← True Crime Garage
True Crime Garage
Missing Sodder Children /// Part 2 /// 893
00:58:08
In Fayetteville, West Virginia there once stood two billboards. Billboards announcing a mystery and asking for help. These billboards were up for decades, seeking answers. Passing motorists could easily see either as they wizzed by in their automobiles. This is the information from one of them. At the top was a simple announcement - “After thirty years it is not too late to investigate” Below this text, the billboard featured pictures of each of the five missing Sodder children - Maurice, Martha, Louis, Jennie, and Betty.
Loading summary
Transcript106 lines
- [00:01]
Oregon Lottery Announcer
Looking for a last minute gift for your people. You know, your people, that weird bunch of friends and family that you love dearly. Well, here's an easy idea. Oregon Lottery Holiday Scratchets. Because your people, they're the ones that, amidst all the holiday crowds and endless notifications, help you find the fun. Which calls for a little gift that brings big cheer. Oregon Lottery Holiday scratchets. You know where to find them. Grab some today. Must be 18 or older to play. Lottery games are based on chance and should be played for entertainment only.
- [00:31]
Nick
Oh, the car from Carvana's here.
- [00:34]
The Captain
Well, will you look at that.
- [00:35]
Nick
It's exactly what I ordered. Like, precisely. It would be crazy if there were any catches. But there aren't, right?
- [00:44]
Carvana Announcer
Right. Because that's how car buying should be with Carvana. You get the car you want, choose delivery or pickup and a week to love it or return it.
- [00:52]
Nick
Buy your car today with Carvana.
- [00:55]
Carvana Announcer
Delivery or pickup fees may apply. Limitations and exclusions may apply.
- [00:58]
The Captain
See our seven day return policy at Carvana.com Sam. Foreign.
- [01:41]
Nick
Garage, wherever you are, whatever you're doing, thanks for listening. I'm your host, Nick. And with me, as always, is a man who maxed out all of his credit cards for this year's Christmas. The cap.
- [01:52]
The Captain
It was all that cocaine and strippers. It's good to be seen and good to see you. Thanks for listening. Thanks for telling a friend.
- [02:01]
Nick
Today we are extra holly and extra jolly. If you shake us, we jingle. That's right. We are still sipping on some holiday cheer from Shiner. This is a Christmas and holiday brew dressed up with some Texas peaches and roasted pecans. Some say it's too peachy. I think it's absolutely delicious. I'll tell you how I do it. I only have two because, yes, after that it is too much peach. But pour this one into your favorite frosted mug and sit by the fireplace with a nice warm blanket and chill out. Garage Grade four and three quarter bottle caps out of five. Deck the halls, baby. And let's give some thanks and praise to our good friends for helping us out with this week's beer fund. First up, it's here to Andrew Busum from Roseville, Michigan.
- [02:55]
The Captain
And a big we like your jib and tall cans in the air to Jamie from Prince George, Virginia.
- [03:01]
Nick
And last but certainly not least, we have Rona McDonald in Glasgow, Scotland. Rona, we like the cut of your jib. Rona's attempting to reconnect with Laura Miller from here in central Ohio. So cheers to both of you. Hope you connect and cheers to everyone we just mentioned and to all for listening and to all of you we say thank you.
- [03:22]
The Captain
Yeah. B W Double R U N beer run for everything. True crime. Check out truecrimegarage.com make sure you follow us on social medias and give us five star review if you get a chance. Hey just go over to Apple podcasts and go, hey, these guys are the best to ever do it. Some say the Michael Jordan of podcast. And that's enough of the bsness.
- [03:45]
Nick
All right everybody gather round, grab a chair, grab a beer. Let's talk some true crime. The solder house fire and the subsequent disappearance of five of their children is one of America's most enduring unsolved mysteries. The events of which unfolded rapidly on Christmas Eve and Christmas morning. On Christmas Eve of course, we have the Solder family of Fayetteville, West Virginia preparing for Christmas. Around 10 to 11pm the parents and some of the children go to bed, go to sleep, but some of the other kids stay up to play with new toys and listen to the radio. Around 12:30am approximately early Christmas morning, the phone rings, waking up mother and wife Jenny Sodder. She does not recognize the voice on the other end of the line. She hangs up. She also notices that the front door is unlocked, the lights are still on and she corrects this before going to bed. And shortly after, time uncertain, Jenny hears a noise, a loud bang on the roof, followed by some rolling. And then the next time when Jenny wakes up, this time it's to the smell of smoke and there is fire. The house is on fire. Some of the family is able to make it outside. Some are believed by others to have been trapped inside of the home. The fire department experienced delays for one reason or another. They are late to get to the fire and by the time they get there, the house has been burned to the ground. And they are now searching through the ruins looking for the missing solder family members. On Christmas Day, firefighters search the wreckage but find no human remains, not even a single bone fragment. The fire chief suggests that the children were completely incinerated. We went through the events of the fire as they've been reported over the years and we went through the emergency services arriving on the scene. And then later the determination by the inquest that the the kids had perished in the fire, completely incinerated as the fire chief had suggest, and death certificates signed for each one of these five solder children. So now what? Okay, where do we go from here? We have a mess on our hands. If you fill the garage with with the People, in this true crime story, we have half of the room saying, it's so obvious these poor little five kids perished in the fire. The other half of this room, Captain saying, shout out to the great Lee Corso. Not so fast. Not so fast, my friend. I want to give my children a proper burial. Where are they? Where are the remains? Where.
- [07:07]
The Captain
Yeah, I think there's two ways to look at this. If you're the father, okay, I can either accept that they died in the fire. Now I want to figure out how the fire started. Was it truly an accident or just faulty electrical work? And if so, then what happened to my ladder that was always leaning against the house? Well, what happened to my cars that night? I mean, I'd be interested to know how cold it was outside because if they couldn't get the vehicles to start, it could just be simply that they were too cold. Sometimes that happens and that will, it will stop your car from turning over. But you would think that within a week or so, George would of been able to figure out if something actually happened. And, and I, I've never seen anybody talk about. Oh, yeah, well, they, they later learned that somebody tampered with these engines or whatever to get them not to start.
- [08:09]
Nick
Yeah. One online article and you know, when we talk about where are the kids? Because that to me and to everyone, I think that is the, the, the biggest part of this mystery, right with and one online article, and it was a good one. Forgive me for not recalling the name of the publication, but the article was titled what Happened to the Solder Children? The Siblings who Went up in Smoke. I like the title. Not sure if it was supposed to be a little tongue in cheek, maybe a throwback reference to Cheech and Chong, but regardless, it's a tidbit, brilliant as it's quick to the point and haunting. The children who Went up in Smoke when the flames were extinguished and the smoke cleared. Where are the children? Where are they? We got a lot to get to. But while mentioning that article, it now occurs to me that I should add to the New York Times article that I referenced at the top of the show of episode one with the title 11 children die in four home fires. The December 26, 1945 article that was across the country that previous day or two. The five solder kids in West Virginia are a part of that 11 counts. Three kids in Pennsylvania in a fire there, two in Kansas and one in New York. But this is the only one in that story where we don't have remains. We have several items to get to some that you could say is evidence that the children did in fact perish in the fire, and some that is suggestive that maybe they were taken, whisked away just before the fire even started. So we have a statement made that the five kids were definitely in the house after the fire started. We have the ladder that the captain has brought up. We have a phone line, we have a witness, an excavation, some bones, a heart, and a mysterious photo perhaps of one of the children. But in the photo, that child is now a grown man. I think one thing here that I want to leapfrog over the items I just listed would be the layout of the home. As we mentioned, this is a two story home with a basement. This is helpful and necessary, but hardly ever reported. Many, many articles out there describing the events as they happen so quickly, of the family trying to flee a burning house and details of how they're attempting to flee and what happened, what they observed once outside, but no details as to the layout of the house. So I'll do my best to describe it to the good folks out there in listener land. We have a front porch. This is as if I'm walking in the front of the house, right, Captain? So I've, I'm up on the front porch, I go into the home. Now out front of the house, looking to my right will be Mr. And Mrs. Sodder's bedroom. This is on the ground level. So in part that makes sense that they would make it out of the home. And some of the kids that may have been upstairs did not.
- [11:21]
The Captain
Right.
- [11:22]
Nick
So to the right you have their bedroom. To the left you have the living room. One key detail that's important about that living room is remember Marion was sleeping on the couch. Again, she's on the ground level. She made it out. If you continue past these two rooms, you will now be in front of the stairwell. All right, these stairs, they go up, there's a landing, they go up again. And on that second floor is separated into two rooms. You have a large boys room and you have a large girl's room. Those are the only rooms upstairs in the second floor of this home. If you go back to the ground level, past the stairs to your right, you have the office. To the left you have a dining room. Okay, what's key about that office is a couple of things. This is where the phone, the house phone was. This was the phone that Mrs. Sodder says that once she, she wakes up in the middle of night because the phone was ringing, answers it, doesn't recognize the Voice call ends. And then later when she wakes up again, smelling smoke, realizing there's a fire, she. Her, her first instinct is to run to this phone to call for help. That's when she's met with the fire, according to her statement. I think this is fascinating. According to her statement, this is where the first time the fire is seen really by, by anybody. So if you want to try to figure out where this fire started, this would be to me where, where one would be looking right now, past the, on the left there, past the dining room, you have the kitchen. And then I guess you would say past the, the office. But, but on the exterior of the home, you have another porch. So you have a back porch. And remember we talked about the landing on the stairway having that window that we know Mr. Sodder broke in an attempt to get to his children, but was unable to do so because by the time he busted out that window, the stairs were completely engulfed in flame. Let's talk about this statement here. Okay, so this is from an official report of the investigation by the Department of Public Safety. It says that this report was taken the day of the fire, but officially reported on January 21, 1946. So less than a month later is the. I guess it's officially reported. And this document states that we have the. The five kids who were killed. This official document states the cause of the fire stated as undetermined, but it is believed that the fire started either from defective wiring or from spontaneous igniting of combustibles in the basement. It is mentioned that the basement was used as a workshop for their trucks, but there is no mention of gasoline being in the basement.
- [14:21]
The Captain
Okay, so this is, I believe the family denies that there was materials, combustible materials left in the basement.
- [14:29]
Nick
Correct. From what we've reviewed it, the family is stating there, there was an engine, maybe two engines that were down in the basement, but no gasoline. I do want to not gloss over the obvious here. Defective wiring. I would, I would really like to know the date of when this electric stove was installed. And then it required the second fuse box, the one that some guy pointed to and said, that's going to start a fire someday.
- [15:01]
The Captain
Right.
- [15:01]
Nick
Because we know, according to those statements, that was weeks before the fire. We don't. I don't have an exact date, but it's interesting to me on two fronts. Right. That's a recent addition to the home. Would make sense that, that something went wrong with it, but they, they appear to have had that for night after night, for however many nights. Now, it was considerably colder this night. So the statement here that is troubling is as follows from this report. John Sodder. So this is one of the. The older boys stated he heard his mother yelling, woke up his brother George, goes by Ted, and then went into the other room and shook the kids awake. Note. We should note here that John later denies this and changes his statement to that he was yelling up to the kids after he himself had already fled downstairs.
- [15:59]
The Captain
Right.
- [15:59]
Nick
Of course, this is going to be a huge point of contention in this case and one of the factors that leads many to believe that they did in fact die in the fire. Because if his original statement is factual and true, that places the missing kids inside the home after the fire had started.
- [16:17]
The Captain
And obviously, if the parents are questioning whether or not those kids were in the house, they're going to do the best shakedown to get the truthful information out of their son.
- [16:29]
Nick
He then went outside to try to put the fire out, then ran back in to bring the rest of the kids down, but by that point the stairs had been engulfed in flames. He also tried to start one of the trucks, but could not. And he states that the wind was blowing from the direction of the corner of the house where the fire started, the southeast corner. He also states that they repaired motors in the basement. And to his knowledge, there were two motors down there at the time of the fire. I guess trying to crawl inside, inside of this dude's head here. I mean, what level of guilt does he have? A massive amount of guilt that they died in the fire. Right. And keep in mind, this report, this official report is stated that it was taken the day of, but not reported officially until January 21st. So here's what I'm getting at. Bear with me here, Captain. I know that a lot of times all we have to go off of is someone's words, right? And. But we both agree that this case has been reported on a lot of different ways over the eight decades. I don't know, I just could see a situation where in the moment, right. Your brothers and sisters died in this house fire. And in his grief and in the moment and just reacting to the unimaginable, he says, I tried to. I woke them up. They didn't get out of the house. And then later, with a clear head and a clear view of what he remembers, states, I, I didn't wake them up. I ran downstairs and I was yelling for them to get up.
- [18:09]
The Captain
Yeah, I can't remember who said it, but because I'd love to give them credit for this thought. But the thought was that his initial statement is what he should have done. And the later statement was the truth. Because of eventually, as the. As there's questions, are they in the house or not? These little details then matter. And once this individual knows that these details matter, he just tells the truth.
- [18:36]
Nick
Exactly. I. I could see that. I mean, again, in the moment, reacting to the unimaginable. What did he say? And is that a reflection of the truth or not? Or more of his feelings? The ladder is an interesting part of this story. I think it's one that's talked about at length. But you and I agree on the general statements regarding this ladder. We have multiple members of the Sodder family saying the ladder was always here in this position. We always kept it here. And then when we went to go and get it when we needed it the most during the middle of this fire, all of a sudden it wasn't there. Now the ladder is stored outside of the home. Any person could get to it. Anybody could take it. Somebody could do something with the ladder. What we do know, and this is in every report, distance varies, but the general statement is always the same. The ladder was later found over an embankment. And some take it a step further, say, you know, appears somebody had thrown it over an embankment. And the report I have in front of me here, Captain, states that it was approximately 70ft from. From the hold.
- [19:49]
The Captain
Yeah.
- [19:50]
Nick
So this would be an implication that if the fire was arson, somebody got rid of the ladder, thinking that that would slow people to get out of the house or maybe even slow extinguishing the flames.
- [20:06]
The Captain
Yeah. It's also a very good possibility because you have so many kids that at some point maybe one of the kids moved this ladder. And, and obviously we have five missing kids. So we have five kids that could have moved the ladder before the fire took place. And they can't. They're not around to confess to it.
- [20:28]
Nick
Yes, that. That could very well be true. And that doesn't necessarily mean that it was an accidental fire or an arson. It kind of leaves it right still in the. The gray area. We've mentioned the trucks several times. I kind. I appreciate the candor here because I found later reports. Look, it's often been speculated and often been reported that the trucks were possibly messed with or disturbed. We have in a later article one of the family members who was attempting to start the truck that night admitting that we probably choked them too hard as we were panicked in a hurry, and we probably prevented them from. From starting. Now, that's not Scientifically conclusive information. But I find that interesting that the, the folks that are in the camp, the family members that are in the camp of someone stole our loved ones and set our house on fire, are openly saying years later we think the truck part of this was just us rushing to rescue and we, we failed.
- [21:47]
The Captain
Yeah, I really wish they would have brought out some kind of scent dogs because you have another scenario too where you have kids that are saying hey, we want to stay up and play. Is there any, do we have any cause for concern that they left the property like on their own very cold that night.
- [22:06]
Nick
It was snowing at some point. It was a white Christmas that night. The Here, here's another interest and this is fact. After the fire, remember we had the, the one time boss, the one time business partner, the co signer on the home, Forenzo Gianutello, the man who was encouraging George to increase the insurance on the house and take out insurance on family members of the Sodder family. It was learned after the fire that John Otello did it on his own, raised the insurance anyways on the home without telling George Sodder. From 1500 to 1750, Johnatello was, was paid out after the fire. Remember he was the beneficiary of this insurance.
- [23:02]
The Captain
Well, that could be a motive.
- [23:03]
Nick
Yes, it very well could have. So the, that would have been a little over $30,000 today, which is a lot of money. Can be. And, and we've seen unfortunately, we've seen people killed or bad things done to people for a lot less. A lot lot less. Unfortunately. But to me it does seem like a rather small amount to nine children. Not saying it's impossible.
- [23:28]
The Captain
Yeah, but see, but again that's the difficult thing here because you could go. His plan could have been well, screw this George guy, I'm going to burn down the house. But they'll get out. Nobody will get killed.
- [23:44]
Nick
And we've seen plenty of times where somebody holds a grudge, some weird crazy grudge and all reasoning tossed aside. Right. Just it's all. It's, it's about getting even and nothing else.
- [24:01]
The Captain
Yeah, but I'd also say desperate times cause for desperate measures. And I think again, we don't know what was going on in his world. One of the things that people talk about is because of the, because that they were from Italy and we don't, we don't really know why he left. Like there's not like a complete story of why, why did George decide to come to America and start a new life? And so then there's some thoughts that maybe he was tied to some bad or shady businesses back there.
- [24:38]
Nick
He could have been. But we need to keep in mind he was 13 years old when he came from Italy to the United States. Right.
- [24:46]
The Captain
And then I just wonder because. And again, this is probably because I, I'm really late to the party. But I just finished, I just finished the Sopranos a little bit ago. And you see in that situation where they're like, well, if we're gonna mess with if this guy owes us money or this guy is dead to us, the actions of terror or the actions of violence is towards that individual. They normally stay away from children and wives and stuff. And so. But that, that gets brought up often in this case.
- [25:25]
Nick
Well, and the witness that we have is quite interesting because we talked about where did the fire start? That's always been something that is heavily debated. And we do know that based off of the statements given by Mrs. Sauter that she first. She appears to be the first one in the family to see the flames. And she sees them in the office already inside of the home. But it's later learned that a witness come, comes forward saying that I'm driving past the house. He states that he saw what looked like balls of fire in the air, in the sky, being thrown onto the roof or thrown at the house.
- [26:08]
The Captain
Yeah. Didn't they find some weird like cocktail bomb?
- [26:13]
Nick
Yeah. So that's what. When I read that statement, I immediately went to Molotov cocktail thinking that that's what may have been thrown there. There is a report, a statement in one of the reports that later they found what they described as either a pineapple bomb or a grenade type device. But. And some reports state that they were like little green balls. But I don't know. I, I would like to. You would think that that would be something that would be photographed and well documented and not kind of like, oh.
- [26:52]
The Captain
By the way, again, because this case is so bizarre and mysterious, it lends itself to some wacky rumors.
- [27:09]
Oregon Lottery Announcer
Looking for a last minute gift for your people, you know, your people, that weird bunch of friends and family that you love dearly. Well, here's an easy idea. Oregon Lottery Holiday scratch. It's because your people, they're the ones that amidst all the holiday crowds and endless notifications, help you find the fun, which calls for a little gift that brings big cheer. Oregon Lottery Holiday scratchets. You know where to find them. Grab some today. Must be 18 or older to play. Lottery games are based on chance and should be played for entertainment only.
- [27:39]
Mint Mobile Announcer
Don't let Overpriced phone bills suck the joy out of your holidays this year. Right now, all of Mint Mobile's Unlimited plans are 50% off. You can get 3, 6 or 12 months of unlimited premium wireless for 15 bucks a month. As you can tell, I'm sick. But what I'm sick of is these big wireless companies charging an arm and a leg and saying that it's a premium service. Not with Mint Mobile you get high quality wireless service at a fraction of the price. I switched to Mint Mobile. I'm saving a little over $100 per month. Turn your expensive wireless present into a huge wireless savings future by switching to Mint. Shop Mint unlimited plans@mintmobile.com TCG that's mintmobile.com TCG Limited time offer upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for six months or $180 for 12 month plan required $15 per month equivalent taxes and fees Extra initial plan term only over 35 gigabytes may slow when network is busy. Capable device required Ability, speed and coverage varies. See mintmobile.com if you want to save money but still get great quality wireless Service, check out mintmobile.com tcg today time it's always vanishing.
- [29:10]
Carvana Announcer
The commute, the errands, the work functions, the meetings. Selling your car Unless you sell your car with Carvana, get a real offer in minutes. Get it picked up from your door. Get paid on the spot so fast you'll wonder what the catch is. There isn't one. We just respect you and your time. Oh, you're still here. Move along now. Enjoy your day. Sell your car today. Carvana Pick up fees may apply cold.
- [29:36]
Nick
Mornings Holiday plans this is when you need your wardrobe to just work stuff that looks sharp and feels good. Quince makes gifting easy when everything's worth keeping for yourself. By partnering directly with trusted factories that maintain high standards for craftsmanship and ethical practices, Quince cuts out the middlemen and markups. That means premium quality at half the cost of the other high end brands so you can give luxury pieces without the luxury price tag. This fall I am loading up on quints. Stuffing my closet with quince. Just picked up some stretch Quartery five pocket pants in storm blue. Blue? That's crazy. And I got the sweater Knit fleece full zip jacket. It comes in three colors and because the price was so juicy good, I got two of them. Get your wardrobe sorted and your gift list handled with quints. Don't wait. Go to quint.comgarage for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns now available in Canada too. That's Q u I n c.com garage free shipping and three 65 day returns quint.com garage.
- [31:09]
The Captain
All right, we are back you filthy animals. Talk. Hands in the air. Cheers to you Colonel.
- [31:15]
Nick
Cheers to you Captain Little Little shiner. Holiday cheer beer with a eggnog sidecar. Everybody out there wishing you the very best and happiest of all holidays. The phone line is something that should be discussed as well because there were reports that the phone line, and this makes sense, simply melted, was destroyed in the fire. Some of the reports state that Jenny Sodders picked up the phone and the phone didn't work.
- [31:50]
The Captain
Right.
- [31:51]
Nick
The report I gave and chose to use here for the telling of this true crime story is that she didn't make it to the phone because of the flames. The office space was already in. Engulfed in flames and she, she couldn't make it to the phone.
- [32:06]
The Captain
Yeah.
- [32:07]
Nick
Either way, the result is the same. No phone call for help came from inside the solder home.
- [32:14]
The Captain
Yeah, and again, I'm not electrician, but this is. We get into this weird gray area because you have some eyewitnesses saying, well yeah, we saw a fire but the lights were still on. And then you go, well, they have this separate fuse box. So is that two separate systems? So could hypothetically, could you have the one system have faulty electronics, it goes up in flame and it has really zero effect on the other electricity to the house until the fire gets big enough.
- [32:50]
Nick
I agree, I'm no out Borlin or Bob Vila, but I would, it would stand to reason that one could operate while the other has is not.
- [32:59]
The Captain
Yeah, I'm no Bob Vila, but I got a whole trunk of duct tape.
- [33:03]
Nick
It was later so later when it came time to restore the phone line. So we should point out something here that is unique about this story as well. When they came time to rebuild their home or build a new home, they didn't build it over top of where the old one once stood. No, they put, they, they basically built it next to there.
- [33:25]
The Captain
Yeah, he ended up basically George, that's what I'm talking about. The father ended up just burying the whole old building and it was basically like a little hill in their yard. That was a burial to his children. And you know, I should say a memorial to the children because I, I don't think the family had a gut feeling that their loved ones were gone. I think their gut feeling was telling them, no, they're still alive. They're out there somewhere.
- [33:56]
Nick
Gut Feel, I mean, they fought till. Till they. For the rest of their lives to try to find these children.
- [34:02]
The Captain
Yeah.
- [34:02]
Nick
And what. What I find interesting too. And this goes back to something that was said that we said on the show many, many moons ago in the first season of our show that, you know, I had said. I'm always suspicious when a. A kid disappears, goes missing, and then later the family moves away. Yeah, I always find that very strange. Here you have the exact opposite. You would have. What I would expect, a grieving family, grieving parents, parents that are convinced that their child could be alive out there somewhere. They never move. They never change their phone number. Why? Because God forbid that kid get the chance to, you know, not God forbid. Let's hope that that kid gets the opportunity to get to a phone and can call home. We can't change the phone number. We should never move. Because what if they try to come back and the solders didn't move? They built their home right next to the old one. So the phone company has to come out and put up a new restore phone service now to the new house. Right. The phone company informs the solders that, hey, the old phone line, it didn't melt in the fire. We found that it was cut. And it was cut 14ft in the air and 2ft away from the pole. This many people saying, and rightfully so, meaning that a ladder would have to have been needed to reach it.
- [35:30]
The Captain
Makes sense.
- [35:31]
Nick
So think about this for the moment you manage to set the house ablaze, you're attempting an arson either prior to or shortly after you want to cut the phone line, you borrow the ladder. Maybe the ladder was. You didn't. Maybe the perpetrator or whoever set the fire walked down this road with me and pretend for a moment. Maybe they didn't move the ladder and throw it down the embankment because they were hoping that it would deter people from getting outside or extinguishing the flames. It was simply they moved it to cut the phone line at some point and toss the ladder after doing so.
- [36:08]
The Captain
Yeah, I always wondered too. Did they use the ladder to remove the children from the house?
- [36:14]
Nick
That's a strong possibility. I always wondered if the kids never went back upstairs, if they were removed from the ground level.
- [36:23]
The Captain
Right.
- [36:24]
Nick
Right near the front porch.
- [36:26]
The Captain
But then why wasn't the littlest one removed, the one that was on the couch?
- [36:31]
Nick
You're right. So I failed to report that in our timeline. She went to bed with the mother.
- [36:36]
The Captain
Right. So that makes sense. We don't want to try to wake the mother she went to bed with.
- [36:41]
Nick
The, with the littlest one in the parents room. From, from my understanding this part is odd because it's not reported in a lot of the reports on this. But again the captain was right. A lot of times near Christmas time you get the retelling of the story and you kind of get the 10 minute version. So you're, you're not going to have every fine detail that is involved in the story. But what was learned and reported on that at some point either prior to or after the fire had been set, we don't know. Lonnie Johnson and Jeff Adkins, remember these are the two that own that Cass's place, the, the beer place that was Cass's park that we had mentioned. Lonnie Johnson and Jeff Adkins entered the solders barn, stole a pair of chain hoist and threw them over an embankment to retrieve at a later time. Now stealing these chain hoist would not have been an easy task as they were connected to the ceiling in the barn and would take a fair amount of time and assistance to remove them. Now when George Sodder found out after the fire, he finds out about this, reports it, Jeff Atkins, he around the same time enrolls in the army and he goes off and he is gone for about two years. Yeah, Jeff Adkins, the other guy was as this report goes, never questioned or charged for this theft. However, that Lonnie Johnson was ordered to appear in court but never did and was eventually fined $25 for this and nothing else was done. Part of this chain hoist story includes the telephone line. Lonnie Johnson also admitted to cutting the telephone lines because quote, he thought it was the power line and thought cutting the power line would stop the fire. And we know based off of the other reports that Lonnie Johnson and Jeff Atkins were persons that showed up to the fire that morning. So his statement is yeah, I cut the, I cut the phone line, but I didn't know that it was the phone line. I thought there's faulty wiring, it's an electrical fire. If I cut the, the power to running to the house that, that would, would help put out this fire which.
- [39:08]
The Captain
Would, which would have probably killed him. Yeah, well, he's probably your criminal because what, what have we learned in the last 10 years? A lot of these criminals are dumb.
- [39:20]
Nick
Well, and okay, when the latter part is a big part of the story again that what he thought was the power line but turns out to be the telephone line and they say, well a ladder would have had to been used to cut It. At that point.
- [39:36]
The Captain
Yeah.
- [39:37]
Nick
Where's the followup of. Okay, well, how did you get up there, sir? And, oh, you used the family's ladder. Because here's. Here's the part that, that matters with this. If it was cut before the fire and he used that ladder, he moved the ladder. If it was cut after the fire, which we don't have. We don't have that marker on our timeline. It's not known. But it goes back to, well, did he bring his own ladder to the. To the situation to cut it to try to save the day, or did he. Did he move the ladder after the fire had started? Because if he was the one to move the ladder, then the ladder was still in its position when he found it.
- [40:18]
The Captain
Yeah. Then it makes you wonder if George the father, is telling the whole truth and nothing but the truth. Or again, it's a very chaotic scene. So the fact that some of these individuals are going to report things that might not have been true because there's this chaos, that's a very good likelihood. So then if you can explain the cutting of the phone line and you can explain the ladder, you can explain the cars. Oh, we just probably choked them out too quickly. Okay, that's great. And maybe it was just an accident, but where are the children? And I think that's what's very difficult, too, because I'm not a scientist, I can't tell you when somebody's cremated how much is left behind, how big are the bone fragments? Because these were smaller children, Would that play a role? Is there a difference in the bone density of smaller children? Would that affect how. And it's no easy way to say that, but it's like there could be all these reasons that would affect if we find their remains or not. So you can have a situation where. Yeah, and, and that's where I go back to with, like, the insurance man when. When he goes, oh, well, your. Your house is going to burn down, your kids are going to suffer, and blah, blah, blah. Did he do an inspection? Because I was watching the show the other day, you might have heard of it. It's called the Gilmore Girls. And she had a bed and breakfast basically in. And she thought she was getting screwed on her insurance. So she had an agent come out, but the agent had to do an inspection on the house. So this is information that George would have been privy to. When the agent came to the house, did he just. Was he making threats or did he go around the house and look at things and go, hey, yeah, your, your electrician told you this stuff is correct, but it's not, and you need to do something about this. And so then when George says, well, no, I'm not going to do anything. I'm not raising the insurance on this house because I wouldn't benefit from it anyways. And the agent's like, yeah, but I just, I just inspected your house and you have some problems. So if you don't do this, your whole house is going to burn down, your children are going to die. Like, where's trying to talk some sense into him? So that's where it's like, did this individual threaten him or was the individual trying to say, what are you doing? Like you have things that you need to fix or bad things can happen.
- [43:08]
Nick
Well, later we have bones that are found. We have an excavation that takes place and it yields some findings. Those findings are some bones. Okay, so this report, report on examination of bones by Oscar B. Hunter, the items that are being tested were received on August 19, 1949. The report is from August 25, 1940. 49. We have eight fragments of bone that were found in the northeast corner and were determined to be animal bones. Six bones, two of which are fragments, were found in the southeast corner. Two fragments were determined to be chicken femurs, but the other four definitely consisted of a lumbar vertebrae. Okay, so eight fragments of bone were determined to be animal bones. And then we have six bones. Two of those fragments were determined to be chicken femurs, but the other four definitely consisted of lumbar vertebrae. These vertebrae show no evidence of being burned. However, the approximate age of this vertebrae, 14 to 15 year old child. Now here's the problem. You don't find the rest of the skeleton. What this report states is that this vertebrae would have had to have been forcibly removed from the rest of the skeleton, suggesting that these bones were separated from the remaining portion of the skeleton at a later time and that the skeleton was. The vertebrae too have no evidence of being burned. This is very strange. So while it may tell some people that this could be one of the kids, remains of one of the kids, it's also saying these remains weren't burned at any time. So there's a shipping invoice to the Smithsonian Institute that took place on September 20, 1949. Inside of it were those human and animal bones. And the human bones consisted of four lumbar, lumbar vertebrae belonging to one individual. The age of that individual is anywhere from 16 to 22 years of age and at the time of death. So this, this is A different report by a different agency. It is possible but not probable that these bones would belong to a 14 and a half year old boy. So that would be Maurice. Again this report two states vertebrae showed no evidence of being exposed to fire. This report also states that it is very strange that no other bones were found. Also states that since the house was estimated to have burned for only. This report says half an hour. But I'm with the captain. I've seen reports 45 minutes to an hour that they would expect to have found full skeletons of the children, not just fragments. And then did you hear the story about the heart?
- [46:09]
The Captain
You saved the best for last.
- [46:11]
Nick
We have a heart that was found. All right, bear with me on this because it's complicated. It stated that a heart was found and that it was buried at the scene. Now when the solder parents catch wind of this, they want to know where, where was this heart? We want to retrieve it. Where was it buried? And they were told that it was a stake was used to mark where it was buried. The problem with that portion of the story is there's no stake. The family remained on the property, they lived on that property. No steak. So eventually they're shown where this air quotes heart was buried to which when they retrieve this item, it is sent off for testing and it's determined to be a beef liver. So not a heart at all and not human. And some reports state that it is fresh. So keep in mind this, this, this is quite a bit of time later. So this is saying that somebody went back to the location of the fire, the house fire, and planted this item in hopes that whoever found it would buy what this person was selling. That it was in fact a heart. Now later this person admitted that, hey, I went there and I put this item there. I was hoping that the family would find it. And then in turn they would except what happened to their children. That they, they clearly needed some strong evidence to tell them that their kids perished in that fire. They don't have the mental, emotional capacity to accept that.
- [47:59]
The Captain
Right.
- [47:59]
Nick
And so I placed this item there, place to live because I was hoping to help them. I was hoping to help them.
- [48:06]
The Captain
So stupid.
- [48:07]
Nick
And then we also have small town.
- [48:08]
The Captain
So all these people are connected. You know, the old boss is connected to the fire department, the fire department people are connected to the coroner, the coroner is connected to the insurance agent. They're all connected. But it's weird because it's like, okay, if these five children, everything scientifically kind of points to that. They're not in the house. And then you go, cool. Okay, so maybe the fire was a distraction for kidnapping these children or an.
- [48:39]
Nick
Attempt to cover up them being taken. Right. If.
- [48:43]
The Captain
No, that's what I mean. Like, we're gonna take the children and then we'll start this fire, and then.
- [48:51]
Nick
Everyone will think that they died in the fire. And as you pointed out, that was unfortunately such a common thing. Much more common back then than it is today. So it would seem conceivable. Right? Yeah.
- [49:07]
The Captain
And also, I think it's like when winter time, especially back then, winter time and, and Christmas time was like, that was the house fire season. But then you also wonder too, like. Well, I wonder too, like, maybe it was more sinister than that. Maybe this ex boss had this fondness for his children, but thought, you know, what if I'll burn down the house, so I'll get the money, but I'll take the children because I want to make sure that they're safe. I don't want them to die, but I can't get to all of them. Well, I'll just, you know, whoever's going to start the fire, you just tell, hey, start the fire. Get as many of the kids you can, and then the kids will go away. We'll send them to somebody to raise, and then I get to see the destruction that I caused. Like you said this would. This would have to be somebody that was not. Not just in it for the money, but in it for the revenge to watch George Sodder suffer for the rest of his life. But then it's also too like some of these businesses were backed by organized crime. And, and that I think that's something. Again, I don't think George would have told anybody that except for maybe his other family members. Well, this might have happened because I had some ties to some people I shouldn't have had ties to, but I don't think anybody's reporting that he was a drunk or a gambler or whatever. And most people don't steal your kids and add responsibility to their own plate because you owe somebody money.
- [50:51]
Nick
Well, years later, the solders receive a letter. And this many say, is believed to be possibly the most credible evidence that they were right, that. That. That the children were still alive. And in this specific scenario, at least, Lewis was still alive. Because as the story goes here, Captain, one day Jenny found in the mail a letter addressed to her, postmarked in Central City, Kentucky, with no return address. Inside, Jenny finds a picture of a young man who appears to be in his late 20s, maybe 30 years old, with she says features that strongly resembled Lewis, one of their missing kids, who would have been in his 30s if he had survived. On the back of this was written Lewis Solder, I love brother Frankie llil boys. And then this is handwritten, too. So a little bit of speculation here. A 90132 or a 90135 on the back of this. But we were. There was. They were never able to determine if this was, in fact, Lewis, where it came from, who sent it, or really any other information about this picture. Now?
- [52:13]
The Captain
No, I. I believe they actually had the return address, and they. This is the one where they sent the private investigator out to look for the individual. But the private investigator took their money, I don't think ever returned. And so a lot of people make that a big deal of this story. Well, a private investigator disappeared as well. Well, we don't know if he just took the money or not. Right?
- [52:37]
Nick
Yeah. So I, I think the part of this is. I think from my understanding that was a story that came out of Houston, Texas, that, that it was a tip that came into the family with this one that we have with the picture of the unidentified person with the name Louis Sodder written on the back. The reports I have say that it was postmarked in Central City, Kentucky, with no return address.
- [53:05]
The Captain
Even if they had an address on it, they're probably not gonna put their house address on it. So you could come looking for them. You wonder too, like, okay, so if this kid. Let's just go down a hypothetical road here. If this child is alive, then the other ones got out of the fire as well, and they're living somewhere else now. Are they all still alive? Who knows? But that means all five got out and. And they're alive somewhere. And it's probably somebody that just saw from a distance what was happening and felt like they had to do something to give this family some answers or some type of closure. And then I guess you can also. These stories get so big. The amount of pictures I've received of people that go, hey, don't you think this person looks like Mara Murray? Hey, don't you think this person looks like Brian Schaefer? And it's like, I don't know, did you go up and talk to him? Like you just took a picture from afar or. Or you found this picture on the Internet? So this story being as popular as it was and as talked about it as it was, even though it was a long, long time ago, the. The story would have traveled slower, but it still would have traveled so it could just be somebody that thought that this looked like one of the children all grown up.
- [54:36]
Nick
Well, and I think one part too, that, that is important to understand here. Okay? So this story, when you review it and you just start to look at it from the 30,000ft view to me, I go, the kids burned up in the house. And I'm terribly sorry that that happened, but that seems to be the obvious explanation. Then when you tell me that nothing was found. And then when stuff is found, it's not remains that can be identified as any of these, these children, most of it not human at all. And then what? The remains that were human show no signs of being part of a fire. That's when I start to go, you know what? I, I have a difficult time wrapping my head around the idea that somebody took the kids and set the fire and managed to keep them away forever. But you don't have a body. You don't, you don't have any bodies. And then there's also the science of it. Okay? We talked about items that were found that were recovered from the site of the fire, and some of those items were coins. So up until 1982, pennies were made of 95% copper, 5% zinc. Copper burns, melts at just under 20. Sorry, just under 2000 degrees Fahrenheit. Zinc burns, melts at just under 800 degrees Fahrenheit. Nickels, up until 1942, nickels were made of 25% nickel and 75% copper. Nickel burns, melts at 2600 degrees Fahrenheit. Now, from 1942 to 1945, nickels were made from a three part alloy that contains silver and copper because they were saving nickel supplies for the war effort. So this alloy in particular burns, melts at 1630 degrees Fahrenheit. Bone is difficult, okay. Bone turns to ash through a process where extreme heat removes water and burns organic material, mostly collagen, causing mineral crystals to change and fuse, requiring temperatures generally from 120092 degrees Fahrenheit to over 1800 degrees Fahrenheit. Okay, so that, that temperature certainly falls within the range of nickels that may have melted. But we have things that are burning and, or, sorry, not burning and surviving at the scene that burn and melt at a much lower temperature than bone. And then here's the problem though, too. If, if you were to burn bone. So a cremation, Right, let's take cremation, for example.
- [57:55]
The Captain
Yeah.
- [57:55]
Nick
Crematories reach around 1800 degrees Fahrenheit. So you're going to burn for one to two hours. 1800 degrees Fahrenheit. 1800 degrees Fahrenheit is much higher than the zinc.
- [58:12]
The Captain
Yeah.
- [58:13]
Nick
And it has to burn for one to two hours. Now let's say, let's pretend maybe that fire did burn for, for one hour. This reducing the body to bone fragments. They didn't find fragments. 1800 degrees gets you to fragments. If you were to get true ash, complete combustion to mineral ash requires a much higher heat and longer durations of that heat making bone fully disappear. And it's such a high heat and such a lengthy process that this isn't typically the standard in cremation. You look at the science of it and I'm, and I don't want to sit here and pretend to say that. Look, that definitively says what did or did not happen that day. I think what it says is this is more reason to question why they didn't find remains of five people, not of one person, of five people.
- [59:11]
The Captain
And what are the odds of that? Slim to none. And where I'm going when this is all said and done, I'm going to burn for a lot longer than that, my friend.
- [59:20]
Nick
For those that are saying absolutely not, they died in the fire, I just want you to, to have this information because if it could happen once, it's very conceivable that it could have happened before. Okay. This is a story out of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The headline is a fire that authorities six years ago thought killed a 10 day old girl was a ruse to kidnap the infant. Philadelphia police said. And I'll just read you part of the story and that is the baby, Delamar Vera was sleeping in an upstairs front bedroom when a fire broke out at her family's two story row house in North Philadelphia. This took place December 15, 1997. Her mother runs upstairs, could not find Delamar, the baby, when she ran into the room. She eventually ran out of the house overcome by smoke. She was burned herself. Her other two children survived, thank God. The remains of the infant's body were never found and police concluded that they had been incinerated in the flames. The official cause of the fire was listed as an overheated extension cord attached to a space heater. Six years, six years later, the mother sees a young girl and she says, I recognize the face. That's my daughter. They do DNA test and confirm that it was this woman's missing daughter. So just have the information that when they, when the officials ruled on this house fire and a deceased completely incinerated body in the flames in 1997, 52 years after the Christmas fire on 1945. If they got it wrong in 97 using that technology, those resources, then it's very conceivable that they may have gotten it wrong back in 1945.
- [61:51]
The Captain
I want to thank everybody so much for keeping us company in the garage all year long. Thanks for being our friends. Thanks for listening to these true crime stories. Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays to everybody. And happy holidays to you as well, my friend.
- [62:06]
Nick
Colonel Merry Christmas. Happy holidays to you as well, Captain. And cheers to everybody out there listening to my voice right now. I hope you have the best of holidays for you and yours and a happy, healthy and prosperous New Year.
- [62:25]
The Captain
Sam.
- [62:58]
Oregon Lottery Announcer
Looking for a last minute gift for your people? You know, your people, that weird bunch of friends and family that you love dearly. Well, here's an easy idea. Oregon Lottery Holiday Scratch. It's because your people, they're the ones that amidst all the holiday crowds and endless notifications, help you find the fun, which calls for a little gift that brings big cheer. Oregon Lottery Holiday Scratchets. You know where to find them. Grab some today. Must be 18 or older to play. Lottery games are based on chance and should be played for entertainment only.