Loading summary
Jane Coaston
Foreign
It's Monday, March 30th. I'm Jane Coston, and this is what a day. The show that doesn't see the issue, American Conservative Union Chairman Matt Schlapp. Here he is at the Conservative Political Action Conference on Friday.
Tom Homan
How many of you would like to see impeachment hearings? No, that was the wrong answer. We tried again. How many of you would like to see impeachment hearings?
Jane Coaston
No.
Tom Homan
Can someone bring some coffee out for the.
Jane Coaston
I don't think coffee is going to help. On today's show, Transportation Security Administration agents are finally set to be paid, but federal immigration officers are staying in airports to keep bringing down the vibes. And the Trump administration is reportedly planning a ground invasion of Iran, even though President Donald Trump insists we already won the war. But let's start with reproductive rights. It's been nearly four years since the Supreme Court's ruling in Dobbs v. Jackson. Women's Health Organization found that the Constitution does not protect the right to an abortion. The decision overturned Roe v. Wade and sent the issue back to the states. Since then, more than a dozen states have essentially banned abortion, while others have severely limited access to. But of course, some anti choice activists think that's not going nearly far enough. Back in February, two Tennessee Republican legislators had a terrible idea. What if women who had abortions could be charged with homicide of an unborn child? That would make them eligible for the death penalty under the state's criminal law statutes. Yes, the death penalty. Though when state Representative Jodi Barrett was asked about that provision by Nashville's News Channel 5, he made it clear that putting women to death for ending their pregnancy wasn't a real problem because it would be rare.
Tom Homan
Now, do I have to admit that the death penalty is a possibility? Sure. But since the death penalty was reinstated In Tennessee in 1977, there's been less than 200 people that have been sentenced to death and only 16 have been actually executed, none of them women.
Jane Coaston
Wow. I don't feel better at all. The bill mercifully failed on a House committee, but lawmakers in 10 other states have tried putting forth similar bills over the last two years. So to talk more about the state of abortion in America right now and how the GOP is trying to thread an impossible needle in legislating women's reproductive rights, I spoke to Shefali Luthra. She's the reproductive health reporter at the 19th Shefali, welcome back to what a Day.
Shefali Luthra
Thanks for having me.
Jane Coaston
It's been almost four years since the Supreme Court struck down Roe versus Wade. And a lot has happened since then. Obviously, the decision sent the issue of abortion back to the states, and a lot of states made some decisions. Where has it become difficult or even dangerous for women to seek abortion care?
Shefali Luthra
What I think is a really interesting facet of this question is that obviously if you live in states with abortion bans, and that's almost half the states in the country, and those range from near total to 6 week to 12 or a little bit later, it's very dangerous to get an abortion. It is illegal, right. If you live in, say, Texas or Oklahoma or Florida after six weeks of pregnancy. These quite meaningful states in terms of population. But what I've been thinking about a lot is it's more than just what state you live in. It can be down to where specifically in the state. And I think this is really striking to conceive of the fact that if you live in a state like Texas, like Florida, like Oklahoma, like all sorts of these more conservative states, your rights are less, your ability to get reproductive healthcare is limited. But also if you live in a community with law enforcement whose politics you may or may not know, that can make that even more dangerous.
Jane Coaston
Something I've been thinking a lot about is that for people who oppose abortion, there's been a new movement and you've done some writing about this for the abolishment of abortion writ large. So ending Roe vs Wade wasn't good enough for them. Ending. And in the last year, we have seen some pretty extreme bills that would either completely outlaw or criminalize abortion come up in red states. Like in February, Tennessee Republicans introduced a bill that would make women who have an abortion eligible for the death penalty because it would turn abortion to be a homicide. Now, thankfully, it failed. But what's going on here? Because you look at the polling on abortion and Americans kind of feel the way the Americans have felt about abortion for a long time, which is like they're largely supportive of legalized abortion. They may want some restrictions, but they don't want to abolish abortion. So why are we doing this?
Shefali Luthra
It's a really good question. And what it speaks to is this growing frustration and also schism within the anti abortion movement. Broadly, abortion opponents thought abortions would decline with the fall of Roe v. Wade. And that actually hasn't happened because people are resilient. They are finding ways to continue getting abortions even when they live in states with bans, whether they are traveling out of state or getting medication mailed to them. And so abortion opponents are thinking about this in different ways. And some of them say we need to target the drug manufacturers or the healthcare providers who are making abortions available to people living in states with bans. And some are saying if you are truly intellectually consistent in your position that abortion is murder, you need to treat it as such and go after everyone who is involved in the abortion, including the pregnant patient seeking healthcare. This is still very divisive amongst abortion opponents. And that's why those bills you referenced, they become more and more prominent every year. More states have them, but they haven't made meaningful progress. Even in deeply conservative states like Louisiana, like Texas, the mainstream anti abortion movement views this as a step too far. And I think the really important question to pay attention to is whether that remains the case or whether this repeated year after year end introduction of and almost normalization of these bills ultimately contributes to a bigger culture shift and leads to actual statutory change.
Jane Coaston
Here's my question, and it might be a big one. Do you think Republicans like the gop, do you think they want this kind of aggressive legislation?
Shefali Luthra
That's a very good question. And at the very least, the President does not. And he has made very clear that he does not want to engage with abortion policy, at least on the federal level right now, because it is unpopular. Voters do not largely support where the GOP is on abortion, on abortion law, on abortion restrictions. They like Roe v. Wade, they wish it were still all at the land. And in fact, a lot of people have become even more supportive of abortion rights having seen the consequences of these bans. So Republicans, many of them, know that this is not a good issue for them. But they're really in a difficult place because at the same time, they have relied on the anti abortion movement to for a very long time for their support and their political resources and capital. And so they're trying to walk this very fine line. How do we keep this important influential constituency in our corner without alienating the vast majority of the country? And they don't have an answer to that yet.
Jane Coaston
Right. And I think that goes to my next question. We do know that Republicans are trying to thread that needle by making it harder for women to get safe abortions. Missouri Republican Senator Josh Hawley introduced a bill earlier this month that would remove the FDA approval for mifepristone, which is one of the two drugs used for medicinal abortions in the U.S. what would it mean for abortion care if this bill is successful?
Shefali Luthra
It would be a very big deal. And I first want to be very clear at this point, a bill like this is not Passing. It does not have 60 votes in the Senate. It may not even have 50. For those aforementioned political calculation reasons, however, getting medication abortion is very important for how people end their pregnancies in this country. Most abortions are done with medication, and a growing share are done with medication provided in the mail, especially to people living in states with restrictions. This is a key way for people to keep getting abortions without having to travel, in some cases hundreds of miles, thousands of dollars of trips to get that health care. And that's why people like Senator Hawley have really zeroed in on this as an area of public priority. They view this as undercutting and in some ways fundamentally defeating the purpose of their abortion bans by helping people keep getting that medical care. I do think that this is going to be a really continued area of focus for abortion opponents, and they'll keep framing it as he has, in this more conventional language. They say we are protecting women. They are being targeted by unscrupulous doctors who are sending them these medications in unsafe conditions, and we need to make sure that they are having more proper care. And frankly, that's not true. The science is very clear. This is a safe drug to take at home. It is very effective. You can talk to your doctor on the phone, over video chat. As long as you have some kind of medical supervision, even if it is virtual remote, you will be fine for the most part. And if you have complications, which are again, very, very rare, there are clear protocols for dealing with that.
Jane Coaston
Some abortion critics have also spoken out against ivf, saying that any embryos that aren't viable for implantation and that are then discarded are basically being aborted. And that's something that's come up with the White House, where they briefly were talking about free ivf, but then they got yelled at by this group. You've written about a fertility movement that's being promoted by conservatives. Can you tell me what restorative reproductive medicine is?
Shefali Luthra
It's really interesting because when you talk to fertility specialists, they call restorative reproductive medicine repackaging a lot of what they already do. But conservatives will say we are trying to find the causes of infertility and treat those, rather than just forcing IVF upon people. And as anyone who's gone through this process knows, it's actually very difficult to get IVF in this country, and people go through many, many steps before they actually have that fertility regimen made available to them. But so a restorative reproductive medicine clinic, they will test you for endometriosis. They will Monitor your hormone levels. They will see what your progesterone looks like. All these other things that are part of typical preconception counseling. But they say if we focus on this and do as much testing as possible, we can find the cause of your infertility and treat it rather than providing you with this invasive, expensive, and they view as unethical medical regiments. I think what's really important about this as well is that a, it's very expensive and very time consuming, which can be difficult if you are right later in your biological fertile years and maybe don't have as much time or as much money to spend on these very prolonged tests. And also it doesn't factor in people who maybe have male factor infertility. And it really does not account at all for queer couples because, yeah, I
Jane Coaston
was about to say, like, I don't think they're thinking about me here.
Shefali Luthra
They certainly are not. They would say that you need a penis and a uterus and you need sperm and eggs to come together and anything else is maybe not. In fact, I've even had some of them say, not worthy of public subsidy, which I think is very revealing indeed.
Jane Coaston
It is revealing. And I think that this is another issue. And I'm curious when you report on this, where Republicans are trying to thread the needle between critics of ivf, some of whom even want to ban the procedure, and the fact that there are lots of Republicans, lots of conservatives, lots of people who would term themselves to be anti abortion conservatives who have used IVF and have seen that it is indeed an effective infertility treatment for many families who are struggling to get pregnant. Like, what do those conversations look like?
Shefali Luthra
There was a phrase that got used very, very often in the immediate weeks and months after the fall of Roe v. Wade. The dog that caught the car.
Jane Coaston
Right.
Shefali Luthra
That's kind of where we are. You've had the Republican Party embrace abortion restrictions in their fullness because it was a politically viable path for them and there were no consequences. But now in this post Dobbs landscape, you have to follow that very often to its intellectual end. It. If you view an embryo as life, then the argument against IVF makes a lot of sense. Right, because you do discard embryos. And so they are still in a very difficult spot of trying to figure out how do we reconcile what we know people want with this argument and this organization and institution we've embraced for so long. And yet again, they're kind of stuck in the middle. They don't have a good answer. And in fact, a lot of them are very frustrated that the President has come out saying that he supports ivf, even if he hasn't in fact done very much to bring down the costs.
Jane Coaston
Shefali, thank you so much for joining me.
Shefali Luthra
Thank you for having me.
Jane Coaston
That was my conversation with Shefali Luthra, reproductive health reporter at the 19th. We'll link to her work in the show. Notes Every time we report on abortion access, I get furious. And I know you do too, especially since reproductive rights don't get nearly enough coverage. If you support our show giving this issue the space it deserves, make sure to subscribe, leave a 5 star review on Spotify and Apple Podcasts, watch us on YouTube and share with your friends. More to come after some ads. This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. March includes international Women's Day, a moment to celebrate women's strength and progress while also recognizing how much they carry every day. But I know how easy it is for our emotional well being to be overlooked. BetterHelp wants to remind women how much they matter and that therapy offers a space for them to take care of themselves in the way they deserve. You play a massive role in your family and your community, but how are you dealing with that pressure? Therapy can help create balance in your life and give you what you need to set healthy boundaries. BetterHelp therapists work according to a strict code of conduct and are fully licensed in the US BetterHelp does the initial matching work for you so you can focus on your therapy goals. A short questionnaire helps identify your needs and preferences and their 12 years of experience in industry leading match fulfillment rate means they typically get it right the first time. If you aren't happy with your match, switch to a different therapist at any time from their tailored recommendations. Your emotional well being matters. Find support and feel lighter in therapy. Sign up and get 10% off@betterhelp.com wad that's betterhelp.com wad Wadaday is brought to you by Quince these days I'm all about quality over quantity, especially in my closet. If it's not well made and versatile, it's just not worth it to me. That's honestly why I love Quince. The fabrics feel elevated, the cuts are thoughtful and the pricing actually makes sense. Quince makes high quality wardrobe staples using premium fabrics like 100% European linen, 100% silk and organic cotton poplin. Lightweight cotton cashmere sweaters. Perfect for the changing seasons and can't miss seasonal colors and prints for spring. Versatile, well made pieces that make getting dressed simple. Quint's works directly with safe, ethical factories and cuts out the middlemen. You're not paying for brand markup or fancy retail stores, just quality clothing. I love my Quince sweaters, but I'm looking forward to adding some cotton tops for spring and I know Quince will have just what I need. Stop waiting to build the wardrobe you actually want. You don't need a closet full of options. You need pieces that work right now. Go to quince.com wad for free shipping and 365 day returns. That's a full year to wear it and love it. And you will now available in Canada too. Don't keep settling for clothes that don't last. Go to q U-I-N-E.com wad for free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.com wad
Erin Ryan
quick question. Are you politically engaged and spiritually exhausted
Jane Coaston
if you said yes to both? Welcome home. I'm Erin Ryan.
Erin Ryan
And I'm Alyssa Mastromonaco and we're the
Jane Coaston
hosts of Hysteria, the podcast for women who care about democracy, culture and not losing their minds in the process.
Erin Ryan
We break down the news, call out the nonsense and spotlight the women actually fighting back on Capitol Hill, in classrooms and everywhere. The stakes are high.
Jane Coaston
It's sharp, honest analysis featuring women's voices with humor and zero hand holding.
Erin Ryan
Listen to Hysteria wherever you get your podcasts and watch full episodes on YouTube.
Tom Homan
Get ready to rev those engines. The 2026 Les Schwab Classy Chassis Parade and Car show was back in East Wenatchee, WA. Kick things off Friday, May 1st at 6pm for the big parade plus the after party with live music. Then join us on Saturday, May 2nd at 10:00am at the Eastmont Community park for the car show. It's two days of classic cars, food, music and free family fun for everyone. For all the details, visit eastwanancheewa Go. We'll see you there.
Jane Coaston
Here's what else we're following today. Head of Lines
Tom Homan
if less TS agents come back, that means we'll keep more ISA agents there. The President has been clear he wants to secure those airports, especially as I said earlier, in an increased threat posture, we need to secure those airports. ICE is there to help our brothers and sisters in tsa. We'll be there as long as they need us until they get back to normal operations and feel like those airports are secure.
Jane Coaston
White House border czar Tom Homan, speaking on CBS's Face the Nation Sunday, threatened us all with a bad time keeping Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers in the airports until airports are normal again. What exactly does normal mean in airport Tom Homan On Friday, President Trump signed an executive action to pay Transportation Security Administration agents amid the ongoing Department of Homeland Security shutdown. Administration officials say that the money is coming from Trump's 2025 tax bill. This executive action, which the administration could have done at any point during the shutdown, came after the House and Senate passed tax two separate DHS funding bills on Friday. But GOP leaders were unable to agree on a bill to reopen the agency before leaving for recess. ICE workers were sent to airports by the federal government last week. The Trump administration says that's because hundreds of TSA workers have quit and many others have stopped going into work during the shutdown. And while Holman says ICE agents are needed to keep our airports secure, first hand accounts of agents standing around doing nothing tell a different story. Officials from Pakistan announced Sunday that they will hold diplomatic talks between the US And Iran, but Iran's parliament speaker called the talks a distraction from a potential U.S. ground invasion. U.S. officials who spoke with the Washington Post said the Trump administration is preparing for an invasion that could last several weeks. In a comment to the Post, White House Press Secretary Caroline Levitt said that the preparations do not mean that Trump has decided whether or not to invade Iran. There are currently more than 50,000 US troops in the Middle east, which the New York times reports is 10,000 more than usual. Perhaps in a possible sign of where the president is leaning, Trump posted on Truth Social Saturday, telling his followers to watch Fox News host Mark Levin's show that night. Levin then mocked people opposing a ground invasion.
Tom Homan
He said, no troops on the ground. I don't remember that in any campaign speech either. But why would we need troops on the ground? Well, there's a lot of reasons and we wouldn't need 300,000 of them.
Jane Coaston
Great point, Mark. Trump definitely said, I'm not going to start a war. But he never said no troops on the ground. You got us there. It is our strong hope that this
Shefali Luthra
mission is the start of an era where everyone, every person on Earth can
Jane Coaston
look at the moon and think of
Shefali Luthra
it as also a destination.
Jane Coaston
NASA astronaut Christina Koch spoke to reporters on Sunday as she and her fellow crewmates prepare to blast off on humanity's first trip to the moon in more than half a century. According to NASA, the Artemis 2 crew will venture on an approximately 10 day journey around the moon, testing out a new spacecraft and, quote, paving the way for future lunar surface missions. The astronauts are set to launch on Wednesday from the Kennedy Space center in Florida. But Artemis 2 commander Reid Wiseman tempered expectations during the press conference.
Tom Homan
Just to remind everyone, this is a test flight. This is the first time we're going to try this. This is the first time we're loading humans on board. And I will tell you, the four of us, we are right ready to go. The team is ready to go and the vehicle is ready to go. But not for one second do we have an expectation that we are going. We will go when this vehicle tells us it's ready and when the team is ready to go. So we, we might go out to the pad and we might have to try again a few more times and we are 100% ready for that.
Jane Coaston
If the vehicle tells you not to go, I say just don't go at all. Clearly the vehicle would like to stay here. Large crowds turned out to protest in cities around the world on Saturday, the latest in a series of no Kings protests organized in response to the second Trump administration. Organizers estimated that around 8 million people participated in the protests. Obviously, there's no shortage of issues to oppose when it comes to the Trump administration, but this weekend many protesters showed their resistance to the war in Iran. Anger over Trump's brutal immigration enforcement policies was also on full display. In Minneapolis, a huge crowd showed up at the State Capitol to send a message after the Trump administration deployed three thousands of ICE officers to Minnesota. Earlier this year, rock legend Bruce Springsteen headlined the Minneapolis protest.
Tom Homan
The power and the solidarity of the people of Minneapolis and of Minnesota was an inspiration to the entire country. Your strength and your commitment told us that this is still America.
Jane Coaston
Did you go to a no Kings rally this weekend? Tell us about your protest experience in the the comments and that's the news. Before we go, Empire City, the untold origin story of the NYPD is Crooked's award winning deep dive series into how the New York City Police Department became the largest police force in the world and why that history feels so relevant when you're scrolling stories about immigration crackdowns, federal deployments into major cities and communities facing racial profiling, Host Chenjerai Komanika traces how power was built, who it was built for, and what that origin story tells us about public safety today. Now he's taking the conversation even further. Join the virtual Empire City Podcast club from Crooked Ideas, kicking off tomorrow, March 31st. Together, you'll dig into the themes of the show, connect the dots, wrestle with big questions, and imagine what real safety could look like for all of us. Sign up@crookedideas.org EmpireCity that's all for today. If you like the show, make sure you subscribe. Leave a review do not ask me where 413,793 Kit Kat bars are and tell your friends to listen. And if you're into reading and not just about how I don't know anything about the 413,793 delicious and tasty kit Kat bar stolen from a tree truck heading from Italy to Poland and you can't prove otherwise like me. What a Day is also a nightly newsletter. Check it out and subscribe@cricket.com subscribe I'm Jane Coaston and I am perfectly innocent of any Kit Kat related crime as far as you know. Also, congratulations to the Michigan men's basketball team for making it to the Final Four. Go Blue. What a Day is a production of Crooked Media. It's recorded and mixed by Desmond Taylor. Our associate producer is Emily Foer. Our producer is Caitlin Plummer. Our video editor is Joseph Dutra. Our video producer is Johanna Case. We have production help today from Greg Walters, Matt Berg, and Ethan Oberman. Our senior producer is Erica Morrison and our senior vice president of news and politics as Adrienne Held. Our theme music is by Kyle Murdoch and Jordan Cantor. We had help today from the Associated Press. Our production staff is proudly unionized with the Writers Guild of America East.
Erin Ryan
Quick question. Are you politically engaged and spiritually exhausted
Jane Coaston
if you said yes to both? Welcome home. I'm Erin Ryan.
Erin Ryan
And I'm Alyssa Mastromonaco.
Jane Coaston
And we're the hosts of Hysteria, the podcast for women who care about democracy, culture, and not losing their minds in the process.
Erin Ryan
We break down the news, call out the nonsense, and spotlight the women actually fighting back on Capitol Hill, in classrooms and everywhere, the stakes are high.
Jane Coaston
It's sharp, honest analysis featuring women's voices with humor and zero hand holding.
Erin Ryan
Listen to Hysteria wherever you get your podcasts and watch full episodes on YouTube.
LifeLock Advertiser
It's tax season. And @LifeLock, we know you're tired of numbers, but here's a big one you need to hear. Billions. That's the amount of money and refunds the IRS has flagged for possible identity fraud. Now here's another big number. 100 million. That's how many data points LifeLock monitors every second. If your identity is stolen, we'll fix it. Guaranteed. One last big number. Save up to 40% your first year. Visit lifelock.com specialoffer for the threats you can't control. Terms apply.
Date: March 30, 2026
Host: Jane Coaston
Guest: Shefali Luthra (Reproductive health reporter, The 19th)
Main Theme:
A detailed exploration of the ongoing legislative and political battles over abortion access in the United States, nearly four years after the Dobbs decision overturned Roe v. Wade, with a special focus on emerging hardline anti-abortion measures and the Republican Party’s struggle with public opinion and internal divisions.
Jane Coaston opens by contextualizing the evolution of abortion rights in the U.S. post-Dobbs decision, highlighting recent extreme legislative attempts, and the persistent, complex push by anti-abortion activists. She interviews Shefali Luthra to unpack the nuanced and escalating battle over abortion access, including the push to criminalize abortion further, Republican internal conflicts, attacks on IVF, and the growing conservative interest in "restorative reproductive medicine."
[02:37–03:54]
"If you live in a state like Texas, like Florida, like Oklahoma, like all sorts of these more conservative states, your rights are less, your ability to get reproductive healthcare is limited. But also if you live in a community with law enforcement whose politics you may or may not know, that can make that even more dangerous."
[01:53–02:12], [03:54–06:13]
[06:13–07:47]
"Voters do not largely support where the GOP is on abortion, on abortion law, on abortion restrictions. ... So Republicans, many of them, know that this is not a good issue for them. But they're really in a difficult place because at the same time, they have relied on the anti abortion movement to for a very long time for their support and their political resources and capital."
[07:23–09:29]
"Most abortions are done with medication, and a growing share are done with medication provided in the mail, especially to people living in states with restrictions... That’s why people like Senator Hawley have really zeroed in on this as an area of public priority."
[09:29–12:09]
"They certainly are not [thinking about queer couples]. They would say that you need a penis and a uterus and you need sperm and eggs to come together and anything else is maybe not. In fact, I've even had some of them say, not worthy of public subsidy, which I think is very revealing indeed."
[12:09–13:08]
"There was a phrase that got used very, very often in the immediate weeks and months after the fall of Roe v. Wade. The dog that caught the car. That’s kind of where we are."
On the Death Penalty Bill:
"Wow. I don't feel better at all."
On the persistent cultural gap:
"... what it speaks to is this growing frustration and also schism within the anti abortion movement. Broadly, abortion opponents thought abortions would decline with the fall of Roe v. Wade. And that actually hasn't happened because people are resilient."
On what mainstream anti-abortion groups will accept:
"Even in deeply conservative states like Louisiana, like Texas, the mainstream anti abortion movement views this as a step too far."
On the narrative shift after Dobbs:
"Right."
On IVF rhetoric:
"... not worthy of public subsidy, which I think is very revealing indeed."
Jane Coaston's hosting blends informed outrage and dry humor with empathetic inquiry (e.g., "I don't feel better at all"). The conversation is candid, analytical, and grounded in both lived realities and policy nuance.
This episode gives a concise yet deeply informed overview of the current legislative climate post-Dobbs, focusing on the hardening of anti-abortion tactics, the resistance and resilience of abortion seekers, internal Republican turmoil, and the anti-IVF rhetoric gaining traction among conservatives. As the GOP struggles to balance its base and wider public opinion, the ground remains unsettled on both reproductive rights and the party’s political strategy.
For further exploration, listeners are directed to Shefali Luthra’s reporting at The 19th, linked in the show notes.
(End of content summary. Ad sections, non-content portions, and post-show promos omitted.)