Podcast Summary
Two Ts In A Pod with Teddi Mellencamp and Tamra Judge
Episode: By Order of the Faithfuls: Winner, Winner w/ Trishelle Cannatella
Date: October 31, 2025
Guest: Trishelle Cannatella
Hosts: Wells Adams, Tamra Judge, Dolores Catania
(Note: Teddi Mellencamp is referenced but does not appear in the transcripted conversation)
Episode Overview
This episode of "By Order of the Faithfuls" recaps Season 2 of The Traitors, focusing on guest Trishelle Cannatella’s experience as a contestant and ultimate winner. Amid banter and reality TV nostalgia, Trishelle discusses gameplay strategies, relationships with castmates, and behind-the-scenes insights. The discussion includes reflections on her competitive drive, cast dynamics, and thoughts on future reality TV projects.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. Trishelle’s Reality TV Journey & Persona
- Playboy Surprise: The hosts start with a lighthearted revelation about Trishelle having posed for Playboy, which some co-hosts didn’t previously know.
- (03:06) Trishelle: “It's not something that I tell people or brag about.”
- (03:23) Wells: “You should.”
- Living the Southern Life: Trishelle shares about her recent busy weekend and her support for LSU, highlighting her down-to-earth roots.
- (03:42) Trishelle: “I’m from Louisiana, so we’re just LSU people.”
2. Strategy & Experience on The Traitors
- Gameplan Gone Awry: Trishelle originally intended to keep a low profile but found herself unable to stay quiet due to her competitive nature.
- (04:39) Trishelle: “My plan was to lay low until the middle and... then kind of amp it up. But it just sort of happened that way. I guess I just can't keep my mouth shut.”
- Emotional Volatility: Her outspoken approach also resulted in nightly anxiety about being “murdered” out of the game.
- (05:04) Tamra: “She was outspoken and worried every single night that she was maybe murdered. Oh yeah, you lost it.”
- Relationship with CT (Chris Tamburello):
- Trishelle describes her journey from suspicion to trust with CT, noting his savvy gameplay and the emotional rollercoaster, including a moment where she almost voted him out.
- (06:39) Wells: “Did you ever think that he could be a traitor?”
- (06:39) Trishelle: “Yes. Yes, very much so... There were definite moments that I felt like he was, and it made me spiral even more.”
- The hosts probe if her on-screen emotional moments were strategic or genuine:
- (07:54) Wells: “Was it a little bit of gameplay?”
- (07:54) Trishelle: “No, I really felt that way. You get to a point where you feel alone... and so I felt like he was my good friend, and it hurt my feelings.”
- At the final ceremony, she was moved by CT’s reaction and reversed her vote.
- (09:01) Trishelle: “I changed because I saw how he was tearing up, and he was, like, about to start crying, and I was just like, oh my god.”
- Trishelle describes her journey from suspicion to trust with CT, noting his savvy gameplay and the emotional rollercoaster, including a moment where she almost voted him out.
3. Cast & Social Dynamics
- Dealing with Annoying Players: John is described as “most annoying” and “long-winded” during roundtables.
- (14:25) Trishelle: “Let me correct you. John wasn’t annoyed. He was annoying.”
- Phaedra’s Masterful Play: Phaedra's social savvy impressed Trishelle and the hosts—a lawyer who leveraged warmth and subtlety.
- (15:16) Trishelle: “She was so poised at the roundtable and able to spin it around on someone else in a way that was just masterful.”
- Dan’s Downfall: Dan from Big Brother failed to provide names until it was too late, which they all agree made him look suspicious.
- (15:46) Trishelle: “I was just like, you played the crappiest game ever.”
- Surviving Online Backlash: Both Trishelle and the hosts reflect on receiving hate, including death threats after the show.
- (19:19) Dolores: “You read your death threats like the paper for breakfast.”
- (19:23) Trishelle: “I got off Twitter. I was just like, I'm done.”
- Reunion Fallout: There was lingering resentment at the reunion, particularly from MJ and Peppermint.
- (18:55) Dolores: “She came into that reunion, barrels loaded…”
4. Post-Show Reflection & Future Plans
- What She Would Do Differently: Trishelle would try to have more fun and “spiral less.”
- (16:57) Trishelle: “I would have probably enjoyed it more and spiraled less… I was just so uptight, and I was writing notes, and I was crazy.”
- Advice to Future Contestants: "Be yourself. That's it." (17:30)
- Willingness to Return: Okay with coming back for an All-Star edition, but aware the win makes her a future target (21:09).
- Picks for Early Departures: She wishes Bananas and Marcus stayed longer for their fun energy (19:41).
- All-Star Theories: The hosts predict a winners-only season might be in the works (21:18).
5. Reality TV Industry & Personal Life Updates
- Maintaining Marriage & Independence: Trishelle highlights trust with her pilot husband, noting mutual independence given their travel schedules.
- (13:35) Trishelle: “I have to kind of be cool with him, and he’s cool with me. I don’t track his location. I don’t do any of that stuff.”
- Future TV Prospects:
- Frequently asked back to MTV/Challenge but declines due to low pay (28:47).
- Working on a pilot centered around her life and friends in New Orleans, with an entrepreneurial, philanthropic lifestyle.
- (29:20) Trishelle: “I’ve been interviewing for a show around my friends and I in New Orleans…”
- Favorite Reality City: New Orleans gets several shout-outs, praised for food, art, and culture (30:04).
6. Upcoming Season Predictions
- Season 4 of The Traitors:
- Notable cast: Rob from Survivor, Steven from Laguna Beach, Natalie from Amazing Race, Donna Kelce (Travis and Jason’s mom), several Real Housewives.
- Trishelle expects Candace to do well, sees Lisa Rinna going out early, admires the casting choices. (25:52-26:38)
- She discusses the importance of cross-group alliances, referencing their season’s Housewives “grouping” dynamic (26:15).
7. Memorable Moments & Banter
- Trishelle’s Crush on Wells:
- (31:08) Trishelle: “I had the biggest crush on you ever.”
- (31:13) Wells: “Really?”
- Poker Players as Potential Cast: Suggests Daniel Negreanu or Phil Hellmuth, lauding their skill at deception as an edge (32:26).
Notable Quotes & Timestamps
- Trishelle on Playing The Traitors:
- “My plan was to lay low until the middle and... then kind of amp it up. But it just sort of happened that way. I guess I just can't keep my mouth shut.” (04:39)
- Trishelle on Emotional Gameplay:
- “No, I really felt that way. You get to a point where you feel alone... and so I felt like he was my good friend, and it hurt my feelings.” (07:54)
- On Phaedra’s Gameplay:
- “She was so poised at the roundtable and able to spin it around on someone else in a way that was just masterful.” (15:16)
- On online backlash:
- “I got off Twitter. I was just like, I'm done.” (19:23)
- On future participation:
- “After you win a show, it puts a target on your back to go back. But I would.” (21:09)
- On being true to herself:
- “That's my personality and that's why I rub people the wrong way.” (17:45)
- Wells to Trishelle:
- “My pick is Wells to win. I really thought that you were going to win.” (23:01)
Key Segments & Timestamps
- 04:39 – Trishelle discusses her intended versus actual strategy
- 06:39–09:01 – Relationship with CT, suspicion, and the turning point
- 13:35 – Marriage, trust, and independence with her husband
- 14:25–15:16 – John’s annoying gameplay and Phaedra’s skill
- 16:57–17:45 – Lessons learned and personal reflection
- 18:55–19:23 – Reunion drama and reactions to hate
- 21:09 – Returning for an All-Star edition and thoughts on casting
- 25:52–26:38 – Season 4 predictions and cast analysis
- 28:47–29:41 – Reality TV opportunities and New Orleans project
- 31:08–31:32 – Trishelle’s on-air Wells Adams confession
- 32:26–33:00 – Suggestions for poker players as future contestants
Tone & Atmosphere
The episode is upbeat, candid, and sometimes self-deprecating, with plenty of inside jokes, honest reflections, and supportive camaraderie typical of veteran reality TV participants. The hosts and guest blend playful teasing with genuine insights about competition, fame, and friendship in the reality TV world.
For Listeners Who Missed the Episode
This episode delivers a behind-the-scenes look at The Traitors Season 2 with winner Trishelle Cannatella, exploring strategic dynamics, relationships that shaped the outcome, and the emotional toll of high-stakes competition. Trishelle’s warmth and openness, paired with frank discussion from Tamra and Dolores, make for an engaging and revealing conversation about reality TV’s pressures, the importance of authenticity, and why she’d (probably) do it all again.
Perfect listen for: Reality TV fans, aspiring contestants, or anyone curious about the off-camera realities of competitive shows.
No advertisements, intros, or outros included in this summary.