Real Dads on the Best Father’s Day Gifts They’ve Ever Received

Summary

---

The Wirecutter Show

Episode: Real Dads on the Best Father’s Day Gifts They’ve Ever Received
Release Date: June 12, 2026
Host: Christine Cyr Clisset

---

Episode Overview

This episode of The Wirecutter Show is an affectionate deep-dive into real-life Father’s Day gift memories, told by dads (and a few loving children) from the Wirecutter staff. Balancing humor, nostalgia, and practical advice, the episode explores what gifts have truly made a difference—ranging from quirky personalized socks to the power of a heartfelt letter—and offers inspiration for listeners hoping to make this Father’s Day special.

---

Key Discussion Points & Highlights

Intro & Episode Context

• Christine Cyr Clisset opens the show (00:31), noting past Mother’s Day episodes and framing this as an opportunity to spotlight dads on staff.
• She encourages listeners to check Wirecutter’s curated gift guides for more ideas.

---

Heartfelt & Memorable Father’s Day Gifts

Fire Pit Memories & Marshmallows

• Grant Clauser (Audio, Video, and Smart Home Team) shares how a Landmann backyard fire pit became the centerpiece of many cherished evenings:

  “We spent a lot of wonderful evenings sitting around the fire, maybe roasting some marshmallows or just telling stories." (01:56)

  • Despite initial longevity (“even then it was at least seven years old”), the fire pit finally rusted out—prompting a hopeful hint for a ‘smokeless’ upgrade from his now older kids.

Punk Rock Personalized Socks

• Ben Fruman (Editor in Chief) recounts the surprisingly emotional joy of receiving DivvyUp custom socks adorned with his kids' (and cat’s) faces:

  “These socks give me that sense of punk rock, geeky, cool personality even when I have to wear like work clothes... what I love most... I sort of feel like I got my kids with me throughout the day.” (03:43)

  • The socks are a Wirecutter-recommended pick in their personalized gifts guide. He admits it’s “kind of goofy, kind of fun,” and very meaningful.

Tie Dye & Preschool Art

• Dave (YouTube Team) shares a classic “parents of young kids” moment: wearing a tie-dye t-shirt made by his preschooler:

  “He gets really amped whenever I do." (04:47)

  • A reminder that gifts can be deeply personal and tap into cultural trends at the right moment.

Letters as Living Legacy

• Harry Sawyers (Senior Editor, Home Improvement & Kids) flips the script, explaining he gives rather than receives on Father’s Day—by writing his kids a one-page letter every year since 2013:

  “I tell them what it's like to be their dad, how they are as kids, what being their parent has meant to me...” (05:03)

  • He started the tradition out of a wish for such keepsakes from his own father, hoping his kids will cherish these words in the future.

---

Gift-Giver Perspectives & Surprising Practical Picks

Changing a Life with a Cookbook

• Samantha Shea (Gifts Team) tells how a simple Indian cookbook gave her dad newfound confidence in the kitchen:

  “He learned to cook…and it gave him a lot of confidence. He’s still a terrible cook if he just goes at it alone—but if he has a recipe to follow, he can actually make a lot of delicious food.” (08:32)

Little Luxuries: Hot Sauces & Baseball Pants

• Liam McCabe (Home Improvement Writer) values sentimental gifts from his daughter but fondly remembers two that added daily delight:
  • Variety pack of hot sauces:

    “It was fun to experiment and try different things out, and found a few that I've worked into my regular rotation.” (09:38)

  • Fitted baseball pants for rec league:

    “A couple teammates said, ‘did you lose weight?’...I guess they made a good impression.” (10:29)

Handmade with Heart (and Humor)

• John Chase (Smart Home Editor) highlights his kids’ creative efforts:
  • Rainbow trout leather belt (from his daughter—he’s a fly fisherman)
  • Handmade mug (“number four best dad”)

    “Thanks, buddy.” (11:28)

  • These reflect the offbeat, loving honesty of family-made gifts.

---

Music, Loss & Asking for What You Want

Wearable Guitar Jokes

• Tom Dunn (Senior Staff Writer, Home Improvements) brings musician dad humor to the mix:
  • T-shirt printed with D, A, and D guitar chord charts

    “I get a lot of mileage out of that graphic, too, in a lot of situations.” (12:01)

Lessons from a Father’s Specificity

• Hannah Morrell (Editor, Gifts Team) shares a heartfelt reflection after her father’s passing:

  “Father’s Day was one of his favorite holidays. He’d send us long lists of what he wanted...At the time we rolled our eyes…but now I really value that.” (12:28)

  • From DVD players to a pontoon boat, her dad “asked for what he wanted.” She sees in that a lesson about not letting life just happen to you.

---

Timestamps for Key Moments

• 00:31 — Christine introduces episode & site gift guide
• 01:41 — Grant on the fire pit family tradition
• 02:42 — Ben on personalized socks with his children's faces
• 04:20 — Dave and the tie-dye shirt from preschool
• 04:55 — Harry’s tradition: annual letters to his kids
• 08:10 — Samantha on the transformative cookbook
• 09:10 — Liam on hot sauces and rec league baseball pants
• 11:02 — John on rainbow trout belt and “number four best dad” mug
• 11:42 — Tom on the guitar chords T-shirt
• 12:17 — Hannah’s reflections on her late father’s gift requests

---

Notable Quotes

• Grant Clauser: “I actually wrote about it in 2020 and even then it was at least seven years old. We spent a lot of wonderful evenings sitting around the fire...” (01:50)
• Ben Fruman: “These socks are great. They're kind of goofy, they're fun...I think what I love most about them is I sort of feel like I got my kids with me throughout the day.” (03:35)
• Harry Sawyers: “I write them all a letter, one page, every Father's Day going back to 2013...meant to show appreciation and gratitude for the gift of fatherhood they've given me.” (05:00)
• Samantha Shea: “He was probably in his 50s when I gave him this cookbook. And it totally changed his cooking life.” (08:29)
• Hannah Morrell: “He asked for what he wanted...you don’t have that kind of trajectory by letting life happen to you...” (12:41)

---

Tone & Takeaways

The episode is warm, conversational, and sprinkled with both humor and emotion. Gifts that genuinely resonate with dads—whether sentimental, practical, or outright silly—are at the heart of these stories. The underlying message: the best gifts reflect the recipient’s unique personality and create lasting memories. And sometimes, the most meaningful ones aren’t things at all, but words, actions, or ongoing traditions.

---

Further Gift Inspiration

• For detailed guides on thoughtful gifts, visit Wirecutter’s Gifts Section
• Seek out personalized, handmade, or experience-based presents—they often carry the deepest meaning.

---

Happy Father’s Day from The Wirecutter Show!

Transcript

[A]

My name is Shannon Maldonado. I'm the founder of Yaoi, a gift shop. From the lens of artists and handmade objects, I chose Shopify because when I was testing other platforms it was definitely one of the most user friendly. It was important to me to think about where we would be in the future. All of the tools for reading your sales, like planning inventory, they're just right there on your dashboard. For anyone starting a small business, the biggest thing I can tell you is it doesn't have to be perfect. Shopify can help you build upon it. Start your free trial on shopify.com

[B]

I'm Christine Cyrcassette and you're listening to the Wirecutter Show. Hey there, it's Christine and Father's Day is right around the corner on June 21st. We've done a few episodes about Mother's Day on the show and this year we wanted to even things out and talk about dads too. We actually have quite a few dads on the Wirecutter staff, so we wanted to let them take the spotlight. For this episode, we asked a bunch of our colleagues with kids what the best gift they've received for Father's Day was. I hope the reflections give you some ideas of great ways to celebrate the father or father figure in your life. This year we also have tons of great Father's Day ideas on our site. Our Gifts team spends a ton of time curating great gifts and you can find [e-mail] gifts okay, let's let the dads take it away.

[C]

Hi, I'm Grant Clauser and I'm on the Audio, Video and Smart Home Team and I think the best Father's Day gift I ever received from my kids, although technically I know it was from my wife, was a backyard fire pit. Landman backyard fire pit to be exact. I actually wrote about it in 2020 and even then it was at least seven years old. We spent a lot of wonderful evenings sitting around the fire, maybe roasting some marshmallows or just telling stories. Unfortunately, last year after sitting out in the backyard through all weather, I even left it out in the winter because I'm irresponsible. The bottom finally rusted out. My kids are a lot older now, so maybe they can afford to get me one of those nice smokeless ones this year.

[D]

Hey there.

[E]

This is Ben Fruman, Wirecutters Editor in Chief, and I am here to tell you about one of the all time greatest Father's Day gifts that I have received. Their socks. Now, they're not Just any socks. I know socks sounds boring, generic kind of gift you could give any dad. But these socks are special. These socks have my children's faces on them. These are personalized socks. They are a Wirecutter recommended gift pick in our guide to the best personalized gifts by Samantha Shea and Mari Uehara. They are divvy up custom socks and these socks are great. I have two pairs with both of my kids faces on them. I have another pair with our beloved cat Rocky's face on them. These socks give me that sense of punk rock, geeky, cool personality even when I have to wear like work clothes. They're kind of goofy, they're fun. And I know this is going to sound very, very sappy, but I think what I love most about them is I sort of feel like I got my kids with me throughout the day. I'll be sitting in a meeting, obviously not a boring meeting. We never have any of those. I'll be sitting in a super interesting meeting and I'll look down at my feet and I'll see my boy's smiling face looking up at me or my beautiful daughter smiling up at me.

[D]

And it makes me happy.

[F]

Hi, this is Dave from the YouTube team here at Wirecutter. The best Father's Day gift I ever got is a little bit limited because my son is only five years old. But when he was in preschool, him and his class tie dyed a bunch of shirts for all the dads and it happened to be the summer that tie dye really came back into vogue. So now I get to wear it and look good and he gets really amped whenever I do.

[G]

Hi, this is Harry Sawyers. I'm a senior editor at Wirecutter. My team covers home improving, emergency prep pets, and once upon a time I helped launch our kids coverage when my own kids were much younger. So for Father's Day, I am not a great gift giver myself. Which probably explains why I don't get many gifts for Father's Day, although I do complain about it. Instead, I have a tradition. I write them all a letter, one page, every Father's Day going back to 2013. I tell them what it's like to be their dad, how they are as kids, what being their parent has meant to me, or what it means at this point at least. And it's meant to show appreciation and gratitude for the gift of fatherhood they've given me. Although it probably veers into complaints itself. I started because it occurred to me when I was a new parent that I really would have appreciated something like that from my own dad and he didn't write that stuff down and he didn't really remember what it was like to be a parent of a young child either. So I didn't have that and so I started just writing my own in case they ever felt the same way.

[B]

We're going to take a quick break and when we come back we'll hear about a great gift for a music loving dad and one for a sporty dad. We'll be right back.

[H]

This message is brought to you by Apple Card. For a limited time, when you get a new Apple card and purchase AirPods Pro 3 at Apple, you can earn back the cost up to 250 daily cash. New AirPods Pro and up to $250 daily cash back. Now that's music to my ears. Subject to credit approval, limitations and spend requirements apply. Apple Card is issued by Goldman Sachs Bank USA, Salt Lake City branch terms and more at Apple Co AirPods.

[E]

You're always evolving, so sell some things that belong to your former self on ebay. Maybe you had a trinket obsessed phase, a leather jacket moment or a year you thought you'd learned to cook. Let some of those versions go. Selling on ebay is easy. Just photograph and list with millions of buyers. The right things, find the right people. Suddenly you've got more space, some extra cash and someone out there is thrilled to find what you're selling. Find what you love, sell what you don't on ebay.

[D]

This is a vacation with Chase Sapphire Reserve. The butler, the spa. This is the Edit a collection of handpicked luxury hotels and a $500 edit credit chase Sapphire Reserve now even more rewarding. Learn [e-mail] Sapphire Reserve cards issued by JP Morgan, Chase bank and a member FDIC subject to credit approval.

[B]

We're back and we're getting ready for Father's Day by hearing from a bunch of dads on staff at Wirecutter about the best gifts they've received over the years. We'll let some of our gift experts, Samantha Shea and Hannah Morrill, also chime in because you know they've got excellent gift advice. Let's hear

[I]

hi, this is Samantha Shea. I'm a staff writer on the gifts team at Wirecutter. And the best gift I ever gave my dad was a really simple Indian cookbook. When I was growing up, he did not cook at all. The only thing I ever remember him cooking were cheesy hot dogs. So he was probably in his 50s when I gave him this cookbook. And it Totally changed his cooking life. And he learned to cook, and he learned to follow recipes, and he would cook entire Indian meals, and it gave him a lot of confidence. And he's still a terrible cook if he just goes at it alone. But if he has a recipe to follow, he can actually make a lot of delicious food. So that was probably the best Father's Day gift I ever gave him.

[J]

Hey, this is Liam McCabe. I'm a home improvement writer at Wirecutter. This will be my ninth Father's Day as a dad. I really do appreciate the handmade cards and frame photos and. And those kinds of sentimental gifts. Keep them on my desk. I look at them all the time. Those are great. The ones that surprise and delight me the most. The kinds of don't really expect to get but end up really enjoying are usually nicer or just slightly different versions of things that I use all the time Anyway, so one year, my wife and daughter got me a variety pack of hot sauces, which was great. I have my one hot sauce that I put on most things, and I know where to get it for a good price, and I sort of stick with that. They got me this variety pack with 10 or 12 different bottles, and it was fun to experiment and try different things out and found a few that I've sort of worked into my regular rotation, which has been great. Wouldn't have happened without that gift. And the other one I comes to the top of my mind is a pair of baseball pants. I play rec league softball. Not a very high level of competition, but still fun and, you know, you want to be comfortable. I usually wear shorts or track pants, that kind of thing. But they surprised me with a pair of actual fitted baseball pants. They were a lot more comfortable than I was expecting them to be. They protect my legs a little better on the rare occasion when I end up on the ground. And a couple of my teammates looked at me when I first wore them and said, did you lose weight? And I'm like, no, definitely not. Couple people thought I was running faster, too, which was definitely not true either. But I guess they made a good impression, and I'm really glad that they gave them to me.

[K]

Hi, this is John Chase, and I am the smart home editor at Wirecutter. I have two kids, and they always give me wonderful Father's Day gifts, of course, and they're almost always handmade. And a couple that stand out that I really love. My daughter made a leather belt that is colored like a rainbow trout. I fly fish, and so it's Just this gorgeous, lovely, completely unique item. And my son gave me one of my most treasured gifts. It's a handmade mug, and on the side it says, number four, best dad. Thanks, buddy.

[L]

Foreign.

[M]

My name is Tom Dunn and I'm a senior staff writer on the home Improvements team. The best Father's Day gift I ever received when I'm not testing the air conditioners. I'm also a musician, so my wife and kids like to get me some fun guitar swag sometimes. And I think my favorite of all was one year they got me a graphic T shirt with the fingering charts for a D, A and D chord. Get it? I get a lot of. Lot of mileage out of that graphic, too, in a lot of situations. So that's always fun.

[L]

Hello, I'm Hannah Morrell and I'm an editor on the Gifts team. My dad died this past year, but Father's Day was one of his favorite holidays. He always would send my brother and sister and I long ahead of Father's Day lists of what he was expecting from each of us this year. And at the time, we always sort of like, rolled our eyes about it. We're like, okay, dad. And now it sort of has become like something I really value about him. And of course, I see it differently now. This was a man who asked for what he wanted, and there was a tongue in cheek aspect to it, but it was. He had had a sort of like a tough upbringing. He was not raised by his parents. He was sort of orphaned and became a college professor. And you don't have that kind of trajectory by sort of letting life happen to you and by not asking for what you want. So things my dad has asked for over the years are like DVD players and a pontoon boat one year language courses, a new watch. I mean, whatever was sort of like going on his life, we would ask us for that. And so, yeah, I think this Father's Day, I feel really reflective on the gifts my dad has asked for in the past and the enduring lessons in his asks.

[B]

As always, you can find great ideas for gifts for Father's Day on the Wirecutter site. And we'll drop some links in our show notes, too. Happy Father's Day. See you next time. The Wirecutter show is executive produced by Rosie Guerin and produced by Abigail Kiel. Engineering support from Maddy Mazziello and Nick Pittman. Today's episode was mixed by Katherine Anderson. Original music by Dan Powell, Marion Lozano, Rowan Nimusto, Catherine Anderson and Diane Wong. Cliff Levy is wirecutter's deputy publisher and general manager. Ben Fruman is Wirecutter's editor in chief. I'm Christine Cyrclassette. Thanks for listening.