Deporting Kilmar Abrego Garcia (to Uganda)

Summary

---

Today, Explained: Deporting Kilmar Abrego Garcia (to Uganda)

Podcast: Today, Explained (Vox)
Episode Date: September 3, 2025
Hosts: Derek Thompson, Ellie Hoenig (guest)
Topic: The legal, political, and societal saga of Kilmar Abrego Garcia—the most high-profile deportee in the U.S.—and its implications for the U.S. justice system, immigration policy, and American demographic shifts under President Trump’s administration.

---

Main Theme / Purpose

This episode unpacks the complex legal and political journey of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, whose deportation case has gripped the U.S. public. Once detained in El Salvador in violation of a judge’s order, brought back to the U.S. to face criminal charges, and now under threat of deportation to Uganda, Abrego Garcia’s case exposes the intersections of immigration enforcement, judicial process, and the Trump administration’s hardline stance on deportation—a story emblematic of deeper tensions within U.S. immigration politics and policy.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Background and Complexity of Kilmar Abrego Garcia’s Case

• Parallel Legal Proceedings:
  • Garcia is fighting both immigration and criminal cases at the same time, complicating his status.

    “To try to understand this whole saga … you have to understand there are two separate proceedings happening at the same time, but separate from one another. … Parallel, really.”
    —Ellie Hoenig [03:17]

• Mistaken Deportation to El Salvador:
  • Garcia was deported to El Salvador despite a judicial order barring it on grounds of likely persecution.
  • While detained in a notoriously harsh Salvadoran prison, official records recount specific mistreatment.

    “Abrego and 20 other Salvadorans were forced to kneel from approximately 9pm to 6am … Abrego Garcia was denied bathroom access and soiled himself.”
    —Derek Thompson [04:50]

2. Supreme Court Ruling and DOJ’s Political Maneuvers

• Facilitate, But Not Enforce Return:
  • Supreme Court told the administration to “facilitate” Garcia’s return—not to forcibly bring him back. The administration provided the most minimal compliance.
  • DOJ then indicts Garcia and brings him back for criminal prosecution—a rare procedural move.

    “You don’t deport someone, let them … sort of waste away for a few months and then bring them back to prosecute them and then potentially just redeport them. It makes no sense.”
    —Ellie Hoenig [07:15]

• Charges and Political Context:
  • Garcia faces allegations of alien smuggling but DOJ public communications heavily implied, though didn’t formally charge, him with more heinous offenses (e.g., soliciting minors, role in murder)—a pattern suggesting political motivations:

    “None of that’s charged, but now what happens? It’s all out there. People on the administration side say, see … these facts demonstrate Abrego Garcia is a danger to our community.”
    —Ellie Hoenig [08:21]

  • Defense successfully highlighted the flimsiness of evidence (multiple levels of hearsay, unreliable documentation), leading to Garcia’s temporary release on bail.

3. Immigration/Deportation Proceedings and the Uganda Decision

• Permanent Limbo & Retribution Narrative:
  • Upon criminal bail, Garcia was immediately re-detained by immigration authorities.
  • The government proposes to deport him to Uganda, with officials casting this as a “choice” since Garcia claims El Salvador isn’t safe.

    “Garcia has said he doesn’t want to go back home to El Salvador. That’s what he said. So we’re honoring that request by providing him with an alternate place to live. We’re not a travel booking agency.”
    —Derek Thompson (satirical comment, likely quoting administration rhetoric) [11:05]

• Judicial Interventions & Costa Rica Offer:
  • A federal judge, suspicious of how the case has been handled, bars removal until due process claims are heard.
  • Garcia’s legal team had even secured potential safe harbor in Costa Rica, but U.S. authorities refused.

4. Systemic Failures or Successes?

• Critique of Systemic Handling:
  • Hoenig notes repeated failures by the system in Garcia’s case, including prosecutorial resignations in protest:

    “I should note, by the way, that when this indictment was being put together, a veteran, career nonpartisan Prosecutor … resigned in protest. And I think that tells you something.”
    —Ellie Hoenig [12:34]

• Courts Playing a Moderating Role:
  • Some faith in the judiciary remains, as courts have reined in excesses and forced government compliance with process.

5. The Broader Demographic and Policy Implications

• Potential First-Ever Population Decline:
  • With low birth rates and drastic drops in immigration, 2025 may see America’s first annual population decrease.

    “For the entirety of American history, the US has only known population growth. … But Donald Trump is on the precipice of a truly historic and, as you said, dubious achievement. … In 2025, it is absolutely possible that the US population shrinks for the first time on record.”
    —Derek Thompson [17:40]

• Immigration’s Essential Role in Key Sectors:
  • Agriculture: “Two-thirds of agricultural workers are immigrants.” [23:03]
  • Housing Construction: “30 to 40% of the construction labor force is foreign born in Florida, [etc].” [23:50]
  • Health Care: “Foreign born people account for up to 25, 27% of America's physicians and surgeons. One in six people working across the healthcare sector are foreign born.” [24:26]
• Economic & Political Ramifications:
  • Restrictive immigration risks labor shortages, inflation, and longer lines for essential services.
  • Trump administration may wield immigration pain as leverage over states/industries.

    “He has a three step formula for everything that he does. Step one, create pain. Step two, offer to remove pain. Step three, demand tribute.”
    —Derek Thompson [25:30]

  • The immigration pendulum: public dissatisfaction swings back and forth, punishing incumbents for either “mass immigration” or “record deportations.”

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On the government’s procedural pretext:

  “What DOJ did when they got this indictment is ... they brought him back to prosecute him. You don't ... let them ... waste away for a few months and then bring them back to prosecute.”
  —Ellie Hoenig [07:15]

• On evidence against Garcia:

  “The charges against Kilmara Brego Garcia were incredibly flimsy and based ... on third and fourth hand hearsay ... that's how flimsy the government's proof is in this case.”
  —Ellie Hoenig [09:11]

• On the policy’s impact on daily life:

  “If you don't have enough people to build houses ... housing prices ... go up because there's a housing shortage.”
  —Derek Thompson [24:00]

• On the cycle of immigration politics:

  “I think many Americans clearly did not like the era of mass immigration ... but I think they might hate the era of record deportations even more.”
  —Derek Thompson [26:47]

---

Timestamps for Important Segments

• [03:00] – Explanation of two-track legal battle (immigration vs. criminal)
• [04:18] – Judge’s order violated, Garcia deported to El Salvador (despite danger)
• [05:03] – How the administration “facilitated” Garcia’s return in the narrowest way
• [06:05] – Garcia indicted and brought back to U.S., political motivations debated
• [08:08] – DOJ publicizes uncharged, inflammatory accusations
• [09:11] – Detailed breakdown of flimsy evidence and bail decision
• [10:56] – Immigration proceedings resume, Uganda proposed as deportation locale
• [12:34] – System critique, resignation of career prosecutor
• [17:40] – Historic threat of U.S. population decline explained
• [22:51] – Economic role of immigrants in food, housing, health care sectors
• [25:30] – “Three-step formula” for Trump’s use of immigration as political weapon
• [26:47] – Prognosis for future political backlash and policy swings

---

Overall Tone and Takeaways

• The episode adopts a forensic, explanatory tone with a touch of dry irony and frustration—particularly as it dissects the often circular, punitive, or politically motivated decisions taken by authorities.
• The story serves as a microcosm of America’s conflicted and polarized approach to immigration and its far-reaching consequences, both humanitarian and demographic.

---

For listeners seeking a deeper understanding of how one deportation case reflects larger national anxieties, and the procedural, political, and real-world fallout of the Trump administration's immigration crackdown, this episode is an essential primer—blending legal analysis, policy critique, and demographic forecasting in a single, dramatic narrative.

Transcript

[Derek Thompson]

Presidente Trump has said he wants to deport a million people out of the United states every year, 1 million illegal aliens per year thus far in 2025, he's falling well short of that goal. Estimates are in the neighborhood of 200,000 as of August. But the one deportee most people can name remains Kilmar Abrego Garcia Mi nombre, Kilmar Abrego Garcia que estoy libre y me rejo unico mi familia. After months in El Salvadoran lab, camp prison complex, Abrego Garcia returned to the United States in June. But the latest news is that the federal government wants to deport him to Uganda.

[Ellie Hoenig]

He needs to never be in the United States of America, and our administration is making sure we're doing all that we can to bring him to justice.

[Derek Thompson]

We're going to try and understand why and wrap our heads around what his story tells us about our country on Today. Explained.

[Silicon Valley Bank Advertiser]

Whether you're a founder, investor or innovation company executive, you need a bank that truly understands your business inside and out. A bank that offers uniquely specialized solutions for your unique needs. A bank like Silicon Valley Bank. Silicon Valley bank is still the SVB you know and trust. The only difference? SVB is now backed by the strength and stability of First Citizens Bank. Yes, SVB. Learn more at svb.com Vox.

[Robinhood Advertiser]

Support for this show comes from Robinhood. Wouldn't it be great to manage your portfolio on one platform? With Robinhood, not only can you trade individual stocks and ETFs, you can also seamlessly buy and sell crypto at low costs. Trade all in one place. Get started now on Robinhood Trading. Crypto involves significant risk. Crypto trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Crypto llc. Robinhood Crypto is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the New York State Department of Financial Services. Crypto held through Robinhood Crypto is not FDIC insured or sipic. Protected investing involves risk including loss of principal. Securities trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Financial LLC Member sipic, a registered broker dealer. Estana escuchando a Hoy exprigado to TODAY Explained.

[Ellie Hoenig]

My name is Ellie hoenig. I am CNN's senior legal analyst. I'm a former federal and state prosecutor. I am a writer for New York Magazine and Cafe. I'm part of the Vox family and I have a new book coming up called when youn Come at the king inside DOJ's pursuit of the President From Nixon to Trump.

[Derek Thompson]

Outstanding. And the last time I heard you say that was the last time you were on the show, which was back in April when we were last discussing the. The Abrego Garcia case. At the time, of course, he was stuck in El Salvador. Where is he now?

[Ellie Hoenig]

He is physically located in the United States, in Virginia. I guess that's the good news for Kilmara Abrego Garcia. The bad news is he's in custody. He is in the custody of immigration officials. Because the one thing I want to say right at the outset, to try to understand this whole saga around Kilmara Brago Garcia, you have to understand there are two separate proceedings happening at the same time, but separate from one another. Parallel, really. One of them is he's here in the country in the United States illegally, and so immigration authorities are trying to deport him. That's happening in the immigration courts separately, but mostly simultaneously. He also has a criminal case. He's now been charged by indictment with certain federal crimes by the U.S. department of Justice. So he's fighting both of those battles at once. But as we speak, he is in the United States. He's in Virginia in a federal immigration detention facility.

[Derek Thompson]

I feel like this story got a lot of attention early on because it was kind of easy to understand why this would upset people. But now it's gotten so complicated. It still feels like it's upsetting people. But can you help us understand how deeply complex it is? Exactly. Can we take it chronologically from, like, where we last left off in El Salvador?

[Ellie Hoenig]

Kilmar Brego Garcia gets deported in March. He's here illegally. He gets deported, but to where? El Salvador. The one place on the globe the United States government was not allowed to send. Kilmar Abrego Garcia was El Salvador. There was a preexisting order from a judge saying he cannot be sent there because he has shown that he might face the risk of persecution or retribution.

[Derek Thompson]

This man lived here, had lived here for quite a few years, but he was picked up by ice. And then, in spite of a judge's order saying that he should not be deported to El Salvador, he was sent to that prison that we've all seen on TV.

[Derek Thompson (continued or another expert guest)]

The filing said, in part, quote, Abrego and 20 other Salvadorans were forced to kneel from approximately 9pm to 6am Abrego Garcia was denied bathroom access and soiled himself.

[Ellie Hoenig]

Initially, the administration admitted in court that that was a clerical error, they claimed. Case winds its way up to the U.S. supreme Court, and the U.S. supreme Court says, well, you must, quote, facilitate. And this word got a lot of scrutiny. Facilitate his return to the United States. What does the Trump administration do? They give that word, facilitate essentially its narrowest possible interpretation, and they do next to nothing. And they basically take the position of, well, if he should happen to arrive here, then I guess we'll let him in. And for a while, when we last spoke, he was in a sort of purgatory. The big change in this case was, was the Department of Justice indicted Kilmar Abrego Garcia.

[Department of Justice Official]

Good afternoon. We're here today to announce a major update in an important case.

[Ellie Hoenig]

And what they did at that point is they brought him back to the United States. They made a big, splashy announcement by the AG he's been indicted, and we're bringing him back here now because he's a criminal, and we're going to prosecute him.

[Department of Justice Official]

The grand jury found that over the past nine years, Abrego Garcia has plenty of played a significant role in an alien smuggling ring. He was a smuggler of humans and children and women.

[Ellie Hoenig]

And so he was brought back to the country to face prosecution. But what has happened since then, this picks up where my last answer left off, is he got bail on the criminal case because this criminal case is so flimsy and such a mess, and therefore he was technically free. So he got released on the criminal side, but immediately the immigration side swoops in and. And picks him back up, which brings us to him being in custody in Virginia.

[Derek Thompson]

So before we get to this sort of the two separate proceedings thing, why did the United States government indict him and bring him back? Was there pressure to do that, or were they just like, maybe we have a better chance with this other path?

[Ellie Hoenig]

I think really the play there was political. I think it's a PR play, because what happened while Kilmar Brego Garcia was in this purgatory while he was in El Salvador, and there was this sort of stalemate about what's going to happen. This debate broke out, this political debate where Democrats, I'll generalize here, were saying, I'm not vouching for the man.

[Derek Thompson (continued or another expert guest)]

I'm standing up for his rights because.

[Ellie Hoenig]

All of our rights are at risk if we don't. The Trump administration and others were saying, yeah, but he's a horrible guy. He's a gangster, he's vicious, he's violent, he's a terrorist. What DOJ did when they got this indictment is, first of all, they brought him back to prosecute him. You don't. That is almost never the way things are done. You don't deport someone, let them you know, sort of waste away for a few months and then bring them back to prosecute them and then potentially just redeport them. It makes no sense. That's number one. Number two, the way DOJ rolled out this case to me was such a tell that it was political. The charges here against Kilmar Abrego Garcia are that he basically drove illegal aliens across state lines. That's it. Yet if you looked at the DOJ announcement, Pam Bondi made a televised announcement with the cameras from behind the podium. They say in the announcements, not in the indictment, but in their various announcements.

[Department of Justice Official]

A co conspirator alleged that the defendant solicited nude photographs and videos of a minor. A co conspirator also alleges the defendant played a role in the murder of a rival gang member's mother.

[Ellie Hoenig]

None of that's charged, but now what happens? It's all out there. People on the administration side say, see.

[Department of Justice Official]

These facts demonstrate Abrego Garcia is a danger to our community.

[Ellie Hoenig]

And then the defense lawyers essentially pick it apart, which is why he got bail.

[Derek Thompson]

For the first time in five months. Kilmar Abrego Garcia is no longer in federal custody and finally is reunited with his family. So he gets bail in this criminal case. He still has the ongoing proceedings regarding his status in this country. How does he get bail in the first place?

[Ellie Hoenig]

So one of the big questions when you're arguing bail in the federal, and again, we're now on the criminal side is how strong is the evidence of this person's guilt? I've done, I don't know, more bail arguments than I could ever count. And the defense lawyers really exposed that the charges against Kilmara Brego Garcia were incredibly flimsy and based sometimes on third and fourth hand hearsay. So I'll give you one example. One of the arguments that prosecutors made to keep Kilmara Brago locked up on the criminal case is, well, we have evidence that he was transporting minors. Okay, the way they established that is prosecutors pointed to a handwritten note. Now, they don't know who wrote the note. They don't know where it came from, but it's a handwritten note that was in a cop's files. A cop had done a traffic stop of Kilmar Abrego Garcia. And one of the notes say, seems to reflect that somebody in the car had a birth date of 2007. And so prosecutors can't explain who wrote that note or who it refers to, but they say, look, 2007, that would make the person a minor Then somebody photographed the handwritten note. Then a cop sees the photograph of the handwritten note. Then a cop tells an FBI agent about the handwritten note. And then the FBI agent testifies to the grand jury. So you can count. That's three, four levels of hearsay. And here's an even bigger kicker. And the judge found this. When you look at the handwritten note, it's not even clear whether that note says 2007, which would make the person a minor, or 2001. You know, the 7 and the 1 are kind of a little close in how they look, which would make the person not a minor. And on top of that, prosecutors don't even know who the note refers to. They don't know if it's a boy or a girl, a man or a woman, a minor or an adult. They can't locate the person. They can't put a name on the person. So that's how flimsy the government's proof is in this case. And that's a reason that the judge cited. She said, it doesn't mean the case is over. It just means he's getting out on bail. And that led to him then three days later being re incarcerated re locked up. On the immigration side of things.

[Derek Thompson]

And this is where Uganda enters the chat.

[Ellie Hoenig]

Exactly at this point, and this is where it starts to be almost overtly retributive.

[Derek Thompson]

Garcia has said he doesn't want to go back home to El Salvador. That's what he said. So we're honoring that request by providing him with an alternate place to live. We're not a travel booking agency. It's not our job to say to illegal alien terrorists, pick your favorite destination in the world, and we'll send you a charter jet there.

[Ellie Hoenig]

And now what his lawyers have done is said, whoa, whoa, whoa, put a pause on that. He has a right to contest that because you don't have a lot of say if you're in the country illegally about where you get deported to, but you do have a right to due process to argue, maybe I'm not the guy. Maybe I'm not here illegally. And to argue that he would face persecution or danger if sent to that country. And so there's now a different federal judge involved who's sort of overseeing the immigration case, who has said, basically, I don't trust you government. You've played fast and loose, and you are not to move him out of this country until I've had a chance to decide this. And so the judge is gonna figure out whether it makes sense to send in to Uganda. And what's really crazy about this is Abrego Garcia's lawyers have said he will gladly. They had done some work. They had connected with the government of Costa Rica and said, please just send, you can get rid of him if you want. Just send him to Costa Rica. He'll be safe there. We've worked it out and the US Government has said no. I mean, if their concern was really getting him out of the country, this could be over by now.

[Derek Thompson]

And because you've been inside this system, Ellie, do you see the system working throughout the three, four or five months of this Kilmar Abrego Garcia case, or do you see it failing more?

[Ellie Hoenig]

I think it. Well, it certainly failed with respect to Kilmar Brego Garcia. And I should note, by the way, that when this indictment was being put together, a veteran, career nonpartisan Prosecutor in that U.S. attorney's office resigned in protest. And I think that tells you something.

[Derek Thompson]

But they failed. They failed over and over and over again. Now he's sitting in detention and he might not even get to go to Uganda like they want because there'll probably be a lot of protest over it. I don't know. We'll see. But does that give you hope or no? I mean, I'm not looking for the hope. I'm just curious. From your expertise.

[Ellie Hoenig]

Yes, I think I do. I think the courts have done their job here, I think, so far. And that applies to the judge in the criminal case, the Supreme Court justice. I mean, I mean, a lot of people, a lot of judges have done the right thing here and have said no. You have to follow the rules. You have to do things by the book. You have to remain accountable. But I guess from a political calculation, what does one fear more? On the one hand, you know, having a bunch of legal setbacks coming out in these judicial opinions that are sort of nuanced or just being able to say, we got this horrible guy, we want him out and Democrats want to keep him in here. And look, you know, they want it. They want this terrorist to move in next to you. Like what plays better with the American public. I'm not so sure.

[Derek Thompson]

Ellie Hoenig, if you like books, check his out once more. It's called when youn Come at the king inside DOJ's pursuit of the President from Nixon to Trump. It drops in a few days. The president and his administration are using Kilmar Abrego Garcia to scare off other immigrants, to deter them. The consequences when we're back on today, explained Support for the program today comes from Shopify. When you're creating your own business, you have to juggle a lot of roles. Marketing, sales, outreach, design. Shopify can simplify all of that. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and according to the company, 10% of all e commerce in the US from household names like Mattel and Gymshark to brands just getting started like maybe, I don't know yours. They say they have hundreds of ready to use templates to help design your brand's style. And they say they can make marketing easier by creating email and social media campaigns so you can connect with customers wherever they be scrolling. Shopify also has AI tools created for commerce they say can help you create product descriptions, generate discount codes and more. You can turn your big business idea into reality with Shopify on your side. You can sign up for your $1 per month trial and start selling [e-mail] explained. You can go to shopify.com explained that shopify.com explained does anyone have a cash register handy.

[Oracle Cloud Infrastructure Advertiser]

In business? They say you can have better, cheaper or faster, but you only get to pick two. What if you could have all three at the same time? That's exactly what Cohere, Thomson Reuters and Specialized Bikes have since they upgraded to the next generation of the cloud. Oracle Cloud Infrastructure OCI is the blazing fast platform for your infrastructure, database, application development and AI needs where you can run any workload in a high availability, consistently high performance environment and spend less than you would with other clouds. How is it faster? OCI's block storage gives you more operations per second cheaper. OCI costs up to 50% less for compute, 70% less for storage and 80% less for networking better. In test after test, OCI customers report lower latency and higher bandwidth versus other clouds. This is the cloud built for AI and all your biggest workloads right now with zero commitment. Try OCI for free. Head to oracle.com Vox that's oracle.com Vox Support for this show comes from Indeed Indeed. Sponsored Jobs help you stand out and hire fast With Sponsored Jobs, your post jumps to the top of the page for your relevant candidates so you can reach the people you want faster and listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit. To get your jobs more visibility@ Indeed.com Vox Business, just go to Indeed.com Vox Business right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Indeed.com VoxBusiness Terms and Conditions apply. Hiring Indeed is all you need.

[Derek Thompson]

Explained Derek Thompson co wrote a book called Abundance. You may have heard of it, but he's also got a substack. And on it this week, he wrote that the United States is on the precipice of a historic, if dubious, achievement. We asked him to tell us about it.

[Derek Thompson (continued or another expert guest)]

Well, for the entirety of American history, the US has only known population growth. The US Grew through the Civil War. We grew through the Spanish Flu. We grew through both World Wars. We grew through Covid, even despite the deaths of a million people. But Donald Trump is on the precipice of a truly historic and, as you said, dubious achievement. In 2025, it is absolutely possible that the US population shrinks for the first time on record. And the math here is straightforward. There's only two ways for a population to grow. There's something called natural increase, which is births minus deaths. And there's net immigration, which is migrants who arrive minus migrants who leave. Last year, births outnumbered deaths by about 500,000 people. And that straightforwardly means that if net immigration declines by more than 500,000, the US could shrink for the first time in history. And several demographers are, in fact, forecasting that net immigration could be negative 500,000 or in excess of that. And that would mean, essentially that, yes, the US Would. America would, for the first time ever, be a shrinking nation.

[Derek Thompson]

Is the reason that this isn't, like, above the fold, you know, breaking news? Because we don't actually know if this is for sure gonna happen next year. This year.

[Derek Thompson (continued or another expert guest)]

Yeah, we don't know this is gonna happen. So I spoke to William Fry, who's a really renowned demographer and a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution. And I said, you know, do you think it's possible the US Shrinks this year? And he said, quote, it's certainly possible. My bet at the beginning of 2025 was that growth would be positive but very slow. But it's certainly possible that the population could shrink this year, end quote. So one possibility is that I'm wrong and the US doesn't shrink this year. I do think population growth will be very low. But I think most simply, the reason why we aren't talking about this is that I don't think enough people have put together the basic math here. Number one, natural increase, births minus deaths is very low. US Fertility is low. I write a lot about that. And number two, net immigration is low because of all these deportations and all the migrants that the Trump administration is scaring away from even trying to enter the US in the first place.

[Derek Thompson]

You think A lot about shrinking birth rates. We just spent half our show talking about Kilmar Abrego Garcia. And these two very different stories somehow meet in the middle of this thing we're talking about right now, which is where this country's population might be heading. How does something like the story of Kilmar Abrego Garcia tie in to what might be happening right now with the country's population?

[Derek Thompson (continued or another expert guest)]

Well, immigration politics clearly has swung in a pendulum over the last few years. Donald Trump's first term had some very cruel policies.

[Ellie Hoenig]

I'm establishing new vetting measures to keep radical Islamic terrorists out of the United States of America. We don't want them here.

[Derek Thompson]

The executive order also stops the refugee.

[Ellie Hoenig]

Program altogether for all refugees from anywhere.

[Derek Thompson]

For four months, pending review, and installs.

[Ellie Hoenig]

An indefinite ban on Syrian refugees.

[Derek Thompson (continued or another expert guest)]

More than 10,000 asylum seekers at the.

[Derek Thompson]

Southern border have been sent back under the contrary, controversial remain in Mexico policy.

[Ellie Hoenig]

1995 children were taken from their migrant parents at the border. That's an average of 48 kids separated from their families per day.

[Derek Thompson (continued or another expert guest)]

And then Joe Biden responded to those cruel policies by liberalizing immigration and liberalizing asylum law. And that created some years of the highest in migration in American history. I think in 2023, 2024, we had in excess of 2.3, 2.5 million immigrants coming into the U.S. that's extraordinary. And there was a backlash against that migrant surge.

[Ellie Hoenig]

Last week. A lot of people came in from the Congo, a big prison in the Congo in Africa. Welcome to the United States. We don't want to blame immigrants for higher housing prices, but we do want.

[Derek Thompson]

To blame Kamala Harris for letting in.

[Oracle Cloud Infrastructure Advertiser]

Millions of illegal aliens into this country.

[Derek Thompson]

Which does drive up, cost him.

[Derek Thompson (continued or another expert guest)]

And that backlash is partly, not exclusively, but partly responsible for Donald Trump being the president now. And he has swung the pendulum all the way back to not only shutting down the border, but also these extralegal deportations, these, in many cases, illegal deportations, scaring migrants from coming over in the first place, sending ICE into all these cities and rounding up people that he thinks doesn't look, that they think don't look like native born Americans. But what's really historic, I think, is combining that with the fact that, as you said, the fertility rate is low enough that without consistent immigration, the US Is going to shrink very, very soon. Most demographers thought the US wasn't going to shrink until the 2000s, 2000s. Donald Trump's immigration policies might pull forward that moment of American shrinkage. 60 years.

[Derek Thompson]

And you wrote on Your substack about how this is going to affect three essential sectors of American life. Food, housing, health care. Please indulge us.

[Derek Thompson (continued or another expert guest)]

Well, little in life is more fundamental right than food, shelter, and medicine. So it's pretty important that immigrants play a disproportionate role in each. I'm gonna start with farming. Two thirds of agricultural workers are immigrants. Two thirds. So in the absence of new migrant arrivals, farms are gonna struggle in a number of ways. They can struggle to find replacements, and then wages go up for people working in agriculture. That can be really good for folks working in agriculture, but it means higher prices for people who are buying produce, milk, meat at the grocery store. And we're already dealing with years of higher inflation. Housing immigrants account for about 50%, 60% of roofers, painters, drywall installers, plasterers. So you need construction workers, you need immigrants to build houses. And in fact, if you look across the country, 30 to 40% of the construction labor force is foreign born in Florida, in Georgia, in Texas, in Nevada, in California, in New York. Almost all of the largest housing markets are incredibly dependent on foreign labor. So sometimes you hear this thing about, like, you know, I say, you know, America's going to shrink this year, and people say, oh, you know, thank God, you know, everywhere is too crowded. Immigrants are competing for houses, they're competing for jobs. This is gonna be fantastic for the country. Well, guess what happens if you don't have enough people to build houses? You don't have enough houses. What happens to housing prices? They don't go down, they go up because there's a housing shortage.

[Derek Thompson]

And then finally, health care.

[Derek Thompson (continued or another expert guest)]

Yeah, we're an aging nation and we need more clinicians and we need more caregivers. And in a world with low immigration, we're gonna have fewer clinicians and fewer caregivers. This was one of the things that really surprised me most in my reporting. I mean, just how immigrant heavy the American medical labor force is. Foreign born people account for up to 25, 27% of America's physicians and surgeons. One in six people working across the healthcare sector are foreign born. And so if you have an aging country and you have fewer people to care for them, then once again, you could have higher prices and just, you know, longer lines at the hospitals, fewer people to be that home health aide for your sick parent, your sick grandparent or uncle. So once again, I see major, major problems coming in a world where we have fewer immigrants.

[Derek Thompson]

Do you see the Trump administration trying to sort of counter their immigration policies with the effects they may have on the economy with other policies. Are they aware of these pain points?

[Derek Thompson (continued or another expert guest)]

There are definitely folks in the Trump administration that just want an America with fewer people and certainly want an America with fewer non white people. I mean, that's clear. I'm more interested in how Donald Trump will use immigration policy as a weapon. So one of the things I'm most interested in is Donald Trump's sort of theory of economic power. And as far as I can tell, it's something like this. He has a three step formula for everything that he does. Step one, create pain. Step two, offer to remove pain. Step three, demand tribute. How can you use immigration policy in this way? Well, immigration policy that's restrictive is painful for cities and states and companies and industries that rely on immigrants. Right. So you can imagine maybe some hospital or some city, you know, that's maybe struggling with population growth in 2026, 2027, going to Donald Trump and saying, can we, can you please change your immigration policy? And then maybe he'll change immigration policy only if they offer him something in return. So that's one way I think the politics of American stagnation could be quite interesting.

[Derek Thompson]

So do you think if this goes badly in the coming years, if people attribute a negative economic circumstance to these policies, that we could just have another shift and reverse some of what's happened in the past six months?

[Derek Thompson (continued or another expert guest)]

Yeah, I absolutely do. As I wrote in my piece, I think many Americans clearly did not like the era of mass immigration, record high immigration under Joe Biden, but I think they might hate the era of record deportations even more. It's hard, I think, sometimes to really take the temperature of the median voter when it comes to immigration policy. But if I had to do my best, I would say that the median American voter wants positive immigration that feels orderly. And what happens is that immigration politics swings either too far to the left or too far to the right in a way that makes them continually punish whoever the incumbent is in power. And right now, I think we have an immigration policy that is unjust, unfair and incredibly disordered. At least if you're around a place where ICE members are knocking on doors and asking random people to show their papers.

[Derek Thompson]

Or if your name is Kilmar Abrego Garcia.

[Derek Thompson (continued or another expert guest)]

Indeed.

[Derek Thompson]

Derek Thompson. He's also got a podcast. It's called Plain English. Miles Bryan and Rebecca Ybarra made today, Explained today. Aminah Al Saadi edited. Laura Bullard, fact checked. And Matthew, Billy and Andrea Christens daughter mixed. And today's the last day I'll be saying Andrea's name on the show, at least for a while. We call her Andy, by the way. Andy's got a new gig. She's sad to go, and we'll be sad to lose her. But we are not mad at her. In fact, we're happy for her. And we're gonna miss her. Bye, Andy.

[Department of Justice Official]

Elskikar Watak.