Debate of the Week: Most Underrated Athlete

Summary

---

Tranquilo Sports Talk (Stay Tranquilo Network)

Episode: Debate of the Week: Most Underrated Athlete
Date: February 24, 2026

---

Episode Overview

This week’s Tranquilo Sports Talk delivers a lively, barbershop-style debate on the most underrated athlete in current sports. The Miami-based hosts tackle the question from several angles—highlighting overlooked NFL linemen, expressing respect for hockey’s unsung warriors, and making the case for both elite and grinder-level PGA golfers. Expect that signature blend of South Florida candor, sharp sports analysis, and Miami-flavored enthusiasm, all focused on athletes who play in the shadows yet shape the games we love.

---

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. Opening Challenge: Who’s the Most Underrated Athlete?

[00:45–01:17]

• Host sets the stage for the debate, noting how tough it is to nail down a single "most underrated” in the modern era.
• Joe: “It’s easier to talk about, like, all-time most underrated players…but to think modern day, I think that’s tough.”

2. Miami Dolphins Linemen Get Their Flowers

[01:17–02:00]

• Joe’s Picks:
  • Aaron Brewer: Overlooked due to his size, but now a rock-solid All-Pro center.
  • Patrick Paul: Initially doubted for his raw technique and draft spot, yet has emerged as a starter after learning behind Armstead.
• Quote:
  • “Aaron Brewer, when he came here, people thought, who is this guy? He’s undersized…He’s turned into an all-pro center.” (Joe, 01:22)
  • “Patrick Paul…everybody said what at this high? Like what are you doing?...And then he sit behind Armstead for one year…just plug and play, forget about it." (Joe, 01:34)

3. Ice Cold Respect: Underappreciated Hockey Players

[02:09–04:47]

• Wingo’s Hot Take:
  • Not just one athlete—the entire sport of hockey is underrated:
    • Skill set involves skating, taking hits, controlling the puck, playing hurt, and insane durability.
    • Players like Panthers’ “Chucky” (Matthew Tkachuk) get little recognition despite playing soon after injuries.
  • Quote:
    • “I got an underrated athlete for you…all hockey players. I think hockey is one of the most [underappreciated]...You have six bruised ribs, a concussion, [and] you got fake teeth in and dentures.” (Wingo, 02:09–03:14)
• General & Host Agree:
  • Barkov (Aleksander Barkov) also shouted out as perennially overlooked, only lately cracking “top-5 in the NHL” lists.
  • General’s Take: “In my opinion, I think Barkov is the second best player in the NHL…He’s rarely was in that conversation, now he’s kind of entered it.” (General, 04:13)

4. The Relentless Grind: Unsung PGA Tour Pros

[06:06–06:51]

• Host pivots to professional golf, crediting the hard work and financial grind of mid-tier PGA Tour players (ranked 100–140):
  • Many pay their own expenses, scraping by unless they make the cut, and hustling year-round for a chance at breakthrough success.
  • Cites Jake Knapp as an example—unknowns who “come out of nowhere…are now in the thick of it and making a ton of money.”
  • Quote:
    • “Those guys are grinding, right?...Those PGA Tour guys…shit's coming out of their pocket, no one's really seeing the grind." (Host, 06:07)

5. Unsung Heroes: Hockey Referees

[06:51–07:29]

• Host and General: The conversation gets meta, throwing major props to NHL referees:
  • Their agility and stamina get overlooked—dodging pucks, breaking up fights, and continuously skating without line changes.
• Quote:
  • “Talk about athletes, bro. I picture myself being a referee on ice... Every time I see that guy jump clear in the air over a puck and land—one, the instinct to react in real time...then just keep moving like if nothing happened.” (Host, 06:56–07:17)

6. NFL’s Overlooked Difference-Maker: Harrison Smith

[07:48–08:44]

• Joe advocates for Harrison Smith (Minnesota Vikings safety):
  • Consistent, hard-hitting, and playmaking safety, rarely discussed among the elite despite a lengthy, high-impact career.
• Quote:
  • “No one talks about Harrison Smith. That dude has been a dog for 15 straight years. [He] will come down and knock a motherfucker’s head off and then take a pick six, 90 yards. And he’s like 33 at this point.” (Joe, 08:27)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Host, on the challenge of naming the most underrated:

  • “That fucking makes my head spin a lot.” (00:54)

• General, on Barkov’s quiet dominance:

  • “Barkov for me…I think should be in the discussion for the second best player in the NHL…He's literally been this guy for years.” (04:13–04:25)

• Wingo, defending hockey’s demands:

  • “People don’t want to do that on land, you know.” (05:01)

• Host, on hockey refs:

  • “They don't have those intermission periods, you know?...they’re up and down the whole time.” (07:29)

• Joe, on positional bias in football:

  • “When was the last, like, real good, like, white safety?...the most underrated player in the league might be Harrison Smith.” (08:06)

---

Timestamps for Important Segments

• 00:45 — Debate kick-off: Defining “most underrated” athlete
• 01:17 — Dolphins' Aaron Brewer & Patrick Paul highlighted
• 02:09 — Wingo champions all hockey players as underrated
• 03:29 — Aleksander Barkov gets his due; Panthers’ playoff outlook
• 05:05 — Stats from Sports Science: Hockey players' physical toll
• 06:06 — Host spotlights PGA Tour’s financial grinders
• 06:51 — Unsung athleticism of NHL referees
• 07:48 — Joe’s argument for Harrison Smith as most overlooked NFL player

---

Summary Takeaways

• The crew brings serious love and South Florida perspective to athletes who excel in the background—O-linemen, goalies, grinding golfers, and even referees.
• Hockey dominates as a sport not getting its due, with multiple hosts highlighting its physical and skill demands.
• The Dolphins and local teams get their flowers, but there’s also national scope—especially with shoutouts to Viking safety Harrison Smith and journeyman PGA Tour players.
• The tone stays true to Miami: candid, high-energy, and full of both humor and respect for the overlooked warriors of the sports world.

---

Transcript

[Lowe's Commercial Announcer]

When it's time to replace your appliances, Lowes has you covered. Get up to 35% off select major appliances and members get more like free delivery. Haul away basic installation and parts and a two year Lowe's protection plan where you spend $2,500 or more on select major appliances. Our best lineup is here at Lowe's. Valid through 225. Wall supplies last selection varies by location. Excludes Massachusetts, Maryland, Wisconsin, New Jersey, Florida loyalty program. Subject to terms and conditions. Visit lowe's.com terms for details. Subject to change.

[McDonald's Commercial Announcer]

You've made it on time for the McDonald's breakfast menu. You think to yourself, finally I can start my day. But what if breakfast could be even more perfect with the hot honey sausage egg biscuit? It finally is. Go to McDonald's and get it while you can.

[Host]

Most underrated athlete right now.

[Joe]

You know you could give me credit for the topic, but it's not an

[Host]

easy to me but I really liked it. I'm like, shit, that fucking makes my head spin a lot.

[Joe]

Yeah. Because I actually try to think about it. I'm in the shower, I'm like, I think it's easier to talk about like all time most underrated players but like to think modern day. I mean I think that's tough. I think just the easy one obviously. I watch the Dolphins a lot and I could pair these together.

[Host]

Okay.

[Joe]

I think underrated's got to be. You could time together. Aaron Brewer and Patrick Paul. You know Aaron Brewer, when he came here, people thought, who is this guy? He's undersized. He's never going to hold it down in the middle. He's turned into an all pro center. Like he does his thing week in and week out. Patrick Paul, when we drafted him, everybody said what at this high? Like what are you doing? He had bad tape, bad feet, bad hand placement. Raw as can be. They had no shot at development. And then he sit behind Armstead for one year and he starts this year for the first time and he's just plug and play, forget about it. So to me, I think both of those guys are highly underrated. And Patrick Paul a little deserving. I mean first year starting. Yeah, I get that. But nonetheless, those guys are awesome.

[Host]

Brewer for sure, I mean didn't even make the first.

[Sylvania Commercial Announcer]

The all.

[Host]

What is it? The, the Pro Bowl.

[Sylvania Commercial Announcer]

Pro Bowl.

[Host]

But it was like first team all pro. Make it make sense.

[Wingo]

You know, I got a, I got an underrated athlete for you. Not just somebody in specific, but all hockey players. I think hockey is one of the Most I agree. For one, you're learning how to be coordinated to skateboard. You're hit, you're hitting each other, you're using the puck, you're. There's so many different things that go into hockey I think is very difficult. And then we got to give a shout out to our boy Chucky, right. When you look at somebody who was coming off an injury, right, he was out for most of the season, comes back to play with the Panthers and then just gets thrown right into this, this trip with United States. I mean, shout out to him. I, I think people aren't giving him the kudos that he deserves there. Obviously he's a top player in the NHL, but look at someone who was just coming off a major injury. He got back mid season for his regular season team, is now playing for the Olympics. I think that's something definitely that hasn't been highlighted as much going into how difficult hockey really is for guys and the toll that they take on their bodies. I mean you get to the end of the season, you realize that you have six bruised ribs, a concussion, you have all these no teeth. You got fake teeth in and dentures. So I think that's something that's definitely underrated that people don't realize.

[General]

Yeah. To piggyback on you, Wingo, I like

[Host]

that's a great take.

[General]

That's. I was actually going to go the hockey route as well. And the fact that you took all the hockey players is actually like. It's true though.

[Host]

It is, bro.

[General]

It's almost underrated sport.

[Host]

And obviously playing with like broken stern.

[General]

Crazy. It's crazy. But for me, kind of like you mentioned Chucky, right. Somebody who I don't think is as underrated anymore because of the run that we've had these last two years. But people are always, always sleeping on Barkov. Right. And Barkov is somebody that in these two years people have come to realize obviously how good he is now. Right. He's not as underrated as he was maybe just two years ago, but Barkov has been this guy for years, like eight years at this point. And, and I think it's even. You're even seeing it now with this current Panthers team. Like obviously we've missed him the entire year and not that like we're not like fully struggling, struggling, but like we're, we're going to have to make a big push again to the playoffs and missing Barkov is such a huge piece. So I think like in pairing with Chucky because Chucky's also been out like how important those two guys are to us. But also just like league wide. Because everyone talks about obviously McDavid, dry seidel. Like in my opinion, I think Barkov is the second best player in the NHL. And that's my take. I. I think Barkov. Conor McDavid is number one. Like he is. He's ridiculous. Barkov for me I think is it should be in the discussion for the second best player in the NHL. And he. He's rarely was in that conversation now. He's kind of entered it in terms of like people consider him like probably top five, I would assume five range. But I think he's number two. So.

[Host]

Yeah, no, I. I agree. Hockey players are at another level as far as like athletic abilities. Cuz they're doing all that on ice. Yeah, like. Yeah, it's insane.

[Wingo]

People don't want to do that on land, you know.

[Host]

You know what's funny is that by the way underrated. Well you know what? I'm going to make this as my take.

[General]

I'll make it after one of the. One of the early thing. You guys remember the show Sports Science. So one of my favorite. I just. I remember this like vividly is they had a thing about what sport gen like who sweats the most after a game. And the winner was actually hockey. Like they had technically the least amount or one of the least amount of time because they're always interchanging. But even those short spurts that they're on there, they are. They are doing so much. Exactly. That they actually even being in the ice, in the cold, they are. They finish a game and like they are the one, the most. The sweatiest athletes of all. And then two, you look at like you hear stories of. Of these goalies who will drop like £15 in a game throughout a game. Like and they're. You just think like they're just there, right? All those little moves constantly being like

[Host]

it because drainage you're. You're balancing the whole time. Like you got to be engaged at all times. You're not on flat land. Like it's. It's absurd.

[General]

It is crazy.

[Host]

Which I was gonna go you know, very similar route to like Wingo General, you know, general athlete. Which I'm gonna give him a little love right Is. Is those PGA Tour guys that are 100, 140 right. Where shit's coming out of their pocket. No one's really seeing the grind that you know those guys are going. And they're expensive. Fighting to make cuts. It's expensive. You pay for your Travel, you pay for your caddy, you pay for your coach, right? All these things. You might get some sponsors and stuff like that that help eat some of the cost throughout the year. But those guys are grinding, right? And you've seen guys like Jake Knaps, right, that they come out of nowhere, 150 plus, and then all of a sudden are now in the thick of it and making a ton of money, right? But it is a grind to be those guys. But when we were having this hockey talk, the referees, bro, are freak athletes, bro.

[General]

Yes, freak.

[Joe]

Those.

[Host]

Those pucks are coming under. They're jumping up in the air, landing smooth on their feet, dodging pucks, sprinting up and down the ice. Like, talk about athletes, bro. Those. I picture myself being a referee on ice, and you're just thinking, oh, you just got to watch the game, make sure no penalties. Break up a fight here or there's no, bro, those guys. Every time I see that guy jump clear in the air over a puck and land one, the instinct to react in real time to a puck coming God knows how fast at you and then land on the ice and then just keep moving like if nothing happened. Breaking up fights, being in the thing, always on.

[General]

On the ice, up and back, up and down, bro.

[Host]

And they. They don't have those intermission periods, you know? Like, some of these players have, like, obviously intermission of the actual periods ending. But, like, they're not getting on and off the ice. Like, they're up and down the whole time. So shout out the refs in hockey, because it is impressive what. What they do.

[General]

Yeah. Well, since we. Since we are. Oh, go. Go for Bob.

[Joe]

I was just. Me and Joe was actually on the phone this morning, and we were talking about the kid from Oregon coming out in this draft. He's a white safety. And I remember at first, I really didn't like him, and then I was like, man, we got to get him in the second round. And this morning, a report that came out said after the combine, he might be a top 20 pick.

[General]

Wow.

[Joe]

And I was like, dude, it's so crazy. And we started thinking about it. When was the last, like, real good, like, white safety. There's not. There's only a few, and there's, like, one for every decade. And that made me realize the most underrated player in the league might be Harrison Smith for the Vikings.

[Sylvania Commercial Announcer]

Wow.

[General]

I think you're gonna go.

[Host]

He's a dog put.

[Joe]

No one talks about Harrison Smith. That dude has been a dog for 15 straight years. Yeah, that dude is like, will come down and knock a motherfucker's head off and then take a pick six, 90 yards. And he's like 33 at this point. And like, no one talks about Harrison Smith. That dude has had no decline in 12 years.

[Host]

He is a dog.

[General]

That's a dog. That's a dog.

[Host]

People do not talk about him enough as being like one of those safeties. Like, like you said. How long has he been in the in the league now?

[General]

Been for a while, dog.

[Host]

Been there for three, huh?

[Sylvania Commercial Announcer]

Yeah.

[Wingo]

He's 33. Almost nine years. Nine, 10 years.

[Sylvania Commercial Announcer]

Yeah.

[Host]

Like it? I like it.

[Sylvania Commercial Announcer]

With Sylvania seeing better while driving at night starts with you because headlight bulbs dim over time and can lose up to 50ft of visibility before burnout. That's why you shouldn't wait. Upgrade your drive with brighter lights for better visibility on the road ahead. Sylvania's step by step installation video guides make it easier than ever to take control of your nighttime clarity, all without a trip to the mechanic. So before a burnout darkens your day, upgrade to Sylvania and see better tonight.

[State Farm Commercial Announcer]

Having the right people in your corner for life's biggest milestones makes all the difference. Like a friend who's there when you're house hunting or checking out a new ride, State Farm is there too, helping you choose the coverage you need. With a State Farm agent, you know someone is there to help you along the way. And with so many coverage options, it's nice knowing you have help choosing a plan that fits your needs so you can continue celebrating all of life's milestones. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there.

[McDonald's Commercial Announcer]

You've made it on time for the McDonald's breakfast menu. You think to yourself, finally I can start my day. But what if breakfast could be even more perfect with the hot honey sausage egg biscuit? It finally is. Go to McDonald's and get it while you can.