The Wirecutter Show - Episode Summary: "Valentine's For All"

Release Date: February 10, 2025
Hosts: Christine Cyr Clisset, Caira Blackwell
Producer: Rosie Guerin
Guest: Samantha Shea, Gift Writer at Wirecutter

Introduction: Embracing Valentine's Day Beyond Tradition

In the "Valentine's For All" episode, The Wirecutter Show delves into the multifaceted nature of Valentine's Day, exploring gift ideas that cater to a diverse range of relationships and personal preferences. Host Rosie Guerin sets the stage by emphasizing that Valentine's Day isn't limited to traditional gifts for significant others but extends to Galentine's, self-gifting, and unconventional presents that break the mold.

Balancing Consumerism and Genuine Sentiment

Samantha Shea opens the discussion by acknowledging the duality of Valentine's Day as both a consumer-driven holiday and a meaningful occasion to express love and appreciation.

"I fully realize that it is a consumerist holiday and that it was, you know, made up kind of to get us to buy things. That said, I also kind of really like it." (02:58)

She advocates for a "no junk" approach to gift-giving, steering clear of clichéd last-minute purchases like teddy bears holding hearts. Instead, she emphasizes meaningful acknowledgments over extravagant gestures.

Thoughtful Gift Ideas for Every Valentine

Traditional Yet Low-Key Gifts

Samantha prefers simple, traditional gifts that hold sentimental value without being over the top. She shares her family's approach to Valentine's Day, which includes:

• Handmade Cards:
  "I will make handmade gift cards, Cards I might give my kids, like candy or, you know, lip gloss or if I'm really feeling generous, like a jelly cat stuffy." (03:34)

• Heart-Shaped Treats:
  "One year we made heart shaped hamburgers. Like that was the big celebration." (04:09)

• Fresh Flowers:
  "I always get flowers delivered because I love fresh flowers and my husband is well trained in that regard." (04:27)

Gifts for Self-Care and Personal Indulgence

For those who choose to celebrate themselves, Samantha recommends affordable luxuries that add a touch of joy to everyday life:

• Sparkly Socks:
  "They're super warm and cozy but they're also super fun and they're really affordable. I think they're like 15 bucks." (05:15)

• Silk Hair Accessories from LilySilk:
  "If you have longish hair, this curler thing will make your hair. You'll look like a movie star when you take it out of your hair in the morning." (05:15)

• Elegant Gold Chains:
  "It's just a very simple, very classic herringbone gold chain... it looks like the real thing and it's will last forever." (06:17)

• Artisan Chocolates:
  "Our favorites are this box of rakuti chocolates. They're delicious. They're amazing." (06:17)

• Paper Flowers from Unwilted:
  "They're so beautiful and so colorful, and they look like the real thing, but of course, they last way, way longer." (08:00)

Unique and Subversive Gifts

Breaking away from conventional gifts, Samantha highlights options that are both unique and thoughtful:

• La De Rey Paris Macarons:
  "These cookies are insane. They're so beautiful... they're pastel thin shortbread cookie with a little bit of, like, jam or caramel on top." (07:56)

• Gummy Candies:
  "Personally, like, gummies would be the way straight to my heart." (07:56)

Navigating Valentine's Day in New Relationships

Valentine's Day can be particularly challenging for those in the early stages of dating. Samantha offers guidance on finding the right balance to acknowledge the day without overwhelming a new partner.

"If you're seeing someone beyond just like a hookup situation, you should acknowledge the day in some very small way and just kind of solve the whole problem." (10:29)

She shares a personal anecdote about receiving a charming yet modest Valentine's gift—snowballs and a handwritten note—that left a lasting positive impression without being excessive.

"I was just dating this guy... he gave me a package of snowballs... he gave me a little note written on binder paper. And I was totally charmed and cost him maybe $5, probably less, but it worked." (10:29)

Samantha emphasizes that small gestures, such as flowers or chocolates, are sufficient to acknowledge the day without sending mixed signals.

Crafting Meaningful DIY Cards

As an artsy individual, Samantha enjoys creating handmade cards, adding a personal touch to her Valentine's Day celebrations.

"I buy the ready made blank cards of watercolor paper and then I paint them... I've definitely simplified now, and I mostly just do watercolors." (12:56)

She reminisces about elaborate card-making parties from her childhood, highlighting the joy of creating personalized expressions of love.

Advice for Couples with Differing Views on Valentine's Day

When one partner embraces Valentine's Day and the other doesn't, Samantha advises indulging the one who does to maintain harmony in the relationship.

"Indulge them. I mean, why wouldn't you take the opportunity to make them happy, you know, with some small gesture." (12:06)

She cautions against letting differing opinions on Valentine's become a source of conflict, suggesting that small acts of kindness can bridge the gap.

Personal Valentine's Plans

Wrapping up the episode, Samantha shares her own Valentine's Day plans, which reflect her philosophy of thoughtful, simple gestures:

"My daughter's name is Magnolia, and I found a really pretty mug that says Magnolia on it. And I sent her that... I'll probably send my son candy. I'll make them both cards." (13:59)

Conclusion: Celebrating Love in All Its Forms

"Valentine's For All" encourages listeners to tailor their Valentine's Day celebrations to their unique relationships and personal preferences. Whether it's through traditional gifts, self-care indulgences, or thoughtful DIY creations, the episode underscores the importance of meaningful acknowledgment over extravagant spending.

For more detailed gift recommendations and to explore the products featured in this episode, visit The Wirecutter Show's website.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• "I fully realize that it is a consumerist holiday and that it was, you know, made up kind of to get us to buy things. That said, I also kind of really like it." — Samantha Shea (02:58)

• "I'm a big handmade card person and I always have been since I was a kid." — Samantha Shea (03:34)

• "If you have longish hair, this curler thing will make your hair. You'll look like a movie star when you take it out of your hair in the morning." — Samantha Shea (05:15)

• "If you're seeing someone beyond just like a hookup situation, you should acknowledge the day in some very small way and just kind of solve the whole problem." — Samantha Shea (10:29)

• "Indulge them. I mean, why wouldn't you take the opportunity to make them happy, you know, with some small gesture." — Samantha Shea (12:06)

• "It's just a gesture, it's an acknowledgement. It's not to my mind, a huge gift giving." — Samantha Shea (04:35)

For more insights and product recommendations, subscribe to Wirecutter's newest newsletter, The Gift, and stay tuned for upcoming episodes of The Wirecutter Show.