A (2:51)

Okay, so at this point, is it fair to say that the Epstein files have been released?

D (2:57)

Definitely not. So the DOJ said they released a smaller tranche of materials on Friday and on Saturday and they were going to continue to release materials. What's interesting is that the bill that compelled the release of these materials that Congress passed last month actually required them to release materials by Friday. So a lot of lawmakers are saying that DOJ is breaking the law by not fully releasing the files.

C (3:22)

They sent a six page memo to Congress and said they cited preexisting laws as reasons that they weren't going to follow our law. For instance, our law requires them to release information regardless of embarrassment. But they are trying to say that a previous law prevails when it doesn't.

A (3:40)

If you say the files weren't fully released, what did you spend all weekend looking at? What did we get?

D (3:47)

So we got a lot of materials from doj. We got some photos, we got some documents, but there really wasn't much in the way of new information in these files. The expectation was that DOJ would answer a lot of questions in its release of the files. People want to know how Epstein amassed his fortune. They want to know who else was involved in his crimes. And really in these files we didn't find out really anything about any of those questions. We mostly saw material that had already been public.

B (4:20)

For the first time, the Epstein files.

C (4:22)

Made public the Justice Department posting hundreds.

B (4:25)

Of thousands of items online related to.

C (4:28)

The DOJ's criminal investigations of the late sex offender. Thousands of photographs, some graphic and heavily redacted.

B (4:35)

Bill Clinton seems swimming in a pool with Ghislaine Maxwell and another woman with her face redacted. Clinton with another unknown woman on his lap.

A (4:43)

One of the new files confirms that Epstein was reported to authorities almost 30 years ago.

D (4:48)

There is one thing that drew a lot of attention over the weekend and that is some images appeared to actually disappear from the DOJ website. Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche claims that that was because DOJ was concerned that victims identities were not properly redacted.

C (5:07)

When we hear concerns whether it's photographs of women that we do not believe are victims or we didn't have information to show that they were victims, but we learned that there are concerns. Of course we're taking that photograph down and we're going to address it. If we need to redact faces or other information.

D (5:23)

Will at least one of those photos included an image of Donald Trump.

A (5:27)

Huh?

D (5:28)

And DOJ has rejected the idea that they're trying to protect Trump in, in in the release of these files. And that image of Trump has since been re added back to the website.

B (5:39)

The absurdity of us pulling down a.

C (5:41)

Photo, a single photo, because President Trump was in it is laughable. And the Fact that everybody's trying to act like that's the case is a reflection of their true motivation. But. But the reality is it.

A (5:55)

So we remember that it was Congress that compelled the administration to release these files to give us what we've got so far. How did lawmakers react to what was released?

D (6:08)

Lawmakers are really upset.

C (6:10)

They released one document from a New York grand jury of 119 pages, totally blacked out. They've not shown any deference or respect for the victims at all for the survivors of this nightmare. And it's all about covering up things that for whatever reason, Donald Trump doesn't want to go public.

D (6:29)

They think that DOJ is not complying with the law and not fully releasing the materials. By the deadline that Congress has set, we actually saw two lawmakers, one Republican and one Democrat, Thomas Massie of Kentucky and Ro Khanna of California, threaten to start impeachment proceedings for Pam Bondi and to file content charges.

C (6:50)

The quickest way, and I think most expeditious way, to get justice for these victims is to bring inherent contempt against Pam Bondi, Thomas Massie and are exploring all options. It can be the impeachment of people at justice, inherent contempt or referring for prosecution. Those who are obstructing justice, their threat.

A (7:12)

To impeach Pam Bondi, what is that grounded in? Are they saying she didn't give us what Congress ordered her to give us?

D (7:20)

Yes, they are. They're saying that DOJ is not complying with the law. DOJ maintains that it would be impossible for them to truly comply with the law and release all the information on time. But members of Congress are saying you're not doing what the law says you were supposed to do.

A (7:38)

As part of the Epstein files release, we were supposed to get grand jury documents that relate to Ghislaine Maxwell. Did we learn anything new about her?

D (7:49)

We really also didn't. Didn't learn much new about her. DOJ did ask judges to be able to release the grand jury materials publicly, and they did release those materials, but they were also heavily redacted. I think Ghislaine Maxwell's request for some kind of reprieve from her sentence is really a wild card in this saga. You never really know with Trump what he's going to do. He has said that he has not ruled out pardoning her. The Supreme Court is back in session. They rejected today an appeal by Ghislaine Maxwell to overturn her conviction.

B (8:23)

That means her only chance at getting.

D (8:25)

Out of prison is a pardon from you. Is that something you're open to.

B (8:28)

Who are we talking about, Maxwell? You know, I haven't heard the name in so long, I can say this, that I'd have to take a look at it. I would have to take a look. Did they.

D (8:38)

And so I'm not sure if we saw information in this tranche of materials that could give us any kind of signals of what's going to happen, in part because Trump is just a unpredictable character in this saga.

A (8:50)

Do you think the objective has become muddled? I mean, it's worth asking, like, why do we want to see them? And you mentioned people being held accountable. And then there is the politics of all of this. Both parties are trying to sort of use this to their advantage. Do you think there is a clear objective at this point?

D (9:10)

I think this really tragic saga of a powerful man who was able to use his power to abuse one for years has really morphed into a kind of political firestorm and flashpoint. We have Democrats trying to stoke division among the president's base and really use this issue to kind of pare back support for. For Trump. And on the flip side of that, we see Republicans acting defensively. We know that Trump has ordered his attorney general, Pam Bondi, to investigate Democrats with ties to Epstein. And so we really see this kind of turning to a political back and forth around a really tragic case of abuse.

A (9:51)

You've been covering this story for a long time, and when Congress said it was going to compel the release of these files, it was a very, very big deal. You also know that there is a lot of theorizing and conspiracy theorizing around the Epstein fil. Do you think there is any information that could be released that would make people feel like this is enough? We know all that we are ever going to know.

D (10:18)

I don't know that the American public is ever going to be fully satisfied with the information that is provided in this case. I think that people want to see the people who helped Epstein or potentially were involved in his crimes held accountable. And it's unclear if we are ever going to see that. I think for now, Democrats really want to see DOJ fully release the files, which is something that they have not done and theoretically could do.

A (10:50)

Hayley Fuchs is a reporter for Politico. Coming up, Ghislaine Maxwell, the author of a book on what we now know about Jeffrey Epstein's accomplice.

C (11:13)

Support for today's show comes from Quince. We've all handed someone a gift and received a force. Thank you. I love it this holiday season. Quince can give you something that's both luxurious and built to last so you can finally get a real thank you. Quint says that every piece is made with premium materials from trusted factories and priced far below what other luxury brands charge. Our colleague Nisha Chital has tried Quints. Here's what she had to say.

A (11:40)

I got the organic cotton boyfriend crewneck sweater.

D (11:45)

I mean I've seen similar styles of.

A (11:47)

Sweaters from higher end brands for double, triple or even more.

D (11:54)

The price, the style and the quality feel similar to much more expensive brands.

C (11:59)

You can find gifts so good you'll want to keep them. With quints, you can go to quince.com explain for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada too. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E.com explained to get free shipping and 365 day returns. That's quince.com explained.

A (12:28)

Support for today's show comes from Found. Found has a message for all the small business owners out there. When was the last time you fel like you had your business finances totally under control? That's what Found is for. Found is a business banking platform that says they can let you effortlessly track expenses, manage invoices and prepare for taxes all in one place. Found says. Found has found the tasks that create the most hassle for small businesses such as categorizing your expenses, preparing for your taxes, managing invoicing, budgeting an says Found. They built an app that does it all directly from your business checking account. They even say they can help you uncover tax credit write offs. Oh, you can take back control of your business. Today you can open a Found account for free@found.com that's f o u n d.com found is a financial technology company. It is not a bank. Banking services are provided by lead bank member fdic. You can join hundreds of thousands who've already streamlined their finances with Found. Support for today's show comes from Green Chef, which healthy eating trend is for you. Green Chef cuts through the noise delivering farm sourced ingredients. You can let Green Chef do your research, meal planning and grocery shopping to enjoy low prep low mess meals. Claire White has tried Green Chef. Here's what she thinks.

D (13:52)

Green Chef inspires me to cook more in my day to day life even without the product. It teaches me new ideas. It gives me new ideas for recipes. Things that I would have never thought to do in my home kitchen. Like breaded cauliflower for tacos or fried zucchini for the top of a pasta. Green Chef has a ton of great meals and within those great meals comes great inspiration.

A (14:16)

Right now you can go to greenchef.com explainedgraza and use code explainedgraza to get started with 50% off of green Chef and some free Graza olive oil in your second and four third boxes. This 50% offer is only available for a limited time. That's code explained graza@greenchef.com explained Graza.

C (14:45)

This is today explained.

A (14:49)

I'm Noel King with Barry Levine. Barry is an investigative journalist who wrote a book called the Inside the Criminal Web of Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell. Barry, tell me about Maxwell's early years.

B (15:03)

Well, Ghislaine grew up in England in a mansion with 50 or 60 rooms. Her father, of course, was Robert Maxwell, the famous Fleet street media tycoon. One man and the company he founded has done more than any other to harness the communications revolution. The man is Robert Max. The company is Maxwell Communication Corporation. I certainly would hope to make a small contribution with the help of these newspapers if I become proprietor to halting the retreat of Great Britain, which has gone on for so long that the natives have forgotten that they're going backwards. She was the youngest of their nine children. It was a very strange upbringing in the sense that her father was extremely explosive and he demanded a great deal of his children. Ghislaine's mother, Elizabeth, later in her autobiography, said that her husband Robert, would fly into these rages and subject the children to humiliation and harsh treatment, including corporal punishment. So she grew up privy to a life of obscene luxury. However, it was a very difficult life growing up under her father.

A (16:27)

Did she express resentment of him? Did she dislike the pressure that was put on her?

B (16:33)

No, no. In fact, she embraced that she was Daddy's little girl in all that sense. And not only were they close as she was growing up, but he also wanted to groom her for the family business. When Robert Maxwell acquired Macmillan Publishing in 1988, along with the New York Daily News, the person that he brought with him from England was his daughter, Ghislaine. She was well known, had a tremendous Rolodex of contacts of the rich and famous, and so Robert Maxwell wanted to tap into that. And then, of course, the tragedy hit when her father and his sons, Kevin and Ian, had to battle the bank of England for defaulting on close to $75 million in loans.

D (17:30)

The latest revelations surrounding the Maxwell empire.

B (17:33)

Are probably the most damaging yet.

D (17:35)

The resignation last night of Kevin and Ian Maxwell from the board of Mirror Group Newspapers signaled the start of a huge inquiry into allegations that Robert Maxwell used some £300 million from the Mirror Pension to prop up some of his other troubled companies.

B (17:50)

He was on a yacht off the coast of the Canary Islands, his yacht, which was named after Ghislaine, the Lady Ghislaine. And he was seen on the deck early that morning, and then he had fallen overboard. His body was found 12 hours later in the Atlantic Ocean by Spanish fishermen. An autopsy interestingly revealed that there were no signs of foul play. The people around the Maxwell family believed it to be a suicide.

D (18:20)

I also want to take this opportunity to thank all the many hundreds of people who have sent messages of support to us at this very, very sad time.

B (18:41)

Now, Ghislaine didn't want to believe that. She did not want to believe that her father would take his life. So she said this was a result of a dark conspiracy involving Mossad renegades and Sicilian contract killers who were responsible for her father's death. Of course, this was Ghislaine's viewpoint. She didn't want to believe her father would take his own life. And so this was the conclusion.

A (19:14)

How did Ghislaine Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein meet?

B (19:17)

Ghislaine and Jeffrey Epstein never specifically cited where they in fact, met. It was very mysterious how the two of them came together at that time. And then, of course, they show up together at a fashion show in Paris in 1992. You have to remember at the time that Ghislaine was really not herself. She was extremely distraught after her father's death. People who I interviewed for my book said she was constantly crying, she was constantly breaking down. She was really not in any type of good graces. She moved into a small New York apartment, really just kind of wondering what her future was going to be. And then all of a sudden, she's with Jeffrey Epstein and she is spending time at his mansion, townhouse mansion on the Upper east side. Jeffrey Epstein was able to provide this type of super wealthy lifestyle that she had become accustomed to.

A (20:27)

How did Ghislaine Maxwell become part of Jeffrey Epstein's abuse?

B (20:34)

Well, about two years into their relationship, Jeffrey Epstein invited Ghislaine Maxwell to travel with him to Northern Michigan in the spring of 1994. There was a music camp there called the Interlocean School. Jeffrey Epstein had studied there as a young student from Brooklyn, New York. After he made his money, the school erected a Jeffrey Epstein Scholarship Lodge in his honor, because Jeffrey Epstein gave the music school financial gifts. So Ghislaine Maxwell goes with Jeffrey in 1994 to this music school and Jeffrey Epstein met a 13 year old girl there who is identified in court documents as a Jane Doe. And Jeffrey Epstein approached this girl and said, you have talent. I would like to bring you to Palm Beach, Florida, where I live and I want to provide for you private voice lessons and myself and Ghislaine, we will take care of you. We will put you up in a nice place to live. They met the girl's mother and invited the girl's mother to their Palm beach estate. And Ghislaine played the role of Jeffrey Epstein's love interest, really legitimizing the deal for the mother, seeming that this was a couple that was going to take care of my daughter. And it was a, you know, a teenager's dream to hang out in a, in a mansion, be lavished with clothing and gifts. But then it went to the dark side. Ghislaine was instructed by Jeffrey Epstein to groom this 13 year old girl into learning about sexual positions. This was to me, the rubber hitting the road in the sense that Ghislaine Maxwell was now becoming a co conspirator to Jeffrey Epstein and basically feeding this young child to the wolf.

A (22:52)

So the story of this 13 year old girl is one in which Jeffrey Epstein spots this kid, decides I want her, and then Ghislaine Maxwell helps him groom and abuse this child. How does her role in the abuse evolve?

B (23:07)

When they return to Palm Beach, Ghislaine Maxwell was instructed by Jeffrey Epstein to begin finding other girls. And this of course, began the process of their sex trafficking. Ghislaine Maxwell would recruit girls from the local schools, from local parks, as alleged.

D (23:27)

Maxwell and Epstein had a method.

B (23:29)

Typically, they would befriend these young girls.

D (23:32)

By asking them questions about their lives, pretending to be taking an interest in them. They would take them to the movies and treat them to shopping trips.

B (23:44)

She would have Jeffrey Epstein's driver drive around, she would spot a girl, she would say, would you like make a couple hundred dollars giving my friend a massage? Of course that was code for the sexual abuse that would take place. And then they would pay these girls $200, $300. And the girls were asked to recruit other girls that they knew. Maxwell enticed minor girls, got them to.

D (24:12)

Trust her, then delivered them into the trap that she and Epstein had set for them. She pretended to be a woman they could trust. All the while she was setting them.

B (24:23)

Up to be sexually abused by Epstein.

D (24:27)

And in some cases by Maxwell herself.

B (24:31)

Ghislaine was in charge of overseeing this entire operation, she would present herself as this big sister, even a motherly type of individual to welcome these young girls. It boggles the mind why she would do this, why she would destroy the childhoods of these minors.

A (24:57)

Ghislaine Maxwell, of course, like Jeffrey Epstein, ended up in prison. Where is she now and what is she doing now? Barry?

B (25:07)

Well, Ghislaine has been moved to a minimum security dorm like facility in Texas from the federal facility lockup that she was in Florida. And this had to do with the fawning interview that she gave recently to Todd Blanche, that she never witnessed any wrongdoing involving Donald Trump while he was friends with Jeffrey Epstein, that he didn't know anything about any of this.

D (25:37)

I never witnessed the President in any inappropriate setting in any way. The President was never inappropriate with anybody in the time of I was with him. He was a gentleman in all respects.

B (25:49)

Elaine, as a reward, I believe, was moved to this minimum security facility. She's working on asking for clemency from the President and that's where she is right now.

A (26:05)

Do you think there is a possibility that she will get a pardon, that she will get out?

B (26:10)

Donald Trump knew Ghislaine Maxwell going back to the late 1980s. I don't think it's far fetched that Donald Trump could do this. Yeah, I mean, I'm gonna have to.

C (26:22)

Take a look at it.

B (26:23)

I have to ask doj.

C (26:25)

I didn't know they rejected it.

B (26:26)

I didn't know she was even asking for it. Frankly, it would be to the absolute horror of the Epstein and Maxwell survivors for Ghislaine to be pardoned. I think it would be for the women now who interacted with Maxwell who were sexually abused by her. I think that this would cause traumas for these women today if Ghislaine Maxwell was pardoned and she belongs behind bars for the, you know, for the remainder of her sentence.

A (27:19)

Barry Levine is an investigative journalist and the author of the Spider. Danielle Hewitt produced today's show with help from Avshai Aartsi. Amina Elsadi edited Laura Bullard and Jolie Meyer's Check the Facts and Patrick Boyd and David Tadashore, engineer here. I'm Noel King. It's Today Explained.

B (27:59)

Sam.