Today, Explained: The Making of a Beauty King
Released on February 14, 2025 | Part of the Vox Media Podcast Network
Hosts: Sean Ramstorm and Noel King
Guest: Elizabeth Segren, Senior Writer at Fast Company
Introduction to Sephora's Dominance
The episode opens with Noel King reminiscing about Sephora's inception in 1998, highlighting its revolutionary approach to beauty retail: offering hundreds of curated beauty brands under one roof. Elizabeth Segren elaborates on this unique model, emphasizing the freedom it provided consumers to explore and test products without brand loyalty constraints.
Noel King [00:01]: "On Today Explained way back in the mists of time, 1998, a new beauty store hit the scene. Its appeal was choice."
Elizabeth Segren [00:09]: "It would put hundreds of these carefully curated beauty brands in a single store. And as a customer, you were free to roam the aisles and test all the products that you wanted to your heart's content."
This innovative approach quickly resonated with consumers, setting Sephora apart from traditional department stores and becoming a pivotal player in the high-end beauty industry.
Sephora: King Maker in the Beauty World
Sephora's influence extends beyond offering a variety of products; it has become a formidable gatekeeper for beauty brands aiming for success in a $30 billion global market. Elizabeth Segren discusses how Sephora’s expansive presence—with 700 US stores and an additional 1,000 locations within Kohl’s—positions it as the linchpin for emerging beauty brands.
Elizabeth Segren [03:11]: "So it basically now controls the fates of beauty brands on the market. And that is why so many beauty founders are so desperate to break into Sephora."
She points out that while competitors like Ulta Beauty and Nordstrom strive to emulate Sephora's model, Sephora remains a step ahead by continuously identifying and nurturing trendy, innovative brands, ensuring that consumers always have something new to explore.
Case Study: Glossier’s Rise and Transformation
One of the standout examples of Sephora’s influence is Glossier. Elizabeth Segren provides an in-depth look into Glossier's journey from a direct-to-consumer brand to becoming a staple in Sephora stores.
Elizabeth Segren [05:16]: "Glossier emerged at this time when all of these venture capitalists were just pumping money into startups. And Emily Weiss was really, really good at raising money for Glossier."
Glossier capitalized on the social media-driven beauty landscape, raising $266 million and achieving a valuation of $1.8 billion. However, the brand faced significant challenges related to inclusivity and internal culture, particularly during the Black Lives Matter movement.
Elizabeth Segren [09:18]: "And at some point, Emily Weiss stepped down and brought in another CEO. And it was this new CEO who basically said, you know, let's just like revisit, rethink what we want Glossier to be."
To achieve the necessary scale and satisfy investor expectations, Glossier eventually partnered with Sephora in 2022, marking a significant shift from its original direct-to-consumer stance.
Elizabeth Segren [11:00]: "Glossier totally reversed its stance and suddenly it was there next to 300 of its competitors. But it realized that that was the only way for it to get the kind of scale that it needed to satisfy its investors."
The High Cost of Sephora Partnership for Beauty Brands
Breaking into Sephora is portrayed as a highly competitive and financially demanding process. Elizabeth Segren outlines the various hurdles brands must overcome to secure a spot in Sephora stores:
- Exclusivity Agreements: Brands must agree not to sell their products elsewhere for at least two years.
- Significant Financial Investment: Costs for in-store fixtures can range from tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars.
- High Commission Rates: Sephora takes a substantial 65% of each sale, far exceeding industry norms.
Elizabeth Segren [18:23]: "So if you sign a contract with Sephora, first of all, it means signing an exclusivity agreement saying that you won't sell your products anywhere else for at least two years."
Despite these costs, the allure of access to Sephora’s vast audience—bolstered by a loyalty program with 40 million members—breeds a desperate race among brands to secure their place within Sephora’s expansive network.
Trade-Offs and Downsides of Sephora’s Power
While Sephora offers unparalleled exposure, it also exerts significant control over the brands it houses. Elizabeth Segren discusses how Sephora often influences key aspects of a brand’s development, including product formulation and packaging.
Elizabeth Segren [21:01]: "They're letting Sephora make decisions about things like packaging. There's a brand called Soft Services that creates beautiful skincare products and it wanted to create these eco-friendly, refillable containers, but Sephora said, no, that's too complicated for us to sell in our store."
Moreover, not all brands thrive under Sephora’s stringent requirements. The constant churn of brands in Sephora stores means that those failing to meet sales targets are promptly removed, leading to financial and operational strains for struggling brands.
Elizabeth Segren [22:26]: "It's kind of like a pay to play model because you have to pour so much money into Sephora in order to succeed that you're basically kind of on this hamster wheel trying to go out and get VC funding, pouring it into your brand so that you can meet Sephora's targets."
High-profile failures, such as J. Lo’s beauty brand, exemplify the harsh realities of Sephora’s dominance, where even celebrity-backed ventures are not immune to the retailer's demanding standards.
Sephora's Broader Impact on Beauty Consumption and Trends
Sephora’s innovative retail experience has not only shaped consumer habits but also influenced broader beauty trends. Elizabeth Segren notes that Sephora has been instrumental in elevating the status of products traditionally considered drugstore items, like shampoos, into high-end commodities.
Elizabeth Segren [17:30]: "Sephora decided that consumers actually would be willing to drop a lot of money on fancy shampoos and conditioners. So it actually went out there and cultivated a new generation of these brands."
However, this transformation comes with a downside. Sephora fosters a culture of excessive consumption, continually pushing new trends and products that create a sense of inadequacy among consumers.
Elizabeth Segren [25:16]: "Sephora has created a really exciting in-store experience... But I also think that it is creating this culture of excessive consumption. It's constantly cultivating our desire for new beauty trends and it's making us feel like we'll never have enough makeup or shampoo or skincare to make us feel beautiful enough."
Conclusion: The Dual-Edged Sword of Sephora’s Influence
The episode concludes by acknowledging Sephora's significant role in shaping both the beauty industry and consumer behavior. While Sephora has democratized access to high-end beauty products and fostered innovation, it also imposes substantial financial and creative constraints on brands, perpetuating a cycle of high-stakes competition.
Elizabeth Segren [26:08]: "It's definitely a complicated calculation that founders need to make when they're trying to break into this world of Sephora."
Hosts Noel King and Elizabeth Segren underscore the complexity of Sephora’s influence, inviting listeners to reflect on their own consumption habits as they navigate the ever-evolving landscape of beauty retail.
Notable Quotes:
- Elizabeth Segren [00:26]: "You no longer had to be Team Clinique or a Lancome lady. Maybe for you it wasn't solely Maybelline and that was fine. In Sephora, you were free."
- Elizabeth Segren [05:16]: "Glossier emerged at this time when all of these venture capitalists were just pumping money into startups."
- Elizabeth Segren [17:30]: "So it's basically Sephora's world and we're just living in it."
- Elizabeth Segren [25:16]: "It's constantly cultivating our desire for new beauty trends and it's making us feel like we'll never have enough makeup or shampoo or skincare to make us feel beautiful enough."
Produced by: Amaska Llewellyn
Special Thanks: Amina El Saadi, Andrea, Kristen’s daughter, Laura Bullard, Patrick Boyd, Abishai Artsy, Hari Muagdi, Victoria Chamberlain, Peter Balanon, Rosen Miles Bryan, Travis Larkin Chuk, Devin Schwartz, Jolie Myers, Miranda Kennedy.
Stay tuned for more insightful episodes by subscribing to Today, Explained on your preferred podcast platform.