Transcript
Podcast Announcer (0:00)
You're listening to tip.
Stig Broderson (0:03)
In today's episode, I'm joined by my recurring guest and close friend, David Fagan for a conversation about indexing and the uncomfortable truth most investors never hear. We talk about why indexing works for the vast majority of people and how missing just a few percentage points in annual returns can quietly cost you years of your life. We also discuss what investors should really look for when evaluating track records, benchmarks, and the value provided by financial advisors, and sometimes the lack thereof. In this episode, as you also hear, we cover asset allocation, rebalancing, and what it really means to be the overseer of your investments, even when you trust someone else to manage them. And finally, the conversation goes beyond investing into expectations, behavior, and leadership. We discuss how simplicity and consistency compound over time, both in markets and in life.
Podcast Announcer (1:02)
Since 2014 and through more than 190 million downloads, we break down the principles of value investing and sit down with some of the world's best asset managers. We uncover potential opportunities in the market and explore the intersection between money, happiness, and the art of living a good life. This show is not investment advice. It's intended for informational and entertainment purposes only. All opinions expressed by hosts and guests are solely their own, and they may have investments in the securities discussed. Now for your host, Stig Broderson.
Stig Broderson (1:44)
You're listening to the Investors Podcast. I'm your host, Stig Broderson, and I am here today with my friend David Fagan. David, how are you today?
David Fagan (1:52)
Yeah, I'm doing great, Stig. Thank you very much for the invite. I'm really looking forward to this.
Stig Broderson (1:57)
Well, David, thank you for making time. And let's just jump right into the first topic here. Today we're going to talk about why we should index. So with that very cold start, I'm just going to throw it over to you. David.
David Fagan (2:10)
No, that's lovely. Yeah, I wanted to talk about indexing and how I use that with our family's wealth and do a bit of a deep dive of the thinking behind it. I know many of the listeners come here for value investing, concentrated portfolios, and understanding individual businesses. So this episode might not be directly for you, but it might be for someone that you're connected to. I've shared my indexing memo titled Compounding Simplicity with more than a few of our Mastermind community members. And it's something that they've passed along to their friends, their family members, and anyone just starting out who needs a reliable framework to start building wealth. So today I want to encourage you to listen to see if this resonates with you or anyone that you're connected with, like a friend or family member, to set them up on a strategy that will teach them about the market, or the person who doesn't really want to pick stocks at all and just wants a simple plan that works. You know, sometimes there's accounts that are just too small to start out to do anything else in them. I mean, in Canada we have what's called a tax free savings account. And once you turn 18, you can put up to a maximum of $7,000 in it. And this is a prime example of something that you can do in an account like this. Starting out is, is indexing. And for a lot of people, maybe you have a small allocation of your investments in index funds as well and want to learn a bit more about it. So to jump right in, Stig, when someone like Warren Buffett says in his 2013 shareholder letter, My advice to my trustees of my state could not be more simple. Put 10% of cash in short term government bonds and 90% in a very low cost index like The S&P 500, I think that really deserves our attention. I mean, what is he really saying and telling the world when he says use index funds? And Stig, this conversation is worth having because indexing is one of the very few investment strategies that works for almost everyone, regardless of experience and financial background. So I guess before we go a bit deeper, let's just back up and do a quick overview of what an index is. I mean, there's countless resources out there on what it is. So I'll keep this really simple. I mean, an index fund or an ETF is just a basket of hundreds of companies packed into one low cost investment. So instead of trying to pick winners and outsmart the market, index funds track the entire market. And you own all the companies in that chosen index, such as the S&P 500 or in Canada, the TSX. And as those businesses grow, innovate and earn profits, the value of the basket rises with them. And so you're not just betting on any one company, you're actually buying the entire market to share a couple fun facts about the industry. I mean, even though there's roughly 50% of assets are now classified as passive, only about 23% are held in true index funds. In the US market and in Canada and Europe, it's around 12 and 13%. Index funds account for only 1% of the trading volume in the US so even though they own a quarter of the market, they're hardly trading. And I feel like that means active investors are still overwhelmingly driving price discovery. Only 17% of individual stocks beat the market over the last decade. And as the Best and Binder research report shows that only 4% of the stocks created all the net worth in the market going all the way back to 1930, it's a remarkable study for those that are not familiar with that. So a tiny number of superstar companies drive all the gains. And one of the reliable ways that you can ensure that you own those winners is to buy index funds. And lastly, it's. It's hard even for the pros to beat the market after fees and expenses. So in the US roughly 90% of large cap managers underperform the S&P 500. And in the last 15 years in Canada, it's even more dramatic. 98% of the Canadian equity managers failed to beat the S and P TSX index. And just as an FYI, I grabbed those scorecards from S and P Global using their Spiva reports that's on their website. And Stig, from my own anecdotal evidence, as an accountant preparing corporate tax returns and reviewing client portfolios for more than two decades, I can count on one hand how many times I've seen long term capital returns beat a simple blend of the TSX and the S and P. And this is even after fees and allocating some, taking into account some fixed income allocations, the compounding just isn't there for a lot of people. So yes, everyone wants to be Warren Buffett and compound at 20% for decades, but very few people live in that reality. And a lot of us are playing a different game. I mean, I think of investing for myself in three silos, real estate, public equity, and private equity in Canadian small businesses. And early in my career, I was very passive with my public investments. My focus was on saving money, minimizing taxes, and building wealth through entrepreneurship. And my wife and I, we have eight accounts for registered and four unregistered. And of course in Canada and many other places, there's RRSPs and TFSAs. And so it doesn't take a whole lot to have a whole bunch of different accounts. We index six of those eight accounts. And because most of our wealth has come from entrepreneurship, I don't need to chase home runs or swing for a 20% kegger in the public markets. My priority is just really staying financially independent, protecting what we've built. And indexing fits that reality for us. I mean, I do have the other two accounts that I spend a fair amount of time on, and that's where I run a concentrated portfolio. That's where I've personally chosen to challenge myself intellectually and, and do studying of, of different companies. But indexing is the core that gets us to where we need to go. And those accounts are, are indexed to ma maintain our financial independence. I mean, I often think of what Howard Marks talks about, about longevity and wealth creation and that superior investment returns isn't about ranking in the top 5% in any given year. It's about consistency and steady returns over long periods of times. I mean, he just told the story to William in their most recent podcast that early in his career he was reviewing investment returns for different funds and he saw a pension fund that never ranked above the 27th percentile or that same pension fund didn't rank below the 47th percentile yet after 14 years, guess what? They were in the, they were in the 4% overall on the ranking. And that's a remarkable observation early in his career that has stayed with him for 40 years, which is another remarkable piece to that story. I mean, the message is simple, avoid big losses and let consistency win. And for me, indexing is exactly that. Average market returns, but for a very long time. And I guess just to kind of finish a little bit on my early thinking of this, just to kind of zoom out and look at the macro reasons why I index and the rationale for that. In line with the Bessembinders research report, it's nice to know that you're owning all the winners because the winners drive most of the returns. It's good to apply Occam's razor when you can and understand that simplicity beats complexity. And that's a whole other tangent that we could go on in terms of what that means, because that can go into many different aspects of your life. Then there's the time paradox too. I mean, both time in the market and time that you save in your life. I mean, I spend a fair amount of time, and I know you do too, stay on a concentrated portfolio. But the reality for so many people is that they are not going to read investor presentations in 10Ks. And so you have to understand that there's a big commitment to time if you really want to get concentrated portfolio investing right? At least I think you should be dedicating a significant amount of time to it. Capitalism is very competitive. The other thing about indexing is the tax side. And tax minimization studies have shown that portfolio turnover alone can cost up to 2% of gross returns every year. There's lots of research reports that are out there that support that. So a 12% pre tax return can quickly become 9% after turnover and fees and the taxes. And you know, maybe the last thing about indexing is just fewer unforced errors or as Munger would say, just being less stupid. So you know, most people aren't going to have a 40 year relationship with any single fund manager anyways. You know, often people switch brokers and they trigger a ton of changes when that happens. So their taxes are significant in their portfolios and you're going to introduce grinds on your returns at some point. So indexing is a plan that you can stick to for a very long time. Like it's going to shield you from making decisions 20 years down the road and switching and and getting in and out of investments. And you know, it can also save you from a lot of the behavioral biases that so many people have in terms of herd mentality and FOMO and trying to time the market, all of that stuff. I you can it helps you ignore noise and focus on what can actually have a profound impact on your wealth, savings, discipline, tax efficiency and just simply good behavior in the markets.
