Loading summary
A
Welcome to Thoughts on the Market. I'm Andrew Sheats, head of Corporate Credit Research at Morgan Stanley. Today I'm going to revisit our story for 2025 and what could make things better or worse. It's Thursday, January 9th at 2pm in London. Based on the number of out of office replies, I have a sneaking suspicion that many investors took advantage of the timing of holidays this year for a well deserved break. With this week marking the first full week back, I thought it'd be a good opportunity to refresh listeners on what we expect in 2025 and realistic scenarios where things are better or worse. Our base case is that credit holds up well this year, doing somewhat better in the first half of 2025 than the second. Credit likes moderation, and while we think the shift in U.S. policy leadership generally means less moderation and a wider range of economic outcomes, this shift doesn't arrive immediately on Morgan Stanley's forecast. The bulk of the disruptive impact from any changes to tariffs or immigration policy hits in 2026. Meanwhile, credit is entering 2025 with some pretty decent tailwinds. The economy is good. The all in yield the total yield on US investment grade corporate bonds at above 5.4% is the highest to start any year since January of 2009, which we think helps demand. And while we think corporate confidence and aggression will rise normally a bad thing for credit, this is going to be coming off of a low conservative starting point. We think that credit spreads will be modestly tighter by mid year relative to where they finished 20:24 and then start to widen modestly in the second half of the year as the market attempts to price that greater policy uncertainty in 2026. We think that issuers in the financial and utility sectors outperform and we think bonds between 5 and 10 year maturity will do the best. The bear case is that we exit the current period of moderation more quickly. At one end, a deregulatory push by a new administration could usher in an even faster rise in corporate confidence and aggression, leading to more borrowing and riskier dealmaking. At the other extreme, the strong current state of the economy and jobs market could make further gains harder to come by. If the rise in unemployment that our economists expect in 2026 is larger or arrives earlier, credit could start to weaken well ahead of this. So how could things be better, especially given the relatively low tight starting point for credit spreads? Well, we'd argue that the current mix of data for credit is borderline ideal. Reasonable growth, falling inflation, still low levels of corporate aggressiveness and still high yields that are attracting buyers. Recall that the tightest levels of credit in the modern era, which are still tighter than today, are occurred during a period with similar characteristics, the mid-1990s. When thinking about the mid-90s as a bull case, there's a further detail that's relevant and topical, especially this week. At that time, interest rates stayed somewhat high and the Fed only lowered short term rates modestly because the economy held up. In short, in the best environment that we've seen for credit, less action by the Federal Reserve was fine so long as the economic data was good. This is a bull case rather than our base case because there are also a number of key differences, with the mid-1990s, not the least being a much worse trajectory today for the US Government's budget. But in a scenario where things change less and the status quo lasts longer, it could come into play. Thanks for listening. If you enjoy the show, leave us a review wherever you listen and share thoughts on the market with a friend or colleague today.
B
The preceding content is informational only and based on information available when created. It is not an offer or solicitation, nor is it tax or legal advice. It does not consider your financial circumstances and objectives, and may not be suitable for.
Podcast Information:
In the January 10, 2025 episode of "Thoughts on the Market," Andrew Sheats, Head of Corporate Credit Research at Morgan Stanley, revisits the firm's economic outlook for 2025. Sheats aims to provide listeners with a comprehensive update on the base case scenario for the year, alongside potential factors that could lead to better or worse economic outcomes.
Notable Quote:
“[...] I thought it'd be a good opportunity to refresh listeners on what we expect in 2025 and realistic scenarios where things are better or worse.”
— Andrew Sheats [00:00]
Sheats outlines the base case, where credit performance remains robust throughout 2025, with a slight improvement in the first half compared to the second. The key factors contributing to this outlook include:
Moderate Credit Environment: Credit prefers moderation, and despite anticipated shifts in U.S. policy leadership, the disruptive impacts are expected to materialize primarily in 2026.
Favorable Yield Conditions: The total yield on U.S. investment-grade corporate bonds stands above 5.4%, the highest at the start of any year since January 2009, enhancing demand.
Corporate Behavior: While increased corporate confidence and aggression could pose risks, the current low conservative baseline for corporate actions mitigates potential negative impacts.
Notable Quotes:
“Our base case is that credit holds up well this year, doing somewhat better in the first half of 2025 than the second.”
— Andrew Sheats [00:45]
“The all in yield [...] is the highest to start any year since January of 2009, which we think helps demand.”
— Andrew Sheats [01:10]
Sheats highlights that certain sectors and bond maturities are expected to perform better:
Outperforming Sectors: Financial and utility sectors are anticipated to lead in performance.
Preferred Maturities: Bonds with maturities between 5 and 10 years are projected to yield the best returns.
Notable Quote:
“We think that issuers in the financial and utility sectors outperform and we think bonds between 5 and 10 year maturity will do the best.”
— Andrew Sheats [02:30]
While the base case remains optimistic, Sheats discusses potential bear scenarios that could challenge the economic outlook:
An unexpected deregulatory push from a new administration could rapidly boost corporate confidence and aggression, leading to:
Increased Borrowing: More aggressive borrowing practices could elevate financial risks.
Riskier Dealmaking: Enhanced corporate aggression may result in more volatile market activities.
Notable Quote:
“A deregulatory push by a new administration could usher in an even faster rise in corporate confidence and aggression, leading to more borrowing and riskier dealmaking.”
— Andrew Sheats [02:10]
Conversely, if the robust current state of the economy and the job market continues unabated:
Hindered Gains: Sustained economic strength could limit further growth opportunities.
Unemployment Fluctuations: A larger or earlier-than-expected rise in unemployment in 2026 could weaken credit conditions ahead of schedule.
Notable Quote:
“If the rise in unemployment that our economists expect in 2026 is larger or arrives earlier, credit could start to weaken well ahead of this.”
— Andrew Sheats [02:50]
Exploring the potential for better-than-expected outcomes, Sheats draws parallels to the mid-1990s, presenting a scenario where credit conditions could flourish:
The combination of reasonable growth, decreasing inflation, low corporate aggressiveness, and high yields creates a near-ideal environment for credit:
Notable Quote:
“We’d argue that the current mix of data for credit is borderline ideal. Reasonable growth, falling inflation, still low levels of corporate aggressiveness and still high yields that are attracting buyers.”
— Andrew Sheats [03:00]
In the optimal scenario, the Federal Reserve's minimal intervention aligns with strong economic data:
Notable Quote:
“Less action by the Federal Reserve was fine so long as the economic data was good.”
— Andrew Sheats [03:20]
Caveat: Sheats notes that while this bull case is optimistic, it diverges from the base case due to differences like the current U.S. Government's budget path.
Andrew Sheats concludes by emphasizing the balanced nature of the current economic indicators, positioning 2025 as a year of cautious optimism within Morgan Stanley's forecasts. He encourages listeners to stay informed and consider various scenarios as the economic landscape unfolds.
Notable Quote:
“When thinking about the mid-90s as a bull case, there's a further detail that's relevant and topical, especially this week.”
— Andrew Sheats [03:25]
This episode serves as a strategic update for investors and market enthusiasts, providing a nuanced view of the potential trajectories for 2025. By dissecting the base, bear, and bull scenarios, Sheats equips listeners with a comprehensive understanding of the factors that could influence market dynamics in the coming year.
For those interested in more insights, consider listening to the full episode of "Thoughts on the Market" by Morgan Stanley.