
Conspiracy theories flooded the internet after a shooting at the White House Correspondents' Dinner. What used to be fringe is now a default reaction.
Loading summary
Noel King
Acting Attorney General Todd Blanch offered a bit of a reality check about the shooting at the White House Correspondent's Dinner. The President, he said, was not really in danger.
Todd Blanche
This man was a floor above the ballroom with hundreds of federal agents between him and the President of the United States.
Noel King
The worst never came to pass.
Todd Blanche
Law enforcement did not fail. They did exactly what they are trained
Noel King
to do, solid Attorney Generaling. Then late yesterday, Blanche filed a request ask asking a federal judge to overturn a previous ruling and allow President Trump to build a ballroom. Wait, what? How did this get to be about the ballroom? Today on Today Explained from Vox fallout from this weekend's attempted assassination. The good, the bad, the weird, the conspiracies, all of it up ahead.
Todd Blanche
It's drone proof.
Molly Olmstead
It's bulletproof glass. We need the ballroom. If you need more evidence of why this feels staged, everyone is talking about the ballroom.
Sponsor Voice
Support for the show comes from Shopify. Every worthwhile journey starts with a handful of what ifs. But one day you'll be able to look back and realize that all those what ifs were small steps towards turning your dream into a thriving business. Shopify can help you get there. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10% of all e commerce in the US join them and turn those what ifs into With Shopify today up for your $1 per month trial today at shopify.com VoxBusiness go to shopify.com VoxBusiness that's shopify.com VoxBusiness.
Todd Blanche
This message comes from Betterment. Betterment. Stan Egan talks about tax loss harvesting. Tax loss harvesting is a tax management strategy. When you have a position that's gone down over time, we intentionally sell out of it to realize a loss, which we then say to the irs, hey, we lost money. You get to use that to offset your ordinary income every year, decreasing your tax burden. Investing involves risk performance, not guaranteed. Betterment does not offer tax advice. TLH may not be suitable for all customers. Learn more@betterment.com TLH-terms
Molly Olmstead
this is today Explained.
Noel King
Molly Olmsted is a staff writer at Slate. She writes about the Right. Okay, so this weekend we White House Correspondent's dinner is underway. Shooter enters the Hilton, doesn't make it past security. No one is killed. Shooter's apprehended, the Internet reacts. And what's the reaction?
Guest Expert/Analyst
It was instantaneously. I would say skeptical in a way that was actually kind of remarkable. I mean, I know that I was fielding text messages from people asking me if it Was staged within minutes of it happening. You know, if you look, it was happening on the parts of the Internet, the parts social media that. That are dominated by liberal voices. A lot of people are not buying that this assassination attempt was legit.
Molly Olmstead
I mean, Trump is known to stage things for his benefit.
Todd Blanche
I don't believe in that whole White House correspondent shooting event going on. Don't believe in it. I think it's all staged.
Guest Expert/Analyst
They didn't even wait for evidence, really. It just was kind of an almost gut reaction that people had based on the idea that there was an attack against the president and that there had been several of them before.
Noel King
It's not entirely unexpected, but it does make you wonder about the people who say it was staged. Okay, gotcha. Why? Why do they think it was staged?
Guest Expert/Analyst
Well, there is what they'll tell you, which is that, you know, Trump's facial expression doesn't look like it reflects real fear. Trump clearly smirks when shots are fired.
Paula Reid
No panic, no fear. He knew it was coming.
Guest Expert/Analyst
Or that there was something odd to how Caroline Levitt was saying there were gonna be shots fired tonight, which she meant in a purely rhetorical way. There will be some shots fired tonight in the room. Then there were people who sort of couldn't believe that a gunman would be able to get into the hotel.
Todd Blanche
All right, I'll be that guy. Where did the agents shoot him? What stopped him?
Molly Olmstead
Where's the blood?
Todd Blanche
Why is his supratrochlear vein not indicating that he is in any pain or distress? Is this another staged event?
Guest Expert/Analyst
All of these things sort of reflect, I think, a lack of understanding, maybe about how security operations work or about how just humans react to times of crises and just sort of the randomness of life.
Noel King
Why would President Trump stage this? What are people saying to that question?
Guest Expert/Analyst
The dominant answer was that President Trump was using this to get support for his White House ballroom. There were two real reasons for this. One was that the President himself made the argument afterwards that this showed why they needed a secure ballroom.
Paula Reid
It's not a safe ballroom. I'm building a safe ballroom.
Guest Expert/Analyst
And the second reason was that a bunch of MAGA influencers all said essentially the same thing. After last night, I think it's safe
Paula Reid
to say that building the ballroom at the White House is an absolute must.
Molly Olmstead
Build the ballroom would be real nice
Todd Blanche
if the White House had its own ballroom. Huh?
Guest Expert/Analyst
It's actually not remarkable. It's how the system MAGA influencer system works. But to anyone who is less familiar with it, it seemed really Suspicious. That's why Trump wanting the ballroom and staging his own assassination attempt to get the ballroom became the dominant narrative. One interesting thing, and one thing that makes right wing conspiracy different from left wing conspiracy theories is that the accounts that are doing it are, for the most part, not actually that big. They'll have lots of followers, but they won't be personalities that are really known into themselves. So with the right, you have these, you know, mega influencers, huge people who have huge podcasts who will be saying these things. With the left, it's sort of these like, lib accounts and they will post either to try and provoke some sort of anti Trump outrage or as a sort of engagement bait, something to put encourage discussion. So before saying like, I believe this was staged, they would poll their followers to be like, do you think this was staged? Which was so clearly an attempt to get their own engagement for their own financial gain. And I also have to say here that I don't know, I don't really have a way of knowing of how many of these are bots, because again, they are not really known people. But there are a lot of just strivers in this space that are clearly pushing this.
Noel King
What do you mean by strivers? That's a great word, I think.
Guest Expert/Analyst
I mean, people who aspire to the kind of influence that the right wing influencers have, the people who want to take up their own space within the movement and they are really trying to get power influence and are really just not able to carve out their own space with quite the success that a lot of these, like, big name conservatives are able to do.
Noel King
You noted that it was like minutes after the shooting happened that the online conversation becomes conspiratorial. Were you surprised it happened that fast?
Guest Expert/Analyst
I mean, this may be a little naive of me, but I was, I was a little surprised. I did expect it to happen because, I mean, we live in this world where this is how people are thinking. I mean, especially after the shooting in Butler, there was something very dramatic about that assassination attempt.
Molly Olmstead
The gunshots erupting during his rally in
Todd Blanche
Butler, Pennsylvania,
Molly Olmstead
the microphone picking up the cries of people yelling to get down.
Paula Reid
It was
Todd Blanche
a crazy moment.
Paula Reid
You know, I went on to win the presidency.
Guest Expert/Analyst
I don't know if that had anything
Paula Reid
to do with it, to be honest.
Guest Expert/Analyst
There was just such drama to it that it lent itself to people sort of going to the most fantastical place.
Molly Olmstead
Just admit you staged it in Butler.
Paula Reid
So right after there are gunshots fired at a campaign event, Trump's team's first reaction is to go get the photographers. Basically.
Noel King
It all looks really suspicious and really bizarre.
Guest Expert/Analyst
So they're primed to see another assassination attempt as a hoax. This is just the waters we're in now. Everyone's a conspiracy theorist.
Noel King
The US Fell victim to conspiracy mindedness. I don't know. Sometime in the last 10 years is what I would say is where I would place. Doesn't feel like this is anything new. It feels like this is a continuation. But that's me. I don't cover this and you do it. Is something new happening this week in the last 72 hours?
Guest Expert/Analyst
I do feel like there is something that's new here. These conspiracy theories used to be largely the purview of the right. I think in the second Trump administration, really, we have seen an explosion of this kind of thinking into the left, but also in a way that has escaped the normal boundaries of partisan thinking. So you've seen offshoots within the MAGA movement of people who are thinking in this conspiracy theory way in a way that does not actually benefit President Trump, in a way that is actually puts them at odds with other parts of the conservative movement, the annals of history.
Paula Reid
I think within them, you will be relegated to a philosophical discussion, the madness of President Trump. A lot of people who really like Trump are very disappointed in Trump. More than disappointed, feel betrayed.
Guest Expert/Analyst
And you see this with people on the left who previously felt that they were in opposition to the conspiracy thinking that drove, say, QAnon, but now they are actively engaging in this themselves.
Noel King
If I were defending the conspiracy theorizing from the left, here's what I might say. Tell me what you think. President Trump and members of his administration lie constantly. Why should we believe their recounting of events? Why shouldn't we be convinced that if they're gonna lie to us about, I don't know, immigration and tariffs, they wouldn't also lie about an assassination attempt.
Guest Expert/Analyst
I totally do think that if we're talking about something like war crimes or, you know, financial shenanigans or anything really, that should be met with suspicion. And I think this is also a reporter's obligation to do so as well. I do think, though, that when it comes to these sort of complex conspiracy theories, there has to be something to base it on. And when it comes to Butler, Pennsylvania's assassination attempt, when it comes to this incident, there's really nothing. I mean, there were so many journalists who were in that room, not where the incident occurred, because that was outside of the White House correspondent's dinner, but they were around. If there was some sort of indication that there was some sort of malfeasance. I mean, I think we should absolutely pursue it, but this is based off of nothing but speculation. I think that jumping to that is ultimately harmful for our democracy. We would not be working off of a shared reality in any way that lets us get to any sort of practical solutions for any of the myriad problems our country faces. We can't work in a system in which we all just treat each other as the most fantastical, extreme version of ourselves. So trust Donald Trump? Absolutely not. But jump to think that there's some sort of convoluted, strange thing going on. That's that's not healthy either.
Noel King
Molly Olmstead is a staff writer at Slate. When we return, Todd Blanche, the acting attorney general, acts.
Molly Olmstead
Support for the show today comes from Quince Spring Cleaning. It takes many forms. I might do some this weekend. Deep cleaning the kitchen. Done it already. Fixing broken appliances. Done it already. And the classic cleaning out the closet. That's what I'm gonna do this weekend. So if this season you're ready to reset your wardrobe with some quality, long lasting pieces, you might want to check out Quince. Quince says they make high quality wardrobe stap using premium fabrics like 100% European linen, organic cotton and super soft denim. Super soft denim with style starting around $50. They say their spring pieces are lightweight, breathable and effortless. That kind of thing you can throw on and instantly look put together. That's the dream. Our colleague Nisha Sheetal has tried Quints.
Guest Expert/Analyst
I love wearing a sweater and jeans. I've seen similar styles of sweaters from higher end brands for double, triple or or even more the price. So they do feel like really, really
Noel King
good value for your money.
Guest Expert/Analyst
And the style and the quality feel similar to much more expensive comparable brands.
Molly Olmstead
You can refresh your spring wardrobe with quince go to quince.com explained for free shipping and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada. Hi go to q U-I-N-C e.com explained for free shipping and 375 data returns. Quince.com explained. Support for the show comes from Shopify. Every thriving business starts with a series of what if questions. Shopify says there's what if I fail, but you should also consider this one what if you don't? I like that thinking glass half full kind of thinking. There's only one way to find out and you can make it happen with help from Shopify. They say millions of businesses around the world rely on Shopify for e Commerce from businesses just getting started to household name brands. It can help you with everything from payment processing to analytics to website design. You can choose from hundreds of templates to create great looking websites. Their email and marketing tools can help you get your name out there and stay connected with customers. And if you ever need help, Shopify's 247 award winning customer support has got your back. I like the 24 7. That's nice. You can turn those what ifs into a thriving business with Shopify today. You can sign up for your $1 per month trial today at shopify.com explained. You go to shopify.com explained. That's shopify.com explained. Support for Today explained comes from 1-800-Flowers and who doesn't Love Flowers?
Guest Expert/Analyst
If you're planning to send your mom
Molly Olmstead
flowers this Mother's Day, you might want a little help choosing the perfect bouquet to show her how much she means to you. 1-800-Flowers says that for more than 5050 years they've been helping people send beautiful arrangements by perfecting the details that matter most. And if you're Prone to procrastination, 1-800-Flowers says that they've been saving their customers with same day delivery for years. Even if May 9th snuck up on you, they can still make May 10th count. That's a nice thought. Claire White did you try flowers?
Guest Expert/Analyst
I took advantage of 1-800-FLowers. Buy a dozen roses and get a dozen free deal for this Mother's Day. I sent some over to my mom. They were beautiful, really well packaged and fresh, bright spring roses. And now I've got a bouquet for myself which is just great to have.
Molly Olmstead
Mother's Day is Sunday, May 10, just FYI. And bouquets are selling out fast. They say you don't have to wait to claim your double roses offer before they're gone. You can visit 1-800-flowers.com explained. That's 1,800flowers.com explained 1,800flowers.comexplained 1,800-flowers, a website.
Guest Expert/Analyst
This is Today Explained.
Noel King
Paula Reid is the chief legal affairs correspondent for cnn. She was at the White House Correspondent's Dinner and was also watching the aftermath, in part to see how the acting head of the DOJ would conduct himself.
Paula Reid
It was interesting when the President addressed the nation late Saturday, he was flanked by his top two Justice Department officials, Todd Bl and Cash Patel. Todd is the acting Attorney General, and he came out and did what you would expect the nation's top law enforcement official to do. Tell us what they know about what's
Todd Blanche
going on there will be multiple charges surrounding the shooting around the possession of firearms and anything else that we can get get on this guy detail exactly
Paula Reid
what steps they were taking and what we can expect next.
Todd Blanche
Justice will be served.
Paula Reid
Todd Blanche has actually I think really met the moment perfectly, especially in the larger context of my reporting on for Attorney General because what happened Saturday night, this is the first thing that has sort of happened to the Blanch Justice Department as opposed to being, you know, something they've done or what we've seen throughout the Trump Justice Department which has been a lot of self inflicted controversies, the handling of the Epstein files.
Guest Expert/Analyst
Please raise your hands if you have still not been able to meet with this Department of Justice. Please know for the record that every single survivor has raised their hand the controversial firings.
Todd Blanche
Well, the Justice Department issued a wave
Molly Olmstead
of firings late last week and into the weekend.
Todd Blanche
In fact, more than 20 of those
Molly Olmstead
employees were people who worked on former
Todd Blanche
special counsel Jack Smith's cases against President Donald Trump.
Noel King
They are gone, they've been let go.
Paula Reid
Decisions they've made around cases trying to charge people, that's all self inflicted. But when you're the Attorney General, you're going to deal with a Boston Marathon bombing or a San Bernardino shooting. This is not quite of that level, but it is certainly a massive event that they have to respond to. So seeing how you respond to something that was not of your own doing, I mean that is a real test for the Attorney General. And so far it's been a textbook response from him. He certainly can't afford to mess this up given the significance. But we heard from him immediately after the event with the President. He did the Sunday shows, he took questions.
Noel King
Was it safe to have the President, cabinet officials, members of Congress, the first
Guest Expert/Analyst
lady, the Vice President, such high ranking
Noel King
officials all in the same room at the same time?
Todd Blanche
Yes, of course we're not gonna stop living, we're not gonna start doing our jobs, we're not gonna start stop all the work that we're doing every day.
Paula Reid
And then we heard from him again after Monday's arraignment.
Noel King
So Todd Blanche is new to this job. Pam Bondi of course was fired earlier this month.
Paula Reid
The dow is over 50,000 thousand right now.
Noel King
Tell me about how Todd Blanche ended up in this job. Where does he come from?
Paula Reid
So I'm gonna push back on the idea that he's new to the job because he is officially, yes, the Acting Attorney General. Now prior he was the Deputy Attorney General. Usually the difference there is the Deputy Attorney General runs this sprawling agency in all the different U.S. attorney's offices and components, the FBI and the marshals, it's the boss running the day to day. Behind the scenes, the Attorney General is usually more the front facing figurehead. But with Pam Bondi and her repeated stumbles, public stumbles over the Epstein files and other matters, Todd took on a more public facing role. He was also sort of a bigger presence behind the scenes. It was constantly in contact with the White House, with Stephen Miller, with the President. Pam Bondi talked to the President as well. But Todd really, in many ways was doing a lot of this job. So he started out, he was actually a federal prosecutor at the Southern District of New York for a long time. Then he went into white collar practice and then he joined the Trump leg around 2023, when Trump was in the middle of those four major legal cases. And Todd worked on the two federal cases brought by Jack Smith.
Molly Olmstead
The attack on our Nation's Capitol on
Paula Reid
January 6, 2021, was an unprecedented assault
Molly Olmstead
on the seat of American democracy.
Noel King
In a post on Truth Social, Trump said he had been indicted, quote, over what he called the boxes hoax. That is a reference to the boxes found at his Mar A Lago estate by the FBI last August, which contained classified.
Paula Reid
They also represented him in New York on the hush money case. But what really distinguished Todd Blanche is that Trump lawyers come and go. I mean, I've probably talked to like 40 of them over the past decade, right? They come, they go. They have trouble with the client, they have trouble with some of the people behind the scenes, the spotlight, the cases. Todd flourished. Yes, his client was convicted in New York, but he kept him out of jail. And ultimately their legal strategy on the federal cases resulted in Trump never facing trial on either one of those. In Trump's eyes, Todd Blanche is the guy who kept him out of jail.
Noel King
What, what has he been up to since he ended up in the acting role?
Paula Reid
He's been a busy beat.
Molly Olmstead
Ah.
Paula Reid
In my reporting, I talked to over a dozen people inside doj, high level people. Some people I know don't particularly care for Todd as a person. They're rivals, whatever. There was a general consensus, though, this is his job to lose, but in order to keep this, he's going to have to deliver on weaponization for the president. And that means Trump wants his political adversaries to be prosecuted. And that is something that they have not been able to do yet. Judges and grand juries have to sign off on this. They are largely been reluctant.
Noel King
A US District judge ruled the appointment of Attorney Lindsey Halligan is unlawful.
Paula Reid
We have learned that the Justice Department's case against former FBI Director Jim Comey and the New York Attorney General have both been dismissed. And so they're getting tripped up by the checks in the system. It's nearly impossible in some cases, the things that Trump has wanted, but he's made it clear this is what he wants. So that's ultimately, in order to get this job and to keep it, he needs to bring a case against the political adversary.
Noel King
All right, so we know that President Trump likes Todd Blanche. We know that MAGA has been disappointed by the job that the Justice Department has done investigating the Epstein files.
Molly Olmstead
How many of you are satisfied?
Noel King
You can you clap?
Molly Olmstead
Satisfied with the results of the Epstein investigation?
Noel King
Clap.
Guest Expert/Analyst
I think it's a huge miscalculation, and I truly just stand with the women, and I think they deserve to be the ones that we're fighting for.
Molly Olmstead
When will we see justice?
Noel King
Does maga, which was very unfriendly at the end toward Pam Bondi, does MAGA like Todd Blanche?
Paula Reid
So the two knocks on Todd Blanche are that, quote, he's not MAGA enough and that he doesn't get the Trump do from the, quote, original sin of how they've handled the Epstein files. Let's start with, are you MAGA enough? So I have talked to officials inside the administration, including this one White House official who said, yeah, we feel that Todd is not MAGA enough. He doesn't do enough for the base. But even those people who in past stories have been pretty tough on Todd said, when it comes to being the acting Attorney General, he's done the job. It's about as good as we're going to get. Were not opposed to him having this job. So when it comes to the Epstein files, one one administration official told me that is, quote, the original sin of the Trump Justice Department. And by that, they mean just Pam Bondi's repeated bungling of the rollout of those files, promising there was new information. And those binders that she handed out that really had just a rehash of things that was already, already in the public domain. Her saying that she had the client list on her desk when really there's no client list. Eventually they just had Todd take over the messaging. Right?
Todd Blanche
To the extent that there frustration, I understand where that comes from. Just from what we know about Mr. Epstein, I hope that the work that the men and women within this department have done over the past two months hopefully is able to bring closure.
Paula Reid
He was also the one who went down and met with Ghislaine Maxwell, he was the one who oversaw the release of the documents. He has been front and center on this. So when he becomes the acting attorney general, the concern from some administration officials is while putting him in charge isn't going to get us past our biggest embarrassment, which is Epstein. But I don't think in Trump's eyes that's going to be disqualifying because I think many people say that Todd had to go and pick up the mess that Pam Bondi had made. And he or some of the staffers might argue that Congress put him in a bad position because they had so little time to do those redactions. No intelligent minds could argue the Justice Department has actually had like a decade to release all this stuff. But that's a matter for another day. He's just talking about the tight timeline that he had to do that review process. And that is part of why they say it was so messy as opposed to a grand conspiracy to protect people.
Noel King
He is acting ag. Is this job his? If he wants it. Are there any other serious contenders?
Paula Reid
My sources say this job is Todd's to lose. Now, even if you get it, every Trump attorney general has been fired, replaced, or resigned. So we'll see. Maybe he's found his Merrick Garland, who wants to stay through the end. But there are certainly other people nipping at Todd's heels. But in the eyes of the president and everyone I've talked to, this is his job to lose. But there are also some people in the wings. One is the US Attorney, Jeanine Pirro.
Guest Expert/Analyst
I see too much violent crime being committed by young punks who think that they can get together in gangs and crews and beat the hell out of you or anyone else.
Paula Reid
It was funny. On the night of the dinner and the shooting, Todd was at the White House. He did the press conference to the President, said there will be charges, there'll be a gun charge, maybe a law enforcement related charge. 30, 45 minutes later, I don't remember how much time passed, but the U.S. attorney, Pirro, she did a press conference and man, she was, she was yelling the specific statues into that microphone.
Guest Expert/Analyst
Right now the defendant is being charged with two counts 9 24C, using a firearm during a crime of violence and a second crime under 111, which is assault on a federal officer using a dangerous weapon.
Paula Reid
It felt a little like one upsmanship. Maybe it was just her enthusiasm and I'm reading something into it, but her name has certainly been mentioned. We got two and a half more years. I mean, there's probably time for everyone to be attorney general if Todd can't or won't stay on the job for two and a half years. It's a tough job under any administration, but this one really brings some unique challenges.
Noel King
Paula reid is cnn's chief legal correspondent. Danielle hewitt and kelly wesinger produced today's show and jolie meyers edited. David tadashore is our engineer and gabriel duntov checked the facts. I'm noel king. It's today explained.
Guest Expert/Analyst
Foreign.
Todd Blanche
Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. I don't know if you knew this, but anyone can get the same Premium Wireless for $15 a month plan that I've been enjoying.
Molly Olmstead
It's not just for celebrities. So do like I did and have one of your assistant's assistants switch you
Todd Blanche
to Mint Mobile today. I'm told it's super easy to do@mintmobile.com
Guest Expert/Analyst
Switch upfront payment of $45 for 3 month plan equivalent to $15 per month
Sponsor Voice
required intro rate, first 3 months only, then full price plan options available, taxes and fees, extra fee, full terms@mintmobile.com.
“Staged” dives deep into the fallout from the recent attempted assassination at the White House Correspondents’ Dinner. The hosts, Noel King and Sean Rameswaram, along with experts and reporters including Molly Olmstead (Slate) and Paula Reid (CNN), dissect not only the facts of the incident but—crucially—the explosion of conspiracy theories about it, the political optics, and how shifts in public trust and partisanship are redrawing the boundaries of “reality” in US political discourse. The episode also provides a profile of Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche and discusses the tough realities of the modern Justice Department.
On the ballroom conspiracy:
“If you need more evidence of why this feels staged, everyone is talking about the ballroom.”
– Molly Olmstead [01:07]
On instant conspiracy theorizing:
“They didn't even wait for evidence, really. It just was kind of an almost gut reaction that people had…”
– Guest Expert/Analyst [03:23]
On trust and speculation:
“We can't work in a system in which we all just treat each other as the most fantastical, extreme version of ourselves. So trust Donald Trump? Absolutely not. But jump to think that there's some sort of convoluted, strange thing going on...that's that's not healthy either.”
– Guest Expert/Analyst [12:20]
On DOJ performance:
“So seeing how you respond to something that was not of your own doing, I mean that is a real test for the Attorney General. And so far it's been a textbook response from him.”
– Paula Reid [18:04]
On the DOJ’s internal reputation:
Around the Epstein files: “That is, quote, the original sin of the Trump Justice Department.”
– Paula Reid [23:57]
On being ‘MAGA enough’:
“Yeah, we feel that Todd is not MAGA enough. He doesn't do enough for the base. But even those people who…have been pretty tough on Todd said, when it comes to being the acting Attorney General, he's done the job. It's about as good as we're going to get.”
– Paula Reid [24:02–24:14]
This summary covers all major points and notable exchanges from the episode, emphasizing both the facts and the rapidly shifting public/political reactions surrounding them.