True Crime with Kendall Rae: A Fitbit Helped Solve This Murder?! The Case of Nicole VanderHeyden

Release Date: January 9, 2025

Introduction

In this gripping episode of True Crime with Kendall Rae, host Kendall delves deep into the tragic and complex case of Nicole VanderHeyden. Released on January 9, 2025, this episode uncovers the intricate details of Nicole's life, her untimely death, and the unexpected role a Fitbit played in solving her murder. Kendall's empathetic approach shines as she meticulously breaks down the events leading up to Nicole's disappearance and the subsequent investigation.

Background: Who Was Nicole VanderHeyden?

Nicole "Nikki" VanderHeyden was a beloved mother, teacher, and an active member of her community. Born on March 29, 1995, in Green Bay, Wisconsin, Nikki was known for her intelligence, passion for education, and unwavering dedication to her children. She earned dual bachelor's degrees in science and education from the University of Wisconsin, Green Bay, and became a substitute science teacher, inspiring countless students with her love for biology.

Kendall highlights Nikki's vibrant personality and her profound impact on those around her:

"Nikki was the type of person that didn't just show up and do the job. She genuinely loved it. And she helped her students get excited about what they were learning about. She especially loved biology." ([04:15])

Nikki was a devoted mother to two children from a previous marriage and was eagerly expecting her third child. Her love for family was evident in her active lifestyle and her efforts to create lasting memories with her children.

The Fateful Night: May 20, 2016

In January 2015, Nikki began dating Doug Dietri, a 33-year-old whom she believed could be a supportive partner. However, their relationship soon showed signs of strain. On the night of May 20, 2016, Nikki and Doug, along with Doug’s friends, decided to spend the evening at The Watering Hole, a local bar and music venue where the band Steel Panther was performing.

As the night progressed, tensions between Nikki and Doug escalated. Around 11 PM, following the concert, the couple became separated amidst the chaos of the departing crowd. Instead of regrouping, Doug stayed behind with a friend, leaving Nikki feeling abandoned and increasingly upset. Nikki began sending Doug distressing text messages expressing her anger and suspicion:

"What slut are you with? Because none of your friends know. Fuck you, abusive asshole." ([19:34])

Nikki's distress culminated in her leaving the bar alone, captured in surveillance footage as she exited through the back gate, resisted by one of her companions who tried to convince her to return.

Disappearance and Initial Investigation

Doug, appearing unbothered, drove back home, raising red flags for those around him. Nikki failed to return, and Doug waited until the next day before reporting her missing. Concurrently, another individual discovered a body near the scene of Nikki's disappearance, initially mistaking the severe brutality for decay due to the body's condition.

Authorities quickly connected the dots, recognizing the distressing timing of Doug’s missing person report just hours after the body was found. An official report was filed, and Doug was subjected to questioning. During an interview, Doug exhibited behavior that was deemed suspicious by investigators, showing minimal concern despite the gravity of the situation.

Breakthrough: The Role of Technology

A pivotal moment in the investigation came with the analysis of data from Doug's Fitbit. This wearable device tracked his movements meticulously. The Fitbit data revealed that Doug had taken only 12 steps during the critical three-hour window when Nikki was murdered, suggesting that he hadn't left his home as initially suspected. This evidence was crucial in undermining the prosecution's case against Doug.

"The Fitbit ended up playing a huge part in the case, and it actually helped prove that he didn't commit her murder." ([27:15])

Additionally, forensic evidence initially pointed towards Doug, including a pair of shoes matching the pattern found on Nikki's body and traces of blood. However, further analysis debunked these findings:

• The blood on Doug's shoe was identified as turkey blood.
• DNA found on Nikki's tissues matched her sister, not Doug.
• Nikki's car, monitored by Progressive Snapshot, showed it had not moved on the night of her disappearance.

Arrest and False Accusations

Despite the emerging evidence pointing away from Doug, investigators were initially convinced of his involvement due to his suspicious behavior and prior allegations of abuse from an ex-partner. Doug was arrested on suspicion of first-degree murder, but the Fitbit data and other forensic evidence quickly dismantled the case against him, leading to his release after 18 days.

The Real Culprit: George Stephens

With Doug exonerated, attention turned to George "Big Country" Stephens, a 38-year-old from Virginia with a history of violent behavior. Stephens' DNA was found on Nikki's sock, and phone data placed him at all significant locations related to the crime. Moreover, his involvement in a prior hit-and-run incident added to the suspicion.

Investigators pieced together Stephens' movements, linking him directly to the crime scene through his phone's GPS data. His casual demeanor during questioning and lack of a credible alibi further solidified the case against him. Ultimately, Stephens confessed to the murder during trial, driven by a combination of personal motives and opportunistic violence.

Trial and Conviction

The trial commenced in February 2018, with the prosecution presenting overwhelming evidence against Stephens, including DNA matches and witness testimonies. Stephens' defense attempted to shift blame to Doug, but the Fitbit evidence and DNA conclusively proved his sole responsibility for Nikki's murder.

After a swift trial lasting two weeks, Stephens was found guilty and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. The judge remarked on the severity of the crime, acknowledging Nikki's suffering and the impact on her family.

Aftermath and Justice Served

Kendall emphasizes the closure that justice brought to Nikki's family, despite the irreparable loss:

"Nikki deserved so much better. And George Burch got exactly what he deserved, which is rotting in prison until the day he dies." ([48:30])

Additionally, the episode sheds light on the ongoing struggles of Nikki's children, who continue to live without their mother. A fundraiser has been initiated to support their education, with Kendall pledging to assist through her foundation, Higher Hope.

Conclusion

This episode of True Crime with Kendall Rae poignantly captures the harrowing journey of Nicole VanderHeyden's murder case. From the initial misdirection and wrongful accusation of Doug Dietri to the eventual identification and conviction of George Stephens, the story underscores the importance of meticulous investigation and the role of technology in solving crimes. Kendall Rae's compassionate storytelling not only honors Nikki's memory but also highlights the resilience of her family in the face of unimaginable tragedy.

Note: For further updates and to support Nikki's family, visit the Higher Hope foundation and the linked GoFundMe page provided by Kendall.