Throughline Podcast Summary: "Embedded: The Black Gate"

Release Date: December 24, 2024
Host: Rund Abdelfattah and Ramtin Arablouei
Series: Embedded (NPR)

Introduction: The Plight of the Uyghurs

In the inaugural episode of the three-part series "The Black Gate" from NPR's Embedded podcast, hosted by Rund Abdelfattah and Ramtin Arablouei, listeners are transported into the harrowing reality faced by the Uyghur Muslim minority in China’s Xinjiang region. The episode delves deep into the systematic oppression, cultural eradication, and the personal tragedies endured by families like the Kuchars.

Abdulatif Kuchar’s Heartbreaking Journey

The narrative centers around Abdulatif Kuchar, a Uyghur man whose life was shattered by the Chinese government's crackdown on his family. In 2017, while Abdulatif was in Istanbul, his wife Maryam and their children were violently separated from him in Xinjiang.

Key Moments:

• December 2017: Abdulatif recounts the night Maryam was taken. (02:22)
  “She was so scared, but she told me she had to open the door.” – Abdulatif Kuchar

• Aftermath: The chaos left their children, Lutfula and Aissou, traumatized and ultimately separated as Abdulatif’s extended family members were also arrested for attempting to care for them. By 2016, both Abdulatif and his children had their passports confiscated, trapping the family in a dire situation.

• Migration to Istanbul: Seeking safety, Abdulatif relocated to Istanbul, hoping to reunite with his family. However, upon his return to Istanbul, Maryam and the children remained missing, pushing Abdulatif to embark on a perilous quest to find them.

Historical Context: Uyghur Resistance and Chinese Occupation

The episode provides a comprehensive history of the Uyghur struggle against Chinese rule:

• 1949 Onwards: Chinese troops annexed Xinjiang, promising autonomy to ethnic minorities like the Uyghurs and Tibetans. However, promises were broken as the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) imposed strict control.

• Family History: Abdulatif’s grandfather was an active figure in the Uyghur independence movement, aligning with leaders like Niaz Hoxa Niaz. Post-occupation, the family faced persecution; Abdulatif’s father was coerced into joining the CCP and renouncing his Islamic faith, leading to familial strife and eventual divorce. (07:23-08:04)

• Diaspora and Business Ventures: In 1986, Abdulatif’s mother moved the family to Turkey, granting Abdulatif and his brother Turkish citizenship. Despite relocating, the brothers maintained business ties in Xinjiang, believing in a hopeful economic future under Chinese rule until the early 2000s.

The Escalation of Repression: From 2001 Onwards

The global events of September 11, 2001, significantly influenced China's policies in Xinjiang:

• War on Terror: China leveraged the global anti-terrorism sentiment to justify stringent measures against Uyghurs, labeling cultural and religious expressions as potential threats. (12:01)

• Cultural Suppression: Uyghur cultural renaissance in the late 1990s and early 2000s, marked by the restoration of mosques and revitalization of Islamic practices, was met with severe crackdowns. Authorities attributed these cultural expressions to extremism. (09:47-10:41)

• Violence and Retaliation: The 2009 Urumqi riots, sparked by ethnic tensions and violent clashes between Uyghurs and Han Chinese, resulted in over 150 deaths and heightened state repression.

The Black Gate: A Massive Detention Apparatus

"The Black Gate" refers to the expansive network of detention centers established by the Chinese government to incarcerate Uyghurs and other Muslim minorities.

Key Insights:

• Scale of Detentions: Between 2017 and 2021, over one million Uyghurs were detained. (22:50)

• Purpose and Justification: Officially labeled as "vocational education and training centers," these facilities aim to "eradicate terrorism and religious extremism" by indoctrinating detainees with CCP ideology and Mandarin language skills. (22:50-23:00)

• Arbitrary Detentions: Leaked documents reveal that detentions were often based on trivial indicators such as men having long beards or women wearing veils. (22:50)

• Human Rights Abuses: Detainees are subjected to forced labor, political indoctrination, and severe human rights violations, making it one of the largest and most systematic internments of an ethnic minority since the Holocaust.

Notable Quote:

• Emily Fang:
  "The Black Gates that China built to intern hundreds of thousands of Uyghurs and other ethnic minorities in Xinjiang. These detainees can be seen... likely the largest internment of an ethnic or religious minority since the Holocaust." (22:45-22:50)

Voices from the Uyghur Community

The episode amplifies the voices of those directly impacted by the crackdown:

• Kalbennor: A young Uyghur mother from Kashgar describes the pervasive fear and constant harassment by authorities. (13:09-13:51)
  “People began disappearing... my life became very isolated.” – Kalbennor

• Abdoulaye Ayup: A Uyghur language teacher and activist, Abdoulaye sought to preserve Uyghur culture through education. His efforts led to his arrest in 2013, exemplifying the targeting of cultural leaders. (18:05-19:12)
  “We will not compromise... We shouldn't lose our language.” – Abdoulaye Ayup

Personal Struggles and Enduring Hope

Abdulatif’s unwavering hope to reunite with his family amidst oppressive circumstances highlights the personal toll of geopolitical conflicts. His family’s resilience and determination to maintain their cultural identity in the face of systematic eradication underscore the broader struggle of the Uyghur people.

Key Moments:

• Road Trip Revelation: In 2016, Abdulatif took his family on a road trip across Xinjiang, only to witness a massive military presence, signaling the intensifying crackdown. (20:21-20:36)

• Deportation and Separation: Despite efforts to secure his Turkish passport, Abdulatif was deported, leaving Maryam and their children behind—a move that ultimately led to their disappearance within the Chinese detention system. (25:11-26:38)

Conclusion: A Continuing Battle

"The Black Gate" paints a grim picture of the systematic oppression of Uyghurs in Xinjiang. Through personal stories, historical context, and firsthand accounts, the episode underscores the urgent need for global awareness and intervention. Abdulatif Kuchar’s relentless search for his family symbolizes the broader quest for justice and human rights for the Uyghur people.

Final Quote:

• Emily Fang:
  “It is currently impossible to verify Haigt’s well-being and whether he made the statements in the video under duress.” (27:49-28:00)

Production Credits

• Reporter: Emily Fang
• Producers: Phoebe Wang, Adelina Lancian Hees
• Editing: Jenny Schmidt
• Supervisory Editor: Katie Simon
• Executive Producer: Irene Noguchi
• Music: Ramtin Arablouei
• Translation and Interpretation: Abdoulaye Ayup, Qasem Abdurrahim Kashkar Mametchan, Jimeh Muqaddas, Qasim Abdurahm
• Special Thanks: Dee Dee Schenke, Vincent Knee, Lee Hale, Shirley Henry, and the Kuchar family.

Further Listening

To delve deeper into the Uyghur history, listeners are encouraged to check out "Five Fingers Crushed the Land" from the Throughline podcast, available via the episode description.

Subscribe to Throughline+: Support the creation of in-depth historical stories and gain access to bonus episodes and sponsor-free listening by subscribing at plus.npr.org/throughline.