Watch What Crappens Podcast Episode #2921: RHOA S16E18 Part 1 - "Eady Come, Eady Go"

Release Date: July 14, 2025

In episode #2921 of the "Watch What Crappens" podcast, hosts Ben Mandelker and guest co-hosts Diamond Cooper and Andrew Puglisi dive deep into the recent Real Housewives of Atlanta (RHOA) reunion episode titled "Eady Come, Eady Go." This episode marks a significant discussion point as it navigates the tumultuous events surrounding cast members, particularly focusing on the fallout from Kenya Moore and the notable absence of Brit Fitzpatrick from the reunion.

Introduction to the Episode

The episode kicks off with Ben Mandelker welcoming Diamond Cooper and Andrew Puglisi in the stead of Ronnie Karam, who is enjoying a well-deserved holiday. Ben sets the stage by referencing their comprehensive discussion on previous RHOA episodes and Love Island finales available exclusively on their Patreon page.

Season Overview and Initial Impressions

Diamond Cooper expresses her initial skepticism about the season, stating, "[06:16] Last season, I wanted it to be completely done. I wanted a full. No, I don't even want reboots anymore." However, she acknowledges a slight improvement in the current season but ultimately felt it "missed the mark" due to unresolved tensions and character developments, particularly her growing disdain for Brit Fitzpatrick by the season's end.

Ben Mandelker offers a contrasting view, mentioning, "[07:19] I actually enjoyed this season more than I thought I would." He appreciated the early strong start of the season but notes that events surrounding Kenya Moore derailed their initial plans. Ben particularly highlights the dynamic between Portia and new cast member Phaedra, emphasizing the "good energy" and "fun dynamics" they brought to the show.

Andrew Puglisi, as a newer viewer, shares his fresh perspective, appreciating characters like Cynthia Cheekbones. He remarks, "[08:27] I wanna know her. She seems so nice," indicating his interest in her character development and interactions.

In-Depth Cast Member Analysis

Portia de Rossi

Both hosts commend Portia's return to the show. Diamond Cooper states, "[06:38] I was really happy that Portia was back," appreciating the depth she adds to the storyline. Ben Mandelker echoes this sentiment, highlighting the positive interactions Portia has with other cast members, which injects fresh energy into the reunion.

Cynthia Cheekbones Bailey

Andrew praises Cynthia, noting her likability and the balance she brings to the group. Ben Mandelker adds, "[09:11] I think her as a friend is a good lane for her. We get to visit with Cynthia, but we don't have to be burdened with her storylines." This balanced role allows Cynthia to remain engaging without overwhelming the narrative.

Kelly Prasad

Kelly receives mixed reviews. Diamond Cooper criticizes her for being overly loud and inconsistent, saying, "[09:57] First of all, too much screaming from this woman." Conversely, Ben Mandelker feels Kelly showed potential but ultimately didn't capitalize on it, noting her lack of impact throughout the season.

Angela Drysdale

Angela stands out as a favorite among the hosts. Diamond Cooper rates her a perfect 10 out of 10, praising her ability to inject drama and maintain a strong presence, "[11:49] When you have someone like Angela there... she’s bringing the drama." Andrew Puglisi adds, "[12:22] I love Angela. She's so funny." His admiration underscores Angela's influential role in the show's dynamics.

Brit Fitzpatrick

Brit's absence from the reunion is a focal point of the discussion. Diamond Cooper expresses relief, stating, "[13:58] I just can’t [handle her presence]." The hosts speculate on the reasons behind her non-attendance and its implications on the reunion's flow, with Ben Mandelker theorizing that her absence forced the production to rely on less engaging filler content.

Drew Sedora

Drew Sedora's controversial behavior is scrutinized. Diamond Cooper is vocal about her disdain, saying, "[25:06] I wanted her gone last season." Ben Mandelker further critiques her authenticity and business practices, highlighting her dubious claim regarding weight loss and her LLC operations, "[26:17] Drew has to go." However, Andrew Puglisi offers a nuanced view, appreciating her self-aware antics that add to the show's plot progression.

Reunion Episode Breakdown

The hosts dissect the reunion episode's structure and content, emphasizing several key moments:

• Brit's Absence: The episode starts with confusion over Brit's missing presence. Andrew Puglisi questions, "[14:24] That was like, when you go low, I go lower."

• Delays and Production Flaws: The reunion begins three hours late, leading to disorganized and superficial interactions among the cast. Ben Mandelker remarks, "[17:44] They started this reunion at like, three hours late."

• Dress Code and Presentation: The all-gold metallic dress code receives mixed reviews. Diamond Cooper praises Portia's appearance but criticizes Phaedra's, stating, "[19:44] I didn't like Phaedra's headpiece and earrings."

• Conflict Over Divorces: A heated exchange arises when Kelly and Portia compare their divorces. Kelly insists, "[52:41] You cannot say you were asking out of concern." Diamond Cooper counters, "[52:43] Concern for who? Fallon." highlighting the tension and lack of resolution.

• Shamia's Involvement: Shamia's role becomes contentious as questions arise about her introducing Portia to Simon, leading to defensiveness and denial. Ben Mandelker observes, "[57:22] She said, I was there when they met." indicating mixed signals and distrust.

Production Insights and Theories

Ben Mandelker speculates on the impact of Kenya Moore's departure mid-season, suggesting that it "messed up the entire season" due to disrupted filming schedules and narrative arcs. He posits, "[07:22] I have a theory that when someone gets fired... it messes up the entire season." This disruption led to the forced inclusion of lesser storylines and reliance on less engaging content to fill airtime.

Conclusion and Teasers for Part Two

As the episode draws to a close, the hosts express anticipation for the continuation of the discussion in part two. Ben Mandelker humorously notes the absence of a cliffhanger, only to be reminded by Diamond Cooper, setting the stage for more in-depth analysis in the upcoming installment.

Notable Quotes from the Episode:

• Diamond Cooper [07:19]: "I didn't know that I would hate Brit by the end of the season."

• Ben Mandelker [09:11]: "I think her as a friend is a good lane for her. We get to visit with Cynthia, but we don't have to be burdened with her storylines."

• Diamond Cooper [09:57]: "First of all, too much screaming from this woman."

• Diamond Cooper [19:44]: "I didn't like Phaedra's headpiece and earrings."

• Ben Mandelker [25:16]: "Drew has to go."

• Ben Mandelker [57:39]: "We get it. We're back at the reunion. We understand."

This comprehensive discussion offers listeners insightful critiques and enthusiastic praise for various elements of the RHOA season, making it a valuable listen for both avid fans and newcomers eager to understand the latest developments in this reality TV saga.