Podcast
Weird True Crime
Hosted by Gina Nichols and Amber Paul · EN
Weird True Crime is the ultimate podcast for fans of bizarre, lesser-known, and jaw-dropping true crime stories. Hosted by Gina Nichols and Amber Paul, these lifelong besties explore strange crimes that will leave you stunned. They dive into ethical, victim-focused storytelling with family interviews that bring humanity to the forefront of the narrative.
Every episode of Weird True Crime unravels mysterious cases, unsolved crimes, and shocking events you won’t believe are real. Need a lighter take? Tune in biweekly for WTF Wednesday, where Gina and Amber share hilarious stories of dumb criminals, true crime history, and other oddball crime tales guaranteed to make you laugh.
As part of the Weird True Crime family, you’ll join a growing community of "little skeletons" led by our quirky mascot, Billy the Skelly, who guides you through these wild and fascinating tales.
Whether searching for podcasts about true crime, strange cases, ethical storytelling, or even light-hearted crime stories, Weird True Crime offers a unique blend of heart, humor, and spine-tingling content.
Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast platform, and let Gina, Amber, and Billy take you on an unforgettable journey into the weirdest corners of crime.
Weird True Crime is a Fire Eyes Media LLC production.
Instagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrime
TikTok: www.tiktok.com/weirdtruecrime
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@WeirdTrueCrime
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/weirdtruecrime
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/weird-true-crime--5679751/support.
Every episode of Weird True Crime unravels mysterious cases, unsolved crimes, and shocking events you won’t believe are real. Need a lighter take? Tune in biweekly for WTF Wednesday, where Gina and Amber share hilarious stories of dumb criminals, true crime history, and other oddball crime tales guaranteed to make you laugh.
As part of the Weird True Crime family, you’ll join a growing community of "little skeletons" led by our quirky mascot, Billy the Skelly, who guides you through these wild and fascinating tales.
Whether searching for podcasts about true crime, strange cases, ethical storytelling, or even light-hearted crime stories, Weird True Crime offers a unique blend of heart, humor, and spine-tingling content.
Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast platform, and let Gina, Amber, and Billy take you on an unforgettable journey into the weirdest corners of crime.
Weird True Crime is a Fire Eyes Media LLC production.
Instagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrime
TikTok: www.tiktok.com/weirdtruecrime
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@WeirdTrueCrime
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/weirdtruecrime
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/weird-true-crime--5679751/support.
18episodes
Episodes
Newest firstAll episodes
What Melissa Left || Episode 5: May 28th
3d ago00:23:45Tap to summarizeIn Episode 5, Amber and Gina cover the discovery of Melissa Casias's remains in McGaffy Ridge, Carson National Forest on May 28th, 2026 — eleven months after she disappeared. They walk through what was found at the scene, the evidence concerns raised by the family's attorney, the forensic questions still being pursued, the suicide narrative and why the evidence pushes back on it, and the next steps in the civil investigation led by attorney David Adams of Parnall and Adams. Everything shared in this episode comes directly from official reports, documented evidence, and statements from Melissa's family and their legal team.If you have information about Melissa's case and have been unable to reach NMSP: Parnall & Adams New Mexico State Police: (505) 425-6771 Crime Stoppers (anonymous): (505) 843-STOP or text ABQCS to 738477Links & Resources Justice for Melissa Facebook Page Parnall & Adams Facebook Page GoFundMe Reward Fund📢 Follow & Subscribe: Subscribe on Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrime Website: www.weirdtruecrime.com Instagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrime TikTok: www.tiktok.com/weirdtruecrime YouTube: www.youtube.com/@weirdtruecrime Email: weirdtruecrime@gmail.com Music by @djantonyflower⭐ Leave a 5-star review if you enjoy the showProud Member of Fire Eyes Media LLCBecome a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/weird-true-crime--5679751/support.
Transcribe →What Melissa Left || Episode 4: The Call
3d ago00:23:43Tap to summarizeIn June 2025, Melissa Casias — a devoted mother, daughter, and sister — vanished from Taos, New Mexico, leaving everything she owned behind. Eleven months later, in May 2026, her remains were found in Carson National Forest. In this episode of Weird True Crime, hosts Amber and Gina reveal the new evidence that reframes everything: neighbors who reported Mark Casias asking about their security cameras in the days before Melissa disappeared, a woman's scream heard from the home at 1:45 p.m. on June 26th, the phone reset that happened within that same window, and presumptive-positive blood inside the house. You'll hear a recorded phone call in which Mark repeatedly insists he couldn't have hurt Melissa because he was at work — an alibi now called into question by a coworker who has formally told New Mexico State Police that Mark was not at work that day. Most disturbing of all is a witness account of a phone call allegedly placed by Mark on the day Melissa disappeared, and the questions surrounding a man named Ray Cortez. The episode also examines the documented failures in the NMSP investigation — turned-away federal help, ignored tip-line callers, and a family forced to do the investigative work themselves — and introduces the Mondragon family's new attorney, David Adams of Parnall & Adams. Every detail in this episode comes directly from official New Mexico State Police reports, documented evidence, recorded conversations, and statements from Melissa's family, their private investigator, and their attorney. If you have information about the disappearance and death of Melissa Casias in Taos, New Mexico, resources for coming forward are linked below.If you have information about Melissa's case and have been unable to reach NMSP: Parnall & Adams New Mexico State Police: (505) 425-6771 Crime Stoppers (anonymous): (505) 843-STOP or text ABQCS to 738477Links & Resources Justice for Melissa Facebook Page Parnall & Adams Facebook Page GoFundMe Reward Fund📢 Follow & Subscribe: Subscribe on Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrime Website: www.weirdtruecrime.com Instagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrime TikTok: www.tiktok.com/weirdtruecrime YouTube: www.youtube.com/@weirdtruecrime Email: weirdtruecrime@gmail.com Music by @djantonyflower⭐ Leave a 5-star review if you enjoy the showProud Member of Fire Eyes Media LLCBecome a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/weird-true-crime--5679751/support.
Transcribe →
WTF Wednesday: True Crime Chat with Dani After Dark
1w ago01:13:31Tap to summarizeWe’re mixing things up this week! Join us as we chat with Dani After Dark about all things true crime - what got us into podcasting, ethical storytelling, the cases that stick with us, and the most important question - what kind of pets do we have?!Gina and Amber talk about the importance of advocacy in true crime, what makes us stand out in such a large niche, and the cases that stick with us - like Ryan Waller and Melissa Casias. Make sure to subscribe to Dani on Youtube and follow her on socials! You can find all of her information below!Happy listening!Find Dani After Dark!YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@daniafterdarkInstagram at: dani_after_darkTikTok: dani.after.dark Email: thedaniafterdark@gmail.com📢 Follow & Subscribe: Subscribe on Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrime Website: www.weirdtruecrime.com Instagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrime TikTok: www.tiktok.com/weirdtruecrime YouTube: www.youtube.com/@weirdtruecrime Email: weirdtruecrime@gmail.com Music by @djantonyflower⭐ Leave a 5-star review if you enjoy the showProud Member of Fire Eyes Media LLCBecome a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/weird-true-crime--5679751/support.
Transcribe →
The Robert Fisher Case: A Family Murdered, A Father Gone
2w ago00:39:48Tap to summarizeOn the morning of April 10, 2001, a home in Scottsdale, Arizona exploded. Inside, investigators found the bodies of Mary Fisher, 38, and her two children — Brittney, 12, and Bobby, 10 — still in their beds. All three had been killed before the fire started. The father, Robert Fisher, was nowhere to be found. He has never been seen since.In this episode of Weird True Crime, Amber and Gina walk through the full story of the Fisher family — from Robert's childhood and the divorce that scarred him, to his controlling marriage, his obsession with keeping his family together at any cost, and the night everything collapsed. They also cover the two-decade manhunt, the tips that went nowhere, Robert's time on the FBI's Ten Most Wanted list, and where the case stands today.If you have information about Robert William Fisher, contact the FBI at tips.fbi.gov.📢 Follow & Subscribe: Subscribe on Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrime Website: www.weirdtruecrime.com Instagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrime TikTok: www.tiktok.com/weirdtruecrime YouTube: www.youtube.com/@weirdtruecrime Email: weirdtruecrime@gmail.com Music by @djantonyflower⭐ Leave a 5-star review if you enjoy the showProud Member of Fire Eyes Media LLCBecome a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/weird-true-crime--5679751/support.
Transcribe →WTF Wednesday: Florida Man Round Two!
4w ago00:42:52Tap to summarizeFlorida Man is back, and he brought friends. After our first Florida Man episode had you absolutely losing it, we knew it was only a matter of time before we had to revisit the Sunshine State's most unhinged residents. This week on WTF Wednesdays, Gina and Amber are bringing you ten brand new Florida Man (and one Florida Woman) stories that prove truth is always, always stranger than fiction. Buckle up, because the Questionable Decision Olympics have officially begun.📢 Follow & Subscribe:Subscribe on Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrimeWebsite: www.weirdtruecrime.comInstagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrimeTikTok: www.tiktok.com/weirdtruecrimeYouTube: www.youtube.com/@weirdtruecrimeEmail: weirdtruecrime@gmail.comMusic by - @djantonyflower⭐ Leave a 5-star review if you enjoy the showProud Member of Fire Eyes Media LLCBecome a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/weird-true-crime--5679751/support.
Transcribe →
The Little Girl Who Vanished: HaLeigh Cummings || Part 2
Jun 1000:24:37Tap to summarizeDisclaimer: Gina tried to do something new with her audio set up and failed miserably. Please forgive her underwater sound this week. Part two of our deep dive into the HaLeigh Cummings case picks up where the investigation gets darker — and more complicated. Within days of HaLeigh's disappearance, Misty Croslin's story had already changed multiple times. She gave different versions to law enforcement and the media, failed every polygraph she took (despite publicly claiming otherwise), and investigators received tips suggesting she may not have even been in the home when HaLeigh went missing. By August 2009 — on what would have been HaLeigh's sixth birthday — authorities made it official: they did not believe a stranger had taken her. The physical evidence contradicted Misty's account, and she, they said, held the answers.In a bizarre turn, Ronald Cummings and Misty married in March 2009 — while searches for HaLeigh were still actively underway. By October, they had divorced. Both returned to drug use, which opened the door for investigators to run a sting operation. Over two months, an undercover detective purchased thousands of dollars in oxycodone and hydrocodone from Misty, Ronald, and three others. Misty was present at every single transaction. When all five were arrested in January 2010, investigators hoped the weight of the drug trafficking charges — minimums of 25 years — would finally shake loose the truth about HaLeigh.What followed was one of the most gut-wrenching moments in this case: a detailed, disturbing confession from Misty's brother Tommy about what happened to HaLeigh — followed by a three-day river search, a recovered concrete block, and then a full retraction. Tommy admitted he had made the entire story up. Misty was sentenced to 25 years. Ronald took a plea deal for 15. And HaLeigh has never been found. A retired state investigator went on record with his theory: the child accidentally ingested drugs and someone panicked and disposed of her body. We close this episode by bringing it back to HaLeigh herself — who she was, what she looked like, and how you can still help. If you have information about the HaLeigh Cummings disappearance, the Putnam County Sheriff's Office tip line is 1-888-277-8477. A $15,000 reward remains available.📢 Follow & Subscribe:Subscribe on Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrimeWebsite: www.weirdtruecrime.comInstagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrimeTikTok: www.tiktok.com/weirdtruecrimeYouTube: www.youtube.com/@weirdtruecrimeEmail: weirdtruecrime@gmail.comMusic by - @djantonyflower⭐ Leave a 5-star review if you enjoy the showProud Member of Fire Eyes Media LLCBecome a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/weird-true-crime--5679751/support.
Transcribe →
The Little Girl Who Vanished: HaLeigh Cummings || Part 1
Jun 1000:20:12Tap to summarizeDisclaimer: Gina tried to do something new with her audio set up and failed miserably. Please forgive her underwater sound this week. On February 10, 2009, five-year-old HaLeigh Ann-Marie Cummings vanished from her home in Satsuma, Florida — a small rural community along the St. Johns River in Putnam County. Her disappearance became one of the most heartbreaking and confounding missing child cases in Florida true crime history. In this episode of Weird True Crime, hosts Amber and Gina introduce us to HaLeigh: a curly-haired kindergartner at Browning Pearce Elementary School who loved nail polish, mac and cheese, and taking care of her baby brother. Her family called her "little mama." She was 39 pounds, five years old, and by every account, completely adored.We walk through the family background — the custody battle between her father Ronald Cummings and her mother Crystal Sheffield, the move to rural Satsuma, and the arrival of 17-year-old Misty Croslin, who had been living in the home and watching the children while Ronald worked second shift. On the night of February 9th into the early morning hours of February 10th, Ronald was at work. Misty was the only adult present. When Ronald came home at 3:25am, HaLeigh was gone. Within minutes, a 911 call went out — and within hours, investigators were already questioning whether the scene they found told the true story of what happened that night.This episode covers the initial search, the AMBER Alert, the FBI response, and the deeply troubling physical evidence: no forced entry, an undisturbed pile of laundry in front of the back door, HaLeigh's Hannah Montana shirt found in a place it shouldn't have been, and a crime scene that investigators would later describe as possibly staged. Misty Croslin's first account of the night begins to unravel almost immediately. If you're researching the HaLeigh Cummings case, Florida missing children cases, or true crime cold cases involving child disappearances, this is the episode to start with.📢 Follow & Subscribe:Subscribe on Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrimeWebsite: www.weirdtruecrime.comInstagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrimeTikTok: www.tiktok.com/weirdtruecrimeYouTube: www.youtube.com/@weirdtruecrimeEmail: weirdtruecrime@gmail.comMusic by - @djantonyflower⭐ Leave a 5-star review if you enjoy the showProud Member of Fire Eyes Media LLCBecome a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/weird-true-crime--5679751/support.
Transcribe →What Melissa Left || UPDATE & Family Statement
May 3100:00:59Tap to summarizeGBecome a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/weird-true-crime--5679751/support.
Transcribe →WTF Wednesday: Weird Facts!
May 2700:37:45Tap to summarizeWhat happens when two true crime podcasters dig through the random facts they've been mentally collecting for months? You get one of the most fascinating, surprising, and downright bizarre episodes we've ever recorded. This week on WTF Wednesdays, Gina and Amber are pulling ten wild true crime adjacent facts out of the depths of their brains and breaking them all down — and trust us, you're going to want to stick around for all of them.📢 Follow & Subscribe:Subscribe on Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrimeWebsite: www.weirdtruecrime.comInstagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrimeTikTok: www.tiktok.com/weirdtruecrimeYouTube: www.youtube.com/@weirdtruecrimeEmail: weirdtruecrime@gmail.comMusic by - @djantonyflower⭐ Leave a 5-star review if you enjoy the showProud Member of Fire Eyes Media LLCBecome a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/weird-true-crime--5679751/support.
Transcribe →
What Melissa Left: The Disappearance of Melissa Casias | Episode 3: Missing Pieces
May 2000:25:38Tap to summarizeMelissa Casias has been missing since June 26, 2025. In the final episode of this series, Gina and Amber pull back the lens — examining the full scope of the investigation failures, the documented patterns of abuse and financial control inside the Casias marriage, and the three possible scenarios for what happened to Melissa. They don't tell you what to think. But they lay out everything the evidence supports — and everything it doesn't.This is the episode where it all comes together.🚨 If You Have InformationNew Mexico State Police: (505) 425-6771 Crime Stoppers (anonymous): (505) 843-STOP | Text ABQCS to 738477Find Melissa Mondragon Casias on FacebookGoFundMe Reward FundSourcesNew Mexico State Police Report — on fileFBI: No-Body Homicide Cases — A Practical Approach (Special Agent Michael Yoder)Recorded Phone Calls provided by familyInterview Transcript with Trudy and JazminWeird True Crime is an independent true crime podcast. If this episode moved you, please share it — and share Melissa's face. The more people who know her story, the better the chance that someone comes forward.📢 Follow & Subscribe:Subscribe on Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrimeWebsite: www.weirdtruecrime.comInstagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrimeTikTok: www.tiktok.com/weirdtruecrimeYouTube: www.youtube.com/@weirdtruecrimeEmail: weirdtruecrime@gmail.comMusic by - @djantonyflower⭐ Leave a 5-star review if you enjoy the showProud Member of Fire Eyes Media LLCBecome a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/weird-true-crime--5679751/support.
Transcribe →