Podcast Summary: Three - Episode "Why? Why? Why?" | Chapter 8
Introduction and Context
In the gripping tenth episode of Waveland's true crime series Three, titled "Why? Why? Why?", hosts Justine Harmon and Holly Millay delve deeper into the tragic 2012 murder of Skylar Neese. The episode, released on March 29, 2024, explores the complex dynamics of the teenage triangle that led to Skylar's untimely death and its enduring impact on her family and the community.
Setting the Scene: The Neese Family Home
The episode opens with a poignant visit to the Neese family's residence in Morgantown, West Virginia. Justine Harmon recounts her visit in February 2014, shortly after Rachel Shoaf was sentenced for Skylar's murder.
“In the living room, Skylar was smiling from pictures, drawings, collages and a photo blanket draped across a chair... Dave wore some of Skylar's ashes in the cross around his neck, and Mary too, in her heart-shaped locket.” ([03:15])
The home is depicted as a sanctuary frozen in time, honoring Skylar's memory with personal possessions and memorials, reflecting the deep loss the family continues to endure.
Life Inside Lakin Correctional Center
The narrative shifts to Lakin Correctional Center, the only women's prison in West Virginia, where both Rachel Shoaf and Sheila Eddy are incarcerated. The episode provides a detailed description of the prison's restrictive environment, highlighting the stark contrast between inmates' perceived freedoms and the harsh realities of prison life.
“At Lakin, everything is highly regulated—from the daily inmate counts at 6 AM to strict guidelines on personal appearances and limited recreational time.” ([08:36])
Stormy Wilson, a former inmate who served time alongside Sheila and Rachel, shares her chilling first impressions of them:
“Sheila was sitting on the bench beside me... it's like, how did people even not realize that in the real world that she had that evil?” ([09:05])
Stormy's account underscores the manipulative and intimidating presence both women wielded within the prison, shaping the social hierarchy and influencing fellow inmates.
Interactions and Influence Within Prison
The episode explores the precarious relationships between Rachel, Sheila, and other inmates. Rachel's close bond with Amy Cobb, leading to their marriage post-release, is particularly highlighted:
“They were caught and separated, but would see each other in the rec yard... Rachel was able to keep Amy firmly in her thrall.” ([14:15])
Sheila Eddy's popularity and manipulative nature are further examined, revealing how both women maintained extensive networks of influence even behind bars.
Impact on the Neese Family and Community
Justine Harmon and Holly Millay emphasize the relentless grief experienced by the Neese family, who remain deeply connected to Skylar's memory through social media and personal outreach. The family's struggle to move forward is palpable, as they navigate the possibility of Rachel Shoaf's parole after a decade of incarceration.
“Once you've gotten to know Mary and Dave and Skylar and those who love them, you can't let go. You stay connected through Facebook and the Team Skylar page and texts and phone calls.” ([17:05])
Parole Hearing: Rachel Shoaf's Bid for Freedom
A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to Rachel Shoaf's parole hearing on May 9, 2023. The hosts provide an intimate portrayal of the family's anticipation and anxiety as they await the parole board's decision.
“It's been almost 11 years now since Skylar was murdered, and now Shoaf is up for her first parole hearing next week.” ([20:09])
During the hearing, Rachel's emotional testimony reveals her remorse and the psychological turmoil that led to the crime:
“I realized that I was gay as an early teenager and that scared me... the relationship between Sheila and I was immediately very unhealthy and intense and obsessive.” ([22:22])
Her heartfelt apology to Skylar's family underscores the depth of her regret, though it leaves listeners questioning the sincerity and sufficiency of her remorse.
Family and Community Response
The Neese family's unwavering stance against Shoaf's release is evident throughout the episode. Dave and Mary Neese, along with close friends and community members, rally to support their daughter and oppose Shoaf's parole.
“More than 32,000 people signed an online petition advocating for the parole board to keep Shoaf in prison.” ([20:19])
This collective outcry reflects the broader societal impact of Skylar's murder and the enduring quest for justice and closure.
Conclusion: The Lingering Questions
As the parole hearing concludes without immediate resolution, the episode leaves listeners contemplating the complexities of justice, redemption, and the long-term effects of teenage relationships gone tragically wrong.
“And Rachel, who says she has received a high school degree and a bachelor's degree in culinary arts and cosmetology while incarcerated, says she hopes to move in with her mom and Mary should she be granted parole.” ([29:41])
The episode wraps up by highlighting the unresolved tensions and the ongoing emotional journey of those left behind, setting the stage for future explorations in the series.
Notable Quotes with Timestamps
- Justine Harmon: “Skylar was smiling from pictures, drawings, collages...” ([03:15])
- Stormy Wilson: “It's like, how did people even not realize that in the real world that she had that evil?” ([09:05])
- Rachel Shoaf: “I was terrified of maybe getting kicked out of my house or maybe getting kicked out of my church...” ([22:22])
- Dave Neese: “It's been almost 11 years now since Skylar was murdered...” ([20:09])
- Rachel Shoaf: “I know that what we did was terrible and horrendous...” ([28:31])
Final Thoughts
Three continues to provide a compelling and empathetic exploration of one of America's most haunting teenage murder cases. In "Why? Why? Why?", the series not only revisits the tragic events but also delves into the psychological and social intricacies that surround them. Through detailed interviews, personal anecdotes, and emotional testimonies, Justine Harmon and Holly Millay offer listeners a profound understanding of the lingering questions that remain unanswered a decade later.
For those seeking a deep, nuanced portrayal of true crime stories, Three by Waveland is an essential listen.
If you enjoyed this summary, consider subscribing to Three on your favorite podcast platform and follow Waveland on Instagram @wavelandmedia for more insights and updates on upcoming episodes.