Loading summary
Aisha Roscoe
I'm Aisha Roscoe, and this is a Sunday story from up first, where we go beyond the news to bring you one big story. Not long ago, reporter Will James walked into an apartment building in Seattle and met a tenant named Kenny Taylor.
Will James
Oh, thanks so much.
Kenny Taylor
Oh, this is home.
Will James
Yeah, this is great.
Aisha Roscoe
This building. The Union Hotel is the first in Seattle to operate under a philosophy called Housing first, and Kenny was one of the original tenants who moved in 30 years ago. He came here straight off the streets.
Kenny Taylor
I was homeless for about five years before I moved in here. I slept in doorways, I slept on the street, I slept in tents. I slept at the missions and stuff like that. It's not fun. Being homeless is not fun at all.
Aisha Roscoe
When Kenny moved into his apartment in the 1990s, Housing first was an experiment, and nobody knew how it was going to turn out. But now, 30 years later, housing first, the central strategy the federal government uses to combat homelessness. So is it working? And is it working like it's supposed to? When Housing first was introduced, the idea was to take some of the most vulnerable people living on the streets and move them immediately into their own permanent, subsidized apartments. A lot of these people had serious mental illnesses and addictions. The plan was to get them a home first and then worry about treating those problems later. Housing first started as a fringe idea, but eventually evidence started piling up that this worked to resolve many of the most stubborn cases of chronic homelessness. When people got housing under this approach, they usually stayed housed for years. Like Kenny.
Kenny Taylor
This is my home. I'm willing to keep my home as long as I. As long as I pay my rent, I just feel happy here. I wouldn't trade it for nothing in the world.
Aisha Roscoe
But with homelessness now at record levels, conservative think tanks and activists have set their sights on the philosophy of Housing First. They're pushing for more programs that require treatment and sobriety before housing, and Project 2025 calls for ending support of it altogether. After a break, reporter Will J. James joins me to talk about the future of Housing first and whether it's time for a course correction and how the US Handles one of its most persistent problems.
Ron Rutson
This message comes from NPR sponsor Saatva, maker of quality handcrafted mattresses. Founder and CEO Ron Rutson shares one of their core values.
Maureen Holley
At Saatva, we believe sleep does unlock a superpower. When you wake up and you're totally refreshed, you go after things more.
Will James
And it all starts with being on the right mattress.
Ron Rutson
And that's what Saatva has been inspired.
Maureen Holley
By from the day that we started.
Ron Rutson
Save up to $600 through President's Day at saatva.com NPR this message comes from Charles Schwab.
Michelle Huckabee Virick
When it comes to managing your wealth, Schwab gives you more choices like full service, wealth management and advice when you need it. You can also invest on your own and trade on thinkorswim. Visit schwab.com to learn more support for NPR. And the following message come from IXL Learning. IXL Learning uses advanced algorithms to give the right help to each kid, no matter the age or personality. Get an exclusive 20% off IXL membership when you sign up today at IXL.com NPR.
Aisha Roscoe
We'Re back with the Sunday Story. I'm here with Will James, a reporter and producer for KUOW in Seattle. He recently published an audio documentary about the Housing first approach to homelessness, its history and its future. Will welcome to the podcast.
Will James
Hey, thanks for having me, Aisha.
Aisha Roscoe
So, Will, Housing first has been around for 30 years, and it's been the US government's central strategy for fighting homelessness for at least a decade now, depending on when you start counting. Help us to understand the backlash to this philosophy. Like, where is it coming from?
Will James
Yeah. So there's a piece of this that is political. Housing first was political pretty bipartisan under George W. Bush and Barack Obama. But over the past few years, activists and think tanks on the political right have been pretty successful at branding this philosophy as left coded or liberal coded. But there's another element to this backlash that's actually much more interesting to me. As a reporter covering homelessness here in Seattle, I started hearing doubts about Housing first from people I didn't expect to hear them from folks who work directly with the homeless population at nonprofits that practice Housing first, sometimes even from people who lived on the streets themselves and moved inside under Housing First. And this really threw me because as a reporter, I'd been hearing for years that Housing first is the most studied, the most proven, the most cost effective strategy for getting people off the streets. And at the same time, some of the evidence that these critics were pointing to rang true to me, like they were pointing to problems that I have witnessed myself in my reporting. And this is what really made me want to dive into Housing first with this documentary. It was my own genuine confusion about how to reconcile these things.
Aisha Roscoe
That is very interesting because you are talking to people who are dealing with this firsthand, and they are fueling some of these doubts about Housing first. Like, like what? What are they Seeing that's causing their concerns.
Will James
So the first observation that critics of Housing first tend to make is since 2013, the US government has really pushed local governments and nonprofits to adopt Housing first practices. And for years, a majority of federal grants for homelessness have gone to Housing first projects, adding up to billions, billions of dollars. But the U.S. homeless population hit a new record in 2024. And so this has caused some people to wonder whether Housing first or maybe the way we're practicing Housing first is not meeting this moment. The second observation that critics make is that Housing first in practice can look very imperfect, to put it mildly. Yes, it offers people an apartment, a bed, a door that locks behind them. But the environment in these buildings can be challenging because the chaos of the streets tends to follow people indoors.
Aisha Roscoe
And you talked to some tenants who had experiences like this for your audio documentary?
Will James
Yeah. So we're gonna hear from a woman named Maureen Holley who lives in a building in downtown Seattle. It's this 14 story building that's a century old. And some of the tenants there are just low income, but others come straight off the streets under a Housing first program there. There is staff on site to help them with addiction and mental health if the tenants want that. But like with every Housing first project, treatment is not a requirement. Requirement of living here. Maureen's lived here for more than two decades after spending some time homeless herself. Two years ago, Maureen had an encounter with a neighbor that she says almost killed her. Here's Maureen from the documentary.
Bill Hobson
I was using crack cocaine at the time, and I was given a glass pipe to smoke, but it had fentanyl in it, and I didn't know it. I was in a coma for about four days. And they said it was a miracle that I managed to live because I had enough fentanyl in my system to kill me.
Daniel Malone
The rise of fentanyl has sent a surge of overdose deaths through housing programs across Seattle. These deaths nearly quadrupled between 2020 and 2023.
Will James
Michelle Huckabee Virick is one of Maureen's neighbors. Michelle has struggled with fentanyl addiction herself and says after a wave of overdose deaths in their building, she started to hoard stuff in her apartment.
Aisha Roscoe
I mean, there was people dying around you, so you hoard things, you make walls, you know, so, like, somebody came through the door, they couldn't get to you, you know, I never in my life lived like that. I felt like no one was safe, not even me. I just kind of basically left and I, like, camped out across the street. I Was really scared. So conditions were so bad in the building that Michelle actually felt safer staying in a tent out on the street.
Will James
Yeah, that's right. And she. She was there until some outreach workers helped clean out her apartment and then move her back in. This story is just one of a few anecdotes I've heard over the years that have trickled out of buildings like this. These stories have fueled questions about whether housing first, as we currently practice it, is working like it's supposed to. A common perception I've heard from tenants, and even occasionally from staffers who work in these buildings, is that housing first is taking people off the streets and sort of hiding their problems behind four walls and not doing enough to address those problems like substance use or mental illness.
Aisha Roscoe
And vocal critics of housing firsts, like the vice president, J.D. vance, have picked up on these anecdotes Right in their efforts to dismantle these programs. But what do they want instead?
Will James
Generally speaking, they want to change course and return to a philosophy called treatment first. This is the idea that people should follow a series of steps like treatment, sobriety, and employment that eventually end with permanent housing as the last step. And this idea of treatment first goes way back before housing first took off. Treatment first was the go to approach for many, many years.
Aisha Roscoe
Okay, so. So housing first was an alternative to treatment first. Yeah. So what were the problems with this reward and punishment based system that, you know, housing first emerged to address?
Will James
Yeah, that is a really important question, and I really wanted to understand this, so I dug back into the history of housing first. Back in the 90s, people working in the homelessness field realized that treatment first wasn't working for a subsection of the homeless population. They called this group the hardest to serve population. These were people who were the most disabled by mental illness and addiction and could not abide by the rules of treatment first. So they always ended up back on the streets. That's when some innovators decided to take a big risk and try just housing them and then bringing the treatment to them in their new apartments. And this was the birth of housing first. And here's where Seattle enters the story in a big way. In 2005, a Seattle nonprofit called the Downtown Emergency Service Center, DESC planned to open a building with 75 apartments for people who had been homeless for years and addicted to alcohol. At that point, Housing first had mostly been focused Focused on people whose main health problem was mental illness and who often had addiction on the side. But DESC's project was going to test housing first. For people whose main health problem was alcoholism. This blew up into a national news story. And it remains probably the most famous and controversial example of housing first in U.S. history.
Aisha Roscoe
So you're talking about the 1811 Eastlake project. You've got a section about this in your audio documentary. And it starts with this excerpt from a local Seattle call in show. Back then the conversation.
Maureen Holley
The downtown emergency service center is opening the facility at 1811 E. Lake Ave. For homeless men and women who have been identified as some of the most down and out chronic alcoholics. Residents will be allowed to drink in their rooms.
Will James
Anyone who moved into 1811 Eastlake was.
Daniel Malone
Not required to participate in any kind of treatment for alcoholism.
Will James
It was there if they wanted it.
Daniel Malone
But they could also just keep drinking.
Will James
It sounds to me like you're taking alcoholics and saying, please drink as much as you like. Why don't we have call in shows anymore?
Daniel Malone
This is good radio.
Will James
I mean, basically what they're talking about doing is having a public tax dollar funded flop house. I mean, what are they going to do? Just let them live there and continue.
Michelle Huckabee Virick
To drink themselves to death?
Will James
What's the purpose? What's going to be the outcome of this?
Daniel Malone
The person these callers were angry at was Bill Hobson. He ran DESC at the time and he was one of the country's most enthusiastic adopters of housing.
Will James
First, Bill was a bit of an iconoclast.
Daniel Malone
Daniel Malone runs DESC today and he worked under Bill.
Will James
Back then. He was pretty plain spoken a lot of the times about calling out things that he thought were wrong headed.
Daniel Malone
It was up to Bill, the head of desc, to explain to the irate public radio listeners of Seattle how all of this would work.
Bill Hobson
First of all, we're not saying please drink as much as you like. One of the goals of the project is to get residents in the building to reduce use. We believe that once you eliminate the chaos of homelessness from somebody's life, that they can more effectively and meaningfully go through the stages of change that they need to go through in order to become a bit more clinically stable and much more socially stable.
Maureen Holley
Now, as you're probably well aware, the most vehement criticism of this often comes from people who are recovering alcoholics or have recovering alcoholics in their family. They are kind of appalled that you would operate a facility and allow folks to keep drinking. And they would say their recovery would have never happened if they didn't stop. And they see this facility is not doing that. How do you respond to people like that? I'm sure you get that all the time.
Bill Hobson
We do.
Daniel Malone
Bill said, sure. For lots of people with alcoholism, abstinence did work. But what he wanted listeners to understand was that this was not the population he was talking about. He was talking about the hardest to serve. The 1811 Eastlake project was for people who back then were called chronic public inebriates. There were more than 1,000 of them in Seattle, according to a state estimate. Their health problems were comparable to people in developing countries, and their average age of death was 42 to 52 years old. In the Seattle area, their emergency room visits alone cost $100,000 per person per year. And on average, they had already tried to stop drinking 16 times, and it didn't work.
Maureen Holley
You're kind of acknowledging that it's highly likely these people will never stop drinking.
Bill Hobson
That's correct. I mean, we're talking about men and women that have been living on the streets of downtown Seattle for 15, 20 years and have gone into conventional treatment multiple times and have not succeeded with it.
Aisha Roscoe
So what I'm picking up on here is that there are very different ideas about what looks like under Housing First. The callers were basically saying they want people to get sober. And Bill, who runs the nonprofit, is saying we have to accept that some percentage of people are never going to get sober.
Will James
That's right. And that's why this recording from 20 years ago was so eye opening to me. The proponents of Housing first were always clear eyed about what their tenants were dealing with. They just have a very different idea of what recovery means for the people they're trying to help. In many cases, recovery for them doesn't mean sobriety. It means a life that is a little more stable, a little more comfortable, a little more dignified. And this is incredibly painful and frustrating for a lot of critics to hear because it goes against a lot of values that we're steeped in as Americans. It's saying that there is a limit to how far grit and self improvement will get you. And there are a lot of people who just don't. Don't want to believe that.
Aisha Roscoe
Yeah, I can see how it's hard to accept that some people won't be able to get helped in the way that we think about it. Like, can everybody with the right approach get sober? What happened with 1811?
Will James
Eastlake DESC did open the building in 2005, and they moved in 75 of the most disabled people living on the streets of Seattle with alcoholism. And then an academic study came out a few years later. This study showed that the first wave of people who moved into the building stayed housed there, and that housing them ended up being cheaper than just letting them cycle through emergency rooms and sobering centers and jails. And it showed that the people who moved in ended up drinking a little less on average once they were inside. Now, these results were pretty modest. They went from drinking something like 16 drinks a day to 11 on average. But this fear that people had, that this environment was going to enable people and their alcoholism was going to get worse, it just wasn't true. In fact, the opposite was true. These results got a lot of attention and helped build hype for Housing First Across America. And results like this have been replicated again and again for decades now. It's worth saying, too, that 1811 Eastlake is still going on here in Seattle. It still has 75 units, and 20 years later, it's still doing essentially the same thing.
Aisha Roscoe
So Will has raised a lot of really difficult questions about Housing first as a policy. After the break, he tries to make sense of all of this nuanced information, the good stuff, the bad stuff, and how it can all fit together.
Bill Hobson
Foreign.
Ron Rutson
This message comes From NPR Sponsor 1Password if you bypass security to save yourself some time, you're not alone. Fortunately, with one password Extended Access Management, security and productivity no longer have to be at odds. 1Password Extended Access Management ensures that whatever device your employees use for work, it's healthy and uncompromised. Get started today, securing every app, device and identity, even the unmanaged ones. For a free two week trial, visit1Password.com.
Michelle Huckabee Virick
First support for NPR and the following message come from IXL Learning. IXL Learning uses advanced algorithms to give the right help to each kid, no matter the age or personality. Get an exclusive 20% off IXL membership when you sign up today@ixl.com NPR this.
Ron Rutson
Message comes from HubSpot. As a marketer, you have to generate leads, create content and make your brand go viral. It's a lot. Thankfully, there's Breeze, HubSpot's suite of AI tools. Now you can turn one piece of content into all the assets you need, find the best leads and beef up your reporting all in one place. Visit HubSpot.com marketers to see how companies like yours are generating 110% more leads in just 12 months.
Aisha Roscoe
We're back with the Sunday Story, talking with reporter Will James about the complicated reality of housing First. Will, I want to take us back to the question that kicked off your reporting. The results from 1811 Eastlake are part of this stack of evidence that housing first works, and yet the shortfalls that you point to in your reporting are real. So in practice, people continue to relapse and overdose and have crises even once they're inside. Under housing first, I'm wondering, how have you come to understand the role of housing first in addressing homelessness?
Will James
When housing first was first invented, it was really for a subpopulation of the homeless population. It was for the most disabled people living on the streets with serious mental illness, with serious substance use disorders. And those things sort of happen over time, right? When someone becomes homeless and then they stay on the streets for months or years, those disabilities tend to compound over time. So housing first is like throwing them a lifesaver and giving them something to grab onto, some foundation upon which to do the really intense, lifelong work of rebuilding. But a little over a decade ago, this definition of housing first started to expand, and the federal government started to really incentivize housing first practices for all sorts of organizations that were trying to address homelessness. And so we saw more and more people, you know, fall under the housing first umbrella. And this is where some of the questions start to emerge, like, are people getting swept up in housing first when some of them might actually do better in a more structured setting like sober housing or an addiction treatment center? And when I look at all of this, it's clear that housing first was only ever meant to be one piece of the solution to homelessness. When we look at why housing first on its own is not going to solve homelessness, one of the reasons is that new people are constantly falling into homelessness. A metaphor that I've heard that's been really helpful is that housing first is one way of bailing out the bathtub. Meanwhile, the faucet is still on, and new people are constantly falling into homelessness. So that's why housing first on its own is not sufficient.
Aisha Roscoe
So it sounds like people may need to modify their expectations of what housing first can do. But do you think there are ways to continue improving it, like, as a part of a comprehensive plan to reduce homelessness?
Will James
So there's been this debate for decades now about the best way to implement housing first. Sam Sambaris, who's like the father of the housing first approach, wanted his clients to be scattered in apartments all across a city, in buildings where they're surrounded by neighbors from, like, mainstream society. But other communities found that it was sometimes cheaper and often just easier to put all of their tenants together in one big building. And, of course, concentrating people with a lot of really Serious problems in one building like this that does contribute to some of the issues we see here in Seattle and that we document in the piece. When I talk to Sam, he mentions something else that's important for implementing this approach.
Ron Rutson
Remember, the program for me was not about somebody moves into an apartment and lives happily ever after, although a great many do. This is a journey for people. It's very hard to recover. It's very hard to acknowledge you have problems, but we're going to stay with you through the journey.
Will James
To be clear, there are plenty of providers who do follow through. Sam cited the downtown Emergency Service center here in Seattle as an example of that. They have doctors, nurses, addiction specialists on staff. That's what Housing first can aspire to. But Sam worries that these practices aren't widespread enough.
Aisha Roscoe
So I want to go back to Kenny. You point to his life as an example of what success looks like under Housing First. But you also point out in your audio documentary that it's a complicated success.
Daniel Malone
Across 30 years at the Union Hotel in Seattle, Kenny Taylor has seen all that's good and bad about Housing First. The bad includes a neighbor who bangs on the wall at three in the morning and has knocked holes in it.
Will James
Bam, bam, bam, bam, bam, bam, bam, bam.
Kenny Taylor
I'm a wall and I call police on him. They can't do nothing for me.
Daniel Malone
Kenny says his girlfriend died in her apartment here a few years ago after using heroin, falling and hitting her head. He wishes there wasn't so much drug use in the building. And he keeps his distance from a lot of his neighbors because he feels like they just want money out of him. But for 30 years, Kenny has chosen to keep living here anyway. This is where Kenny says he got sober. He says he quit drugs about 10 years ago and alcohol two years ago. And it wasn't any sort of pressure that got him there. Kenny says recovery just moves at its own pace. In his case, it took decades.
Kenny Taylor
I was determined that. I was determined that the drugs or the alcohol wasn't going to destroy me. I come this far, might as well go all the way. That's how I felt about it.
Daniel Malone
Sometimes he helps out with communal meals here in the dining room.
Will James
Do you cook?
Kenny Taylor
Yeah, a little bit. Southern style. I cook. I love grits. I love grits.
Daniel Malone
Kenny's life, in all its messiness, all its ups and downs, is what success looks like under Housing First. You might notice it's not all that different from the stories critics point to as evidence of failure. Kenny's lived some of those same headaches and tragedies here. So is Housing first working for Kenny? He'd say yes. Having a place has allowed him to adopt his cat, Treasure, which he says has given his life purpose. Kenny spends most of his days lately writing a book about treasure.
Kenny Taylor
I got 19 chapters written already. I'm about ready to get it published. Everybody's got a purpose in their life, and my purpose was to write this book.
Will James
What story does the book tell?
Kenny Taylor
That anybody can put down paper, that they love something and stick to it? So far, I've stuck to it.
Aisha Roscoe
Well, I mean, that's incredibly moving. Getting back to the politics of all of this, President Trump, he's surrounded by critics of Housing First. So what is the possible impact of shifting away from Housing first on a national level?
Will James
Yeah, the approach in Project 2025 would be to end support for Housing first altogether and reimpose requirements like entering treatment for addiction and mental illness. And it's worth noting these are programs that have historically been underfunded and in short supply. And as we saw in the past, like the 1990s and before that, that approach risks condemning a lot of people to the streets. And if that were to happen, it would happen at a time of record homelessness in America.
Aisha Roscoe
That's Will James, reporter and producer at Seattle member station kuow. You can find his full documentary on Housing first at the link in our show notes. Thank you for being here, Will.
Will James
Thanks for having me, Aisha.
Aisha Roscoe
This episode of the Sunday Story was produced by Justine Yan and Kim Naderfane Petersa. It was edited by Jenny Schmidt. Kwesi Lee mastered the episode. Special thanks to Liz Jones, who edited the KUOW audio documentary on Housing First. The Sunday Story team includes Andrew Mambo and our senior supervising producer, Lianna Simstrom. Irene Noguchi is our executive producer. I'm Aisha Roscoe. Up first is back tomorrow with all the news you need to start your week. Until then, have a great rest of your weekend.
Michelle Huckabee Virick
Support for NPR and the following message come from Bolen Branch. Change your sleep with the softness of Bolen Branch's 100% organic cotton sheets. Feel the difference with 15% off your first set of sheets@bolenbranch.com with code NPR exclusions apply. See site for details. Support for this podcast and the following message come from Cunard. Discover the best of Alaska on a luxury voyage aboard Cunard's Queen Elizabeth. Round trip from seattle. Choose from 7 to 12 nights with more time in iconic ports and scenic cruising through Glacier Bay national park and Hubbard Glacier. Enjoy spacious accommodations, locally sourced cuisine and award winning entertainment. Only on Cunard can you experience an Alaskan afternoon tea, the Ice White Ball and guest speakers sharing stories of the region. Visit qnar.com Alaska this message comes from Mint Mobile. Mint Mobile took what's wrong with wireless and made it right. They offer premium wireless plans for less and all plans include high speed data, unlimited talk and text, and nationwide coverage. See for yourself at mintmobile.com. switch.
Up First from NPR: "A Home But Not A Cure" – Episode Summary
Release Date: February 16, 2025
In the episode titled "A Home But Not A Cure," NPR's Up First delves deep into the complexities of the Housing First philosophy—the federal government's central strategy to combat homelessness in the United States. Hosted by Aisha Rascoe, the episode explores the philosophy's three-decade history, its successes, challenges, and the emerging backlash questioning its efficacy in the face of record homelessness levels.
The episode opens with Aisha Rascoe introducing Kenny Taylor, one of the original tenants of Seattle's Union Hotel, which operates under the Housing First model. Thirty years ago, Kenny transitioned from homelessness to securing a permanent, subsidized apartment without the prerequisite of treatment for his mental illness and addiction.
Notable Quote:
"This is home. I'm willing to keep my home as long as I pay my rent, I just feel happy here. I wouldn't trade it for nothing in the world."
– Kenny Taylor [02:16]
Kenny's story exemplifies the initial success of Housing First—providing stability to those most vulnerable by offering housing first and addressing other issues subsequently.
Housing First originated in the 1990s as an alternative to the traditional "treatment first" approach, which required individuals to undergo treatment for mental illness or addiction before qualifying for housing. Recognizing that the hardest-to-serve populations often cycled back to homelessness due to unmet needs, innovators like the Downtown Emergency Service Center (DESC) in Seattle piloted Housing First to provide immediate housing as a foundation for recovery.
Key Points:
Despite Housing First's proven track record, homelessness in the U.S. reached new highs by 2024. This surge has led to increased criticism from conservative think tanks and activists who argue that the approach enables substance abuse and fails to address underlying issues.
Notable Quote:
"Housing first was the most studied, the most proven, the most cost-effective strategy for getting people off the streets."
– Will James [05:02]
Will James, the episode's investigative reporter, expresses confusion over the backlash, especially as some critics are individuals directly involved with or formerly experiencing homelessness themselves.
James's documentary highlights specific challenges within Housing First implementations, such as:
Overdose Deaths: The rise of fentanyl led to a surge in overdose deaths within Housing First facilities, nearly quadrupling between 2020 and 2023.
Notable Quote:
"The rise of fentanyl has sent a surge of overdose deaths through housing programs across Seattle."
– Daniel Malone [09:09]
Environmental Struggles: Even with housing, tenants often continue to face chaos related to their past lives on the streets.
Notable Quote:
"It's challenging because the chaos of the streets tends to follow people indoors."
– Will James [07:49]
A pivotal part of the episode focuses on the 1811 Eastlake project initiated by DESC in 2005. This project was designed to house 75 of Seattle's most chronically homeless individuals with severe alcoholism, allowing residents to drink within their apartments without mandatory treatment.
Notable Quotes:
"We're not saying please drink as much as you like... One of the goals... to reduce use."
– Bill Hobson [15:07]
"You're kind of acknowledging that it's highly likely these people will never stop drinking."
– Maureen Holley [16:52]
Despite initial fears from the public that this approach would exacerbate alcohol abuse, studies revealed that residents' drinking levels decreased on average, demonstrating that providing stability can lead to modest improvements even without mandatory treatment.
The episode examines the political shift against Housing First, particularly under the influence of conservative figures like Vice President J.D. Vance and policies such as Project 2025, which aims to dismantle Housing First programs in favor of "treatment first" models requiring sobriety and participation in treatment programs before housing.
Notable Quote:
"We're talking about men and women that have been living on the streets... and have not succeeded with [treatment first]."
– Bill Hobson [16:56]
This political movement risks stripping away support systems that have historically prevented the most vulnerable populations from returning to the streets, especially amidst rising homelessness.
Kenny Taylor's narrative captures the nuanced reality of Housing First. While he has maintained his housing and achieved sobriety, his life has been marked by ongoing challenges, including neighbor conflicts and the loss of loved ones to addiction.
Notable Quotes:
"I was determined that the drugs or the alcohol wasn't going to destroy me. I come this far, might as well go all the way."
– Kenny Taylor [27:58]
"Everybody's got a purpose in their life, and my purpose was to write this book."
– Kenny Taylor [28:12]
Kenny's story illustrates both the stability provided by Housing First and the persistent struggles that tenants may continue to face.
Will James contends that while Housing First has been instrumental for many, it alone cannot address all facets of homelessness, especially as the influx of new individuals continues. A comprehensive approach that includes Housing First as one component, alongside other supportive services and preventive measures, is essential.
Notable Quote:
"Housing first was only ever meant to be one piece of the solution to homelessness."
– Will James [22:43]
The episode closes by emphasizing the need for a balanced strategy that adapts Housing First to current challenges while integrating additional support systems to effectively reduce homelessness.
Episode Production Credits: Produced by Justine Yan and Kim Naderfane Petersa. Edited by Jenny Schmidt with mastering by Kwesi Lee.
Further Listening: Listeners interested in an in-depth exploration of Housing First can access Will James's full documentary available via the show notes.
This comprehensive episode of Up First sheds light on the intricate dynamics of the Housing First philosophy, highlighting both its transformative potential and the critical challenges it faces in contemporary America.