Come Back, America! with Rory Stewart - The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart

Summary

The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart Episode: "Come Back, America! with Rory Stewart" Release Date: April 24, 2025

In this thought-provoking episode of The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart, host Jon Stewart engages in a deep and comprehensive discussion with renowned author, former Member of Parliament, and former minister Rory Stewart. The conversation delves into the tumultuous state of American politics under President Donald Trump, the shifting dynamics of international relations, and the rise of populist and far-right movements both in the United States and Europe.

1. The Tumultuous First 100 Days of Trump's Presidency

Jon Stewart opens the discussion by expressing his frustration with the current state of American politics. He highlights the resignation of Senator Dick Durbin of Illinois after a lengthy 40-year tenure, questioning the societal norms that have led to such a development. Stewart critiques the ongoing trade war with China, emphasizing its detrimental impact on the U.S. economy and global stability.

“We are so generally fucked.” — Jon Stewart [06:19]

Stewart laments the chaotic approach of the Trump administration, particularly focusing on the self-inflicted tariffs that are destabilizing the global economy without yielding substantial benefits.

2. European Perspectives on American Policies

Introducing Rory Stewart, Jon Stewart seeks to understand Europe's increasingly hostile stance towards America. Stewart discusses the historical context of U.S. involvement in global institutions post-World War II and how recent policies have strained these relationships.

“Throughout the history of the United States, the executive has always had a great deal of power, but it's always supercharged that power through the process of emergency declarations.” — Rory Stewart [09:08]

Rory Stewart analyzes how the Trump administration leverages emergency powers to override other branches of government, leading to a concentration of authority that undermines democratic checks and balances.

3. The Impact of Tariffs and Trade Wars

The conversation delves into the complexities of Trump's trade policies, particularly concerning China. Stewart critiques the administration's inconsistent messaging regarding tariffs, highlighting their adverse effects on American businesses and global trade relations.

“I was riveted by the first one. I don't, I don't remember any of the rest of it.” — Jon Stewart [47:24]

Stewart questions the sustainability of tariffs as a strategy, pointing out the contradictory statements from Trump about the intentions behind these economic measures.

4. Decline of Liberal Democracy and Rise of Authoritarianism

Stewart and Rory Stewart explore the broader implications of America's internal turmoil on the global stage. They discuss the erosion of liberal democratic values and the ascent of authoritarian leaders who challenge the established international order.

“We’ve entered this funny shadow world. The rules-based international order has become the strong will do what they will and the weak must suffer what they must.” — Quentin [23:17]

The pair examines how the weakening of democratic institutions has created a vacuum that populist leaders are eager to fill, leading to increased instability and conflict.

5. Rise of Populism and Far-Right Movements in Europe

The episode critically assesses the surge of far-right parties across Europe, such as Germany's Alternative for Germany (AfD), correlating it with similar trends in American politics. Stewart discusses the factors fueling this rise, including economic discontent and nationalistic sentiments.

“These are people who think like many people did in the 1920s and 30s that liberal democracy was kind of weak and indecisive and incompetent and it failed people.” — Quentin [50:30]

He highlights the dangerous parallels between historical fascist movements and current populist leaders, emphasizing the need for robust democratic responses.

6. Immigration Policies and Their Political Consequences

Immigration emerges as a central theme, with Stewart and Rory Stewart debating the impact of America's broken immigration system on political stability. They argue that uncontrolled immigration is a significant driver behind the rise of far-right sentiments in Europe.

“Uncontrolled immigration is the number one reason for the rise of the far right in Europe.” — Quentin [56:27]

Rory Stewart advocates for humane yet controlled immigration policies, stressing the importance of balancing compassion with national security and economic stability.

7. The Role of Media and Modern Political Discourse

The discussion shifts to the influence of media and the changing landscape of political communication. Stewart criticizes the spectacle-driven nature of modern politics, likening it to reality TV and highlighting its role in promoting superficial engagement over substantive policy debates.

“It's the politics of reality TV.” — Quentin [62:07]

They explore how social media and entertainment-centric politics have undermined informed discourse, contributing to the electorate's susceptibility to demagoguery.

8. Solutions and Opportunities for Democratic Renewal

In addressing the challenges discussed, Stewart and Rory Stewart propose actionable solutions to restore and strengthen democratic institutions. They emphasize the need for patience, investment in grassroots initiatives, and reforms that promote transparency and accountability.

“We need committed, idealistic, tenacious, resilient young students to go into journalism.” — Rory Stewart [73:51]

Stewart highlights successful models of international cooperation and development, such as the transformation of Eastern European countries post-World War II, as examples of what coordinated, patient policy efforts can achieve.

9. The Importance of Economic Policies and Redistribution

The conversation touches on the role of economic policies in fostering stability and prosperity. Stewart critiques regressive environmental policies that disproportionately affect the poor, advocating for more equitable approaches to taxation and redistribution.

“Most of our environmental policies have been regressive, which means that they've had the biggest impact on the poor.” — Quentin [58:39]

He underscores the necessity of comprehensive tax reforms that address inequality while promoting sustainable development.

10. Call to Action: "Come Back, America!"

As the episode concludes, Stewart and Rory Stewart issue a heartfelt plea for America to reclaim its role as a stabilizing force in the world. They call for a resurgence of values that prioritize democracy, human rights, and international cooperation.

“Come back, America.” — Quentin [65:30]

This rallying cry encapsulates the episode's overarching theme: the urgent need for renewed leadership and a recommitment to democratic ideals to navigate the present crises and shape a more stable and prosperous future.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

Jon Stewart: “We are so generally fucked.” [06:19]
Rory Stewart: “Throughout the history of the United States, the executive has always had a great deal of power, but it's always supercharged that power through the process of emergency declarations.” [09:08]
Quentin: “We’ve entered this funny shadow world. The rules-based international order has become the strong will do what they will and the weak must suffer.” [23:17]
Quentin: “These are people who think like many people did in the 1920s and 30s that liberal democracy was kind of weak and indecisive and incompetent and it failed people.” [50:30]
Quentin: “Uncontrolled immigration is the number one reason for the rise of the far right in Europe.” [56:27]
Quentin: “It's the politics of reality TV.” [62:07]
Rory Stewart: “We need committed, idealistic, tenacious, resilient young students to go into journalism.” [73:51]
Quentin: “Come back, America.” [65:30]

Conclusion

This episode of The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart serves as a comprehensive examination of the current challenges facing America and the broader international community. Through incisive dialogue with Rory Stewart, Stewart offers a critical analysis of political dysfunction, economic instability, and the erosion of democratic values. The discussions emphasize the necessity for thoughtful policy reforms, international cooperation, and a reinvigorated commitment to democratic principles to address the multifaceted crises of the modern world.

Transcript

Quentin (0:00)

Location the lab. Quentin only has 24 hours to sell his car. Is that even possible? He goes to Carvana.com. what is this, a movie trailer? He ignores the doubters, enters his license plate. Wow, that's a great offer. The car is sold. But will Carvana pick it up in time for.

Kaley Cuoco (0:19)

They'll literally pick it up tomorrow morning. Done with the dramatics.

Quentin (0:23)

Car selling in record time. Save your time. Go to Carvana.com and sell your car today.

Kaley Cuoco (0:28)

Pickup fees may apply.

Jon Stewart (0:31)

Hey there travelers. Kaley Cuoco here. Sorry to interrupt your music. Great artist BT Dubs, but wouldn't you rather be there to hear it live? With Priceline you can get out of your dreams and into your dream concert. They've got millions of travel deals to get you to that festival gig, rave, sound bath or sonic experience you've been dreaming of. Download the Priceline app today and you can save up to 60% off hotels and up to 50% off flights. So don't just dream about that trip. Book it with Priceline.

Quentin (0:57)

Go to your happy price.

Rory Stewart (0:58)

Priceline Foreign. Hello everybody, welcome once again. Weekly show podcast with Jon Stewart. My name is Jon Stewart. I'm actually the person in the intro. It just, I don't know, it just worked out that way. We are talking to you Wednesday, April 23rd. We always try and date it because of the speed in which current events has been moving. It is exhausting. We are approaching the first hundred days of Donald Trump's re presidency and the first congressional casualty, Mr. Dick Durbin. Senator Dick Durbin of Illinois. Illinois. Illinois. I like to add the S. Although what would he Plural. Illinois. Illinoises. I don't know. We'll figure it out. He said he is not going to seek reelection. And here's the shocking part. He's only been in Congress I think 40 some years and he's only 80. To see a senator self deport at the ripe young age of 80. My God, my God, what have we become as a society to drive these kinds of adolescent junior senators from office? It's like watching someone declare for the draft as a freshman. No sir, you're not ready. You're not ready to go. You must, you must mature. We're so generally fucked. And that the trade war is apparently now this is going to be such an interesting Houdini esque escape from these utterly disastrous self inflicted tariffs. You saw Trump today in a press conference. Well, nah, you know China, they, they've got to make a deal, they've got to do it. And so because they have to make the deal. And because everybody's kissing my ass even though no deals are done, I'm probably just gonna, you know, remove the tariffs at some point. Having nothing to do with the fact that yesterday I sat down with Target and Walmart and all the big box stores and they were like, you're killing us. We are the only thing keeping the economy going for cheap goods and we will have nothing on our shelves in like a week. You're going to see a run on toilet paper that would make the COVID era panic seem like a stroll in the park, for God's sakes. And somehow they'll pull off the, the feet of saying this was the plan the whole time. And what a brilliant strategy it was to tank the global economy for as long as he did while still getting nothing out of it. Meanwhile overseas, who the hell knows how will, will the EU move towards China? Will Russia just be able to consume Ukraine in the way that they want to? We just have no idea. This is a failure on all levels. The first hundred days have been nothing but sturm and drang and noise signifying nothing. And it doesn't have to be this way. So many of their policy goals could be achievable in non chaotic terms and yet they seem incapable of playing that out. Fucking madness. But we're going to get the view from Europe today with our guest, which I'm very excited about. Quite a, quite a renaissance gentleman that we have joining us on the program today. Delighted to have him. Foreign ladies and gentlemen, delighted. Today, the Stewart brothers, that's it. Reunited Rory Stewart, nay Leibowitz brothers from a different mother, co host of the Rest is politics, but truly an enlightenment gentleman, author, former mp, former minister. We're just, we're excited to have you discussing things with us today. Rory. You are obviously, you know, your career as an author and as a minister. You're so ensconced in politics as well as broadcasting and all these other things. We just thought you'd be a great person to give us a broad perspective on the view from overseas towards America. As you know, America, we're very shy. We don't like people to think about us.