Podcast Summary: The Making of Musk: Understood
Episode 3: The Legion
Host: Jacob Silverman (CBC)
Guest/Reporter: Julia Black
Release Date: October 21, 2025
Overview
This episode dives deep into Elon Musk's ideological project of building a "legion" of children. Far beyond mere celebrity gossip, the show interrogates the philosophy of pronatalism among tech elites, the use of reproductive technologies to "optimize" offspring, the social and ethical implications, and how Musk’s personal life intertwines with broader debates about eugenics, social hierarchy, and the future of humanity. The episode also examines Musk’s technological ambitions, particularly in brain-computer interfaces (BCIs), and his controversial vision of society's future.
“This is so much bigger than just the births of a couple of children and some tabloid story. This is really, if you ask me, in Elon’s mind, about reshaping the public understanding of a natural genetic hierarchy…”
— Julia Black (05:48)
Key Discussion Points and Insights
The Breaking Story: Musk’s “Secret” Children
- [00:36-05:22] Julia Black recounts her investigation, beginning with a tip that Elon Musk was purposefully fathering many children as an ideological “project.”
- Discovers legal filings in Austin, Texas, revealing twins born to Musk and Neuralink executive Siobhan Zylis.
- Black’s reporting moves the conversation beyond tabloid rumors to evidence of deliberate action and ideology.
- Musk’s children with Zylis exposed lack of efforts to keep the births private:
“There was something so surreal about being at this courthouse, downloading these documents. And I was really shocked at the lack of effort to keep this private.”
— Julia Black (02:39) - After Black’s story broke, the records were quickly sealed.
Pronatalism in Tech Elites
-
[06:31-09:32] Musk uses language like “legion” to describe his children, aligning his ambitions with pronatalist ideology—encouraging large families, undergirded by beliefs in genetic superiority.
- Pronatalism, especially in Silicon Valley and the political right, gained steam amid fears of population collapse and a “dumbing down” of society.
- Musk publicly advocates the need to have more children as a duty.
“If people do not have children, there is no new generation.”
— Elon Musk, political conference speech (07:44)
-
Artificial Scarcity and “Dysgenics”:
- The episode traces the roots of Musk’s worldview:
- Apartheid South Africa’s obsession with racial demographics.
- Nick Bostrom’s “existential risks” idea of “dysgenics”—fears that only the “inferior” would reproduce, leading to decline in collective intelligence.
- Cultural references (e.g., the film Idiocracy) enter the tech world’s consciousness as cautionary tales.
- The episode traces the roots of Musk’s worldview:
-
Musk’s Early Adoption:
- Sources indicate Musk held these views even when having his first children in the 2000s.
- The loss of his first child, Nevada, and family traumas possibly fueled Musk’s personal obsessions.
The Personal Is Ideological: Family as a “Project”
-
[21:38-22:37] Julia Black characterizes Musk’s family planning as an organized project:
- Coordination of partners, use of IVF and surrogacy, construction of a compound in Austin, managed by a dedicated aide.
-
“Elon… has had this obsession with building a legion of children who can maximize his own personal impact on the future of humanity and who can carry what he sees as his massively superior genes forward.”
— Julia Black (21:38)
-
Ethics and Social Ramifications:
- The show distinguishes between the general concern over declining birth rates and the Musk/Silicon Valley approach, which especially intertwines with questions of genetic “improvement” and exclusivity.
- Julia Black flags how the debate intersects uncomfortably with immigration and race (23:52):
“Probably first and foremost, because I think the best solution... is going to be immigration.”
- Musk supports “super motivated” immigrants (H1B visas), but echoes right-wing culture war rhetoric against other forms of immigration.
Designer Babies: Embryo Selection and the Quest for Optimization
- [27:29-36:54]
-
Musk uses companies like Orchid to select embryos for IVF, going beyond health to allegedly screen for IQ.
“Secretly behind the scenes, I have it confirmed from a number of sources… they will offer, quote-unquote, high roller customers the opportunity to test embryos for IQ.”
— Julia Black (28:25) -
Raises profound bioethical issues similar to the film Gattaca—engineering advantage and solidifying social stratification.
“What does it mean for a billionaire to believe that his children are intellectually superior... because he’s got the paperwork to prove it?”
— Julia Black (30:17) -
Musk’s trans daughter, Vivian Wilson, feels objectified by this logic—chosen as a boy, disowned for not matching her father’s vision.
“She feels like she was a product that was bought and paid for by her father.”
— Julia Black (31:02) -
Vivian’s public response on social media demonstrates generational pushback and the complex emotional legacy of such “optimization.”
-
The Broader Vision: Technology “Fixes” the Human Future
- [36:54-44:15]
-
Musk’s desire to control and engineer extends from family to society to the species:
“He sees the future as something to be designed and controlled.”
— Jacob Silverman (36:54) -
The episode transitions to Musk’s Neuralink venture in brain-computer interfaces (BCIs), opening with paraplegic trial participant Nolan Arbaugh, whose life is transformed by the tech.
-
Potential for empowerment (greater autonomy for disabled people, regaining abilities) is real, but ethical and privacy implications are massive.
-
Musk’s stated goal is the merger of human and AI to avert obsolescence.
-
“From a long-term existential standpoint… that’s like the purpose of neuralink: to create a high-bandwidth interface to the brain such that we can be symbiotic with AI…”
— Elon Musk, The Joe Rogan Experience (44:15) -
Risks: Control over thoughts, privacy, effects on identity, who benefits, and who gets left behind amplify social inequities.
-
The Elite’s Bubble and End Game
- [47:43-48:17]
-
Pronatalist and techno-optimist strategies create social bubbles—the elite wall themselves off, physically (compounds) and genetically, from the rest of society.
-
Musk’s “company towns” in Texas and beyond echo the exclusionary societies of South African apartheid and fascist social engineering.
-
“They just want to create their own lane where… only the best embryos, only the best communities… It’s very much building more and more of this exclusive bubble…”
— Julia Black (47:43)
-
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
-
On Journalism and Moral Dilemmas:
“I did, frankly, have some moral deliberation about doing this story. I had to decide for myself that this was really important for the public to know about. The thing is, from the moment this tip was brought to me, it was very clear to me that this was part of an ideological project.”
— Julia Black (05:01) -
From Ideology to Practice:
“To reach legion level before the apocalypse, we will need to use surrogates.”
— Musk in texts to Ashley Sinclair, as reported by The Wall Street Journal (20:30) -
The Children’s Perspective:
“Vivian has spoken publicly about the fact that… perhaps the reason that her being transgender has been so very offensive to her father is because he actually, you know, paid for her to be a boy.”
— Julia Black (35:27)“Vivian might answer that she never felt she’d been given the best chance in life, that she was engineered for someone else’s ideal, not her own.”
— Jacob Silverman (36:54) -
On the Technocracy Dream:
“For techno optimists like him, the tools to do that are always just around the corner. It’s a philosophy that echoes the technocracy movement his grandfather once championed. The belief that society could be rationally engineered, its future managed like a machine.”
— Jacob Silverman (36:54) -
On BCI’s Future:
“Imagination is what makes the whole thing work. That and experimental neurosurgery.”
— Dvija Mehta, ethicist (42:40) -
On the Social Divide
“It’s these ideas that these small elite minorities should have the right to exit society and to build their own kind of parallel universe…”
— Julia Black (47:43)
Timestamps for Important Segments
- [00:36] — Julia Black recounts initial tip-off and investigation
- [02:39] — Discovery of legal filings for Musk’s twins with Siobhan Zylis
- [05:48] — The ideological framing behind Musk’s “legion” of children
- [07:44] — Musk’s public pronatalist statements at political events
- [09:32] — “Dysgenics” and science fiction influences like Idiocracy
- [13:18] — The loss of Musk’s first child and impact on family dynamics
- [20:30] — Musk’s text: “To reach legion level before the apocalypse…”
- [21:38] — Julia Black on Musk’s 20-year legacy-building mission
- [27:29] — Introduction of embryo selection services (Orchid)
- [31:02] — Vivian Wilson’s feelings on being a product of genetic “optimization”
- [36:54] — The philosophical through-line: engineering children, companies, species
- [39:50] — Nolan Arbaugh’s story: Neuralink’s breakthrough and hope for the disabled
- [44:15] — Rogan/Musk on merging humans and AI
- [47:43] — Wealthy exits and parallel societies—“exclusive bubbles”
Conclusion
This episode reveals how Musk’s worldview and private life are inseparable from his public projects. From the purposeful creation of a “legion” of children—sometimes described in explicitly eugenic or optimization terms—to new frontiers like BCIs, Musk wields technology to further a particular elite vision of the future. The podcast raises urgent questions about inequality, ethics, and the social contract, suggesting that attempts to rationally engineer the future—familial, genetic, or technological—carry unpredictable consequences not just for Musk’s children but for society at large.