
Loading summary
Amazon Pharmacy
This message comes from Amazon Pharmacy. Ever been so sick that thinking of going to the pharmacy made you more sick? With Amazon Pharmacy, meds are delivered fast right to your door. You just have to make it to your door. Amazon Healthcare just got less painful.
Rachel Martin
What's a belief you chose to let go of?
Father James Martin
Oh my gosh. That God was a transactional God, that you do something and that by doing it you will, in a sense, force God to do this right. So I had to let go of that idea of the transactional God versus God who's kind of in relationship with us.
Rachel Martin
I'm Rachel Martin and this is Wildcard, the show where cards control the conversation. Each week, my guest answers questions about their life. Questions pulled from a deck of cards. They're allowed to skip one question and to flip one back on me. My guest this week is author and podcaster Father James Martin.
Father James Martin
I mean, I'm a Jesuit priest. I feel like I've found the purpose of my life. I still feel the sense of, oh, you know, I need more.
Rachel Martin
You all out there who listen to Wildcard a lot will know that this show has been a place where I've gotten to work through a lot of my own questions about religion and faith and spirituality. All of the above. But it comes in through the side door mostly. Today we're doing something a little different. No side door spirituality. We are going right through the front with Father James Martin. He is arguably one of the most famous Catholic priests in the country, thanks to his many appearances with Stephen Colbert. Now he's the host of a new podcast called the Spiritual Life with Father James Martin. And I am so happy to welcome him to Wildcard. Hi, Father Jim.
Father James Martin
Hi. Happy to be here. Thanks for inviting me.
Rachel Martin
We're going to start with memories. Ready? Let's go. First, three cards for Father Jim. One two or three?
Father James Martin
One.
Rachel Martin
One. What was your form of rebelling as a teenager?
Father James Martin
Dishing.
Rachel Martin
Father Jim.
Father James Martin
That's an easy one.
Rachel Martin
Oh really?
Father James Martin
Well, yes. So I have to say to people, I wasn't always a Jesuit priest. Right.
Rachel Martin
That's true. It's very important to remember out of.
Father James Martin
The womb that way as a Jesuit priest. So, um, yeah, I probably the first time I've ever admitted this. Smoking a lot of pot and getting drunk a lot during college.
Rachel Martin
There you go.
Father James Martin
So that was pretty rebellious.
Rachel Martin
Uh huh.
Father James Martin
And my parents were not particularly happy about that, but I didn't really let them know. And you were good at deceit also, Apparently I was good at brushing my teeth after I smoked pot. So yeah, that was Kind of rebellious.
Rachel Martin
Who were these hooligans you were hanging out with? Who was your crowd in high school?
Father James Martin
Well, actually, I didn't come till college, really. In high school, I was a bit of a square. But then in college, I fell in with a group at Penn. Wonderful young people I'm still friendly with. And one of the things that was surprising was, you know, when I was growing up, I was told that anybody who smoked pot or drank were these kind of waste cases and stay away. And here were these very well educated, very thoughtful, very articulate guys who. And women who, you know, smoked pot, you know, every week and got drunk a lot, and so I fell in with them, and then we're still friends. I think a certain amount of rebellion is probably in order for anybody at that time of their life. Yeah. So not stuff I do any longer, but okay.
Rachel Martin
Yeah. For the record, thanks for clarifying that. Were your parents super religious? Were they aimed as a church?
Father James Martin
No, my parents were both Catholic, and my mom's still alive. She's still Catholic, of course, but we weren't the kind of family that, you know, said grace at meals every night and said the rosary together and went to daily Mass, and I didn't go to Catholic schools. So that when I entered the Jesuits, it was kind of a shock, and they were not happy. So we were Catholic, I would say. I call them sometimes lukewarm Catholics, so, you know, good people and moral, but not really into all the churchy stuff. So it was a big shock when I decided to join the Jesuits.
Rachel Martin
I mean, I have so many questions about that moment. I mean, it might come up in the cards, but I'm sort of just gonna ask it now if it doesn't. So what was the provocation like? Were you exploring spirituality after college? How did you decide you were going to dedicate your life to God in this way?
Father James Martin
Yeah, well, I went to Penn, as I said, and I was an undergraduate at Wharton, and I got a job at ge, formerly Great Company in New York, and was very happy as a young executive and worked there for about six years and started to get bored and thinking, you know, what. What is this all about? And what am I doing with my life? Business is a real vocation for a lot of people, but it didn't seem to fit me. And I didn't know what to do because I thought I studied business. What am I going to do, right? What am I going to, like, you know, like, join the opera or, you know, try out for the Phillies or something. And one night I Came home and turned on the TV and saw a documentary about Thomas Merton, the Trappist monk. And I just was captivated by it. It was fascinating. And I started to read about Thomas Merton and the monastery, and I just thought this just seemed really romantic and beautiful. And I went to my local parish priest. I was living in Connecticut at the time. And I said, you know, I think I'm interested in the priesthood. So really, I always say a TV show kind of changed my life. So it was the fact that his life in the monastery seemed more beautiful and more purposeful and more interesting than my life at ge. So I. Yeah, I took the plunge and, yeah, never looked back, I'm sure.
Rachel Martin
I mean, it's one thing to romanticize a life as being more fascinating, compelling than your current. It's another to walk that life, which you have now. And, I mean, has the romantic quality of it all dissolved into just, like, the quotidian nature of doing the work and being a Jesuit priest, or does that still hold that kind of romance for you?
Father James Martin
Yeah, I would compare it to, like, a marriage, right? I mean, you get married and you kind of get to know the person. You think, oh, they're not perfect. But there is the romance, you know, that continues in some way. You know, Thomas Merton said, the first and most elemental test of anyone's religious vocation, whether you're a Jesuit, a Carthusian, a Trappist, or a Franciscan, is the recognition that everyone in your community is more or less imperfect. And so I think that's part of it, that I'm imperfect, too. And the guys I live with and the guys that I'm friends with are imperfect, but it works for me. And there are times when I do feel that romance, right? When I do feel if I'm celebrating Mass or with someone in a spiritual moment or. I was able to participate in covering the conclave a couple of weeks ago and watching Pope Leo walk out on the balcony, someone who I knew slightly. I mean, that was really exciting. And to be kind of in the midst of that was really great. And I wouldn't have been able to do any of that if I weren't a Jesuit. So, yeah, a lot of the romance is still there.
Rachel Martin
Okay. Thank you for that.
Father James Martin
You're welcome.
Rachel Martin
We're going to the next three.
Father James Martin
Okay.
Rachel Martin
One, two or three?
Father James Martin
I'll pick two.
Rachel Martin
Two. What's a moment with a stranger that made you feel loved?
Father James Martin
Oh, my gosh. These are great questions. Did you write these? Did you write these?
Rachel Martin
I'm with my team.
Father James Martin
These are Great. So, because I'm an author and I do stuff in the media, from time to time, I have people come up to me and tell me what my work has meant to them. And in the past couple of years, I've done a lot of work with LGBTQ Catholics, helped to start a group called Outreach. And, yeah, I was at a retreat recently for LGBTQ Catholics. And I'll try to keep this confidential, but, you know, a mother came up and said, you know, thanks to your work, my daughter feels at home in the church. So that made me feel really loved and really grateful for the kind of work that I'm able to do.
Rachel Martin
You've gotten some grief from some corners for your work with LGBTQ Catholics.
Father James Martin
That's an understatement if there ever was one.
Rachel Martin
It must have been hard, though, to hear from fellow Catholics who took issue with a cause that was very dear to you and that you'd spent a lot of your life working on.
Father James Martin
Yeah, but not too surprising. You know, I would say there's still a lot of homophobia in the world, of course, and particularly in, you know, places like sub Saharan Africa, Eastern Europe, and there's still homophobia in the United States, and there's still homophobia in the church. I think what was surprising was how personal it got. You know, you're a false priest, you're apostate, you're a heretic, you're death threats and protests. We had protests. A couple of weeks ago. We had a retreat for LGBTQ Catholics outside of Philly, and we had people protesting. And I thought, what are you protesting? You're protesting that LGBTQ people are praying that they're going to Mass, that they're experiencing God in their life. So there's a lot of hatred out there, but I also see it as kind of part of the ministry. Our model in all this, I'm not comparing myself to him, but our model in all this is Jesus. And Jesus obviously faced a lot of pushback, and he promised his followers that they. That they would face pushback too.
Rachel Martin
Yeah. Okay, last one in this round. One. Two or three?
Father James Martin
Three.
Rachel Martin
Three. Ah. Were you intimidated or excited about leaving your parents house?
Father James Martin
Oh, my gosh. What a question. I will ask you that. What about you nipping?
Rachel Martin
Oh, I love. I've lost. Both my parents have passed, but I really was good friends with them. So this is not an indictment of their company, but I was, like, so ready to go. I was really ready to leave. I remember after college, I even went to Japan. I taught English there for a couple years. But then when I came back, I have this image of leaving my parents house and moving to San Francisco. And I had this big red Jeep Cherokee and it was jam packed with all my belongings and my parents. It really was like something out of a movie. My parents were in the street and I was driving away looking at my dad in the rear view mirror and I was just like, baba, I love you. I'm leaving.
Father James Martin
No, I was excited to go to college. That was exciting for me. And so it was 19, what, 78. And it was just kind of thrilling. And this is before social media and kind of knowing what to expect, really. Right. I visited the campus once or twice, so it was sort of a tabula rasa. But like you, I think the big move for me was when I left college and moved to New York, which was also like a movie. I really I roomed with a good friend of mine, my friend Rob, a roommate from Penn. And we got this apartment on 71st street and my first day of work at GE. I swear this is true. It sounds like something out of a movie. I went to the newsstand, I said, you know, not being from New York, I said, I'll have a copy of the New York Times. And the guy goes, kid, you're in New York. It's just the Times. I thought, oh my gosh, I feel like I'm in a movie. So yeah, New York in the 80s was tons of fun. Yeah. Loved it.
Amazon Pharmacy
This message comes from Strawberry Me. You've worked hard to get where you are, but what's next? Strawberry Me Career coaching helps professionals like you take the next big step with confidence by matching you with a certified career coach who understands your goals and challenges. This isn't just advice. It's a personalized, results driven approach to uncover hidden strengths, overcome obstacles, and accelerate your career growth. Visit Strawberry Me NPR to claim your $50 credit.
NPR Sponsor
This message comes from Moises, proud supporter of NPR Music and the 2025 Tiny Desk Giveaway. You can win a trip for two to see a Tiny Dess concert live at NPR's headquarters. Enter for free by September 12th and increase your odds by donating to the NPR Network. Support comes from Moises, your AI Powered studio created by Musicians for Musicians. Learn more at Moises AI. No purchase or donation required for entry. Must be 18 years or older to enter. Links to the entry page and official rules can found@npr.org tinydeskgiveaway.
Amazon Pharmacy
This message comes from WISE, the app for doing things in other currencies. With WISE, you can send Spend or receive money across borders, all at a fair exchange rate, no markups or hidden fees. Join millions of customers and visit wise.comt's and C's apply.
NPR Sponsor
This message comes from DSW. Where'd you get those shoes? Easy. They're from DSWell. Because DSW has the exact right shoes for whatever you're into right now. You know, like the sneakers that make office hours feel like happy hour, the boots that turn grocery aisles into runways, and all the styles that show off the many sides of you, from daydreamer to multitasker, and everything in between. Because you do it all in really great shoes. Find a shoe for every you at your DSW store or dsw.com.
Rachel Martin
Okay, so before we start round two, I want to talk more about your new show. It is called the Spiritual Life with Father James Martin. Who do you want your audience to be for this?
Father James Martin
Honestly, I want it to be everybody. Yeah, so I wrote a book a couple years ago called Learning to Pray, A Guide for Everyone. Because I think everybody, you know, has a natural. I believe everyone has a natural desire for God. And the point of this show called the Spiritual Life is that it talks to people about their experiences of God in their daily life and in their prayer. And, you know, so far, it's been people who are pretty well known. Stephen Colbert, Whoopi Goldberg, Pete Buttigieg. But we're also going to have people that aren't as well known but are really good spiritual practitioners. Right. That might be good spiritual directors or spiritual writers that might not be on everybody's radar. One of the reasons I started it, or we started it, was that, you know, I think a lot of what passes for spirituality online and in the media and, you know, just everywhere is pretty shallow, like, hey, I'm Catholic and I do my rosary, and the end, I check the box and that's that. Or I go to Mass every day.
Rachel Martin
Right.
Father James Martin
And. Okay, well, let's. Let's talk about, you know, your experiences of God and what happens when, you know, it feels like God isn't showing up or things are going wrong. Right. What does it mean to suffer and where is God in that? And can you still believe in a God you don't understand? And what's your prayer like, and what does it mean to live a spiritual life, you know, and in a complicated world? And so we give our guests, you know, for about an hour, the opportunity to talk about that. So I've been really happy with it so far. And it's, you know, I've been Doing spiritual direction, which is listening to people talk about God in their daily lives and their prayer for, like, 30 years. So this is kind of a comfortable way of sort of encountering people, if that makes sense. You know, I'm used to having those conversations, and it's been great. It's been a lot of fun.
Rachel Martin
So how'd you end up being, like, the priest who's the bridge between the Vatican and American standup comedy?
Father James Martin
Oh, you mean the Colbert stuff?
Rachel Martin
Well, the Colbert stuff. You've been on Colbert so many times, but then you were part of the effort to bring all these American standups to the Vatican to meet Pope Francis in an audience. And, I mean, besides just, oh, I've got Stephen Colbert's number on my phone and I can make some calls. You clearly see, like, a benefit, a collective benefit to marrying these two institutions. Standup comedy and faith.
Father James Martin
Yeah. The old definition of a Jesuit is that the Jesuit explains the church to the world and the world to the church, which I like. So there's that kind of connection and that bridging. And lots of Jesuits do that, you know, not just me. That story about the audience is actually pretty funny. The papal audience. Can I tell you the story, Please? I'll try to make it short. I got a call from two friends of mine in the Vatican, and they said, hey, Pope Francis wants to meet with comedians in, like, two months. And so we want you to help us arrange for the American ones. And I was like, okay. So they said, here's our list of comedians. And with this huge, long list. And some of them I didn't know. So I went to my friends at American Media, where I work, and I said, like, let's give me a thumbs up or a thumbs down, because some of these people, I don't know, and we have a pretty young staff. And they were like, oh, that one I don't know. So I came up with a list, and then I reached out to Stephen Colbert and Jim Gaffigan, who I both know, and they sort of edited their list. So we sent out these. Thanks to Stephen Colbert's booker. We sent out these invitations, and I immediately got these emails from people like Conan o', Brien, saying, is this for real? I was like, yeah, this is, in fact, for real. Everyone said, yes. We had about 15 people from the United States. It was wonderful. And I was a little sort of not suspicious, but kind of curious how it would work out if we would look kind of cheesy. But Pope Francis gave this beautiful talk on humor, and basically his point Was, you know, laughter helps people. Right. And your vocation is an important vocation. So it was a lot of fun. It was a lot of fun. And, you know, being with these comedians, you know, some of whom I didn't know, they're pretty funny.
Rachel Martin
They're funny and they're pretty deep people.
Father James Martin
Yes.
Rachel Martin
Their ability to deconstruct human behavior and the observations that they can make. There's something about that that seems Jesuit to me, too.
Father James Martin
Yeah. Yeah. And we were afterwards, and Stephen Colbert, I think, is doing a little documentary on this afterwards. There was a. I think I can say this. This is not telling tales out of school. And he said, well, what does everybody think about the intersection now between faith and comedy? And Julie Louis Dreyfus, by the way, who's lovely and funny, of course, said, well, what I want to know is what's up with those Swiss Guards uniforms? I said, what do you mean? And she goes, well, they look ridiculous. Who designed them? And I said, well, Michelangelo. And she goes, well, he may have known a lot about sculpture, but he doesn't know much about clothes because those people look like clowns. And I just thought it was fantastic.
Rachel Martin
So I will ask you one big question, though, about the church, because you said, you know, you've met or in passing Pope Leo. I mean, he's a nice guy.
Father James Martin
Yeah. I spent time with him during the synod. We were at the same table for two weeks. Yep.
Rachel Martin
I know you only spent a brief amount of time with him, but what's your assessment of Pope Leo?
Father James Martin
I think he's great. As I said, I was at his table. It was a funny story. After the election, I said, oh, my gosh, I can't believe it. He was at my table at the synod, and someone said, no, you were at his table. I'll tell you. After I was helping out ABC during the conclave. And when he came out, I was very moved. And after we were finished our broadcast, I cried because I was really grateful. That's how good I think he is. I think they made a great choice under the guidance of the Holy Spirit. He's very smart. He's been all over the world, you know, visiting people. As the Augustinian Prior General, he worked in a very poor diocese, Chiclayo in Peru. Right. So, I mean, a really poor diocese. So he knows the struggles of people in the margins, and he's kind of the perfect candidate. Now, is he the perfect person? No, no one's perfect. Right. Will he do things that people find difficult or hard to accept? Probably, but I think he's great. I was really grateful that they chose him. And I think so far he's done a great job. You know, his first words to people were peace to you, which I thought was lovely.
Rachel Martin
Father Jim, you know, you gotta get him on your show.
Father James Martin
I'll try.
Rachel Martin
Is the request in? I feel like you should put it in right now.
Father James Martin
Not yet.
Rachel Martin
You ready to get back in the game?
Father James Martin
Ooh, the blue cards. Now what's. The blue cards are what? Insights. Okay.
Rachel Martin
Insights.
Father James Martin
Oh, my gosh. The pressure's on. I don't know.
Rachel Martin
I don't know why I did my eyes. I didn't mean.
Father James Martin
Is it my insights or someone else's insights?
Rachel Martin
Your insight. Your insights into your own life.
Father James Martin
Oh, gosh. Okay.
Rachel Martin
Well, one, two or three?
Father James Martin
One.
Rachel Martin
What are you like when no one is around?
Father James Martin
Yeah. Maybe quieter than people would think. I think I entered the Jesuits as an extrovert on the Myers Briggs. I was an enfp, which is a real kind of extrovert storyteller. The more I'm a Jesuit, the more I treasure my quiet time, my time in prayer, my time reading, my time being alone. That's kind of new for me. So I think a little quieter than most people would think. I like to write, I like to read, I like to be quiet. I'm still an extrovert, but with an introvert side that is developing.
Rachel Martin
I think you were talking about Thomas Merton and how he used to write and think a lot about. About the self, about your identity, about who you are when no one's looking, about what is the essentialness of you and without the definition of other, you know?
Father James Martin
Yeah. He had this idea of the true self and the false self. And the false self is the self that we want to present to the world or that we feel that we have to present to the world. He talked about it as if being clothed in different, like bandits. And what does that mean? Well, I was in college, you know, what did I want? I wanted everyone to think I was cool, basically. Like I had it all together and where everyone wants that. Right.
Rachel Martin
Cool.
Father James Martin
You're smart, you're on top of things. And the key is to let your true self be known and known by yourself as well, and to have that public self be your true self. Right. What is your true self? It's the self you are before God. Right. And we're always on a journey, but it's not being embarrassed about who you are and not trying to get people to like you. I think the biggest move in my life towards freedom has been the letting go of the need for people to love, like, or approve of me. And I think in terms of my LGBTQ ministry, you know, I really had to let go of that because so many people were opposing me and still do. Right. And. Oh, please. Yeah. I was on retreat once. This is very spiritual. And I was meditating over the Gospel story where Jesus is rejected by the people in Nazareth. So in the Gospels, he stands up in the synagogue in Nazareth and says, basically, he's the Messiah, and they chase him out of the synagogue and try to kill him. They try to push him off the cliff. And I remember being in a retreat setting. I was on my annual retreat, and I was thinking about it from Jesus's point of view, and I thought, well, how are you able to do that? How could you? You knew. You grew up in Nazareth. It's a small town of 200 to 300 people. You knew if you stood up and said, you're the Messiah, what people's response is going to be? I mean, you know, come on, Jesus. Well, right. And I said to him in my prayer, in this kind of meditation, how were you able to do that? You know, because I could never do something like that. And, I mean, not that I'm the Messiah, but I could never do something that would sort of knowingly cause people to turn against me.
Rachel Martin
Right.
Father James Martin
And the words I heard in prayer, not orally, but the words that kind of came to me were Jesus saying to me, must everyone like you?
Rachel Martin
How do you. How do you feel having surrendered that? You said you felt free.
Father James Martin
Yeah, it's freer. So when I get protests or death threats, I mean, it bothers me, obviously, but it doesn't paralyze me. Because you get death threats, Father Jim. Oh, yeah. I also get what I call Catholic death threats, which is, I hope you die so you can go to hell and find out how wrong you are. So not exactly a death threat, but I get real death threats, too. Yeah. And I think it just goes with the territory. But again, Jesus promised us this. He said, you know, you're gonna face opposition, and so why would I not expect this? But I think the letting go of the need to be loved, liked, or approved of has been very freeing for me.
Rachel Martin
That is a good one for all of us to be reminded of.
Father James Martin
Thanks.
Rachel Martin
Yeah. Three more cards. One, two, three.
Father James Martin
I'm gonna go crazy. And go for three.
Rachel Martin
You are crazy.
Father James Martin
I know. It's insane.
Rachel Martin
Oh, this one is the same. How much do you rely on the validation of others?
Father James Martin
Oh, okay. There we go. Well, I'll ask you. I'll flip that to you. How about you? There's an important question.
Rachel Martin
Oh, come on.
Father James Martin
Sorry.
Rachel Martin
But then you still have to answer it. The flip doesn't work that way. Here's what will happen. I will answer this for you. You've already answered it. And then we'll pick another one.
Father James Martin
Okay, good. Yeah. I'm curious.
Rachel Martin
How much is my answer? How much do you rely on the validation of others? Far too much than I should. I mean, I'm also. I'm in this strange job where I need people to like what I make sure.
Father James Martin
Yeah.
Rachel Martin
And as a result, the thing. What the show is, is very personal. It's a really personal project. And so it's hard to detach that from. If someone doesn't like the show, well, do they not like who I am? And so these are mushed and woven together in a new way for me, my job and myself. But, I mean, a lot of it does come with age. I don't suffer nearly that anxiety of needing to have approval of people in my regular world that I did when I was younger, and I. I didn't fall in love until later in my adult life. And so there were all kinds of issues about, is there something wrong with me? Have I just not found the right person? Or is there something unlovable about me and what I'm projecting? So, oh, yeah, I got all kinds of validation issues, Father Jim. But I will say that I am much better about that than I ever have been. It just. This show now is. Tamped it up ever so slightly, and.
Father James Martin
I'm trying to tamp it back down. Well, no, thanks for being honest. I mean, I think that the, you know, the fact that you have to do that professionally is tough because I find that, like, as an author, you have to promote your books. Right. And it's about, you know, getting people to buy them and getting people to. In your case, getting people to listen to the show. And. Yeah, I think the key is to not let that in, to not let it affect how you see yourself, to sort of have that distance professionally and personally. Yeah. But it is something. I mean, I find more and more, as you were saying that more and more, my friends say, you know, as I get older, I don't care, you know, I am who I am.
Rachel Martin
So you have to answer another one of these.
Father James Martin
Okay, so.
Rachel Martin
Oh, okay. Well, this is the one in my hand. What do you feel as if you're constantly chasing.
Father James Martin
Oh, wow, these are great questions. Well, you know, I would say I feel Like I'm being constantly chased by God. Right? The Hound of Heaven, as they say. And then I would also say chasing or seeking the way to live my life. That is the most authentic and holy and whole way of being a Jesuit and of being a priest and of being a Catholic and of being a Christian. You know, we're all imperfect, right? We all sin. And so there's that kind of. It's kind of a neat word. There is that kind of chase or that kind of journey or that kind of pilgrimage. Yeah. St. Augustine said, which I love. Our hearts are restless until they rest in youn, Lord. So it's a. We're always gonna have these restless hearts. And there's nothing wrong with that right there. I think people who can identify within themselves this feeling of incompletion, right. Like there must be more to life than this. I always say to people, that's God. That's a call from God. Our hearts are restless until they rest in you. Which I think, isn't that beautiful?
Rachel Martin
It is beautiful. But people who feel that restlessness, it's not like God comes in and assuages that feeling.
Father James Martin
Not totally, but I think there is a sense of fulfillment, you know, of, you know, it's like. Would be like falling in love, right? People want to. Most people want to fall in love and get married, right. And eventually you do find someone. You know, many people find someone and they get married and there is that sense of completion, but not total completion.
Rachel Martin
Right.
Father James Martin
I mean, you talk to married couples and it's like, you know, my spouse doesn't totally fulfill all my needs.
Rachel Martin
Wait, this person can't be everything to me.
Father James Martin
Everything. Right. And so, you know, there's always going to be a sense of incompletion. I mean, I'm a Jesuit priest. I feel like I've found the purpose of my life. I still feel the sense of, oh, you know, I need more. And that desire really is not going to be fulfilled, I think, until we meet God face to face. But yeah, but I guess what I'm saying is that restlessness and that incompletion, what one theologian called the God shaped hole in our life, really can only be filled by God. And to pay attention to that desire, right. As something holy and not to dismiss it.
Rachel Martin
I mean, I will tell you, I have had a hard time filling the God shaped hole. I don't know if it's God shaped. I mean, I appreciate the sentiment, but my parents are very religious, grew up in a very religious family and knew very explicitly what my spiritual Inheritance was. And tried that on for years, and then increasingly it has felt like it is not. It just doesn't fit me. And so, yeah, I'm in the in between where I don't want to put a hat on that says I'm an atheist.
Father James Martin
I.
Rachel Martin
Or an agnostic, even. But I don't feel like a Christian. And I do feel that sense of. Well, I actually don't feel a sense of, is this all there is? Because there's a lot. There's so much in my life that's lovely and beautiful and sacred, but I just can't get from here to there to.
Father James Martin
Well, I must say two things. First. Yeah, again, that's not to say that the things that are in people's lives who are atheists or agnostics is not meaningful. Right. Or important. It's just that I think everyone, no matter who they are, no matter how fulfilling their life is, is going to say in their quiet moments, you know, is this. Is this all there is in my life? Right. Is. Is. Is this the meaning of life? Is there something more? Is there something after my life? What happens when we die? Those kinds of questions.
Rachel Martin
Well, I am mixed with those questions.
Father James Martin
Yeah. Well, and the other thing is. The other thing is, I think, you know, it sounds like you're in this kind of liminal space. You're in this journey. And that's, I think, oftentimes when God speaks the most bluntly to people and loudly to people, when our defenses are down. You know, a lot of people, if they're going through a struggling, a time of struggle, someone's, you know, they, like terminal illness or they have an illness, or someone dies in their family or some disaster, and they experience God. People sometimes. I'm not saying you're saying this. People say, oh, you know, you're just saying this because you're, you know, looking for something. But I think what happens is when our defenses are down and when we are more vulnerable, God is more easily able to break in. Yeah, sorry. I go into spiritual direction.
Rachel Martin
I know you can't help it, but I'm also open to it, so it's fine. Okay, thanks. And paying attention is a lovely kind of. I mean, that's what prayer is.
Father James Martin
Yeah. Noticing, noticing, noticing. In that line from Lady Bird, did you see that movie Lady Bird? Yeah. Where Cersei Ronan goes into the nun played by Lois Smith, and the nun says something like, oh, I think you love our town. Right. Cause you took all these pretty pictures. And she said, no, I was just paying attention. And she said, well, isn't that what love is? That was really sweet. So it's like, it's like, it's like prayer.
Amazon Pharmacy
This message comes from BetterHelp. Workplace stress can be difficult to manage and a holiday can help, but it isn't a long term solution. Therapy can help you navigate whatever challenges the workday or any day might bring. Take the steps to care for yourself and relieve stress with BetterHelp, the largest online therapy provider in the world. Visit betterhelp.com NPR for 10% off your first month.
NPR Sponsor
This message comes from Progressive Insurance. Progressive makes it easy to see if you could save when you bundle your home and auto policies. Try it@progressive.com Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states.
Amazon Pharmacy
This message comes from FX's Alien Earth. From creator Noah Hawley and executive producer Ridley Scott comes the first television series inspired by the legendary Alien film franchise. A spaceship crash lands on Earth, bringing five unique and deadly species more terrifying than anyone could have ever imagined. And a technological advancement marks a new dawn in the race for immortality. FX's Alien Earth premieres August 12th on FX and Hulu.
NPR Sponsor
This message comes from Mint Mobile. Mint Mobile took what's wrong with wireless and made it right. They offer premium wireless plans for less and all plans include high speed data, unlimited talk and text and nationwide coverage. See for yourself@mintmobile.com Switch.
Rachel Martin
Round 3 this is the beliefs round. I feel like you're going to knock it out of the park.
Father James Martin
I would hope for this, though. Do you believe in God? Yes. Next question. Next.
Rachel Martin
1, 2 or 3?
Father James Martin
These are fun. 1, 1.
Rachel Martin
What's a belief you chose to let go of?
Father James Martin
Oh my gosh. That God was a transactional God.
Rachel Martin
Ah. In other words, that at some point.
Father James Martin
I think so. I think every Christian at some point.
Rachel Martin
Believes that you pray for something and you expect.
Father James Martin
No. That you do something and that by doing it you will in a sense force God to do this. If I do xyz, then God will almost have to do abc. If I say three rosaries, God's going to heal my father from whatever and God live up to your bargain. Now, I think it makes sense and I think it's natural to pray for what you want and pray for good things, right? I mean they are fathers of prayer petition. But I think that that transactional model, which I think isn't that part of.
Rachel Martin
The basis of the Catholic Church.
Father James Martin
Well, I think you ask for things, but God has freedom. Right. I think what it leads to in the extreme version is and I Want to be clear, I ask for things all the time in prayer, but the fact that you could sort of push these buttons and make God do something that leads to the prosperity gospel. All right, so if I do these things, I will be financially and socially and even physically successful. And look at people who have not done those things. They clearly don't believe in God and haven't done the right prayers. That's what I mean by that. So I had to let go of that idea of the transactional God versus God who's kind of in relationship with us. Right. So, yeah, and I think that's a really deeply held belief by a lot of people, even though they might not express it that way.
Rachel Martin
I remember when my mom was ill, she was dying of cancer, and I was just flipping through channels back when we did that. And an evangelical televangelist, who I shall not name was on preaching the prosperity gospel and was talking about people who could overcome grave illness if they just prayed enough. And my mother was a. A devout woman, and the insinuation that she was gonna die and it was because she wasn't praying hard enough to prevent that just like cut me to my core.
Father James Martin
Yeah, it's monstrous. It's a monstrous belief and it makes people feel like they've done something wrong if they're suffering. And I always point to a couple things. If you're a Catholic, look at someone like St. John Paul II. He suffered from Parkinson's disease. Did he somehow pray wrong? I mean, her mother Teresa. Right. Saint Teresa of Calcutta, who was suffering at the end of her life. No, I mean, even Jesus. There's a. I think it's in John chapter nine, the man born blind. And they ask him, which I think is great, who sinned that this man was born blind? And he says, no one sinned, you know, and so. Yeah. And I think that current day belief is. Can sort of tempt us to this idea of the transactional God. Right. And it's something to really be avoided. I had to let go of that really early on.
Rachel Martin
Last one.
Father James Martin
I love these questions.
Rachel Martin
I'm so glad.
Father James Martin
Yeah, they're great.
Rachel Martin
Thank you. One, two or three?
Father James Martin
Three.
Rachel Martin
What does it mean to live a good life?
Father James Martin
Oh, that's a great question. Means to love, basically. It basically love believing God. For me, that's a good question. I think it depends on different people, but I would say to love, to be charitable, to give to people who are less fortunate than you are, that's.
Rachel Martin
A specific kind of love.
Father James Martin
It is, yeah. It's a self Sacrificing love. But, you know, I think for the Christian, what it means to live a good life is to follow what Jesus did, and not just in words, but in deeds. One of my favorite lines is from the Christian spiritual writer Richard Rohr, who's very wonderful, and he said, which I found fascinating, that Jesus never says in the Gospels, worship me now we should do that. Of course, what he says is, follow me. And so the Christian, it's really following Jesus, but for everybody, it really just means to love, and those two things are the same.
Rachel Martin
We end the show the same way every time with a trip in our memory time machine. Okay, so in this memory time machine, you choose one moment from your past that you would like to. To go back to. It is not a moment you want to change anything about. We're not changing things. It's just a moment you'd like to linger in a little longer.
Father James Martin
Ooh, that's an easy one.
Rachel Martin
Oh, what you got?
Father James Martin
It's probably the only time that I can say that I've had anything like a mystical experience. And I go back to in prayer a lot, and I've written about it, so it's easy to go back to. I was going to school, Ridge Park Elementary School in Plymouth Meeting. It was a summer day, and I was riding my bike, my Schwinn Speedster bike. I was probably about 10 or 11, and there was a meadow in between our neighborhood and our school. And that makes it sound more grand than it was. It was filled with wildflowers and snapdragons, and I was riding my bike, and it was a beautiful summer day, and I could see the school in the distance, and I loved school. And I sort of paused for a bit, and all around me was, like, so much life, butterflies and grasshoppers. I really. I can feel myself there. And I remember thinking that I just wanted to kind of have this and possess it and enter into it, and it was just this feeling of just beauty and awe and wonder, and then it was gone. And at the time, I thought it was just a moment of happiness, but I look back, and I think that's probably the closest I've ever come to kind of a mystical moment. And I really believe that I go back to it in my prayer and I'll share something I don't think I've shared with anybody. I sometimes hope when I die that that's where Jesus meets me. So that's my memory.
Rachel Martin
Father James Martin. He is the host of a new podcast that you should check out. It is called the Spiritual Life with Father James Martin. Thank you so much, Father Jim.
Father James Martin
A joy and a pleasure. Thank you.
Rachel Martin
If you like this conversation, I highly recommend going back and listening to the episode we did with LeVar Burton. LeVar's story is similar to Father Martin's, but in the opposite way. Levar planned on being a priest from a young age. He even went to seminary. But then he answered a different call that led him to TV stardom. It was great. I loved having that conversation and I think you're gonna love listening to it. Today's episode was produced by Lee Hale and edited by Dave Blanchard. It was mastered by by Patrick Murray. Wildcard's executive producer is Yolanda Sangweni, and our theme music is by Ramtin Arablouei. If you've got thoughts on the show, we'd love to hear them. We're@wildcardpr.org we're going to shuffle the deck and be back with more next week. Talk to you then.
NPR Sponsor
This Message comes from homes.com when you're shopping for a home, you want to know as much about the area around it as possible. Homes.com has got you covered with a comprehensive neighborhood guide from local experts. Homes.com, we've done your homework.
Amazon Pharmacy
This message comes from NPR sponsor Netsuite by Oracle. Netsuite gives you visibility and control to make quick decisions. And with AI embedded, you can automate a lot of everyday tasks, letting your teams stay strategic. Trusted by over 42,000 businesses, NetSuite helps you know what's stuck, what it's costing you and how to pivot fast. Tame the chaos with NetSuite. If your revenues are at least in the seven figures, download the free ebook Navigating Global 3 Insights for Leaders at netsuite.com story this message comes from Warby.
NPR Sponsor
Parker Prescription eyewear that's expertly crafted and unexpectedly affordable. Glasses designed in house from premium material starting at just $95, including prescription lenses. Stop by a Warby Parker store near you.
Episode Title: Father James Martin is Okay with Not Being Liked
Release Date: July 31, 2025
Host: Rachel Martin
Guest: Father James Martin, author and podcaster
In this insightful episode of NPR's Wild Card with Rachel Martin, Rachel welcomes Father James Martin, a renowned Jesuit priest, author, and podcaster known for his appearances alongside Stephen Colbert and his work with the LGBTQ Catholic community. The conversation delves deep into Father James's personal journey, beliefs, and his approach to faith and ministry.
Father James Martin opens up about his rebellious teenage years and the transformation that led him to the priesthood. He candidly shares, “[At] college, I fell in with a group... [and] smoked pot and got drunk a lot” ([02:16]).
Father James discusses the pivotal moment that shifted his life trajectory—a documentary about Thomas Merton that inspired him to seek a more purposeful existence beyond his successful corporate career at GE.
The conversation touches on the evolution of Father James's faith and his role within the Jesuit community.
Father James emphasizes the importance of embracing imperfection within the community, drawing parallels between religious vocation and personal relationships.
A significant portion of the discussion centers on Father James’s advocacy for LGBTQ Catholics and the challenges he faces.
Feeling Loved Through Ministry: “A mother came up and said... thanks to your work, my daughter feels at home in the church” ([07:30]).
Facing Opposition: “You get death threats... Jesus promised his followers that they [would] face pushback too” ([08:32], [24:48]).
Father James highlights both the heartfelt gratitude from those he supports and the intense backlash from critics, underscoring his commitment to inclusive ministry despite the risks.
Father James shares his unique role in fostering connections between the Vatican and American stand-up comedians, illustrating the Jesuit mission of explaining the church to the world.
He recounts the process of selecting comedians and the positive reception from both religious and comedic communities, emphasizing the universal language of humor in bridging diverse worlds.
During the Insights segment, Father James explores his personal growth and understanding of self.
He discusses the influence of Thomas Merton’s concepts of the true self versus the false self, reflecting on his journey to authentic self-expression beyond societal expectations.
Father James delves into the theological concept of restlessness and the pursuit of a meaningful spiritual life.
He articulates the inherent human desire for fulfillment and how this restlessness drives individuals toward a deeper relationship with God, acknowledging that complete fulfillment is a future aspiration.
In the Beliefs round, Father James addresses the concept of a transactional God and his shift towards viewing God as a relational entity.
He criticizes the prosperity gospel, emphasizing that suffering is not a result of inadequate prayer or lack of faith, using examples like St. John Paul II and Saint Teresa of Calcutta to illustrate that suffering does not equate to divine disfavor.
Father James defines his understanding of a good life centered around love and following Jesus’s example.
He underscores self-sacrificing love and active deeds over mere words, aligning his philosophy with Christian teachings that prioritize love and service.
In the final segment, Father James shares a cherished memory that has profound spiritual significance to him.
He recounts a serene childhood moment filled with natural beauty and awe, reflecting on how this experience has influenced his spiritual life and aspirations.
Rachel Martin wraps up the episode by highlighting Father James Martin's new podcast, The Spiritual Life with Father James Martin, aimed at exploring deep spiritual questions and personal experiences with faith. She also recommends a previous episode featuring LeVar Burton, drawing parallels between their spiritual journeys.
Father James expresses gratitude for the conversation, reinforcing his commitment to his vocation and the ongoing journey of faith and self-discovery.
Key Takeaways:
Notable Quotes:
This episode offers a deep dive into Father James Martin's life, providing listeners with a nuanced understanding of his journey, beliefs, and the challenges he navigates as a modern Jesuit priest dedicated to fostering inclusive and meaningful spiritual connections.