← The Why Files: Operation Podcast
The Why Files: Operation Podcast
615: Lincoln Conspiracy: a Diary, a Mummy and The Escape of John Wilkes Booth
00:42:57
Loading summary
Transcript62 lines
- [00:02]
Commercial Announcer
Upgrade your laundry routine with a durable and reliable Maytag laundry pair at Lowe's. Like the new Maytag washer and dryer with performance enhanced stain fighting power designed to cut through serious dirt and grime. And what's great is this laundry pair is in stock and ready for delivery when you need it the most. Don't miss out. Shop Maytag in store or online today at Lowe's.
- [00:31]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
Everyone thinks they know how Lincoln died. John Wilkes Booth shot the President, escaped, and was killed 12 days later on a Virginia farm. But the FBI's own forensic tests discovered Booth's diary is missing 86 pages. Pages filled with names, payments and secrets. Lincoln's assassination wasn't the work of a single extremist. It was a plot to take control of America. And it worked. The evidence exposes secret allies, strange coverups, and why the truth was buried for more than a century. This isn't the story of how John Wilkes Booth died. This is the story of how he escaped and who helped him do it. In early 1865, the Civil War was in its fourth brutal year. The Confederates were losing, but they continued to fight. And Union casualties continued to mount. During this time, John Wilkes Booth was one of the most famous actors in America. He was known for his emotional performances and striking good looks. Dark hair, unusually dark eyes. He was lean and athletic. He was the first documented celebrity to have his clothes torn by infatuated fans.
- [01:46]
Grainger Commercial Voice
I am ever so grateful, sir.
- [01:49]
John Wilkes Booth / Confederate Sympathizer
It is my pleasure entirely.
- [01:51]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
Booth was obsessed with Shakespeare's Julius Caesar, a play he performed with his brothers. He saw Lincoln as a tyrant. Like Caesar, Booth was from Maryland, a slave state. He identified as a Southerner. So when war broke out, he became a Confederate spy. As an A list celebrity, he could move freely in polite society. He socialized with wealthy businessmen, politicians, and all kinds of important people. He then sent their secrets to the Confederates. Through a clerk with access to Lincoln's private correspondence, Booth saw the President's plan for after the war, and it horrified him. Confederate leaders would be tried for treason. Their land would be given to former slaves, who would also get the right to vote. Everything the south stood for would be erased from history. He had to act. Booth came up with a bold kidnap Lincoln. If the north wanted their President back alive, they would have to release all Confederate prisoners of war and give the south better terms. Booth assembled a team, and after months of planning, they were ready. Then just before the plan went into motion, General Robert E. Lee surrendered at Appomattox. Booth was devastated. The war was over, and now the kidnapping plot was useless. Then Booth had a stroke of luck. He overheard that the President would be attending a play at Ford's Theater in Washington, D.C. booth knew the theater well. He performed there many times. He even knew where the President would be sitting because Lincoln attended one of Booth's performances there. So Booth came up with a new plan. Kill the President during the play. He knew he could move around the theater freely without raising suspicion. So getting in wasn't a problem. Getting out was. But John Wilkes Booth had friends in high places who wanted Lincoln dead as much as he did. They would help him escape. His contacts weren't Confederate spies deep in the South. They were right here in Washington, inside Lincoln's own cabinet. This episode is sponsored by Fume Zero, the grab and go flavored air device that's changing habits, not just replacing them. Fume 0 is single use, preloaded and ready to go right out of the box. No charging, no refills, no setup. And it's completely clean. Zero nicotine, zero vapor, zero batteries, just natural plant based flavored air crisp Mint is my go to when I need that afternoon pick me up. It's cool, clean and helps me reset without reaching for something I'll regret later. With six bold flavors and over 10 days of use, Fume Zero keeps things simple and satisfying. You can even adjust the airflow to get the perfect draw, and the sleek triangular design feels great in your hand. The subtle click is surprisingly calming, and the soft, chewable tip checks that box when you need something to hold onto. Fume Zero is designed to replace the ritual without the chemicals and without the guilt. Take zero chances with Fume Zero today available for just $24.99. Just head to try fume.com that's T-R-Y-F u-m.com to start with. Zero.
- [04:57]
Grainger Commercial Voice
This is the story of the One as a custodial supervisor at a high school, he knows that during cold and flu season, germs spread fast. It's why he partners with Grainger to stay fully stocked on the products and supplies he needs, from tiss to disinfectants to floor scrubbers. All so that he can help students, staff and teachers stay healthy and focused. Call 1-800-GRAINGER click granger.com or just stop by Granger for the ones who get it done.
- [05:33]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
Abraham Lincoln's second inaugural address was about unity. He called slavery a sin, but he avoided placing blame on the south, he famously said, with malice toward none and charity for all. Lincoln wanted to pardon most Southerners and allow the states to regain their rights, but no slavery. The plan was not universally well received. Like Julius Caesar, Abraham Lincoln was surrounded by enemies. On one side were the Democrats. They wanted a quick return to the status quo. They wanted most Southerners pardoned. And most Democrats voted against freeing the slaves. On the other side were the Radical Republicans. They wanted all slaves freed and given the land seized in the war. They wanted federal military control of the Southern states and harsh punishment. Radical Republicans weren't just in Congress. They were in Lincoln's own cabinet. Secretary of War Edwin Stanton was the most powerful man in America after Lincoln. He controlled the military and all federal law enforcement agencies. But he could not control President Lincoln. Stanton believed showing mercy to the south was a betrayal of everything the Union soldiers died for. Lincoln wouldn't budge. But Vice President Andrew Johnson would. His loyalty was flexible. Stanton could control him and become the real power in Washington. Through his intelligence network, Stanton contacted John Wilkes Booth and gave him everything he needed to kidnap Lincoln. With Lincoln gone, Congress would impeach him. Johnson would step in, and Stanton would control the government. But if the public learned of a coup, it would divide the country. But if Lincoln were kidnapped by a Confederate terrorist, the country would unite behind Johnson, essentially behind Stanton. Booth was the perfect choice. He was wealthy, famous, and an outspoken critic of Lincoln's. The whole country would believe it. Booth agreed. Stanton gave him Lincoln's schedule, security details, funding, maps of escape routes, everything he needed. But the war ended. The kidnapping plot wouldn't work. Stanton was trying to think of another solution when he learned that Booth was going to kill Lincoln instead. It would happen in public during a play in a Washington theater. Now Stanton had a decision to make. Warn Lincoln and save his life or let Booth go through with it. Stanton made his choice. He made sure that the assassination would succeed. He removed military escorts and left escape routes open. General Ulysses S. Grant was supposed to join Lincoln at the theater. Stanton gave him different orders. Lincoln requested that Major Thomas T. Eckert be his bodyguard, But Stanton said he was needed elsewhere. He left Lincoln exposed. The more Stanton thought about the plan, the more he liked it. It was clean and dramatic. It was perfect. But as the plot to kill Lincoln unfolded, things would go very, very wrong.
- [08:46]
John Wilkes Booth / Confederate Sympathizer
He gives our slaves freedom, that they take up arms against us. I swear, the man's gone mad. You know what he'll do next? Bring his carpetbaggers down here. Northern men with clean coats and dirty hands buying up what's left for pennies. I did not fight to live under a Yankee boot. Lincoln cannot be allowed to Continue. This is tyranny. If Lincoln will not listen to reason, we must take our grievances to the Congress. This is not merely about politics anymore, sir. It is about the future of the Republic. We have to move against him now while we still can. And what would you have us do? The war's lost, the Confederacy's ashes. What's left but survival? Sometimes survival is cowardice. Sometimes history demands blood to balance the scales.
- [09:33]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
You speak of treason.
- [09:39]
John Wilkes Booth / Confederate Sympathizer
I speak of patriotism. Careful, John. Union spies are everywhere. These walls have ears. Oh, let them hear. History listens, too. I'll not stand by while Lincoln crowns himself emperor of a mutilated nation. You're an actor, not a soldier. Don't play hero in the wrong tragedy. Every play needs its villain. History will decide which one.
- [10:13]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
On April 14, 1865, Washington, D.C. was celebrating. Robert E. Lee had surrendered at Appomattox five days earlier. The Civil War was over, but something had. Lincoln rattled. During a cabinet meeting, he mentioned a recurring dream he had about a president being assassinated. Killed by a shot to the back of the head. Secretary of War Edwin Stanton listened to but said nothing. President Lincoln and his wife, Mary Todd, decided to celebrate by watching a performance of Our American Cousin that night at Ford's Theater. Booth's plan went into motion. That morning, he drilled a peephole in the door of the presidential box at the theater. He'd know exactly when to make his move. Evening came, and the President and First lady settled into their seats outside the door. Lincoln's bodyguard was replaced by John Parker, who had a history of being drunk and sleeping on duty assigned by Edwin Stanton. Once the play started, Parker left his post and headed for the saloon. The only person left outside the door was Charles Forbes, Lincoln's valet. Forbes wasn't a bodyguard. His job was to run errands and plan travel. So when Booth approached the presidential box, Forbes let him pass. Just another celebrity stopping by to see the President. Once inside, Booth quietly wedged a piece of wood behind the door and broke the lock. Now all he had to do was wait for the right moment, and that moment would come during the third act, the biggest laugh of the night. The line, you suck dologizing old man trap. He knew exactly when this line was said. At 10:15pm the audience exploded in laughter. Booth stepped forward and raised his pistol.
- [12:01]
John Wilkes Booth / Confederate Sympathizer
Ever thus to tyrants.
- [12:05]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
One shot lost in the roar of 1500 people laughing. President Lincoln slumped in his chair. Booth jumped from the box and onto the stage. At first, the crowd did nothing. They thought this was part of the show. Then Booth raised his knife and yelled, sic semper tyrannis. Thus always to tyrants. The line Brutus said when he stabbed Julius Caesar. It's also the state motto of Virginia. Booth turned to run and felt pain shoot up his left leg. He broke his ankle, but adrenaline kept him moving toward the unguarded back door. Outside, a horse was waiting. Within the hour, Edwin Stanton took control. He shut down every bridge leaving Washington except one, the one Booth used for his escape. Everything had gone according to plan. Lincoln was dead, and Stanton would control the investigation himself. There was just one final loose end. Stanton had to deal with John Wilkes Booth. Within hours of Lincoln's assassination, Secretary of War Edwin Stanton mobilized the largest manhunt in American history. Every bridge out of Washington was sealed. Every road was blocked. Every farm was searched. The reward for John Wilkes Booth and his conspirators was a staggering $100,000, almost 2 million in today's money. The authorities preferred him alive, but Edwin Stanton preferred him dead. Booth hooked up with another conspirator, David Herold. Together they slipped through the Union dragnet and headed toward Virginia. Their first stop was Dr. Samuel Mudd's farm in southern Maryland. Mudd set Booth's broken leg and gave them a place to rest. By dawn, word of the assassination had spread. Mudd, suddenly realizing the danger, forced them to leave. David Herold guided them deeper into Confederate country. They moved at night. They hid in swamps during the day. Other Confederate agents gave them food and newspapers. Six days later, they crossed the Potomac river into Virginia. They thought they'd be safe in Virginia. The Confederacy was dead, but Confederate sympathy was still very much alive. They found shelter, food, and horses from local farmers who still hated the Union. But the manhunt was closing in. On April 24, Booth and Harold reached the Garrett farm near Port Royal, Virginia. Richard Garrett, a tobacco farmer, offered them a place to stay. He thought they were Confederate soldiers heading home from the war. For two days, Booth rested and played with the Garrett children. His broken leg was feeling better. He talked about going to Mexico or maybe heading west. The future looked possible again. But on the night of April 25th, everything changed. 26 soldiers from the 16th New York Cavalry surrounded the barn. They called for the men to surrender or they would set fire to the building. David Herold immediately gave up. He stumbled out of the barn with his hands raised, yelling, don't shoot. I'm David Herold. But Booth refused to surrender. As the flames started to grow, a soldier saw a figure moving around inside. The man was holding a rifle. The soldier raised his pistol and shot the man through the neck, severing his spinal cord. He couldn't move, but he could still breathe, but just barely. The soldiers dragged Booth out of the barn. He whispered, tell Mother I die for my country. By sunrise, John Wilkes Booth was dead. Justice had been served, the case was closed, and America could finally move on. But John Wilkes Booth had a secret if my three cats could talk, they'd probably thank me for finally upgrading their litter. I mean, I wouldn't use single ply toilet paper, so why make them deal with outdated cat litter? Pretty Litter has truly improved things. It's soft on their paws, lasts longer than clay litter, and the color changing crystals help me catch potential health issues early. A big deal with three cats. And the crystals are totally safe for cats and humans. It ships free. No heavy bags, no last minute store runs, and the odor control is excellent. My house actually smells like a house, not a litter box. I use Pretty Litter and you should too. It's smart, safe, and makes life easier. Right now save 20% on your first order and get a free cat toy at pretty litter.com thewifiles that's prettylitter.com thewifiles to save 20% on your first order AND get a free cat toy. Pretty litter.com thewifiles Pretty Litter cannot detect every feline health issue or prevent or diagnose diseases. A diagnosis can only come from a licensed veterinarian. Terms and conditions apply. See site for details.
- [16:41]
Grainger Commercial Voice (Venue Maintenance)
This is the story of the One as head of maintenance at a concert hall, he knows the show must always go on. That's why he works behind the scenes, ensuring every light is working, the H Vac is humming, and his facility shines with Granger's supplies and solutions for every challenge he faces. Plus 24. 7 customer support his venue never misses a beat. Call quickgranger.com or just stop by Grainger for the ones who get it done.
- [17:15]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
At the height of his career, John Wilkes Booth was one of the highest paid entertainers in the world, earning close to half a million dollars a year in today's money. His career depended on his bachelor image, but in 1859, Booth secretly married actress Isola Martha Mills. Within a year, Isola gave birth to their daughter, Ogarida. Booth quietly supported them. The arrangement worked until the assassination, and after reports of Booth's death, John Stevenson proposed to Issola. He'd loved her for years, but she refused. She quietly told him she was still married. Booth was alive and hiding in San Francisco under a False identity. She was meeting him there. In a few weeks, on the other side of the country, a British passport was issued to John Byron Wilkes. Wilkes and his wife boarded the Indian Queen, a former Civil War blockade runner. John and Isla sailed to India. But Isla couldn't stay. The heat, the unfamiliar culture, the isolation. She was pregnant again and couldn't imagine raising a child in India. So she returned to the States. Months passed without a word from Booth. So John Stevenson proposed again. This time, she accepted. She needed stability for her unborn child. Stevenson said he would claim the child as his own. Not long after Isola gave birth to her son, Harry Jerome Stevenson, back in Bombay, John Wilkes Booth wrote out a last will and testament. He signed it John Byron Wilkes, then mailed it to the States. The will was detailed money and property to his wife Isola, his daughter and son Ogarita and Harry Jerome Stevenson. He named Sarah Scott and Mary Louise Turner as his other daughters. By other women. He left money for his personal valet, Henry Johnson, and his wife Sarah, who looked after the children. Word of the will spread. Ulysses S. Grant himself ordered an investigation to locate all the heirs. Eventually, John Wilkes Booth's estate was distributed exactly as the will instructed. But Grant never let it go. How could a man named John Byron Wilkes know every detail about Booth's secret life? His lovers, his children, his financial affairs. Information that only Booth would know. But aside from the will, Grant had no real evidence. He was forced to let it go. So the official story was John Wilkes Booth was killed on Garrett's farm in 1865. But in the summer of 1872, someone saw a ghost in a dusty saloon in Texas. And that ghost was pouring whiskey and reciting Shakespeare. The man behind the bar was John St. Helen. Average height, lean build, dark hair going a little gray at the temples. He quoted Shakespeare from memory, and when he thought nobody was looking, he practiced drawing a pistol from his coat. St. Helen drifted into town in the spring of 72. He said he was from back east, but didn't talk much about his past. That suited everyone fine. Texas in 1872 was full of men running from something. After a few whiskeys, John St. Helen would recite full Shakespearean soliloquies. It was during one of these performances that Finest Bates first walked into the bar. Bates was a young lawyer from Memphis. Smart, ambitious, easy to talk to. The kind of man who bought drinks for interesting strangers and listened to their stories. St Helen and Bates hit it off immediately. The bartender was well read, articulate, and had opinions about everything from politics to poetry. They spent hours talking after the saloon closed, sharing whiskey and stories. Well, Bates shared stories. St. Helen mostly listened. They spoke about the war and the future of the country. St Helen never mentioned his past. That winter, St. Helen caught pneumonia. For days, he ran a high fever and drifted in and out of consciousness. Bates sat by his bedside, convinced his friend was dying. On the third night, St. Helen grabbed Bates by the wrist and pulled him close. He was still running a high fever, but his eyes were bright and focused.
- [21:18]
John Wilkes Booth / Confederate Sympathizer
Finus, I need to tell you something before it's too late. I'm not who you think I am. My real name is John Wilkes Booth.
- [21:30]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
Bates thought John was delirious, but he wouldn't stop. He told Bates everything. The conspiracy, the escape, the years in hiding. He described details that only Booth would know. The layout of Ford's Theater. The feeling of the wooden stage beneath his feet. The sound Lincoln made when the bullet hit. Bates was stunned. Either his friend was having the most elaborate fever dream in history or. Or he was the most wanted man in America. By morning, the fever had broken and John St. Helen was going to live. And that's when the panic set in. He said, too much. What have I done? Three days later, he was gone. All that was left of John St. Helen was an empty room and a bartender's apron hanging on a hook. John Wilkes Booth had once again disappeared. Bates didn't tell anyone about John's confession, but he never stopped wondering. Was John St. Helen really John Wilkes Booth? Or was that a sick man's delusion? Well, in 1903, a painter in Oklahoma committed suicide. When they searched the man's belongings, they found a handwritten note. It said, if anything happens to him, contact a lawyer named Finus Bates. The Telegram reached Bates three days later. After 26 years of questions, he was about to get an answer when Bates arrived at the funeral parlor. His hands were shaking. The undertaker led him to a back room where a body lay on the table. He was told the man was David E. George. Bates pulled back the sheet and stared for a long moment. The man on the table was older and thinner, but it was unmistakable. It was John, going by the name David E. David E. George had been living there for several years, working as a painter. He was quiet. He kept to himself. He was forgettable. But he had secrets. David E. George drank too much. He talked to himself. Late at night, neighbors in the boarding house heard him reciting Shakespeare. The landlady, Mrs. Harper, said David George had been acting strange for weeks. He was nervous and paranoid. He kept saying they were coming for him. She thought he meant bill collectors. On January 13, 1903, David bought a bottle of strychnine from the pharmacy. He told the clerk that he had a rat problem. That night, he drank the poison. He lived long enough to call for a minister. The minister found David writhing on his bed, foam coming from his mouth. The minister held his hand. When David made his confession, he whispered that he was John Wilkes Booth, the man who killed Abraham Lincoln. He begged God's forgiveness, and then he was gone. Among David's possessions were newspaper clippings about Lincoln's assassination and the manhunt for Booth. Some pages were yellow with age there for decades. Bates was convinced this was John Wilkes Booth. He asked the local authorities to preserve his body. If this really was Booth, then this was the most important corpse in American history. The body was embalmed and put on display for months. Crowds lined up to stare at the preserved remains of David E. George, AKA John St. Helen, AKA John Wilkes Booth. The mummy toured across the country. It appeared at carnivals, state fairs and local museums. Doctors examined the body and found intriguing details. The corpse had a broken left leg, just like Booth, a deformed right thumb, also like Booth. And there was a scar on the back of the neck that matched the location of a scar Booth had from a tumor removal. The mummy eventually disappeared into storage and then into legend. But the story continued. John Wilkes Booth had lived for 38 years after supposedly dying at Garrett's Farm. So how did Booth get out of that burning barn? Well, he didn't. The man who was shot on Garrett's farm was someone else. When Union soldiers surrounded Garrett's farm that night, they had orders capture Booth alive. But Secretary of War Edwin Stanton let it be known that if Booth were found dead, the reward would still be paid. After Booth was killed, the military demanded an autopsy. The body was quickly wrapped in a horse blanket and transported from a wagon to a steamship, then to a government tugboat, and then finally to the USS Montauk at the Washington Navy Yard. The identification was hasty, highly controlled and deeply suspicious. Surgeon General Joseph K. Barnes conducted the autopsy. A photograph was taken to the body, but it's never been released to the public. This was probably the most important autopsy in US History to that point. But the photograph has either been lost or suppressed. Dr. Barnes allowed three civilians aboard. None of the three knew Booth personally. Booth had friends all over Washington. Actors, politicians, socialites. Barnes didn't call any of them. Instead, he called Dr. John Frederick May. May had removed the growth from Booth's neck a few years earlier. He was brought to verify the scar. May examined the body and hesitated. In his memoirs, he wrote that he didn't recognize it as Booth's. He wasn't sure about the scar. He noticed that the body had an injured right leg, but Booth fractured his left leg. Now, maybe the witnesses got that wrong. But the injury on the corpse was old. Booth's wasn't. He broke it less than two weeks before, and despite his protests, Dr. May was pressured into signing off that this was John Wilkes Booth. Other witnesses raised doubts. The man had the wrong proportions, the wrong bone structure. The body was buried quickly, in secret beneath the floor of a military prison. Booth's family begged to see the remains. They were denied. If this wasn't John Wilkes Booth, then who did the soldiers drag out of that barn? Well, they asked David Herold and he told him Lately it feels like every headline is about AI. And yeah, it's impressive. But the question is, how do you actually use this stuff and get more done? Well, that's where Zapier comes in. Zapier is the easiest way to automate your work across thousands of apps. No coding required. It connects tools like Gmail, HubSpot, Typeform, and Slack and lets them talk to each other. Think of it as your behind the scenes assistant, quietly running repetitive tasks so you don't have to. We actually use Zapier every day in Slack. Zapier moves info between Slack and our other apps automatically. You can set up custom workflows called zaps in minutes, like sending form responses to a channel or turning saved messages into to dos. It's simple, fast and incredibly powerful. And Zapier is for everyone. No it bottlenecks, no complexity, just clean automation that helps you get more done. Join the 3.4 million companies already automating with Zapier and transform how you work with Zapier and AI. Get started for free by visiting zapier.com the y files that's z-a p I-E-R.com thewaifiles.
- [28:34]
Grainger Commercial Voice
This is the story of the one as a custodial supervisor at a high school, he knows that during cold and flu season, germs spread fast. It's why he partners with Granger to stay fully stocked on the products and supplies he needs, from tissues to disinfectants to floor scrubbers, all so that he can help students, staff and teachers stay healthy and full focused. Call 1-800-granger. Click granger.com or just stop by Granger for the ones who get it done.
- [29:08]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
David Harold came out of the tobacco barn with his hands up. The first thing he said was, don't shoot. Then he said, that's not Booth in there. Then Harold named the man James William Boyd. The soldiers ignored him. Boyd was an ex Confederate soldier, the same build as Booth, same complexion, and coincidentally, the same initials. Harold said Booth was a day ahead of them in Harper's Ferry. The plan was to catch up, and Boyd would help them sail across the Potomac. But Boyd was a double agent. He was just released from prison by Stanton personally. And there was a reason for that. Stanton and Booth had a deal. Booth would be allowed to escape to India with his wife. Boyd would stand in and take the fall. So Boyd and Booth swapped coats. But Booth forgot to take his diary, which revealed everything. Names, meetings, payments, all pointing back to Edwin Stanton. When Stanton received the diary, he destroyed it. He destroyed all the evidence and created the official story that Americans believed for 150 years. John Wilkes Booth walked away from Garrett's farm. He sailed to India as John Byron Wilkes. He returned to America as John St. Helen and died in Oklahoma as David E. George. Three vertebrae were removed from the body during the autopsy. A DNA test could prove or disprove that the bones came from Booth. No testing has been allowed. His body is allegedly buried in the Booth family plot in Baltimore. And now people leave pennies on the gravestone they believe to be John Wilkes Booths, as if giving Lincoln the last word. And the family has requested that the body be exhumed for testing. That request was denied. Nobody even knows where in the cemetery he's buried. His brother. Edwin didn't mark the grave out of fear it would be vandalized. And John Wilkes Booth has a lot of descendants alive today, all through his marriage to Isola. History says Booth didn't have children, but his descendants believe that he did. And as far as they're concerned, they're living proof foreign. I'm a big fan of American history. If you made it this far, you are, too. And this story was fun. But if Booth escaped, we have to rewrite history. So did he. Well, let's pull it apart. Dr. John Frederick may identified Booth's body. It's true that he said he didn't recognize it at first, but that was because it was badly decomposed. When he saw the surgical scar, he was convinced it was Booth. He would know. He performed the surgery. And multiple witnesses confirmed the body's identity. The broken leg was also confirmed. Now, John Wilkes Booth did keep a diary, and it was tampered with. That's documented. But he didn't use his diary as a journal. It was more like a day planner. The missing pages may contain incriminating evidence, but probably not. Still, nobody knows for sure. James William Boyd was a real person. He was a Confederate captain and prisoner of war. And Secretary of War Edwin Stanton authorized his release. That's true, but this wasn't unusual. Boyd had seven children. His wife had died and they would starve without him. He requested compassionate release, and Stanton granted it. The story of Boyd being a double agent comes from finest. Bates, the man who discovered John St. Helen, wasn't just a lawyer. He was also an entrepreneur. In 1907, 30 years after his supposed encounter in Texas, Bates published a book. The Escape and Suicide of John Wilkes Booth.
- [32:30]
Commentator / Skeptic
There's always a book.
- [32:32]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
Oh, now you're here. Why so quiet?
- [32:34]
Commentator / Skeptic
Well, dead presidents are only funny when they're in my wallet.
- [32:37]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
Fair enough. The book was a hit and made Bates famous. More importantly, it made Bates money. Bates went on speaking tours. He brought the mummy with him. He charged admission. The man who claimed his friend had confessed to being Lincoln's assassin built an entire career on that story. But here's what Bates never mentioned. When experts studied the handwriting samples he claimed came from John St. Helen, they didn't match John Wilkes Booth's confirmed writing. Not even close. They were from different people. The Isla story. That came from a 1937 book called this One Mad act, written by Isola Forrester. Forrester claimed to be Ogarita's daughter, the granddaughter of Booth and Isla Mills. And just a few years ago, the descendants of both Ogarita and Harry Jerome Stevenson had their DNA compared against confirmed Booth family DNA. No match. Neither family was related to John Wilkes Booth.
- [33:30]
Commentator / Skeptic
I love it when paternity tests come back negative.
- [33:33]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
So Booth never married and didn't have children. At least none that we found so far. And remember, when he killed Lincoln, he was only 26.
- [33:41]
Commentator / Skeptic
If I was a 26 year old movie star with ladies grabbing at my gills, I'd stay single, too.
- [33:47]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
The entire romantic subplot was fiction, just like Booth's will. Most of the story elements come from a 1977 book and movie called the Lincoln Conspiracy. And this wasn't a historical research project, it was entertainment. The authors even admitted they created composite characters and invented dialogue to make the story more dramatic. It was fiction.
- [34:07]
Commentator / Skeptic
Don't you do that.
- [34:08]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
Quiet. The Lincoln Conspiracy was fiction, but people treated it like fact. The book recycled Bates, debunked claims and added new ones. The body double theory. The government Cover up the missing diary pages that implicate Stanton. And speaking of Stanton, let's clear his name. Edwin Stanton was a villain in the story, but he was just as interested in helping freed slaves as Lincoln. He definitely thought Lincoln was too lenient on the south, but he was much closer to Lincoln's idea of Reconstruction than Andrew Johnson, a self described racist. Johnson's leniency toward the south led directly to the Jim Crow era. And those are wounds that still haven't healed. But the most damning evidence against the escape theory isn't what's missing, it's what's there. The detailed, day by day record of Booth's movements during his 12 days as a fugitive. There were multiple witnesses at every stop. Confederate sympathizers who helped him, Union soldiers who pursued him. You can't fake that kind of evidence. You can't.
- [35:05]
Commentator / Skeptic
If you can fake a moon landing, you can fake this.
- [35:09]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
Now, I think John Wilkes Booth died on Garrett's farm. But many people, including some of Booth's alleged descendants, believe he got away. There's a reason stories like this capture our attention. They let us reimagine history. Everybody likes to play what if. What if John Wilkes Booth got away? That's a fascinating and fun question. A more interesting question is what if Lincoln wasn't killed? What if. What if he were able to serve out the almost four years left in his second term? What if Lincoln oversaw Reconstruction? What if Andrew Johnson, who owned slaves before the war, never became president? Would Lincoln have allowed the KKK to form in 1866? Probably not. But Johnson did. Johnson vetoed almost every civil rights bill that came across his desk. He has the dishonor of being the first president ever to be impeached.
- [35:59]
Commentator / Skeptic
Oh, back when impeaching a president meant something.
- [36:01]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
Yep. If Lincoln lived, I suspect we'd be living in a very different country. A better country, a more just and united country. And John Wilkes Booth took that from us, from all of us, black and white. 150 years later, his actions are still felt today. Now, I enjoyed this mystery, but I will not celebrate the man. Whether shot to death in a barn or mummified, humiliated, and turned into a sideshow exhibit, either is a fitting end for one of the most despicable villains in in American history. There's only one thing I can tell you for sure about this story. If there's a hell, John Wilkes Booth is in it. Thank you so much for hanging out today. I'm A.J. that's Echelfish.
- [36:47]
Chiquis (Podcast Host)
Sick.
- [36:48]
Commentator / Skeptic
Super feely, concrete.
- [36:50]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
This has been The Y Files. If you have fun or learned anything, do us a favor. Like subscribe, comment, share. I know I'm a broken record, but that stuff really helps, I think. And like most topics we cover on the channel, today's is recommended by you, by quite a few of you. And I'm glad you recommended this one. As I'm recording this, I don't know how well this is going to do. I'm hoping to be pleasantly surprised. If not, we'll go back to aliens. Anyway, if there's a story you'd like to see or learn more about, go to yfiles.com tips email us jump on Discord, Send a chat, whatever you want to do. Remember, the why Files is also a podcast. You could take us on the road and twice a week I post deep dives into the stories we cover on the channel. I also post episodes that wouldn't be allowed on the channel, and those are labeled unredacted. The podcast is called, wait for it, the Y Files Operation Podcast and it's available everywhere you get your podcasts. And if you are listening on an audio platform, do me a favor, hit the thumbs up, the follow, the subscribe, all that stuff that really does help us out. Now, if you need more Wild Files in your life, see a therapist. I'm kidding. Check out our Discord. I don't know if we're at 100,000 people on there yet, but we're coming close. So that means 24. 7 There are people on there talking about the same weird stuff we talk about here on the show. It's a great community, it's really supportive, it's a lot of fun, and it's free to join. And speaking of 24. 7, check out our 24. 7 stream on the Y Files backstage link down below. Over there we run episodes back to back with some surprise fun content in between. And the live chat is more entertaining than the videos. If you want to know what's going on with the Y Files at any given time, check out our production Calendar. It's at thewhitefiles.com Cal There we post our episode schedule, upcoming podcasts, live streams, all the stuff that's going on. We post it there, usually. Special thanks to our patrons who made this channel possible. Every episode of the Wild Files is dedicated to our Patreon members. I couldn't do any of this without you. The channel means nothing without the support of our community. And if you'd like to support the channel, keep us going and join this amazing community. Become a Member on Patreon. It's only three bucks a month. Get access to all kinds of perks, like videos early with no commercials, exclusive merch only available to members, plus two private live streams every week just for you. And those are a lot of fun. So my webcam is on, but you get to meet the whole team. I'm going to forget some people, but Gino's there. Victoria, Jen, A.C. was there this week. The hybrid, Mary Jane. Anyone else I forgot? Those are great mods, but you can put your cam on, jump up on stage, ask us a question, tell a joke, recommend a topic, maybe follow up on something that we covered here. Whatever you want to talk about, I think it's the best perk there is. Another great way to support the channel is grab something from the WI fi store.
- [39:30]
Commentator / Skeptic
I grab a heck of a T shirt, one of these fist the book coffee mugs that you could stick your fist in or whatever you want to put in there. It's none of my concern. I grab a hoodie. Oh, shut my face on it. I get one of these squeeze little talking. Look how cute he is. One of these talking fishtail toy dolls.
- [39:46]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
But if you're gonna buy merch, make sure you become a member on YouTube. YouTube members get 10% off everything in the WI fi store. Get a new code every month and it's only three bucks. So if you're gonna spend $40 on t shirts, get the code and it pays for itself. And look, if you want to join, get the code and cancel. That's totally fine. The membership is not there to make me money. It's there to save you money. And besides, all that revenue goes to the team, not to me.
- [40:09]
Commentator / Skeptic
Yeah, you want to stop flapping me yappy with that one.
- [40:12]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
Those are the plugs. And that's going to do it. How long have I been talking for? 2 hours. This has been. This has been a doozy of an episode. I hope you enjoyed watching it as much as I enjoyed researching it. Until next time, be safe, be kind, and know that you are appreciated.
- [40:47]
Paranormal / UFO Enthusiast
I believe Olivia scenario A secret cold inside the Bible said I would.
- [40:56]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
I.
- [40:56]
Paranormal / UFO Enthusiast
Love my UFOs and paranormal fun as well as music so I'm singing like I should but then another conspiracy theory becomes the truth, my friends and it never ends no, it never ends.
- [41:25]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
I.
- [41:25]
Paranormal / UFO Enthusiast
Feel the crab cat and got stuck inside mel's home with MKUltra of being only 2 aware did Stanley Kubrick fake the moon landing alone on a film set or were the shadow people there? The Roswell alias gets fired called the smiling man I'm told and his name was cold I can't believe I'm dancing.
- [41:54]
Singer / Performer
With the fish handle fish on Thursday night Wednesday J the truth to the weapons.
- [42:12]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
Time.
- [42:30]
Paranormal / UFO Enthusiast
The M Man s and the solar stone still come to Agatha the secret city underground mysterious number stations Planet Surf 02 Project Stargate and what the dark watchers found.
- [43:04]
Singer / Performer
They change to.
- [43:05]
Paranormal / UFO Enthusiast
And the All I ever wanted was.
- [43:32]
Singer / Performer
To hear the truth so girly loves to dance yeah girly loves to dance on the dance floor because she is a camel and camels love to dance. That's when the feeling is right. Always in time.
- [44:27]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
Sam Foreign.
- [44:58]
Chiquis (Podcast Host)
Hi, this is Chiquis from the Chiquis and Chill podcast. My fur babies give me everything and I wish I could give just as much back. But hey, I'm only human. That's why I trust Hill's Pet Nutrition. Hill's science led nutrition helps you give more love than humanly possible. Most days my schedule is jam packed. I'm either out all day recording new episodes of Cheekies and Chill or I'm stuck in back to back business meetings. And I feel guilty knowing my babies Bancho and Raju are at home waiting for me to get back. But when I'm finally home, that's when I show them how much I love them by feeding them their favorite pet food so they can taste mi amor profundo. This human understands Science does more. Find the right food@hillspet.com forward/iheart.
- [45:49]
Singer / Performer
And I needed more. My kid was so bad and the smell never leaves. I don't know what to do. I'm always in the dark. The Sweatin Dance short smells like a dark dark. I'm Downy Rinsing tonight.
- [46:06]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
Downy Rinse fights stubborn odors in just one wash. When impossible odors get stuck in, rinse it out.
- [46:16]
James (Laundry Commercial Character)
That's the sound of James adding long lasting gain scent boosters to his laundry this morning. Several hours later, James sniffs the irresistible scent of Gain on his shirt.
- [46:27]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
Gain.
- [46:28]
James (Laundry Commercial Character)
Several hours later, James has even caught the attention of his mother in law and she never gives him attention.
- [46:34]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
Ooh, you smell amazing James. Oh thanks mom.
- [46:37]
Grainger Commercial Voice (Venue Maintenance)
I love you too.
- [46:38]
Narrator / Historian (A.J. Echelfish)
I never said that.
- [46:40]
James (Laundry Commercial Character)
Add gain scent boosters to your laundry. Add joy to your day.