Podcast Summary: "Why Owning Your Audience Matters: AI, Email Newsletters, and the Future of Content"

Trends with Friends — Hosted by Howard Lindzon (with JC Parets, Phil Pearlman, Michael Parekh, guests Ben Kahn & Tyler Denk)
Date: December 18, 2024

Overview

This special year-end episode dives into the importance of owning your audience in a rapidly shifting digital landscape. The conversation spans the resurgence of email newsletters, the pitfalls of audience dependence on social platforms, the arc of media business models, and how AI and new tools like Beehive are empowering creators to build lasting, direct relationships with their communities.

Guests include Ben Kahn, trader and podcaster, and Tyler Denk, CEO/founder of Beehive, who share unique insights on creator monetization, the newsletter boom, platform risks, and future trends in content distribution, with further market commentary from AI and market expert Michael Parekh.

Main Discussion Themes

1. The Email Newsletter Renaissance & Platform Disillusionment

• The Collapse of Platform Trust:
  Tyler Denk recounts how publishers built huge followings on platforms like Facebook, only to be burned when algorithms changed.
  • “All those publishers got decimated... The platforms always win at the end of the day, and it typically comes at the expense of the publishers who had built up those networks.” — Tyler Denk (08:10)
• Why Email?
  Newsletters represent a resilient, decentralized means of audience ownership amid algorithmic control and the collapse of organic reach on social.
  • “Newsletter-first media companies are having a huge resurgence because they own the distribution, they own the audience.” — Tyler Denk (08:43)
• The Substack Dilemma:
  Tyler criticizes Substack’s pivot towards building a social network, highlighting misaligned incentives and tactics that siphon audience and control away from individual writers.
  • “Once your reader has downloaded the Substack app, that's no longer your reader. That is Substack's user...” (14:56)
• Supporting Independent Journalists:
  Beehive’s initiatives to provide legal and health support for creators reflect new models for sustainability outside major platforms. (13:54)

2. Building Tools for the Ownership Economy

• Beehive’s Platform Vision:
  Beehive aims to combine newsletters, websites, link-in-bio, community, courses, and more—reflecting the convergence of creator tools.
  • “We're going to start to see this convergence... I think we're going to see some start to emerge.” — Tyler Denk (18:38)
• Upcoming Website Builder:
  Launching January, Beehive will bundle advanced, customizable website functionality to rival WordPress, Webflow, Squarespace, but keep integration open.
  • “I think January is going to be a pretty big inflection point for the business where we can flip the model entirely on its head.” (21:13)
• Ecosystem Flexibility:
  Beehive’s openness allows users to integrate with external sites or leverage an internal template marketplace, unlike Substack’s walled garden.
  • “We are firmly pro-user in the sense of flexibility and autonomy to choose what tech stack you want...” (27:12)
• Vanity Metrics vs. Real Engagement:
  On Beehive, the focus is on authentic engagement, not inflated follower counts—growing organically and via opt-in cross-promotion between writers.
  • “If you come to Beehive, don't expect magic in terms of your followers... that's still got to be on me...” — Howard (64:12)

3. The Creator Economy: Monetization & the Algorithm Arms Race

• Algorithms, Creators, and Distribution:
  The group laments algorithmic gatekeeping—on YouTube, Twitter, elsewhere. Owning email lists is pitched as the best defense against platform volatility.
  • “In the 21st century… we are going from a 20th-century world gated by people and organizations to a world gated by algorithms.” — Michael Parekh (35:45)
  • “You need to subtly or forcefully start a weekly newsletter where your YouTube followers can actually hear directly from you.” — Howard (34:31)
• Ad Networks and Creator Revenue:
  Beehive’s upcoming ad network will allow any newsletter, no matter how niche, to easily monetize—with sponsors from Nike to Netflix—without the manual hassle.
  • “With two clicks and no relationship to any of these brands, you can have your newsletter sponsored by Nike and get paid…” — Tyler Denk (66:15)

4. AI, Market Tailwinds, and Next-Gen Infrastructure

• AI’s Transformative Impact:
  Michael Parekh explains how legacy companies like Broadcom are being revalued as AI infrastructure plays, not just chips, and AI’s impact will continue to ripple through incumbents and new startups.
  • “All these tech companies that have been around 30, 40 years… are now being discovered as AI companies because they have an AI tailwind.” — Michael Parekh (39:33)
• AI Productivity & Internal Automation:
  Tyler and Howard share how using AI to streamline internal workflows is more practical now than full-blown content generation.
  • “Rather than hiring having to hire three to four people to do a certain task, can we have one person spend half their time training an AI model...” — Tyler Denk (44:51)
• Google & Competition:
  Consensus is Google remains underestimated in AI, given their scale, proprietary hardware (TPUs), and asset moat—technological arms race is just beginning.
  • “Google is still viewed in a defensive crouch on AI and it's incorrect in my view… The US is actually in a pretty good place.” — Michael Parekh (47:24–48:51)

5. Platform Risk, Ownership, and the Future

• Platform Aggregators vs. Tools:
  Beehive deliberately positions itself as a "Shopify" (ownership tools), not an "Amazon" (aggregator), promising not to pull a Substack-style bait-and-switch.
  • “We are the Shopify as to Substack being an Amazon... We do not aggregate content.” — Tyler Denk (63:06)
• The Vanishing “Easy Mode”:
  The era of building an entire business atop a single platform’s algorithm is over—horizontal integration and business focus are now existential requirements for creators and startups.
  • “You cannot go do what you did in Web2. You have to have a business before you can land and expand.” — Howard Lindzon (28:56)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Newsletter Power:

  “I was able to send what I thought was a compelling case to 70,000 people directly, which... I would have never had the distribution on Twitter or LinkedIn to be able to communicate that.”
  — Tyler Denk (09:54)

• On Platform Rugpulls:

  “The original rug pull is Facebook. With all these changes, the networks that we thought were great were the original rug pulls, right?”
  — Howard Lindzon (11:05)

• On Algorithms & Survival:

  “Algorithms... we're not getting away from it. If anything, AI is going to accelerate it. We have to learn to live with them.”
  — Michael Parekh (35:45)

• On Monetization:

  “We allow you to offer paid subscriptions. We do not take 10% of your earnings... But the large majority of content creators and the way that people have made money on the Internet... has been via ads.”
  — Tyler Denk (66:15)

• On Platform Independence:

  “Once your reader has downloaded the Substack app, that's no longer your reader. That is Substack's user...”
  — Tyler Denk (14:56)

• On Tesla & Elon Musk:

  “I'm just tired of opening up Twitter every day and his dog tweets are at the top of my algorithm... For a guy who's been so obsessed with short sellers, who by the way, he should be commending because without the short sellers squeezing his stock higher, he wouldn't be worth what he is today.”
  — Ben Kahn (53:14)

Key Segments & Timestamps

• 00:09 – 08:10: Year-end context; panel intros; framing of degenerate trends, AI, and email newsletter focus.
• 08:10 – 15:36: Tyler Denk on the rise and risks of email newsletters and pitfalls of Substack’s social strategy.
• 15:36 – 22:03: Deep dive on Beehive’s competitive landscape, product roadmap, and comparison with legacy platforms.
• 25:31 – 28:41: Practical discussion on website building, WordPress vs. Beehive, open ecosystem philosophy.
• 31:07 – 37:21: YouTube and the creator dilemma; algorithm frustrations and why email is the best hedge.
• 37:30 – 48:51: Michael Parekh on AI market shake-ups; Broadcom, NVIDIA, Google, the new “Magnificent Eight.”
• 51:44 – 62:01: Elon Musk, Tesla, platform power, and the future of audience control.
• 62:01 – 66:15: Platform integrity: how Beehive avoids becoming the next Substack, ad network vision.
• 68:18 – 73:22: Trends With No Friends: Argentine equities, meme stocks, lessons from crowded trades.

Tone & Style

• Candid, humorous, occasionally irreverent (“Coronado is full... the only place in America where you can still get a jaywalking ticket and kind of thank the policeman”—Howard).
• Blunt, practical advice punctuated by sharp industry critique: from “platform rugpulls” to “vanity metrics.”
• Firsthand, insider perspectives from guests and panelists who've both ridden and built waves in the creator and financial economy.

Takeaways for Listeners

• Modern content creators should relentlessly strive for direct audience ownership via email and their own domains—not rented algorithmic reach.
• Platforms will always optimize for their own interests; flexible, open tools like Beehive let creators guard against capricious policy, shadowbanning, and the next big rugpull.
• AI is transforming not just content, but the plumbing of work itself, supercharging efficiency for those who wield it effectively.
• In both investing and content, avoid the “trend with too many friends”—the best gains often come from unloved, under-followed opportunities.
• The next era belongs to those blending creative content with creative infrastructure—rewiring the Internet for genuine independence and resilience.

For more, subscribe to the Trends with Friends newsletter or follow the show on YouTube for future updates and deep dives on these ongoing trends.