True Crime Garage: Brian Walshe ////// 894

Released: December 31, 2025
Hosts: Nic & the Captain

Episode Overview

This episode of True Crime Garage explores the chilling disappearance and murder of Anna Walsh from Cohasset, Massachusetts. Anna’s husband, Brian Walshe, becomes the prime suspect after overwhelming digital and forensic evidence, despite Anna’s body never being found. Nic and the Captain guide listeners through the relationship’s rocky history, Brian’s criminal past, the timeline of Anna’s disappearance, the investigation, trial, and the complex motives behind the case.

Main Discussion Points and Insights

Introduction to "No-Body" Homicide Cases

[03:34 – 07:22]

• Nic explains the complexities of prosecuting homicide cases where no body is recovered.
• Success rates for such prosecutions are surprisingly high—about 85%—due to the overwhelming evidence required to proceed.
  • Quote: "No body homicide court cases, though rare, often have conviction rates around 85%. This is higher than typical murder cases because the evidence must be overwhelming..." (Nic, 05:37)

Background: Anna and Brian Walsh’s Relationship

[07:22 – 11:02]

• Anna immigrated from Serbia, married Brian after her divorce.

• Early red flags: Anna reported to police that a boyfriend threatened to kill her and her friends (did not name Brian; no charges filed).

• The couple moves in with Brian’s mother, has three children (all under six at Anna’s disappearance).

  • Quote: "If you have a boyfriend that threatens to kill you and your friends. That's ... a deal breaker. Dump the loser, move on with your life. But she didn't. She ends up marrying him." (Captain, 10:46)

Brian’s Art Fraud and Legal Problems

[08:42 – 18:21]

• Brian sold forged Andy Warhol "shadow paintings," using authentic paperwork to make forgeries more convincing.

• He was arrested in 2018, pleaded guilty in 2021 to wire fraud and other charges, placed on house arrest awaiting sentencing.

• Sentenced to 37 months in prison, $475,000 restitution, supervised release.

  • Quote: "He made forgeries of the legitimate paperwork, too, to go along with the fake paintings... If it seems too good to be true, it is, right?" (Nic, 12:10)

Anna’s Career, Affair, and Marital Strains

[18:21 – 22:47]

• Anna advances to a regional manager role, commuting weekly to Washington, D.C.

• Anna begins an affair with a man in D.C., spends Thanksgiving 2022 with him abroad.

• Brian’s mother hires a PI to surveil Anna; minor evidence of the affair found.

  • Quote: "You just feel bad for these three young children because they have to deal with the mom doing this. But you... have then the ultimate fallout of what their horrible douchebag father is going to do.” (Captain, 20:27)

• On December 27, Brian Google searches: "what's the best state to divorce for a man."

Days Leading to and Following Anna’s Disappearance

[23:38 – 36:15]

• December 28: Anna tells a friend about plans to take the children after leaving Brian, expresses distress about his anticipated incarceration.

• New Year’s Eve: Anna last seen around 1:00-1:30 am, January 1, 2023, after hosting a dinner.

• Brian tells police Anna left for a "work emergency" to D.C. on Jan 1; coworkers—not Brian—report her missing on January 4.

  • Quote (On reporting): "It seems like she was reported missing by her job and not anybody in the family. Which, red flag there." (Captain, 30:34)

Digital Trail and Suspicious Behavior

[30:44 – 36:15]

• Brian conducts at least 20 disturbing Google searches on Jan 1 about body disposal, decomposition, and cleaning blood, starting at 4:55 am.
  • "10 ways to dispose of a dead body if you really need to..." (Nic, 31:21)
• Surveillance: Brian is seen disposing of trash at a liquor store dumpster; more surveillance captures further dump trips.
• Jan 2: Buys over $400 in cleaning supplies at Home Depot, wearing gloves and a mask (multiple shopping trips over days).

Evidence Against Brian Walsh

[38:17 – 41:23]

• Anna’s phone was traced as still being in the house on Jan 2, belying Brian’s story that she left.

• Police find a plastic liner and blood in Brian’s vehicle.

• More Google searches on son's iPad, e.g., "Does the dishwasher remove blood from a knife?"

  • "Some say he's on the spectrum of being a Jeffrey Dahmer type." (Captain, 41:33)

• Blood and a broken knife discovered in the Walshes’ basement.

• Brian initially charged with misleading an investigation; within days, charged with Anna’s murder.

The Prosecution’s Case and Brian’s Defense

[43:44 – 49:50]

• The digital record of Google searches practically amounts to a confession, per the hosts.
  • "His whole defense is, yeah, I disposed of her body. I’m not going to tell you where I put her...But I didn’t kill her. Like, one of the most bizarre defenses I’ve ever heard." (Nic, 47:16)
• Prosecutors argue motive was money, specifically Anna’s $2.7 million (or $1.25M, per testimony) life insurance, and her affair.
• Defense claims Anna died suddenly in bed and Brian panicked, thinking “no one would believe him.”
  • "If you find her dead in your home, what do you do about it? Do you try to rescue her? ... But that’s not what the Google searches are." (Captain, 44:43)

Trial, Verdict, and Aftermath

[49:50 – 54:46]

• Jury selected in November 2025; trial testimony lasts two weeks.
• Jury finds Brian guilty of first-degree murder on Dec 15 after learning, just before deliberations, about his previous art fraud conviction.
  • "No reaction in the courtroom from Brian Walsh... After he’s announced guilty, he’s handcuffed, shackled, and they take him out." (Nic, 48:42)
• Sentence: life in prison.
• Anna and Brian’s children are now in state custody.

Notable Quotes and Moments

• On Brian's character: "He seems like a somewhat smart, but doesn't know how to follow through. But for the most part, he's...he's a moron." (Captain, 19:22)
• On the defense’s story: "Brian’s defense is that Anna Walsh died suddenly of some kind of unexplained death... He panicked and started searching the Internet how to dispose of the body.” (Nic, 44:08)
• On motive: "He was the sole beneficiary of his wife’s over $2 million life insurance policy and also motivated by the affair she was having." (Nic, 45:34)
• On the Google searches: "If you have to google 10 ways to dispose of a dead body if you really need to… You’re in trouble.” (Nic, throughout timestamps 31:13–36:15)
• On the verdict: "It’s always nice... when you have a slime ball that does a horrific crime, to know that [they’re] going to spend the rest of [their] life in jail and not just three years for art fraud." (Captain, 58:43)

Key Timeline Timestamps

• [05:37]: Nic describes "no-body" homicide success rates.
• [10:46]: Captain’s warning about early abuse—"deal breaker."
• [12:10]: Brian’s art forgery method.
• [18:54]: Anna’s affair and Thanksgiving trip discussed.
• [21:40]: Brian’s Google: best state for men to divorce.
• [31:13–36:15]: Timeline and details of Brian’s incriminating Google searches.
• [38:17–39:52]: Police ping Anna’s phone, find blood in car.
• [44:08–44:43]: Discussion of Brian’s defense and the prosecution’s arguments.
• [47:16–48:42]: Deliberations, verdict, and Brian’s courtroom reaction.

Episode Tone

The hosts maintain their signature mix of candid, sharp banter and serious true crime analysis. There's both outrage—especially regarding Brian’s character and actions—and empathy for Anna and her children. The episode balances detailed recounting of events, timelines, and evidence with reflective commentary on domestic violence, the failures of the system, and the psychological and practical aftermath for the surviving children.

Summary for New Listeners

This episode delivers a thorough analysis of the Anna Walsh disappearance and murder, with Nic and the Captain dissecting everything from forensic evidence and timelines to legal maneuverings and personality flaws. They offer a nuanced look at the motives and means of Brian Walshe, integrating both extensive research and lively, no-nonsense commentary. Despite Anna’s body never being recovered, the evidence—especially Brian’s digital footprint—leads to his conviction and a life sentence, ensuring a deeply troubled figure is kept from further harm. The episode is both informative and emotionally resonant, making it compelling listening (or reading) for any true crime enthusiast.

For more episodes and to support the show, visit truecrimegarage.com.