← We Fixed It, You're Welcome
We Fixed It, You're Welcome
Hired or Hustled? Avoiding Job Search Predators
01:01:09
In this episode, our panel explores a troubling trend in today’s job market: companies that exist to exploit job seekers. The reality of today’s job market? Ongoing layoffs and exponentially more candidates than open jobs. As a result, many people are opening their wallets to paid recruiters, coaches, career accelerators, and “job connector platforms” that promise hidden opportunities for a steep monthly fee. It’s all so confusing: which of these services provide legitimate help? Which ones are just middlemen that prey on the unemployed? How can job seekers steer clear of the ones motivated by greed that don’t provide any real value? Throughout this timely conversation, our panel discusses how the modern job search landscape has changed, why so many questionable services have emerged, and how candidates can protect themselves. We also share practical advice on identifying ethical recruiters, avoiding scams, and navigating the job market with confidence and strategy. The episode ...
Loading summary
Transcript93 lines
- [00:01]
Progressive Insurance Announcer
Ever notice how life's best stories don't happen in your living room. They happen on the open road, out on the water or parked under the stars. At Progressive, they get that you want to focus on the experience, not worry about the what ifs. That's why they offer quality insurance designed for your ride, whether That's a boat, RV or motorcycle adventure with confidence. Visit progressive.com and see how easy it is to protect your favorite way to get away. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates not available in D.C. prices vary based on
- [00:31]
American Airlines Business Program Announcer
how you buy the American Airlines Advantage Business program is changing the way companies book travel and get rewarded. Designed for fast growing businesses, the program makes it easy to earn rewards and it's free to join your company. Earns one Advantage mile for every dollar spent on business travel booked anywhere with American. Use these miles to help offset future travel expenses, transfer to employees and more. You'll also gain access to a suite of tools to streamline travel management, including the ability to view employee activity, manage trip credits and report with ease. And it's a win win. Travelers can earn additional loyalty points on top of what they already earned through the Advantage program, helping them reach status faster. Earn more on business travel you're already taking with the American Airlines Advantage Business program. Register today@aa.com Advantage Business welcome to We
- [01:27]
Host
Fixed it, you're welcome, the show where we take over companies. You come along for the ride and we try to put them back better than we found them. When it comes to identifying talent, that's a real skill, making professionals better at what they do. That's a true specialization. There are seasoned professionals out there who are really good at this, like coaches and recruiters who are helping people find their way and doing a lot of good. Even in a labor market as complicated as this one, which we'll talk about, they're finding opportunities for job seekers, helping people upskill and providing actual value. And then there's a new type of company that's playing in ethically gray areas. These companies are doing great. They'll tell you that themselves. They are making a killing off of unemployed or underemployed people, many of them vulnerable, who just want to work. And these types of companies are acting as a new hoop to jump through. You want opportunities?
- [02:23]
ExpressVPN Announcer
Oh, don't talk to the companies themselves.
- [02:25]
Host
You're going to have to talk to us first. And you better get in line. We're going to talk about this new type of job, gatekeeper, skimming off the top every which way and see what it'll take to make them go away. Melissa, Tell us more about this.
- [02:39]
Melissa
Well, if you've been looking for a job anytime in the last few years, you don't need anyone to tell you how bad it feels out there. It's stressful. You're applying and you see hundreds of other candidates. Some of these roles may be stale, or are they even really open? You finally get traction. You run the interview gauntlet. Thousands of interviews. It feels like at least five screens. Panels, culture chats, take home projects. And just when you start to have hope, the role goes on hold and disappears without a word. Ghosted. You're exhausted, scared about money and somehow still back at square one. And that's exactly when this new wave of helpers shows up. If your LinkedIn says open to work or fractional, your inbox fills up quickly. Pay to play recruiters who will represent you if you swipe your card. Platforms that charge a monthly fee plus a cut of any revenue you make each, even if you found the work yourself. High ticket programs that want up to 10k up front and 10 to 15% of whatever you might earn someday with no real guarantees they'll deliver anything. Not all of these services are bad. Some coaches and platforms genuinely help people tell their story, land roles, review their resumes, and turn lemons into lemonade. But far too many feel engineered to profit from our personal panic. They lean on fear, ask if you're worth investing in, and then publicly celebrate their own revenue and growth while their clients are still lying awake at 3am worrying about how to pay rent. This isn't just annoying, it's a serious distortion of who holds the power and who carries the risk. The people around the job market are thriving and the people who actually need work are paying in time, money and emotional bandwidth they don't have. So the question for us today is
- [04:38]
Chino
how did we get here?
- [04:40]
Melissa
Where's the LAO to Success stories belong to vendors, not the workers. And what would it take to flip that script so that the ethical recruiters and truly helpful coaches out there stay and the exploiters get pushed out and job seekers are treated like the customer in this very system, not just the product being sold. That's what we're here to unpack and hopefully to start fixing today. And I'm so excited to do that with this panel, Aaron and Chino, because I believe we all lend to a very professional yet personal perspective to this current fun employment landscape.
- [05:21]
Chino
Let's get going.
- [05:23]
Host
This is a big one.
- [05:26]
Chino
Yes, it is. And you know, for the listeners who don't know, I actually Run my own recruitment agency like Cappuccino. And I am so close to this. And I guess before we begin, I think what's really important is trying to figure out how to decipher, you know, what is a recruiter who is a coach. Because as Melissa just shared, there's a thousand people who call themselves a coach or recruiter, and it doesn't mean that they're all doing so with your best interests at heart. And so I think I want to take it back. Because the reason why recruitment or HR or talent became a specialty is because, you know, back in the day when the market was doing great and everybody had jobs, it was really hard to find people. So you would have recruiters who would specialize in a particular market, creative design, engineering, whatever the case may be, whether it was full time, which is again, kind of my area, where you're looking for people for a full time role. And then there are recruiters that focus on temp work where, you know, you have an agency that needs, you know, three days of support on a shoot, or, you know, they need you to come in as a SWAT for a specific project that's really highly specialized and only you have the tools or that experience. Right. And so this is where recruiters had come in traditionally to help kind of bridge that gap and to find those specialties. That's not to say that's not happening. I'm quite busy in my own role, so I know that that is happening. But where you see the shift is these fake jobs where recruiters are now, you know, putting out, you know, job boards where you're spending your time investing, you know, emotional labor, physical labor as well, sometimes even money. Like they're, they're charging you to be a part of their roster with no real job in mind. And in this market, that doesn't work anymore. And so, you know, particularly with this coaches, if you again have that open to work on LinkedIn, they're targeting you and saying, okay, well, I know you need help. Does this make sense, you know, for you to jump into that? And I think what people need to start asking themselves is, is this real? Who are you representing? And I think that's the first kind of step in helping decipher who are the good actors and who are there with the intent to kind of capitalize on your downfall. And I don't want to take up all the airspace here because I have so much to say, but I think it's important to just understand why their recruitment was there to begin with and how that has Kind of changed in the last, not just 10 years, not 15 years and less eight months. It's completely different. And it keeps. The cycle used to be a lot longer and now you're seeing a change in kind of the job market recruitment landscape, I would say every six or seven months now for the last three years. So, you know, want to give you the tools to make sure you know how to read what's real and what's not.
- [08:38]
Host
Yeah. And those tools are going to be, that's going to be everything because Melissa, you touched on it. But if you have the word fractional or you have open to work on your LinkedIn and it is relentless, you and our listeners know this. You get, you get bombarded to put it up for a day, try it out as an experiment. You will find companies coming out of the woodwork to offer their services, to say, we'll help you through this, through this market, which, you know, very few people understand this market to a degree that the rest of us don't know. There are experts that do. But some of these companies are, you know, look, look at when they register their domain. Some of them are a few months old or less than a year old and what they're bragging about is we have X number of subscribers or we have X number of. We'll say I'm in marketing. We'll say marketing. We have 450 marketing candidates in that that are signed up to our monthly subscription. You should do that too. Which seems like, okay, good, safety in numbers. And my peers are there and they must be finding some value. But in actuality, you know, and I've had this conversation with these companies. Why, why would I be 451? That seems to benefit you as opposed to me if, if I was, you know, if I was interested in what you had to sell me. Now I'm, you know, I'm, I'm at the back of the line with 450 others in front of me who are already paying you for what you may or may not be fulfilling for them with or without a promise or expectation that you, you know, you'll actually fulfill what, what you, you say you will because there's, it's really hard to hold these companies accountable. And now, you know, why, why am I just another number to you? So I've had these argumentative, it can get very, you know, triggering. I've had these argumentative kind of conversations and, and, and talked about these ethical areas with these, these vendors and you know, they get very up in arms about it and they point to. But the big thing is they point to their profitability, their own profitability as a sign of success. That's their metric.
- [10:41]
Melissa
Well, and I think that the big thing is to say the quiet part out loud. This whole set and series of businesses only exists because candidates like Aaron, you know, fractional candidates or people who are unemployed have almost zero power in this market. And so because you don't have the power, that risk is totally upside down, right? So where I'm absorbing all the risk because I'm the candidate looking for a role and I'm desperate. You go to whatever, you know, it's like moths to a light, right? You go to someplace where you're like, okay, this is the, the new shiny thing. This is how I'm going to get a job. Because I've applied to 400 jobs and gotten two interviews, gone through the gauntlet as we talked about earlier, and I still don't have a role, right? And it's way beneath my pay grade that I was hoping for. It's beneath my expertise level, my education level, whatever it might look like. And I still can't get a job at Trader Joe's. You know, what, what the heck is going on here? And so I think that when people are in these modes of desperation, that taking advantage of the power that you hold and wield over them and the influence that you may have just in. Sorry to say this, Aaron, but like, you're marketing, right? Like, I know opened up a website, I don't even know you. I don't even know if you've ever done anything. And so how do we like, get people to take a moment to, you know, really work on the confidence of people who are trying, candidates who are trying to put themselves out there. And she know, I'm sure that you've had conversations with the lots of candidates that you present to great opportunities and roles that, you know, we already had imposter syndrome before. Now we have all of this going on and fear, I mean, fear is really something that's playing into this power play and these, and these new companies that, you know, middleman companies or whatever we want to call them, consult business consultants or whatever they might be. And again, I don't want to just bash on all of them because there are some true ones, wonderful coaching opportunity, etc.
- [13:01]
Chino
Etc. So, Gina, Yeah, no, I, you know, I put my hand up too, because, you know, it's funny, I obviously rebranded a year ago. So on paper it looks like I've been there for you, but I've been doing this for 13 years. I've built a rapport with people, but I've always been behind the scenes. And so I would say first thing to any candidate is one, do you trust this person? Do you know their background? Can you actually speak to some of the work that they've done? Right. A lot of recruiters, as you said, or a lot of coaches, their terms of success is, you know, their profitability. That doesn't mean anything to you as a candidate whatsoever? For me, and one of the metrics that we put forward is I got a 98.8% success rate in filling candidates. In my 13 years, I've only ever had to replace one person, and that was on my team due to Covid. Ever. Right. Unheard of numbers. Knock on wood. Hopefully it stays this way and I have referrals to back that up. If you were to look at my network and you talked work with me, that's backed up. So it's really important for candidates to do their due diligence on who they're working with. So, you know, I'm speaking recruitment recruiters, but a ton of coaches, even myself, who is on the other side of this, I too also get inundated with people and I look at that and I say I look at their credentials first. What is it that you're offering me? Are you sending a blanket, kind of spray it and pray kind of approach where you're not really knowing what I'm looking to get into. Are you just kind of hoping that I'm going to respond? You know, there's a ton of that and people get hooked on that because there is this desperation. And so the first step as a candidate is to do your due diligence on assessing who these whether it's a recruiter or a coach, is there are times that it is needed. Sometimes people do need a coach. Whether you're running a business and you have a business coach to help you kind of scale up with either AI or whatever's going on in the world or acting as leaders, great. That person should have a rap sheet. They should have, Hey, I have 98.8% success rate. Here's what I've done in my 13 years of time. If they can't talk to you about this and if they're just telling you, hey, I have this certificate, which again, a better leg up look at if it's accredited, sure, another leg up. But what have you actually done? Who have you actually helped? I don't care about your profitability as a business. I need to understand how often have you actually helped people with what I need. So that's step one, and I'm curious to kind of get both of your perspectives on the other side of this, of having reached out to people or having been reached out to those people, of kind of how has it been for you? And like, what have you experienced with that?
- [15:53]
ExpressVPN Announcer
You know when you see people with
- [15:54]
Host
phones with cracked screens and you think, whoops, they weren't careful?
- [15:58]
ExpressVPN Announcer
Well, that's something you can see on the outside. But what you can't see is how careful they're being with their online data. Because whenever someone goes online without ExpressVPN, it could mean trouble, like passwords and logins all out in the open. If a screen cracks, you can fix it, but once your personal data's out there, it's out there. You can protect your own data with ExpressVPN and feel great about it. ExpressVPN creates a secure, encrypted tunnel between your device and the Internet. You can use it on your phone, tablet and laptop at its lowest price ever, with plans starting at around 12 cents a day. It matters to me that your data is protected. I love fixing problems, and this one's easy to solve, and it's rated number one by top tech reviewers like CNET and the Verge. Secure your online data today by visiting visiting expressvpn.com fixed that's E-P-R-E-S-S V-com fixed to find out how you can get
- [16:49]
Host
up to four extra months.
- [16:50]
ExpressVPN Announcer
Expressvpn.com fixed ever notice how life's best
- [16:56]
Progressive Insurance Announcer
stories don't happen in your living room? They happen on the open road, out on the water or parked under the stars. At Progressive, they get that you want to focus on the experience, not worry about the what ifs. That's why they offer quality insurance designed for your ride and whether That's a boat, RV or motorcycle adventure with confidence. Visit progressive.com and see how easy it is to protect your favorite way to get away. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates not available in D.C. prices vary based on how you buy. Ever notice how life's best stories don't happen in your living room? They happen on the open road, out on the water or parked under the stars. At Progressive, they get that you want to focus on the experience, not worry about the what ifs. That's why they offer quality insurance designed for your ride, whether That's a boat, RV or motorcycle adventure with confidence. Visit progressive.com and see how easy it is to Protect your favorite way to get away. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates not available in D.C. prices vary based on how you buy.
- [17:59]
Host
Yeah, I'll take the bait sometimes just to have the conversation like I want to see what these companies are all about. And it's real like you know, you're talking about finding the right resources and you know, knowing you're on the right track and that's all, all super valid. And you know there was a study that was, that was talked about in BBC that it's the average American job search to find a replacement job takes six months. So we're sitting at a six month deficit of employment and the average, well, not average Wall Street Journal Talked about the $10,000 job search and that's not lost wages. That's the amount that candidates, potential candidates, wannabe candidates are at times putting into resources, companies, services that again claim maybe they do, maybe they don't claim to understand this market better, claim to have a shortcut, claim to have you know, a training program, claim to have whatever it is that's going to expedite cut, you know, take that six months down to six weeks or whatever their, their bold claim is. But again what gets me about it is it's the smoke and mirrors of we're successful. You know, they talk a good game. We're successful as a company, look at how we're doing, come be a part of or you know, by, by proxy, you're just by being around us that's going to be contribute to your success. You know, like when reality, who knows what they're doing? Like they may not have a direct conduit to a single company. They may be submitting. Yeah they may have an AI bot that submits your resume the same way that you would only only with their name on it. You know, so who really knows. But when you're sitting on a, you know, a six month or longer peer period without gainful employment and you want to be employed and you've been committing sunk costs and devoting resources into your own search. You know, people can get to the point of vulnerability and then someone comes along and talks a good game and says do you really believe in yourself? Are you worth investing in? Do you, do you care about your own future? Because we're successful. So. And there are hundreds of others here that have already believed in us. What, what's your problem?
- [20:26]
Melissa
Yeah, I don't like is like kind of the tricky fraudulent take on it too. Aaron, I'm sure you've seen this as well because as a fractional advisor, you get a lot of oh, join our fractional network or. Right, right, whatever. And I've had people reach out to me only to find out it's a franchise and they want you to pay 25k to create a executive coaching franchise. And I'm like, why would I do that? Like I do that on my own. I only 25, I need 25k from you, you know, that kind of thing. I'm not going to give you 25k to put your name on what I would be doing right. You know, and they're like, oh, we'll
- [21:14]
Chino
give you a playbook, you know, your favorite thing, you know.
- [21:17]
Melissa
And I'm like, I don't think I need a playbook. So to me, one of the things that I find really frustrating as well, and this is part, part and parcel to the whole, you know, power play here is when you look at like roles that are open Chino, so many of them look AI generated first of all, because every single bullet point is exactly the same for all the, for the entire job, including the required whatever experiences, et cetera. And I have found that really off putting. And, and then you see like 3,000 people have applied in the last 24 hours and it's like, give me a break. I actually just interviewed and it was interesting because the reason I actually even applied to the role was the job description was fantastic. It was a story about what they were looking for. It wasn't a job description. It was like, this is what we're building. This is what kind of person needs to come in. You need to be able to do this. It wasn't bullet points, it was like a big old narrative. It felt real. And so actually when I had this conversation the other day with the person, I just told them, I said can I just tell you wow on your job description and, and you're posting and they said, you know, within less than 24 hours in this high level role that, you know, they said they had over 250 applicants, they had to take it down. But he was very, he was enthusiastic about it. He's like, oh, I love that you actually recognize that. And I said, yeah. And, and not to say that things aren't that are posted on LinkedIn are, you know, fraudulent. But I do feel like that's the other thing is for somebody who's trying to get a job and try to be gainfully employed, it's so hard to read the room, right? It's so hard. And you just think like, well, this is a good company. It's in the Fortune 1000, you know. And so is this really a real role or is it not? I mean Chino, is there ways for your candidates to really look at that?
- [23:36]
Chino
So we talked about, first and foremost is looking at the credibility of whoever's reaching out, whether it's a coach or recruiter. And then the next part is figuring out what type of recruiter they are. So for me, for example, we are not the recruiters that you hire need to find you a job. Those recruiters are far and few between. And to be honest with you, in this given market scammy. I'd be very aware of anyone that's telling you, hey, if you pay me X amount of dollars, I'm going to find you a job by X kind. It's impossible because there needs to be a role. So unless they're hiring you, very hard to make that promise. So that's a huge red flag for anyone making these promises. For coaches, again, looking at their credibility, looking at what it is that you need. So if say you're, you know, you're meeting with people and you know the next stage in your career is to do more on the leadership aspect, right. Maybe you've kind of had not direct reports where you know you're approving their time off but you've mentored folks but you just need a little bit of help on kind of the people management managing up as a leader and kind of what it is when you're in those rooms and understanding that to get you up to speed, great, you figure out exactly what you need. Go find a coach to do that for you. I think it's a lot easier if you really need someone if you're saying, hey, I'm really desperate, I want to have someone to help flip it around and find someone versus having them come to you. Because the reality is there's a lot of AI slop and fake reach outs which is a challenge. So that's the one side, right? So someone promising you X, Y and Z, probably not real. Then there's the other side where it's me and it's, I get the same. I had the had spoke to a candidate this morning, same feedback. And what has always stood out for me is I'm a real person. I talk to people like real people. But there are times when I'm working with clients, huge big brands where it's under an NDA. And so when I'm reaching out, I can't necessarily tell you exactly who it is via email because this brand is, you know, doing this super confidential project. They've hired me to find them specific people that they can't do internally because it's less confidential. And so I always joke, take the call and hear what a recruiter has to say because it's real, then assess if it's actually real. Because there was one instance where you can check my LinkedIn, the person actually posted about it and who the client was, which is a huge travel brand for an agency. But when I had reached out to somebody else, they said, you know, this client doesn't have this role on their website. And I was like, no, they, they don't. That's why I'm here. I'm actually here to help them find. And this person was great. And they missed out. And it wasn't until like two weeks ago when they saw the person that we actually hired post and say, oh, my goodness, this is actually real. And I was like, yes, I'm real. I almost always tell people, this is real. Let's have a conversation. And I'm happy to talk more about it there. So it's hard because when you have real roles like I do, but when I'm reaching out, people then are hesitant because of all this loft and all of the fake jobs that are out there. So, you know, credibility, figuring out what type of recruiter or coach that it is, then the next is, what are they actually working on? Right. And I'm very candid with candidates about what's real. I might say, hey, this is the specific search I'm working on right now. I'm working on two or three of these with this company and this company. That's it. I do work with others, but I am not at this moment. And I think if a recruiter can't tell you exactly what it is and like, you're not having an interview within a week with this actual company, it's fake. It's unfortunately fake and they're wasting your time. So it's being able to assess that and there's a bit of trust because I, again, good after here, can't always share exactly what it is. And so it's being able to read between the line. But to your point, Melissa, the messaging, I've never had a no. And the only other time is someone was kicking themselves in the foot because, like, this felt real, but I just didn't hear the name of it. I'm like, it's because I can't. And so understanding that aspect too, when companies are hiring me, it's because obviously there's a huge Market. It's something special. It's something probably NDA. And so there's a bit of trust that you have to understand, but how they speak to you is. The fourth part is what's important there.
- [28:19]
ExpressVPN Announcer
Going online without ExpressVPN is like driving without a seatbelt. You might be careful, but if something risky happens, wouldn't you want to feel more secure? Well, every time you connect to public WI fi, it's like you're not wearing a seatbelt because your data is vulnerable and valuable, like your logins and credit cards. People want them. And learning how to steal your data is easy. But guess what? So's protecting it. ExpressVPN creates a secure, encrypted tunnel between your device and the Internet. Whether you're on a phone, a laptop or tablet, you can rest easy wherever you go. And when I say easy, I mean easy. You open the app, click a button, and that's it. Look, hackers gotta hack, but it's important to me that you don't fall victim to them. This one's obvious. If you could protect your data anywhere you go for about 12 cents a
- [29:02]
Host
day, why wouldn't you?
- [29:04]
ExpressVPN Announcer
So buckle up and secure your online data today by visiting expressvpn.com fixed that's expresvpn.com fixed to find out how you can get up to four extra months. ExpressVPN.
- [29:20]
Melissa
Well, you've almost given us like the BS checklist. Right? Like it. You know, because if you have ever dealt with an executive recruiter like yourself, Chino, you understand the NDA component of it, but then you can go back and look at the. Validate the actual. Whoever it might be, the firm.
- [29:41]
Chino
Right.
- [29:41]
Melissa
So like cappuccino, Right. You. You can validate that. I love what you were talking about earlier too, with the data. Like, we live in a time of data. And you shared your data, you shared, you know, your placement rate, you shared the referrals, you shared all the. Yep. All that information. Time to fill. Like you, you know, when you can share expectations, especially like some of these roles that are maybe at a higher level, they may take a couple months in order for you to get through the gauntlet of interviews. Right. So I think that there is, you know, like a kind of like this. What's the BS monitor of that? I've had some folks reach out to me directly on LinkedIn and I immediately go and check their profile. Who are they working for? Are they actually working for? And how long have they been working for the company that they are representing? If if it's the, the company specifically that has an opening or if it's a recruiting firm or whatever. And there are some, you know, there's some old time recruiter recruiting firms that everybody kind of knows their names in your industry and you should really investigate those and make sure you understand like are these people actually working for them? Right. But I do think, you know, like if anything, if it feels too good to be true.
- [31:07]
Chino
Right. It probably is.
- [31:10]
Melissa
And I think that's where we talk about Aaron again, that power play of like when you're in, in desperation mode, you're you, you take whatever life ring is being thrown at you. Kind of.
- [31:22]
Host
Yeah. And you don't always believe what's real either.
- [31:25]
Chino
Right.
- [31:26]
Host
You know, you're incredibly talented and great at what you do and you know, the, in the same week that I, that I would get approached with an actual recruiting opportunity from a recruiter that's looked at my background and understands what I do, which is kind of nuanced. You know, I'm, I'm multifunctional and I, and I cross departments and I work inside the organization and outside. So you kind of, you know, from a marketing perspective, you kind of have to understand that about me as opposed to a plug and play engineer 2 to engineer 3 role, you know, but that it happens. But in the same week I've also got one of those companies that says we'll represent you as a candidate and it's here's a monthly fee up front. There's a six month commitment and it's a percentage of anything you book through us or elsewhere.
- [32:15]
Melissa
No.
- [32:16]
Host
And an email that says, you know, you want, you want to stay with clients, we'll get you, we're going to send out. I've had this multiple times. A million emails on your behalf. No, I mean think about.
- [32:26]
Chino
No.
- [32:28]
Host
A million, you know, play the percentage game. What would I do with a percentage of a million? You know, prospects responded to me.
- [32:38]
Chino
What's the quality of that? Not great. And again like to your point, sorry to cut you off, Aaron, but excitement was like, no, like anyone that's asking you to pay for something, it's, it's real. And so it's not real. Like there's no way in this market to do that. Like it's, it's, it's not maybe 30 years ago, this is even like I've been doing this for 13, 14 years now. Right. I've been in the game for a long time behind the scenes. But, and again, going back to that point, Melissa and Erin, asking your network who this is, like, no one will know. Like, if you're just a layman person, you might not know who I am, but if you actually work in the back of those rooms, when I'm working with these big agencies, we've stopped posting. I actually made a post last year. We've stopped posting our roles because we get inundated. So to be frank, as person who was like, I didn't really know you were real, because I don't really know. And then having actually spoke to someone, they said, oh, my God, Gina, respond to her message immediately. They're like, ah, too late. It was a real job. So you can also just go back on kind of what their presence is. Because as much as I'm giving you the BS barometer, I would probably hit a flag kind of if you don't know me or if you don't do your research onto who I am and where I've been and kind of looking at the credibility there, Right? So, you know, there is a part of that, and I think there was a joke a few years ago where someone posted on LinkedIn, you know, have you ever looked at all of the archived messages that you just. That didn't come to your outbox that looked like spam? And I'm like, oh, man, I could have been working at the head of Google or X, Y and Z if I had only just looked at this, you know, whatever the company would be, because it didn't feel real. So I didn't respond to it. But they were actually real roles at the end of it. So there is a part for having the conversation. It's important to have this conversation because you don't actually know what is real. Have the barometer up and a real recruiter will tell you. And I had to do that with two, literally two people who said, oh, thank you, thank you. Okay. Just even having this dialogue with you, I know this is real. And again, here's what it is again, behind the scenes. It's not posted anywhere. But here's the meeting, or here's where I'm thinking about. Or here, have us think about this. It's up to you, right? And I'm not going to charge you for that because that's not what I do. That's the company's paying me to find them very specific people. But it is important to just ask, like, know who you're. There are industry recruiters that are there who've been there. Do your research.
- [35:13]
Host
That's so interesting, you know, because in a normal Market. You know, you get approached by recruiters. It happens, and you evaluate. You know, maybe you. You want to move forward, maybe they want to move forward. Maybe you go through the process, maybe you hired, maybe you don't, but that happens. You know, it's just part of the course of a work week or, you know, every so often, depending on your specialization. But isn't it. It's so interesting. Isn't that a sign of the market we're in that there's skepticism and distrust? Because we're. We're all worn down by these parasites and these other. You know, there's just so much noise from these other companies that have sprung up that, that claim to know different, claim to know better. Probably a lot of people on the, you know, in the, in the. Looking for an opportunity have been burned maybe once, maybe twice, maybe three times, because they're just looking for the hope that the hope is still there. They're looking for the, The. The company or the resource or the, the sage advice that's going to guide them through. There's these very turbulent times. So something real comes up. I just find it really fascinating that our, Our. Our reflex is to just question everything,
- [36:22]
Chino
you know, as you should. And yeah, it's. We're desensitized. We're absolutely desensitized. I've been on record for, like, I think I've straddled my career. I was like a recruiter that hated recruiters, kind of joke about that all the time. One of my clients have said that because there's different ways to approach it, and I think people forgot. And sure, AI is here. You can kind of. I don't even use AI to screen people because so many people get left out. And we've had podcasts, and I'm sure we'll talk about episodes about this as well. But a good recruiter will be candid with you, and I can tell you, hey, this is what's happening. A no update. Update is important. Sometimes I'm waiting on the client. He was waiting on what's happening. And you know what? Maybe because of the political climate, their clients are waiting, which is what's happening. It was all. All uncertainty with a few in certain markets. Right. And so I think it's important to understand that a good recruiter, a great. A good recruiter will, you know, maybe keep you up to date. A great recruiter will be real with you and will have those conversations with you of this is when you should hear from me or what I'm expecting. Right. And I always Tell my candidates, listen, you don't hear back from me by next Wednesday, please nudge me. I'm not ghosting you. I might be talking to 10 other people for other roles or whatever the case may be, but that's not what we do over here. I am speaking to you because I care. And what's very interesting now in Ontario to combat that because there were a lot of bad actors in Canada taking advantage of the immigration force coming here. And so what they have done in Ontario is set up a recruitment license where as a recruiter I need to pay the government to be able to function as a recruiter to combat all of the shitty recruiters and coaches out there who were scamming people. This is now the law in Ontario. I had to, you know, put my money down and tell them, hey, this is how I am. And hey, I actually only work on full time roles where people pay me to find, you know, it's not temp and it's become such a problem that it's now become legal process. It's not just an Ontario something that it's going to continue to, you'll see because of this very problem. But the fix here is hoping that anyone listening that's a candidate is to understand what their BS monitor is. And it's okay that you have your backs up, take a conversation, you never really know what's on the other end because again, if you do see a chino or like cappuccino in your inbox, it is real. I don't work on fake rolls. I can give you that guarantee here.
- [39:06]
Melissa
I love your perspective, Chino. I love your perspective sharing and thank you for sharing so clearly your, you know, your point of view. I think one of the things that I do want to get back to though is Aaron, is this middleman and the power struggle. And the reason I say that is I feel blessed. I've worked my whole life, I've worked very hard to be where I'm at. So I am able to have relationships with headhunters and executive recruiters. Right, Like a Chino. Aaron, I'm sure you the same. So this is something that we can navigate, you know, like we understand that, like, yeah, I don't pay a headhunter. They pay, they pay, they pay the company to find the right candidate to fill that role. Right, we understand that's how that works because I've hired headhunters for me personally to help me fill roles that I had on my teams. But for the people that are, you know, the vast amount of workforce that has been laid off today. That's where I think they're gullible to the idea of these middleman types of things, because they, they're not used to having a headhunter coming at them and saying they're not used to having, like, cappuccino in their inbox. Let's just get real. They're used to, okay, I, I file for unemployment. I'm, you know, on LinkedIn. I'm on.
- [40:30]
Chino
Indeed.
- [40:30]
Melissa
I'm on, you know, built in. I'm on all ladders. I'm on all the things. Trying to apply. I'm applying a hundred jobs a day, and I'm hearing from two. And then I'm getting in my LinkedIn box because I have the green banner up. I'm getting all these ideas of, like, if you give us 10k or if you give us 5k, we can get you in front of Google and Meta and all, you know, blah, blah, blah, blah. And you're like, wow, yeah, I want to. I want to.
- [41:02]
Chino
It's not. It is.
- [41:03]
Melissa
It's like, it's kind of like paying for pre check, you know, or clear. You're like, I'm trying to get to the front of the line because I know when I look at how many people have applied in the last 36 hours, it's over 500 in the front of the line.
- [41:19]
Host
So, yeah, because you look at LinkedIn or you look at Reddit or anywhere, and you see experiences of. I applied for 100. There was an article I was reading this morning. 100. 180 to 200 jobs. And then I stopped counting.
- [41:31]
Chino
Right.
- [41:32]
Host
And so you see that maybe that's your own personal experience, or you see that you wake up and you see someone else saying that on LinkedIn and you're, you're, you know, a week and a half into your, your job search. That's panic mode.
- [41:43]
Melissa
Yeah. And so I don't want to calm people's fears. I, I mean, because I think that fear is real. I mean, I've had it myself, you know, I think it's real, but it's how you navigate that so that you can protect yourself. Because think about, you're, you know, they're saying you're investing in you by giving them $5,000. But, like, if that $5,000 is going to help you live for the next three months, why would you give it to somebody on a promise?
- [42:15]
Chino
That's not real.
- [42:16]
Melissa
Right?
- [42:17]
Chino
It's not real. And so I can't. I literally, I like, the whole time Elizabeth's Been if anyone's listening, because I have been shaking my head, throwing up the X's because it is not real. That is not a thing.
- [42:27]
Melissa
No one is.
- [42:28]
Chino
You are. Okay, great. So you gave them, you know, $5,000. What about the other 10, other 20 other people that gave them $5,000? You're in front of Google for what? What is it that Google wants from me? That does not make any sense. So my whole thing being on the other side of this and like one of the few people who, you know, in Canada and the U.S. there's an allies and recruitment group that I'm a part of who have been combating this. We put something together for years talking about this. This has been a struggle the great recruiters have had to deal with. Right. There's so many bad actors. But in this market and any other market in the future, someone's promising you they're going to get you in front of this. You need to ask yourself why? What makes you different? You could be the best engineer in the world. Guess what? They probably are already hiring you. That you've probably had an interview with something that you can't get in the back of the seat. What you need to do, what people need to do. So great, you're going to get all these things and you're, you need to get a coach for something awesome. Do not let people come to you. Go to them. If you weren't aware of this and someone comes up again, explore, do your research, figure out the credibility is the first step. And if you actually feel like, hey, getting a bit of coaching here on how to present or you know what, I'm the fairly junior person, I'm intermediate, I don't really know how I'm trying to apply for senior roles. I need to help on that. Awesome. There are genuine great coaches out there. But again, you will know that from the credibility. You will know that from asking them, hey, can you give me a referral of people who actually work with you? Not just what they say, because you can say anything. How is anyone going to validate that? Right?
- [44:14]
Host
Right.
- [44:15]
Melissa
Yeah. And I love what you said because you've really opened up the doors to this is a real true fix in this, in today's market, you need to use your direct contacts, right. Your network. So, I mean, most all of us know someone who knows someone. If you don't know someone already that works at one of these companies, right. And or is part of an alumni group. Right. Whether it's, you know, a school network, et cetera, et cetera but direct outreach to a company, somebody that works there already or has worked there, is the most important networking that you can do because you can learn about, like, is this really an open role? Where are they in the process? Do you know the recruiter or talent manager? Do you know the hiring manager? Can you forward my resume to them? And. And would you be open to having coffee with me? Because I'd love to talk to you about what it's like to work there.
- [45:23]
Chino
Does not want to give it. That's not the advice. That's not the advice. That was the advice five years ago. Sorry, Melissa. Oh, advice five years ago. Yes, that's helpful. Right now, again, look at how many, like block laid off so many people. And now the people that are there, they're told, you cannot go and reach again for someone for a lot of places, Huge, big tech names. They would never know. They're working with me. They would never know. And that is so what you need to do, right? Yes. Do all of that. It's important. Talk to your network. That's the first thing you should always do, regardless. But there's a. When everyone is doing that, it becomes really hard for the people that are there and they. They stop responding. Right. If. If you've had a thousand people there.
- [46:07]
Melissa
Right.
- [46:08]
Chino
If there's 3,000 people, don't put your
- [46:09]
Melissa
burden on someone else.
- [46:10]
Chino
Right.
- [46:11]
Melissa
Yes.
- [46:11]
Chino
Reach out. And again, you should reach out. But the way to actually get in is to speak to the recruiters. Speak to not the HR people. It's the recruiters that are working behind the scenes. The problem is right now is there's a lot of people reaching out for this. I am not a recruiter that helps candidates find a role. I'm a recruiter that companies hire me to find them something great. That said, there are times, I have times in my calendar every week to speak to different candidates. Regardless, I try to make that time because that's what a great recruiter does. But understanding that there's things that are not going to ever be posted and you know who you want to talk to or have you think of your name first, you know, top of mind is that recruiter that's working behind the scenes. It's not the role that's posted. Yes, that's there. They usually have an internal team. But get to know who your recruiters are in that space. Try to understand, try to put yourself forward and keep yourself top of mind. Mind you, it is a lot. There's a lot of volume across the board. So there's Only so much we can do. But a great recruiter versus a good recruiter will tell you this is what my capacity is right now. I can't have this conversation this second because I'm not actively working on it. But I will think of you for this. Follow up with me in a month. I'll have something a little bit closer to this. They should be able to talk to you about what is actually going on with their rules. And sometimes that means not much, not much because of how the job market is. So there is that understanding. But if you can connect from that perspective, you're going to put yourself way ahead of anyone else that's just applying or only just looking at their network because their network is not a recruiter where we get the behind the scenes of everything for those that are doing it genuinely and that's right. That's the kind of harsh reality of where we are. Yeah, I, I think that's what I
- [48:14]
Melissa
meant is like there's that direct connection that I think is missing when you, and especially like as you know, Chino, because you, you're in the business. But like that's why a middleman or a middle business doesn't even make sense sense because they're not it, you know, they're, they're really not in direct contact with those recruiters. They're not sharing that type of relationship which you can develop on your own is what I think. Exactly.
- [48:42]
Chino
And, and you know. Exactly Melissa. And just I know I've like taken so much of the airspace because this is, this is my forte and like this is my whole expertise. But I have to say, you know, for us and as recruiter, like within my cappuccino, we don't just work with anybody because I think too the challenge with a lot of recruiters and coaches, as you said, if they're not actively in the role and are working with the hiring manager on a day to day, they might not know what's going on. So they might not know as much as you don't know. A great recruiter has completely buttoned down, knows the person, knows the team, can talk to you about the job, can talk to you about the timelines of the job. I have fired clients in this market because they are not partners. I have something in my contract that says you need to get back to me within a week of interviewing someone because I don't want to waste candidates time. That's the difference between a great recruiter and a good one. You need to make sure you do your due diligence. On who you are working with. The same goes to coaches. Who are they actually working with? What is that relationship like to you? Because people can say, oh, you know, I'm close with the founder. Are they. You'll know that really well from one conversation.
- [49:58]
Host
Yeah. If you. I love everything you're saying. If you run it through the logic test, you know, really how many respected corporations are signing exclusive deals with companies that are a year or two old and saying, yes, please be another cog in this. In this already complex system. Please be a gatekeeper. I love that you're charging candidates for the privilege of going through this process. Please profit off that. Like, is that. That's not a thing, right?
- [50:30]
Chino
Not a thing. No one is charging you, no matter how they proceed. Exactly. Like, it's again, like going back to like, you know, I've only set up my. See, I've been doing this for 13 years under myself, for a long time. I rebranded. So technically, I don't hit the more than two years because I just rebranded last year, but I've been doing this for 13 years, so there's that. But I will never. I'm never charging a candidate. That is not ever what I would do. I'm not wasting a candidate's time. I will fire a client if they are not thinking of the candidate experience in mind. And that is what a great recruiter is versus just a good one or a bad actor. And you will know that from the second you speak to them. So do your due diligence on who they are. Figure out what their relationship is with the team. Is this just a transactional? I don't do transact. I will say no to a role I don't do. There's a thousand recruiters. I only work exclusively. We've stopped putting our roles on LinkedIn. I stopped even posting on LinkedIn because I get inundated and it's impossible for me to do a great job with candidate experience in mind. There are not many recruiters that do this. I can literally name maybe 10 in the world. Figure out who you're working with, make sure they have something to back it up, ask around and understand their relationship to the client. There's never, ever, ever a time where a recruiter is charging you to. For you to be on their roster. That is insane. That is fraudulent. It's not. That's. It's a no. So hands up. Sorry for stealing the airspace, but it's a hard no for me.
- [52:13]
Host
No. And I, you know, I appreciate that. Canada at least is putting more guardrails around it. And it sounds like we're a step behind, you know, in. Because unfortunately, you know, there's. There's not a universal recruiter degree certification type of thing. So just like anyone who was let go yesterday can be a consultant. Anyone who decides they're in the recruiting space can be a recruiter. Right. Or start a directory of, of candidates that they charge for. Or there's. There's not, you know, really in Canada. There's. There is. There's increasingly. But you could be a wedding photographer tomorrow if you want to. You can go into marketing tomorrow. You can become a podcaster, let's face it, tomorrow, you know, um, so there's. But there's no. Not real oversight. So I think, you know, if we're a step behind, that just means that it's underway or there's something coming down where someone's got to take a good hard look at this, this labor market imbalance. Today's headline, which there'll be many more, you know, between that, between today and when this airs, is Morgan Stanley just shed 2500 jobs. So that's 2,500 candidates on the market. You know, you're not going to reach out to each one or have a moment for each one, unfortunately. But welcome to, you know, now they're consultants, now they're competing with one another. We used to be co workers, so, you know, we've got to figure out how to rewrite these rules of engagement and how do we realign some of the. The power imbalance and, and give candidates something to, you know, to fight for that's worth fighting for.
- [53:49]
Chino
Yeah, no, I agree. And just on that, like, there are good actors there and we have a collective of other recruiters like me who are trying to work on that. Exactly. On the US side and as well through the rest of Canada, because it's become a really big problem. And I think again, for companies as well, they're losing out on talent. When no one's responding or if it's, you know, a volume thing where you're getting a thousand applicants, they're not being able to see that. So you want to work with recruiters that make you also look good and have your brand shine through. Because again, it's not a good look. If you're working with a recruiter that just ghosts or doesn't respond or doesn't. Is not human and doesn't actually engage the top talent, like you said, Melissa, it was the message, it was how they approached. It was thoughtful. If you're working with A recruiter. Now, in this market, if they don't have candidate experience, top of mind. If you've not made a commitment to actually make sure that this recruiter is successful so that you're successful, you shouldn't be working with the recruiter, period. End of the story. Right? When we're talking about full term searches, full time searches with freelance again, you need to just do your assessment. Sometimes it is just a numbers game. It's a timing, it's availabilities. Keep putting your name out there in front of these recruiters and if you feel like you need to be coached on something, great, figure out exactly what and you approach them. Right. Do your due diligence. Don't have. There's never a time you should be paying anybody at this stage unless it's something you specifically need and seek.
- [55:35]
Host
Okay, well, Chino, I'll start with you. We're going to fix this since you're actually putting measures into place to fix this and forming your own coalitions and things. So. All right, so take your credit card out. If you are looking, you are the one initiating. You're seeking to upskill. There's someone that has something valuable that you need to know. They have the reviews and expertise behind them, their voice, credible, verified, all those things. And let's disconnect it from the promise of employment, right? They're there to teach you something. They're there to give you a skill. Anyone who says, give me your money and we will, you know, I know this market better than you. I, I'm a CEO whisperer. I've got a shortcut. We, we're, you know, we're living the yacht life over here at our company because we, we have so many people like you run the other way. Right. And if you are, well, let's, we'll fix. But if, let's just say you're, you're three, you know, looking at the six month. For a lot of people, that's their experience and it could be even longer. You're three months in. Let's build this into our fix. But what do you do through, you know, three? You're doing all the things. You're three months in. You spent a little bit to get some outside expertise. You learned something, you're better off than you were. What do you do different? You're still hitting a wall.
- [57:07]
Chino
You speak to the recruiters in the room that you know and you try to figure out what's happening behind the scenes because there's a lot happening behind the scenes. And as much as we keep hearing these sensationalized, you know, news coverages of this person has laid off X amount of people and it's going to continue to happen. As we talked in the past episode, this is a trend, you know, what they don't talk about is how busy I've been because of all the companies that have been hiring. I don't post that anywhere. So you're not going to hear those stories. They're far and fewer in between, but they are there. Keep going, keep going, keep going. It does become a numbers game. But you know what helps? When you streamline those numbers and you figure out exactly what it is that you want to do and where you want to be and you target that. You got to look at it almost like, you know, I think taking a sales approach even to how you sell yourself to companies is really important. Partner with people you trust and that you know and have credibility and keep going. It will happen. There is hiring happening despite what you're hearing on the news?
- [58:15]
Host
Yeah, right. Well, they, they said that there's 55% fewer job cuts in February than there were before. So that's, you know, that. But that's partly because there were such dramatic job cuts that it's okay, good. Well, that's a good number, I guess. But, you know, I, I, I'm, I'm an eternal optimist. I think we'll see some economic reversals this over the course of this year. And so part of that, you know, you're saying patience is one as a candidate. Keep making yourself the best candidate you can be by upskilling, by pursuing resources yourself, by being the one to initiate those interactions and by vetting and validating and verifying the companies you trust and the resources you work with. And if you're a recruiter, obviously be one who cares about candidates. Be one that knows your stuff. Be ethical and don't pretend to be something you're not, that you have some, you know, secret handshake. Deal with a company that does, we all know, doesn't exist. Do away with the smoke and mirrors. Don't be a parasite. Especially don't take advantage of vulnerable. Vulnerable people that have, you know, are already beating themselves down for just being, you know, seeking employment in this market. Go, go away. I will keep having these conversations with you just because I find it amusing and I hope that maybe I retrain your behavior a little bit. Probably won't happen, but, you know, I'll have it out with anybody that is adamant that their own financial success and re fast track to revenue trajectory is an indicator that they're doing anything for anybody. They're not. So approach me. I will have those conversations, but I don't want to. I want you to go away. If we do all that, Chino, did we fix this situation?
- [60:07]
Chino
I think we have people candidacy to understand, you know, there is change happening. There are good actors here that are actually fighting for your experience. I do think based on all of the kind of tips and the playbook, as one may say, of how to kind of spot the BS is going to be important. That's on you. Don't let anybody take your money. That's hard earned. And if they're going to take your money, you need to know it's going to actually help you with whatever is next. And that means coaching and skilling up for things that you actually need, not what someone's putting in your mind. And great recruiters are out there. So do take the call and drill them if you need to and a great recruiter will be able to come back and, you know, give you that confidence to move forward. Otherwise, like those two candidates who I'm sure if you're listening, you know who you are. And we joke about it now because I reached out to get them to be like, oh, chinos in the inbox. There are like cappuccinos in the world. Not everybody's a bad actor. And just remember that too. Lean on the people that you know and trust.
- [61:14]
Host
Yeah, good. Okay. And if you hear from Chino, that's like gold. Like, pay attention to that.
- [61:19]
Melissa
Call me.
- [61:20]
Chino
Chino.
- [61:22]
Host
Melissa, did we fix this?
- [61:25]
Melissa
I think we did. And I think the biggest thing that we've, we've really uncovered here is you need to trust yourself. You know, the BS filter is your own.
- [61:37]
Chino
We, most of us know when it's
- [61:39]
Melissa
too good to be true, it's too good to be true. So use your own methods of due diligence because it matters. Do your research. It's a strategy for you to figure out how to get gainfully employed again. So do the things, do all the hard work. Create that network that you have. Let kind of go by the wayside. Figure out what are you passionate about. Get in those industry discussions and networks. There's a lot of free things that you can participate in. Lunch and learns. And there's a lot of like live feeds on LinkedIn and things like that in your industry. And start that networking, start those connections. Like Chino said, it's so important that it's direct and it's real and it's not, you know, based in fear. And so, you know, give yourself grace, but most importantly, trust yourself and trust that you know what's best for yourself. And, and then I think you will find those right opportunities, find those great partnerships and those advocates for you. But you've gotta be your best advocate yourself. So you really need to know and understand what your situation is. And it's okay to be scared.
- [62:55]
Host
Yeah, it's.
- [62:56]
Melissa
It's okay.
- [62:57]
Host
Yeah, I'm with you, Melissa. Well, that's going to do it for this episode of We Fixed It. You're welcome. To everyone out there navigating this crazy job market we've been talking about, trust your instincts and remember the right opportunities are out there and they don't involve intimidation or pressure. And they're probably not going to be ones you pay for. If you get approached by a service or company that offers to help and payment is involved, just stop and think about who's getting the better end of that deal. It's probably them. Melissa and Chino, I think we did some good here. Well done. Thank you to our new listeners, our devoted listeners, our fixaholics. If you enjoyed the conversation, please share it with someone else who needs to hear this. Chances are you know at least one person that is in this very situation that will benefit from this conversation. For everyone looking for their next we know it can be a journey. Just know that we are in your corner. We think you're awesome. Keep keeping on and we will see you next time.
- [63:55]
ExpressVPN Announcer
We hope you enjoyed this episode of We Fixed It. You're welcome.
- [63:58]
Host
We go into every episode somewhat cold and nothing.
- [64:01]
ExpressVPN Announcer
Everything we say should be construed as legal advice, financial advice, or anything that would get us in trouble. All trademarks, IP and brand elements remain property of their respective owners.
- [64:10]
American Airlines Business Program Announcer
With VRBOL's last minute deals, you can save over $50 on your spring getaway. So whether it's a mountain escape with
- [64:17]
Melissa
friends, a family week at the beach,
- [64:19]
American Airlines Business Program Announcer
or sightseeing in a new city, there's still time to get great discounts. Book your next day now $72 select homes only.
- [64:28]
Chino
It.