Podcast Summary: "Schizophrenia Took My Brother"
Podcast: We're All Insane
Host: Devorah Roloff
Guest: Kelly
Date: January 12, 2026
Episode Overview
In this deeply personal, raw episode, Kelly shares her family’s experience with her twin brother Brian’s diagnosis of schizoaffective disorder. She traces their story from an idyllic, tight-knit childhood through the tumultuous years of Brian’s illness, examining how mental health challenges rippled through her entire family. The episode explores stigma, frustration, heartbreak, resilience, and the difficult balance between caring for loved ones and maintaining one’s own mental well-being.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. Family Background and Childhood
- Kelly and Brian are twins, the youngest of five siblings; their parents divorced when they were babies ([00:29]).
- Childhood was largely happy, marked by a strong sibling bond—especially between the twins (“You wouldn’t really get me without him. So we did, like, everything together…” [01:24]).
- However, their older full brother, feeling left out, exhibited aggression and acted out, creating a sometimes tense home environment.
2. Relationship with Parents
- Kelly describes a good relationship with her dad, who provided fun escapes, but realized as an adult he never truly opened up about his own life ([04:03]).
- Early signs of introversion and undiscussed mental health challenges appear in the family history, with Kelly reflecting:
“I think that my family is full of mental health issues, illnesses, some that are just not spoken about…” – Kelly [07:45]
3. Personal Mental Health Struggles
- Kelly experienced anxiety and OCD symptoms from a young age, though these were not recognized as such at the time ([07:26], [13:37]).
- Kelly’s anxiety manifested as negative self-image even in elementary school: “I remember being little, like second grade, and thinking I was hideous. Like I didn’t want to look at mirrors.” – Kelly [12:51]
- She was socially withdrawn during adolescence, while Brian was popular and outgoing.
4. Early Signs of Brian’s Decline
- Senior year: Brian ceased caring about school, failed to graduate with Kelly, and showed extreme self-criticism, particularly in sports ([14:25]).
- He briefly tried college but soon dropped out. At this point, Kelly and Brian’s closeness diminished ([17:39]).
5. Family Trauma and Possible Triggers
- 2017: Family vacation included a violent, traumatic incident involving relatives, which seemed to profoundly affect Brian, leading him to isolate and shut down ([20:15]):
“That’s the first time I’ve ever seen him like that ... I do think that had an effect on him somehow.” – Kelly [20:43]
6. Losses and Onset of Brian’s Illness
- 2019: The family experienced three significant losses—uncle to alcoholism, eldest brother Michael to a drug overdose, and their family dog.
- Kelly noticed Brian was hit especially hard, becoming withdrawn and increasingly attached to weed ([38:24]).
7. COVID-19 Pandemic and Escalation
- Kelly’s own anxiety worsened during the pandemic ([43:24]).
- Brian’s behavior took a sudden turn: paranoia, belief that people were following him, and suspiciousness toward family began ([47:28]).
8. Acute Episodes and Hospitalization
- An argument with their father turned physical; police were called, leading to Brian’s first 72-hour psychiatric hold and an initial (mis)diagnosis with bipolar disorder ([50:10]).
- He refused to maintain medication regimens; delusions centered around inappropriate sexual accusations, primarily but not exclusively against their father, began to fracture the family ([52:04]-[58:57]).
- Kelly highlights the critical importance of achieving HIPAA release or power of attorney early in an adult family member’s treatment:
“Right away, get this release form… It all happened so fast and just so rapidly…” – Kelly [52:39]
9. Living with Schizoaffective Disorder
- Clarified:
“Schizoaffective is basically bipolar and schizophrenia as one ... he has manic depression and psychosis...” – Kelly [59:48] - Brian’s daily reality involves persistent delusions, even with medication. The family sees worse symptoms if he stops meds or continues smoking weed ([60:39], [62:54]).
10. Family Relationships and Caregiving Complexity
- The caregiving burden falls mainly to their father (with support from their mother), both monitoring medication and accommodating Brian’s needs ([61:54]).
- Brian is unable to maintain employment; his limited work (Uber Eats) funds his weed addiction ([64:44]).
- Sibling relationships are strained; Kelly’s relationship with Brian is distant due to trauma, while their other brother David tries to maintain some connection ([67:08]).
11. Complex Delusions and Social Impact
- Brian develops delusions about sexuality, both his own and others’, and grandiose beliefs of being a famous musician (Jeff Buckley).
- Kelly discusses difficult moments, including his false claims of relationships with women from their past, occasional inappropriate behaviors, and trouble distinguishing reality from imagination ([73:41], [87:51]).
- Traumatic episodes for Kelly include feeling threatened by Brian during active psychosis ([91:30]).
12. Criminal Justice System Failures
- Psychosis led to a minor traffic violation and eventual arrest. Brian was jailed, injured, and not provided appropriate mental health care—prompting conversation about the need for better police and justice system training ([97:19]-[101:56]).
13. Coping, Guilt, and Boundaries
- Kelly and her parents each cope differently; both parents have struggled with depression and breakdowns as a result of Brian’s illness ([104:38]).
- Joining support groups (NAMI, Family Caregiver Alliance) provided some relief, but eventually reactivating trauma led Kelly to limit participation ([107:00]).
- On the need for self-care: “It’s okay to let that go... It’s okay that we’re not always feeling happy when he’s around or that we do have these feelings… It’s just not possible right now with all that’s going on in my own life.” – Kelly [131:42]
14. Stigma, Empathy, and Moving Forward
- Kelly emphasizes the need for empathy towards those suffering from severe mental illness, urging others to see the person, not just the illness:
“It happened to Brian, who was least likely… He didn’t seem to have any anxiety or fears, but it happened to him.” – Kelly [136:03] - She relates her work as a behavioral therapist for autistic children to the patience and compassionate responses required for Brian and others with mental illness.
- The importance of setting personal boundaries and not feeling shame in doing so is highlighted repeatedly.
Memorable Quotes (with Timestamps)
- [07:45] “I think that my family is full of mental health issues, illnesses, some that are just not spoken about…”
- [12:51] “I remember being little, like second grade, and thinking I was hideous. Like I didn’t want to look at mirrors...”
- [20:43] “That’s the first time I’ve ever seen him like that ... I do think that had an effect on him somehow.”
- [38:24] “Now looking back on it, I see how Michael was a drug addict... It definitely hit Brian the most.”
- [52:39] “Right away, get this release form ... It all happened so fast and just so rapidly…”
- [59:48] “Schizoaffective is basically bipolar and schizophrenia as one ... he has manic depression and psychosis...”
- [61:22] “It is extremely hard to have a relationship right now with him. Even right now, he’s not in our reality. So having a conversation, things just don’t really make sense.”
- [87:51] “He started to believe he was like a famous rock singer ... Jeff Buckley ... And he also thinks that I’m not his sister…”
- [104:38] “My dad was just a complete wreck from all the accusations… I felt pretty alone. I felt like I had to be the one to stay strong…”
- [107:00] “You can’t help somebody who doesn’t want the help…”
- [131:42] “It’s okay to let that go ... to be up front with those feelings too.”
- [136:03] “It happened to Brian, who was least likely to have this diagnosis....I would hope people could refer back to this ... and think, like, that's somebody’s brother or son or family member and that they're struggling and just have more empathy.”
Timestamps for Important Segments
- 00:00—04:00: Introduction, family background, and childhood
- 07:26—14:21: Early signs of anxiety and OCD in Kelly; contrast with Brian’s demeanor
- 14:25—17:59: Brian’s struggles finishing high school, emerging withdrawal
- 18:07—21:15: Major family trauma during vacation – first signs of Brian’s psychological unraveling
- 38:24—46:48: Family loses and Brian’s slide into addiction; COVID pandemic amplifies everything
- 47:28—52:02: Onset of psychosis, hospitalization, medication non-compliance
- 58:57—62:54: Family fragmentation and struggle for care, boundaries, and understanding
- 83:12—91:30: Dangers for Kelly during Brian’s acute episodes
- 97:19—101:56: Jail incident; consequences of untreated severe mental illness in the criminal justice system
- 104:38—111:30: Family systems strain, therapy and support groups
- 118:19—127:56: Strategies for conversation with delusional loved ones, loss of close sibling bond, learning boundaries
- 131:19—140:10: Navigating guilt about “living your own life” and the importance of communication and balance
- 136:03—140:10: Combating stigma, empathy, and insights from her work as a behavioral therapist
Guest’s Takeaways & Advice
- On Support: Seek family support groups (e.g., NAMI); connect with others who understand.
- On Care: Obtain HIPAA release/power of attorney early, before illness progresses.
- For Families: Acknowledge the reality of delusions for the patient’s sake—don’t argue, but gently redirect.
- For Self-Care: It’s okay to set boundaries. You cannot save someone by sacrificing your own mental wellbeing; you have to live your life, too.
- On Empathy: Remember, people with severe mental illness are still people—approach with patience, care, and understanding.
Tone & Language
Throughout, Kelly’s tone is open, at times humorous, deeply vulnerable, and marked by a desire to reduce stigma. The episode is peppered with empathy, honesty, and realistic reflections on what it takes to navigate mental illness within a family.
This summary covers all the major topics, personal insights, and emotional truths discussed. For anyone facing similar experiences – or who wants to better understand families affected by severe mental illness – this episode is a powerful resource.
