Loading summary
Mike Ferguson
They say imitation is the highest form of flattery. But I say when it comes to preparing for my next of kin, I want the proven original the Knockbox. With more than 400,000 satisfied customers, the Knockbox is a complete system that will help you organize everything in your life, from your accounts to your spare keys to your estate plans. With a Knockbox, your loved ones won't have to search through drawers or struggle to access online accounts during an already difficult time. Each folder inside of your Knockbox inside includes a checklist that tells you what to add to the folder and tells your next of kin what to do with the information. You can't get more comprehensive than a Knockbox, so don't settle for a knockoff. No, no, no. Get the gold standard in organizational systems and make life easier for your next of kin. Go to thenockbox.com and use code TCAT today to save 16% on the knockbox of your choosing. That. That's the inokbox.com code TCATT at checkout to save 16%.
Ollie Advertiser
Goodbye New Year, new you. This season, Ollie is here to help you embrace a slower pace. The kind where you cozy up at home with your dog tucked right beside you. After the holiday rush and all the spending, you're probably craving those quieter moments, soft blankets, a comfy couch, and the kind of emotional reset that only happens when you're curled up with your p up. Spending intentional time with your dog isn't just comforting. It's proven to support your mood, reduce stress, and help you feel more present during the winter slowdown. If you're leaning into that slower, more intentional rhythm, Ollie can help support it with fresh human grade food, slow cooked recipes, tailored meal plans, and an app that lets you tap real experts whenever you need peace of mind. Visit ollie.com wondery and use code wondery for 60% off your first.
Mike Ferguson
Hello, everyone, and welcome to episode 477 of the True Crime all the Time podcast. I'm Mike Ferguson, and with me, as always, is my partner in True Crime, Mike Gibson. Gibby, how are you?
Mike Gibson
Hey. I'm doing pretty good. How about you?
Mike Ferguson
I'm doing great.
Mike Gibson
That's good.
Mike Ferguson
Having an amazing week, to be honest with you.
Mike Gibson
Why does it have to be amazing?
Mike Ferguson
Because that's how I roll.
Mike Gibson
Yeah. You know, you could say I'm having a mediocre week.
Mike Ferguson
I work in superlatives. That's just. That's just how I am.
Mike Gibson
Throwing your big words out again.
Mike Ferguson
All right, buddy, we're jumping right in.
Mike Gibson
We are.
Mike Ferguson
We're talking about the abduction of Connie and Larry Van Oosten. And I found this to be just a fascinating case. In February 2017, Connie and Larry Van Houston were abducted from their home by a masked man and held in a makeshift dungeon inside a basement. Authorities were shocked when they learned the suspect was someone from the Van Oosten. Small, peaceful town. And we're going to get into all the details. Right. As we always do. But, you know, I. I think. And you and I have touched on this before. Your home, kind of your. Your safe place, your sanctuary, for sure. Right. When that is invaded, I don't know. For me, there's like, an extra element to it. Now, it would be horrible to be snatched up on the street, but there's something about a home invasion that I think really scares people.
Mike Gibson
Well, because after that, if you survive, where would you ever feel safe again?
Mike Ferguson
Right. Because that home is the place where you are supposed to. To feel safe.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
Connie and Larry Van Houston are a married couple from Erie, Illinois, a small town in Whiteside County. They have two children, Amy and Jeff. Connie and Larry were both in their early 60s, and they were both retired. Connie once owned a flooring store, and Larry operated a pest control company. Now, their daughter Amy took over the flooring store after her daughter was born. Jeff didn't want to take over the pest control company because he was already pursuing a career in Florida farming.
Mike Gibson
Okay.
Mike Ferguson
Larry sold that business, and it was said that he made enough money to, you know, invest, live off of that, and retire.
Mike Gibson
Well, there you go.
Mike Ferguson
And I'm kind of viewing this as, like, the dream. Right. You have a couple of businesses, you made money. You're able to pass one of them down, sell the other. But you're in your kind of golden years, your retirement years, and you have enough money to live on.
Mike Gibson
You can do those things you've been wanting to do.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, absolutely. And he and Connie did some traveling. They also dedicated more time to their church and volunteering in the community. They also loved being grandparents to Amy and Jeff's children. My wife and I keep dropping subtle hints to our daughters, you know.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
Especially our oldest daughter. Not our youngest. Yeah. But my oldest, who is getting married this year. You know, we keep saying we can't wait to be grandparents, you know, to
Mike Gibson
have a true crime all the time. Grandchild.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah. I will have onesies made up. I'll go. I'll do it all.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
I think a pacifier that says TK
Mike Gibson
Why do I feel like you have the diaper stamp with Gibby on them?
Mike Ferguson
This One's full of gibby.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
This one's been used. So, I mean, that's good. Right? We work essentially our whole lives, if you think about it.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
Now we are living longer. Right. People are living longer than they ever have before. But you work, work, work, work to get to the point where you can retire and then hopefully still be in good enough health to do some of the things you want to do.
Mike Gibson
That's the plan. Right.
Mike Ferguson
I think the other thing that goes along with that is you have to have the money.
Mike Gibson
Yeah, you do.
Mike Ferguson
So that means during all of that working time, you have to have saved enough to have a nest egg that you can live off during retirement. At 4:45pm on February 8, 2017, the Whiteside County Sheriff's Office received a call about a possible kidnapping at First Trust and Savings bank in Albany, Illinois. What happened was Connie Van Houston entered the bank and she requested $350,000. She passed a note to the teller indicating that she and her husband Larry were being held against their will and they needed help.
Mike Gibson
I mean, that would be an interesting note to receive as a teller. I mean, 1, $350,000. I don't know if most banks even have that type of cash on hand without a fair notice ahead of time.
Mike Ferguson
I think most banks do you. Yeah. But how many people actually walk in and say, you know, by the way, I need $350,000 in cash. Yeah. Not many. And you're going to be questioned.
Mike Gibson
Oh, for sure. I mean, you can't even get $3,000 out without them saying, what's this money used for?
Mike Ferguson
Yeah. And we know, having worked, and you still work in the financial industry, but, you know, anything over, what, 10, then you're. You're getting into the area of, like, a suspicious activity report. And there's. There's protocols around that. $350,000 is definitely going to make the alarm bells go off.
Mike Gibson
Sure.
Mike Ferguson
But then on top of that, Right. You have this note.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
And it was said that Connie wrote the note on a church bulletin that she had in her purse. So, you know, you've seen that before in movies, you know, pass a note to the teller. Hey, we're being. We're being held up. Bank employees tried to talk Connie in to stay, but she said she was afraid her husband would be killed. And if she didn't leave, the bank tellers agreed to give her the check because they didn't want anything to happen to her. And, you know, I thought, okay, a check seems strange. If someone is holding you for Ransom or holding you against your will for money. Normally, they want cash because a check is fairly easy to trace.
Mike Gibson
It's very traceable, even if it's made out to cash. Right. You're going to at least know what bank it was cashed at and what.
Mike Ferguson
Well, who's going to. Who's going to cash a $350,000 back? And if you deposited it, obviously they're going to know where it was, you know, what account it was deposited into. But I also understand, okay, Connie's hesitant to stay. On the one hand, she could be safe if she stays in the bank, but then she's leaving her. Her husband and. Okay, most spouses wouldn't want to do that.
Mike Gibson
There's some spouses that might do that, but.
Mike Ferguson
Well, yeah, my wife probably would.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
Maybe she's like, I know I'm safe. Hopefully he's. Everything goes okay with him, but good luck to you. If not, you know, we'll make it through.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
Connie left the building, and the staff called the police. Connie was captured on surveillance leaving the bank, walking down the street and getting into a vehicle that then drove out of the area. The problem was the license plate wasn't visible in the video. Jeff Van Oosten called his sister Amy around 5:30pm to tell her that their parents had been abducted. A friend in the police department told Jeff what had happened. And that's a tough call to make to your sibling.
Mike Gibson
Oh, yeah.
Mike Ferguson
You know, hey, mom and dad have been abducted. I don't have all the details, let's say I don't know what's going on, but, hey, it's not good. Amy then soon received a call from the police asking her to meet them.
Mike Gibson
Well, I'm sure the police want to try to gather as much information that maybe the kids can help with, you know, maybe fill in some. Some blanks or. A lot of blanks. Right.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah.
Mike Gibson
In the process of what happened.
Mike Ferguson
Well, and depending on what the police know, they have to rule the kids out. Right. Because the kids are most likely heirs. Yeah. To the money. At 6:15pm deputies went to the Van Houston's home and found Jeff already there. Jeff said that he'd been away from home on a business trip in Washington and hadn't heard from his parents. Deputy searched the property and discovered that a basement window had broken or had been broken from the outside.
Mike Gibson
Okay, so point of entry, most likely.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah. I think, you know, if you're the authorities, you kind of have to go that route. Inside the house, they found Taser, confetti And a few drops of blood on the carpet.
Mike Gibson
So maybe where the Taser hit somebody.
Mike Ferguson
Mm. I don't know if there's, you know, stuff that comes out.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
Along with the probes, typically.
Mike Gibson
I mean, you have not been tasered, have you?
Mike Ferguson
No, no.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
No, that's something I try to stay away from.
Mike Gibson
It doesn't feel good.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, it doesn't look like it. On the body cam videos that I watch now, I did learn that there is a very distinct difference between when they press the taser onto you.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
Which does cause pain.
Mike Gibson
Right.
Mike Ferguson
Versus when they shoot you with the Taser. And the barbs stick in. Right. That's where you really get the, like, involuntary muscular incapacitation.
Mike Gibson
Right.
Mike Ferguson
The other one just hurts.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
I did not know that.
Mike Gibson
Yeah. That's when I wet myself that one time. Yeah. It happens.
Mike Ferguson
Stop doing yourself. Stop doing questionable stuff, and you won't have that problem. So, you know, what we have is a. A bad situation. Right. From what we know so far, Whiteside county authorities reached out to the FBI for assistance. Both Jeff and Amy were questioned to rule out their involvement, which we talked about. Right. They have to do that protocol. Jeff faced more scrutiny because he'd been out of town and was at the house before the police arrived. He was asked if he was having financial trouble or if he'd borrowed money from his parents. Jeff was more than willing to answer all of their questions, and he and Amy were cleared of any involvement in. In their parents disappearance.
Mike Gibson
That's the best way to get cleared. Be upfront, honest about everything going on. No surprises.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah. Be truthful.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
Right. Well, if you haven't done anything wrong, it's very easy to be truthful.
Mike Gibson
Well, that's true.
Mike Ferguson
The FBI determined that the vehicle captured on surveillance was a Chevy Caprice from the early 1990s. So. All right, we're talking about 2017 here. By 2017, how many early 1990s Chevy Caprices are still operating?
Mike Gibson
Probably not very many.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, I would think it would narrow the number quite a bit. We're not talking about a 2015 F Ford F150. Right. Where there'd be. Oh, my God, Tons and tons of them. But nothing showed up in the computer system, so the surveillance video was just distributed to the media.
Mike Gibson
This Caprice were huge. The 1990 ones.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah. Were they the rounded ones? Because in the old days, they were boxy.
Mike Gibson
Yeah. Really boxy.
Mike Ferguson
And then I thought they went. They went to more of a rounded look, but I don't know if that was the early 90s or not.
Mike Gibson
I think it was like mid-90s. They finally went to that look. And short. They were shortened up to a little bit.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, they were boats there for a while.
Mike Gibson
They were.
Mike Ferguson
But I. You know, to me, that's a smart thing. Right? You have surveillance video. Get it out to the media. Kind of reminds me of the Nancy Guthrie case that is very current, dominating the media right now. And, you know, like that. The FBI received multiple tips in this case. One witness saw the vehicle in Geneseo, Illinois, or as you like to say, Illinois.
Mike Gibson
And I would say Genesosi, Illinois.
Mike Ferguson
Okay. I'm not sure I said it correctly, but I know for a freaking fact you. You didn't say it correctly.
Mike Gibson
I would love it.
Mike Ferguson
Genesosi.
Mike Gibson
Somebody from Genesis. Jenna. Genesis, Genesiso.
Mike Ferguson
You've said it four different ways now, and none of them have the correct number of consonants to support that.
Mike Gibson
That's true. That's true. But maybe somebody. Hey, actually, that's how we say it here.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, maybe.
Mike Gibson
I'd love it.
Mike Ferguson
People say that just because they want to be on your side, though, too. So a witness saw vehicle. The car was heading northbound. The FBI learned that Connie obtained the $350,000 and in the form of a cashier's check that was made out to a company called the Storedge LLC, which
Mike Gibson
I find very strange because you can search LLCs.
Mike Ferguson
Oh, absolutely. Find out who owns it, all of that. An older model Chevy Caprice was registered to an individual connected to the business, a man named Chad Skipper. And investigators, you know, what they had to do was establish some type of connection. Right. Between the Van Oostens and Chad Skipper. Jeff and Amy were completely shocked, and they couldn't believe that Chad would be involved in abducting their parents. They had both known Chad for many years. He attended their church. He was in their youth groups. Chad was a year ahead of Jeff in school. They didn't have the same friend group, but they were friendly with each other and said hello in passing.
Mike Gibson
Okay, but somebody they knew.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, somebody they knew. But also, back to some of the things that you've been talking about. Didn't take authorities very long to figure out who this was. Right where you had the kind of. I don't want to say odd but not very plentiful car, the Chevy Caprice. You've also asked for the check to be mailed out to a business that you actually have a connection to.
Mike Gibson
Yeah. You had the check made out to this llc. Doesn't seem like you're very smart about this.
Mike Ferguson
So what does that mean? Either the person is, like you said, not very smart or wasn't planned out well, was, you know, spur of the moment and they just didn't know what to do.
Mike Gibson
Yeah, didn't think it through.
Mike Ferguson
You know, my wife and I have had a Thrive Market membership for quite a while now and we have no plans to give it up. There's a lot to love about Thrive Market, but a couple of things we really love is the convenience of getting items delivered and being able to filter by dietary preference for the entire family. Thrive Market is a membership based grocery service where you can shop from wherever you are. Simply just hop on their app. The membership breaks down to just $5 a month and it gives members access to weekly sales, personalized shopping with filters, auto ship and save, free gifts, and peace of mind knowing there's no junk in any of the products they carry. Instead of paying fees on every grocery delivery order, you. You pay once for the year and benefit from it every time you shop. And the membership gives me access to brands and flavors I never see in my local store. And I don't have to worry about perusing labels because Thrive Market's already done that for me. And for less than the price of one latte, I get all of this. Ready to make healthy swaps and become a member. Join Thrive Market with our link thrivemarket.com tcatt for 30% off your first order plus a free $60 gift.
Sponsor Announcer
This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever find yourself playing the budgeting game? Well, with the name your price tool from Progressive, you can find options that fit your budget and potentially lower your bills. Try it@progressive.com, progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Price and coverage match, limited by state law. Not available in all states.
Mike Ferguson
Chad was valedictorian of his class. Jeff looked up to him because of his intelligence. And this Chad guy seemed like he had it all together.
Mike Gibson
So he's not somebody that's dumb.
Mike Ferguson
No, no. He obviously must have been smart. And I think he was popular as well. Chad and Larry were both elders at their church a couple of years prior. Chad was starting out as a financial advisor and Larry decided to seek him out and, you know, meet with him about potentially becoming a client.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
When Larry reviewed Chad's proposal, he decided not to work with him because he didn't think it would benefit his investments. They discussed their investments with Chad during the meeting, which is important because that means he was acutely aware. Right. Of just how much money they had.
Mike Gibson
Yeah. At that point, he knew there was 350, 000 sitting in the bank.
Mike Ferguson
Well, and they could have had a
Mike Gibson
lot more than that, but he knew that. Right.
Mike Ferguson
At least they had that. Yeah, probably. Jeff and Amy recalled their parents mentioning this meeting when it happened. In the early hours of February 9, 2017, the FBI linked Chad Skipper to two properties in Geneseo. One of the addresses was a large rental home with a four car garage. Agents went to the property, but they didn't find anything out of the ordinary unusual from the outside. So they didn't have probable cause to
Mike Gibson
conduct a search, which I find strange. Right. I mean, you know that where the check was made out to, you know about the Caprice, you have some other knowledge around it. But know, obviously the courts must need a lot more information than that before you can enter the home.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, I mean it's, it's, you know, it's one of our protections that we have. And I get it. I, I don't want police coming into my house for no reason just because they think I might have some done something or know something about something.
Mike Gibson
Well, you do.
Mike Ferguson
I know some stuff about things you've done.
Mike Gibson
Well, I didn't want to say that on camera, but yeah, let's go ahead
Mike Ferguson
and throw it out there. Agents split up and they conducted surveillance on the rental home and the Van Houston home in Erie. A deputy watching the Van Houston house saw a silver Caprice in the area and they attempted to pull the driver over. The driver acted like they were going to stop, but then they sped up. And I see this actually quite a bit on my body cam videos.
Mike Gibson
Love that stuff.
Mike Ferguson
I do love the, the videos, but people will pull over and it's like they wait for the police officer to get out of the car and maybe get about three fourths of the way to their car and then they take off because they know it's going to give them a little bit of lead time. The officers then got to race back to their car, get in.
Mike Gibson
I, I guess if you stole the car, that might work for you, but if you didn't steal the car, well, they see your license plate, they have your license plate, they know who you are, where you live.
Mike Ferguson
Well, and also look at the technology today with helicopters, you know, you can't outrun a radio, you know, so, you know, there's night vision. There's just so much technology. Also, if I'm being honest, I don't know that a early 1990s caprice is the best vehicle to choose to try to get away from Police?
Mike Gibson
Yeah, probably not. I'm sure it had a big V8 in it. Probably.
Mike Ferguson
But still, it also weighs a ton. You know, we're not talking about a Hellcat or, you know, a Corvette, a Lamborghini or something like this. You're. You're basically driving a tank, a tank down the road. Now if you want to ram into some people or you want to try to not get, like, pit maneuvered, yeah, that might be a good car for it, but I just don't know. I don't think you're out running anybody.
Mike Gibson
I don't think you're going to be able to get away.
Mike Ferguson
It's kind of like Jason Bateman and horrible bosses when he's driving the Prius and they're talking to the police and he says he drag races and he says, I don't win a lot.
Mike Gibson
Yeah, of course not.
Mike Ferguson
Which I thought. It's just the way he delivers the line that to me is so funny. So obviously a high speed chase ensues, and it ended on Illinois Route 84. The driver swerved into the opposite lane as another car was approaching. They were, you know, going fast, obviously it's high speed, and crashed into a guardrail. Luckily, the other driver only had minor injuries, and the driver of the Caprice was identified as Chad Skipper. Okay, so you talked about probable cause before. You know, I think, you know, the burden's high, right, to enter someone's home. But pretty obvious what we're dealing with here.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
Why does this guy not want to pull over? Why does he not want to stop? And then why are you trying to run away from police? And he pretty readily admitted that he was holding the Van Houston and even gave the address that FBI agents were already staking out.
Mike Gibson
He came sort of clean or he came clean.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, yeah. And, you know, I'm always fascinated by interrogations. Right. They can go a couple of different ways, a few different ways. You have the people who, no matter what you say to them, no matter what mountain of evidence you throw at them, they're never going to admit to what they've actually done. And then you have the people who, you know, right out of the gate, they say, nah, you got the wrong person. It wasn't me. But they wear down.
Mike Gibson
Sure they do.
Mike Ferguson
And then they kind of fold as time goes on. And then you have some people who just, like, right off the bat are like, yeah, you got me.
Mike Gibson
I just. I think Chad was going to have a hard time explaining some items that were in his car when they did finally get a Hold of him.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, yeah, no doubt about it. Because when they searched his car, they found a shovel. They found plastic sheeting, duct tape, a saw. I mean, basically, this is some Dexter type stuff. Indications that he was planning on burying a body or multiple bodies.
Mike Gibson
I mean, a saw. I mean, he was playing on cutting them up.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, potentially. Yeah, yeah, no doubt about it. But I mean, we all carry things inside our vehicle. What most people don't carry is essentially a hit kit or an after a hit kit to bury a body. Yeah, you might take a shovel if you're going to do some work. People might have duct tape just for general repair or whatever. But it's. It's all of it together. Right.
Mike Gibson
You know, before I leave here tonight, I need to leave something in your garage.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, I would prefer you didn't. Yeah. So that's kind of a standing rule that we have. No leaving stuff in my house.
Sponsor Announcer
That's right.
Mike Gibson
Take my stuff with me.
Mike Ferguson
You've tried multiple times.
Mike Gibson
A few.
Mike Ferguson
So at 3am Agents kicked in the door of Skipper's property. They cleared the entire house, but they couldn't find Larry or Connie. During the second round of searching, they discovered a TV monitor on the floor of one of the rooms that showed a surveillance video feed. And they could see footage of two people lying on a mattress in a room with no windows or doors. Agents had a feeling that, you know, Connie and Larry were inside the house. They just weren't looking in the right spot. They just couldn't find them. This gives me a little bit of like saw vibes.
Mike Gibson
It does, yeah.
Mike Ferguson
Right. You have the surveillance video that, you know, the saw guys looking at or whoever is the saw person at that point. Those movies get a little convoluted a little bit. Yeah, at times. But how do you have a room with no windows or doors then? That's an interesting concept. It also makes it kind of hard to find people. You don't think about searching that?
Mike Gibson
No.
Mike Ferguson
Right. But during the search, the agents noticed that it looked like a wall had recently been put up in the basement. In an upstairs closet, an agent removed a piece of plywood covering the floor, revealing a solid steel hatch. Agents cut the lock and opened the hatch, which then led to a secret room in the basement.
Mike Gibson
Wow. I mean, some of that planning.
Mike Ferguson
Well, what does that tell us, though? This guy didn't abduct these two people and then all of a sudden install all this?
Mike Gibson
Right.
Mike Ferguson
This was done ahead of time.
Mike Gibson
Definitely pre planned.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah. There's no doubt about it now whether it was specifically for them, you know, we'll have to talk about. But, you know, it's a little bit. I don't want to use the word ingenious, because I don't want to give this guy credit. But, you know, if you're searching, let's say, my basement here. Right, Right. The studio is in my basement. You look over and you see that wall. There's no door. There's no nothing. You just assume there's nothing behind it.
Mike Gibson
But little do they know there is.
Mike Ferguson
There isn't, because that's concrete, But.
Mike Gibson
Oh, is this. When we go. It's concrete.
Mike Ferguson
It's concrete. Concrete. But is. It's a little bit of an ingenious plan. Although I hate to give this person credit. Inside that room were Connie and Larry, who were lying on a mattress. Larry recalled that it was a very joyful moment.
Mike Gibson
I bet it was.
Mike Ferguson
When they were rescued.
Mike Gibson
Yeah. I'm sure you thought things were going to be over soon.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah. I could imagine in a scenario like that, whether you're by yourself and, in this case, husband and wife are together, you are probably, I would think, Gibbs, at the very least, making right with the situation, that you may not come out of this a lot. So to all of a sudden have law enforcement show up and save you. I. I can't even imagine what that feeling would be like, because, obviously, I've never been in that position.
Mike Gibson
I think you would definitely be. Happy.
Mike Ferguson
That's your adjective.
Mike Gibson
Happy.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah. Yeah. I'll go with happy. There are a lot that you could use, but. Yeah.
Mike Gibson
Yeah, happy.
Mike Ferguson
So, you know, I. Again, joyful, happy. Whatever you want to call it. Larry said they told us it was the FBI and they were here to rescue us and that we were safe. And again, at that moment, it had to be one of the better feelings that they'd probably experienced in their lives.
Mike Gibson
Music to my ears.
Mike Ferguson
But Chad Skipper had created basically a makeshift dungeon right inside the basement. The walls of the room were reinforced with steel.
Mike Gibson
Okay.
Mike Ferguson
Which they'd have to be, because if you think about just putting drywall up. Well, you can bust through drywall. Yeah.
Mike Gibson
Kick your way out of that.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, you just kick in between the studs. You just walk right through. Like the. Yeah, like the Kool Aid, man. So something's gonna have to be reinforced. And then the metal hatch could only be opened from the outside. And we mentioned it. Right. He had installed cameras connected to monitor the room.
Mike Gibson
I mean, he did put some planning into this.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, quite a bit, I would think. There were stacks of ramen inside the Room, as well as a shower and a toilet on the other side was a locking mechanism for handcuffing. Oh. So my assumption would be, you know, if he needed to come down.
Mike Gibson
Right.
Mike Ferguson
He would maybe handcuff one and handcuff the other. There's got to be a system to where you're not putting yourself in jeopardy that you're going to be overpowered.
Mike Gibson
Right. He'd have them go to that wall, put their hands through, maybe chain them up, then go down and do whatever. Restock the ramen.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, something like that. Hopefully chili ramen because that's my very favorite.
Mike Gibson
I don't know if it's spicy and you're in a dungeon with only one toilet.
Mike Ferguson
You're right.
Mike Gibson
You might want to rethink that.
Mike Ferguson
The room obviously had been designed to hold people against their will. And it was clear, like you said, that Skipper had put significant effort into building this room and also planning the abduction. You know, a thoughtfully built wardrobe comes down to pieces that mix well. And last, that's where Quint shines. Premium fabrics considered design and everyday essentials that feel effortless to wear and dependable even as the seasons change. My wife absolutely adores their lightweight cashmere sweaters. I'm more of a flow knit performance type of guy, but they have everything I need. Lightweight joggers, shorts, tops, but they also have coats. European jersey linen. Quint works directly with top factories and cuts out the middlemen. You're not paying for brand markup but or fancy retail stores, just quality clothing. And they only partner with factories that meet rigorous standards for craftsmanship and ethical production. Right now go to quint.com teacat for free shipping and 365 day returns. That's a full year to build your wardrobe and love it. And you will now available in Canada too. Don't keep settling for clothes that don't last. Go to quince.com/tcatt for free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.comTCAT in his post arrest interview, Chad admitted that he had been thinking about the abduction for a long time. He said I wanted to do it and I did do it. Money was tight and I kept trying to find a way to push it and push it. It was said that he was low on money due to some bad investment.
Mike Gibson
Okay, so your fix is to kidnap this couple, take their money?
Mike Ferguson
Well, sure.
Mike Gibson
And then because you can't have them remain alive, you're going to kill them?
Mike Ferguson
Most likely. Also, he can't manage his own money. Probably good that Larry didn't invest his money with him.
Mike Gibson
That's what I was thinking the same thing. And then I'm thinking, so you're going to get this money. You suck at managing your own money.
Mike Ferguson
Probably going to lose that, too.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
And then you're going to be back to square one where you gotta, what, rob somebody else?
Mike Gibson
Yeah. How many people are in this town that you can pull this off with?
Mike Ferguson
But, you know, this is what strikes me about a lot of these types of crimes. You have somebody who we'll call it being in a. In a pinch.
Mike Gibson
Right.
Mike Ferguson
During a bad situation. And I get it. Nobody wants to be bro. Broke or nobody wants to. When. When you're kind of riding on top, let's say stumble, you make some bad investments, you lose a bunch of money. But there are ways to dig yourself out.
Mike Gibson
Of course there is.
Mike Ferguson
Of any of those situations. But I think so often people want to find the easy way out, the quick solution, even if it involves stealing from or hurting other people.
Mike Gibson
I'm thinking this guy here, I mean, if you filed bankruptcy, isn't that better? And you be out of it and, I don't know, four, five, six, seven years versus robbery.
Mike Ferguson
Taking the chance on spending maybe the rest of your life in jail. Yeah.
Mike Gibson
If you're gonna have to kill the
Mike Ferguson
people, I would think so. It's just, you know, on the one hand, you have Larry and Connie who had essentially worked their entire lives to support their family, raise their kids, and put enough money away to, you know, live well during retirement.
Mike Gibson
They did everything right. They did everything they were supposed to do to get to the point that they could retire and do the things they wanted.
Mike Ferguson
Yes, absolutely. And then you have their captor who basically wants to skip all of that part and go straight to the money. And. And it just. Could it work? I guess you could get away with it, but, you know, you could also just put in the hard work like the rest of us.
Mike Gibson
Exactly.
Mike Ferguson
To get what you want. Chad told investigators, I asked Larry and Connie for money a few years back. If they had helped me out, then things might have been different.
Mike Gibson
Probably not because you were not good at investing your own money, but also,
Mike Ferguson
what kind of sense does that make? You know, okay, they wouldn't give me any money or loan me money or whatever the situation was. So this is how it had to turn out. No, it didn't have to turn out that way. You know how rich people stay rich? By not giving away their money.
Mike Gibson
Exactly, exactly.
Mike Ferguson
Or not investing it with people who they don't have a Good feeling about.
Mike Gibson
I mean, they work hard for that money. They have their money. Why would they give it to him? I mean, it doesn't make any sense.
Mike Ferguson
No, not at all. Chad admitted that he knew the police could track him through the llc, but said, I was only thinking about the moment and getting the money.
Mike Gibson
There you go.
Mike Ferguson
It goes back to what we were talking about earlier. He had planned all of this out, but then he doesn't plan. That part just doesn't make sense.
Mike Gibson
And I get it. He was the top of his class,
Mike Ferguson
but he's also a financial guy.
Mike Gibson
Well, but we know he's not a very good financial.
Mike Ferguson
Well, that's. That's true. That's true. He claimed he was disassociated during the commission of the crime, saying, I looked at it through as if I was someone else looking through what I was doing. The demon inside me.
Mike Gibson
The demon. Huh?
Mike Ferguson
Frog demon.
Mike Gibson
Frog demon.
Mike Ferguson
Which we haven't actually talked about in a long time. He's talking about his frog demon.
Mike Gibson
Yeah. There was a different demon here.
Mike Ferguson
Well, you have a couple of frog demons that people have sent in. Yeah. To you over the years.
Mike Gibson
That's the one I know mostly, though.
Mike Ferguson
But, you know, you hear this from criminals from time to time. It's like I was standing above myself seeing myself do this. It wasn't really me. No, it was you.
Mike Gibson
Yeah, it was you for sure.
Mike Ferguson
Larry and Connie recounted the abduction in an interview for the show fet. Larry said, it was about 7 o' clock in the morning. I was sound asleep. I thought I was dreaming. I felt a presence in the room. And I saw this person standing next to the bed, dressed in black and with a gun. Finally, I realized this is real. And I yelled. And the next thing I knew, he shot a taser at me. Connie said, the first words that I spoke were, oh, Lord, please help us. Please help us. And his first words to me were, where's your God now?
Mike Gibson
Okay.
Mike Ferguson
Pretty rough for a couple of very
Mike Gibson
religious people, including him. He attended the same church.
Mike Ferguson
That is true. I forgot about that. But again, as I've said often, you know, these home invasion type scenarios are very scary to me. You know, you're. You're supposed to be all bundled up safe in your home. You're sleeping. We've talked about how vulnerable people are when they're sleeping. You wake up to see a man all in black with a gun. Very scary.
Mike Gibson
It would be scary.
Mike Ferguson
Connie was forced to handcuff Larry, and the masked man handcuffed her. He put tape on their Eyes and mouths. And they were ordered to keep quiet. They were forced into the trunk of the Chevy Capri and were in the car for about half an hour. Now, those cars did have a big trunk.
Mike Gibson
They did. Kind of. Probably kind of roomy. I mean, if you're going to be put into a trunk, that.
Mike Ferguson
That's not a bad car to.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
For it to be.
Mike Gibson
Stretch your legs out a little bit.
Mike Ferguson
Connie said that once they arrived at the house, he took me out first and led me to what I thought was going to be a small room, but it turned out to be a closet. And then I had to climb down a ladder. Connie asked Chad, why are you doing this? He said he would keep them until he got all their money and then he would have to kill them.
Mike Gibson
Well, he's being upfront about it.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah. Which I guess, to me, is kind of a strange way to go about it. Maybe you might want to give the person some hope. I'm not telling abductors how to do their business, obviously, but, you know, when you tell someone that you're going to kill them ahead of time, what do they have to lose?
Mike Gibson
What's their incentive to help you get
Mike Ferguson
what you need and be cooperative and all that? Connie knew that writing the note at the bank was their last chance to be rescued. They believed that God helped them through their ordeal. Larry recalled the fear he felt when Connie was taken to the bank. He said, when he took her through the bank, I kept going through different scenarios. What should I have done? What could I have done? What can I do? How do I help her? And just being tied up there and knowing there was nothing I could do to help her. I'll never forget that. And that must have been a sense of helplessness. That would just drive you crazy.
Mike Gibson
Would it? Would.
Mike Ferguson
Connie said, larry never thought that he protected me, but he did. He stood by me the whole time, and he was there and did everything in his power to protect me. And he's continued to do that. And let's face it, what else could the guy do? You have a guy with a gun, right? You're tied up. You don't have a lot of options. Not just tied up. You're handcuffed.
Mike Gibson
Very limited.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah. You're limited in what you can do,
Mike Gibson
but at least you know he's letting her know I'm here with you. We're in this together.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah. And Larry called his wife a hero, saying she didn't have to come back. She could have stayed right there at the bank and sent the police. But she didn't do it. She came back on her own free will just so they could find me. She came back to save me.
Mike Gibson
Yeah, she really did.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah.
Mike Gibson
And that says a lot.
Mike Ferguson
It does. I mean, you really have to give her credit for that, because I'm sure that must have been a scary thing to do. But I think it also shows you, you know, how much she loved her husband.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
I mean, she wasn't going to leave him alone.
Mike Gibson
Some wives or partners would have stayed. Some might not have even went to the bank to get the check.
Mike Ferguson
Just taken off. Yeah. And Left Forever. On February 9, 2017, Chad Skipper was charged with home invasion, kidnapping, and two counts of aggravated kidnapping. Chad's parents, Marlon and Linda Skipper, sued him in July 2017. They found evidence that Chad lied about several investments he made on their behalf. According to the suit, in September 2010, while Chad was working as a financial advisor, his parents invested $160,000 from their 401k into a principal annuity account. Chad closed that account without telling his parents. It was worth about 221,000 by that time. His parents claim Chad took the money for himself.
Mike Gibson
He's just a thief.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah. Not only is he bad at investing, he just takes the investments as well. He also alleged that between February 2013 and February 2017, Chad led him to believe he had invested $10,000 in annuity and $77,000 into a CD. He took that money and $600 a month he received as part of the CD.
Mike Gibson
He is just not going to get the son of the Year award.
Mike Ferguson
No. I mean, bad enough to do this to other people, but to do it to your own parents and steal their hard earned money, their retirement savings, I mean, that's pretty low.
Mike Gibson
Pretty much a scumbag.
Mike Ferguson
He also allegedly cashed a check on one of their credit cards and charged over $13,000 to a card he opened in their name.
Mike Gibson
Wow.
Mike Ferguson
Between September 2012 and March 2013, Chad allegedly rolled money from his parents, 401k into a company called Skipper Financial Services. He allegedly stole around $97,000 during that period. In total, Gibbs, his parents accused him of stealing around $444,000 from that.
Mike Gibson
Almost a half a million dollars. How do you do that to anybody, let alone your parents?
Mike Ferguson
Well, it's a ton of money, but let's look at what the money represents. Right. Most likely their life savings and what they're going to be relying on to live the rest of their lives after retirement.
Mike Gibson
Yeah. Now, now they. Because you did that, what do they have Besides maybe Social. Social Security, what are they.
Mike Ferguson
Easy for you to say.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah. I mean, this probably forced them to keep working longer than what they wanted to, and it's just terrible. They discovered the theft shortly after law enforcement searched the desk in his home. After he was arrested. In September 2017, First Trust and Savings bank filed for foreclosure on a house in Erie owned by Chad. The bank attempted to recover $44,000 on a line of credit Chad took out against the house in 2013. And it's kind of ironic, right? This is the same bank where Chad attempted to cash the $350,000 cashier's check.
Mike Gibson
Okay.
Mike Ferguson
On November 15, 2018, Chad Skipper pleaded guilty to three charges. Two counts of aggravated kidnapping and concealing identity. Home invasion with a dangerous weapon. So, you know, aggravated kidnapping, brutal, concealing identity. All right, yeah, you know, maybe not at the top of the list, but home invasion with a dangerous weapon, that's up there as well. He was previously charged with harassment and witness tampering, but those charges were dismissed with his guilty plea.
Mike Gibson
I'm just trying to figure out what the heck did he do with all this money that he stole from his parents? Like, did he have a. I. I don't believe the research ever said. Did he have, like, a. A drug habit, Drug habit or gambling problem or.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, it didn't say that. What it did talk about was bad investments.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
So is it possible that, you know, he made some bad investments and then he was. Because this is a vicious cycle, Right. It's like gambling. You lose a bunch of money at the track, so you go get a bunch of money from somewhere else and try to make it up. Gambling on something else, and you just keep getting deeper and deeper in debt.
Mike Gibson
What'd he do? Did he invest it with. Was that Leo DiCaprio's Wolf of Wall Street? Wall street penny stocks, yeah. Just didn't pay out.
Mike Ferguson
Maybe. We don't know. On April 3, 2019, Chad was sentenced to 60 years in prison without the possibility of parole. He was 40 years old at the time of his arrest. According to the Illinois DOC website, Chad's projected discharge date is 2071. He would be in his 80s by that time.
Mike Gibson
I don't feel bad for the guy. His.
Mike Ferguson
I don't either.
Mike Gibson
His parents are got to be struggling because what he did to them and then obviously what he did to this other family, but. And who knows who else he stole money from, right?
Mike Ferguson
There could have been other people as well.
Mike Gibson
If you can steal money from your mom and dad, you can steal money from anybody.
Mike Ferguson
Oh, I. I would say that's absolutely correct. But you and I just got done dropping a Patreon episode on Saturday night this past Saturday night. And in that episode. Now, granted, we were in Australia. Right. But somebody got like six years or so.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
For doing some really bad things. Now, I'm not saying this is not bad, but what it does show is the difference between countries. And we talk about that quite a bit as far as it come, as far as it goes with sentencing and things like that.
Mike Gibson
Big difference.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, I'm happy with 60 years.
Mike Gibson
Oh, I am too. He would have probably killed these two individuals.
Mike Ferguson
There's a good chance, if he didn't
Mike Gibson
have the accent that he had and they, you know, were able to locate the mysterious dungeon.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, yeah, you're probably right. But that's it for our episode on the abduction of the Van Houston's. And you got anything else?
Mike Gibson
No. At one point I was going to be Rex Van West.
Mike Ferguson
Huh.
Mike Gibson
Because like that Vaughn Van west, you know, like.
Mike Ferguson
Like Van Helsing.
Mike Gibson
Yes, exactly. Go around and chase vampires and stuff.
Mike Ferguson
So we didn't. I don't know if everybody noticed, but I got a couple of new signs here.
Mike Gibson
Very fancy.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah, yours, yours has your alter ego on it, but if anybody likes the signs and, you know, you can get these little things made up. They're not very. They're not very expensive at all. But if you'd like to go out to our website, we have our mailing address on there. We do send us a couple. As long as they're not too vulgar, you know, we'll put them up for sure.
Mike Gibson
Yes, you will. Especially if they have something funny about me.
Mike Ferguson
I know, absolutely. Or if they're funny about me, I'm funny about you. I can take it as well. All right, buddy, that is it for another episode of True Crime all the Time. So we'll talk to you all next week. And for Mike and Gibby.
Mike Gibson
And Gibby.
Mike Ferguson
I messed that completely up, didn't I? You.
Mike Gibson
You do that now then.
Mike Ferguson
And for Mike and Gibby, stay safe and keep your own time ticking. I think it's weird because we don't do the music and we don't do all of that. So I get out of my natural rhythm.
Mike Gibson
The intro. Intro and outro.
Mike Ferguson
Yeah. To get technical.
Mike Gibson
Yeah.
Mike Ferguson
All right. We love y' all and we'll see you next episode.
Sponsor Announcer
If you're the purchasing manager at a manufacturing plant, you know, having a trusted partner makes all the difference. That's why, hands down, you count on Grainger for auto reordering with on time restocks, your team will have the cut resistant gloves they need at the start of their shift and you can end your day knowing they've got safety well in hand. Call 1-800-granger. Click granger.com or just stop by Granger for the ones who get it done.
Release Date: March 5, 2026
Hosts: Mike Ferguson & Mike Gibson ("Gibby")
In this episode, Mike Ferguson and Gibby dive into the harrowing abduction of Connie and Larry Van Oosten, a retired couple from Erie, Illinois, who were kidnapped from their own home in February 2017. The hosts unravel how the seemingly safe life of this couple was shattered by a meticulously planned kidnapping, executed by a trusted member of their community. The episode covers the investigation, the shocking reveal of the perpetrator's identity, and the couple’s ordeal in a makeshift dungeon. Ferguson and Gibson bring their signature blend of seriousness for the crime and lighthearted banter to the discussion.
The Dream Retirement:
Family & Community Ties:
The Crime Scene:
Investigation Unfolds:
A Familiar Face:
Premeditation and Discovery:
Evidence & Motive:
Ordeal in Captivity:
Rescue & Survival:
Legal Outcomes:
Family Testimony:
On Home Invasion Fears:
On Community Shock:
On the Dungeon Discovery:
On Survival:
On Motive and Regret:
On Chad’s Betrayal:
On Connie’s Bravery:
The hosts balance gravity and empathy with their usual light banter. They focus on the horror, premeditation, and betrayal underlying the crime, while commiserating about retirement dreams and drawing broader insights on human motivation and criminal hubris. The interplay between Ferguson and Gibby maintains a conversational, sometimes humorous, yet always respectful tone—especially around the personal courage and ordeal of Connie and Larry.
This episode illustrates the chilling disruption of safety and trust by someone within the community, the egregious violation of familial and professional relationships, and, most inspiringly, the resilience and bravery exhibited by Connie and Larry Van Oosten. The investigation highlights the importance of vigilance, law enforcement collaboration, and the quick thinking by the victims that ultimately led to their safe recovery and the perpetrator’s conviction.