
What do kids actually want for the holidays? We consulted three elementary-schoolers to find out if our gift recommendations for kids were hitting the mark.
Loading summary
Noah
Remy, welcome.
Remy
Out for Christmas, San Hanukkah.
Rosie
That's Noah, my four year old daughter. She's talking to her twin brother, Remy.
Remy
A tulip, a cake and a new light and a manor.
Rosie
I'm Rosie and this is the Wirecutter show. We are nearly through our holiday gifting series where we've been featuring product recommendations, gifting advice and listener questions all about giving to those you love over the holidays. The other episodes in this series are admittedly geared toward grownups, but in my experience, kids are perhaps the most complicated recipients on a gift list. Almost always discerning, committed to honest feedback, specific about what they want, and sometimes incredibly unspecific.
Remy
Noah, what do I like for Christmas in Hanukkah? I like a princess thing with and then a sparkly present for Hanukkah which was a golden medal and then a surprise.
Rosie
So today we're going straight to the source. I'm going to talk to real life kids about what they like and and don't like. To help you get a sense of what might make good gifts for the kids in your life. I sat down with three kids. Dior, age 8, Robinson, age 11 and Chloe, who's specifically 6 and 3 quarters. These kids are from different places, they celebrate different holidays, but one thing they all have in common is that they're kids who love presents. Shock her. These three told me what they've got on their list this year and and I showed them each an age appropriate Wirecutter gift guide to get their take on our picks to see how our expert recommendations are received by the real experts.
Remy
And now a beautiful dressful dress up and some fenty shoes and some gloves.
Rosie
Onto the main event.
Remy
And sparkly shoes and sparkly gloves and legos and a new book.
Chloe
Okay.
Rosie
Okay buddy, we'll be right back.
Narrator/Announcer
The Wirecutter show is supported by Audible. This holiday treats someone to the gift of Audible. Pick a bestseller or a new release audiobook. You know they'll love or gift a membership and they can pick exactly what they want with monthly credits. If they're already an Audible member, they'll get even more audiobooks and absolutely love you for it. Or if you'd like to treat yourself to Audible, now's a great time. Audible is only 99 cents a month for the first three months. Offer available until December 16th. Head to audible.com wirecutter hey, it's John.
John
Chase and Mari Uehara from Wirecutter, the product recommendation service from the New York Times. Mari, it is gift giving time and.
Mari
We have so Many great lists this year.
John
What's an easy gift for someone, like.
Mari
Under 50 bucks in our gifts under 50 list? I really love this watercolor set from Japan. The these beautiful, beautiful colors. It's something that kids can do, adults can do.
Rosie
I love that.
John
What's, like, something fun that my dad is going to enjoy.
Mari
We have these custom Funko Pops on our Gifts for dads list. You can custom make a little bobblehead toy in the likeness of your dad. They're totally unserious. They're just silly and fun, and people really love them.
John
This is so hysterical. I had never seen these before. They're amazing.
Mari
I have to admit, I sort of want one myself.
John
Check out all of wirecutter gift recommendations for yourself and everyone else@nytimes.com holidayguide Wait.
Mari
We still have to talk about the butter warmer.
Rosie
Welcome back. You're about to meet my new friend Dior, who, it turns out, wants just about everything she can name off the top of her head for the holidays this year. Let's see if we can narrow down her list a little bit. Check it out.
Dior
My name is Dior and I am 8 years old.
Rosie
So we are going to talk about the holidays. Will you tell me what holidays you celebrate?
Dior
I celebrate Thanksgiving, Christmas, Valentine's Day.
Rosie
For Christmas. Let's just take Christmas as an example. What do you do to celebrate?
Dior
So usually we'll have a Christmas party on Christmas Eve, and my family will come and.
Rosie
Yeah, who's in your family?
Dior
My mom, my dad, my grandma, my grandpa, my cousins, my aunties, and my uncle.
Rosie
Do you have a list? Yeah. What's on the list?
Dior
So my first thing is a nail kit. Cause I really want to be a nail tech when I grow up.
Rosie
What? Have you started doing your own nails?
Dior
Yeah.
Rosie
How did you learn?
Dior
I usually would just do some on my mom or, like, do some on my dolls, like starting to paint nails. But now I really want to start doing acrylic nails.
Rosie
That's so cool. So this nail kit that's on your list, what is it?
Dior
Like, so there's like, a fake can where you can, like, either paint it or do acrylics on it and stuff like that.
Rosie
I got you. I got you.
Narrator/Announcer
Okay, that sounds amazing.
Rosie
What else is on your list?
Dior
I really want more Nike shoes. Um, I want more dog toys for my dog.
Rosie
Do you have a dog?
Dior
A puppy. She's turning one.
Rosie
Oh, my goodness.
Dior
Her name's Chanel.
Noah
Mm.
Rosie
Chanel and Dior. Okay, so what are you trying to get for Chanel?
Dior
Probably, like More chew toys and stuff? Cause she likes chewing on stuff a lot.
Rosie
That's kind of nice. That's not even a present for you. It's a present for your dog.
Chloe
Uh huh.
Rosie
Okay, so that may be even something that you would give.
Dior
Mm.
Rosie
All right, what else?
Dior
I have a reborn baby doll on my list.
Rosie
What is a reborn baby doll?
Dior
It's like a baby, but it's realistic to a real baby.
Rosie
Is it creepy?
Dior
A little. Some are.
Rosie
What's the one that you want?
Dior
It has dark hair. I don't know how to describe it.
Rosie
Is it literally a baby that you hold in your arms and you can dress it and stuff?
Dior
Yeah.
Rosie
Does it cry?
Dior
No. Oh, that's.
Rosie
So I'll show you some things that are in our guide and you tell me like, if you would be excited about them or if you think maybe even your friends would be excited for them. This is a drawing tablet.
Narrator/Announcer
Do you like to draw?
Dior
Yeah, I love to draw.
Rosie
Yeah. So what do you usually like to draw with?
Dior
Probably like some scratching pads or like whiteboards.
Rosie
I don't really use paper, so I feel like a tablet could be kind of fun. All right, so yes to the tablet we're cooking. Let's see what else we have on this list. Oh, you might be into this. You got some white classic white slip on vans. Yeah. You have outfits that would go with these?
Dior
Yeah.
Rosie
Do you like ice cream?
Dior
Yeah.
Rosie
Would you make ice cream?
Dior
Yeah.
Rosie
In an ice cream maker. If you open this and it was like you got an ice cream maker, like, how long would it be until you ran to the kitchen and made ice cream?
Dior
Um, probably five minutes.
Rosie
Yeah, that seems reasonable. Have you ever seen one of these?
Dior
Yeah, at my school.
Rosie
A lava lamp.
Dior
Uh huh.
Narrator/Announcer
What would you want one though?
Chloe
Yeah.
Rosie
You'd be excited about that.
Noah
Uh huh.
Rosie
Well, so we know that you like ice cream. Do you like cookies?
Dior
I love cookies.
Rosie
So this is like a cookie subscription, Like a box of cookies. Just like, you open it up.
Dior
Yay.
Rosie
So the people at home can't see your face. But I think you just got like really excited hearing about the cookies.
Noah
Uh huh.
Rosie
Yeah. Okay, cool. So that'd be a good gift. Do you like stuffies?
Dior
I love stuffies.
Rosie
I love Stuffies. Nobody loves stuffies more than I love Stuffies, but maybe you're second. This stuffy is a capybara. It's really cute. What's your favorite animal?
Dior
A dog.
Rosie
Chanel.
Dior
Yeah.
Rosie
Specifically. Yeah, Love it. So what, oh my gosh. What if you got a stuffy that looked like Chanel I would die for it. Okay, fair enough. Me too. Oh, I have one more question. What do you like to give for gifts? What are you gonna give your parents?
Dior
Probably for my mom, I would give her like slippers, pajamas, cause she loves PJs.
Rosie
Nice.
Dior
And then for my dad, probably like a journal book and some new clothes because he's trying to start a business and he can write down all his plans.
Rosie
I love that. That is so thoughtful.
Dior
If it was for my cousin, it would probably be like those hair mannequin things because she loves doing doll's hair. And probably a makeup kit because she loves using makeup.
Rosie
How old is your cousin?
Dior
10.
Rosie
So is this what you're gonna be doing next year if you come back and we talk about gifts?
Dior
Yeah.
Rosie
Happy holidays, Theora. I hope you have such a good time with your friends and family.
Dior
You do?
Rosie
I think it's going to be hard to go wrong with gifts for Dior this year. But specifically gifts that are nail adjacent. Gifts about dogs, cookies, all winners. Good stuff, Dior. Okay, next up, we're growing up. My new pal Robinson has some ideas about what might be on a preteen boy's radar. And he's definitely got thoughts about what is not. Let's hear it.
Noah
I'm Robinson, technically 11. I turned 11 five days ago.
Rosie
Tell me about your family. Who is in your family and what holidays do you have?
Noah
Brother, he's 14. My mom, my dad. We do Christmas, Hanukkah.
Rosie
So what's your feeling about gifting? Do you like receiving gifts or giving gifts or equal measurements, equal measure?
Noah
Because there's a satisfaction of knowing you gave the best gift. And there's also the satisfaction of getting a good gift.
Rosie
I could not agree more. How do you figure out what you're gonna gift to your parent, for instance?
Noah
That's honestly kind of hard because the way I would give to like my mom or my dad is, for instance, if I'm giving a gift to my dad, my mom will tell me what my dad wants.
Rosie
Got it.
Noah
That's how it works. Because I mean, I don't have as much of a understanding in that way.
Rosie
Got it. Is that the same with your brother too?
Noah
No, I know my brother better.
Rosie
Really? Okay, so tell me, what are 14 year olds into?
Noah
Honestly, we are into very similar things.
Rosie
Okay, hit me.
Noah
Pokemon, video games, Legos. We both like Legos a lot. Dnd which is a Dungeons and Dragons. It's like, yeah, they have a lot of different things you can buy and waste your money on.
Rosie
Pokemon cards, taking me through your list. Let's keep on Christmas for a minute.
Noah
Generally, my birthday just happened. And some. Honestly, making lists is kind of hard because I have to find out what I actually want.
Rosie
But how do you find out what you want?
Noah
Well, for instance, Pokemon. I just, like, keep on track with, like, the news of the what's happening. Legos. I get a Lego magazine every month.
Rosie
Nice.
Noah
And for books, I just. Honestly, normally I just see a book that I think might be good. Ask for it.
Rosie
What kind of books do you like to read?
Noah
Honestly, I read a lot of manga. Shonen Manga as a category.
Rosie
Nice.
Noah
Yeah.
Rosie
So you're just in bookstores and you're sort of subtly pointing things out, like, hey, no, no. Like that my birthday.
Noah
No, Like, I put them on the list. Books aren't as major presents, so you can expect to get more.
Rosie
Got you. I got you.
Noah
The best good way to get, like, certain presents is you point out an expensive present, then point out less expensive presents after. But there's also this thing that is this much. They're more likely to go for that.
Remy
Yay.
Rosie
You are giving away all your secrets.
Noah
Well, my mom's not gonna hear this, right? Right?
Rosie
I didn'. So I want to show you this. So we have guides, the guide of.
Noah
Things for me to critique and do.
Rosie
So be gentle. So look through and just tell me, what do you think about what's here?
Noah
Bear, bee, nappling. A fuzzy big blanket, I guess.
Rosie
Yeah. So you're playing your video games and you're on the couch or whatever. Are you snuggling with this blanket or not? Not really.
Noah
Seven pounds.
Rosie
What are you a weighted blanket person or.
Dior
No, I. Not really.
Noah
Not.
Rosie
Okay.
Noah
But I do like them. But $140 for a blanket?
Rosie
A weighted blanket.
Noah
That's crazy, though. That's absurd. I was like, this is somewhat good idea, but $140 is too much.
Rosie
I got you, brother.
Noah
What is it, a sewing machine?
Rosie
It's a sewing machine.
Noah
I've never done sewing ever.
Rosie
Okay, so pass now or something. Now or something. What are you looking at?
Noah
Lego chess set. Chess is a great game. Legos are great.
Mari
Yes.
Noah
$75. What a great deal.
Rosie
Okay. That's a yes.
Noah
100%. Anybody could build this. Anybody could play it. Acrylic paint set.
Rosie
Do you paint?
Noah
No, I do not. I don't know what acrylic does. I've never done, like, been into, like, a lot of art and stuff. It's $19, so it's good.
Rosie
Okay. The vibe I'm getting from you Is that the value is important. So the thing has to be. Okay.
Chloe
Planet.
Noah
It's a board game. Have I played this? Players take turns adding magnetic tiles terrains to their planet. Based on the terrain, they also complete animal cards. Alright, that. Actually, yes. I kind of like that. Honestly.
Rosie
You'd be into that?
Noah
I would play that. I bet after I understand it, I'd play it.
Rosie
Right. And now we're gonna end on Lego again.
Noah
That is fine.
Rosie
So what's the vibe here? What are we looking at?
Noah
Okay, so LEGO creator Bird. Three in one birdhouse. All right, so you can transform into a beehive and a park bench for a squirrel and hedgehog. Now this actually looks really nice and fun to build because. Yeah, it's three in one, which I honestly like those.
Rosie
Awesome.
Dior
Yes.
Noah
I would take this.
Rosie
Cool.
Dior
Good.
Rosie
Thanks, Robinson.
Noah
All right.
Rosie
Okay, so for precocious boys in the preteen range, what I'm hearing is Legos and maybe anime and definitely video games. Most important, you've got to be thinking about value, people. Next up, we've got a first grader who already has a lot of things on Wirecutter's list. So let's see if we can find something new she'd be interested in.
Chloe
My name is Chloe and I'm six and three quarters.
Rosie
So tell me, Chloe, what holidays you celebrate?
Chloe
I celebrate Christmas and New Year's.
Rosie
What is Christmas like at your house?
Chloe
I don't do it at my house. I go to my grandma and grandpa's house. They have a lot more space and we don't have a Christmas tree.
Rosie
Do you give presents or do you get presents?
Chloe
Then I open presents.
Rosie
And who gives you presents? Usually?
Chloe
Usually my mom or my grandpa and grandma.
Rosie
Your mom and your grandpa and grandma. Okay.
Dior
And my dad.
Rosie
Let's not forget your dad. So have you thought about what you might want for Christmas this year? What's on the list?
Chloe
I have a lot of things.
Rosie
All right, hit me. I'm ready.
Chloe
First thing is like I have one of these at my grandma and grandpa's house, but it moves too fast, so I got a slower one. And it's like this remote control snake. And it's like I can move it wherever I want.
Rosie
A remote control snake. So it's on the ground and it slithers around your house? Yeah, that sounds creepy. What else is on the list?
Chloe
A sleeping bag. I already have one, but it's like the pillow is like. It pops up, so I want a different one.
Rosie
And what color. What color are you asking for? What's your Favorite color.
Chloe
It's a unicorn one.
Rosie
It's gotta be a unicorn one.
Narrator/Announcer
I love a unicorn.
Rosie
Okay, so we got sleeping bag, we've got remote control snake. What else would make you just so excited?
Chloe
A Barbie doll house. I already have Barbie doll playing, but now I want to get a Barbie doll house.
Rosie
How many Barbies do you have?
Chloe
A thousand.
Rosie
A thousand Barbies. Okay, so would you be happy or not happy if you also got another Barbie?
Chloe
Not happy.
Rosie
Really?
Chloe
I don't have a thousand, but it's like I'm saying a thousand because there's a lot.
Rosie
There's a lot. Okay, I got you. What else?
Chloe
A panda that has like this little baby bottle and also it comes with a toilet.
Rosie
That sounds really silly and very fun.
Chloe
It also has a diaper.
Rosie
So what are you going to change this panda's diaper? Oh, brother. Okay, so can I show you some of these gifts and I want to see what you think we can just look at these and I want to see like if you think that you would want something like this or your friends who are also sick. This is an inner tube. Like this is a snow tube. Do you go snow tubing in the winter at all?
Chloe
I only sled down.
Dior
Sled.
Rosie
Only sled. So would you be excited if you got a sled?
Chloe
I already have one.
Rosie
Well, there we go. Moving on. What is this? I don't.
Chloe
That's a bicycle with three wheels. But I already know how to ride a two wheel bicycle, so.
Dior
No.
Rosie
So what I'm hearing is you got to make sure if you're going to give a six year old a bike, you got to make sure that they don't have a bike and that they don't already know how to ride one. Because you already know.
Chloe
Yeah, that's too easy.
Rosie
It's too easy. Got it. Magna tiles, Are you into them?
Chloe
I already have some.
Narrator/Announcer
How do you feel about building stuff?
Rosie
Do you like to build stuff?
Dior
Yeah.
Rosie
So things like this or Legos.
Chloe
I build a. I sort Legos a lot more when I build them. So if I had to pick between this and Legos, I would choose Legos because I sort them more and play with them more.
Rosie
I got you. How about painting? Do you like to paint?
Dior
Yeah.
Rosie
So if you got a paint scent that would be cool.
Chloe
There's too many paints, but if there was like an outline or something, I would paint inside. Yeah.
Rosie
I love. Sounds like new markers and craft supplies could be a hit with six year old Chloe. And if you're relying on our guides for gifts, this year. Check in with the parents in your life just to make sure you're not double dipping. Super special thank you to the kids and the families who participated in this episode. We hope you hear about something new that gets your wheels turning. For the little ones on your list, we'll drop links to these kid approved items in our show notes and we'll also link to the age based wirecutter gift guides we talked about today. And if you haven't caught them yet, go check out the first two episodes of our gifting series, about our staff's favorite items of 2025 and about giving to the hard to shop for adults in your life. Next week we're dropping the final bonus episode in our series on gifting and it's for you last minute shoppers out there. Ideas and suggestions for great gifts on let's call it a quick turnaround. Thank you so much for listening.
Chloe
And also I play hockey and I do ballet and gymnastics.
Rosie
So how do you find the time? And you go to school? Yeah, I don't know when you're going to have time to change this panda's diaper.
Narrator/Announcer
The Wirecutter show is supported by Audible. This holiday treat someone to the gift of Audible. Pick a bestseller or a new release audiobook. You know they'll love or gift a membership and they can pick exactly what they want with monthly credits. If they're already an Audible member, they'll get even more audiobooks and absolutely love you for it. Or if you'd like to treat yourself to Audible, now's a great time. Audible is only 99 cents a month for the first three months. Offer available until December 16th. Head to audible.com wirecr.
Episode: Gift Guide 2025: Kids Tell Us What They Want
Hosts: Rosie Guerin (producer), with contributions from co-hosts Christine Cyr Clisset and Caira Blackwell
Date: December 12, 2025
This episode ventures straight to the most discerning gift recipients of the holiday season: kids! Rosie Guerin sits down with children of various ages—Dior (8), Robinson (11), and Chloe (6¾)—to ask them what’s on their wishlist and get their honest, often surprising, reactions to Wirecutter’s 2025 kids gift guide recommendations. With funny detours and razor-sharp opinions, these “real experts” reflect on what truly makes an excellent gift for kids today.
The episode is playful, candid, and rooted in the lived reality of kids—full of endearing tangents, unfiltered opinions, and moments of thoughtful kindness. Rosie’s role is that of an enthusiastic facilitator, balancing curiosity with gentle humor and empathy.
If you’re shopping for kids in 2025, this episode is full of actionable, sanity-saving wisdom. Kids know what excites them—and what doesn’t. LISTEN to them (and their parents), and you’re on your way to a winning, delightful holiday. Check the show notes for links to all the Wirecutter’s kid-approved picks and guides for every age and interest.