Podcast Summary: Three – "Forever 16" | Chapter 9

Introduction

In Chapter 9 of Wavland’s gripping 10-part series Three, titled "Forever 16," listeners delve deeper into the haunting case of Skylar Neese, a 16-year-old whose life was brutally taken by her two closest friends, Rachel Shoaf and Sheila Eddy. Released on April 5, 2024, this episode explores the enduring pain of Skylar’s family, the ongoing legal battles, and the profound impact on the Morgantown community ten years after the tragedy.

Parole Hearing: A Heart-Wrenching Stand

The episode opens with a tense recounting of Rachel Shoaf’s parole hearing. Normally, victims’ families are present physically, but due to the pandemic, Dave and Mary Neese had to join remotely. Rachel appeared before the parole board, attempting to present her case for release.

Dave Neese passionately opposed her parole:

“This inmate has proven that she is evil and mentally unstable... This inmate is a rat who got a deal. That's the only thing that saved her from first degree murder charges.” (04:02)

Despite Rachel’s father, Rusty Shoaf, advocating for her rehabilitation, Dave's raw anger and heartfelt pleas highlighted the immense suffering endured by Skylar’s family. The parole board ultimately decided not to grant Rachel parole, a decision that only deepened the family's anguish.

Dave and Mary Neese: Living with Unending Grief

Dave and Mary Neese’s journey through grief is poignantly portrayed. Ten years after Skylar’s murder, they continue to honor her memory through public talks aimed at preventing similar tragedies. Dave reflects on the constant presence of his daughter in his life:

“Skylar will forever be 16. It's the worst thing I've ever heard. But it's so true... Nobody does anything to deserve something like that.” (23:42)

Mary’s unwavering stance against parole exemplifies their commitment to justice and remembrance. Their emotional testimonies convey the depth of their loss and the enduring impact of Skylar’s absence.

Community Impact: Morgantown’s Lingering Trauma

The murder profoundly affected Morgantown, a close-knit community struggling to reconcile how three beautiful girls could commit such violence.

Chief of Police Jessica Kolbank observes:

“You could be the most facially beautiful person with the most destructive demonic soul. ... That's how these girls were.” (17:17)

Residents like Kelly Kearns and Kim Keener chose to relocate, seeking distance from the painful memories. The episode captures the collective trauma, illustrating how the case shattered the town’s sense of safety and trust.

The Complex Relationship Between Rachel and Sheila

A significant portion of the episode examines the toxic dynamic between Rachel Shoaf and Sheila Eddy. Their romantic involvement and escalating animosity culminated in Skylar’s murder.

Jessica Kolbank provides chilling insights:

“It's not everything isn't always as it seems. So I think that was the biggest shock for the community.” (17:17)

Holly Millay interviews individuals close to the case, revealing how their bond intensified to a destructive level, ultimately leading to betrayal and murder. The intimate nature of their relationship and the choice of stabbing as the method highlight the personal and brutal nature of the crime.

Unresolved Mysteries: Skylar’s Phone and Legacy

The episode touches on lingering questions, such as the significance of Skylar’s phone found at the crime scene. Despite being sealed and seemingly inaccessible, the phone remains a symbol of the unresolved aspects of the case.

Dave Neese reflects on the phone:

“She’d been rehabilitated and she was not a threat to any member of society.” (04:02)

Additionally, Dave shares heartfelt memories and signs of Skylar’s continued presence in his life, emphasizing that her spirit remains a guiding force for him and his family.

Forgiveness and Moving Forward

A recurring theme is the struggle between seeking justice and finding forgiveness. Dave and Mary’s unwavering refusal to forgive Rachel underscores the profound betrayal and the seemingly insurmountable pain caused by the loss of their daughter.

Dave Neese expresses:

“Skylar will be forever 16. It's the worst thing I've ever heard. But it's so true.” (23:42)

Their dedication to keeping Skylar’s memory alive through public speaking engagements serves as a beacon of resilience and a call to prevent such tragedies in the future.

Conclusion: A Community Still Healing

As the episode concludes, listeners are left with a vivid portrayal of a community still grappling with the aftermath of Skylar Neese’s murder. The enduring pain of the Neese family, the complex dynamics between the perpetrators, and the lasting scars on Morgantown paint a comprehensive picture of a tragedy that continues to resonate a decade later.

Justine Harmon reflects:

“It's 10 years later and we're still getting over because... the realism hits. Hey, we're not immune to what really is going on.” (16:08)

Notable Quotes Summary

• Dave Neese: “This inmate has proven that she is evil and mentally unstable...” (04:02)
• Chief Jessica Kolbank: “You could be the most facially beautiful person with the most destructive demonic soul.” (17:17)
• Dave Neese: “Skylar will forever be 16. It's the worst thing I've ever heard. But it's so true.” (23:42)
• Justine Harmon: “It's 10 years later and we're still getting over...” (16:08)

Final Thoughts

"Forever 16" offers a profound exploration of loss, betrayal, and the enduring quest for justice. Through intimate interviews, emotional testimonies, and expert insights, Wavland crafts a narrative that not only recounts a tragic event but also examines its lasting repercussions on individuals and a community. This episode stands as a testament to the series' ability to uncover the deeper layers of true crime stories, making it an essential listen for those seeking a thorough and empathetic understanding of such harrowing cases.