Up and Vanished: Jodi Huisentruit
Season 4, Episode: VANISHED: Jodi Huisentruit
Release Date: February 17, 2025
Introduction
In this gripping episode of Up and Vanished, Tenderfoot TV delves into the mysterious disappearance of Jodi Huisentruit, a beloved morning news anchor from Mason City, Iowa, who vanished on June 27, 1995. Host Payne Lindsey, along with co-host Maggie Freeling and producer Meredith Steadman, unpack the intricate details of the case, exploring the evidence, suspects, and lingering questions that have kept this case unsolved for nearly three decades.
The Morning of Disappearance
On the morning of June 27, 1995, Jodi Huisentruit failed to appear for her morning news broadcast at KIMT, a local news station in Mason City. Initially thought to have overslept, her absence quickly raised alarms when producer Amy Kunz realized Jodi hadn't been heard from by 4:00 AM. A wellness check by the Mason City Police revealed a troubling scene outside Jodi's red Mazda Miata: scattered personal items, potential drag marks, a bent car key, and a tilted car mirror suggesting a struggle (16:00).
Notable Quote:
"Jodi, Mason City's beloved morning news anchor, was about to become the day's top story."
— Payne Lindsay 00:09
Initial Evidence and Suspicions
The police found high-heeled shoes, a hairdryer, a hairbrush, and hairspray near Jodi's car, alongside indications of a possible struggle or abduction. Despite these clues, no immediate suspects emerged, and authorities canvassed the area for additional evidence or witnesses. Reports from neighbors mentioned possible screams and the presence of beer cans near Jodi's apartment, adding layers of suspicion (15:29).
Notable Quote:
"It appears to be a crime scene, but we don't know if a crime took place there. Because I remember feeling like, is there a chance this was staged?"
— Kyle Tequila 16:00
Key Suspects: John Van Cise and Serial Offenders
One of the primary persons of interest is John Van Cise, who was notably present at Jodi's 27th birthday party six months before her disappearance. A video from the party shows Jodi dancing closely with Van Cise, despite a significant age difference. Van Cise claimed to be the last person to see Jodi alive, an assertion that has raised eyebrows given the timing and lack of corroborating evidence (24:07).
Notable Quote:
"Jodi had a stalker in the recent past before she went missing. I think it's pretty safe to say that though a random crime of opportunity as possible, there is so much evidence pointing towards a crime of passion that I don't think that can be ignored."
— Kyle Tequila 17:18
Additionally, the episode explores the possibility of Jodi being targeted by serial offenders in the area, such as Tony Jackson and Thomas Corskaddin, who had histories of assaulting women and possessed vans similar to the one reportedly seen at the time of her disappearance.
Notable Quote:
"A lot of the stories we've heard pointed towards that, too. A lot of people wanted to be around her also. That's terrible that what you said about, like, her phone number and address being public information."
— Kyle Tequila 20:46
The Investigation for Up and Vanished
The Up and Vanished team conducted an exhaustive investigation, revisiting the original case files, interviewing Jodi's coworkers, and following up on new leads. They traveled to Mason City, spoke with Amy Kunz, and even sought to confront John Van Cise in Arizona, where he had relocated. Their research unearthed inconsistencies in Van Cise's alibi and raised questions about his motives and behavior following Jodi's disappearance.
Notable Quote:
"If I can find a purpose behind all of this and help, even if I just help one person, mission accomplished."
— Maggie Freeling 62:44
Theories and Unanswered Questions
Several theories emerged from the investigation:
-
Stalker or Serial Rapist: Jodi had reported being followed and had taken self-defense classes, suggesting she may have been targeted by someone persistent or known to her.
-
Connection to Drug Operations: The death of Jodi's friend, Billy Pruin, under suspicious circumstances, hinted that Jodi's investigative journalism might have threatened local drug lords, specifically Dustin Honkin, a methamphetamine kingpin implicated in multiple disappearances.
-
John Van Cise's Involvement: The oddities surrounding Van Cise's interactions with Jodi, his abrupt move to Arizona, and his reluctance to speak with investigators pointed towards a possible deeper connection.
Notable Quote:
"I think that a lot. I do. And I don't think that only people in the limelight can be obsessed over stalked. However, I think you're absolutely right."
— Kyle Tequila 19:51
Confronting John Van Cise
One of the most intense moments in the episode is the direct confrontation with John Van Cise. Payne Lindsey and the team attempted to reach out to Van Cise, who initially ignored their outreach. Determined, they flew to Arizona to speak with him in person. The interaction was tense, with Van Cise refusing to engage and displaying dismissive hostility.
Notable Quote:
"This man has been hounded for 20 years... The truth will eventually come out, Period."
— Maggie Freeling 46:59
Current Status and Legacy
Nearly 30 years later, Jodi Huisentruit remains missing, with no definitive answers about her fate. The case has left a lasting impact on those who knew her, particularly Amy Kunz, who continues to seek closure. The Up and Vanished team's investigation highlights the challenges of solving cold cases without physical evidence and underscores the importance of relentless pursuit for truth and justice.
Notable Quote:
"It's been decades since Jodi aired her final segment at KIMT. In all these years, authorities have been unable to uncover what really happened to her."
— Meredith Steadman 61:23
Conclusion
The Up and Vanished episode on Jodi Huisentruit meticulously examines the enigmatic circumstances surrounding her disappearance. Through comprehensive investigation, interviews, and on-the-ground reporting, the episode presents a compelling narrative that keeps listeners engaged while honoring Jodi's memory. The unresolved nature of the case serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities inherent in true crime investigations and the enduring quest for truth.
Call to Action
The episode concludes by urging listeners with any information about Jodi Huisentruit's disappearance to come forward, emphasizing the ongoing need for community involvement in unsolved cases.
Notable Quote:
"If you have any information about Jodi Huisentrut's disappearance, call the Find Jody tip line at 641-999-1109 or email teamindjodi.com or submit an anonymous tip at findjoni.com or contact the Mason City Police Department at 641-421-3636."
— Meredith Steadman 62:54
End of Summary
Transcript Reference
The timestamps referenced in the summary correspond to the times in the provided transcript, facilitating easy cross-referencing for those who wish to delve deeper into specific sections of the episode.