Timcast IRL Ep. "Illegal Immigrant ARRESTED After Shooting At DHS, War ERUPTS In Chicago w/ Dan Dillon"

Date: November 11, 2025
Host: Seamus Coughlin (filling in for Tim Pool)
Panel: Dan Dillon (Babylon Bee/Not the Bee), Shane Cashman, Elad Eliyahu, Phil Monte

Episode Overview

This episode dives into breaking news and heated issues, including the arrest of an illegal immigrant for shooting at DHS agents in Chicago, widespread lawlessness at protests, America's immigration crisis, and the latest policy proposals from the Trump administration. The panel, featuring voices from new media, music, and reporting, debate escalating political violence, immigration, the burdens of government, and cultural change. Expect sharp opinions, comedic interjections, and an undercurrent of culture war strategy throughout.

Panel Introduction

• Seamus Coughlin (host, FreedomToons creator) sets a playful-yet-serious tone, filling in for Tim Pool, and plugs his own crowdfunded show (Twisted Plots).
• Dan Dillon, CTO/co-owner of Babylon Bee/Founder of Not the Bee, brings a satirical and media-savvy perspective.
• Shane Cashman, Inverted World Live host, offers cultural and political commentary, often with a conspiratorial or outsider's edge.
• Elad Eliyahu, White House correspondent for Timcast, grounds discussions with reporting experience.
• Phil Monte, musician (All That Remains), presents as an unapologetic anti-communist, counter-revolutionary voice.

Key Segments & Discussions

1. Illegal Immigrant Shoots at DHS Agents in Chicago (06:45 - 19:02)

Headlines & Developments

• Illegal Mexican immigrant arrested after allegedly firing at border patrol agents during a Chicago raid.
• Crowd at the scene threw bricks at law enforcement.

Commentary & Analysis

• Reclassification of Protesters:
  "When you're lobbying bricks, you're no longer protesters...that's a riot." – Seamus Coughlin (06:45)

• Rhetoric Escalates Violence:
  Government agents (ICE/DHS) are routinely demonized as "Nazis" or "Gestapo," fueling lawlessness.

  • “The rhetoric surrounding this issue has paved the way for this kind of obstruction and violence to continue...” – Seamus (09:18)

• Law Enforcement's Response:
  Debate on why officers hesitate to engage/defend themselves amid violence.

  • “They don’t want to inflame tensions even further.” – Elad Eliyahu (12:02)
  • “This light touch with protesters and with the left...is not going to work.” – Phil Monte (12:18)

Notable Quotes

• “If you don’t want to get shot, don’t throw rocks at people with guns.” – Seamus (09:14)
• “What inflames and emboldens violent criminals is getting away with it.” – Seamus (14:51)

Policy Frustrations

• Weak law enforcement is emboldening repeat offenders.
• Double standards noted: Swift justice for January 6 participants, but leniency toward left-wing rioters.

2. Policy, Rhetoric, and Lawlessness (19:02 - 23:14)

• Boomerang of Political Narratives:
  Pointing out how leftist talking points ("riots are the language of the unheard") get used selectively, flipped for/against groups after events like Jan 6.

  • “They're saying, we like the rioters. We don't like the people who are opposed to them.”—Seamus (20:18)

• Enforcement: Across the Spectrum:
  Both “establishment” (Shane) and “outsider/conspiracy” (Elad) voices on the panel agree: Those engaging in riotous violence—including brick-throwers—should be arrested and prosecuted.

• “Two people from the complete opposite end of the spectrum…saying these people need to be thrown in prison. Why? Because it’s common sense.” – Seamus (22:39)

3. Obesity and Immigration Policy (23:50 - 34:27)

• US Considering Visa Denial for Obese Applicants:
  “Foreigners could have their US visas rejected if they are obese.” – Seamus (23:51)

• Panel mocks and debates the rationale—public health burdens, potential for discriminatory overreach.

  • “If the taxpayer is going to pay for your health care, then what you eat...is the business of the taxpayer.” – Phil Monte (25:16)

• American Irony:
  America is fatter than most other countries; panel jokes Americans might have less reason to restrict heavier immigrants.

  • “I think even a fat person from another country might be bringing the weight average down.” – Elad (27:43)

• Personal Responsibility vs. Food System:
  Debate about how much is systemic (food, additives, public health) versus personal (choices, discipline, virtue).

  • “People need to cultivate virtue...not over consumption.” – Seamus (35:49)

Comic Relief

• “We should have a border that’s an American Ninja Warrior course...lose those pounds before they get here.” – Shane Cashman (32:28)

4. Trump’s Housing & Wealth Proposals (35:48 - 54:45)

50-Year Mortgage Plan

• Trump proposes dramatically lengthening mortgage terms to make homes more “affordable.”
• Panel universally skeptical:
  • “You don’t actually start paying principal on these things for like 30 years...so, you’re just renting the house.” – Dan Dillon (38:37)
  • “For 20 years extra, for like 200 bucks a month savings...that’s insane.” – Seamus (47:49)
• Points raised: Delayed market correction, risk of “debt slavery,” housing cost inflation.

$2,000 Tariff Dividend

• Trump floats dividends/tax breaks funded by tariffs.
• Panel debates short-term political benefits versus long-term inflation and national debt concerns.
  • “Last time we got a stimulus check, we ended up losing like $10,000 in purchasing power.” – Seamus (54:45)
  • “People love free shit.” – Elad (55:02)

5. Shutdown Politics & Government Dysfunction (59:20–66:03)

• Shutdown Ends After Democratic “Cave”:
  Senate reopens government after Democrats broke ranks; reveals that narrative blaming Republicans was misleading.
  • “It’s almost like they wanted the government open the entire time and it was the Democrats preventing it from happening.” – Seamus (61:32)
• Libertarian vs. Neocon Jabs:
  Libertarians (Rand Paul) get blamed for voting against reopening; libertarian/conservative differences in approach and goals.
• Panel Frustration:
  Both left/right use shutdown theatrics to grandstand; collateral damage for travelers and workers.

6. Escalating Campus and Protest Violence (68:45–77:36)

• Antifa Attacks TPUSA Event at Berkeley
  Protesters attempt to break down barriers, some arrests made.
  • “You don’t arrest these people, they become emboldened.” – Seamus (70:27)
  • “Anyone in a face mask? Honestly at this point…gone—right to jail.” – Shane (71:22)
• Law Enforcement Paralysis:
  Panel frustrated by fear of bad optics and demotivating political culture for police.
  • “It seems like these days you’re actually demonized for [standing up and doing the right thing].” – Dan Dillon (73:28)
• Strategic Weakness:
  “Only one side is required to play by the rules here.” – Seamus (73:56)
  • Calls for mass arrests and enforcement within the law.

7. Supreme Court Declines to Rehear Obergefell (Same-Sex Marriage) (79:13–101:19)

• SCOTUS refuses appeal that could overturn the gay marriage precedent.
• Panel split between relief, disappointment, and culture war strategy.
  • “If there’s one institution that shouldn’t worry about optics, it’s the Supreme Court…” – Dan Dillon (82:26)
• Debate over shifting party attitudes, normalization of LGBTQ identity among Republicans, and line-drawing between “big tent” coalition politics and moral principles.
  • “If you allow the Democrats to get back into power, they’re going to start throwing conservatives in jail...they associate Christians with Nazis…” – Phil Monte (94:27)
  • “My self-preservation is rooted in eternity, outside of the material world.” – Shane (94:32)
• Discussion of whether Trump’s pivot on abortion/gay marriage is alienating Christian conservatives.

Notable & Memorable Moments

• Satirical Wisdom:
  “Dave Ramsey in critical condition after learning a 50 year mortgage.” – Babylon Bee via Dan Dillon (38:37)
• Policy Irony:
  On the fat-visa ban:
  “I will say, you know, this is a little ironic because Americans…are a lot fatter than most on average people from any other country.” – Elad (27:43)
• On Rules of Protest:
  “Every parent, you know, at a certain age, they have to give their child the talk — ‘Don’t throw bricks at police officers’ talk.” – Seamus (17:56)
• Political Realism:
  “We have to do something to make sure young people have a reason to buy into America...There has never been a [generation that] believes in America less.” – Phil Monte (46:21)
• On Law Enforcement Weakness:
  “All these White House social media accounts will post these edgy edits…then they won’t actually step in and enforce the law because they think that’s too inflammatory.” – Seamus (15:13)
• Campus Violence:
  “Round all those people up and they should all go to jail. Like, all of them. They can. They’ve got buses, bring the buses out, wrap them up and put them in jail.” – Phil (71:06)

Timestamps – Important Segments

• 06:45 — Illegal immigrant shooting & Chicago riot
• 14:51 — Rhetoric, recidivism, law enforcement hesitancy
• 19:02 — Double standards: Jan 6 vs. left-wing riots
• 23:51 — "Visa ban” for fat foreigners, public health/burden debate
• 38:37 — 50-year mortgages; critique & satire
• 47:49 — Debt slavery; practical vs. political solutions
• 54:45 — $2,000 tariff dividend, inflation politics
• 61:32 — Congressional/democratic maneuvering re: shutdown
• 68:45 — Berkeley Antifa violence/riot
• 71:06 — Enforcement paralysis and call for crackdown
• 79:13 — SCOTUS on Obergefell, Republican coalition debate
• 94:27 — Culture war, party identity, and pragmatism

Tone & Panel Dynamics

• Comedic but sharp, with regular satirical jabs (esp. at government and the left)
• Frequent interruptions and debates—panelists often disagree, especially on coalition-building vs. ideological purity, prioritizing policy vs. politics.
• A blend of policy frustration and dark humor, especially regarding lawlessness, government dysfunction, and the border crisis.
• Regular plugs for crowdfunding, panelists' personal/side projects, and audience participation.
• Candid about intra-movement disagreements—but unified in sense of urgency that “something has to change.”

Summary Takeaway

This episode delivers a timely, no-holds-barred evaluation of the political and cultural crossroads America faces. The panel sees escalating violence, declining norms, and soft law enforcement—a recipe for repeat rioting and lawlessness. Trump’s policy proposals (long mortgages, checks) are seen as well-meant but ultimately band-aids or worse. Cultural divides are front and center: immigration, obesity, housing, gay marriage, all through a prism of generational disaffection and party transformation.

Panelists agree:

• The rule of law needs reassertion—swift, visible, and confident.
• Weak or optics-obsessed enforcement emboldens bad actors.
• American identity, and the meaning of citizenship, is at stake from the border to the ballot box to the culture wars.

Most importantly:
They urge courage and clarity—from law enforcement, lawmakers, the courts, and everyday Americans—to reestablish order, define values, and secure the future amid chaos.

For Listeners Who Missed the Episode

• You’ll get high-energy, in-depth debate on law, culture, and party identity.
• Sharp, meme-heavy insight—with the panel drawing deep connections between recent headlines and persistent social trends.
• Plenty of classic Timcast IRL banter, but with a pointed edge given the seriousness of the news.

For more discussion, check out their Members Only segment and don't miss the closing call to build up new right-leaning storytelling through projects like Twisted Plots.