
In this interview, Keyes discusses publicity and strategy, the impacts of his crimes on his family, searching for remains, the NY victim, lies he's told about his time in Texas, and serial killers he's read about and studied. TROVA TRIP to Costa Rica...
Loading summary
Shell Commercial Announcer
Shelby Power Nitroplus fuels every drive from the Pacific coast to the high desert with a fuel like no other. It contains active coating ingredients that clean and protect for longer lasting engines. That means more protection with active ingredients for longer lasting engines. Shel V Power Nitro Plus Premium gasoline engine performance that lasts Chances are you're not far from a Shell station. Find it using the Shell app formulation unique to Shell compared to minimum detergent gasoline. With continuous use of Shell V Power Nitro plus and gasoline direct injection engines, actual effects and benefits may vary. See Shell Us More protection for more information.
Intuit ERP Advertiser
If you're chasing data down instead of seeing it in one place, you need the Intuit ERP Intuit Enterprise Suite. All your data in one place with built in AI for real time insights. Learn more at intuit.com ERP
Starbucks Advertiser
during Memorial Day at Lowe's Shop household must haves for less. Save $80 on the Char Broil Performance Series 4 Burner Grill to chef up something special plus get up to 45% off select major appliances to keep things fresh. Our best lineup is at Lowe's Lowe's. We help you save valid through 527 while supplies last selection varies by location. See lowe's.com for details.
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
Visit your nearby Lowe's.
True Crime Bullshit Host
Hey everyone. While True Crime Bullshit is on hiatus, we'll be popping in sporadically to share with you some of Keys's FBI interviews, some NamUs 45 episodes and some bonus content. True Crime Bullshit will be back with season eight on October 5th. And today I'm sharing with you keys October 22nd FBI interview. We'll be back on Thursday with the second part of this interview. Stay tuned after this episode to find out where we're going on our next Trova trip this November. This is a studio both and production.
Officer Bell
It's officer bell, apd. I'm going on tape. It is 8:47 by my watch. On the 22nd of october, interview with israel keys. Preamble in the rooms. Mb sa, jolene godin, usa's frank russo and kevin feldis.
Israel Keyes
You can say that.
FBI Agent Interviewer
All right, well, today you're gonna spice it up for us, right?
Israel Keyes
Yeah.
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
All right.
FBI Agent Interviewer
You want to make it a good day? Should we call it an interesting day or a boring day? What do you think?
Israel Keyes
I don't know.
FBI Agent Interviewer
All right, well, let's do the. We'll do the advisement.
Israel Keyes
All right.
Officer Bell
You have the right to remain silent. You understand that?
FBI Agent Interviewer
Yep.
Officer Bell
Anything you say can and will be used against you in the court of law. Do you understand that?
FBI Agent Interviewer
Yep.
Officer Bell
You have the right to talk to a lawyer and have him present with you while you're being questioned. You understand that?
FBI Agent Interviewer
Yeah.
Officer Bell
If you cannot afford to hire a lawyer, one will be appointed to represent you before and during any questioning, if you wish. You understand that?
Israel Keyes
Yes.
Officer Bell
You can decide at any time to exercise these rights and not answer any questions or make any statements. You understand that?
Israel Keyes
Yes.
Officer Bell
And we are here only to talk about other crimes. We're not here to talk about Samantha Koenig. You have standby counsel at least. Rich Gertner, Jackie Welch and Mark, would you like any of those present with you today? No.
FBI Agent Interviewer
All right. Israel, as you know, the court also said if at any time you want standby counsel present. Right. Just let us know.
Israel Keyes
Okay?
Officer Bell
Right.
FBI Agent Interviewer
And if for any reason, you want the court to appoint a different attorney to represent you, you let us know that as well.
Israel Keyes
Okay?
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
Right.
FBI Agent Interviewer
All right. We're gonna brought you over here to talk to you about other crimes, things separate from the Samantha Koenig investigation. You understand?
Israel Keyes
Yes.
FBI Agent Interviewer
All right. Well, I think that covers the introductions and the warnings. Is there anything that you wanted to ask about those before we started?
Israel Keyes
No.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Okay, good. Well, these guys told me they talked to you a couple weeks ago. Was it, what, about end of September?
Israel Keyes
Yeah.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Last time they got together. And I know there's a couple things that they wanted update you on at some point today, but when we met last. When they met with you last time, they came back and told Frank and I about a couple of things just that you were thinking about. So help me remember what some of the questions were. One of them was, you know, getting involved a little bit and not being shut out if you give us information. Not being shut out from that. Right. Kind of being involved. And my reaction to that was that that's not a problem.
Israel Keyes
Okay.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Basically, that can be done. And I think these guys have also checked that out with your bosses.
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
Yeah, we did. I talked to our. We have what are called tech agents, and those are the guys that do all the techie kind of stuff. Yeah, exactly. And basically what they are working on and currently working on, so that when we get to a point when we can do this, it can be ready to go, and it can be ready to go pretty quickly, twofold. So we had talked about the piece about having you help us find places, because that in and of itself is going to be potentially pretty difficult to do in some situations. So having a live feed with a camera at a location. So if you tell. We look at Google Maps and you say you know, I think it's in this area. We can send folks out there with a camera, with a live feed that we can see back here on the camera with that. That camera will also have a GPS on it. So you're going to be able to see. You'll essentially have two screens. You can see Google Maps overhead to see, like, if we're along a river or if we're next, wherever we're at, you can see overhead where they are. So you can look at landmarks as well as actually seeing what the live feed is as they're walking. And you can say, no, go right, go left. One of the things that. That's the thing that the tech guy is working on. And it'll depend. All the tech stuff that he's doing, depending on the more remote the area it is, depends on how it happens, whether it happens via satellite or whether it happens using the cell towers or something like that. So he's working.
Officer Bell
One of the things he said that's important when we get to this point in time, locations of whether we're going to be able to use satellite or whether it's going to have to be cell reception only or if there's cell reception even where it's at.
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
So he's working on both. And they're. I mean, they'll be ready to go, okay, whenever. When we get to that point. Any questions about that? That's kind of what we were talking about in terms of the live feed. And then, you know, we had talked about also expanding beyond that once we're actually doing some of the things, digging or whatever. And that's something that we can also do. You know, we can. I don't know, realistically, live feed is going to be difficult because those have been over 18 hours kind of a thing. So you'd be sitting here for a long time. So we can work that piece out in terms of video piece, but.
FBI Agent Interviewer
So what do you think of that?
Israel Keyes
Sounds good.
FBI Agent Interviewer
All right, so we'll ask them to continue to roll with that. And my reaction was, let's make it happen. We can do that, right?
Israel Keyes
Yeah. The only, the only issue being, I mean, that's great. That's a given at this point. I'm going to expect that for any information that I give you, Because essentially, regardless of whether I give you the information and I get to be a part of, see what happened with the investigation now or later, I'm still entitled to that. But the issue right now is. What else I can use this information for as far as my situation. My current situation. That's the tricky part because, you know, all this stuff takes a lot more time than anticipated.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Well, what we're. And what I've told you for months and months is, you know, we can make these other things move quickly. And, you know, we've gotten better at what we're doing since we first started talking to you. Right. The FBI has gotten much more geared up than we were in the summer. They've got, as we said, they've got a whole team of people ready to roll on things and follow up on things, and they're doing that anyway. But you can speed that along. Right. So timing has always been one of your concerns of we've been keeping in mind. And we can move a lot more quickly than you think, but that's up to you. And I've told you that before. If we don't, you know, if we meet every two months, it's going to go slowly. If we meet every week, it's going to go fast. So we're doing better than we did. And we'll admit that we were slower than we wanted to be in the beginning, but. So what's your reaction to that?
Israel Keyes
Like I say, my biggest concern right now is with current ongoing issues. It's not with any of these potential issues. I guess you could say I've become somewhat disenchanted with this whole process. And. Even though, you know, I think it's inevitable that we resolve all the issues that I can. I'm a little more hesitant now than I was in the beginning to talk about things because I didn't have. I feel like I talked about some things without thinking through possible outcomes that that information could be used for. And just being well, overwhelmed at the time with the whole situation from my end, not really overwhelmed anymore. Kind of settled into the good life of jail.
Starbucks Advertiser
You
FBI Agent Interviewer
not too boring for you?
Israel Keyes
Mandatory boredom?
FBI Agent Interviewer
Well, that's one area where we might be able to help you with as we move along with some of these things. At least we're all working on something.
Israel Keyes
Yeah, but that. I'm still concerned about the long term. From my perspective.
FBI Agent Interviewer
What's your concern? Tell me what your concern is.
Israel Keyes
My concern is. It's twofold, really. There's two different ways it can go. I can go for maximum publicity with. With the information that I have, or I can go try and go for minimum publicity. And I'm including, you know, all the issues in that statement. My issue right now is I don't know which way it's gonna go. There's an aspect of this to where I would prefer to keep it all, minimum publicity. But to a certain extent it's already too late to do that. Granted, lately there hasn't been much publicity, which has been good. It's given me some time to consider that option. But that being said, not all these issues are resolved yet, so I don't know how much publicity there's going to be filled. So it would be premature for me to give out any more information with the hope of keeping at minimum publicity if in the end result there's going to be certain other issues that come out anyway.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Sounds like you're undecided about this.
Israel Keyes
I am. Just because of a personal conflict I have with, you know, from my own personal perspective, I don't mind the publicity, but, you know, there's other factors involved.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Too concerned about.
Israel Keyes
Right.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Anyone. Anyone other than her that you're concerned about?
Israel Keyes
Not as much anymore. But yeah, there's. There are some peripheral concerns, you know,
FBI Agent Interviewer
What about your family? They pretty much know what's going on. Is this going to come as a shock to them or do they already kind of know that?
Israel Keyes
I don't know. Initially I was thinking being in their position, they're going to. Even as technologically backwards as some portions of my family are, eventually they would come to terms with the reality of me being in the situation I'm in and they would seek out that information for themselves and kind of draw their own conclusions. Even though the press releases have been limited, there's still enough information in them to deduct and draw some conclusions that, you know, this stuff didn't come out of thin air kind of thing.
FBI Agent Interviewer
So
Israel Keyes
that's another issue that I have right now is because I don't know, I know some of them are. Certain people who have known me are still definitely in denial about the whole thing.
FBI Agent Interviewer
You try to set them straight about
Israel Keyes
your life of crime. That's the issue that's confused confusion I have right now because I've never told any of them since this whole thing started that, oh, I'm innocent. I haven't come out and said, oh, I did this and this. I have mostly kept my statements about the whole situation very vague under the guise of, well, I can't say anything, but at the same time, you know, kind of draw your own conclusions sort of thing.
True Crime Bullshit Host
Lately I've been way more intentional about what I wear from day to day. Leaning into pieces that feel easy, comfortable, but still put together. It just makes getting dressed simpler. And Quint's has been my go to because Their fabrics feel elevated, the fits are clean and everything just works without needing to overthink it. It's stylish but simple. Quince has all the wardrobe staples for spring. 100% European linen shirts and shorts from $34. They're lightweight, breathable and comfortable, but still look put together and and clean. 100% Pima cotton tees with a softness that has to be felt. Their pants also hit that same balance. Relaxed and comfortable, but still polished enough to wear pretty much everywhere. And everything at Quint's is priced 50 to 80% less than what you'd find at similar brands because Quint's works directly with ethical factories and cuts out the middlemen. So you're getting premium materials without the markup. I recently bought a couple of their 100% organic cotton ribbed crew neck sweaters. They look great, they fit perfectly and they're great for layering throughout spring. I also just ordered their weatherproof long rain jacket, which is cute and going to be perfect for a very rainy Iceland next month. Refresh your everyday with luxury you'll actually use. Head to quint.com tcbs for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada too. That's Q U I n c e.com tcbs for free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.com tcbs whether it's slots or live
SpinQuest Advertiser
dealers, spinquest.com has the fun and action you're looking for with Spinquest exclusive exclusives. Blackjack, roulette, baccarat and even live dice. With craps and bubble craps. The games never stop so you don't have to. And right now new users get $30 coin packs for just 10 bucks. Play now@Spinquest.com SpinQuest is a free to
Israel Keyes
play social casino void where prohibited. Visit spinquest.com for more details.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Well, when it comes to these other criminal activity, obviously, I mean we know about the couriers and we know a lot of things. Is there something that we can do to facilitate you communicating with your family or if that's important to you, for them to know before it hits the papers?
Israel Keyes
There may come a time shortly when, when I have to make a decision on which route I'm going to go, whether I go for maximum publicity or minimum publicity. And of course if I come to the conclusion that I'm going for maximum publicity, then I'm going to tell them about it first. In which case there are possibly some
Officer Bell
things that could be done to arrange that as facilitated.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Correct? What would Cause you to go the maximum publicity route.
Israel Keyes
If I were to come to the realization that. Well, a couple different things. For one, if I was to come to the realization that minimum publicity wasn't going to be an option, I think you all know me well enough to know that I'm not, as far as me personally, I'm not that conflicted about the whole situation. Therefore, all that remains in my mind from my perspective, is to see which way it plays out.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Yeah, no, that's an interesting question. I mean, I think part of us, all of us know that the cow has left the barn, you know, long ago. Right. You know, to some extent, no matter what any of us do, you know, it's already out there. So there is that consideration. Obviously, we offer to do things in certain ways to, to limit what was in. I think in a large extent, we've been pretty successful about that. But a lot of some of this is out of our control. Right.
Israel Keyes
And I understand that now, that's the biggest issue that I was naive on initially is what the options were for limiting the amount of information that gets out. I'm a little more. A little better informed at this point as to what's ultimately going to be known by the general public. And I'm also, you know, a little more adapted to my current living situation, so become a little more realistic about, well, if this is the way it's going to be, then I should. I'm the one in jail, so I should use whatever I have to benefit my own situation. The bottom line is now that I'm in jail, everybody on the outside, regardless of how traumatic this may be for them, it's essentially over.
FBI Agent Interviewer
We know you don't. I mean, you've told us that this is not a concern of yours, but it's not over for a whole bunch of others.
Israel Keyes
I'm just saying, as far as physical threat is concerned, it's over. The damage is done. Whatever damage is done is already done.
FBI Agent Prosecutor
How does it impact your cooperation on other crimes, whether that's, you decide, maximum
Israel Keyes
publicity or minimum publicity?
FBI Agent Prosecutor
I mean, if what maximum publicity, how would you proceed in continuing to give us information as opposed to. If it was minimum publicity? So we can understand that.
Israel Keyes
Well, that hinges on another issue for
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
me,
Israel Keyes
which is essentially how long am I willing to sit in jail? Regardless of how much entertainment value I get out of any of this,
FBI Agent Interviewer
My
Israel Keyes
perspective on sitting in jail definitely hasn't really changed. I guess you could say I haven't. Discovered a new clique of friends in jail. Don't expect That I will anytime soon. So I don't really see a long term interest in survival living there. That being said, I'm more realistic about the situation being that it is. They watch me like a hawk. They're gonna keep me, you know, my own separate indefinitely probably. So, you know, that hinges directly on the realization that if I'm going to be in this situation, then I should use, you know, what information I have as entertainment. For me, that's where the maximum publicity issue comes in.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Yeah, I mean, you know that for us this is obviously not entertainment. We have no interest in entertainment. I know, I say that I understand that you have expressed before today that just sitting in jail for you, there's nothing to that, there's no entertainment. But if you want to be involved in something, meaning helping us move forward on one or more of these investigations, we're willing to offer you to. And that's unusual and unprecedented and all that. And we're willing to do that as a compromise. Obviously, you know, there's limits, but we can do that.
Israel Keyes
Well, right, yeah. There are certain aspects of any investigations from this point that I would be interested. I don't want to sit in jail and wait to be charged with them. I'd rather. If I'm going to give the information, I'd rather. It's not like I don't know what happened. It's not like there's any mystery in it for me. But at the same time it's interesting to me because it's all these things, once I've done them, they become, you know, that's it. It's like the taboo, that's the end of it. It's not like I get to go back and you know, whatever I have residual from those things that happen, things that I did, they're all in my head. So, you know, and as far as being unprecedented, that's not really true either because the reality is unless I'm fairly close involved, we're not even going to be able to find.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Oh yeah, I mean, unprecedented that we be, you know, showing you video feeds
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
and things like that, how we would be doing it.
FBI Agent Interviewer
That doesn't happen.
Israel Keyes
Yeah, I can see that. But at the same time, you know, like I say, eventually I would get to see those things anyway if this were to play out, if two were able to.
FBI Agent Interviewer
I mean, if you get charged with an individual crime, eventually, you know, but yeah, as far as I understood it, you have no interest in being charged with all these crimes.
Israel Keyes
And so that's not to say that I. I'M just saying it's depending on the way I give you the information. I could make it so that you would force you. I could force you to charge me for each individual one. I can give you enough information to get me, but not to get me. So, you know, what we're talking about is, you know, essentially the same side of the same coin. Different sides of the same coin. Anyway, I understand what you're saying and I appreciate the fact that you're willing to work with me, but at the same time, you have to see it from my perspective where, yeah, I know what I could say, especially with 2020 hindsight at this point, to get. To get that, you know, but my concern is with other issues right now.
FBI Agent Interviewer
What other issues?
Israel Keyes
Well, the current crimes that I'm charged with.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Well, I mean, as weird as it sounds, it does sound weird to us. I mean, we are trying to see it from your perspective in approaching it with this and saying, you know, hey, we can do these things and work together on them.
Israel Keyes
Yeah, well, I know and I understand the reason. I understand from your perspective, this was all wrapped up neatly with the bow on it. Make your lives a lot easier, I would say. I'm sorry, but I'm not really that nice of the guys.
FBI Agent Interviewer
But we always ask you, string with
Israel Keyes
us
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
one thing in terms of timing, just to keep this in mind, whatever you decide, however you decide this is going to play out in the end, the piece about you being part of it and us going out and doing what we have to do. You give us information, we go out, we look for bodies or whatever, however many we end up looking for, however much information you give us, we have the benefit of having people all over the place. So the timing piece is somewhat. Obviously, it's totally up to you with that, but we have the benefit of having people all over the place so things can be happening at the same time. It's not like, you know, we have to do. It's just going to be the same team going to this location. You got to wait till they're done and then they're going to fly to here and then they're going to fly to there. So just keep that in mind when you're thinking about timing, is that it can. It can happen quickly if you want it to happen quickly.
True Crime Bullshit Host
Did you know that three out of four US Homes have toxic chemicals in their tap water? Even though contaminated water looks clear, it could put you at risk for devastating health concerns, including fatigue, hormone disruption, cognitive decline, even cancer. Surprisingly, standard fridge and pitcher filters do very little to remove. Most contaminants and bottled water contain microplastics. So what's the solution? Aquatru. It's a countertop water purifier tested and certified to remove 84 contaminants, including chlorine, lead, forever chemicals and microplastics. Its patented four stage reverse osmosis system goes way beyond ordinary filters for pure, healthy water that you can trust with no plumbing and no installation necessary. Aqua True has been featured in Business Insider, Popular Science and named Best countertop water filter by Good housekeeping. So join 98% of customers who say their drinking water is cleaner, safer and healthier, including me. Go to aquatru.com now for 20% off your purifier by using promo code longshort. Aquatru even comes with a 30 day best tasting water guarantee. That's aquatru.com a q u a t r u.com promo code l O N G S H O R T hey, what up y'?
FBI Agent Interviewer
All?
Starbucks Advertiser
Summer moves like a great jam session. You start with one idea, one direction, and then it shifts. Somebody calls. Energy changes. You take a detour. That's the beauty of it. For me, summer's always been about discovering new sounds, new places, new people, new ideas. You start one place, end up somewhere completely different, and somehow that's exactly where you're supposed to be. I've always had my spots along the way. Starbucks has been one of those constants. Before a session, on the way to a gig, and between conversations that turn into something bigger than you expected. It's part of that movement, part of that rhythm. The summer's got its own soundtrack, too. You can almost hear it without trying. Life's happening all around you. That feeling of staying open to whatever's next. Sometimes it's the smallest things that lock you into that moment. What you're holding, what you're sipping. The new Tropical Butterfly Refresher from Starbucks. Guava and passion fruit flavors with mango pineapple flavored pearls. Cold, colorful, alive. Feels like something made for the day that's still unfolding. And that's the thing. Sometimes one small stop changes the whole mood of your day. Start your summer rhythm with Starbucks. Try the new Tropical Butterfly Refresher from Starbucks.
SpinQuest Advertiser
Forget whatever plans you have this weekend because you're staying at home and playing on Spin Quest. And there's never been a better time to sign up than right now. New users get $30 coin packs for just $10, all the table games you love, with hundreds of slot games and real cash Prizes that's at spinquest.com S P I N Q U-E-S-T.com Spin Quest
Israel Keyes
is a free to play social casino void where prohibited. Visit spinquest.com for more details.
True Crime Bullshit Host
Long shot.
FBI Agent Interviewer
So what are you thinking about that way?
Israel Keyes
I feel like I've pretty much laid out my current perspective at this point. Yeah, I don't.
Officer Bell
I don't know.
Israel Keyes
I don't know. I guess, Yeah. There's just a lot of information I've got recently that I should have expected. I should have seen it coming. I know enough about bureaucracy and different aspects. Not specifically this aspect of the federal government, but other aspects. I should have known that wasn't going to be all smooth sailing matter speaking. But I didn't expect. There are some things that I didn't anticipate that are slowing things down or that could potentially slow things down, complicate matters. Yeah, so that's what I'm trying to come to terms with now as far as. Basically what I'm talking about is timelines. How much of a timeline am I willing to deal with,
FBI Agent Interviewer
love? That's up to you, right? We sat here with flip charts months and months ago. We can do this. We'll bring them back. They're pretty good to know because we were. This is what Israel wanted. This is what we were given. Israel. And you know, we've gotten. Now we've gotten where?
Israel Keyes
Well, if it was that easy to go through months and months with a flip chart, well.
FBI Agent Interviewer
But I could get out the notes of where I said, you know, we got plan A and plan B. You know, Plan A is basically where we've been just sitting here twiddling our thumbs for months now instead of out there moving forward.
Israel Keyes
I don't think, I know that nothing's happened recently, but I don't really feel like we're twiddling our thumbs anymore because I think that we have an understanding. I think you know enough about me now to know where I'm coming from on all these issues. And even though, like I say in the beginning, I reacted pretty unpredictably, for me, out of character, for me, it was because of situations that I felt were spinning out of control. And my whole issue with this is to keep control of it. If you let me, to an extent keep control of the situation, then you're going to get what you want, essentially. And, you know, whether or not I get what I want is not really so much the issue anymore. It's. It's what happens in the interim for me, you know, So I don't. I don't. You know, even though we haven't been able to go out and solve any more crimes together recently, we. You understand my perspective as to why that is and why things are at a standstill right now.
FBI Agent Prosecutor
I think. I think it's. You know, we understand that, and I think we've been sort of trying to work on keeping control sort of in the room, so to speak. I mean, the whole Vermont thing has, you know, been calmed down quite a bit. I mean, I was in Vermont last week, and, you know, I met with all the federal prosecutors, the state prosecutors, the family, you know, with that in mind, with the idea of, you know, let's just kind of, you know, hang with us here. You know, we're kind of moving to a place where I think, you know, we all get what we want as long as it doesn't, you know, spin out of control. And so, you know, I think I was pretty successful in trying to convey that message to, you know, most of those people. And, I mean, some of the prosecutors there, I mean, one of them said right out, said, I think this guy's jerking you around. And that's like, an impression that a lot of, like, you know, the bosses have. Oh, he's jerking you around, you know, and, you know, not having sat here and listened to you, I understand that's their perspective.
Israel Keyes
And our.
FBI Agent Prosecutor
What we've been trying to do is try to talk them out of that. One of the things that was persuasive to them is the fact that you had met, you know, just two or three weeks ago. I told him, look, you know, he's still sort of amenable to this because he met a few weeks ago and just, you know, seemed good with the idea of continuing to provide information, in fact, making plans for this sort of thing. So I think that little bit helped us, and it helps us keep control, and it helps you keep control. And it may not be as fast as we like or as fast as you like, but, you know, keeping those lines of communication open and kind of showing some progress in our investigation of other crimes helps us keep control.
Israel Keyes
Yeah, no, I. I can see that.
Officer Bell
And we've been telling you that all along that we've been coming over and getting pressure for the lack of progress. Like you said, to use your word, stall. That's why things have stalled, and that's the way our bosses are seeing it, too.
Israel Keyes
Stalled. Yeah, I didn't. I had just assumed at this point that Vermont wasn't even really an issue anymore. I Figured they were kind of just sitting on their hands waiting to see what happens with the feds.
FBI Agent Prosecutor
But I enjoyed the 20 hour flight out there to try to.
Israel Keyes
It's a nice place, right?
FBI Agent Interviewer
Yeah.
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
Huh.
FBI Agent Prosecutor
Stayed in Essex, right around the corner from the Handy Suites.
FBI Agent Interviewer
I don't think you said a non issue. Nothing is a non issue.
Israel Keyes
Right, Right. Yeah, I've kind of an unrealistic perspective on that sort of thing. So that's what I was assuming at this point, but I guess I shouldn't have assumed that.
FBI Agent Interviewer
No, nobody's forgotten about it for a while.
Israel Keyes
Oh, I didn't think they forgot.
FBI Agent Prosecutor
I just least of all the family members. I mean that, you know, sort of trying to, you know, they want to see what's going to happen here and I was trying to out there to tell them to, you know, sort of give it time, trust us, you know, we're making progress and you know, I think, I think we can make progress. I think we can continue to sort of hold them off and just sort of satisfy them just, you know, with pieces of information. These meetings help?
Israel Keyes
Well, I mean, yeah, if they help on paper, that's all fine and grand. You know, like I say, that doesn't really change the fact we haven't, I mean, from my perspective, we haven't really accomplished anything
FBI Agent Prosecutor
from their perspective, you know, either. I think that they're like, well, what kind of information, what other, you know, stuff has he told you? And I basically have to say, well, you know, look, there's some details I think he talked about some.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Nothing yet, but he will. Yeah. Is that the way we're.
Israel Keyes
I could see where they would be skeptical of. But you know, like you say, they don't have our perspective on it. That whole Vermont thing turned out differently than even I expected it to.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Sure, we've talked about that. We know how to do things differently the next time. Right, but we told you that back this summer. Now it's October 22nd and frankly the ground is freezing in Israel. So if you want to be involved and help us investigate anything. It was 18 degrees out yesterday in Anchorage and I don't think I've been
Israel Keyes
in Alaska, Logan, though I just assumed it's summer everywhere but here.
FBI Agent Interviewer
No, we were both just back east and it's getting cold there too, so we don't have a lot of time to play with. And it's a long cold winter as they say, and without any movement there wouldn't be anything we could do anyway.
Israel Keyes
Well, Be that as it may, from that perspective, nothing else that I'm involved in right now is weather dependent.
FBI Agent Interviewer
So what do you mean?
Israel Keyes
Except temperature's the same in the temperature, Right? Yeah,
FBI Agent Interviewer
No, I get that your temperature is the same, but, you know, everything's going, keep going forward, everybody else.
Officer Bell
And your patience is probably getting better with your situation from the ear in. But everybody else's patience is crumping thin. Our bosses, at least, and pressuring us for progress.
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
Yeah, I was just gonna say, do you want to take a break quick? And I realized I'm missing. I didn't bring the right papers over either. Is your coffee cold?
Israel Keyes
Ah, that's okay.
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
Anything else before we. We're gonna take a quick break. I left something in the room that I needed to.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Okay.
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
Show you. Okay.
Israel Keyes
Still giving you the same food or
True Crime Bullshit Host
May is Mental Health Awareness Month a reminder that whatever you're going through, you don't have to go through it alone. Life is a journey, and some days feel good and others feel overwhelming. But whatever's keeping you up at night, it's easy to feel like you have to figure it all out on your own. The truth is, no one has all of the answers, and no journey should be alone. Having someone with you to listen, to understand, and to support you can make all the difference. Lately, my anxiety has been through the roof. I always get nervous about what's going to happen to the show when we're between seasons, and then I start wondering what my career is going to be like if the show fails. And then I end up in this forever rabbit hole of fear and anxiety. Thankfully, I have my better health therapist, Jane, to not only talk me out of that, but give me the tools to not end up in that rabbit hole in the first place. And since it's May and Mental Health Awareness Month, this is a great opportunity for you to check in with yourself and understand where you are right now. Have you been feeling overwhelmed, stuck, anxious, or unsure? Well, maybe it's time for you to find someone to come on this journey with you to listen, understand, and support you. Better help therapists work according to a strict code of conduct and are fully licensed in the US with over 30,000 therapists. BetterHelp is the world's largest online therapy platform, having served over 6 million people globally. And it works with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 for a live session based on over 1.7 million client reviews, including me. I've been with my better help therapist, Jane for seven years, and my life is so much better because of it. You don't have to Be on this journey alone. Find support and have someone with you in therapy. Sign up and get 10% off@betterhelp.com TCB that's better. H E L P.com TCB True Crime Bullshit is sponsored by BetterHelp.
Starbucks Advertiser
Hey, what up, y'?
Israel Keyes
All?
Starbucks Advertiser
Summer moves like a great jam session. You start with one idea, one direction, and then it shifts. Somebody calls. Energy changes. You take a detour. That's the beauty of it. For me. Summer's always been about discovery. New sounds, new places, new people, new ideas. You start one place, end up somewhere completely different. And somehow that's exactly where you're supposed to be. I've always had my spots along the way. Starbucks has been one of those constants. Before session, on the way to a gig and between conversations that turn into something bigger than you expected. It's part of that movement, part of that rhythm. And summer's got its own soundtrack too. You can almost hear it without trying. Life's happening all around you. That feeling of staying open to whatever's next. Sometimes it's the smallest things that lock you into that moment. What you're holding, what you're sipping. The new Tropical Butterfly refresher from Starbucks. Guava and passion fruit flavors with mango, pineapple flavored pearls. Cold, colorful, alive. Feels like something made for the day that's still unfolding. And that's the thing. Sometimes one small stop changes the whole mood of your day. Start your summer rhythm with Starbucks. Try the new Tropical Butterfly refresher from Starbucks.
SpinQuest Advertiser
Forget everything you had planned for this weekend because you are sitting on your couch and winning from the comfort of your own home. I'm here with Spinquest where you can play hundreds of slot games, all the table games you love, and you could even win real cash Prizes. New users. $30 coin packs are on sale for 10@Spinquest.com SpinQuest is a free to play
Israel Keyes
social casino void where prohibited. Visit spinquest.com for more details.
Officer Bell
Going back on tape re enter it's 9:31 by my watch.
Israel Keyes
Sure enough came back yeah.
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
That your clothes were fitting a little snug. The cities that they put you in.
Israel Keyes
Yeah.
FBI Agent Interviewer
So do you get any place to work out in your cell or.
Israel Keyes
Oh yeah, I can do jumping jacks or something myself. I guess. Put me outside all my jewelry.
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
You're cuffed even when you go outside for yard time.
FBI Agent Interviewer
So you were talking about the maximum publicity versus minimum publicity. What does maximum publicity look like to you? What does that mean to you? Like just you sit down and methodically tell Us what happened, or is there some other, like, dramatic courtrooms that you get ready for?
Israel Keyes
I could make it as erratic as I wanted. That's the whole thing.
FBI Agent Interviewer
So what does it mean to you, though, when you say that maximum?
Israel Keyes
Well, there's a whole sliding scale. But I mean, like I say, if I decide to go maximum publicity, I think, you know, that from my perspective, from what I know, from the resources I have at my disposal, I could get a lot of airtime out of this if I wanted to.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Yeah, if you want to call the newscasters and, you know, but.
Israel Keyes
Well, they'll show up whether I call them or not. But I mean, I'm just saying
FBI Agent Interviewer
there
Israel Keyes
is that aspect of my. Of the way I think of things, but it's, you know, at this point it's still pretty small because it's not really. Not really my nature, but. And at the same time, it's potential entertainment. So something I have to consider.
FBI Agent Interviewer
The master of publicity. Right.
Officer Bell
Is there something that's going to trigger
FBI Agent Interviewer
that or how are you going to decide that?
Israel Keyes
That's a good question. I mean, I, you know, there's. There's a lot of factors involved with it and a lot of unknowns still at this point for me, so. And, you know, a lot of things have happened. Not so much talking about the meetings between us, but just the way things have gone in general as far as the way the system works.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Right.
Israel Keyes
However you want to put it,
True Crime Bullshit Host
we
FBI Agent Prosecutor
don't want to do anything to jeopardize, obviously, the, you know, whatever progress we're making here. So we're just sort of wondering, if you're going maximum publicity, how's that going to impact our cooperation on other crimes? Or is it.
Israel Keyes
Well, it would drag it out for longer. That's the only issue. Whereas the maximum publicity is, you know, it's not a big story unless it goes on for years and years.
FBI Agent Prosecutor
Whereas if it's minimum publicity, you think it would be more expeditious, Wrap everything up?
Israel Keyes
I mean, you know, you've got the recordings of the first interview we did together.
FBI Agent Interviewer
So,
Israel Keyes
you know, from my perspective, this. No matter how much publicity I got out of this or how much entertainment, relative entertainment value I get, it's all relative compared to the way things used to be. So from my perspective, that's what makes it an unknown. That's why I'm not decided on it on that route, because all other things being equal, you know, if I had my way, that's not the way it would go at all. But I'm not in control of all those other factors. There's just a lot of factors I'm not in control of. So part of it is me being spiteful
FBI Agent Interviewer
and. Spiteful about what, though? To whom, for what?
Israel Keyes
Doesn't matter. The point is, you know, if I feel like I'm not being taken seriously or if things aren't going my way, then that's my reaction to it. That's the only reaction I have at
FBI Agent Interviewer
this point is to.
Israel Keyes
Is to do the maximum publicity, to use it to make a point. And I mean, there is, I, you know, there is a point I could make out of it and I don't get it.
Officer Bell
What point we have.
FBI Agent Interviewer
I don't get it.
Israel Keyes
I'm just saying if I wanted to make a point, using my case
FBI Agent Interviewer
as
Israel Keyes
an example, whether, you know, the media would potentially give me a pretty big soapbox to make that point to people, make a point that, you know, this is the system and this is the way it works, regardless.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Like a political point about, oh, the system doesn't work, we'll call it political.
Israel Keyes
To me it's pretty personal, but yeah, I got it.
FBI Agent Interviewer
But for other people, you gotta understand, just like you don't care about those people, they don't look at Israel and say, hey, we really value is opinion. Right?
Israel Keyes
Exactly. Well, that's what the entertainment factor comes
FBI Agent Interviewer
from, a larger political point about, you know, you think the system works too slow or whatever it is.
Israel Keyes
Is that what I mean? Or there's maybe not enough options or something.
FBI Agent Interviewer
What other option would you have?
Israel Keyes
Hypothetical. Yeah, I'm not going to talk about hypothetical options.
FBI Agent Interviewer
I thought you brought it up.
Officer Bell
You said hypothesis.
Israel Keyes
No, not, not. No, I mean, it's. Of course I have all kinds of hypothetical options. That's not what.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Concrete options.
Shell Commercial Announcer
That's my problem.
Israel Keyes
I don't know what my concrete options are at this point. I don't. Because it seems like they change.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Well, the one thing, I mean, we've been consistent with you and the one thing that we, I think you've seen is one thing that we do control are the investigations.
Israel Keyes
Right?
FBI Agent Interviewer
That's the one thing we do control. And that's the one thing that you, you know, you have more control over is investigations, which is what we've been. Is what. Why we're here, Investigations into other things. I think the control goes down over time to some extent, but.
FBI Agent Prosecutor
And to the extent we want to pursue the minimum publicity options.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Right.
Israel Keyes
Well, I understand what you're saying. The control over that option goes down absolutely. Because at some point if we're not able to hammer out some kind of concrete deal and get all this, everything all inclusive and done with, you know, time goes on and eventually more details come out and it's going to, you know, there's going to be publicity either way eventually. So the more time goes by, the more likely it is that we lose control of that option. As far as the maximum publicity, you know, that's something I can do at any time. I just, I think, you know, that's not my first option. That's not my first choice. But if I'm.
FBI Agent Interviewer
I don't know that one I'm left.
Israel Keyes
If that's the only one I'm left with at this, that's. That's. I feel like I'm being pushed into a corner to where that might be the only one I'm left with. And if that is the only one I'm left with, then I'm going to use it to make a point.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Right, but nobody's pushing you into a corner. I mean, we've explained to you the processes that go on and we're trying to give you what's going on out there as best as we can and time moves forward and so things will happen. But no one, I mean, no one has pushed you into a corner a lot of time. We've given you a lot of time.
FBI Agent Prosecutor
And everything we've done is sort of geared towards this minimum publicity and sort of telling not to make any public statements about it.
Israel Keyes
When I say being pushed into a corner, I'm not referring to you specifically. I'm referring to the whole situation and things that are out of all of our control. And the problem that I had especially initially was thinking that I could control the whole situation with just the few people involved with my specific situation. I realized now that's not completely realistic. I realize now there's things we can control and there's other things that maybe we can't, so. Which makes me all the more hesitant at this point to talk about anything else, because. I feel like as soon as I do, there's going to be another whole list of things I find out that I wasn't expecting.
FBI Agent Interviewer
At least, I guess, like I don't understand for Vermont. You know, is there a bunch of stuff we know in Vermont we could have.
Israel Keyes
I'm not just referring to Vermont. Vermont. That is part of it, but, you know, that's. I understand. No, I had issues with the way investigators handled that case initially. I don't have, you know, it's a non issue for me. At this point.
FBI Agent Interviewer
So using that, I mean, that's what we're looking at, you know, because we're here moving forward on the other crimes, using that as a model. If you give us, you know, to the extent you can give us some more information about different things, then we can continue moving forward on this, like more, you know, controlled pace. You'll have more control with her. More control. And for Ahmad, if you kind of understand it, that, you know, we can.
Israel Keyes
No, I understand that we can. You know, if we were to move forward on the other issues. It's not that I am discrediting what you're saying or disbelieving you, that you wouldn't be able to keep it on the down low, as it were, you know, in comparison to the Vermont situation. I'm not doubting that. You know, the issue I have is that once I give out any information, then that's the end of it for me.
FBI Agent Interviewer
From my perspective, the information's gone from you.
Israel Keyes
Exactly right.
FBI Agent Interviewer
But correct me if I'm wrong, but I think you have so much information, right. You have so much information that it could go on for.
Israel Keyes
No, it's not that.
Officer Bell
And, you know, the information you need.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Am I wrong?
Israel Keyes
Well, it depends on years wise, I guess. Yeah, you're. No, you're not wrong. But I'm saying. I just gave you too much information initially, considering.
FBI Agent Interviewer
What did you learn?
Israel Keyes
No, I'm not saying, you know, I did accomplish a certain amount of things by giving you that information, and I'm not dissatisfied with those things. But at the same time, I realize I'm in a place right now where there's not much more that you can offer me or give me. Realistically. I'm not to say that you wouldn't want to or that, you know, we couldn't work out some deal or something, potential deal. It's just not. The things that I'm concerned about are just not in that normal discussion.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Well, that's great. You know, sometimes when you have a complex issue, breaking it down into pieces is the best way to go. Taking it, you know, things we don't control and things we do control.
Israel Keyes
Right.
FBI Agent Interviewer
So you just were talking about whatever we don't control, the things we do control are taking small steps forward on all the information that you have that you think is of value to us and probably is.
Israel Keyes
Right. Yeah. No, I can see that perspective. It's inevitable that this day comes. What day? This day. This is the day where you say, give us more information or else.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Right.
Starbucks Advertiser
Hey, what up, y'? All summer moves like a great jam session. You start with one idea, one direction, and then it shifts. Somebody calls. Energy changes. You take a detour. That's the beauty of it. For me, summer's always been about discovery. New sounds, new places, new people, new ideas. You start one place, end up somewhere completely different. And somehow that's exactly where you're supposed to be. I've always had my spots along the way. Starbucks has been one of those constants. Before a session, on the way to a gig, and between conversations that turn into something bigger than you expected. It's part of that movement, part of that rhythm. The summer's got its own soundtrack too. You can almost hear it without trying. Life's happening all around you. That feeling of staying open to whatever's next. Sometimes it's the smallest things that lock you into that moment. What you're holding, what you're sipping. The new Tropical Butterfly refresher from Starbucks. Guava and passion fruit flavors with mango, pineapple flavored pearls. Cold, colorful, alive. Feels like something made for the day that's still unfolding. And that's the thing, sometimes one small stop changes the whole mood of your day. Start your summer rhythm with Starbucks. Try the new Tropical Butterfly Refresher from Starbucks.
Intuit ERP Advertiser
If data management is slowing down your business, you need the Intuit erp. If one entity is here and one here and one here and one here, you need the Intuit erp. If scaling your business feels like starting, starting, starting, starting over, you need the Intuit erp. Intuit Enterprise Suite is the AI native ERP solution that consolidates, migrates and automates all in one place. Learn more@intuit.com ERP.
SpinQuest Advertiser
Forget everything you had planned for this weekend because you are sitting on your couch and winning from the comfort of your own home. I'm here with spinquest where you can play hundreds of slot games, all the table games you love, and you could even win real cash Prizes. New users. $30 coin packs are on sale for 10@Spinquest.com Spin Quest is a free to
Israel Keyes
play social casino void where prohibited. Visit spinquest.com for more details.
FBI Agent Interviewer
No, I think things are going to move on. You know, things are going to move forward and I'm. We've never been inconsistent about saying we can.
Israel Keyes
Look, I.
FBI Agent Interviewer
No, I'm not.
Israel Keyes
I'm not faulting you for that. I'm just that that is inevitable. Well, from my perspective, you have to understand that not much has happened.
FBI Agent Interviewer
And from our perspective, not much has happened. And that's why we're in A room thinking, can we make something happen?
Israel Keyes
Right. I see that. Okay.
Officer Bell
Like you said earlier, progression is inevitable on this, whether you help us or not help us. And so things have to move forward. From our perspective, our boss's perspective, things have to go forward. We would like them, all of us in this room would like them to go forward the way they've been going forward. But they haven't. They've stopped. And so that's why we're getting pressured to move things forward, even though we all may think that it's a moot point.
FBI Agent Interviewer
But why don't you talk about what New Jersey is doing?
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
One of the things that we've talked about from the beginning. We're going to keep you posted as to what's happening. So nothing is as surprise. Deborah Feldman. We had talked about her before.
Israel Keyes
Yeah.
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
New Jersey is looking into her more. FBI is looking into her more. And that situation.
Israel Keyes
All right,
Officer Bell
now maybe that'd be a place where we could start.
Israel Keyes
No, I mean, not as far as I'm concerned.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Well, what should we tell New Jersey? What should they tell New Jersey? You said to come to you. If they're looking at things, what should we tell New Jersey?
Israel Keyes
I don't know. I mean,
FBI Agent Interviewer
tell him whatever you want. Well, they need to know, you know. You said come to you. We told them we gotta go to Israel.
Israel Keyes
I can't help him, if that's what you're asking.
FBI Agent Interviewer
What do you want us to tell them?
Israel Keyes
I can't help them.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Well, do you know this person?
Israel Keyes
No.
Officer Bell
Cancer won't.
Israel Keyes
That. That's not.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Person buried in New York?
Israel Keyes
No.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Do you know where this person is?
Israel Keyes
No.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Her name was on your computer.
Israel Keyes
Which computer?
FBI Agent Interviewer
Mine? Yeah. On your computer.
Israel Keyes
My laptop.
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
Tower.
Israel Keyes
Oh,
FBI Agent Interviewer
Yeah.
Israel Keyes
I don't.
FBI Agent Interviewer
I don't understand.
Israel Keyes
You don't understand, Understand why the name was on my computer? Well, put it this way. If you. There's a lot of names on that computer.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Right, but we're talking about this one. I don't know here. We search your name.
Officer Bell
We told you we'd do this and we'd come back and try to get information from you without going over to try to get the information. And so we're just trying to hold up our end of the bar.
Israel Keyes
I mean, if you're referring to that 2009. Isn't that what you said?
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
Yeah. Aprilly.
Israel Keyes
If you're referring to the New York trip, I don't know what you mean by going over because there wasn't anybody with me on that.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Okay. No, let's just Cut. I mean, I'm not. I just want to come over here with a clear picture, you know? Are you responsible for her death? No. Okay. Do you know anything about her disappearance? No. Why is her name on your computer?
Israel Keyes
I don't know. Probably because I looked it up. I can't imagine why Kimberly would.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Does that image have any meaning to you?
Israel Keyes
Sure, but probably not on.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Well, just explain. So we're not sitting here wondering.
Israel Keyes
No, I'm not.
FBI Agent Interviewer
I'm not.
Israel Keyes
No, I'm not going to talk about what's on the computer. I mean, if you. Like I say, if you're going to go out. I don't know what you're expecting me to say. I already said we're. I'm not talking about any more specific cases until we get some kind of deal hammered out for something. Beyond that. The only company concerns that I had when I said you're doing investigations was mostly. Mostly thinking of people close to me and bringing. Trying to bring them into investigation. So. But yeah. So, yeah, I don't know what you're saying. Saying what? If you're saying you're gonna go over, like, do a bulletin or something on that trip for 2009, first of all, I don't. Seems like there were several legs. I don't know. I don't know what you want me
FBI Agent Interviewer
to do in terms of this.
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
They were. They're gonna start asking questions is basically what it comes down to. And I think up to this point, my impression has been that you've been pretty honest about stuff. Usually if there was something in the past that you didn't want to talk about, you just say, you know, I don't want to talk about it. You wouldn't. And I could be totally wrong. My impression was, though, you didn't just directly lie to us and say you did something or you didn't do something. You just said you didn't want to talk about it. And so with Deborah, New Jersey FBI is asking questions basically, because it fits. It fits. The date fits, the place fits, a number of things fit. And the fact that she's on your computer. So we're doing what we told you we were going to do is come and tell you, hey, this is what's going on. If there's things that you don't want to talk about, hypothetically. Hypothetically, if this were a victim and there were things that you did not want to talk about, because we're not to that point yet, then, okay, we're just asking for. Are they on the right track? Are they not on the right track. And we can stop at that or we can go further if you want to go further.
Israel Keyes
No, I didn't. I didn't kill her. Okay.
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
Anything else related?
FBI Agent Interviewer
No, I just didn't know if there's any. Is there something else to the story that you're just not willing to talk about today?
Israel Keyes
I don't want to talk about it.
FBI Agent Interviewer
So.
Officer Bell
I mean, you seem conflicted with the answers. You're saying no, but you're kind of saying yes also. And so are.
FBI Agent Interviewer
No.
Israel Keyes
I never said yes.
Officer Bell
No, but I mean, you're right.
Israel Keyes
Well, I. You have to understand from my perspective, I realize now that you know a lot about the things that I've done and places I've been on paper. And whereas I'm already in that respect, I already feel like I'm at a disadvantage. And I thought back on some of our previous interviews, and I know that even though I never initially or I never intended to blatantly lie, there have been some questions that I remember that you asked that I was. Kind of a 2020 hindsight thing when I think back, like, oh, that's why they probably asked that. In that case, I kind of look at it from a different perspective, from your perspective, I guess, as opposed to mine. My memory isn't. Finding more all the time isn't perfect on all this stuff.
FBI Agent Prosecutor
Can you give us an example of something like that in the past?
Israel Keyes
No, I don't want to talk about it. I'm just saying if that sort of thing becomes an issue, then there's any specific. You know, something specific becomes an issue and then we. We can talk about it. But
FBI Agent Interviewer
let me give you what just jumped in my mind when you said that. When we were talking about Texas, we had long conversations about when you were in Texas and the Larson. When you were in Texas, you were talking about being really amped up during that period of time. That whole week we spent.
Israel Keyes
Yeah, we talked about.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Talked about tax and the arson and the bank robbery. You know how you were feeling like you were going to rob a bank in one town and you were out looking for it. Right, right. Remember you were sitting there and you
Israel Keyes
were going to rob the bank in
FBI Agent Interviewer
the town, but you were watching the fire and you couldn't go to that bank anymore, and that was in Azel. And you buried some stuff when you were there. Right? Yeah, there's.
Israel Keyes
I don't. I know what. I know what you're getting at there. You know, there's some things that I haven't told you. About Texas, but that's not what I'm referring to. I was referring to things that happened
FBI Agent Interviewer
years ago, because that's what jumped in my mind. I'm like, this Texas thing, there's more to the story.
Israel Keyes
Like, we know, right? That, you know, that's. But that's not the thing. If I choose not to talk about something that's not the same as giving a misleading answer that could be construed as a lie. That's the point I'm trying to make. I've not been. There's a lot of things I've left out, obviously, and there have been some direct questions that I'm just saying my answers could have been construed as a lie or intentionally misleading, but that's not what my intent was necessarily. It was more of an issue of do I leave it out? Do I talk about it at all? Or do I just give a yes or no answer that may not be accurate? So that's what I was referring to. And so you talk about the New York trip. That's the issue with that a lot. Because I went a lot of places and several other trips prior to that. There was several stops, different flights or whatever involved. So that's what I was referring to.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Sure. And we could lay that all out for you, but we have. But we're not.
Israel Keyes
No, I'm not saying saying that. I'm just saying I remember the high points, if you will, but. Everything else involved, the order isn't always crystal clear anymore. That's something that I've been realizing more all the time as I try to talk about this stuff. It's not nearly as clear when it comes out of my mouth as it is in my head. So. And that was the case even with more recent thing. You know, even the more recent things we talked about. So that's why I was saying, you know, if we're gonna go back further than that, it's. It's gonna be. Just location. Yeah.
FBI Agent Interviewer
And we can. And, you know, we can get you your records to show you where you were at different times. Right. Can help with that. No one's trying to trick you up, but we are trying to make sure that we don't leave any misleading impressions with the things that you said.
FBI Agent Prosecutor
You should write it down.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Yeah.
Officer Bell
We'll be happy to share with you what we have.
FBI Agent Deborah Feldman
You share with us what you have,
Officer Bell
the car you rented and where you drove, and you just have to fill in the blanks. It actually should be pretty easy for
FBI Agent Interviewer
us to work that way. So, I mean, there's something more to the story just so unclear. There's something more to the story of Deborah that you're just not. Don't want to tell us now?
Israel Keyes
I just. Yeah, I just don't want to talk about it.
FBI Agent Interviewer
But I'm right about that.
Israel Keyes
Yeah.
Starbucks Advertiser
Hey, what up, y'?
FBI Agent Interviewer
All?
Starbucks Advertiser
Summer moves like a great jam session. You start with one idea, one direction, and then it shifts. Somebody calls. Energy changes. You take a detour. That's the beauty of it. For me. Summer's always been about discovery. New sounds, new places, new people, new ideas. You start one place, end up somewhere completely different. And somehow that's exactly where you're supposed to be. I've always had my spots along the way. Starbucks has been one of those constants. Before a session, on the way to a gig and between conversations that turn into something bigger than you expected. It's part of that movement, part of that rhythm. The summer's got its own soundtrack, too. You can almost hear it without trying. Life's happening all around you. That feeling of staying open to whatever's next. Sometimes it's the smallest things that lock you into that moment. What you're holding, what you're sipping. The new Tropical Butterfly Refresher from Starbucks. Guava and passion fruit flavors with mango, pineapple flavor, flavored pearls. Cold, colorful, alive. Feels like something made for the day that's still unfolding. And that's the thing. Sometimes one small stop changes the whole mood of your day. Start your summer rhythm with Starbucks. Try the new Tropical Butterfly Refresher from Starbucks.
Intuit ERP Advertiser
If data management is slowing down your business, you need the Intuit erp. If one entity is here and one here and one here and one here, here, you need the Intuit erp. If scaling your business feels like start starting, starting, starting, starting over, you need the Intuit erp. Intuit Enterprise Suite is the AI native ERP solution that consolidates, migrates and automates all in one place. Learn more@intuit.com ERP what's up baby?
SpinQuest Promoter Bretzky
It's Bretzky. And I'm here to tell you that stuff. Spinquest.com is giving out free sweeps coins. All you got to do is purchase a $10 coin pack and guess what? They're going to give you the coins from a $30 coin pack that lets you play all your favorite games like Blackjack, Wanted, Dead, or Wild. And we're talking real cash prizes, baby. Spin Quest.com Spin Quest is a free
Israel Keyes
to play social casino void where prohibited. Visit spinquest.com for more details.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Some of this stuff. I think you said you've been reading, and I know these guys. Different of us have been reading different things with serial killers. Is that something that you. I mean, did you read about specific serial killers or just the fiction? Like just have an interest in that kind of.
Israel Keyes
No, I was more interested in the
FBI Agent Interviewer
real life thing, like books about specific people, like btk. But any case studies on btk? Was that one of them or. Not so much.
Israel Keyes
He wasn't one of my favorites.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Green River.
Israel Keyes
He was interesting. Interesting. I know all of them, Even the ones I was more interested in
Officer Bell
the
Israel Keyes
older stories, like turn of the century.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Okay. Like going way back, like Jack the Ripper, you know, that far back.
Israel Keyes
Well, Jack the Ripper's not that interesting because they never caught him. But. Yeah, there's just a different. Everybody thought of it as a new phenomenon back then.
FBI Agent Interviewer
That's what it was.
Israel Keyes
Well, they just weren't. Genocide was becoming unpopular, so serial killers had to find something else.
FBI Agent Interviewer
What was the most interesting ones that you read about?
Israel Keyes
Holmes. Holmes was one of them.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Tell me about Holmes.
Israel Keyes
Holmes was turn of the century 19,
FBI Agent Interviewer
where
Israel Keyes
he had a castle, castle dungeon combination in, I think it was Chicago. And he would give free room and
Officer Bell
board to people who were coming to
Israel Keyes
the world fair there. He was a doctor, medical doctor, or at least he'd been to medical school. I don't know if he's ever practiced. Anyway, essentially he had his house designed as a body processing factory. He would invite people to stay in this nice castle in these rooms. Had gas plumbed in the rooms and greased ships down to the basement,
Officer Bell
Sell
Israel Keyes
their skeletons to drugstores and medical hospitals and stuff.
FBI Agent Interviewer
How did he get going?
Israel Keyes
Pinkerton's, I think. Pinkerton Detective Agency, they tracked him. He was. He went all across the United States, kidnapped, essentially kidnapped one of his girlfriends or wives, kids or something and took them all across the United States. By the time he got back, none of them were with him anymore. And that's what got people asking questions. Pinkerton's back trailed him and eventually found most of their names. He was. He was interesting because he was pretty sane individual. He looked at it as more of a business enterprise kind of thing. Even though I would say probably unquestionably, he was doing it for more than.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Than that. How do people. Are there books written on him? Did he write a book? Did other people write on him?
Israel Keyes
I read some books about him and then they recently just dug up a bunch more information on him.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Where did the information come from?
Israel Keyes
The most recent information on Him, I think I watched it on tv. Tv. But prior to that I had read about him in a couple different books.
FBI Agent Prosecutor
What's his first name?
Israel Keyes
I don't know.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Is it?
Israel Keyes
His initials were H.H. holmes, I think.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Who else are the. Who else are the interesting names?
Israel Keyes
It's all interesting reading.
FBI Agent Prosecutor
Why didn't you like btk?
Israel Keyes
He was a hack.
FBI Agent Prosecutor
How many number of years he seemed to get away with?
Israel Keyes
He got away with it for a long time. That was the most disappointing thing about him is that he never had to get caught. He just got bored. So he was too much, he was too soft in his old age to actually go out and do anything again. So he decided to go the publicity route without actually doing anything. And that's what was disappointing. He was also pretty unusual in that he was able to stop for a number of years. That's why I think that plus I saw the live Prediction prison interview and my impression of him, his personality is that he was actually sorry for the things that he had done. Younger, kind of like repented or thought he was repenting of his ways kind of thing.
FBI Agent Interviewer
You think that was for real or was that a shock?
Israel Keyes
I don't know. I think it was for real because I honestly, I don't think it was. I don't think if you, if he really didn't believe that he was repenting of his sins, I don't think he ever would have stopped. Because he stopped for like 20 years. I don't know. In my mind that's impossible.
FBI Agent Interviewer
Why do you say that?
Israel Keyes
Just because of the way he, the way he killed people. You know, it's a pretty obsessive compulsive act to kill someone that way. It's not like you're a gang banger doing a drive by or something.
FBI Agent Prosecutor
How long do you think it'd be reasonable otherwise to go before killing someone?
Israel Keyes
Well, from my perspective, Hindsight's 2020, but my perspective, my only regret is that I tried to have as much self control as I did.
True Crime Bullshit Host
We'll be back on Thursday the 20th with part two of this interview. And for those of you looking for a new adventure this winter, we are heading to Costa Rica this November for our fourth Trova trip. We'll be visiting coffee plantations, doing jungle walks, hanging out on the beaches, seeing wildlife and getting to know the Pacific coast of Costa Rica. To find out more or book your spot, check out the link in the show notes. What a perfect way to bring in winter with the tropics.
SpinQuest Promoter Bretzky
What's up baby? It's Bretzky and I'm here to tell you that spinquest.com is giving out free Sweeps coins. All you got to do is purchase a $10 coin pack. And guess what? They're going to give you the coins from a $30 coin pack that lets you play all your favorite games like Blackjack, Wanted, Dead or Wild. And we're talking real cash prizes, baby. Spin Coin Spin Quest is a free
Israel Keyes
to play social casino void where prohibited. Visit spinquest.com for more details.
Starbucks Advertiser
What's up y'?
Israel Keyes
All?
Starbucks Advertiser
Summer's got a different tempo. Everything's a little looser, brighter. One plan turns into another. You hear something, you stay a little longer. Next thing you know, you're somewhere you didn't plan to be. It's those in between moments. That's where the ideas hit. Conversations stretch out. Little memories sneak up on you. Sometimes it's just about what's in your hand. That color. That chill. The new Tropical Butterfly Refresher from Starbucks. Guava and passion fruit flavors with mango pineapple flavored pearls. Yeah, that feels like summer before you even taste it. Funny how one small stop becomes the best part of the day. Start your summer rhythm with Starbucks. Try the new tropical bar Butterfly Refresher from Starbucks.
Shell Commercial Announcer
At McCurley Subaru, service has always meant more than just turning wrenches. It's about turning trust into lasting relationships. That's why we've expanded to better serve you. Double the oil change bays, 33% more technicians and faster turnaround, with basic services done in about 45 minutes. And we don't just service Subarus. We work on all makes and models, old and new. Our new, newly remodeled service apartment is ready when you are. McCurley Subaru. Your way home Book your service appointment today@mccurleysubaru.com.
Host: Josh Hallmark
Date: May 18, 2026
Episode Focus: FBI interrogation of Israel Keyes on crimes beyond the Samantha Koenig case
This episode dives deep into the October 22, 2012, FBI interview with serial killer Israel Keyes. The interrogation, presented mostly via direct transcripts, reveals the ongoing negotiations and psychological maneuvers between Keyes and investigators as they attempt to elicit information regarding his other crimes and missing victims. Tension centers around Keyes's willingness to cooperate, questions of media publicity, and the complexities of managing information, all within his ongoing effort to maintain control in an environment where his freedom is gone.
Timestamps: 02:03 – 04:00
Timestamps: 04:09 – 11:11
Timestamps: 11:20 – 25:13
Timestamps: 25:13 – 38:35
Timestamps: 62:03 – 75:21
Timestamps: 77:44 – 84:54
The tone fluctuates between clinical negotiation, manipulation, and darkly philosophical musings by Keyes. The FBI agents strive for control and patience, but also reveal frustrations, professional pressure, and candid admissions of process limitations. Keyes is measured, detached, at times arrogant; he’s preoccupied with his leverage, the game-like nature of information barter, and control over the narrative—even as he insists that outcome matters less to him than the process.
Next: Part 2 of this interview will air Thursday, May 20, 2026.