Podcast Summary: "MLS All-Star 2025 and YOUR Questions Answered"
Podcast Title: Unfiltered Soccer with Landon Donovan and Tim Howard
Hosts: Landon Donovan, Tim Howard
Episode: MLS All-Star 2025 and YOUR Questions Answered
Release Date: July 22, 2025
Introduction
In this engaging episode of "Unfiltered Soccer," Landon Donovan and Tim Howard delve into the intricacies of the MLS All-Star Game of 2025, share personal anecdotes from their All-Star experiences, critique current MLS management practices, and address listener questions. The conversation is candid, insightful, and packed with memorable quotes that highlight their deep understanding of the game.
MLS All-Star Game 2025
Hosts’ Past All-Star Experiences
Landon Donovan reminisces about his standout performance in the 2001 All-Star Game in San Jose, where he scored four goals. He remarks, "I played my first professional season in San Jose... I took the game really seriously" (00:33). Tim Howard shares his memorable moment from the 2007 All-Star Game against Everton, highlighting his three penalty saves: "I made three saves in the penalty shootout" (46:30).
Preferred Formats for All-Star Games
Both hosts express a desire for more competitive and exciting All-Star formats. Tim Howard criticizes the current setup where MLS All-Stars face European clubs, suggesting alternatives like East vs. West or MLS World All-Stars vs. American Players. Donovan echoes this sentiment, stating, "All All-Star games struggle with how to make it competitive" (03:35), and suggests incorporating elements like penalty kicks to heighten excitement (07:56).
Team Management and Player Salaries
Critique of Toronto FC’s Management
Donovan and Howard discuss the mismanagement of Toronto FC, emphasizing the poor performance and high salaries of players like Sebastian Giovinco and Michael Bradley. Donovan asserts, "They have bad hires, bad leadership... and Bernardeschi has been a joke" (15:43). Howard underscores the unsustainable salaries, noting, "Insignia's salary was 15.4 million. That's insane" (17:00).
Salary Cap and Roster Construction
The hosts debate MLS’s salary cap policies, advocating for investing in a few high-quality players rather than spreading funds thin across many. Tim Howard emphasizes, "Build me a roster like 21 million... Why can't we get there?" (20:44). Donovan agrees, highlighting the need for better valuation of existing talent to retain top players within the league.
National Team Issues
Home Stadium Debate
Listener questions initiate a discussion on whether the US Men's National Team should have one or two home stadiums to boost attendance and provide a consistent home-field advantage. Howard supports the idea of a central national stadium in a major city like Washington D.C., while Donovan questions its effectiveness, "If it's in Atlanta and we play Mexico, that doesn't guarantee anything" (55:48).
Enhancing National Team Appeal
Both hosts agree that improving team performance and player commitment is crucial for increasing fan attendance. They critique recent national team struggles and emphasize the importance of star players engaging with fans to inspire greater support.
Playoff Picture and Season Analysis
Current Standings and Team Performances
Donovan and Howard analyze the current MLS standings, focusing on teams like San Jose, LAFC, Austin FC, and Salt Lake. They discuss the potential of Austin FC and Salt Lake, noting key players like Diego Luna could influence their playoff chances (24:28).
Outlook for Playoffs
The hosts express skepticism about certain teams making the playoffs despite strong performances, citing San Diego FC’s potential but questioning their playoff viability due to roster limitations and lack of star power.
Fan Engagement and Listener Questions
Listener Interactions and Q&A
In the Q&A segment, Donovan and Howard address various listener questions:
-
Reducing Diving in Soccer: Jonathan from Instagram raises concerns about players taking dives to draw penalties. Donovan agrees that simulation damages the sport's image and suggests stricter penalties for unsportsmanlike behavior (50:58). Howard offers a different perspective, advocating for players to leverage diving when contact occurs to gain legitimate advantages (53:48).
-
National Stadium for USMNT: Keenan suggests having two home stadiums to boost attendance. Both hosts discuss the logistical challenges and potential cultural impacts, ultimately leaning towards the idea of a single national stadium but acknowledging it may not fully resolve attendance issues (55:21).
-
Adopting NHL’s Tie-Breaker System: Greg proposes introducing a shootout system similar to the NHL to reduce tie games and attract more fans. Donovan is enthusiastic about the idea, while Howard remains cautious, emphasizing the importance of preserving soccer’s unique dynamics (65:21).
-
Starting XI for the World Cup: Both hosts share their ideal starting eleven for the US Men’s National Team, reflecting their tactical preferences and player evaluations (40:32).
Conclusion and Final Thoughts
As the episode wraps up, Donovan and Howard emphasize the ongoing challenges and opportunities within MLS and US soccer. They advocate for better team management, fair player compensation, and strategic marketing to grow the sport's popularity in the United States. They also highlight the importance of fan engagement and continuous improvement to foster a thriving soccer culture.
Notable Quotes with Timestamps
-
Landon Donovan:
"I took the game really seriously. I scored four goals in the All-Star Game" (00:33).
"We have to get that out of the game" (54:23).
"If you go down without contact, then you should be punished for it" (55:12). -
Tim Howard:
"They need to have spice. All Star games have lost their spice" (07:56).
"Build me a roster like 21 million... Why can't we get there?" (20:44).
"If you have contact, players should go down to gain legitimate advantages" (53:48).
This comprehensive summary captures the essence of the episode, highlighting key discussions, insights, and memorable moments without delving into advertisement segments or non-content sections.