Why Marjorie Taylor Greene Sounds Like A Democrat Lately

Summary

---

Podcast Summary: “Why Marjorie Taylor Greene Sounds Like A Democrat Lately”

Podcast: What A Day (Crooked Media)
Host: Jane Coaston
Guest: Annie Karni (Congressional Reporter, New York Times)
Release Date: October 15, 2025

---

Overview

This episode examines the recent—and surprising—political transformation of Georgia Republican Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene (MTG). Once infamous for championing conspiracy theories and aligning with the far right, Greene is now voicing positions on economic hardship, Gaza, and government transparency that sound strikingly similar to those of some progressive Democrats. Host Jane Coaston interviews New York Times congressional reporter Annie Karni to uncover the motivation behind Greene’s evolving rhetoric, what it signals for the Republican Party and the MAGA movement, and how much real-world impact these shifts may have.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Marjorie Taylor Greene’s Political Evolution

• Early Controversy and Extremism:

  • Greene entered Congress as a conspiracy theorist, doubting the Pentagon 9/11 attack and participating in white nationalist events.
  • [00:19] “When Greene entered Congress back in 2021, she did so as a conspiracy theorist who believed that the September 11th attack on the Pentagon was a hoax.” – Jane Coaston

• Recent Left-Sounding Critiques:

  • Lately, Greene has publicly criticized Trump’s handling of the economy, rising costs, and GOP inaction on health care.
  • She has labeled the situation in Gaza as “genocide” and sought to reduce U.S. defense support for Israel.
  • [01:25] Marjorie Taylor Greene (clip): “The job market is still extremely difficult. Wages have not gone up. Health insurance premiums are going to go up. Car insurance goes up every year. People's homeowners insurance goes up. Rent is going up. People, young people have no hope of buying a home.”
  • Even Democrats like House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries have given Greene kudos for some of these positions.

• Cynicism About The Shift:

  • Coaston suggests Greene’s evolution is less about genuine change and more a sign of a growing rift between Trump and the MAGA movement.

Interview With Annie Karni

(Starts at [02:48])

• Karni on Greene’s Independence:

  • Greene’s break from Trump is rooted in both political calculation and personal grudge—Trump didn’t endorse her during her first primary, giving her confidence to act independently.
  • [03:24] “She told the White House, quote, ‘you didn't get me elected. I do not work for you. I work for my district.’” – (quoting Greene)
  • [03:47] “She’s also willing to break with him for a few reasons. Some are really personal. She has never forgotten that in 2020, he did not endorse her in her primary. And that has given her a big chip on her shoulder.” – Annie Karni

• Changing Dynamics in MAGA:

  • Greene represents the “base,” not just Trump’s interests. There’s an emerging divide where being “MAGA” does not strictly mean loyalty to Trump.
  • [04:59] “MAGA and Donald Trump are not necessarily the same thing.” – Jane Coaston

• Surprising Policy Breaks:

  • Greene’s positions on Ukraine and Iran align with the old “America First” Trump, but her criticism of Israel and labeling of the Gaza crisis as “genocide” marks a significant right-wing shift.
  • She’s also pushing for more Epstein file disclosures, a topic that’s lost steam in Trump circles but remains a focus for her.
  • [05:37] “Palestine was a surprise. Having her say it's a genocide was sort of a moment... even on the right, there's a changing view of Israel.” – Annie Karni

• Tactics and Influence:

  • MTG operates solo; unlike Matt Gaetz, she doesn't bring along a loyal voting bloc. Her influence is issue-based, not rooted in coalition building.
  • She’s succeeded in drawing bipartisan attention, especially around government transparency (Epstein files).
  • [07:22] “Marjorie Taylor Greene is a party of one right now. She does not have a lot of allies. She's not building coalitions like that... So, no one else is following her lead. Although on the Epstein issue... four Republicans right now are signed onto this discharge petition with Democrats.”

• Limits of Her Power:

  • Despite her high profile, Greene’s impact is bounded by Congress’s current inactivity and her lack of leadership position.
  • [08:49] “You're asking a bigger question: what can one member of Congress do? Not much... Congress has just given over its power to the White House... I don’t know that she’s showing a path, but other than just saying that, I don’t know what power she has to stop that.” – Annie Karni

---

Memorable Quotes

• [04:01] Annie Karni (on the MAGA base):
  “She is where the puck is going. She is where the base is on these issues. They agree with her. She goes home to her district—there’s no pushback from voters for breaking with Trump here. They’re with her.”

• [06:39] Jane Coaston (on MAGA's allergy to disloyalty):
  “Trump, MAGA, House Speaker Johnson—they seem allergic to disloyalty or even questions that edge toward disloyalty. That doesn’t seem to have any result for Marjorie Taylor Greene. She hasn’t changed her mind, she isn’t being brought back into the fold by pressure…”

• [08:49] Annie Karni (on Congress’s dysfunction):
  “Congress has just given over its power to the White House. And I don't know that she's showing a path... But other than just saying that, I don't know what power she has to stop that. She's not in leadership.”

---

Timestamps for Important Segments

• 00:19 – Intro to MTG’s history and current “liberal” stances
• 01:25 – Audio clip: Greene criticizing the Trump economy
• 02:48 – Start of Annie Karni interview
• 03:24 – Discussion of Greene’s independence from Trump
• 05:37 – Surprising positions: Gaza and “genocide” language, GOP disunity
• 07:22 – MTG's lack of a coalition/followers in Congress
• 08:49 – Congress’s current weakness and MTG’s lack of real power

---

Additional Headlines Covered

• Trump threatens to withhold aid from Argentina if election outcomes displease him ([12:50], [13:34])
• Israeli-Palestinian ceasefire cracks: casualties and Israel limiting aid ([14:30])
• FBI’s James Comey wins early legal round against Trump DOJ ([15:47])
• Obama backs California Prop 50 redistricting in new ad ([17:42])

---

Episode Tone & Style

The discussion remains analytical, at times wry and skeptical, especially as Jane Coaston points out the ironies in MTG's rhetorical pivot and the broader dysfunction gripping Congress. Coaston ensures the conversation stays substantive, focused on what Greene’s “evolution” signifies for the GOP, the MAGA base, and American politics more broadly.

---

Conclusion

This episode of “What A Day” unpacks Marjorie Taylor Greene’s headline-generating shift towards positions traditionally associated with Democrats, providing listeners a nuanced look at what’s driving her evolution, what it means for the Republican Party, and why her actual influence may be overstated. Coaston and Karni’s analysis goes beyond surface-level political gossip, delving into the structural and personal dynamics that empower MTG to challenge Trump—and what that reveals about the unrest within the MAGA movement itself.

Transcript

[Jane Costen]

It's Wednesday, October 15th. I'm Jane Costen, and this is Whataday, the show celebrating that OpenAI has finally answered our biggest question about the biggest technological advance of our lifetime. When will AI get super horny? According to CEO Sam Altman, the answer for ChatGPT is now for, quote, verified adults by adding erotica. Because, as I've always said, wouldn't it be so great if the app that helps college students cheat on history tests also so sexted them? On today's show, Israel's fragile ceasefire shows cracks as nine Palestinians are killed in Gaza as of this recording. And Israel cuts humanitarian aid. And former President Barack Obama throws his weight behind an upcoming ballot measure to check Trump's power. But let's start with Georgia Republican Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene. When Greene entered Congress back in 2021, she did so as a conspiracy theorist who believed that the September 11th attack on the Pentagon was a hoax. And in 2022, she spoke at a far right political conference hosted by white nationalists, leading to calls for the GOP to disavow her entirely. But in 2025, Greene is sounding more like a liberal. Here she is discussing how Trump has not made the economy great again, like, at all. The job market is.

[Marjorie Taylor Greene (clip)]

The job market is still extremely difficult. Wages have not gone up. Health insurance premiums are going to go up. Car insurance goes up every year. People's homeowners insurance goes up. Rent is going up. People, young people have no hope of buying a home.

[Jane Costen]

That's from a recent episode of the Tim Dillon show, where Greene also went after the Trump administration over the Epstein files. She even railed against her fellow Republicans in Congress for the government shutdown, sexism, and for lacking any kind of a plan on healthcare. This is part of a trend for mtg. For example, in the last few months, she's referred to the horrors taking place in Gaza as a, quote, genocide, and offered an amendment to cut defense support to Israel. Since Greene has started sounding, well, sane, she's getting kudos from Democrats, including House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries. But this is still Marjorie Taylor Greene, the same person who thinks Bad Bunny is going to do demonic sexual performances at the Super Bowl. To me, Greene's sort of evolution is less a story of a politician finding the light and more about a widening rift between MAGA and the Orange man they helped put in the White House. So to talk more about Greene's political journey, I spoke to Annie Carney. She's a congressional reporter for the New York Times who profiled Greene in September. Annie Carney, welcome to what a Day.

[Annie Carney]

Thank you for having me, Jane.

[Jane Costen]

So you recently wrote a profile of Representative Taylor Greene, and you interviewed her at this weird moment. She was backing a bill that demanded the release of more Epstein files, and the White House wanted her to stand down. And you wrote that she told you that. She told the White House, quote, you didn't get me elected. I do not work for you. I work for my district. And this is such a weird moment, especially coming from this particular person who has backed Trump in insane claims of election fraud and apparently joked that if she had run the January 6 riots, she would have won. How are these the same people?

[Annie Carney]

It's a really, really fascinating moment to be covering Marjorie Taylor Greene. It's not just the Epstein files. She was the first Republican in Congress to call the situation in Gaza a genocide. AIPAC is now considering trying to mount a campaign against her, which is probably impossible in her district. She broke with Trump on Iran and Ukraine and his involvement in foreign wars. This isn't coming out of nowhere. Marjorie Taylor Greene should be viewed as a spokeswoman for the MAGA base. I have a quote in that story from Steve Bannon saying, like, she's where the puck is going. She is where the base is on these issues. They agree with her. She told me in that interview, she goes home to her district. There's no pushback from voters from breaking with Trump here. They're with her. So what it is really signifying is a interesting moment in the MAGA universe where there is a growing divide between Trump and the base. And Marjorie Taylor Greene, I think, really represents that divide. She's also willing to break with him for a few reasons. Some of them are really personal. She has never forgotten that in 2020, he did not endorse her in her primary. And that has given her a big chip on her shoulder, like, I got here without you. She kind of thinks she doesn't need the president. She's so associated with him, and she's so associated with being such a loyal MAGA warrior that she's not scared, like some of these other Republicans on the Hill are, of looking on, like, they're not with it or they're breaking with Trump.

[Jane Costen]

Yeah, it's interesting because I think that the point that you're drawing out and that she's drawing out is that MAGA and Donald Trump are not necessarily the same thing.

[Annie Carney]

Right.

[Jane Costen]

Like, one would think that, like, being super maga, being super whatever would be being the most sycophantic Trump supporter imaginable. But that appears to not be true in this case. But you've mentioned a couple of other policies or ideas that she's been pushing back on. What else is on the short list and what was most surprising to you that she's been breaking from the White House on?

[Annie Carney]

I'd say Ukraine and Iran are not surprising. That's the America First Trump that ran.

[Jane Costen]

Right.

[Annie Carney]

She thinks he's changed since she got into office and that he's acting like a more traditional Republican. So that is not surprising. The Epstein files, she kind of stayed the same. It's the president who moved on. That. I mean, that was an issue that was animating the base for a long time. Marjorie Taylor Greene just isn't willing to back down on that issue. Palestine was a surprise. Having her say it's a genocide was sort of a moment. And it shows. You know, there's obviously been a huge change in how Israel is viewed on the left. But to me, that was a statement that showed that even on the right, there's a changing view of Israel right now and of the situation there, that Marjorie Taylor Boone would call it a genocide right now on this shutdown fight, right? She's breaking hard with Speaker Johnson saying Republicans aren't talking about health care. They're wrong on healthcare, Prices are rising. People are upset. Republicans aren't addressing any of this and we should come back to Washington. And she's just completely breaking with the party line on why this shutdown is ongoing and occurring.

[Jane Costen]

It's interesting also because Trump, maga, House Speaker Johnson, they seem allergic to disloyalty or even questions that edge towards disloyalty. We've seen so many Republicans get kind of pushed out of Congress because Trump endorses their competitor or because they just get screamed at by all of the people who Trump listens to. That doesn't seem to be really happening or having any result for Marjorie Taylor Greene. Like, she hasn't changed her mind. She isn't being brought back into the fold by pressure. Like, what kind of impact is she actually having on other Republicans or other people who are her fellow travelers on any number of issues.

[Annie Carney]

She is not a person who brings along a group of lawmakers. Like Matt Gaetz was very good at that, at sort of building a coalition. That's how he managed to oust Kevin McCarthy. He tended to a small group of lawmakers who he made sure stuck together, and that gave him great power and influence because he had a group of seven to 10 members that he could control their votes. Marjorie Taylor Greene is a party of one right now she does not have a lot of allies. She's not building coalitions like that. So no one else is following her lead. Although on the Epstein issue she there's four Republicans right now who are signed onto this discharge petition with Democrats and won't move. That means that it is likely eventually going to come to the floor for a vote. So she is having an effect there. I mean, she's not caving.

[Jane Costen]

I'm curious because it does sound like she is exposing some differences between MAGA and the GOP writ large and MAGA and the White House, which is a weird thing to say in this time where it's like there's a difference between the two. But I can kind of see how that might work, especially for the America first out there. But for people who are listening to the show, who are likely Democratic voters, maybe independents, people who just don't like the policies out of this Republican controlled White House and Congress right now, what difference is she actually making?

[Annie Carney]

I mean, you're asking a bigger question like what can one member of Congress do? Not much. And what is Congress itself doing right now? Not much. They're not even here. Like it doesn't even exist right now. The House hasn't been in in three weeks and there's no sign that they're coming back anytime soon. The overarching story of this year is that Congress has just given over its power to the White House. And I don't know that she's showing a path of like, we can be Republicans and have a job, that we want our own power. But other than just saying that, I don't know what power she has to stop that. She's not in leadership.

[Jane Costen]

Annie Carney, thank you so much for joining me.

[Annie Carney]

Thank you for having me.

[Jane Costen]

That was my conversation with Annie Carney, Congressional Reporter for the New York Times. We'll link to her profile of Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene in the show notes. We'll get to more of the news in a moment, but if you like the show, make sure to subscribe. Leave a five star review on Apple Podcasts. Watch us on YouTube and share with your friends. More to come after some ads. This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. The right therapist can change everything and BetterHelp has 12 years of experience in matching people to the right therapist. BetterHelp therapists work according to a strict code of conduct and are fully licensed in the US and BetterHelp does the initial matching work for you so you can focus on your therapy goals. A short questionnaire helps identify your needs and preferences and their 10 plus years of experience in industry leading match fulfillment rate means that they typically get it right the first time. If you aren't happy with your match, switch to a different therapist at any time from their tailored recommendations. With over 30,000 therapists, BetterHelp is the world's largest online therapy platform, having served over 5 million people globally. And it works with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 for a live session based on over 1.7 million client reviews. This World Mental Health Day, we're celebrating the therapists who have helped millions of people take a step forward. If you're ready to find the right therapist for you, BetterHelp can help you start that journey. Our listeners get 10% off their first month at betterhelp.com wad that's BetterHelp H-E-L-P.com.

[Jerry]

Waad welcome back to Listen to youo Heart. I'm Jerry.

[Jerry's Heart]

And I'm Jerry's Heart.

[Jerry]

Today's Repatha Evolocumab Heart. Why'd you pick this one?

[Jerry's Heart]

Well, Jerry, for people who have had a heart attack like us, diet and exercise might not be enough to lower the risk of another one. Okay, to help know if we're at risk, we should be getting our ldlc, our bad cholesterol checked, and talking to our doctor.

[Jerry]

I'm listening.

[Jerry's Heart]

And if it's still too high, Repatha can be added to a statin to lower our LDL C and our heart attack risk.

[Jerry]

Hmm. Guess it's time to ask about Repatha.

[Repatha Medication Voice]

Do not take Repatha if you're allergic to it. Serious allergic reactions can occur. Get medical help right away if you have trouble breathing or swallowing, swelling of the face, lips, tongue, throat or arms. Common side effects include runny nose, sore throat, common cold symptoms, flu or flu like symptoms, back pain, high blood sugar and redness pain or bruising at the injection site.

[Jerry]

Listen to your heart.

[Jerry's Heart]

Ask your doctor about Repatha. Learn more at repatha.com or call 1-844-repatha.

[Chevy Equinox Advertisement Voice]

The 2026 Chevy Equinox is more than an SUV. It's your Sunday tailgate and your parking lot, snack bar. Your lucky jersey, your chairs and your big cooler fit perfectly in your even bigger cargo space. And when it's go time, your 11.3-inch diagonal touchscreen's got the playbook, the playlist, and the tech to stay a step ahead. It's more than an suv. It's your Equinox Chevrolet. Together, let's drive.

[Jane Costen]

Here'S what else we're following today. Header lines.

[Donald Trump]

If he loses, we are not going to be generous with Argentina.

[Jane Costen]

President Donald Trump is threatening to yank economic assistance for Argentina if midterm elections there don't go his way later this month. Trump made that known on Tuesday as he welcomed Argentine President Javier Milei to the White House. Politically, they're on the same page. And on the personal level, the Associated Press says the pair has entered a bromance. So of course, Trump's weighing in on Argentina's midterm legislative elections. That could be a referendum on his buddy Milei's policies. Note that Milei himself is not up for re election until 2027. But Trump couldn't resist threatening what he'd do if his pal loses.

[Donald Trump]

If the president doesn't win, I know the person that he'd be running against. I believe probably we probably have the person. A person is extremely far left and a philosophy that got Argentina into this problem in the first place. So we would not be generous with Argentina if that happened.

[Jane Costen]

Now you probably remember us talking last week about how Treasury Secretary Scott Besant promised Argentina a $20 billion currency swap to prop up the peso and replenish Argentina's foreign currency reserves. Even with his threats about jumping ship, Trump insisted that the non bailout bailout, which administration officials strenuously deny is a bailout. It's a bail what's about helping our neighbors rather than any ties to the upcoming midterms, make it make sense. Israeli forces killed at least nine Palestinians in Gaza on Tuesday, just a few days into the ceasefire deal between Israel and Hamas, according to the Israel Defense Forces. Five of those deaths occurred when soldiers fired at a group of Palestinians approaching the yellow line that the IDF is now operating from in northern Gaza under the terms of the ceasefire. A spokesperson for the Palestinian civil defense disputed the IDF's claims to ABC News, telling the outlet that the people killed were shot in an area designated as a, quote, safe zone. Meanwhile, the Red Cross delivered the bodies of four more deceased hostages to Israel on Tuesday. Hamas has now returned 8 out of 28 deceased hostages this week. The Israeli military argues that Hamas is violating the ceasefire by not releasing all the remains of the hostages at once, and as a result, Israel says it will cut the number of aid trucks it's sending into Gaza in half. A Hamas official told the New York Times that Israel's destruction of Gaza during the war is now making it more challenging to quickly recover and return the bodies of hostages. Here's Trump speaking with reporters about the situation at the White House Tuesday.

[Donald Trump]

Now they misrepresent it because we were told they had 26, 24 of dead hostages, if we can use those terms. And it seems as though they don't have that because we're talking about a much lesser number. But that's a very tough subject. I want them back.

[Jane Costen]

During those remarks, Trump also said that if Hamas does not disarm, quote, we will disarm them and it will happen quickly and perhaps violently. He declined, however, to give any details on what his plan to disarm Hamas actually looks like. Former FBI Director James Comey landed the first punch in his fight against prosecution by Trump's Department of Justice on Tuesday. A federal Judge denied the DOJ's request to delay turning over evidence in his case. Comey faces charges for false statements and obstruction. The judge said the DOJ's proposed protective order legal speak for we get to keep the evidence secret would have unnecessarily hindered Comey's defense. The DOJ said it's not hiding evidence, it's simply protecting it. But the judge said the DOJ's definition of protected was so broad that it basically includes everything, meaning the DOJ can't just pinky swear that it's like super duper incriminating. This ruling is a potential rebuke of the Trump DOJ's overreach. The judge referenced a 2018 decision in the Paul Manafort case warning prosecutors against treating politically sensitive cases with a quote, unnecessarily broad cloak of secrecy. The DOJ must reveal its evidence, even if when the curtain is pulled back, it's just an orange man yelling into a microphone. The fight now shifts to whether Trump's super qualified handpicked prosecutor, who happens to have zero prosecutorial experience, Lindsey Halligan, can stay on the case. Comey's team argues that Halligan's appointment was unlawful, and they cite recent rulings that struck down cases prepared by similar Trump installed prosecutors. If a judge agrees, the entire Comey prosecution could fall apart. Former President Obama is throwing his weight behind Democrats redistricting efforts in California. In an ad released Tuesday, Obama voiced his support for Prop 50, the ballot measure that could help the party gain five additional seats in the House.

[Jerry]

Democracy is on ballot November 4 Republicans want to steal enough seats in Congress to rig the next election and wield unchecked power for two more years. With Prop 50, you can stop Republicans in their tracks.

[Jane Costen]

Prop 50 is the Democrats response to partisan gerrymandering that Texas Republicans carried out in August following pressure from President Trump. A recent poll by Emerson College found that 51% of California voters support the measure, while 34% oppose it, and the rest are currently undecided. Perhaps the backing of a popular former president will sway some of those voters. And that's the news. Before we go California voters, you have until November 4th to vote on Prop 50. It's a ballot measure to stop Trump from power, grabbing extra seats in the U.S. house and hanging onto his federal trifecta. The best way to make sure Prop 50 passes is to 1 vote yes by November 4 and 2. Make sure everyone you know knows about the election. Vote Save America is hosting an event today, Wednesday, October 15th at 5pm Pacific Time to get you up to speed to take action that night. And you don't have to live in California to join. Have family or friends in California join VSA's call and learn about how to motivate them to get out and vote. Sign up by going to votesaveamerica.com Prop 50 paid for by VoteSave America votesaveamerica.com, not authorized by any candidate or candidates committee. That's all for today. If you like the show, make sure you subscribe, Leave a review. Contemplate the sad tale of the racists running Young Republicans chapters nationwide who spent months posting about how they love Hitler in a group chat on Telegram and are now losing their jobs. And tell your friends to listen. And if you're into reading, I'm not just about how Politico exposed the group chat in a piece that featured the exact amount of casual racism, antisemitism and misogyny you'd kind of expect from a Young Republican's group chat on Telegram. Like me, what a Day is also a nightly newsletter. Check it out and [e-mail] subscribe I'm Jane Costen, and honestly, the best part is that Politico only discovered these messages While investigating how one Young Republicans chapter is nearly $40,000 in debt, racism and misogyny and anti Semitism and mismanaging money. They really are Young Republicans. What a Day is a production of Crooked Media. It's recorded and mixed by Jesmyn Taylor. Our associate producers are Emily Foer and Chris Allport. Our video editor is Joseph Dutra. Our video producer is Johanna Case. We had production help today from Greg Walters, Matt Berg, Sean Ali, Gina Pollack and Caitlin Plummer. Our senior producer is Erica Morrison and our senior vice president of news and politics is Adrienne Hill. We get help today from the Associated Press. Our theme music is by Colin Gilliard and Kashaka. Our production staff is proudly unionized with the Writers Guild of America East.

[DSW Advertisement Voice]

I've never felt like this before. It's like you just get me. I feel like my true self with you. Does that sound crazy? And it doesn't hurt that you're gorgeous. Okay, that's it. I'm taking you home with me. I mean, you can't find shoes this good just anywhere. Find a shoe for every you from brands you love like Birkenstock, Nike, Adidas and more at your DSW store or dsw.com.

[Crooked Media Advertisement Voice]

If your favorite way to enjoy our podcast is on video but you hate ads, we got great news. You can now stream Ad Free video with a paid subscription to Crooked can enjoy shows like Pod Save America, Pod Save the World, Love it or Leave it and Offline with Jon Favreau with no interruptions, just the content you actually came for. With your subscription to Crooked, you will also get Polar Coaster with Dan Pfeiffer, who delivers expert takes on polls and media and Terminally Online, where Crooked hosts and staff reveal the unhinged rabbit holes our algorithms drop dragged us into that week. Best of all, your support helps progressive media that exposes lies, battles misinformation, and pushes back against conservatives who are trying to control the conversation. Ad Free Video is available now on Supercast, Substack and YouTube. Visit cricket. Com friends to learn more.