Transcript
Scott (0:00)
Good morning everybody. Happy Thursday, 10:15am Eastern Standard Time. Technically 10:19 right now, crypto Town hall, which is every single weekday right here on X on the Crypto Town X account. Hope that you're all having a wonderful day and surviving because that is the name of the game when we're in a drop like this. Honestly, until I started digging in this morning, I didn't realize just how meaningful this drop has been. I think you become somewhat immune and numb to bitcoin price action if you've been here for a long time. As we know, these drops are pretty par for the course even in a bitcoin bull market. But just some interesting data. Obviously we had the largest day on Tuesday ever of outflows from Bitcoin Spot ETFs, and that was following one of the largest weeks already before that. So over $2 billion in aggregate and that's not including today, which we know is likely to be a reflection of yesterday's price action. So historic outflows from the Bitcoin Spot ETFs. Also, as you can see in the title, that I didn't even realize that this is According to CoinDesk, Bitcoin registers biggest three day price slide since FTX debacle Obviously pretty shocking considering prices had already been dropping and we don't have an FTX type black swan at the moment. Tom, in the market. Really pretty historic price action here. Right now, Bitcoin trading at about $85,300. A lot of people calling for 74,000. Talking about the fact that there's basically no support on the chart from the current area all the way down to there because of how fast price rose, I think for a lot of people. Also obviously the shock is coming in the form of altcoins. For example, Solana was trading just under $300 all time high just about a month ago, five weeks ago, and you're now trading at $137, obviously way off that, roughly 300 high. And I know that most people who listen to this show probably are pretty exposed to altcoins. A lot happening. Dave, I loved that you did a market video yesterday. Love that you're doing that. We're going to do a lot more of that together. But you basically broke down the market route from yesterday. So still very relevant today. Maybe you can give us some context as to what you think is happening here.
Dave (2:26)
Yeah, I mean, look, it's hard. I'm trying, I've been trying to look at the open interest data to understand, you know, what's happening. The problem is the way they take it, they take it into account. Look, the most important factor post Arthur Hayes and I think you had a conversation with him, didn't you? You know, I think that's how I actually saw it Made his call for 70,000 bitcoin was based upon what would happen on, you know, tomorrow morning. Now for those who don't know what happens tomorrow morning. Tomorrow morning the February CME futures expire and if you had a position of long ETFs or long spot or. Yeah, long ETFs or long spot and short futures which you would have put on as part of what the so called basis trade. I mean look, I used to run an index, our book, you know, for, for years and we take these things for granted. Effectively what you're doing is the futures trade at a premium that's significantly larger than the risk free rate where you borrow capital. If you're a broker, if you're a hedge fund and what that number of capital is somewhere between 5 and 6%, maybe 7. And it is true that the average annual interest rate that you were getting paid to do this trade was double digits. So it was a profitable trade and people levered it up as well. So there was substantial amount of long spot or long ETFs short futures. Now if the theory is that you are going to sell all of that in the one hour period when the futures expiration happens in order to get flat, then it would have been a market cataclysm on Friday. Here's what happened. However, starting earlier this week the futures started trading at a discount. Like right now they're trading flat, actually slightly up. The offer is well above the bid is right around where the bid price is. So right now it's not as easy to do. But yesterday and the day before and Monday you were able to sell futures at, excuse me, buy the futures back at a discount to the spot. So the ability to sell ETFs or spot and get out of the trade early at a better price than you would at expiration presented itself and during that entire time when that was was available where you could buy futures or the offer in the futures market right now the offer in the futures market is $100 above the bid is right on the markets. It's a really widespread. But when the offer was well below you were able to take that trade off. So if you were taking that trade off, what does that mean you were doing? It means you were selling ETFs and so you had huge ETF outflows. And so as long as that offer was there in the futures market, it was going to facilitate dumping spot. And we saw a lot of that now have we seen enough of it such that tomorrow morning there will be no, no, no natural selling when these expire? Well, there are other factors to consider were to roll meaning no longer be, no longer the current, the February futures, but roll the March. Well, March is trading right now at 86, about 5 or 600 bucks. It's right around the risk free rate. It's kind of at around fair value. So if you want to postpone the pain, you could have done that on the hopes that this premium will come back. In the video I talk about why, but the reason why there was this premium is because of something that I've talked about many times on this space. All the broker dealers in the United States have not been allowed to trade spot Bitcoin. And if they're not allowed to trade spot Bitcoin and they wanna offer products to their customers, they had to use the futures or the ETFs. And so the net result is there was a lot of demand. And I said it on this space two months ago once Trump got elected that that demand's gonna disappear because they're gonna be allowed to trade spot, which is actually net long term bullish. But in the short run we're getting this kind of ota.
