Germany's rightward march

Summary

Summary of "Germany's Rightward March" Episode from Today, Explained

Podcast Information:

• Title: Today, Explained
• Host/Author: Vox
• Episode: Germany's Rightward March
• Release Date: February 24, 2025

Today, Explained delves into the recent political shifts in Germany, focusing on the significant election results and the rise of right-wing parties. Hosts Sean Rameswaram and Noel King provide an in-depth analysis of the factors driving these changes and their implications for Germany and the broader European landscape.

---

Election Turnout and Results

Noel King opens the episode by highlighting the unprecedented voter turnout in Germany's recent elections:

Noel King [00:01]: "Germans went to the polls this weekend and it was the biggest election turnout in a generation. More than 8 in 10 eligible voters cast a ballot."

The Conservative CDU party, led by Friedrich Merz, is poised to form the next government. Merz emphasizes the need for traditional democratic parties to take decisive action:

Friedrich Merz [00:25]: "We must be capable of acting again quickly so that we can do the right thing in Germany."

---

Rise of the Alternative for Germany (AfD)

The election saw the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) secure second place with approximately 20% of the vote, marking a significant presence in the Bundestag. Nina Hasa, Deutsche Welle’s chief political correspondent, provides context on the AfD's evolution:

Nina Hasa [05:21]: "They have gone from being an economy-focused, financial policy party to being an anti-immigrant, pro-Russia, pro-China party."

The AfD's transformation and growing support have raised alarms given Germany's historical context and current geopolitical challenges.

---

Key Issues Influencing the Election

Several core issues influenced the election outcome:

1. Immigration: Merz has adopted a more hardline stance on immigration, resonating with voters seeking clarity and control over Germany's borders.

   Nina Hasa [03:56]: "He's adopted a much more hardline stance on immigration, for example, and that has been one of the key issues for him in this election campaign."

2. Economy: Germany's sluggish economy prompted voters to seek change, with the Conservatives promising economic revitalization.

   Nina Hasa [04:09]: "They want the German economy to get going again. Germany's economy is very sluggish at the moment and these were the core topics that the Conservatives focused on and won."

3. Foreign Policy and Ukraine: The government's handling of Russia's invasion of Ukraine and the subsequent challenges played a pivotal role.

   Nina Hasa [04:06]: "Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine... the conservatives used that to their advantage."

---

Implications of the AfD's Success

The AfD's rise to the second-largest party in the Bundestag carries significant implications:

• Legislative Influence: As the second-strongest group, the AfD can influence committee agendas and parliamentary debates.

  Nina Hasa [09:22]: "They're now the second strongest political group in the parliament... shaping the debate in Parliament."

• Potential Constitutional Challenges: With the AfD and other opposition parties, there exists the possibility of blocking fundamental changes to Germany's constitution.

  Nina Hasa [09:22]: "The AfD, together with the far left, Die Linke, can now block that."

Despite their influence, Merz has firmly stated that the AfD will not be part of the governing coalition:

Nina Hasa [11:01]: "The AfD is not going to get into government... all the democratic parties have ruled out collaborating with them."

---

Controversial Endorsements and External Influences

The episode discusses controversial support for the AfD from notable figures:

• Elon Musk: The unelected Vice President of the United States expressed support for the AfD, enhancing their visibility.

  Nina Hasa [07:36]: "They were hoping for an unstable German government under Friedrich Merz... they have their eyes on 2029."

• J.D. Vance: America's elected Vice President publicly criticized Germany's approach to the AfD, advocating for broader free speech protections.

  J.D. Vance [20:55]: "Where police have carried out raids against citizens suspected of posting anti-feminist comments online as part of combating misogyny on the Internet."

These endorsements have sparked debate about the intersection of free speech and the rise of far-right movements in Germany.

---

Responses to External Criticism

Constanze Stelzenmuller, Director at the Brookings Institution, provides insights into the German perspective on external criticisms:

Constanze Stelzenmuller [17:50]: "Germany has very special rules for prohibiting parties and for hate speech because of its history... it was necessary to prescribe statements that declared allegiance to an ideology that had not just been toxic, but literally murderous."

She explains the German legal framework aimed at preventing the resurgence of extremist ideologies, emphasizing the distinction from the American constitutional emphasis on free speech.

---

Future Outlook for Germany

Looking ahead, Nina Hasa outlines the challenges Friedrich Merz faces in forming a stable government:

Nina Hasa [12:01]: "He has a lot of challenges ahead of him."

Additionally, the presence of the AfD ensures that Germany's political landscape will remain complex, with potential for increased polarization and legislative hurdles.

---

Conclusion

The episode "Germany's Rightward March" provides a comprehensive overview of the shifting political dynamics in Germany, highlighting the rise of the AfD and its implications for both national and international politics. Through expert analysis and direct quotes from key figures, Today, Explained offers listeners a nuanced understanding of the factors driving Germany's current political climate and the challenges that lie ahead.

---

Notable Quotes:

• Friedrich Merz [00:25]: "We must be capable of acting again quickly so that we can do the right thing in Germany."

• Nina Hasa [05:21]: "They have gone from being an economy-focused, financial policy party to being an anti-immigrant, pro-Russia, pro-China party."

• J.D. Vance [20:55]: "Where police have carried out raids against citizens suspected of posting anti-feminist comments online as part of combating misogyny on the Internet."

• Constanze Stelzenmuller [17:50]: "Germany has very special rules for prohibiting parties and for hate speech because of its history."

---

This summary encapsulates the key discussions, insights, and conclusions from the episode, providing a clear and detailed overview for those who have not listened to the original podcast.

Transcript

[Noel King]

Germans went to the polls this weekend and how it was the biggest election turnout in a Generation. More than 8 in 10 eligible voters cast a ballot. Friedrich Merz, a conservative from the CDU party, is on track to be chancellor. He said today it's time for traditional democratic parties to start getting things done.

[Nina Hasa]

The world won't wait for us.

[Constanze Stelzenmuller]

It won't wait for long, drawn out coalition negotiations.

[Friedrich Merz]

We must be capable of acting again quickly so that we can do the right thing in Germany, so that we're.

[Noel King]

The party that came in second place. The Alternative for Germany, or AfD, is from the far right fringe. So it is perhaps inevitable that America's unelected Vice president Elon Musk has spoken in support of the AfD, but so has America's elected vice president, J.D. vance. Coming up on TODAY Explained, the transatlantic alliance no one wants.

[Claire White]

Support for Today Explained comes from Addio. Addio is attio. What do they do? It's an AI native CRM built for the next era of companies. They say it's powerful data structure, adapts to your business model, syncs in all your contacts in minutes and enriches everything with actionable data. You can go to addio.com todayexplained and you'll get 15% off your first year. That's a T T I O.com todayexplained.

[Constanze Stelzenmuller]

Thumbtack presents the ins and outs of caring for your home. Out procrastination, putting it off, kicking the can down the road in plans and guides that make it easy to get home projects done out carpet in the bathroom. Like why? In knowing what to do, when to do it and who to hire. Start caring for your home with confidence. Download thumbtack today.

[Noel King]

This is TODAY explained Noel King here with Nina Hasa. Nina is chief political correspondent for Deutsche Welle. That's Germany's international broadcaster. All right, so Nina, big electoral election in Germany this weekend. What's the headline today?

[Nina Hasa]

The headline is that the conservatives swept the Social Democrats out of the chancellery and we will see a new German government in a couple of weeks time that is going to be led by the conservatives in a coalition probably with the Social Democrats and that is still going to be a pro European, a centrist government facing lots and lots of challenges. Also the headline underneath is that for the very first time in a national poll, a far right party, the AfD, managed to get one in five German voters to vote for them.

[Noel King]

Who is the new chancellor?

[Nina Hasa]

The new chancellor is a man called Friedrich Merz. He's a Grandfather. He is not an unknown figure. He entered politics in the 1990s and he was then swept out of political power by a certain Angela Merkel from his same party. He then re entered politics when Angela Merkel left and he has decided to shape the Conservatives in a way that he sees fit to deal with the current challenges. He was always a fierce critic of Angela Merkel's open door policy.

[Friedrich Merz]

Our heart is big, but our ability is limited. I wish someone had said that in 2015 or 16, this can't happen again.

[Nina Hasa]

So he's adopted a much more hardline stance on immigration, for example, and that has been one of the key issues for him in this election campaign.

[Noel King]

What were the other issues that led the conservatives to do so?

[Nina Hasa]

Well, this time the other issues were that Germans showed a lot of desire for change, big change. The current government had started out on a progressive, on a liberal agenda. And then Russia launched its full scale invasion of Ukraine. So they had to make a lot of very tough decisions. They had to try and keep the country together at very, very challenging times. So we had a lot of political infighting and the conservatives at the time were the biggest opposition power. So they used that to their advantage to essentially this government is overwhelmed and we're going to be the ones dealing with all the desire for change that Germans are expressing. They want more clarity when it comes to immigration. They want the German economy to get going again. Germany's economy is very sluggish at the moment and these were the core topics that the Conservatives focused on and won.

[Noel King]

All right, so immigration, the economy, Ukraine. That sounds familiar. This party that came in second, the AfD, tell me about it. Where does it come from?

[Nina Hasa]

The AfD is called Alternative for Germany. That's the name that they've given themselves. They're a fairly young party. They were founded just over 10 years ago. They started off on a platform that was EU skeptic that wanted to get out of the euro, the common currency that we have here in Europe. And over the years they have radicalized.

[Friedrich Merz]

Over the past decade, Germany has faced a wave of far right violence and plots against Jews, Muslims, immigrants and politicians. At the same time, support has soared for the far right party, the AfD, Alternative for Deutschland. They don't always talk about Islamification anymore, they talk about migration. But when you ask them what they mean, they quite clearly mean migration from Muslim countries.

[Nina Hasa]

They have gone from being an economy focused, financial policy focused party to being an anti immigrant, pro Russia, pro China party. And that is something where lots of people here in Germany are saying this would shake up the fundamental pillars of the liberal democratic system that we have here in this country. They are under observation by Germany's intelligence agencies.

[Friedrich Merz]

The top court here in Germany has ruled that the far right alternative for Germany party is a potential threat to democracy.

[J.D. Vance]

Journalists gathered evidence that AfD members and Neo Nazis met in secret to discuss.

[Friedrich Merz]

What far right thinkers call a re migration project. In other words, a plan to expel millions of people.

[Nina Hasa]

They have people in their ranks that have very close ties to the Kremlin. They have a leading figure in the east of the country who is a history teacher but says that Germany needs to move on and stop this whining about this short period of time when this thing called the Holocaust happens.

[Friedrich Merz]

He criticized Berlin's Holocaust memorial, arguing that Germany should reverse the wait. It remembered its past. Prosecutors said his use of the phrase everything for Germany to a crowd of AfD supporters was illegal, effectively repeating the slogan of Adolf Hitler's Stormtroopers.

[Nina Hasa]

And that is of course something that has made a lot of alarm bells ring here in Germany, given our history, where many people feel reminded of just how quickly populism can lead to real life fascism. Having said all that, the AfD say of themselves that they are libertarian, conservative, they got a big push in this election campaign by Elon Musk. I'm very excited for the IFD and I think you're really the best hope for Germany. He held an hour long chat with their co leader Alice Weidel and gave them a lot of visibility on his own platforms. Okay, thank you very much Elon for having me and to give us the.

[Hoyte Ecklert]

Opportunity to openly speak about different matters. Let me just. Can you hear me?

[J.D. Vance]

I can, yes.

[Hoyte Ecklert]

Perfect, perfect.

[Nina Hasa]

So they have definitely benefited from that. They've also managed to be very present in Market Square. So they're very visible, they're very good at describing problems. They haven't offered many workable solutions when you look at the details in their programs. But what they've also done is they've convinced a lot of working class people to vote for them instead of the Social Democrats.

[Noel King]

What does their second place Finnish mean? Does this mean that they now help write German law? That the Conservative Party, that one has to deal with them on a regular basis? Like how much power do they have coming in where they did?

[Nina Hasa]

They're now the second strongest political group in the parliament. And that means that they have certain privileges when it comes to appointing the chair people of the committees, for example. So traditionally the biggest opposition group, which is in this case the AfD, they lead the Budget Committee, so they can influence the agenda of committee meetings. Then the AFD also gets a lot of time to address Parliament as the second biggest group in Parliament. So shaping the debate in Parliament, we'll hear a lot more from them. And last, not least, we have a system here in this country where you have a blocking minority for certain fundamental changes to our basic law. And the AfD alone cannot do that at the moment. But if, for example, the current government wanted to make fundamental changes to the constitution to allow for more spending in support of Ukraine, then they would have to change the constitution, because that is currently a part of our constitution. And the AfD, together with the far left, Die Linke that also made it into Bundestag, can now block that.

[Noel King]

Your new chancellor, Mr. Merz, has already spoken this morning. What is he saying about working with these parties, primarily the AfD?

[Nina Hasa]

The AfD is not going to get into government. I think that is a very important message to send also to listeners in the US that it's considered way too far right by all the other democratic parties. And the Conservatives have therefore ruled out collaborating with them. That is known as the firewall here, that the firewall still stands because of our country's history. Now, the AfD are also very clear that they were aware that they wouldn't enter government this time, but they're hoping for an unstable German government under Friedrich Merz now in the next couple of years. And they have their eyes on 2029 when they say that their positions will become so normalized that they might then actually enter government, if not the Chancellery.

[Noel King]

What do these results mean for Germany over the next year or two?

[Nina Hasa]

The results mean that Friedrich Merz will have to enter coalition negotiations very quickly with the Social Democrats and very quickly come to a good deal with so that he can form a stable government. He has a lot of challenges ahead of him.

[Friedrich Merz]

This is really the last warning to.

[Noel King]

The political parties of the democratic center in Germany to come to joint solutions.

[Nina Hasa]

So he said he needs to get the government together and in a stable way so that Germany can answer and give proper solutions to all these geopolitical challenges that we're facing. Because at the moment, the feeling is that liberal democracy in Europe is under threat from Russia. We're considered to be in a hybrid war with Russia and also increasingly from the United States new administration.

[Noel King]

Nina Hasa of Deutsche WELLE Vice President J.D. vance shocked Germans earlier this month in Munich when he suggested that their posture toward the AfD violates the principles of free speech. What's he talking about? Stay.

[Claire White]

Support for Today Explained comes from Quince who doesn't like a little luxury every once in a while I say to myself when I buy the nice tortillas. But sometimes, as much as people love to indulge in some of the finer things in life, it can do a real number on their wallets. But not with Quince, my friends. With Quince they say you can get luxury essentials at affordable prices like 100% Mongolian cashmere sweaters, washable silk tops and dresses, organic cotton sweaters and 14 karat gold jewelry. Hello. All priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands. Claire White has tried Quince.

[Nina Hasa]

I recently received the Mongolian cashmere cardigan sweater from Quince. It's lightweight while still keeping me warm. It's super soft while still having a really high quality feel and I've been wearing it a lot. It's wonderful. Genuinely.

[Claire White]

You can give yourself the luxury you deserve. With Quince. You can go to quince.com explained for free for free shipping on your orders and 365 day returns. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E.com explained to get free shipping and 365 day returns, quints.com explained.

[Noel King]

Support for today Explained is brought to you by Wondery and their new show, Scam Factory. You've probably received a text or an email that you knew was a scam and you brushed it off as just another annoying message. Sometimes, though, the stranger on the other side of that message is being forced to send it against their will. Huh? Wondry presents this new true crime podcast that tells the story of those trapped inside scam factories, heavily guarded compounds on the other side of the world where people are forced to scam others. I'm probably gonna listen to this told through the eyes of one family's harrowing account of the sleepless nights and dangerous rescue attempts trying to escape one of these compounds, Scam factories and explosive new podcast that exposes what they say is a multi billion dollar criminal empire operating in plain sight. You can follow Scam Factory on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcast. You can listen to all the episodes of Scam Factory early and ad free right now by joining Wondery.

[Nina Hasa]

Plus.

[H]

Support for this show is brought to you by Noom. Weight loss isn't about getting a quick fix, it's about lasting change. That's where Noom comes in, offering a complete science backed approach to sustainable weight loss by pairing GLP1 medications with their proven behavior change program. NOOM has already helped millions achieve their goals and now it's your turn. With Noom GLP1, you can get access to a doctor, a coach and a supportive community all from within the Noom app on your phone. You can ask your care team anything regarding your plan and get support with medication and side effect management. Plus, NoomGLP1 comes with companion, your guide to better and more sustainable GLP weight loss. Companion even comes with Muscle Defense, a program to help you keep the muscle and lose the fat. Noom GLP1 starts at $149 and is delivered to your door in seven days. Start your GLP1 journey today at Noom.com that's n o o m dot com the smart way to lose weight. Not all customers will medically qualify for prescription medications. Compounded medications are not reviewed by the FDA for safety, efficacy or quality.

[Hoyte Ecklert]

You heard Hoyte Ecklert Today explained My name is Constanze Stilzenmuller and I apologize. That's the name I was born with. It's beautiful and I direct the center on the US and Europe at the Brookings Institution, a Washington think tank.

[Noel King]

Constanza Germany has gone so far as to talk about banning the far right AfD, which banning a political party is a really serious thing in a democracy. And I want to get a sense of why so many Germans are so concerned about the AfD. Is it something that this group is doing or is it something that they're saying?

[Hoyte Ecklert]

Both of those things.

[Noel King]

Okay, go ahead.

[Hoyte Ecklert]

So I mean, at the risk of stating the obvious, Germany has very special rules for prohibiting parties and for hate speech because of its history, because of National Socialism that was in power in Germany between 1933 and 1945 and that led to the Holocaust and to World War II. But to answer your question about why the AfD has even gotten into the crosshairs of these legal rules, it is that its members and its leadership over the past decade have repeatedly made overt or barely veiled references to Nazi slogans and Nazi ideas. They cooperate with extreme right and neo Nazi movements. They ally themselves with parties in the rest of Europe and also in the European Parliament that are overtly neo Nazi. As for prosecuting hate speech for the longest time after 1949, throughout the cold War, and much of the decades after reunification in 1990, there were always hard right movements, there were always neo Nazi movements, but they were socially and politically fringe. So it has only been the rise of the AfD in the past decade that has led to the broadening of the spectrum of what is sayable in Germany. Right. What is socially and politically possible. And therefore there's literally been more hate speech in the public domain that has received the attention of not just other political competitors, but also the courts. I will just say this, that the American constitutional order has always privileged freedom of speech in ways that the Germans after 1949, felt that they could not do because of the horrific experience that they had just gone through. Right. You have never had a holocaust. You have never started a world war. We did. And we felt that it was necessary to prescribe statements that declared allegiance to an ideology that had not just been toxic, but literally murderous.

[Noel King]

Earlier this month, Vice President J.D. vance got on stage at the Munich Security Conference and he talked about laws throughout Europe that he says restrict free speech.

[J.D. Vance]

I look to Brussels, where EU commissars warn citizens that they intend to shut down social media during times of civil unrest the moment they spot what they've judged to be, quote, hateful content.

[Noel King]

And then he talks specifically about Germany.

[J.D. Vance]

Where police have carried out raids against citizens suspected of posting anti feminist comments online as part of, quote, combating misogyny on the Internet.

[Noel King]

Here, he says he believes that allowing citizens to speak their mind will make them stronger.

[J.D. Vance]

Which of course brings us back to Munich, where the organizers of this very conference have banned lawmakers representing populist parties on both the left and the right from participating in these conversations. Now, again, we don't have to agree with everything or anything that people say, but when people represent, when political leaders represent an important constituency, it is incumbent upon us to at least participate in dialogue with them.

[Noel King]

Vice President Vance never said afd, but it seemed very clear to everyone in Germany that he was talking about the AfD. Is that right?

[Hoyte Ecklert]

Well, I could say that I was there in Munich. I wasn't in the exact same room. I was in the overflow of the overflow. Because that speech had been awaited with some, I think, a mixture of anticipation and apprehension is fair to say by everybody there. And one of the things that was so startling about it was that everybody had expected a speech about foreign and security policy, about the future of NATO, about the peace negotiations with Ukraine and Russia. And instead of which the Vice President said the greatest threat to security in Europe was not external, but the threat to freedom and democracy.

[J.D. Vance]

The threat that I worry the most about vis a vis Europe is not Russia, it's not China, it's not any other external actor. And what I worry about is the threat, threat from within, the retreat of Europe from some of its Most fundamental values, values shared with the United States of America.

[Hoyte Ecklert]

That's something with which I think 95% of those present at the conference and listening to him would have begged to differ. I mean, it's extraordinary. We are in the middle of a war in Europe, right? Where the Russians are killing people every day on the front line and by bombarding Ukrainian cities every day, and where they are also committing acts of disinformation and sabotage across Europe, including in my own country, Germany, every day. To suggest that a public debate about prohibiting the AFT or other extremist parties or the prosecution of hate speech, to suggest that that is somehow a greater threat to security in Europe, left people absolutely flabbergasted. It left me flabbergasted. You could literally see and hear the shockwaves ripple through the room because it's never happened that an American senior official, apart obviously from the efforts made by Elon Musk, who is, after all not an elected official, that an American senior official had in front of a European audience, espoused parties that seek to subvert the German constitution. Again, you're right that he didn't mention the AfD, but it was pretty clear whom he meant. And the people in the room and the people at the Munich Security Conference and public commentary in Germany and elsewhere in Europe, I think completely correctly read that as an endorsement of the AfD. And by the way, the AfD is problematic not just because it references in a positive manner Germany's Nazi history. It is also problematic because it is pro Putin, it is pro China, it is against the European Union, it is against NATO. And I think it should also interest American listeners that it is also very anti American. Right. It's just now getting so much support from senior American figures that it is letting that part of its platform drop under the counter. And so there were multiple genuinely offensive aspects of that speech. But if the Vice President was trying to help the AfD gain a greater vote share, it hasn't worked. Again, consider the following. The AFD is stuck at around 20%, which is exactly where it was in the polls before Elon Musk and the Vice President began their efforts to help it. I will say this, that while I am relieved that the AfD did not experience a triumphal result, it remains in second place and none of the Democratic parties will coalition with it. And my greatest concern is that we could see a next German government that has to govern with a volatile and perhaps fragile three way coalition, actively opposed by a very strong anti system right wing party, the AfD. And which in turn finds vocal and determined supporters not just in Moscow and in Beijing, but also in Washington, D.C.

[Noel King]

Constanze Stelzenmuller. She's director of the center on the U.S. and Europe at the Brookings Institution. Travis Larchuk produced today's show with help from Avishai Artsy. Amina Elsadi is our editor. Patrick Boyd and Andrea Christen's daughter engineered Laura Bullard and Victoria Chamberlain. Check the facts. I'm Noel King. It's Today Explained.