Two Ts In A Pod: "Who is Soup Man?" (RHOSLC Recap)

Podcast: Two Ts In A Pod with Teddi Mellencamp and Tamra Judge
Episode Date: October 16, 2025
Hosts: Teddi Mellencamp, Tamra Judge
Episode Theme:
A spirited and comedic recap of the latest episode of Real Housewives of Salt Lake City (RHOSLC), focusing on the intense group psychic reading, ongoing feuds – particularly between Lisa and Angie – the confusion over "Soup Man," and the impressive eccentricities within the cast. Teddi and Tamra use their insider Housewife lens to unpack cast dynamics, drama, production choices, and standout comedic moments.

Main Topics & Recap

1. Starting Off: Everyone Feels Ill (04:06–05:22)

• Both Teddi and Tamra admit they're feeling unwell and joke about a possible flu going around following a group lunch.
• Brief cameo mention of Dolores also feeling sick.
• Sets a relaxed, "we're-in-this-together" vibe for the recap.
• Quote:
  • Tamra: “I almost had Dolores step in, but she doesn’t feel good either.” (04:25)
  • Teddi: “Maybe we should ask the psychic if we have food poisoning!” (05:00)

2. The Group Psychic Reading: Real or Reality TV? (05:22–08:35)

• Whitney hosts a lunch with psychic Terence conducting readings.
• Both hosts are skeptical of the psychic’s authenticity.
  • Teddi doubts a psychic could know such production-heavy details.
  • They question if the psychic is just repeating things already on the show, but admit the "horse sunglasses" prediction is oddly specific.
• Memorable moment: Mary’s gossipy remarks about the venue’s tragic history and the supposed impact on the dog.
• Quote:
  • Mary (paraphrased by Teddi): “The owner shot themselves there in front of their dog.”
  • Tamra: “The dog needed therapy and Prozac.” (07:17)
  • Teddi: “No one tells a horror story like [Mary Cosby].” (08:19)

3. Housewives Drama Breakdown (08:45–19:09)

Brittany’s Real Estate Faux Pas (08:45–10:12)

• Brittany criticized for unprofessionally commenting on Angie's unsold $4.5 million house (“on the market too long; priced too high”).
• Tamra and Teddi agree this is not good business and question Brittany’s motives.
• Quote:
  • Tamra: “It’s not good to do business with friends. Especially selling a house, there’s so much emotion…” (09:39)

Brittany & Jared Relationship Analysis (10:52–12:13)

• Cast questions Brittany’s motivation for her on/off relationship with Jared, with hints at performative motives (“vacation or gift”).
• Teddi and Tamra draw parallels to other Bravo relationships, wondering if it’s just for storyline.

Lisa, Angie, and the Ongoing Feud (12:34–16:12)

• Discussion over Angie accusing Lisa of talking behind Meredith’s back, Lisa denying it, and both refusing to let the other have the last word.
• Highlight: The infamous “card flexing” scene—Angie making it rain with credit cards and the introduction of the “Prada Amex bracelet.”
• Quote:
  • Tamra: “She was just, like, making it rain with her cards… Doesn’t mean there’s no limit left on it!” (15:35)

Housewife Prop Comedy: The Return Bin (29:49–30:55)

• Angie brings a bin of gifts Lisa gave her and returns it during the party—both hosts mock the “prop” overload.
• Comparison to the infamous “bunny return” from RHOBH.
• Mary’s confusion over what counts as “Tupperware” brings levity.

4. Psychic Plotlines & Eccentric Predictions (26:24–28:46)

• Terence's readings include predictions of marital discord (for Lisa) and animal injury (for Angie).
• Both comment on the specificity, debate psychic authenticity, and tease an upcoming alternative psychic guest (Scott Cruz).
• Angie’s real-life horse injury surfaces, fueling more suspicion about “scripted” storylines.

5. "Who Is Soup Man?" and RHOSLC's Unique Brand of Bonkers (18:13–19:28, 33:33–35:48)

• Key Quote & Moment:
  • Lisa shouts about “Soup Man” during a fight with Angie, confusing everyone.
  • Teddi: “I’m going to need more info on Soup Man. I have no idea. Can we even, like, Google it?” (18:39)
• The Soup Man reference, along with other odd terms (“Gout Dick”), highlight the bizarre energy of the show.
• The hosts riff on how only on RHOSLC does this kind of randomness fly.

6. Group Dynamics, Bullying, and Authenticity vs. Performance (32:50–35:02, 44:04–48:44)

• Debate over the word “bully” being thrown around—are Angie and Lisa actual bullies, or just role-playing for TV?
• Tamra says fans are now accusing the show of being “scripted and staged.”
• Both hosts agree Angie is trying hard to “make good TV,” but wonder if it’s now backfiring into soap opera territory.
• Quote:
  • Teddi: “It’s damn entertaining, though… but it’s really starting to look like we’re watching a soap opera, not reality.” (35:02)
• Discussion about how chaos and performative drama are seen as part of the job—when drama's missing, fans complain, but too much and it’s “fake.”

7. Fan Reactions, Favorites, and Reality TV Mechanics (43:49–48:49)

• The Daily Beast called it “one of the funniest episodes ever” (43:49).
• Both hosts say they like an episode that’s “one big party” over choppy, multiple-scene episodes.
• They debate this season's hero/villain lineup:
  • For Tamra, Mary is her favorite (“Mary’s at the top of my list”) and Lisa is a “great villain” (46:00).
  • Teddi notes Angie is close behind in villainy, but feels Lisa’s being provoked a lot.

8. The Real Housewives Post-Recap (49:07–53:10)

• Discussion shifts to recent podcast interviews (Miguel, Alexis Splino) and their impressions.
• Banter about making TikTok videos and feeling silly about social challenges.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Mary Cosby on house tragedy: "The dog needed therapy and Prozac." (07:17, Tamra)
• On props and returns: "Don’t you think this was the bunny all over again?...Too many props. They need to stop this." (29:55, Tamra)
• About “Soup Man”: "I’m going to need more info on Soup Man. Soup Man, Soup Man. I have no idea. Can we even, like, Google it?" (18:39, Teddy)
• On performative drama: "Some of it's a little bit performative." (48:44, Tamra)
• On enjoying the chaos: "When you have one girl that's doing most of the work when it comes to drama, suddenly the fans think she's… horrible. And then when she's gone, things aren't the same anymore." (47:04, Tamra)

Key Timestamps

• 04:06: Podcast episode begins, hosts set personal context (feeling ill).
• 05:22: Group reading at Whitney’s lunch, psychic skepticism.
• 08:45: Critique of Brittany’s real estate comments.
• 12:34: Lisa/Angie/Meredith drama begins.
• 15:30: Prop comedy—credit cards, Prada Amex bracelet.
• 18:39: Soup Man confusion.
• 26:24: Terence predicts animal injury and marriage trouble.
• 29:49: Angie returns Lisa’s gifts; “the bunny all over again.”
• 32:50: Bullying, TV performance, and fan response.
• 43:49: Recap of fan/media reactions to the episode.
• 44:04: Hosts debate party episodes and production choices.
• 46:00: Villains and favorites named: Mary, Lisa, Angie.
• 49:07: Shift to podcast/BravoCon talk.
• 53:10: Season fatigue, reality as “a lot” but never boring.

Tone & Style

• Conversational and irreverent: The hosts riff on each other, poke fun at cast and production, and share insider tales from within Bravo.
• Self-aware and industry-savvy: They acknowledge when scenes feel constructed or when tropes (like props) are being recycled.
• Fan-like enthusiasm: Despite critiques, Tamra and Teddi express genuine enjoyment of the chaos, unpredictability, and humor of RHOSLC.

Final Thoughts

Two Ts In A Pod’s recap of RHOSLC leans into the season’s escalating absurdity (“Who IS Soup Man?”), the blurred lines between authentic drama and performed reality, and the Housewife model of fighting, forgiving, and fighting again. Tamra and Teddi are both entertained and exhausted by the relentless pace and props, but agree the show never lets them check the clock – the ultimate Housewife win.

Who's Up, Who's Down?

• Star/Anchor of the Week: Mary Cosby – for unfiltered humor and accidental gravitas.
• Villain(s) of the Week: Lisa (primary); Angie (a close second).
• “We Need More From” Award: Heather Gay – for being too calm this season.
• Most WTF Quote: “Soup Man. Soup Man. I have no idea—can we even Google it?” (18:39, Teddi)
• Fan Verdict: Entertaining, but tiptoeing into soap opera territory.

Summary by [Podcast Summarizer AI]
For those who haven’t tuned in, this episode offers sharp, snarky, and delightful insight into the ongoing spectacle that is RHOSLC. If you want to keep up with Housewives drama (and learn nothing, really, about Soup Man), this recap is essential listening.