Amber Alert ////// Part 2

True Crime Garage

Published: Wed Jan 15 2025

Amber Alert ////// Part 2 Episode: 814 Amber Alert: The Unsolved Case of Amber Hagerman Part 2 of 2www.TrueCrimeGarage.com January 13, 1996 - 9 year old Amber Hagerman was taken off of her pink bicycle and we are still looking for her killer. A still unidentified man snatched Amber off of her bike in broad daylight in a public area. Sadly her body was found 4 days later in a location nearby. Today we have the Amber Alert, an emergency broadcast alert system aimed at saving lives and bringing children home. If you have any information about Amber’s case please contact the Arlington Police Department Detectives at 1-817-274-4444 or remain anonymous and contact crime stoppers of Tarrant County at 1-817-469-TIPS (8477). If you would like to help to bring more kids home - consider donating to the True Crime Garage / National Center for Missing and Exploited Children campaign by typing True Crime Garage NCMEC into your search engine browser. Beer of the Week - Angel’s Perch Amber b...

Summary

True Crime Garage: "Amber Alert ////// Part 2" Summary

Podcast Title: True Crime Garage
Hosts: Nic and The Captain
Episode: Amber Alert ////// Part 2
Release Date: January 15, 2025

Introduction

In the episode titled "Amber Alert ////// Part 2," hosts Nic and The Captain delve deep into the harrowing case of Amber Hagerman, a young girl whose abduction in 1996 led to the creation of the Amber Alert system. This installment offers a comprehensive analysis of the case, exploring various facets from the initial abduction to the lingering questions that have kept the case unsolved for decades.

Case Overview

Amber Hagerman, a nine-year-old girl, was abducted on January 13, 1996, while riding her bike with her younger brother near the Forest Hills Apartments in Arlington, Texas. Despite an extensive search involving multiple law enforcement agencies and widespread community engagement, Amber's body was discovered four days later in a large creek approximately 3.2 miles from the abduction site.

Key Points:

Abduction Details:
- Date & Time: January 13, 1996, around 3:00 PM.
- Location: Near Forest Hills Apartments, Arlington, Texas.
- Witness: An elderly man observed a man in a dark pickup truck abducting Amber.
Discovery:
- Date: January 17, 1996.
- Location: A creek near the Forest Hills Apartments.
- Condition: Amber was found with multiple throat cuts, suggesting a violent end after being kept alive for several days.

Notable Quote:
Nic (05:05): "Everyone hoping it’s not Amber... but everything was pointing towards it being her."

Discussion and Analysis

The hosts meticulously dissect the timeline and circumstances surrounding Amber's disappearance and subsequent death. They highlight the challenges faced by investigators, including the unpredictable nature of the crime scene and the environmental factors that compromised evidence preservation.

Environmental Factors:
Heavy rainfall led to a swollen creek, transforming it into a turbulent waterway that obscured crucial evidence. The fast-moving water likely destroyed key forensic clues, complicating the investigation.

Crime Scene Details:
The abduction site was not isolated, raising questions about the perpetrator's familiarity with the area. The proximity to Amber's grandparents' house and the presence of a large apartment complex added layers of complexity to the investigation.

Notable Quote:
The Captain (10:21): "She was placed in a dumping ground... This shit bag monster dumps this nine-year-old that he murdered naked."

Expert Insights

To provide a deeper understanding, Nic reached out to Jeffrey Reineck, a former FBI agent with extensive experience in child abduction and murder cases. Reineck offered valuable perspectives on the potential profile of the offender and the nature of the crime.

Offender Profile Considerations:

Stranger Abduction: Given the witnessed abduction and the lack of connection to family or known individuals.
Local Perpetrator: The offender likely resided within Arlington, given the familiarity with the area and the method of disposing of the body.
Behavioral Patterns:
- Impulsivity: The suddenness of the abduction suggests a lack of premeditation.
- Control Issues: The violent nature of the crime, especially the throat cuts, may indicate a desperate attempt to eliminate any possibility of identification.

Phases of Abduction (Based on Ken Lanning's Framework):

Build-Up to Abduction: Developing a need for sexual activity, possibly through interactions with like-minded individuals or consumption of related material.
Victim Selection: Choosing a vulnerable target, in this case, a young child.

Notable Quote:
Nic (38:09): "He believes that this person has offended before, meaning sexually assaulted a child, raped a woman, abducted a kid... but has never murdered before."

Investigative Challenges

The episode underscores the significant hurdles faced by law enforcement in solving Amber's case:

Limited Evidence: The harsh environmental conditions at the crime scene resulted in the loss of critical forensic evidence.
Suspect Pool Constraints: The focus on the local area and potential suspects residing nearby narrowed the pool, making it harder to identify the correct individual.
Time Sensitivity: Amber was killed within a short window, limiting the investigation's scope and depth.

Notable Quote:
Nic (28:36): "Time is a killer in your investigation. And here the water is the killer of your evidence."

Impact and Legacy

Amber Hagerman's tragic death was the catalyst for the creation of the Amber Alert system, a nationwide tool designed to rapidly disseminate information about child abductions to assist in their recovery. While the system has been instrumental in numerous cases since its inception, the enduring mystery of Amber's case continues to haunt the community and law enforcement alike.

Notable Quote:
Nic (60:53): "Regardless if it gets solved or doesn't get solved, this is a big, powerful, impactful case. And that's why... the Amber Alert."

Conclusion

"Amber Alert ////// Part 2" serves as a poignant reminder of the fragility of life and the relentless pursuit of justice by law enforcement. Through in-depth analysis and expert insights, Nic and The Captain shed light on the complexities of Amber Hagerman's case, honoring her memory by striving to understand the events that led to her untimely death. The episode not only revisits a pivotal moment in true crime history but also emphasizes the importance of community vigilance and the tools developed to protect the most vulnerable.

Recommended Listening: For those seeking further insight into similar cases and the methodologies employed by seasoned investigators, the hosts recommend Jeffrey Reineck's book, In the Name of the Children: FBI Agents' Relentless Pursuit of the Nation's Worst Predators. Available in Kindle, audiobook, and paperback formats, this book offers a gripping exploration of child abduction and predator identification from the perspective of an experienced FBI agent.

Final Thoughts: Nic and The Captain encourage listeners to stay informed, vigilant, and supportive of initiatives like the Amber Alert system. They also emphasize the enduring hope that Amber's case will one day be resolved, bringing closure to her family and strengthening the mechanisms that safeguard children across the nation.

Stay Connected: For more true crime analyses, recommended readings, and to support the podcast, visit TrueCrimeGarage.com and join their mailing list.

Be good, be kind, and don't litter.