Podcast Title: Watch What Crappens
Hosts: Ben Mandelker & Ronnie Karam
Episode: #2854 The Valley S2E06 Part Two: Fan-tom Menace
Release Date: May 21, 2025

Introduction

In episode #2854 of Watch What Crappens, hosts Ben Mandelker and Ronnie Karam delve into the second part of the sixth episode of The Valley, aptly titled "Fan-tom Menace." This detailed recap explores the intricate dynamics among the show's characters, highlighting key conflicts, emotional moments, and the hosts' candid analyses.

Main Plot Discussion

Jesse and Isabella's Interaction

The episode begins with a humorous yet telling interaction between Jesse and his daughter, Isabella. Isabella offers Jesse a booger, leading to a lighthearted moment that underscores Jesse's attempt to regain control and maturity amidst family tensions.

• Ronnie Karam [02:15]: "And I know you love that. I thought that was so funny."
• Ben Mandelker [03:08]: "I loved it because it meant that Jesse had to have a booger on his finger."

Jesse's Moment of Clarity

Jesse experiences a moment of self-awareness, deciding to prioritize his relationship, business, and daughter over bitterness and resentment towards his wife, Michelle.

• Ronnie Karam [03:09]: "He’s exhausted, so I’m going to be really nice."
• Ben Mandelker [03:23]: "I’ve got my relationship, my business, and my daughter."

Michelle and Isabella's Conflict

Michelle and Isabella engage in a tense exchange over a lost key, revealing deeper issues in their relationship. Isabella accuses Michelle of dishonesty, leading Jesse to confront Michelle about not allowing him to see their daughter unless she changes her behavior.

• Ronnie Karam [04:38]: "You’re lying to me, mommy."
• Ben Mandelker [05:11]: "Why does your 4-year-old have access to the house key?"

Britney's Apology Dinner

The focus shifts to Britney’s attempt at an apology dinner with Chef Gino and other characters present. Britney and her friends attempt to apologize for their drunken behavior, but the sincerity of their apologies is questionable due to their intoxicated states.

• Ben Mandelker [08:26]: "They are apologizing for accusing Danny of being wasted while they themselves were wasted."
• Ronnie Karam [09:16]: "I cried a little bit, which is kind of rare. But then I started cracking up."

Nia and Janet's Confrontation

A significant portion of the episode centers on the confrontation between Nia and Janet regarding Danny’s drinking problem. Janet attempts to draw parallels between her past experiences and Danny’s current behavior, but her approach is seen as manipulative and hypocritical by the other characters.

• Ben Mandelker [16:37]: "Nia’s not being attacked, Danny’s being attacked, but Nia’s not because she’s nice."
• Ronnie Karam [24:51]: "Nia gets away scot-free because Nia’s nice, whereas Danny is being attacked for his actions."

Hosts’ Insights on Character Dynamics

Ben and Ronnie discuss the fairness and hypocrisy in how certain characters are treated compared to others. They highlight the double standards present within the show's narrative and how certain characters like Nia receive leniency due to their likable nature, while others like Danny face relentless criticism.

• Ben Mandelker [26:00]: "Nia has been able to gracefully handle the crap thrown at her, which isn’t fair to the others."
• Ronnie Karam [24:54]: "Janet is hated by the country, and Britney's got mixed reactions, but Nia's viewed as the perfect person."

Hosts’ Analysis and Opinions

Ben and Ronnie provide a critical lens on the show's portrayal of vulnerability and conflict resolution. They express frustration with Janet’s insincere apologies and manipulative tactics, emphasizing the lack of genuine communication and support among the characters.

• Ben Mandelker [20:21]: "If I had a concern, I would separate the issue and address it privately rather than making a public spectacle."
• Ronnie Karam [22:38]: "Janet’s approach is trying to paint Danny as an alcoholic to embarrass him, which is manipulative."

They also touch upon the emotional authenticity of characters, questioning the genuineness of their apologies and the strategic use of personal backstories to garner sympathy or manipulate perceptions.

• Ronnie Karam [12:15]: "Nia explains why she's so positive due to her past struggles, whereas others like Chrishell use similar tactics insincerely."
• Ben Mandelker [13:22]: "Jasmine’s apology lacks vulnerability and comes off as empty compared to other characters’ genuine moments."

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Ronnie Karam [02:15]: "I loved it because it meant that Jesse had to have a booger on his finger."
• Ben Mandelker [03:08]: "I’ve got my relationship, my business, and my daughter."
• Ronnie Karam [04:38]: "You’re lying to me, mommy."
• Ben Mandelker [08:26]: "They are apologizing for accusing Danny of being wasted while they themselves were wasted."
• Ronnie Karam [12:15]: "Christine being mean to me reminds me of being the smelly kid."
• Ben Mandelker [16:37]: "Nia’s not being attacked, Danny’s being attacked, but Nia’s not because she’s nice."
• Ronnie Karam [24:54]: "Janet is hated by the country, and Britney's got people calling her trash all the time."

Conclusion

In this episode of Watch What Crappens, Ben Mandelker and Ronnie Karam offer a comprehensive and engaging analysis of the second part of The Valley's sixth episode. They dissect the intricate character dynamics, highlight moments of hypocrisy and manipulation, and provide thoughtful critiques on the show's portrayal of personal struggles and conflict resolution. Their insightful commentary not only entertains but also invites listeners to reflect on the complexities of reality TV narratives.

Support Watch What Crappens:
For bonus episodes, video recaps, and exclusive access to the Discord server, visit www.patreon.com/watchwhatcrappens.

Listen on:
Available on the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and Wondery+ for ad-free experiences.