Crockett say. She just said it. She said people often commit crimes because they have to. Well, Jasmine, I. Just about a nanosecond after you said that, I looked watched a video of a Los Angeles robbery where a caravan of cars of black males approached an elderly 80 something Asian jewelry store. And the lead car drove right through it. And then somewhere between 15 and 20 black males swarmed the store and they stole over them. They assaulted the owner who was thrown to the ground and they took about $1.5 million in jewelry. Now, is that because they're starving? They have no choice? Are you going to tell me that they don't have bread and eggs at milk at home so they were forced to take valuable jewelry so they could hawk it and therefore they could. I don't believe that. I don't think you believe it either. But I do believe you're a racist and that's why you said it. And I think another thing is the final thought about this murder. To sum up, it's not tragic, it's a breakdown of, of the left wing management of big cities in the judicial system. And it reflects an inability or an unwillingness to talk about a major issue in America, that $20 trillion after the Great Society program, 65 years into the civil rights movement, we still have an existential problem of black males committing about half of the nation's crimes when they represent about that age group and that gender and that race represent about 3%. And it doesn't do any good to say black men are overrepresented in prison. Most of them are not there for dealing marijuana. Believe me, they're overrepresented because they're overrepresenting committing crimes, but they're underrepresented. This is key. If you were to jail them according to what other people are being jailed, they're underrepresented. And finally there is culpability. As I said to Jack, if you have Jasmine Crockett yelling all the time with their videos about white people, white people, white people, and you had somebody like Joy Reid for years at MSNBC talking about white people, white people, white people, white people, and now on her Podcast how bad white people are. And you have on the view sunny host and say the Trump won because of uneducated white white women. White, white. And as I said to Jack, I'm interviewing a book right now, and the author, a PhD, is trying to say that his field is full of white whiteness. And I counted white and whiteness. It's. It's almost two times. Every page, every page, white, white, white, white, white, white, white. This obsession so that. And the person is not a victim of discrimination. So the more that the larger society has talks about reparations and here in California, we're talking about giving back farmland to Native Americans and people of color. And with more of these programs, you get the suspicion that there has to be more racism. But there isn't more racism. There are too many victims and too few victimizers. So the way that square is circled, people like Jasmine Crockett, Maxine Waters, Al Sharpton, they get on the public radio, tv, Internet waves, and they just beat white, white, white to death to convince people that, that their special treatment and their programs are necessary to fight this non existent problem. And this was a turning point, this murder. I really do think it is. I think it was. I've never seen anything like it. I have never seen anything like a person sitting there. He was like some type of predator. And she was like the victim. And she was just sitting there and she was just minding her own business. And then the African American woman to the side of her, and then a man or a woman to the rear were watching this. And then he gets. He slowly takes out his knife and then he stabs her. Something. And he walks away. And they don't do anything. They don't get up, they don't try to put a tourniquet on her. They just leave her. And then she has this. I don't know what you would say. She's just. She's dying and the blood is spurting out and she just looks baffled. She doesn't cry, she doesn't scream, she doesn't say anything. The look is, I am dying. I don't know why I'm dying. Nobody's gonna help me. I've just been murdered by this creepy person. I sat down. I didn't prejudge the area. I didn't avoid the area because there were black people. I'm not that kind of person. I just sat down. I just wanted to be left alone. This man just cut my throat. I'm now falling. I'm out of air. I'm out of cognizant and I'm going to die. And there's not one person here that cares that's going to help me. And she was absolutely right in that last. If I'm correct, that's what she was thinking because the mayor immediately came out and said it was tragic and don't blame homeless people or don't try to use it for political purposes. And then we didn't hear anything from the judge magistrate we had nothing from. And I think it's going to continue. And then this was bookended by the Auburn professor, a retired professor of veterinary medicine who took her weekly walk with her dog, African American male with a history of violence who was let out, strangled her, treated her body terribly, dragged it, just throw it down where dogs defecate and stole her car. And of course, nobody wants to comment on any of this. If it was George Floyd, the country will go into riot for four months and we will create di. Everybody said this on all of the news. People who were honest. Imagine that it was an attractive young black woman sitting on a light rail car and there were three white. There was a white man, maybe a MAGA looking man behind her, and then there was a white woman and a white man around her, and she was just minding her own business. Then the white man looked at her and then he got up and executed her in a brutal fashion by cutting her throat, stabbing her, then walk nonchalantly out. Why no of the other white people did anything. And the white people right next to her watching it, let her fall down on the ground and bleed to death. You know what? We would have, we would have riots right now. It would make George Floyd look like nothing. And so that's the problem. Everybody knows it. And I don't know what you can do about it, but it's a turning point. I think people are going to say, you know what? If the black left wing leadership chooses to collectively represent people, and it does, I speak for black people. I'm Joy Reid. I'm Don Lamone, I'm the View. I speak for black. Then you better speak for black people and you better represent it. Because people are going to say, okay, you're telling me that you're the official spokesperson. What are you going to say now? Because we're going to hold you liable just as you hold larger society liable. If you want to talk in collectives, then we'll talk in collectives. But something has to be done because you can't have a nation where a retired professor just in a very safe neighborhood goes out and walks around and ends up dead and desecrated. And you can't have a society where a person just, I don't know, gets on a train and is brutally executed. You can't have a society with a young kid who's a football player at a track meet. A person from the other side improperly sits down, gets verbal and pulls out a knife and stabs him and then he goes on GoFundMe to get hundreds of thousands. You can't have that. It's not. The society won't work. These people are not gang bangers. You can't have a guy walking in Washington D.C. a young 19 year old congressional staffer shot, just shot and killed. You can't have the doge person just seeing a woman attack and he's beaten to a pulp. And I think most of the people who beat him are out. It doesn't work as a society. It's not civilized. And I know I'm going to get a lot of static for saying that, but I would like people to make the argument that this is nothing or I want to make the argument that somehow this is a MAGA issue or that or somehow Carlos Brown was a victim. As you know, she said people. That's what she implied. Is it by Littles Lytles, the mayor? She should resign in shame, she really should.