True Crime Obsessed – Episode 496: The Curious Case of... The Skincare Queen and the Hitman
Original Air Date: April 28, 2026
Episode Overview
The hosts dive into the wild true-crime documentary, "The Curious Case of the Skincare Queen and the Hitman," recapping a tangled and outrageous story of LA skincare drama turned criminal saga. The focus: Dawn DeLuise, a celebrity facialist in West Hollywood, accused of hiring a hitman to kill her business rival. As the hosts sift through layers of lies, revenge, gossip, and escalating harassment, things get both absurd and dark – all recounted with TCO’s signature blend of irreverence, humor, and outrage.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. Setting the Scene: Skincare, Celebrity, and LA Shenanigans
- The story is set in the world of high-end LA skincare, where reputation is everything and competition is intense. Dawn DeLuise, the “Skincare Queen,” is accused of extreme measures against a neighboring waxing studio owner, Gabriel Suarez (“the Hitman” in question, though not literally).
- The documentary narration style and style choices (like “blocky yellow font”) are praised.
Quote: "I really love the blocky yellow font that they use... I love the style of this series." – A (01:26)
2. Dawn DeLuise: Backstory and Psychology
- Dawn is introduced as a driven, workhorse-type who’s climbed from Florida beauty pageants to Hollywood, eventually amassing a celebrity client list (of dubious authenticity).
Quote: "She made tons of money. She's a workhorse because she has a vision, she has a dream... That's the one thing I will give Dawn." – A (13:05)
- She’s described as image-obsessed, paranoid, “a professional victim,” and (per the hosts and the doc) both racist and homophobic.
- Her business success is questioned, especially the legitimacy of her claims about her celebrity clientele.
Quote: "If they actually came in, she'd have a picture with them." – A (03:49)
3. The Rivalry: Gabriel Suarez and the 'Butt-Waxing' Studio
- Gabriel Suarez opens a waxing studio (“Smooth Cheeks”) two doors down from DeLuise’s facial spa, sparking Dawn’s suspicion and paranoia.
- Dawn fixates on Gabriel, convinced he’s out to destroy her, based on a brief interaction years prior when he inquired about job openings.
- The hosts point out the lack of any logical connection between the two businesses—one does facials, one waxes butts—and suggest it was all in Dawn’s head.
Quote: "Couldn't this have been a great partnership? Like, oh, after they get their butt waxed right next to you for a facial and vice versa..." – A (18:04)
4. Harassment Campaign: Flyers, Doxxing, and Revenge Porn
- Dawn becomes the victim of an escalating series of harassment: tires slashed, slurs painted on her parking sign, and most disturbingly, explicit flyers with her face and personal info distributed around town.
- The narrative initially pushes the idea that Gabriel or people he knows are responsible for the campaign, putting Dawn in legitimate danger.
- The hosts highlight how truly horrifying and traumatic this aspect of the story is—even for someone as problematic as Dawn.
Quote: "They're doxing her... inviting, like, come over and rape me. Saying she likes to get raped. So, like, this is at full stop. Absolutely not. Okay." – B (19:24)
5. The Investigation and Scheming: Who’s Lying?
- Dawn goes repeatedly to the police, who offer little concrete help; she claims self-defense justifies increasingly erratic behavior, including soliciting friends to lie for her.
- Turns out Dawn is orchestrating a campaign to frame Gabriel, asking friends to lie about him while giving police faked evidence and scripting witness statements.
Quote: "She's also falsifying police reports that she's giving to the cops..." – B (35:05)
- However, late in the story, it's revealed (with a twist) that the main perpetrators of the doxxing/flyer campaign were actually Dawn’s own “friends” Edward (Ed) Feinstein and Nick Prugo (of Bling Ring infamy), apparently as revenge for various petty betrayals.
6. Murder for Hire? Dawn’s Arrest and Trial
- The narrative flips: Dawn is arrested in a SWAT raid for solicitation of murder, based on texts where she muses about wanting Gabriel dead and suggests she has found someone (NFL player Chris Guy) to kill him.
- The involvement of friends, “hitmen,” and double-crosses makes the case deeply convoluted. The hosts (and jurors in the doc) question the evidence's strength: is Dawn truly plotting murder, or catastrophically venting amid real harassment?
- Her mugshot becomes tabloid fodder; the LA gay scene revels in her downfall—cruel humor abounds.
Quote: "Everyone also is here to talk about how, quote, unattractive Dawn's mugshot was because she was, like, a beauty guru..." – B (28:09)
7. The Jury’s Dilemma and Systemic Failure
- The jury is torn: Dawn is undeniably racist, untrustworthy, and unhinged, but she is also a genuine victim of dangerous harassment.
- The hosts praise the jury's honesty—she’s swiftly acquitted of the murder-for-hire charges, not because she’s blameless, but because there’s no hard evidence she was actually plotting Gabriel’s death.
- Quote: "...less than 40 minutes to find her not guilty. They're like, all of these awful things happened to her, but I don't think she actually hired this person to kill this guy." – A (49:57)
- The system is shown as ill-equipped: the true stalkers (Nick/Ed) get minimal consequences (probation, community service); Dawn faces no real accountability; Gabriel is left traumatized.
8. Revelations & Aftermath: The Real Villains
- Ed and Nick finally admit to orchestrating the campaign against Dawn and, by extension, Gabriel. Ed is later revealed as an unrepentant scammer and stalker.
- Gabe, the only person truly innocent and decent in the mess, summarizes:
Quote: "She was wanting me beat up, offed. She was the original Karen. She's dangerous." – Gabriel Suarez (37:26)
- Dawn and Ed never apologize—to each other or to Gabriel. Dawn is last seen dumpster-diving for skincare products, her ambitions in tatters.
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
-
[14:18] – On Dawn's 'suspect' story skills:
"In her telling... she looks bad. He's all 'wait over here, you're busy,' and she's like, 'Did you see a sign in the window? Get out.'"
-
[19:24] – On the horror of the harassment campaign:
"This is at full stop. Absolutely not. Okay. They're doxing her... inviting, like, come over and rape me."
-
[35:44] – On Dawn’s self-incriminating texts:
"I'd be lying if I said I didn't wish he was dead. Do I want to be traced to anything that happens to him, or do I want anyone I know to be in trouble? No."
-
[48:13] – On the core riddle:
"Tell me again, Don, how you connected this to the poor butt waxing guy?"
-
[49:46] – On Dawn’s racism:
"Is the Aryan Brotherhood only in prison... I can't believe I can't find a white supremacist to do harm to a double minority. Gay / Mexican. Right? What a piece of shit."
-
[67:19] – Closing burn:
"Dawn is dumpster diving for products. I was like, how is she letting this be filmed?" – A
Timestamps of Key Segments
- Intro/Setting: 00:56 – 03:50
- Dawn DeLuise Backstory: 11:10 – 13:30
- Skincare Rivalry & Gabriel: 15:25 – 18:06
- Harassment Campaign Details: 19:01 – 21:00
- The Set-Up & Perjury Plotline: 26:05 – 29:00
- SWAT Raids & Arrests: 27:32 – 28:39 / 41:12 – 41:46
- Jury Deliberation & Verdict: 47:23 – 51:13
- Reveal of the Real Culprits: 43:35 – 44:05 / 62:11 – 62:34
- Aftermath & Dumpster Diving Endnote: 67:19 – 67:40
Tone and Style
The hosts maintain their signature tone: biting, camp, sardonic, and quick with pop culture asides, but drawing sharp ethical lines around harassment, racism, and homophobia. They celebrate the only true “good guy” (Gabriel), and cast “bad gays” Ed/Nick as tragicomic villains.
Summary Takeaway
This episode of TCO masterfully recaps a story that’s both bonkers and disturbing, holding every character to account (except Gabriel, who emerges as a lone beacon of normalcy and kindness). The documentary serves as a cautionary tale about the toxic LA pursuit of fame, the dangers of petty vendettas, and how quickly reality blurs in the echo chamber of privilege and delusion. The hosts leave listeners with one clear conclusion: sometimes the truth is messier—and much queerer—than fiction.