Who Killed Jennifer Judd? – Episode 4: Suspect No. 1

Release Date: September 4, 2024
Host: Sarah Cailean
Producer: ARC Media for ID
Episode Title: Suspect No. 1

Introduction

In Episode 4, titled "Suspect No. 1," of the gripping true crime series Who Killed Jennifer Judd?, host Sarah Cailean delves deeper into the mysterious 1992 murder of Jennifer Judd. Nine days after marrying her high-school sweetheart, Jennifer was tragically killed in her apartment in Baxter Springs, Kansas. This episode primarily focuses on the investigation surrounding the primary suspect, Chuck Chance, and explores the complexities that have kept the case unresolved for over three decades.

Primary Suspect: Chuck Chance

Sarah introduces Chuck Chance as the initial and most significant suspect in Jennifer Judd's murder. A close friend of both Jennifer and her husband, Justin Judd, Chuck's background paints him as a multi-sport athlete with a somewhat aggressive demeanor.

• Background Details:
  • School Ties: Chuck transferred from Pitcher to Quapaw High School to join a larger football team.
  • Wedding Role: Served as a groomsman in Jennifer and Justin's wedding.

Chuck Chance’s Character:

• Despite having no major criminal record at the time of Jennifer’s murder, Chuck had minor run-ins related to theft and drug-related offenses in later years.
• Quotes:
  • Chuck Chance [02:00]: "There's no doubt I could probably charge Chuck Chance based on the witness information, but I don't think I can convict it."

Sarah notes the unusual nature of Chuck being a prime suspect without a clear history of escalating violent behavior, making his involvement perplexing.

Investigation Findings and Timeline Analysis

Initial Statements and Alibis:

• First Statement: Chuck provided a detailed timeline of his movements on the day of the murder, largely corroborated by witnesses at various locations such as a convenience store, bank, and post office.
• Amended Statement: A few days later, Chuck modified his timeline, narrowing his departure time from Pittsburgh to between 10:00 and 10:15 AM, effectively eliminating a 23-minute window during which Jennifer was killed.

Key Observations:

• The revised timeline tightens the alibi but leaves minimal room for conflict or alibi gaps.
• Fingerprint Evidence:
  • Three fingerprints were found on the murder weapon, with one matching Jeremy Jones, a man who confessed a decade later but was not charged.
  • Sarah Cailean [30:11]: "Jeremy Jones's profile, the only person who has ever claimed responsibility for murdering Jennifer..."

Despite Chuck's seemingly solid alibi, the unresolved window and the presence of Jones’s fingerprint raise critical questions.

Interviews and Testimonies

Leslie Bissell’s Insights: Detective Leslie Bissell, a seasoned law enforcement professional, provides valuable context about Chuck's interactions and the dynamics within their friend group.

• Quote:
  • Leslie Bissell [06:56]: "They were always kind of together, hanging out and so I don't know that he liked him any better than any of the others."

Michelle McCorkle’s Testimony: Michelle offers a more convoluted theory involving the so-called "Quapaw Mafia," suggesting possible drug-related motives and co-conspirators. However, Sarah remains skeptical of this narrative due to inconsistencies and a lack of concrete evidence.

• Quote:
  • Michelle McCorkle [07:35]: "Jennifer had told me one time that she found some stuff in the toilet."

Secondary Suspects: Tommy Davis

Tommy Lee Davis Jr., Michelle McCorkle’s ex-husband and best man at Jennifer and Justin's wedding, emerges as another person of interest.

• Alibi Scrutiny:

  • Initial police reports have conflicting information regarding Tommy’s whereabouts on the day of the murder, leading to doubts about his alibi.

• Quotes:

  • Chuck Chance [24:53]: "The man can't even cut open a deer... we've gotten to fist fights..."

Sarah concludes that discrepancies in Tommy’s alibi likely stem from clerical errors rather than intentional deceit, leading her to rule him out as a primary suspect with 90% confidence.

Emerging Evidence: Fingerprints on the Murder Weapon

A pivotal breakthrough in the investigation reveals usable fingerprints on the knife used to kill Jennifer.

• Jeremy Jones Connection:

  • Jeremy Jones, who confessed to the murder years later, had his fingerprints incorrectly entered into the APHIS database in 2000. This mishap allowed him to evade immediate detection when arrested in Georgia.

• Sarah’s Analysis:

  • Sarah suggests that Jeremy Jones might have fled his bond due to fear of being implicated if his fingerprints matched evidence from the murder scene.
  • Sarah Cailean [35:03]: "I'm becoming more convinced that either this print or DNA testing will tell us who killed Jennifer Judd."

This evidence renews the possibility that Jeremy Jones is the true perpetrator, shifting the investigation's focus.

Emotional Interactions and Community Impact

The episode underscores the emotional toll the case has taken on Jennifer’s friends and family over the years.

• Meeting with Michelle McCorkle:

  • Michelle expresses deep frustration and unresolved anger towards both Chuck Chance and Jeremy Jones, questioning the investigation’s direction and seeking closure.

• Quotes:

  • Michelle McCorkle [26:28]: "He's even came to my house in Quapaw after Jennifer was killed... we’re getting this treatment."

• Chuck Chance’s Regret:

  • Chuck shares his lingering guilt and sense of responsibility for Jennifer’s death, despite lacking definitive evidence against him.
  • Chuck Chance [27:49]: "I feel so much better about that. I'm gonna go home crying."

Next Steps and Upcoming Interviews

Sarah Cailean announces a forthcoming interview with Justin Judd, Jennifer’s husband, which promises to shed new light on the case.

• Justin Judd’s Potential Contribution:

  • As a critical witness and close relation to both Jennifer and Chuck, Justin’s insights are anticipated to be pivotal in unraveling the mystery.

• Quote:

  • Sarah Cailean [43:46]: "I believe Justin Judd is one of those people, and I believe he can help me get to know Jennifer in a way many friends could not."

Conclusion

Episode 4, "Suspect No. 1," meticulously dissects the intricate web surrounding the murder of Jennifer Judd. By scrutinizing alibis, evaluating new evidence, and exploring interpersonal dynamics, Sarah Cailean advances the investigation while highlighting the enduring emotional scars left by the unsolved case. The introduction of fingerprint evidence tied to Jeremy Jones marks a significant turn, potentially steering the investigation towards a long-overdue resolution.

Notable Quotes:

• Chuck Chance [02:00]: "There's no doubt I could probably charge Chuck Chance based on the witness information, but I don't think I can convict it."
• Michelle McCorkle [07:35]: "Jennifer had told me one time that she found some stuff in the toilet."
• Sarah Cailean [35:03]: "I'm becoming more convinced that either this print or DNA testing will tell us who killed Jennifer Judd."
• Chuck Chance [27:49]: "I feel so much better about that. I'm gonna go home crying."
• Sarah Cailean [43:46]: "I believe Justin Judd is one of those people, and I believe he can help me get to know Jennifer in a way many friends could not."

Stay Tuned:
In the next episode, Sarah will sit down with Justin Judd, promising fresh perspectives and potentially groundbreaking information that could finally answer the haunting question: Who killed Jennifer Judd?

Subscribe and Follow:
Don’t miss any updates from Who Killed Jennifer Judd? Subscribe on Apple Podcasts or Spotify to stay informed on this compelling investigation.